SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy servicesRemote ECG interpretation consultancy services
for cardiofor cardiovascular diseasevascular disease
Medtech innovation briefing
Published: 27 July 2018
nice.org.uk/guidance/mib152
pat hways
SummarySummary
The technologiestechnologies described in this briefing are remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation
consultancy services. They are used for assisting in diagnosing and decision-making for people
with cardiovascular disease.
The innoinnovativvative aspectse aspects are that with remote ECG interpretation, a person does not need to
travel to hospital for a consultation with a cardiologist, potentially providing quicker and more
accurate diagnoses.
The intended place in therplace in therapapyy would be to replace referrals to secondary care for interpreting
ECGs from people with suspected cardiovascular disease.
The main points from the emain points from the evidencevidence summarised in this briefing are from 4 UK pilot studies
including 26,320 adults and children in primary care. The studies show that remote ECG
interpretation consultancy services may reduce the number of unnecessary referrals to
secondary care and reduce costs for the NHS.
KKeey uncertaintiesy uncertainties around the evidence or technology are that the economic benefits are not
yet clear and there is a lack of evidence for clinical outcomes. Published evidence of clinical
utility is only available for 1 out of 6 services in this briefing.
The costcost of the services in this briefing ranges from Ā£3 to Ā£195 per report (excluding VAT). The
resource impactresource impact may be cost saving because of reductions in secondary care referrals.
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 1 of
16
The technologyThe technology
An electrocardiogram (ECG) is a recording of the electrical activity of the heart and is used to
diagnose cardiovascular disorders. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services provide
expert analysis of ECGs to support clinical decision-making. The services can receive and interpret
ECGs ā€“ along with other information ā€“ using telephone and digital methods. This briefing describes
6 services that are available in the UK (see table 1).
There are 3 main types of ECG:
12-lead ECG12-lead ECG: the standard diagnostic test used in primary care for a number of cardiovascular
disorders. Ten electrodes are placed on the skin of the chest and limbs to measure the
electrical activity of the heart from 12 angles. The signal is recorded for about 10 seconds.
Holter/ambulatory ECGHolter/ambulatory ECG: a monitor is worn for a period ranging from a day to a week, to record
heart activity. The number of leads varies between manufacturers.
LLoop/eoop/evvent monitoringent monitoring: captures unusual heart activity over longer periods, in some cases up
to 4 years.
An ECG of any type can be interpreted by a trained health professional or by dedicated software.
The services in this briefing all offer interpretation by expert staff at remote locations. The ECG is
transmitted from a primary care centre to the service provider. This can be done automatically
from devices supplied by the services (see regulatory information). Alternatively, ECGs may be
uploaded to the internet using a software platform or webpage, or sent by email.
A cardiac technician, cardiac nurse, consultant cardiologist or specialist consultant cardiologist
such as an electrophysiologist interprets the ECG. Recordings from Holter, loop and event monitors
can be interpreted live. The signal can be continuously transmitted to allow the interpreter to
monitor activity in real time.
The interpreter returns a report with their ECG interpretation or recommendations to the
patient's primary care clinician within an agreed timeframe. All 6 of the services in this briefing can
receive ECGs recorded using any existing device. Three of the services are also able to supply third-
party devices.
Five of the 6 services in this briefing are based in the UK. Smart Telecardiology is based in India and
offers interpretation worldwide. The UK-based services all support transmission using the
N3 broadband network (with an NHS.net email address).
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 2 of
16
Table 1 summarises the remote ECG interpretation services included in this briefing. Other similar
technologies may be available but are not included (for example, if they were not identified, or the
company chose not to participate).
TTable 1 Summary of included remote ECG Interpretation servicesable 1 Summary of included remote ECG Interpretation services
CompanCompanyy TTrransmissionansmission InterpretationInterpretation ProposedProposed
reporting timereporting time
DeDevicesvices ModalityModality
MEOMED NHS email,
dedicated
software
upload.
Instant report* or
consultant
cardiologist's or
electro-physiologist's
written patient care
plan with level of
urgency. Offers live
feedback between GP
and consultant
cardiologist after report
is returned.
Under
24 hours;
average
2 hours.
None. 12-lead,
Holter,
loop/
event.
Primary
Diagnostics
NHS email,
dedicated
software
upload.
Technician's written
report ā€“ if a consultant
cardiologist's expertise
is needed, the ECG can
be passed on to a
service such as
MEOMED.
Under
24 hours.
None. 12-lead,
Holter,
loop/
event.
Broomwell
Healthwatch
Automatic
by
telephone,
or digitally
with NHS
email.
Specialist nurse's or
cardiologist's reports ā€“
quality control
performed by
consultant
cardiologists.
Verbal report
returned
'immediately'
and a full
written report
within 15 to
20 minutes.
Supplies/
leases
third-
party
devices.
12-lead,
Holter,
loop/
event.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 3 of
16
Express
Diagnostics
NHS email. SCST-accredited data
analyst's report with
pathway
recommendation.**
Same day; up
to 10 days.**
Supplies/
leases
third-
party
devices.
12-lead,
Holter.
ECG On-
Demand
Automatic ā€“
digitally with
NHS email
or webpage
upload.
SCST-accredited
cardiac physiologist's
written report with
level of urgency. Quality
control performed by
consultant cardiac
electro-physiologists.
Within
24 hours or
'immediately'
on request.
Average
turnaround
2 hours.
Supplies/
leases
third-
party
devices.***
12-lead,
Holter/
event.
Smart
Telecardiology
Webpage
upload or
dedicated
online
platform.
Technician's or
cardiologist's
downloadable report.**
4 to 48 hours,
depending on
geographical
location and
depth of
interpretation.
None. 12-lead,
Holter,
loop/
event.
Abbreviations: ECG, electrocardiogram; SCST, Society for Cardiological Science and
Technology.
* If ECG is normal and no patient information is provided.
** Depending on the customer's needs.
*** Loaded with (Glasgow) interpretation algorithms. The algorithms identify potentially
abnormal ECGs, and the practice can decide to transmit only identified ECGs or transmit all
ECGs.
Innovations
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services may provide diagnostic reports quicker than with
standard care. Interpretation takes between 15 minutes and 2 days and does not need a person to
travel to hospital for an appointment. This may be particularly useful for specific populations, such
as those who live in rural areas, people who work offshore and prisoners.
Interpreting ECGs often needs in-depth knowledge and continuous practice, so ECGs that are
challenging to interpret are frequently referred to secondary care. Using remote ECG
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 4 of
16
interpretation services may reduce the number of unnecessary referrals to secondary care and the
number of misdiagnoses.
Current NHS pathway or current care pathway
A standard 12-lead ECG should be offered to:
adults when atrial fibrillation is suspected (see NICE's guideline on atrial fibrillation)
people aged 16 and over if they have experienced a blackout (see NICE's guideline on transient
loss of consciousness)
adults with recent onset chest pain, in certain instances (see NICE's guideline on chest pain of
recent onset).
Other types of ECG may be taken in the above circumstances, if a 12-lead ECG is inconclusive.
After taking an ECG, the practitioner can either: interpret the results and treat the person
themselves; refer the person to an NHS consultant; or refer the person for emergency treatment. A
referral to an NHS consultant cardiologist or electrophysiologist can take between 2 and 18 weeks
and the patient must travel to hospital.
Automated ECG interpretation services are related technologies that use algorithms to interpret
ECGs that are automatically uploaded to cloud networks or virtual private networks (VPNs).
Population, setting and intended user
GPs or nurses in primary care take ECGs from people with suspected cardiovascular disease.
Remote ECG interpretation would replace a referral to an NHS consultant cardiologist or
electrophysiologist in secondary care. A GP, nurse or healthcare assistant would record the ECG
and then transmit the results to a remote location for interpretation. The consultancy service
would then send a report back to the GP or nurse, with a recommendation for treatment.
Training may be needed for GPs to learn how to transmit the recorded ECGs and receive the
reports.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 5 of
16
Costs
TTechnology costsechnology costs
TTable 2 Cost of remote ECG interpretation consultancy servicesable 2 Cost of remote ECG interpretation consultancy services
CompanCompanyy Cost (Cost (eexxcluding Vcluding VAAT)T) Additional informationAdditional information
Broomwell
Healthwatch
12-lead ECG service12-lead ECG service:
Ā£14 to Ā£30 per report.
ArrhArrhythmia service ā€“ 24-hour tapeythmia service ā€“ 24-hour tape
(Holter):(Holter):
Ā£30 to Ā£50 per report.
Price depends on speed of
response and level of advice.
MEOMED Cardiologist 12-lead ECG serviceCardiologist 12-lead ECG service: between
Ā£22 and Ā£30 per report.
ArrhArrhythmia service ā€“ (Holter):ythmia service ā€“ (Holter): Ā£65 per
report.
Price varies depending on the
usage for a practice per annum.
Primary
Diagnostics
About Ā£65 per analysis. Price varies depending on the
usage for a practice per annum.
ECG On-
Demand
