Compensation



  Cash, Bonuses, Insurance,
     Vacation, Holidays
     Perks, Recognition
What does
 compensation (what
 you receive for your
services) mean to you?
A Definition . . .
• All forms of
  – financial return,
  – tangible services and
  – benefits
• that employees receive as part of their
  employment relationship
Components of a Total
     Compensation Program - 1
• Financial
• Direct
  – wages, salaries, commissions, bonuses
• Indirect
  – insurance plans
     • life, health, dental, disability
  – social assistance benefits
     • retirement plans, social security, workers’ comp
  – paid absences
     • vacations, holidays, sick leave
Components of a Total
    Compensation Program - 2
• Non-Financial
• The Job
  – interesting, challenging, responsible
  – opportunity for recognition, advancement
  – feeling of achievement
• Job Environment
  – policies, supervision, co-workers, status
    symbols, working conditions, flextime,
    compressed work week, job sharing,
    telecommuting, flexible benefits programs
Factors that Influence Wage
              Levels
    Conditions of
    Labor Market           Compensation
                             Policy of
                            Organization
 Area Wage
   Rates                        Worth of
                                 Job
  Cost of           WAGE
  Living
                     MIX       Employee’s
                              Relative Worth
Collective
Bargaining
                            Employer’s
       Legal               Ability to Pay
    Requirements
Designing a Compensation
         System
 Steps in the Decision Process
Step 1 - Establish General
 Wage Level for Organization
• Factors to consider:
• Other firm’s rates
• Union demands
• Cost-of-living changes
• Firm’s ability to pay
Step 2 - Establish Wage
 Structure (The Pay for Each
             Job)
• Employ a job evaluation system
  –   Ranking
  –   Job Classification
  –   Point System
  –   Factor Comparison
• Results:
  – pay grades
  – rate ranges
Step 3 - Establish Pay for Each
    Individual on Each Job
• Inputs:
• Performance appraisal information
• Seniority system
A Pay Model -- 3 Basic
         Components
• I. Compensation Objectives
• II. Foundation Concepts
• III. Techniques for Management
A Pay Model
I. Compensation Objectives - 1
• Organization Performance
• Labor Costs
• Attitudes and Behaviors
• Laws and Regulations
A Pay Model
I. Compensation Objectives - 2
• Influence forms & procedures
• For example:
  – if objective is pay for performance,
    emphasize incentives, merit pay plans
  – if objective is stable, experienced
    workforce, emphasize seniority-based
    pay
A Pay Model
     II. Foundation Concepts
• Equity
• External Equity
• Comparison: outside organization
• Internal Equity
• Comparison: inside organization,
  among jobs
• Employee Equity
• Comparison: individuals doing same
  job for same organization
Equity Theory
                      Equity
                   Op/Ip = Oo/Io
            Under-reward Inequity
               Op/Ip < Oo/Io
             Over-reward Inequity
                Op/Ip > Oo/Io

           p = personal, o = comparison other

         I = Inputs                O = Outcomes
effort, ability, experience      pay, benefits, perks
Why does Equity Matter?

What Behaviors are Likely to
Occur when Inequity is Felt?
A Pay Model
III. Techniques for Management

• A. Pay Level
• B. Pay Structure
• C. Individual Pay Rates
A Pay Model
    III. Techniques for Management
            A. Pay Level
• Defined: average rates paid by
  employer
• Applicable concept: External Equity
• 3 Pure Alternatives
  – lead competition
  – match competition
  – lag competition
• Mechanism used: Market Wage
  Survey
Market Wage and Salary
         Surveys
Select key jobs.
Determine relevant labor market.
Select organizations.
Decide on information to collect:
wages/benefits/pay policies.
Compile data received.
Determine wages and benefits to pay.
Market Wage Levels


                                            l
                                       Leve
                                  a ge
                            ’ sW             l
                        n yA             eve
                     mp
                       a             eL
                                  ag                  el
                  Co         etW                  Lev
                                               ge
                         ark              Wa
                        M             B’s
                               pany
                         C om




•Which company is leading the market?
•Which company is lagging the market?
•What would the wage level line look like for a company
that was meeting/matching the market?
A Pay Model
    III. Techniques for Management
          B. Pay Structure
• Defined: pay rates for different jobs
  within a single organization
• Applicable concept: Internal Equity
• Pay more for jobs with
  – greater qualifications
  – less desirable working conditions
  – more valuable output
• Mechanism used: Job Analysis & Job
  Evaluation
Job Evaluation
• defined: the systematic evaluation of
  job descriptions
• outcome: a hierarchy of
  organizational jobs according to their
  content and value to the organization
• Methods:
  –   ranking
  –   classification
  –   factor comparison
  –   point method
Job Ranking System

