SlideShare a Scribd company logo
USDA Oversight Past to Present
JENNIFER KUZMA, PHD
CO-DIRECTOR OF GES CENTER
GOODNIGHT-NC GSK FOUNDATION DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR
SCHOOL OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS
Disclaimer:
We are academics trying to understand the new rule. Although we have decades of
experience working with GM crop regulation and genetic engineering & societal issues,
we do not claim to have all the answers about the details or impacts on different sectors.
We are presenting how we understand the process and issues for discussion purposes.
Thank you!
Coordinated Framework for Regulation of Biotechnology
No new categories of risks, no new laws needed, “product not process”
EPA BiopesticideFDA GM plant food/feed—FFDCA
• Voluntary
• No determination of safety
USDA Plant Pest Act
• GM plants with plant pest DNA
sequences
EPA FIFRA
• plant incorporated protectants (Bt)
All other plants have been exempted since
mid 2000s-2010
• USDA Am I Regulated Process
Why “Plant Pest”?—Historic Artefact
USDA Old
Regulatory Paths
Am I
regulated?
2017
Proposed
Rule
Invokes
Noxious
Weed and
Plant Pest
Authorities
2020
SECURE
Rule
Only Plant
Pest Risk
Authorities
2008
Proposed
Rule
Invokes
Noxious
Weed and
Plant Pest
Authorities
Bush II
to Obama
Obama
to Trump
Gene editing arises
Sustainable, Ecological, Consistent, Uniform, Responsible, Efficient (SECURE) rule
“organisms modified through GE”
GE is “techniques that use recombinant, synthesized, or amplified nucleic acids to modify or createa genome”
Organism that can directly or indirectly injure, cause damage to, or cause disease in any plant or plant product
Key Features of SECURE (continued)
USDA New
Regulatory Paths
Under SECURE
Pros and Cons of SECURE
PROS
Shift to Plant Pest Risk Focus and away from
DNA presence
Tiered approach—exempt things with which
we have experience
Provisioning of information and FR comment
period for some categories
 E.g new USDA exemptions for what could be
achieved from conventional breeding
CONs
•Failure to invoke Noxious Weed provisions of
PPA---despite main risks of 1st gen GM crops
•Exemptions having little to do with potential
product risk
•Lack of public information for self or USDA
confirmed exempt
•Lack of formal assessment & comment period
in FR for RSR determinations
Estimate of $8.3M annual cost
savings to private industry
$3.4 M cost to APHIS
Not over $100M so no CBA
mandated by EO 12866
USDA Timeline of
Implementation
of SECURE

More Related Content

What's hot

Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
OECD Environment
 
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary FittOECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
OECD Environment
 
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
OECD Environment
 
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit fliesMolecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
Plant Biosecurity Cooperative Research Centre
 
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threatsQuarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
Plant Biosecurity Cooperative Research Centre
 
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in cropsGenetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
ICRISAT
 
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
John Blue
 
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metricsPlant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
Plant Biosecurity Cooperative Research Centre
 
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCRDetection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
Plant Biosecurity Cooperative Research Centre
 
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinical
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinicalAdvanced Report Customization via VSClinical
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinical
Golden Helix
 
Annotation capabilities
Annotation capabilitiesAnnotation capabilities
Annotation capabilities
Golden Helix
 
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeqAn Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
Golden Helix
 
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
Golden Helix
 
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
Golden Helix
 
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-caOverview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
GlobalCompliancePanel
 
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.finalVaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
Bill Enright
 
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinicalAMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
Golden Helix
 
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
kphodel
 
Avalanche Biotech
Avalanche BiotechAvalanche Biotech
Avalanche Biotech
Healthegy
 
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective AntibodyTherapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
kphodel
 

What's hot (20)

Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
Current risk assessment approaches for environmental and food & feed safety -...
 
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary FittOECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
OECD Co-operative research programme - Gary Fitt
 
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
Regulatory aspects associated to genome editing in Australia - situation for ...
 