12-lead ECG service:12-lead ECG service: Ā£14 to Ā£25 per report
or a fixed monthly fee of Ā£77 per
1,000-practice population, irrespective of
the number of tests done.
Holter analysis:Holter analysis:
24 hours: Ā£45 per report
48 hours: Ā£70 per report
72 hours: Ā£95 per report
7 days: Ā£120 per report.
Consultant cardiologist e-consultation:Consultant cardiologist e-consultation:
Ā£42 per report.
Holter analysis prices are based
on the duration of the ECG is
recording.
Smart
Telecardiology
Fees for 12-lead ECG interpretation start
at Ā£3 for a technician's report and Ā£8 for a
cardiologist's report.
Price depends on client location,
reading cardiologists,
turnaround time for reports and
practice working hours.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 6 of
16
Express
Diagnostics
12-lead ECG service:12-lead ECG service: Ā£10 to Ā£25.
Holter analysis:Holter analysis: Ā£25 to Ā£195.
Price depends on turnaround
time and recording time for
Holter recordings.
Abbreviation: ECG, electrocardiogram.
Costs of standard careCosts of standard care
The standard care in the NHS for ECG interpretation is referral to either emergency care or a
cardiology outpatient unit. The unit cost per attendance for a hospital emergency department is
Ā£138 and for a cardiology outpatient appointment is Ā£156 (Department of Health and Social
Care 2016).
Resource consequences
It is estimated that 34.7 ECGs per 1,000 patients are recorded annually in GP practices (Wolff et al.
2012). Assuming that a GP practice sends all recorded ECGs to a service for interpretation, then
the likely use is about 35 ECGs per 1,000 patients.
TTable 3 NHS use of interpretation consultanciesable 3 NHS use of interpretation consultancies
ServiceService NHS useNHS use TTrrainingaining
Broomwell
Healthwatch
States that its services are currently used by around 70 CCGs in
the UK.
ECG On-
Demand
States its service is used by CCGs, NHS trusts, GP alliances, and
NHS healthcare providers such as mental health trusts and HMP.
MEOMED Performed 3 pilot trials in Brent CCG, Liverpool CCG and Vale of
York CCG.
Primary
Diagnostics
Has provided its service to Suffolk CCG for the past 6 years.
Express
Diagnostics
States that its services are currently used by 20 CCGs.
Smart
Telecardiology
Not currently in use.
Provided
free of
charge.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 7 of
16
Abbreviations: CCG, clinical commissioning group; ECG, electrocardiogram; HMP, Her
Majesty's Prison Service.
As long as the services are compliant with NHS communication networks such as the N3 network
or health and social care network, no changes to current infrastructure are needed.
No published reports on the resource consequences of adopting the technology were found.
Broomwell Healthwatch provided the results of 3 audits of pilot studies performed in Lancashire
and Cumbria, Greater Manchester and Greater Birmingham. Cost savings were estimated based on
secondary care referrals that were prevented in 61 to 65% of the cases. In Greater Birmingham,
1,934 audit forms were returned and the estimated cost savings were Ā£97,672. In Greater
Manchester, 2,377 secondary care referrals were prevented out of 3,732 ECGs, leading to
estimated cost savings of Ā£358,927. MEOMED also provided the results of a number of pilot
studies (see table 5). It estimated that its service could save a 60-practice CCG between Ā£730,000
and Ā£1.816 million per year.
Regulatory informationRegulatory information
Table 4 shows the regulatory status of the remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation
consultancy services included in this briefing. Telehealth services operating in England must be
registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC). The CQC inspects these services and reports
on the quality of care provided.
Some of the services included in this briefing supply or lease medical devices from third parties.
These devices are regulated under the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency's
(MHRA) medical devices directive and must carry a CE mark.
TTable 4 Regulatory informationable 4 Regulatory information
CompanCompanyy CQC registrCQC registrationation Medical deMedical device and CE markvice and CE mark
Broomwell
Healthwatch
Registered 19 May 2011. Last inspection
report 28 March 2013.
HeartView 12L and HeartView
12i (Aerotel Medical systems
Ltd). Class IIa.
LifeCard (Spacelabs Healthcare
Ltd). Class IIa.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 8 of
16
MEOMED Will register with the CQC when work
begins (registration not needed before
starting contract).
Intend to register with the CQC
when work begins.
Primary
Diagnostics
Will register with the CQC when work
begins (registration not needed before
starting contract).
Intend to register with the CQC
when work begins.
ECG
On-Demand
Registered 28 October 2015. No
inspection reports to date.
eMotion Faros 90, 180 and 360
(Mega Electronics Ltd). Class IIa.
Cardioline TouchECG with HD+,
ECG100+, ECG200+ (Cardioline
SpA). Class IIa.
Express
Diagnostics
Registered 30 December 2010. Last
inspection report 5 September 2013.
LifeCard (Spacelabs Healthcare
Ltd). Class IIa.
eMotion Faros 90, 180 and 360
(Mega Electronics Ltd). Class IIa.
Smart
Telecardiology
Not registered. No information available.
Equality considerEquality considerationsations
NICE is committed to promoting equality, eliminating unlawful discrimination and fostering good
relations between people with particular protected characteristics and others. In producing
guidance and advice, NICE aims to comply fully with all legal obligations to: promote race and
disability equality and equality of opportunity between men and women, eliminate unlawful
discrimination on grounds of race, disability, age, sex, gender reassignment, marriage and civil
partnership, pregnancy and maternity (including women post-delivery), sexual orientation, and
religion or belief (these are protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010).
People aged 65 or over are more likely to have cardiovascular disorders. Age is a protected
characteristic under the Equality Act 2010.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 9 of
16
Clinical and technical eClinical and technical evidencevidence
A literature search was carried out for this briefing in line with the interim process and methods
statement. This briefing includes the most relevant or best available published evidence relating to
the clinical effectiveness of the technology. Further information about how the evidence for this
briefing was selected is available on request by contacting mibs@nice.org.uk.
Published evidence
Four studies including 26,320 participants are summarised in this briefing. All 4 are pilot studies,
3 relating to Broomwell Healthwatch and 1 to MEOMED and all were done in the UK. One is an
abstract reporting the results of a large pilot study (n=25,346) over 4 years.
Using these services resulted in improvement of appropriate referrals and this was found to be cost
saving. The average time to receive results was around 2 hours.
Table 5 summarises the clinical evidence as well as its strengths and limitations.
Overall assessment of the evidence
Broomwell Healthwatch and MEOMED were the only services for which there is publicly available
information. These services report results from pilot studies in the NHS and focus on assessing the
clinical utility of the service.
The primary outcome for all of the studies is the proportion of changes to care plans. The potential
utility of the service can be shown by evaluating differences between the remote service's
recommendation and the care pathway prescribed by the practitioner.
There is no direct within-study comparison between the services in this briefing. There are also no
comparisons between the services and other technologies, such as automatic interpretation
services. In the evidence included in this briefing, there was no follow-up of outcomes to ensure
that care pathway recommendations made by the service resulted in improved clinical outcomes.
There are also no comparisons of results between different clinical commissioning groups or
regions of the UK.
TTable 5 Summary of Evidenceable 5 Summary of Evidence
Paynter (2008)
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 10 of
16
Study size,
design and
location
32 people with chest pain or transient loss of consciousness in a 6-week pilot
study in Bridgwater Community Hospital, Somerset, UK.
Intervention
and
comparator(s)
Broomwell Healthwatch compared with automatic referral to acute trust.
Key
outcomes
16% of ECGs had abnormalities not detected by practitioner (that were
identified by Broomwell Healthwatch).
Strengths and
limitations
The study did not report any power calculation. This was a single-centre pilot
and so is not representative of other types of practice, such as GP surgeries.
No economic information is reported and outcomes are limited to descriptions
of the prescribed care plan.
Albouaini et al. (2009)
Study size,
design and
location
24,541 12-lead ECGs and 805 1-lead ECGs, in a 4-year pilot study in the
Greater Manchester and Cheshire Cardiac Stroke Network, UK.
Intervention
and
comparator(s)
Broomwell Healthwatch compared with standard care.
Key
outcomes
In 15,698 people with symptoms (from 24,541 12-lead ECGs), 87.5% were
recommended for treatment in primary care; 6.5% were recommended for
secondary care and 6% recommended for emergency care. In people with
symptoms from lead-I ECGs, 96% were recommended for treatment in
primary care. All ECGs were reported within 2 hours of their receipt. The
prevention rate of secondary care referrals was 65.8% of the total cases (95%
confidence interval 61.6 to 65.8%) and the extrapolated gross savings were
calculated to be over Ā£300,000.
Strengths and
limitations
The study included a large number of ECGs, over 4 years, in multiple GP
surgeries.
Only the abstract is freely available, so there is no detail on the study
methodology.
Weatherburn et al. (2009)
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 11 of
16
Study size,
design and
location
A total of 373 ECGs from people aged 8 to102 years, in a 6-month pilot study
in Lancashire and Cumbria (NHS Northwest), UK.
Intervention
and
comparator(s)