  Simplest and oldest system of job
evaluation by which jobs are arrayed
  on the basis of their relative worth
Job Classification System

 System of job evaluation by which jobs
  are classified and grouped according
to a series of predetermined wage grades
Point System

  Quantitative job evaluation procedure
that determines the relative value of a job
      by the total points assigned to it
Factor Comparison System

 Job evaluation system that permits the
 evaluation process to be accomplished
on a factor-by-factor basis by developing
        a factor comparison scale
Hay Profile Method

Job evaluation technique using three
factors – knowledge, mental activity,
  and accountability – to evaluate
 executive and managerial positions
A Pay Model
    III. Techniques for Management
     C. Individual Pay Rates
• Defined: pay rates for different
  individuals doing the same job within
  an organization
• Applicable concept: Employee Equity
• 2 Techniques
  – Flat Rate
  – Pay Ranges
• Mechanisms used: Performance or
  Seniority
Wage Curve

 Curve in a scattergram representing
the relationship between relative worth
          of jobs and wage rates
Components of the Wage Structure
Pay Grades

Groups of jobs within a particular class
that are paid the same rate or rate range
Elements of the Rate Range
Common Pay Grade Ranges
• Laborers & Trades, up to 20%
• Clerical, Technical, Para-professional,
  15-49%
• First Level Supervisors, Professionals
  30-50%
• Middle and Senior Level
  Management, 40-100%
Monitoring Compensation
            Costs
• Compra-Ratio
• Formula:
       Actual Average Pay for Grade
          Midpoint Pay for Grade

• A compra ratio < 1 indicates lag
• A compra-ratio > indicates excess
How Would You Handle Outliers?
    An individual whose current pay is beyond
    the maximum of the pay grade for his/her
    job




   An individual whose current pay is
   below the minimum of the pay grade
   for his/her job
Federal Wage Laws

            Davis-Beacon Act
                 of 1931



               Walsh-Healy Act
                   of 1936



                Fair Labor
             Standards Act of
                   1938
Nonexempt Employees

   Employees covered by the overtime
provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act
Exempt Employees

Employees not covered by the overtime
provisions of the Fair Labor Standards
                   Act
Comparable Worth

The concept that male and female jobs
that are dissimilar, but equal in terms
  of value or worth to the employer,
        should be paid the same
Wage-Rate Compression

 Compression of differentials between
job classes, particularly the differential
   between hourly workers and their
                 managers