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit fliesMolecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
Molecular basis of response to (sub)lethal stresses in Tephritid fruit flies
 
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threatsQuarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
Quarantine and surveillance modelling for horticulture biosecurity threats
 
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in cropsGenetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
Genetic molecular markers to accelerate genetic gains in crops
 
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
Dr. Patrick McDermott - One Health Antibiotic Stewardship State of Science - ...
 
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metricsPlant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
Plant pest impacts: a common set of metrics
 
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCRDetection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
Detection and surveillance of phylloxera using qPCR
 
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinical
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinicalAdvanced Report Customization via VSClinical
Advanced Report Customization via VSClinical
 
Annotation capabilities
Annotation capabilitiesAnnotation capabilities
Annotation capabilities
 
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeqAn Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
An Exploration of Clinical Workflows in VarSeq
 
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
Exome Analysis with VS-CNV and VSClinical: Updated Strategies and Expanded Ca...
 
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
Introducing VSClinical AMP Guidelines: A Comprehensive Workflow for NGS Testi...
 
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-caOverview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
Overview of-device-regulation-fda-san-diego-ca
 
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.finalVaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
Vaxin Notice of Allowance Release.final
 
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinicalAMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
AMP-Based Variant Classification with VSClinical
 
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
Non-Resistant Antimicrobial Therapy: Treating Superbugs That Cause Nosocomial...
 
Avalanche Biotech
Avalanche BiotechAvalanche Biotech
Avalanche Biotech
 
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective AntibodyTherapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
Therapeutic Targeting of Alzheimer's Disease with a Selective Antibody
 

Similar to 1 Jennifer Kuzma USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020

Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold TrickNuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
Mary-Katherine Kearney
 
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass SummitDavid Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
David Glass
 
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops RedickTerminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
Thomas Redick
 
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and ResponseFoodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
National Restaurant Association
 
Genetic Modified Organism Regulation in India
Genetic Modified Organism  Regulation in IndiaGenetic Modified Organism  Regulation in India
Genetic Modified Organism Regulation in India
MeehirMerai
 
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
Asian Food Regulation Information Service
 
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship? Successes and reinvestment.
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship?  Successes and reinvestment.What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship?  Successes and reinvestment.
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship? Successes and reinvestment.
James McCarter
 
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptxgenetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
HanySaid33
 
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
David Glass
 
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
Daffodil International University
 
Genetically engineered foods
Genetically engineered foodsGenetically engineered foods
Genetically engineered foods
SDAAH
 
International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
 International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ... International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
berciyalgolda1
 
transgenic crops and their regulatory system
transgenic crops and their regulatory systemtransgenic crops and their regulatory system
transgenic crops and their regulatory system
Guru P N
 
Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
   Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx   Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
robert345678
 
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptxGENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
JOEYJIMENEZ7
 
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
Jack Olmsted
 
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
Belinda Martineau
 
FDA Corruption
FDA CorruptionFDA Corruption
FDA Corruption
Allan Marsh
 
intelectual property rights on transgenics
intelectual property rights on transgenicsintelectual property rights on transgenics
intelectual property rights on transgenics
Anilkumar C
 
Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
 Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe... Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
ExternalEvents
 

Similar to 1 Jennifer Kuzma USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020 (20)

Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold TrickNuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
Nuts and Bolts of GMOs - Harold Trick
 
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass SummitDavid Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
David Glass Presentation at 2010 Algae Biomass Summit
 
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops RedickTerminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
Terminology & Legal Issues Biotech Crops Redick
 
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and ResponseFoodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
Foodborne Illness: Prevention and Response
 
Genetic Modified Organism Regulation in India
Genetic Modified Organism  Regulation in IndiaGenetic Modified Organism  Regulation in India
Genetic Modified Organism Regulation in India
 
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
National and International Regulatory Framework for GM Crops_2015
 
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship? Successes and reinvestment.
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship?  Successes and reinvestment.What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship?  Successes and reinvestment.
What makes a city a hub of entrepreneurship? Successes and reinvestment.
 