Broomwell Healthwatch compared with standard care.
Key
outcomes
There were 76 changes made to care pathways. In total, 14 unnecessary
referrals to secondary care were avoided and 18 people who the practitioner
planned to only see in primary care were referred to secondary care.
Strengths and
limitations
The study included results from 8 GP surgeries and 2 walk-in centres and
included people with a wide age range. Rates of use varied between practices
so economic outcomes are not given.
MEOMED Ltd Process Improvement Audit, Hall et al. 2015
Study size,
design and
location
569 people from 3 CCGs (see table 3) in the UK.
Intervention
and
comparator(s)
MEOMED compared with standard care.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 12 of
16
Key
outcomes
Using the MEOMED service, 78% fewer patients were referred to secondary
care when compared to the standard pathway. A total of 37% of all patients ā€“
and 61% of all people with abnormal ECGs (256 from a total of 569) ā€“ had their
condition managed in primary care, based on MEOMED's management plan.
In the patients that the GP would have initially cared for in primary care,
MEOMED recommended, within 2 hours, that 29% be referred to secondary
care.
In addition, 24 unnecessary referrals were prevented in a group of 30 patients
that the GP would have referred to secondary care, based on patient history
alone.
A total of 5% of all patients were referred to secondary care by MEOMED,
based on patient history alone.
The average cost saving for a 60-practice CCG was estimated to be:
Ā£730,000, compared with a technician-led ECG service
Ā£1,816,000 compared with a standard hospital service.
Strengths and
limitations
The study included multiple practices across 3 CCGs. The report was written
by employees of MEOMED in collaboration with Trustech (NHS Northwest
innovation organisation).
Recent and ongoing studies
No ongoing or in-development trials were identified.
Specialist commentator commentsSpecialist commentator comments
Comments on this technology were invited from clinical experts working in the field. The comments
received are individual opinions and do not represent NICE's view.
All 4 experts were aware of, or had used, the remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation
services described in this briefing. Two experts believed that the services were not being widely
used in the NHS, while the other 2 were unsure or did not comment.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 13 of
16
Level of innovation
Two experts believed that the services were novel, while another thought they were not. One
expert believed the services were only a minor iteration of current care that had not been
superseded.
One expert thought that some of these services were innovative because patient reports could be
written and interpreted by experienced clinicians who had access to patient history. Two experts
felt that non-commercial interpretation services available in their local hospital coronary care unit
by trained clinicians offered competition to the services reported in this briefing because, in their
opinion, they were either faster, free or better. One expert mentioned that some services
developed in hospital had a system to immediately assess if ECG changes were new or pre-existing.
They believed that this gave their service an advantage over the commercial services in this
briefing. On the contrary, 1 expert had to stop using a commercial service because their local trust
chose to provide their own in-house service instead. They felt that the commercial service was
better than the service provided by the local trust because it had a faster turnaround time and less
variability in reporting. One expert mentioned open access services for Holter monitors as a similar
technology but added that they were often poorly supervised and did not take patient history into
account.
Potential patient impact
All of the experts agreed that avoiding unnecessary hospital visits was a potential patient benefit.
Three experts also agreed that high-risk cardiac symptoms could be identified earlier than with
standard care and this would allow for earlier prevention or treatment to begin. However, 1 expert
also expressed concern that such services may be used improperly in people with symptoms that
need clinical review, such as acute chest pain or unexplained syncope. One expert mentioned that
some of these services may provide the added reassurance to patients because the results would
be reviewed by highly trained clinicians.
The experts stated various types of patients would particularly benefit from these services
including: people with low-risk symptoms (history of vasovagal syncope, palpitations or
hypertension); people with a pre-existing ECG abnormality because a comparison to a current ECG
might prevent an unnecessary referral or because ECGs taken from Holter monitors are more likely
to be misinterpreted in primary care; older people or those with mobility issues because there
would be a reduced need for them to travel to hospital.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 14 of
16
Potential system impact
All of the experts agreed that a potential reduction in non-emergency referrals to secondary care
specialist clinics would be a benefit to the health or care system. One expert said this reduction
could lead to cost savings in regions where links to secondary care are poor. Another expert added
that less money would need to be spent on secondary care and more could be allocated to primary
care. Two experts thought that cardiac interpretation services could increase costs for their region
but another expert thought that there could be cost savings if cardiologist resources were used
more effectively by reducing unnecessary outpatient appointments. They added that this may also
lead to better resource allocation in secondary care.
Three experts felt that little to no change to current infrastructure would be needed to use these
technologies and that when needed they would presumably be provided by the companies. One
expert believed that advanced ECG interpretation skills would be needed for clinicians to use any
of the technologies.
Two experts expressed some concerns about the resource impact from adopting these
technologies. One thought that the interpreter would need to take a holistic view and take clinical
history into account for best management. They also felt that the most important element of such
services was the skill set of the interpreter. The other expert reiterated that such services should
not be used alone in managing high-risk symptoms and expressed worry that some practitioners
could become overly reliant on these services. A third expert highlighted that primary care services
would be expected to take responsibility for clinical decision-making if not referring patients
onward for additional specialist follow-up. No safety concerns or regulatory issues were raised
surrounding the use of these technologies.
General comments
One expert mentioned that his knowledge of ECG analysis had improved after using an ECG
interpretation service. Another expert felt that establishing local, non-commercial telemetry
services should be attempted before using commercial providers. The expert acknowledged that
some regions may not manage to establish close collaborations with their local hospital to
successfully use non-commercial services. None of the experts had an opinion on how the services
will adapt to the end of the N3 network but stressed the importance of continued data security.
One expert expressed suspicion of services that provide diagnostic guidance without assessing
clinical presentation.
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 15 of
16
Three of the experts felt that the technology would be an addition to standard care, rather than a
replacement. One added that the services could be a replacement for outpatient referral where
links to local cardiology services are poor. The fourth expert agreed, stating that the technology
would replace the need to refer every patient for an initial outpatient appointment.
Two experts identified information technology-related difficulties, such as network and
transmission problems, as the only practical issues with the services. One expert was not convinced
by the published research because of industry involvement and limited real-world cost information.
The expert felt that a pilot trial for an individual healthcare organisation would provide more useful
data as results may vary across different locations. One expert thought that the services should
agree to make audits of their performance available to purchasers. This would be particularly
informative if the results included hospital referral rates and patient outcomes.
Specialist commentatorsSpecialist commentators
The following clinicians contributed to this briefing:
Dr Jonathan Watt, consultant cardiologist, Raigmore Hospital, NHS Highland, member of the
British Cardiovascular Intervention Society. No relevant conflicts of interest.
Mr Charlie Bloe, clinical ward manager, NHS Highland, member of SHARP (Scottish Heart and
Arterial disease Risk Prevention). Mr Bloe is the clinical lead and managing director for a
private healthcare education company and provides regular tuition to healthcare professionals
on electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation.
Dr Richard Schilling, professor of cardiology, Barts Health NHS Trust, member of the British
Heart Rhythm Society. No relevant conflicts of interest.
Dr M C Patel, GP, Brent Clinical Commissioning Group. Dr Patel is a shareholder in Harness GP
Cooperative Ltd and chair of Harness Board. His patients were included in an NHS England
Regional Innovation-funded audit.
DeDevvelopment of this briefingelopment of this briefing
This briefing was developed for NICE by King's Technology Evaluation Centre. The interim process
and methods statement sets out the process NICE uses to select topics, and how the briefings are
developed, quality-assured and approved for publication.
ISBN: 978-1-4731-3030-2
Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152)
Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and-
conditions#notice-of-rights).
Page 16 of
16

