IMPROVING
REALIZATION RATES


FRANK FRANK GOLDSTEIN & NAGER P.C.
              1430 BROADWAY, SUITE 1615
             NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10018
   TEL: (212) 686-0100         FAX (212) 686-6726
                 WWW.FFGNESQS.COM
Realization Rates
 Realization rates should be approximately 90 to
 95 percent.
Issues to Consider
 Insurance carriers aggressively dissuade
    policyholders from pursuing bad debt.
   Check exclusion clause in policy for pursuit of bad
    debt and suits to recover unpaid fees.
   Strict adherence to carrier policies to prevent
    cancellation or suspension of policy and benefits.
   Obtain permission from carrier and provide
    requisite notice.
   Statute of Limitations for accounting malpractice.
   Independent investigation of file.
   Economic reality of lawsuits.
How to increase realization rate, collect
receivables and not violate liability policies.
 Tighten risk management and assessment
  policies.
 Secure engagement letters which include policies
  regarding payment of fees.
 Act timely and diligently to collect past due
  balances.
 Review work papers and files for any possibility
  of counterclaims and suit.
 Consult with your carrier regarding the claim.
High Risk Clients
Engagement Letter
1. A solid engagement letter is essential.
2. Engagement letters should include:
       --Standard clauses.
       --Fees.
       --Specific work being performed.
       --Limitations.
       --Resolution of disputes.
       --Reservation of right to withdraw or terminate
  engagement.
       --Specific clauses which will protect the practitioner.
       --Rates subject to change.
3. Do not proceed without the signed engagement and initial
   retainer.
Addendums to Engagement Letter

 Change in scope or additional work to be
 performed.

 Change in fees or rates.


 Client must sign off on addendum before
 performing future work.
Fee Disputes and Non-Payment:
Always Anticipate a Dispute

A. Include clauses for past due accounts.

“Invoices will be presented monthly and are due on
  presentation. Invoices for which payment is not received
  within 30 days of invoice date shall accrue interest at the
  rate of 1.5 percent (or the highest rate allowable by law)
  per month. We reserve the right to halt further services
  until payment is received on past due invoices. If we
  should be requested to issue a report, we require that we
  be paid in full prior to such issuance for all work
  performed to date (or for all work to date and the
  estimated time and expenses through such report).”
Fee Disputes and Non-Payment:
Always Anticipate a Dispute
B. Include clause regarding fee disputes.

   “In the event that you disagree with or question any amount
    due under an invoice, you agree that you shall communicate
    such disagreement to us in writing within thirty (30) days of
    the invoice date. Any claim not made within that period
    shall be deemed waived.”

       “In the event that collection procedures are required, you
    agree to pay all expenses of collection and all attorneys' fees
    and costs actually incurred by our firm in connection with
    such collection, whether or not suit is filed thereon. If
    litigation is required regarding collection of the account we
    will be paid our hourly rates for all time actually expended
    by our firm in connection with such action.”
Fee Disputes and Non-Payment:
Always Anticipate a Dispute
C. Include a provision limiting your firm’s liability.

   “You agree to indemnify and hold our firm, its
    partners, and employees harmless from any and all
    liabilities, costs and expenses relating to this
    engagement, and expenses (and those of our legal
    counsel) incurred by reason of any action taken or
    committed to be taken by us in good faith. In no
    event will our firm be liable for incidental or
    consequential damages even if we have been
    advised of the possibility of such damages.”
Other Considerations

 Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution.


 Obtain carrier’s written permission to include fee
 dispute language in engagement letter.

 Consider a clause when accountant is a witness.
      --Time and work required.
Client Rejection

 Do it in writing.


 Include writing containing warning that advice
 given during client intake interview should not be
 relied upon as it was offered without investigation
 of underlying facts and documentation.
Collecting Receivables
Collection Trends
                Source: Commercial Collection Agency Association

100%       94.9%
90%
                    89.9%
                            81.3%
80%
                                     69.6%
70%

60%                                             52.1%
50%
                                                        39.1%
40%

30%                                                              22.8%

20%
                                                                         9.3%
10%

 0%
       Due Date 30 Days 60 Days   90 Days    Six      Nine  One Year    Two
                                            Months   Months            Years
IMPACT OF BAD DEBT
          WRITEOFF ON SALES
Your Write                     And Your Net
off                            Profit is
                         2%                  3%            4%            5%             6%
                 You will need the following amount of additional sales to offset the
loss
  $100,000       $5,000,000          $3,333,333     $2,500,000    $2,000,000    $1,666,666
  $250,000      $12,500,000          $8,333,333     $6,250,000    $5,000,000    $4,166,666
  $500,000      $25,000,000        $16,666,666     $12,500,000   $10,000,000    $8,333,333
  $750,000      $37,500,000        $25,000,000     $18,750,000   $15,000,999   $12,500,000
$1,000,000      $50,000,000        $33,333,333     $25,000,000   $20,000,000   $16,666,666
$1,500,000      $75,000,000        $50,000,000     $37,500,000   $30,000,000   $25,000,000
$2,000,000 $100,000,000            $66,666,666     $50,000,000   $40,000,000   $33,333,333




Source: Commercial Collection Agency Association
General Collection Process
Legal Process
Post Judgment Collections
 Property or income execution.


 Bank subpoenas with restraining notices to
 freeze bank accounts.