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptxgenetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
genetic-modification-and-gene-editing-ppt-1416wfcf.pptx
 
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
David Glass BIO World Congress Synthetic Biology Regulation july 2015
 
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
Legal Implications and Public Concerns in Genetic Mortification of foods, rat...
 
Genetically engineered foods
Genetically engineered foodsGenetically engineered foods
Genetically engineered foods
 
International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
 International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ... International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
International and National guidelines regarding use of genetically modified ...
 
transgenic crops and their regulatory system
transgenic crops and their regulatory systemtransgenic crops and their regulatory system
transgenic crops and their regulatory system
 
Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
   Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx   Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
Raising Awareness and Discovering the Dirt 12345 .docx
 
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptxGENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
GENE-EDITING-ETHICAL-AND-SOCIETAL-IMPLICATIONS - Copy.pptx
 
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
The Documented Health Risks of Genetically Engineered Foods (Long Version)
 
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
Science of Genetic Engineering as it relates to the California Initiative to ...
 
FDA Corruption
FDA CorruptionFDA Corruption
FDA Corruption
 
intelectual property rights on transgenics
intelectual property rights on transgenicsintelectual property rights on transgenics
intelectual property rights on transgenics
 
Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
 Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe... Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
Regulation and intellectual property of agricultural biotechnologies: Perspe...
 

More from Genetic Engineering & Society Center

Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policyKuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20207 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20206 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20205 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20204 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech LandscapeSteve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton ProductionKeith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial ContextsJean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOsSupporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOsZachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public EngagementJason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural UseGES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 
GES Center Research Highlights 2017
GES Center Research Highlights 2017GES Center Research Highlights 2017
GES Center Research Highlights 2017
Genetic Engineering & Society Center
 

More from Genetic Engineering & Society Center (17)

Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policyKuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
Kuzma OSTP and biotechnology oversight policy
 
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20207 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
7 Khara Grieger USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
 
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20206 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
6 Todd Kuiken USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
 
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20205 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
5 Jason Delborne USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
 
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-20204 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
4 Keith Edmisten USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020
 
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech LandscapeSteve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
Steve Evans - Reflections on 30 Years Traversing the Ag Biotech Landscape
 
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
Governance of Gene-Edited Crops, Jennifer Kuzma 2/5/2019
 
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton ProductionKeith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
Keith Edmisten - The Adoption of Biotech in Cotton Production
 
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial ContextsJean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
Jean Goodwin - Earning Trust for Science in Controversial Contexts
 
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
Todd Kuiken - PR vs Engagement: Balancing Facts and Values in International G...
 
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
Jennifer Kuzma - Integrating Social Science and Values into Risk Governance f...
 
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOsSupporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Supporting Docs to Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
 
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOsZachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
Zachary Brown - Forecasting Consumer Response to GMOs
 
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public EngagementJason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
Jason Delborne - Emerging Technologies and Public Engagement
 
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural UseGES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
GES Issue Brief - Synthetic Microorganisms for Agricultural Use
 
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
Genetic Engineering and Society (GES) Center Annual Report, 2016-17
 
GES Center Research Highlights 2017
GES Center Research Highlights 2017GES Center Research Highlights 2017
GES Center Research Highlights 2017
 

Recently uploaded

Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Carrer goals.pptx and their importance in real life
Carrer goals.pptx  and their importance in real lifeCarrer goals.pptx  and their importance in real life
Carrer goals.pptx and their importance in real life
artemacademy2
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
Dutch Power
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
Dutch Power
 
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdfASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
ToshihiroIto4
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issueTom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
amekonnen
 
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
SkillCertProExams
 
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics PresentationGregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
gharris9
 
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptxGregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
gharris9
 
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
gpww3sf4
 
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidismUpdated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
Faculty of Medicine And Health Sciences
 
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
Suzanne Lagerweij
 
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie WellsCollapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
Rosie Wells
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Carrer goals.pptx and their importance in real life
Carrer goals.pptx  and their importance in real lifeCarrer goals.pptx  and their importance in real life
Carrer goals.pptx and their importance in real life
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 4. Jochen Cremer - TU Delft 28 mei 2024
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – ČORBA – June 2024 OECD discus...
 