More Related Content

What's hot

A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiac
A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiacA portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiac
A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiacArhamSheikh1
Ā 
EMBS Presentation By Dr Yanulis
EMBS Presentation By Dr YanulisEMBS Presentation By Dr Yanulis
EMBS Presentation By Dr YanulisGeorge Yanulis
Ā 
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interface
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interfaceThe research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interface
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interfaceArhamSheikh1
Ā 
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexing
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexingEvaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexing
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexingjournalBEEI
Ā 
Biotelemetry
BiotelemetryBiotelemetry
BiotelemetrySamuely
Ā 
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoard
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoardPortable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoard
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoardIJSRD
Ā 
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitry
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure CircuitryPPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitry
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitrymgoutham kumarreddy
Ā 
Company Presentation Vitaphone
Company Presentation VitaphoneCompany Presentation Vitaphone
Company Presentation Vitaphoneguestf9a3fbf
Ā 
IRJET- Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...
IRJET-  Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...IRJET-  Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...
IRJET- Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...IRJET Journal
Ā 
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning Techniques
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning TechniquesIRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning Techniques
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning TechniquesIRJET Journal
Ā 
Vitaphone Tele Ecg System
Vitaphone Tele Ecg SystemVitaphone Tele Ecg System
Vitaphone Tele Ecg Systemguestf9a3fbf
Ā 
Bachelorthesis.compressed
Bachelorthesis.compressedBachelorthesis.compressed
Bachelorthesis.compressedDhara Shah
Ā 
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient Recognition
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient RecognitionAR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient Recognition
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient RecognitionCSCJournals
Ā 
Smart hospital technology
Smart hospital technologySmart hospital technology
Smart hospital technologyhiij
Ā 
Implantable Cardiac Devices
Implantable Cardiac Devices Implantable Cardiac Devices
Implantable Cardiac Devices Mohamed Elwakil
Ā 
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings Hussein
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings HusseinFinal Project Slides Buchheit Harings Hussein
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings HusseinScott Buchheit
Ā 

What's hot (19)

A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiac
A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiacA portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiac
A portable electrocardiogram for realā€‘time monitoring of cardiac
Ā 
EMBS Presentation By Dr Yanulis
EMBS Presentation By Dr YanulisEMBS Presentation By Dr Yanulis
EMBS Presentation By Dr Yanulis
Ā 
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interface
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interfaceThe research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interface
The research of_portable_ecg_monitoring_system_with_usb_host_interface
Ā 
The Holter Device and the Event Monitor
The Holter Device and the Event MonitorThe Holter Device and the Event Monitor
The Holter Device and the Event Monitor
Ā 
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexing
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexingEvaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexing
Evaluation of patient electrocardiogram datasets using signal quality indexing
Ā 
Biotelemetry
BiotelemetryBiotelemetry
Biotelemetry
Ā 
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoard
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoardPortable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoard
Portable ECG Monitoring System using Lilypad And Mobile Platform-PandaBoard
Ā 
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitry
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure CircuitryPPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitry
PPG, ECG and Blood Pressure Circuitry
Ā 
The Holter Monitor
The Holter Monitor The Holter Monitor
The Holter Monitor
Ā 
Company Presentation Vitaphone
Company Presentation VitaphoneCompany Presentation Vitaphone
Company Presentation Vitaphone
Ā 
IRJET- Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...
IRJET-  Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...IRJET-  Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...
IRJET- Congestive Heart Failure Recognition by Analyzing The ECG Signals usi...
Ā 
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning Techniques
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning TechniquesIRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning Techniques
IRJET- Cardiovascular Disease Prediction using Machine Learning Techniques
Ā 
Vitaphone Tele Ecg System
Vitaphone Tele Ecg SystemVitaphone Tele Ecg System
Vitaphone Tele Ecg System
Ā 
Bachelorthesis.compressed
Bachelorthesis.compressedBachelorthesis.compressed
Bachelorthesis.compressed
Ā 
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient Recognition
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient RecognitionAR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient Recognition
AR-based Method for ECG Classification and Patient Recognition
Ā 
Smart hospital technology
Smart hospital technologySmart hospital technology
Smart hospital technology
Ā 
Implantable Cardiac Devices
Implantable Cardiac Devices Implantable Cardiac Devices
Implantable Cardiac Devices
Ā 
Documentation for Pacemaker Care
Documentation for Pacemaker CareDocumentation for Pacemaker Care
Documentation for Pacemaker Care
Ā 
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings Hussein
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings HusseinFinal Project Slides Buchheit Harings Hussein
Final Project Slides Buchheit Harings Hussein
Ā 

Similar to Ecg nice 2018

Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...
Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...
Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...IJECEIAES
Ā 
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGY
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGYSMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGY
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGYhiij
Ā 
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac Patients
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac PatientsA Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac Patients
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac PatientsIJERD Editor
Ā 
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1Josh Skinner
Ā 
final report_weisi
final report_weisifinal report_weisi
final report_weisiWeisi Chen
Ā 
Portable Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring System
Portable  Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring SystemPortable  Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring System
Portable Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring SystemIRJET Journal
Ā 
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniques
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing TechniquesHealth Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniques
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniquesijfcstjournal
Ā 
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913calaf0618
Ā 
Wireless Telemetry System
Wireless Telemetry SystemWireless Telemetry System
Wireless Telemetry Systemijsrd.com
Ā 
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM Autoencoder
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM AutoencoderDetection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM Autoencoder
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM AutoencoderIRJET Journal
Ā 
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...hiij
Ā 
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...nikhilpatewar
Ā 
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?6PM Solutions
Ā 
Health Monitoring
Health MonitoringHealth Monitoring
Health MonitoringPravin Burute
Ā 
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...IJERA Editor
Ā 
Cardiology Coding Alert White Paper
Cardiology Coding Alert White PaperCardiology Coding Alert White Paper
Cardiology Coding Alert White PaperCoding Institute (TCI)
Ā 
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with Assistance
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with AssistanceIoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with Assistance
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with AssistanceIRJET Journal
Ā 
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app68917e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891Rajarshee Dhar
Ā 

