SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Title: The effects of small impoundments on headwater prairie stream macroinvertebrate and
fish community structure
Authors: Liz Renner and Keith Gido
Abstract:
Low-order headwater prairie streams provide critical habitat for lotic fishes and aquatic
macroinvertebrates. Unfortunately, these streams are experiencing hydrologic disturbance as
aquifers are drained and small impoundments are constructed for watering livestock, irrigation,
flood control, and recreation. The influence of these small impoundments on macroinvertebrate
and fish communities is not yet well understood. The purpose of this study was to analyze the
influence of small impoundments on the macroinvertebrate and fish communities in headwater
streams within the Tallgrass Prairie National Preserve near Strong City, KS. We hypothesized
that seston levels would be significantly higher downstream of ponds, which would translate into
increased biomass of filter-feeding macroinvertebrates. We also hypothesized that
macroinvertebrate and fish richness would decrease downstream of ponds and that there would
be a greater percentage of centrarchids in pond-influenced reaches. To test these hypotheses, we
sampled 12 100-meter stream reaches, divided into 6 sites influenced by ponds upstream and 6
control sites. Macroinvertebrate samples were taken at each site on two separate sampling events
in June and July 2016 from pools using a stovepipe benthic corer and from riffles using a Surber
sampler. The fish community was sampled in June 2016 via backpack electroshocker and
seining. Seston and benthic organic matter samples were collected and the stream habitat was
characterized for each site. There was no significant difference in seston levels (p = 0.626) or
filter-feeder biomass (p = 0.346) between control and pond-influenced reaches. Ponds had no
detectable effects on downstream macroinvertebrate communities. There was no significant
difference in species richness between control and influenced reaches for either the core (p =
0.672) or surber (p = 0.168) samples. Moreover, we found no significant difference in fish
species richness between control and influenced reaches (p = 0.0503). Our results suggest that
the macroinvertebrates that inhabit headwater prairie streams are resilient in the face of
disturbance, which could explain why impoundments had little effect on them. The decline in
species richness at influenced sites suggests that the habitat fragmentation generated by
impoundments is detrimental to stream fishes. It is important to recognize that detecting shifts in
community structure generally requires multiyear sampling efforts. Future studies should
examine how communities respond to multiple impoundments over the course of a stream
continuum to determine whether there is a compounding pond effect and analyze whether the
distance downstream of an impoundment influences macroinvertebrate and fish community
structure.

More Related Content

What's hot

July 30-350-Barry Southerland
July 30-350-Barry SoutherlandJuly 30-350-Barry Southerland
July 30-350-Barry Southerland
Soil and Water Conservation Society
 
2015 11 - peter henderson
2015   11 - peter henderson2015   11 - peter henderson
2015 11 - peter henderson
SevernEstuary
 
Mullet river testing1
Mullet river testing1Mullet river testing1
Mullet river testing1John Hoopman
 
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
Teaching the Hudson Valley
 
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the Effects
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the EffectsFall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the Effects
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the EffectsMichelle C Bennett
 
Anna Doeser @FTF2013
Anna Doeser @FTF2013Anna Doeser @FTF2013
Anna Doeser @FTF2013FTF2013
 
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...Steven Tulevech
 
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-BradleyDSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
Deltares
 
Talk in ESPA Annual Conference
Talk in ESPA Annual ConferenceTalk in ESPA Annual Conference
Talk in ESPA Annual ConferenceMaafaka Ravelona
 
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns Rob Freudenberg
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns   Rob FreudenbergSea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns   Rob Freudenberg
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns Rob Freudenberg
National Institute For Coastal and Harbor Infrastructure
 
Agricultural Runoff
Agricultural RunoffAgricultural Runoff
Agricultural RunoffSarah White
 
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
Riverina Branch of the Australian Society of Soil Science
 
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's waterExpanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
Scott St. George
 
3 aquatic habitat_english_071418
3 aquatic habitat_english_0714183 aquatic habitat_english_071418
3 aquatic habitat_english_071418
natavoloshyna
 

What's hot (20)

July 30-350-Barry Southerland
July 30-350-Barry SoutherlandJuly 30-350-Barry Southerland
July 30-350-Barry Southerland
 
2015 11 - peter henderson
2015   11 - peter henderson2015   11 - peter henderson
2015 11 - peter henderson
 
FLAMEpresentation
FLAMEpresentationFLAMEpresentation
FLAMEpresentation
 
Mullet river testing1
Mullet river testing1Mullet river testing1
Mullet river testing1
 
PosterSutherland_Midwest
PosterSutherland_MidwestPosterSutherland_Midwest
PosterSutherland_Midwest
 
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
The Hudson during & after extreme weather events. What do they tell us about ...
 