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
Presentatie 8. Joost van der Linde & Daniel Anderton - Eliq 28 mei 2024
 
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdfASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
ASONAM2023_presection_slide_track-recommendation.pdf
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issueTom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
Tom tresser burning issue.pptx My Burning issue
 
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
Mastering the Concepts Tested in the Databricks Certified Data Engineer Assoc...
 
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics PresentationGregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
Gregory Harris - Cycle 2 - Civics Presentation
 
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptxGregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
Gregory Harris' Civics Presentation.pptx
 
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – OECD – June 2024 ...
 
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
Competition and Regulation in Professions and Occupations – ROBSON – June 202...
 
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
 
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidismUpdated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
Updated diagnosis. Cause and treatment of hypothyroidism
 
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
Suzanne Lagerweij - Influence Without Power - Why Empathy is Your Best Friend...
 
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie WellsCollapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
Collapsing Narratives: Exploring Non-Linearity • a micro report by Rosie Wells
 

1 Jennifer Kuzma USDA Rule Panel, 6-5-2020

  • 1. USDA Oversight Past to Present JENNIFER KUZMA, PHD CO-DIRECTOR OF GES CENTER GOODNIGHT-NC GSK FOUNDATION DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR SCHOOL OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS Disclaimer: We are academics trying to understand the new rule. Although we have decades of experience working with GM crop regulation and genetic engineering & societal issues, we do not claim to have all the answers about the details or impacts on different sectors. We are presenting how we understand the process and issues for discussion purposes. Thank you!
  • 2. Coordinated Framework for Regulation of Biotechnology No new categories of risks, no new laws needed, “product not process” EPA BiopesticideFDA GM plant food/feed—FFDCA • Voluntary • No determination of safety USDA Plant Pest Act • GM plants with plant pest DNA sequences EPA FIFRA • plant incorporated protectants (Bt) All other plants have been exempted since mid 2000s-2010 • USDA Am I Regulated Process
  • 4.
  • 7. 2017 Proposed Rule Invokes Noxious Weed and Plant Pest Authorities 2020 SECURE Rule Only Plant Pest Risk Authorities 2008 Proposed Rule Invokes Noxious Weed and Plant Pest Authorities Bush II to Obama Obama to Trump Gene editing arises
  • 8. Sustainable, Ecological, Consistent, Uniform, Responsible, Efficient (SECURE) rule “organisms modified through GE” GE is “techniques that use recombinant, synthesized, or amplified nucleic acids to modify or createa genome” Organism that can directly or indirectly injure, cause damage to, or cause disease in any plant or plant product
  • 9. Key Features of SECURE (continued)
  • 11. Pros and Cons of SECURE PROS Shift to Plant Pest Risk Focus and away from DNA presence Tiered approach—exempt things with which we have experience Provisioning of information and FR comment period for some categories  E.g new USDA exemptions for what could be achieved from conventional breeding CONs •Failure to invoke Noxious Weed provisions of PPA---despite main risks of 1st gen GM crops •Exemptions having little to do with potential product risk •Lack of public information for self or USDA confirmed exempt •Lack of formal assessment & comment period in FR for RSR determinations
  • 12. Estimate of $8.3M annual cost savings to private industry $3.4 M cost to APHIS Not over $100M so no CBA mandated by EO 12866 USDA Timeline of Implementation of SECURE