The document summarizes the Access to Seeds Index, which benchmarks seed companies' efforts to improve smallholder farmers' access to seeds. The index is developed through a multi-stakeholder process to create transparency around the seed industry's role. It presents company and regional scores on strengths, portfolio, and presence. The next steps discussed are further stakeholder engagement, testing new regional indexes, reviewing the methodology, and coordinating with other initiatives.
3. What can be the role of an
industry?
What do individual companies
have to offer?
What can we learn from what is
happening in daily practice?
Provide an evidence base for
stakeholder dialogue
Offer inspiration from peers
and best practices
Give credit to companies that
show leadership
The private sector is seen
as a crucial partner to achieve
the SDG’s
This requires understanding
of how an industry can
contribute
Industry benchmarks can
help building knowledge,
understanding, trust
Background
Industry Indexes can be a powerful instrument to promote private sector
engagement, as needed to achieve the SDG’s
4. Create transparency on current activities
to clarify and understand the role of the seed industry
Provide an evidence base to the conversation
on where and how the seed industry can play a role
Encourage seed companies to step up their efforts
guided by a multi-stakeholder agenda and inspiration from peers
Help identify private sector partners
based on insights in strengths, portfolio, presence
Background
Objectives of the
Access to Seeds Index
5. jan12 – mar13
Feasibility and
landscaping
studies
Consultations
and dialogue
Methodology
development
Index
development
Consultations
and dialogue
Methodology
review
Index
development
mar13 – dec13 jan14 – feb15 feb15 – feb16
mar16 – dec16 jan17 – nov17 dec17 – dec18
2012 2013 2014 2015
2016 2017 2018
Methodology
Report
Access to Seeds
Index 2016 Report
Methodology
Report
Access to Seeds
Index 2018 Report
Timeline
The Access to Seeds Index is developed in a two-year Index Cycle to
monitor progress and refine methodology
Landscaping
Report
Cycle 1
Cycle 2
7. What the Access to Seeds Index presents
Industry benchmarks: insights on leadership,
both on global and regional level
8. What the Access to Seeds Index presents
Company presence per country
in four regions
9. What the Access to Seeds Index presents
Company scorecards: insights on strengths,
portfolio and presence of individual companies
10. Availability
Mobile seed shops to
reach local markets
Victoria Seeds,
Uganda
Autonomy
Marketing affordable
OPV varieties
Kenya Seed Company
Kenya, Uganda,
Rwanda
Profitability
Connecting farmers
to output markets
DuPont Pioneer
Ethiopia
Affordability
Seed insurance
against weather risks
Syngenta,
Kenya, Tanzania,
Rwanda
Suitability
Breeding station for
local crops and varieties
Rijk Zwaan,
East-West Seed
Tanzania
Capability
School for next
generation farmers
Bayer, India
What the Access to Seeds Index presents
Best practices: practical examples of company activities
in various dimensions of ‘access’
11. What the Access to Seeds Index presents
All the data is added to the public domain and
freely available via our reports and website
13. Research scope Scope 2016 Criteria
Geographic • Latin America
• Western Africa
• Eastern Africa
• South and Southeast Asia
• Smallholder presence
• Food security challenge
• Agricultural potential
Crops • Field crops
• Vegetables
• Local crops
• Only food crops
• Common crops based on area harvested in regions
• Local crops based on stakeholder consultations
Company • Global field crop seed
• Global vegetable seed
• Regional Eastern Africa
• Integrated seed business model
• Seed revenues (global)
• Peer recognition (regional)
After each Index, the scope and criteria are evaluated and
where necessary adjusted for the next Index
Scope of Research
To ensure a fair comparison and benchmark,
the scope of research is based on clear criteria
14. • Global Index focuses on activities of global leaders in all
four regions combined
• Regional Index focuses on leading seed companies in a
specific region
• ATSI 2016 presents a Regional Index for Eastern Africa;
Western Africa and other regions explored for 2018 edition
Western Africa Eastern Africa
Benin
Burkina Faso
Cote d’Ivoire
Gambia
Ghana
Guinea
Guinea-Bissau
Liberia
Mali
Niger
Nigeria
Senegal
Sierra Leone
Togo
Burundi
Ethiopia
Kenya
Malawi
Madagascar
Mozambique
Rwanda
South Sudan
Tanzania
Uganda
Zambia
Zimbabwe
Country coverage
The Access to Seeds Index focuses on four regions with
(1) smallholder presence (2) food security challenge (3) agricultural potential
15. Seven measurement areas
Each with four types of indicators
• Commitment
• Performance
• Transparency
• Innovation
Weighted Scorecard approach
Total score is sum of
weighted indicator scores
Relative ranking
Comparing companies with
each other, not to an ideal state
(companies set and raise the bar)
Methodology
The Index assesses company activities in
seven areas with in total 73 indicators
17. The Foundation has no financial ties
to the seed industry
SB and ERC are composed of
experts with various backgrounds
• Farmers
• Industry
• Government
• Science
• NGO’s
SB members cannot have active ties
to companies in index scope
Regional partner and Regional
ERC ensure regional buy-in
Governance
The Access to Seeds Foundation has multi-stakeholder governance
to ensure independence and broad support for the initiative
Supervisory Board
(SB)
Expert Review
Committee (ERC)
Contractors
Research
Regional partner
Staff
Program management
Research
Communication
Finance
Executive Board
Executive director
Operational director
18. Governance
For each step of methodology and Index development, responsibilities
and roles are clearly described in the Foundation’s by laws
Index
Report
Stakeholder
consultations
Methodology
Report
Indicator weighting
scoring guidelines
• SB approves
before publication
• ERC advises on
agenda for review
• SB approves
process, agenda
• ERC evaluates
• SB approves
• ERC gives advice
• SB approves
20. Process
1. Discuss findings with farmers,
industry, other stakeholders
2. Test feasibility new regional
indexes for West Africa, Latin-
America, SSEA
3. Review methodology, start cycle
towards the second Index (2018)
4. Explore coordination with other
index initiatives (World Bank, TASAI)
Topics
1. Focus measurement areas on
need to know, delete nice to know
2. Add country level data to present
private sector activity per country
3. Explore quality and impact as
topics for company assessment
4. Keep burden low of data provision
by companies
Access to Seeds Index
What is next?