Similar to Ecg nice 2018 (20)

Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...
Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...
Electrocardiogram signal processing algorithm on microcontroller using wavele...
Ā 
50620130101003
5062013010100350620130101003
50620130101003
Ā 
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGY
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGYSMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGY
SMART HOSPITAL TECHNOLOGY
Ā 
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac Patients
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac PatientsA Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac Patients
A Real Time Electrocardiogram (ECG) Device for Cardiac Patients
Ā 
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1
VectraplexECGFinal Brochure 3.1
Ā 
final report_weisi
final report_weisifinal report_weisi
final report_weisi
Ā 
Portable Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring System
Portable  Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring SystemPortable  Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring System
Portable Real Time Cardiac Activity Monitoring System
Ā 
eUno R10
eUno R10eUno R10
eUno R10
Ā 
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniques
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing TechniquesHealth Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniques
Health Care Monitoring for the CVD Detection using Soft Computing Techniques
Ā 
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913
ē‚ŗę­é†«é™¢ 20070913
Ā 
Wireless Telemetry System
Wireless Telemetry SystemWireless Telemetry System
Wireless Telemetry System
Ā 
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM Autoencoder
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM AutoencoderDetection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM Autoencoder
Detection and Classification of ECG Arrhythmia using LSTM Autoencoder
Ā 
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...
Classification of cardiac vascular disease from ecg signals for enhancing mod...
Ā 
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...
Wireless Medical Surveillance System Using Raspberry Pi and X-Bee By. Nikhil ...
Ā 
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?
What is StrokePad, it's benefits & main features?
Ā 
Health Monitoring
Health MonitoringHealth Monitoring
Health Monitoring
Ā 
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...
Survey on Mobile Based Telemedicine System for Patient Monitoring and Diagnos...
Ā 
Cardiology Coding Alert White Paper
Cardiology Coding Alert White PaperCardiology Coding Alert White Paper
Cardiology Coding Alert White Paper
Ā 
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with Assistance
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with AssistanceIoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with Assistance
IoT Based Intelligent Medicine Box with Assistance
Ā 
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app68917e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891
7e397c56 3d5b-4898-a4ea-96787699a447-150509181138-lva1-app6891
Ā 

Recently uploaded

(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...Taniya Sharma
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safenarwatsonia7
Ā 
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...Taniya Sharma
Ā 
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...narwatsonia7
Ā 
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Service
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls ServiceKesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Service
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Servicemakika9823
Ā 
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...Call girls in Ahmedabad High profile
Ā 
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoybabeytanya
Ā 
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliAspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliRewAs ALI
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...narwatsonia7
Ā 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Servicevidya singh
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safenarwatsonia7
Ā 
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...Miss joya
Ā 
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune) Girls Service
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune)  Girls ServiceCALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune)  Girls Service
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune) Girls ServiceMiss joya
Ā 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...indiancallgirl4rent
Ā 
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.MiadAlsulami
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹ 9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escorts
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹  9256729539 šŸš€ Indore EscortsVIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹  9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escorts
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹ 9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escortsaditipandeya
Ā 
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patna
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service PatnaLow Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patna
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patnamakika9823
Ā 
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...astropune
Ā 

Recently uploaded (20)

(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
(šŸ‘‘VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi MumbaišŸ–•9920874524šŸ–•Independent...
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Majestic šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Ā 
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
šŸ’ŽVVIP Kolkata Call Girls ParganasšŸ©±7001035870šŸ©±Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
Ā 
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø  8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
High Profile Call Girls Coimbatore Saanviā˜Žļø 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
Ā 
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Service
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls ServiceKesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Service
Kesar Bagh Call Girl Price 9548273370 , Lucknow Call Girls Service
Ā 
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai Samaira 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ...
Ā 
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Darjeeling Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Ā 
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night EnjoyCall Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Call Girl Number in Panvel MumbaišŸ“² 9833363713 šŸ’ž Full Night Enjoy
Ā 
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas AliAspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Aspirin presentation slides by Dr. Rewas Ali
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870  Meetin With Bangalor...
Bangalore Call Girls Hebbal Kempapura Number 7001035870 Meetin With Bangalor...
Ā 
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort ServicePremium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Premium Call Girls Cottonpet Whatsapp 7001035870 Independent Escort Service
Ā 
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% SafeBangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Bangalore Call Girls Marathahalli šŸ“ž 9907093804 High Profile Service 100% Safe
Ā 
Russian Call Girls in Delhi Tanvi āž”ļø 9711199012 šŸ’‹šŸ“ž Independent Escort Service...
Russian Call Girls in Delhi Tanvi āž”ļø 9711199012 šŸ’‹šŸ“ž Independent Escort Service...Russian Call Girls in Delhi Tanvi āž”ļø 9711199012 šŸ’‹šŸ“ž Independent Escort Service...
Russian Call Girls in Delhi Tanvi āž”ļø 9711199012 šŸ’‹šŸ“ž Independent Escort Service...
Ā 
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...
Russian Call Girls in Pune Tanvi 9907093804 Short 1500 Night 6000 Best call g...
Ā 
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune) Girls Service
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune)  Girls ServiceCALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune)  Girls Service
CALL ON āž„9907093804 šŸ” Call Girls Hadapsar ( Pune) Girls Service
Ā 
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...
(Rocky) Jaipur Call Girl - 9521753030 Escorts Service 50% Off with Cash ON De...
Ā 
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.
Artifacts in Nuclear Medicine with Identifying and resolving artifacts.
Ā 
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹ 9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escorts
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹  9256729539 šŸš€ Indore EscortsVIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹  9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escorts
VIP Call Girls Indore Kirti šŸ’ššŸ˜‹ 9256729539 šŸš€ Indore Escorts
Ā 
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patna
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service PatnaLow Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patna
Low Rate Call Girls Patna Anika 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Patna
Ā 
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...
Best Rate (Hyderabad) Call Girls Jahanuma āŸŸ 8250192130 āŸŸ High Class Call Girl...
Ā 