343 pay structure

  • 1.
    Compensation Cash,Bonuses, Insurance, Vacation, Holidays Perks, Recognition
  • 2.
    What does compensation(what you receive for your services) mean to you?
  • 3.
    A Definition .. . • All forms of – financial return, – tangible services and – benefits • that employees receive as part of their employment relationship
  • 4.
    Components of aTotal Compensation Program - 1 • Financial • Direct – wages, salaries, commissions, bonuses • Indirect – insurance plans • life, health, dental, disability – social assistance benefits • retirement plans, social security, workers’ comp – paid absences • vacations, holidays, sick leave
  • 5.
    Components of aTotal Compensation Program - 2 • Non-Financial • The Job – interesting, challenging, responsible – opportunity for recognition, advancement – feeling of achievement • Job Environment – policies, supervision, co-workers, status symbols, working conditions, flextime, compressed work week, job sharing, telecommuting, flexible benefits programs
  • 6.
    Factors that InfluenceWage Levels Conditions of Labor Market Compensation Policy of Organization Area Wage Rates Worth of Job Cost of WAGE Living MIX Employee’s Relative Worth Collective Bargaining Employer’s Legal Ability to Pay Requirements
  • 7.
    Designing a Compensation System Steps in the Decision Process
  • 8.
    Step 1 -Establish General Wage Level for Organization • Factors to consider: • Other firm’s rates • Union demands • Cost-of-living changes • Firm’s ability to pay
  • 9.
    Step 2 -Establish Wage Structure (The Pay for Each Job) • Employ a job evaluation system – Ranking – Job Classification – Point System – Factor Comparison • Results: – pay grades – rate ranges
  • 10.
    Step 3 -Establish Pay for Each Individual on Each Job • Inputs: • Performance appraisal information • Seniority system
  • 11.
    A Pay Model-- 3 Basic Components • I. Compensation Objectives • II. Foundation Concepts • III. Techniques for Management
  • 12.
    A Pay Model I.Compensation Objectives - 1 • Organization Performance • Labor Costs • Attitudes and Behaviors • Laws and Regulations
  • 13.
    A Pay Model I.Compensation Objectives - 2 • Influence forms & procedures • For example: – if objective is pay for performance, emphasize incentives, merit pay plans – if objective is stable, experienced workforce, emphasize seniority-based pay
  • 14.
    A Pay Model II. Foundation Concepts • Equity • External Equity • Comparison: outside organization • Internal Equity • Comparison: inside organization, among jobs • Employee Equity • Comparison: individuals doing same job for same organization
  • 15.
    Equity Theory Equity Op/Ip = Oo/Io Under-reward Inequity Op/Ip < Oo/Io Over-reward Inequity Op/Ip > Oo/Io p = personal, o = comparison other I = Inputs O = Outcomes effort, ability, experience pay, benefits, perks
  • 16.
    Why does EquityMatter? What Behaviors are Likely to Occur when Inequity is Felt?
  • 17.
    A Pay Model III.Techniques for Management • A. Pay Level • B. Pay Structure • C. Individual Pay Rates
  • 18.
    A Pay Model III. Techniques for Management A. Pay Level • Defined: average rates paid by employer • Applicable concept: External Equity • 3 Pure Alternatives – lead competition – match competition – lag competition • Mechanism used: Market Wage Survey
  • 19.
    Market Wage andSalary Surveys Select key jobs. Determine relevant labor market. Select organizations. Decide on information to collect: wages/benefits/pay policies. Compile data received. Determine wages and benefits to pay.
  • 20.
    Market Wage Levels l Leve a ge ’ sW l n yA eve mp a eL ag el Co etW Lev ge ark Wa M B’s pany C om •Which company is leading the market? •Which company is lagging the market? •What would the wage level line look like for a company that was meeting/matching the market?
  • 21.
    A Pay Model III. Techniques for Management B. Pay Structure • Defined: pay rates for different jobs within a single organization • Applicable concept: Internal Equity • Pay more for jobs with – greater qualifications – less desirable working conditions – more valuable output • Mechanism used: Job Analysis & Job Evaluation
  • 22.
    Job Evaluation • defined:the systematic evaluation of job descriptions • outcome: a hierarchy of organizational jobs according to their content and value to the organization • Methods: – ranking – classification – factor comparison – point method
  • 23.
    Job Ranking System Simplest and oldest system of job evaluation by which jobs are arrayed on the basis of their relative worth
  • 24.
    Job Classification System System of job evaluation by which jobs are classified and grouped according to a series of predetermined wage grades
  • 25.
    Point System Quantitative job evaluation procedure that determines the relative value of a job by the total points assigned to it
  • 26.
    Factor Comparison System Job evaluation system that permits the evaluation process to be accomplished on a factor-by-factor basis by developing a factor comparison scale
  • 27.
    Hay Profile Method Jobevaluation technique using three factors – knowledge, mental activity, and accountability – to evaluate executive and managerial positions
  • 28.
    A Pay Model III. Techniques for Management C. Individual Pay Rates • Defined: pay rates for different individuals doing the same job within an organization • Applicable concept: Employee Equity • 2 Techniques – Flat Rate – Pay Ranges • Mechanisms used: Performance or Seniority
  • 29.
    Wage Curve Curvein a scattergram representing the relationship between relative worth of jobs and wage rates
  • 30.
    Components of theWage Structure
  • 31.
    Pay Grades Groups ofjobs within a particular class that are paid the same rate or rate range
  • 32.
    Elements of theRate Range
  • 33.
    Common Pay GradeRanges • Laborers & Trades, up to 20% • Clerical, Technical, Para-professional, 15-49% • First Level Supervisors, Professionals 30-50% • Middle and Senior Level Management, 40-100%
  • 34.
    Monitoring Compensation Costs • Compra-Ratio • Formula: Actual Average Pay for Grade Midpoint Pay for Grade • A compra ratio < 1 indicates lag • A compra-ratio > indicates excess
  • 35.
    How Would YouHandle Outliers? An individual whose current pay is beyond the maximum of the pay grade for his/her job An individual whose current pay is below the minimum of the pay grade for his/her job
  • 36.
    Federal Wage Laws Davis-Beacon Act of 1931 Walsh-Healy Act of 1936 Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938
  • 37.
    Nonexempt Employees Employees covered by the overtime provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act
  • 38.
    Exempt Employees Employees notcovered by the overtime provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act
  • 39.
    Comparable Worth The conceptthat male and female jobs that are dissimilar, but equal in terms of value or worth to the employer, should be paid the same
  • 40.
    Wage-Rate Compression Compressionof differentials between job classes, particularly the differential between hourly workers and their managers