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the Effects
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the EffectsFall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the Effects
Fall poster-Seasonal Variation of the Geochemistry and the Effects
 
Anna Doeser @FTF2013
Anna Doeser @FTF2013Anna Doeser @FTF2013
Anna Doeser @FTF2013
 
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...
Tulevech_Effects_of_Shoreline_Structure_on_Fish_Habitat_Use_and_Schooling_Beh...
 
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-BradleyDSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
 
Aquaculture jrk
Aquaculture jrkAquaculture jrk
Aquaculture jrk
 
Talk in ESPA Annual Conference
Talk in ESPA Annual ConferenceTalk in ESPA Annual Conference
Talk in ESPA Annual Conference
 
Thesis Abstract
Thesis AbstractThesis Abstract
Thesis Abstract
 
Fields-Sommers_SFS_presentation
Fields-Sommers_SFS_presentationFields-Sommers_SFS_presentation
Fields-Sommers_SFS_presentation
 
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns Rob Freudenberg
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns   Rob FreudenbergSea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns   Rob Freudenberg
Sea Level Rise and Environmental Concerns Rob Freudenberg
 
Agricultural Runoff
Agricultural RunoffAgricultural Runoff
Agricultural Runoff
 
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
2019-05-02 - Peter Bacon & Tapas Biswas - Quantifying the benefits of wetland...
 
Term Paper1
Term Paper1Term Paper1
Term Paper1
 
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's waterExpanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
Expanding the window - the past, present, and future of Minnesota's water
 
3 aquatic habitat_english_071418
3 aquatic habitat_english_0714183 aquatic habitat_english_071418
3 aquatic habitat_english_071418
 

Viewers also liked

Qué han investigado los autores del artículo
Qué han investigado los autores del artículoQué han investigado los autores del artículo
Qué han investigado los autores del artículo
Glucosaminoglucano
 
5. Insurance considerations
5. Insurance considerations5. Insurance considerations
5. Insurance considerations
ChartwellPA
 
4. Transitioning to home setting
4. Transitioning to home setting4. Transitioning to home setting
4. Transitioning to home setting
ChartwellPA
 
Aseptic Technique
Aseptic TechniqueAseptic Technique
Aseptic Technique
St Mark's Academic Institute
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Soalan thn 6
Soalan thn 6Soalan thn 6
Soalan thn 6
 
Canada 3
Canada 3Canada 3
Canada 3
 
Qué han investigado los autores del artículo
Qué han investigado los autores del artículoQué han investigado los autores del artículo
Qué han investigado los autores del artículo
 
5. Insurance considerations
5. Insurance considerations5. Insurance considerations
5. Insurance considerations
 
4. Transitioning to home setting
4. Transitioning to home setting4. Transitioning to home setting
4. Transitioning to home setting
 
Aseptic Technique
Aseptic TechniqueAseptic Technique
Aseptic Technique
 

Similar to Abstract_Renner

7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016
7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_20167_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016
7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016Alex Seeney
 
UW WSM - Practicum final draft
UW WSM - Practicum final draftUW WSM - Practicum final draft
UW WSM - Practicum final draftEthan Huffaker
 
Protect Rhode Island Brook Trout
Protect Rhode Island Brook TroutProtect Rhode Island Brook Trout
Protect Rhode Island Brook Trout
Martin Custodio
 
Trophic downgrading of planet earth
Trophic downgrading of planet earthTrophic downgrading of planet earth
Trophic downgrading of planet earth
Loretta Roberson
 
LAUER DenmanPosterFINAL
LAUER DenmanPosterFINALLAUER DenmanPosterFINAL
LAUER DenmanPosterFINALMarissa Lauer
 
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishes
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishesbejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishes
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishesIvonne Bejarano
 
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)Emily McDonald
 
Tawatina River Presentation
Tawatina River PresentationTawatina River Presentation
Tawatina River Presentation
tawatinaw
 
cakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasdcakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasd
HalfHuman1
 
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston MassachusettsOyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Mass Oyster Project
 
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher GoblerNitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
Save The Great South Bay
 
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdfSustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
SOURAV SAHA
 
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152Laura Kelm
 
Local Water Quality Assessment
Local Water Quality AssessmentLocal Water Quality Assessment
Local Water Quality AssessmentKenneth Goodson
 

Similar to Abstract_Renner (20)