Ecg nice 2018

  • 1. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy servicesRemote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiofor cardiovascular diseasevascular disease Medtech innovation briefing Published: 27 July 2018 nice.org.uk/guidance/mib152 pat hways SummarySummary The technologiestechnologies described in this briefing are remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation consultancy services. They are used for assisting in diagnosing and decision-making for people with cardiovascular disease. The innoinnovativvative aspectse aspects are that with remote ECG interpretation, a person does not need to travel to hospital for a consultation with a cardiologist, potentially providing quicker and more accurate diagnoses. The intended place in therplace in therapapyy would be to replace referrals to secondary care for interpreting ECGs from people with suspected cardiovascular disease. The main points from the emain points from the evidencevidence summarised in this briefing are from 4 UK pilot studies including 26,320 adults and children in primary care. The studies show that remote ECG interpretation consultancy services may reduce the number of unnecessary referrals to secondary care and reduce costs for the NHS. KKeey uncertaintiesy uncertainties around the evidence or technology are that the economic benefits are not yet clear and there is a lack of evidence for clinical outcomes. Published evidence of clinical utility is only available for 1 out of 6 services in this briefing. The costcost of the services in this briefing ranges from Ā£3 to Ā£195 per report (excluding VAT). The resource impactresource impact may be cost saving because of reductions in secondary care referrals. Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 1 of 16
  • 2. The technologyThe technology An electrocardiogram (ECG) is a recording of the electrical activity of the heart and is used to diagnose cardiovascular disorders. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services provide expert analysis of ECGs to support clinical decision-making. The services can receive and interpret ECGs ā€“ along with other information ā€“ using telephone and digital methods. This briefing describes 6 services that are available in the UK (see table 1). There are 3 main types of ECG: 12-lead ECG12-lead ECG: the standard diagnostic test used in primary care for a number of cardiovascular disorders. Ten electrodes are placed on the skin of the chest and limbs to measure the electrical activity of the heart from 12 angles. The signal is recorded for about 10 seconds. Holter/ambulatory ECGHolter/ambulatory ECG: a monitor is worn for a period ranging from a day to a week, to record heart activity. The number of leads varies between manufacturers. LLoop/eoop/evvent monitoringent monitoring: captures unusual heart activity over longer periods, in some cases up to 4 years. An ECG of any type can be interpreted by a trained health professional or by dedicated software. The services in this briefing all offer interpretation by expert staff at remote locations. The ECG is transmitted from a primary care centre to the service provider. This can be done automatically from devices supplied by the services (see regulatory information). Alternatively, ECGs may be uploaded to the internet using a software platform or webpage, or sent by email. A cardiac technician, cardiac nurse, consultant cardiologist or specialist consultant cardiologist such as an electrophysiologist interprets the ECG. Recordings from Holter, loop and event monitors can be interpreted live. The signal can be continuously transmitted to allow the interpreter to monitor activity in real time. The interpreter returns a report with their ECG interpretation or recommendations to the patient's primary care clinician within an agreed timeframe. All 6 of the services in this briefing can receive ECGs recorded using any existing device. Three of the services are also able to supply third- party devices. Five of the 6 services in this briefing are based in the UK. Smart Telecardiology is based in India and offers interpretation worldwide. The UK-based services all support transmission using the N3 broadband network (with an NHS.net email address). Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 2 of 16
  • 3. Table 1 summarises the remote ECG interpretation services included in this briefing. Other similar technologies may be available but are not included (for example, if they were not identified, or the company chose not to participate). TTable 1 Summary of included remote ECG Interpretation servicesable 1 Summary of included remote ECG Interpretation services CompanCompanyy TTrransmissionansmission InterpretationInterpretation ProposedProposed reporting timereporting time DeDevicesvices ModalityModality MEOMED NHS email, dedicated software upload. Instant report* or consultant cardiologist's or electro-physiologist's written patient care plan with level of urgency. Offers live feedback between GP and consultant cardiologist after report is returned. Under 24 hours; average 2 hours. None. 12-lead, Holter, loop/ event. Primary Diagnostics NHS email, dedicated software upload. Technician's written report ā€“ if a consultant cardiologist's expertise is needed, the ECG can be passed on to a service such as MEOMED. Under 24 hours. None. 12-lead, Holter, loop/ event. Broomwell Healthwatch Automatic by telephone, or digitally with NHS email. Specialist nurse's or cardiologist's reports ā€“ quality control performed by consultant cardiologists. Verbal report returned 'immediately' and a full written report within 15 to 20 minutes. Supplies/ leases third- party devices. 12-lead, Holter, loop/ event. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 3 of 16
  • 4. Express Diagnostics NHS email. SCST-accredited data analyst's report with pathway recommendation.** Same day; up to 10 days.** Supplies/ leases third- party devices. 12-lead, Holter. ECG On- Demand Automatic ā€“ digitally with NHS email or webpage upload. SCST-accredited cardiac physiologist's written report with level of urgency. Quality control performed by consultant cardiac electro-physiologists. Within 24 hours or 'immediately' on request. Average turnaround 2 hours. Supplies/ leases third- party devices.*** 12-lead, Holter/ event. Smart Telecardiology Webpage upload or dedicated online platform. Technician's or cardiologist's downloadable report.** 4 to 48 hours, depending on geographical location and depth of interpretation. None. 12-lead, Holter, loop/ event. Abbreviations: ECG, electrocardiogram; SCST, Society for Cardiological Science and Technology. * If ECG is normal and no patient information is provided. ** Depending on the customer's needs. *** Loaded with (Glasgow) interpretation algorithms. The algorithms identify potentially abnormal ECGs, and the practice can decide to transmit only identified ECGs or transmit all ECGs. Innovations Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services may provide diagnostic reports quicker than with standard care. Interpretation takes between 15 minutes and 2 days and does not need a person to travel to hospital for an appointment. This may be particularly useful for specific populations, such as those who live in rural areas, people who work offshore and prisoners. Interpreting ECGs often needs in-depth knowledge and continuous practice, so ECGs that are challenging to interpret are frequently referred to secondary care. Using remote ECG Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 4 of 16
  • 5. interpretation services may reduce the number of unnecessary referrals to secondary care and the number of misdiagnoses. Current NHS pathway or current care pathway A standard 12-lead ECG should be offered to: adults when atrial fibrillation is suspected (see NICE's guideline on atrial fibrillation) people aged 16 and over if they have experienced a blackout (see NICE's guideline on transient loss of consciousness) adults with recent onset chest pain, in certain instances (see NICE's guideline on chest pain of recent onset). Other types of ECG may be taken in the above circumstances, if a 12-lead ECG is inconclusive. After taking an ECG, the practitioner can either: interpret the results and treat the person themselves; refer the person to an NHS consultant; or refer the person for emergency treatment. A referral to an NHS consultant cardiologist or electrophysiologist can take between 2 and 18 weeks and the patient must travel to hospital. Automated ECG interpretation services are related technologies that use algorithms to interpret ECGs that are automatically uploaded to cloud networks or virtual private networks (VPNs). Population, setting and intended user GPs or nurses in primary care take ECGs from people with suspected cardiovascular disease. Remote ECG interpretation would replace a referral to an NHS consultant cardiologist or electrophysiologist in secondary care. A GP, nurse or healthcare assistant would record the ECG and then transmit the results to a remote location for interpretation. The consultancy service would then send a report back to the GP or nurse, with a recommendation for treatment. Training may be needed for GPs to learn how to transmit the recorded ECGs and receive the reports. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 5 of 16
  • 6. Costs TTechnology costsechnology costs TTable 2 Cost of remote ECG interpretation consultancy servicesable 2 Cost of remote ECG interpretation consultancy services CompanCompanyy Cost (Cost (eexxcluding Vcluding VAAT)T) Additional informationAdditional information Broomwell Healthwatch 12-lead ECG service12-lead ECG service: Ā£14 to Ā£30 per report. ArrhArrhythmia service ā€“ 24-hour tapeythmia service ā€“ 24-hour tape (Holter):(Holter): Ā£30 to Ā£50 per report. Price depends on speed of response and level of advice. MEOMED Cardiologist 12-lead ECG serviceCardiologist 12-lead ECG service: between Ā£22 and Ā£30 per report. ArrhArrhythmia service ā€“ (Holter):ythmia service ā€“ (Holter): Ā£65 per report. Price varies depending on the usage for a practice per annum. Primary Diagnostics About Ā£65 per analysis. Price varies depending on the usage for a practice per annum. ECG On- Demand 12-lead ECG service:12-lead ECG service: Ā£14 to Ā£25 per report or a fixed monthly fee of Ā£77 per 1,000-practice population, irrespective of the number of tests done. Holter analysis:Holter analysis: 24 hours: Ā£45 per report 48 hours: Ā£70 per report 72 hours: Ā£95 per report 7 days: Ā£120 per report. Consultant cardiologist e-consultation:Consultant cardiologist e-consultation: Ā£42 per report. Holter analysis prices are based on the duration of the ECG is recording. Smart Telecardiology Fees for 12-lead ECG interpretation start at Ā£3 for a technician's report and Ā£8 for a cardiologist's report. Price depends on client location, reading cardiologists, turnaround time for reports and practice working hours. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 6 of 16