 Sell commercial property.


 Restrain monies due from third-parties.
Information Essential to
Collect Your Money Judgment

 Banking information.


 Clients.


 Assets.


 Place of business and locations.
Accounting

Accounting

  • 1.
    IMPROVING REALIZATION RATES FRANK FRANKGOLDSTEIN & NAGER P.C. 1430 BROADWAY, SUITE 1615 NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10018 TEL: (212) 686-0100 FAX (212) 686-6726 WWW.FFGNESQS.COM
  • 2.
    Realization Rates  Realizationrates should be approximately 90 to 95 percent.
  • 3.
    Issues to Consider Insurance carriers aggressively dissuade policyholders from pursuing bad debt.  Check exclusion clause in policy for pursuit of bad debt and suits to recover unpaid fees.  Strict adherence to carrier policies to prevent cancellation or suspension of policy and benefits.  Obtain permission from carrier and provide requisite notice.  Statute of Limitations for accounting malpractice.  Independent investigation of file.  Economic reality of lawsuits.
  • 4.
    How to increaserealization rate, collect receivables and not violate liability policies.  Tighten risk management and assessment policies.  Secure engagement letters which include policies regarding payment of fees.  Act timely and diligently to collect past due balances.  Review work papers and files for any possibility of counterclaims and suit.  Consult with your carrier regarding the claim.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Engagement Letter 1. Asolid engagement letter is essential. 2. Engagement letters should include: --Standard clauses. --Fees. --Specific work being performed. --Limitations. --Resolution of disputes. --Reservation of right to withdraw or terminate engagement. --Specific clauses which will protect the practitioner. --Rates subject to change. 3. Do not proceed without the signed engagement and initial retainer.
  • 7.
    Addendums to EngagementLetter  Change in scope or additional work to be performed.  Change in fees or rates.  Client must sign off on addendum before performing future work.
  • 8.
    Fee Disputes andNon-Payment: Always Anticipate a Dispute A. Include clauses for past due accounts. “Invoices will be presented monthly and are due on presentation. Invoices for which payment is not received within 30 days of invoice date shall accrue interest at the rate of 1.5 percent (or the highest rate allowable by law) per month. We reserve the right to halt further services until payment is received on past due invoices. If we should be requested to issue a report, we require that we be paid in full prior to such issuance for all work performed to date (or for all work to date and the estimated time and expenses through such report).”
  • 9.
    Fee Disputes andNon-Payment: Always Anticipate a Dispute B. Include clause regarding fee disputes.  “In the event that you disagree with or question any amount due under an invoice, you agree that you shall communicate such disagreement to us in writing within thirty (30) days of the invoice date. Any claim not made within that period shall be deemed waived.”  “In the event that collection procedures are required, you agree to pay all expenses of collection and all attorneys' fees and costs actually incurred by our firm in connection with such collection, whether or not suit is filed thereon. If litigation is required regarding collection of the account we will be paid our hourly rates for all time actually expended by our firm in connection with such action.”
  • 10.
    Fee Disputes andNon-Payment: Always Anticipate a Dispute C. Include a provision limiting your firm’s liability.  “You agree to indemnify and hold our firm, its partners, and employees harmless from any and all liabilities, costs and expenses relating to this engagement, and expenses (and those of our legal counsel) incurred by reason of any action taken or committed to be taken by us in good faith. In no event will our firm be liable for incidental or consequential damages even if we have been advised of the possibility of such damages.”
  • 11.
    Other Considerations  ConsiderAlternative Dispute Resolution.  Obtain carrier’s written permission to include fee dispute language in engagement letter.  Consider a clause when accountant is a witness. --Time and work required.
  • 12.
    Client Rejection  Doit in writing.  Include writing containing warning that advice given during client intake interview should not be relied upon as it was offered without investigation of underlying facts and documentation.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Collection Trends Source: Commercial Collection Agency Association 100% 94.9% 90% 89.9% 81.3% 80% 69.6% 70% 60% 52.1% 50% 39.1% 40% 30% 22.8% 20% 9.3% 10% 0% Due Date 30 Days 60 Days 90 Days Six Nine One Year Two Months Months Years
  • 15.
    IMPACT OF BADDEBT WRITEOFF ON SALES Your Write And Your Net off Profit is 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% You will need the following amount of additional sales to offset the loss $100,000 $5,000,000 $3,333,333 $2,500,000 $2,000,000 $1,666,666 $250,000 $12,500,000 $8,333,333 $6,250,000 $5,000,000 $4,166,666 $500,000 $25,000,000 $16,666,666 $12,500,000 $10,000,000 $8,333,333 $750,000 $37,500,000 $25,000,000 $18,750,000 $15,000,999 $12,500,000 $1,000,000 $50,000,000 $33,333,333 $25,000,000 $20,000,000 $16,666,666 $1,500,000 $75,000,000 $50,000,000 $37,500,000 $30,000,000 $25,000,000 $2,000,000 $100,000,000 $66,666,666 $50,000,000 $40,000,000 $33,333,333 Source: Commercial Collection Agency Association
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Post Judgment Collections Property or income execution.  Bank subpoenas with restraining notices to freeze bank accounts.  Sell commercial property.  Restrain monies due from third-parties.
  • 19.
    Information Essential to CollectYour Money Judgment  Banking information.  Clients.  Assets.  Place of business and locations.