Editor's Notes

  • #3 compensation means different things to different people: &gt;return on effort &gt;reward for satisfactory or outstanding work &gt;indicative of value attached to skills and abilities &gt;return on investment in education and training &gt;source of personal wealth &gt;important determinant of economic and social well being
  • #7 Determining the wage offered an employee is a function of both internal and external factors (referred to as the “wage mix”). Internal factors include: Employer’s Compensation Policy . Each employer views compensation as one of the variables under their control and so uses pay as a tool for accomplishing organization goals. In general, companies may lead, match, or trail pay standards relative to the competition and/or combine base pay with incentives to reward specific goal-based accomplishment. Worth of a Job . Where a formal compensation system is lacking, pay is set on the subjective opinion of the responsible party’s evaluation of the worth of a job. Employee’s Relative Worth . The differential contributions and accomplishments of different employees (both hourly and salaried), may be reflected in different levels of pay, often within a given range for an employment level. Employer’s Ability to Pay . All organizations have finite budgets and compensation is limited to what is available. External factors include: Conditions of the Labor Market . The labor market reflects the forces of supply and demand for qualified labor within an area. Area Wage Rates . The company should be aware of the prevailing wage rates being paid in the area of operation. Cost of Living . Inflation increases the cost of living and compensation rates have to be adjusted upward periodically. A common benchmark is the consumer price index (CPI), compiled by the federal government. Collective Bargaining . Collective bargaining pools the power of the labor force in an effort to negotiate an increase in real wages (pay increases above the CPI). Legal Requirements . Legislative actions, such as minimum wage laws, typically set a floor for compensation, at least for hourly employees.
  • #13 Facilitate Organization Performance Control Labor Costs Influence Employee Attitudes and Behaviors attract retain motivate Comply with Laws and Regulations Fair Labor standards Act sets minimum wage exempt/non-exempt; 1 1/2 for OT ages of employees Equal Pay Act equal pay for equal work Comparable Worth?
  • #15 &gt; Equity = building block foundation on which pay systems are designed &gt;Review equity theory: outcomes to inputs External Equity Comparison: outside organization 2 issues: are rates competitive enough to attract/retain employees control HR costs so org prices remain competitive Internal Equity Comparison: inside organization, among jobs does 1 job require more/less skill or experience than another is output of one job more/less value than that of another Employee Equity Comparison: individuals doing same job for same organization should all employees receive the same pay?
  • #17 Reducing one’s own inputs Increasing one’s outcomes Leaving the situation
  • #19 Market Wage Survey -- &gt;done by interview, mailed questionnaire, telephone &gt;done by org or consultants KEY FACTORS: benchmark job work content relatively stable over time held by large # of employees free of discriminatory patterns not subject to recent surpluses/shortages job description employers to include geographic area to cover data gathered median minimum maximum average
  • #22 Effects of Structure: experts argue that equitable pay structures are related to everything from employee performance to strikes Effects employee decisions to join stay leave organization whether or not to invest in additional training required for promotions, new jobs
  • #30 Flat Rate common in union contracts distrust of evaluation system Pay Ranges set limits on rates an employer will pay for a particular job design: 1) develop classes or grades groups of jobs considered substantially similar for pay purposes 2) set midpoints, maximums, minimums Next issue: progression through the ranges criteria? seniority, merit
  • #36 pay structure represents policy, but practice may not always coincide &gt;1 way to examine the correspondence is to compute a Compra-Ratio &gt;the actual average pay for grade/midpoint pay for grade &gt;provides a direct assessment of the degree to which actual pay is consistent with the pay policy a CR of less than 1 suggests that actual pay is LAGGING behind policy a CR of more than 1 suggests that pay and costs exceed policy
  • #38 Compensation management is subject to state and federal regulation. On the state level, a majority of states have minimum wage laws or wage boards that fix minimum wage rates on an industry-by-industry basis. On the federal level, three principal acts of legislation affect wages: Davis-Beacon Act of 1931 . Also called the Prevailing Wage Law, this law requires that the minimum wage paid to persons employed on federal public works projects worth more than $2,000 be at least equal to the prevailing rates and that overtime be 1.5 times this rate. “Prevailing” is defined as the rate paid to at least 30 percent of the workers in the area. In areas where there is a mixture of both union and non-union labor, this 30 percent rule is controversial. If the union represents at least 30 percent of the labor force, then federal contracts there might pay significantly higher wages than are received by the majority of workers. Walsh-Healy Act of 1936 . Called the Public Contracts Act, Walsh-Healy covers workers employed on government contract work for supplies, equipment, and materials greater than $10,000. The act requires employers to pay employees at least the prevailing rates and overtime of 1.5 times the regular rate for work beyond 8 hours a day and 40 hours a week. The wage rate computation must also include any bonuses or incentive payments part of the employee’s total earnings. Walsh-Healy also restricts child and convict labor practices. Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (as amended) . Called the Wage and Hour Act, this bill and amendments cover those employees engaged in the production of goods for interstate and foreign commerce. Major provisions are concerned with minimum wage and overtime payments, child labor, and equal rights.