  • 7. Express Diagnostics 12-lead ECG service:12-lead ECG service: Ā£10 to Ā£25. Holter analysis:Holter analysis: Ā£25 to Ā£195. Price depends on turnaround time and recording time for Holter recordings. Abbreviation: ECG, electrocardiogram. Costs of standard careCosts of standard care The standard care in the NHS for ECG interpretation is referral to either emergency care or a cardiology outpatient unit. The unit cost per attendance for a hospital emergency department is Ā£138 and for a cardiology outpatient appointment is Ā£156 (Department of Health and Social Care 2016). Resource consequences It is estimated that 34.7 ECGs per 1,000 patients are recorded annually in GP practices (Wolff et al. 2012). Assuming that a GP practice sends all recorded ECGs to a service for interpretation, then the likely use is about 35 ECGs per 1,000 patients. TTable 3 NHS use of interpretation consultanciesable 3 NHS use of interpretation consultancies ServiceService NHS useNHS use TTrrainingaining Broomwell Healthwatch States that its services are currently used by around 70 CCGs in the UK. ECG On- Demand States its service is used by CCGs, NHS trusts, GP alliances, and NHS healthcare providers such as mental health trusts and HMP. MEOMED Performed 3 pilot trials in Brent CCG, Liverpool CCG and Vale of York CCG. Primary Diagnostics Has provided its service to Suffolk CCG for the past 6 years. Express Diagnostics States that its services are currently used by 20 CCGs. Smart Telecardiology Not currently in use. Provided free of charge. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 7 of 16
  • 8. Abbreviations: CCG, clinical commissioning group; ECG, electrocardiogram; HMP, Her Majesty's Prison Service. As long as the services are compliant with NHS communication networks such as the N3 network or health and social care network, no changes to current infrastructure are needed. No published reports on the resource consequences of adopting the technology were found. Broomwell Healthwatch provided the results of 3 audits of pilot studies performed in Lancashire and Cumbria, Greater Manchester and Greater Birmingham. Cost savings were estimated based on secondary care referrals that were prevented in 61 to 65% of the cases. In Greater Birmingham, 1,934 audit forms were returned and the estimated cost savings were Ā£97,672. In Greater Manchester, 2,377 secondary care referrals were prevented out of 3,732 ECGs, leading to estimated cost savings of Ā£358,927. MEOMED also provided the results of a number of pilot studies (see table 5). It estimated that its service could save a 60-practice CCG between Ā£730,000 and Ā£1.816 million per year. Regulatory informationRegulatory information Table 4 shows the regulatory status of the remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation consultancy services included in this briefing. Telehealth services operating in England must be registered with the Care Quality Commission (CQC). The CQC inspects these services and reports on the quality of care provided. Some of the services included in this briefing supply or lease medical devices from third parties. These devices are regulated under the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency's (MHRA) medical devices directive and must carry a CE mark. TTable 4 Regulatory informationable 4 Regulatory information CompanCompanyy CQC registrCQC registrationation Medical deMedical device and CE markvice and CE mark Broomwell Healthwatch Registered 19 May 2011. Last inspection report 28 March 2013. HeartView 12L and HeartView 12i (Aerotel Medical systems Ltd). Class IIa. LifeCard (Spacelabs Healthcare Ltd). Class IIa. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 8 of 16
  • 9. MEOMED Will register with the CQC when work begins (registration not needed before starting contract). Intend to register with the CQC when work begins. Primary Diagnostics Will register with the CQC when work begins (registration not needed before starting contract). Intend to register with the CQC when work begins. ECG On-Demand Registered 28 October 2015. No inspection reports to date. eMotion Faros 90, 180 and 360 (Mega Electronics Ltd). Class IIa. Cardioline TouchECG with HD+, ECG100+, ECG200+ (Cardioline SpA). Class IIa. Express Diagnostics Registered 30 December 2010. Last inspection report 5 September 2013. LifeCard (Spacelabs Healthcare Ltd). Class IIa. eMotion Faros 90, 180 and 360 (Mega Electronics Ltd). Class IIa. Smart Telecardiology Not registered. No information available. Equality considerEquality considerationsations NICE is committed to promoting equality, eliminating unlawful discrimination and fostering good relations between people with particular protected characteristics and others. In producing guidance and advice, NICE aims to comply fully with all legal obligations to: promote race and disability equality and equality of opportunity between men and women, eliminate unlawful discrimination on grounds of race, disability, age, sex, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity (including women post-delivery), sexual orientation, and religion or belief (these are protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010). People aged 65 or over are more likely to have cardiovascular disorders. Age is a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 9 of 16
  • 10. Clinical and technical eClinical and technical evidencevidence A literature search was carried out for this briefing in line with the interim process and methods statement. This briefing includes the most relevant or best available published evidence relating to the clinical effectiveness of the technology. Further information about how the evidence for this briefing was selected is available on request by contacting mibs@nice.org.uk. Published evidence Four studies including 26,320 participants are summarised in this briefing. All 4 are pilot studies, 3 relating to Broomwell Healthwatch and 1 to MEOMED and all were done in the UK. One is an abstract reporting the results of a large pilot study (n=25,346) over 4 years. Using these services resulted in improvement of appropriate referrals and this was found to be cost saving. The average time to receive results was around 2 hours. Table 5 summarises the clinical evidence as well as its strengths and limitations. Overall assessment of the evidence Broomwell Healthwatch and MEOMED were the only services for which there is publicly available information. These services report results from pilot studies in the NHS and focus on assessing the clinical utility of the service. The primary outcome for all of the studies is the proportion of changes to care plans. The potential utility of the service can be shown by evaluating differences between the remote service's recommendation and the care pathway prescribed by the practitioner. There is no direct within-study comparison between the services in this briefing. There are also no comparisons between the services and other technologies, such as automatic interpretation services. In the evidence included in this briefing, there was no follow-up of outcomes to ensure that care pathway recommendations made by the service resulted in improved clinical outcomes. There are also no comparisons of results between different clinical commissioning groups or regions of the UK. TTable 5 Summary of Evidenceable 5 Summary of Evidence Paynter (2008) Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 10 of 16
  • 11. Study size, design and location 32 people with chest pain or transient loss of consciousness in a 6-week pilot study in Bridgwater Community Hospital, Somerset, UK. Intervention and comparator(s) Broomwell Healthwatch compared with automatic referral to acute trust. Key outcomes 16% of ECGs had abnormalities not detected by practitioner (that were identified by Broomwell Healthwatch). Strengths and limitations The study did not report any power calculation. This was a single-centre pilot and so is not representative of other types of practice, such as GP surgeries. No economic information is reported and outcomes are limited to descriptions of the prescribed care plan. Albouaini et al. (2009) Study size, design and location 24,541 12-lead ECGs and 805 1-lead ECGs, in a 4-year pilot study in the Greater Manchester and Cheshire Cardiac Stroke Network, UK. Intervention and comparator(s) Broomwell Healthwatch compared with standard care. Key outcomes In 15,698 people with symptoms (from 24,541 12-lead ECGs), 87.5% were recommended for treatment in primary care; 6.5% were recommended for secondary care and 6% recommended for emergency care. In people with symptoms from lead-I ECGs, 96% were recommended for treatment in primary care. All ECGs were reported within 2 hours of their receipt. The prevention rate of secondary care referrals was 65.8% of the total cases (95% confidence interval 61.6 to 65.8%) and the extrapolated gross savings were calculated to be over Ā£300,000. Strengths and limitations The study included a large number of ECGs, over 4 years, in multiple GP surgeries. Only the abstract is freely available, so there is no detail on the study methodology. Weatherburn et al. (2009) Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 11 of 16