7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016
7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_20167_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016
7_PDFsam_FBA_NEWS_70_WINTER_2016
 
R_KingSpreeDayPoster'16
R_KingSpreeDayPoster'16R_KingSpreeDayPoster'16
R_KingSpreeDayPoster'16
 
UW WSM - Practicum final draft
UW WSM - Practicum final draftUW WSM - Practicum final draft
UW WSM - Practicum final draft
 
Beaver Final Paper2
Beaver Final Paper2Beaver Final Paper2
Beaver Final Paper2
 
Protect Rhode Island Brook Trout
Protect Rhode Island Brook TroutProtect Rhode Island Brook Trout
Protect Rhode Island Brook Trout
 
Ecology Essay
Ecology EssayEcology Essay
Ecology Essay
 
Trophic downgrading of planet earth
Trophic downgrading of planet earthTrophic downgrading of planet earth
Trophic downgrading of planet earth
 
SFG poster 2016
SFG poster 2016SFG poster 2016
SFG poster 2016
 
LAUER DenmanPosterFINAL
LAUER DenmanPosterFINALLAUER DenmanPosterFINAL
LAUER DenmanPosterFINAL
 
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishes
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishesbejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishes
bejarano_rodriguez_2013_phd_mesophotic_fishes
 
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)
Kushog Factsheet #2 (Biological)
 
Tawatina River Presentation
Tawatina River PresentationTawatina River Presentation
Tawatina River Presentation
 
Grimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo SalvageGrimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo Salvage
 
cakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasdcakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasd
 
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston MassachusettsOyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
Oyster Restoration Boston Massachusetts
 
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher GoblerNitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
Nitrogen Pollution and The Future of Long Island By Prof. Christopher Gobler
 
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdfSustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
Sustainable Management Approach In Rivers, Lakes And reservoirs.pdf
 
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152WaterQualityReportCard1215152
WaterQualityReportCard1215152
 
A.Strobridge-Research.Paper
A.Strobridge-Research.PaperA.Strobridge-Research.Paper
A.Strobridge-Research.Paper
 
Local Water Quality Assessment
Local Water Quality AssessmentLocal Water Quality Assessment
Local Water Quality Assessment
 

Abstract_Renner

  • 1. Title: The effects of small impoundments on headwater prairie stream macroinvertebrate and fish community structure Authors: Liz Renner and Keith Gido Abstract: Low-order headwater prairie streams provide critical habitat for lotic fishes and aquatic macroinvertebrates. Unfortunately, these streams are experiencing hydrologic disturbance as aquifers are drained and small impoundments are constructed for watering livestock, irrigation, flood control, and recreation. The influence of these small impoundments on macroinvertebrate and fish communities is not yet well understood. The purpose of this study was to analyze the influence of small impoundments on the macroinvertebrate and fish communities in headwater streams within the Tallgrass Prairie National Preserve near Strong City, KS. We hypothesized that seston levels would be significantly higher downstream of ponds, which would translate into increased biomass of filter-feeding macroinvertebrates. We also hypothesized that macroinvertebrate and fish richness would decrease downstream of ponds and that there would be a greater percentage of centrarchids in pond-influenced reaches. To test these hypotheses, we sampled 12 100-meter stream reaches, divided into 6 sites influenced by ponds upstream and 6 control sites. Macroinvertebrate samples were taken at each site on two separate sampling events in June and July 2016 from pools using a stovepipe benthic corer and from riffles using a Surber sampler. The fish community was sampled in June 2016 via backpack electroshocker and seining. Seston and benthic organic matter samples were collected and the stream habitat was characterized for each site. There was no significant difference in seston levels (p = 0.626) or filter-feeder biomass (p = 0.346) between control and pond-influenced reaches. Ponds had no detectable effects on downstream macroinvertebrate communities. There was no significant difference in species richness between control and influenced reaches for either the core (p = 0.672) or surber (p = 0.168) samples. Moreover, we found no significant difference in fish species richness between control and influenced reaches (p = 0.0503). Our results suggest that the macroinvertebrates that inhabit headwater prairie streams are resilient in the face of disturbance, which could explain why impoundments had little effect on them. The decline in species richness at influenced sites suggests that the habitat fragmentation generated by impoundments is detrimental to stream fishes. It is important to recognize that detecting shifts in community structure generally requires multiyear sampling efforts. Future studies should examine how communities respond to multiple impoundments over the course of a stream continuum to determine whether there is a compounding pond effect and analyze whether the distance downstream of an impoundment influences macroinvertebrate and fish community structure.