  • 12. Study size, design and location A total of 373 ECGs from people aged 8 to102 years, in a 6-month pilot study in Lancashire and Cumbria (NHS Northwest), UK. Intervention and comparator(s) Broomwell Healthwatch compared with standard care. Key outcomes There were 76 changes made to care pathways. In total, 14 unnecessary referrals to secondary care were avoided and 18 people who the practitioner planned to only see in primary care were referred to secondary care. Strengths and limitations The study included results from 8 GP surgeries and 2 walk-in centres and included people with a wide age range. Rates of use varied between practices so economic outcomes are not given. MEOMED Ltd Process Improvement Audit, Hall et al. 2015 Study size, design and location 569 people from 3 CCGs (see table 3) in the UK. Intervention and comparator(s) MEOMED compared with standard care. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 12 of 16
  • 13. Key outcomes Using the MEOMED service, 78% fewer patients were referred to secondary care when compared to the standard pathway. A total of 37% of all patients ā€“ and 61% of all people with abnormal ECGs (256 from a total of 569) ā€“ had their condition managed in primary care, based on MEOMED's management plan. In the patients that the GP would have initially cared for in primary care, MEOMED recommended, within 2 hours, that 29% be referred to secondary care. In addition, 24 unnecessary referrals were prevented in a group of 30 patients that the GP would have referred to secondary care, based on patient history alone. A total of 5% of all patients were referred to secondary care by MEOMED, based on patient history alone. The average cost saving for a 60-practice CCG was estimated to be: Ā£730,000, compared with a technician-led ECG service Ā£1,816,000 compared with a standard hospital service. Strengths and limitations The study included multiple practices across 3 CCGs. The report was written by employees of MEOMED in collaboration with Trustech (NHS Northwest innovation organisation). Recent and ongoing studies No ongoing or in-development trials were identified. Specialist commentator commentsSpecialist commentator comments Comments on this technology were invited from clinical experts working in the field. The comments received are individual opinions and do not represent NICE's view. All 4 experts were aware of, or had used, the remote electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation services described in this briefing. Two experts believed that the services were not being widely used in the NHS, while the other 2 were unsure or did not comment. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 13 of 16
  • 14. Level of innovation Two experts believed that the services were novel, while another thought they were not. One expert believed the services were only a minor iteration of current care that had not been superseded. One expert thought that some of these services were innovative because patient reports could be written and interpreted by experienced clinicians who had access to patient history. Two experts felt that non-commercial interpretation services available in their local hospital coronary care unit by trained clinicians offered competition to the services reported in this briefing because, in their opinion, they were either faster, free or better. One expert mentioned that some services developed in hospital had a system to immediately assess if ECG changes were new or pre-existing. They believed that this gave their service an advantage over the commercial services in this briefing. On the contrary, 1 expert had to stop using a commercial service because their local trust chose to provide their own in-house service instead. They felt that the commercial service was better than the service provided by the local trust because it had a faster turnaround time and less variability in reporting. One expert mentioned open access services for Holter monitors as a similar technology but added that they were often poorly supervised and did not take patient history into account. Potential patient impact All of the experts agreed that avoiding unnecessary hospital visits was a potential patient benefit. Three experts also agreed that high-risk cardiac symptoms could be identified earlier than with standard care and this would allow for earlier prevention or treatment to begin. However, 1 expert also expressed concern that such services may be used improperly in people with symptoms that need clinical review, such as acute chest pain or unexplained syncope. One expert mentioned that some of these services may provide the added reassurance to patients because the results would be reviewed by highly trained clinicians. The experts stated various types of patients would particularly benefit from these services including: people with low-risk symptoms (history of vasovagal syncope, palpitations or hypertension); people with a pre-existing ECG abnormality because a comparison to a current ECG might prevent an unnecessary referral or because ECGs taken from Holter monitors are more likely to be misinterpreted in primary care; older people or those with mobility issues because there would be a reduced need for them to travel to hospital. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 14 of 16
  • 15. Potential system impact All of the experts agreed that a potential reduction in non-emergency referrals to secondary care specialist clinics would be a benefit to the health or care system. One expert said this reduction could lead to cost savings in regions where links to secondary care are poor. Another expert added that less money would need to be spent on secondary care and more could be allocated to primary care. Two experts thought that cardiac interpretation services could increase costs for their region but another expert thought that there could be cost savings if cardiologist resources were used more effectively by reducing unnecessary outpatient appointments. They added that this may also lead to better resource allocation in secondary care. Three experts felt that little to no change to current infrastructure would be needed to use these technologies and that when needed they would presumably be provided by the companies. One expert believed that advanced ECG interpretation skills would be needed for clinicians to use any of the technologies. Two experts expressed some concerns about the resource impact from adopting these technologies. One thought that the interpreter would need to take a holistic view and take clinical history into account for best management. They also felt that the most important element of such services was the skill set of the interpreter. The other expert reiterated that such services should not be used alone in managing high-risk symptoms and expressed worry that some practitioners could become overly reliant on these services. A third expert highlighted that primary care services would be expected to take responsibility for clinical decision-making if not referring patients onward for additional specialist follow-up. No safety concerns or regulatory issues were raised surrounding the use of these technologies. General comments One expert mentioned that his knowledge of ECG analysis had improved after using an ECG interpretation service. Another expert felt that establishing local, non-commercial telemetry services should be attempted before using commercial providers. The expert acknowledged that some regions may not manage to establish close collaborations with their local hospital to successfully use non-commercial services. None of the experts had an opinion on how the services will adapt to the end of the N3 network but stressed the importance of continued data security. One expert expressed suspicion of services that provide diagnostic guidance without assessing clinical presentation. Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 15 of 16
  • 16. Three of the experts felt that the technology would be an addition to standard care, rather than a replacement. One added that the services could be a replacement for outpatient referral where links to local cardiology services are poor. The fourth expert agreed, stating that the technology would replace the need to refer every patient for an initial outpatient appointment. Two experts identified information technology-related difficulties, such as network and transmission problems, as the only practical issues with the services. One expert was not convinced by the published research because of industry involvement and limited real-world cost information. The expert felt that a pilot trial for an individual healthcare organisation would provide more useful data as results may vary across different locations. One expert thought that the services should agree to make audits of their performance available to purchasers. This would be particularly informative if the results included hospital referral rates and patient outcomes. Specialist commentatorsSpecialist commentators The following clinicians contributed to this briefing: Dr Jonathan Watt, consultant cardiologist, Raigmore Hospital, NHS Highland, member of the British Cardiovascular Intervention Society. No relevant conflicts of interest. Mr Charlie Bloe, clinical ward manager, NHS Highland, member of SHARP (Scottish Heart and Arterial disease Risk Prevention). Mr Bloe is the clinical lead and managing director for a private healthcare education company and provides regular tuition to healthcare professionals on electrocardiogram (ECG) interpretation. Dr Richard Schilling, professor of cardiology, Barts Health NHS Trust, member of the British Heart Rhythm Society. No relevant conflicts of interest. Dr M C Patel, GP, Brent Clinical Commissioning Group. Dr Patel is a shareholder in Harness GP Cooperative Ltd and chair of Harness Board. His patients were included in an NHS England Regional Innovation-funded audit. DeDevvelopment of this briefingelopment of this briefing This briefing was developed for NICE by King's Technology Evaluation Centre. The interim process and methods statement sets out the process NICE uses to select topics, and how the briefings are developed, quality-assured and approved for publication. ISBN: 978-1-4731-3030-2 Remote ECG interpretation consultancy services for cardiovascular disease (MIB152) Ā© NICE 2018. All rights reserved. Subject to Notice of rights (https://www.nice.org.uk/terms-and- conditions#notice-of-rights). Page 16 of 16