RFP Competitive Price
Forecast Engine	
  
win	
  more	
  deals	
  profitably	
  
Robert	
  D.	
  Brown	
  III	
  
678.947.5997	
  
rdbrown@incitedecisiontech.com	
  
www.incitedecisiontech.com	
  
Sales	
  groups	
  employ	
  a	
  number	
  of	
  means	
  to	
  develop	
  
compeDDve	
  RFP	
  response	
  bids	
  
•  One	
  approach:	
  compare	
  “best	
  
guess”	
  compeDtors’	
  prices	
  to	
  
an	
  iniDal	
  home	
  price.	
  
•  Adjust	
  the	
  home	
  price	
  unDl	
  it	
  
undercuts	
  the	
  compeDtors’	
  
prices.	
  
Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
   2	
  
$Price	
  
IniDal	
  Home	
  
Price	
  
“Best	
  Guess”	
  
CompeDtor	
  
Price	
  
Readjusted	
  
Home	
  Price	
  
What	
  can	
  go	
  wrong	
  with	
  this	
  approach?	
  
•  One	
  rarely	
  knows	
  the	
  compeDtors’	
  price	
  
with	
  certainty.	
  
•  “Best	
  guesses”	
  are	
  based	
  on	
  bias,	
  caveats	
  
&	
  anecdotes.	
  
•  CompeDtors’	
  actual	
  price	
  is	
  based	
  on	
  
uncertain	
  underlying	
  cost	
  components	
  &	
  
desired	
  margins,	
  leading	
  to	
  compounded	
  
uncertainty.	
  
•  Uncertainty	
  leads	
  to	
  ambiguity	
  about	
  the	
  
right	
  direcDon	
  to	
  adjust	
  price.	
  
•  Price	
  compeDDon	
  and	
  margin-­‐destroying	
  
commodiDzaDon	
  escalates.	
  
Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
   3	
  
“Boy,	
  that	
  escalated	
  quickly.	
  I	
  mean,	
  
that	
  really	
  got	
  out	
  of	
  hand	
  fast!”	
  
With	
  the	
  Incite!	
  RFP	
  CompeDDve	
  Price	
  Forecast	
  Engine,	
  
you	
  can	
  
•  Compare	
  your	
  price	
  against	
  the	
  likely	
  range	
  
of	
  compeDtors’	
  prices.	
  
•  Focus	
  prioriDzed	
  adenDon	
  on	
  which	
  
compeDtors’	
  price	
  components	
  affect	
  your	
  
ability	
  to	
  win	
  on	
  price.	
  
•  IdenDfy	
  the	
  most	
  effecDve	
  areas	
  to	
  adjust	
  
your	
  costs	
  to	
  price	
  neutrality	
  to	
  focus	
  on	
  
delivering	
  intangible	
  benefits	
  that	
  customers	
  
value	
  more.	
  
•  Avoid	
  leaving	
  value	
  on	
  the	
  table	
  and	
  cugng	
  
margins	
  by	
  pricing	
  too	
  low.	
  	
  
4	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
The	
  Incite!	
  RFP	
  CompeDDve	
  Price	
  Forecast	
  Engine	
  
follows	
  a	
  three-­‐stage	
  iteraDve	
  process	
  	
  
Prepare	
  
Analysis	
  
Calibrate	
  
CompeDtor	
  
Cost	
  
AssumpDons	
  
Supply	
  Your	
  
Cost	
  
AssumpDons	
  
Adjust	
  Your	
  
Price	
  to	
  Win	
  at	
  
Probability	
  of	
  
Award	
  
Can	
  
CompeDtor	
  
InformaDon	
  
be	
  
Improved?	
  
Can	
  Your	
  
Price	
  be	
  
Improved?	
  
No	
  
IdenDfy	
  Most	
  
SensiDve	
  
Inputs	
  on	
  
Tornado	
  Chart	
  
Recalibrate	
  
Inputs	
  with	
  
Improved	
  
InformaDon	
  
Yes	
  
IdenDfy	
  Most	
  
SensiDve	
  
Inputs	
  on	
  Your	
  
Price	
  
Readjust	
  
Inputs	
  to	
  
Narrow	
  Price	
  
Gap	
  
Yes	
  
End	
  
No	
  
1.	
  
2.	
  
3.	
  
1.  Capture	
  iniDal	
  cost	
  informaDon	
  
2.  PrioriDze	
  areas	
  of	
  greatest	
  
uncertainty,	
  gain	
  intelligence,	
  
then	
  recalibrate	
  accordingly	
  
3.  Modify	
  your	
  costs	
  to	
  reach	
  price	
  
indifference	
  
5	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
Capture	
  cost	
  data	
  according	
  to	
  your	
  unique	
  template	
  
price	
  formula	
  
6	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
Capture	
  &	
  document	
  raDonales	
  for	
  compeDtors’	
  price	
  
components.	
  Calibrate	
  with	
  80th	
  percenDle	
  predicDon	
  ranges.	
  
7	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
The	
  user	
  interface	
  imports	
  the	
  pricing	
  data	
  and	
  
provides	
  key	
  results	
  
8	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
Home	
  Price	
  Probability	
  of	
  Win	
  shows	
  the	
  
corresponding	
  likelihood	
  of	
  winning	
  at	
  a	
  given	
  price	
  
Your	
  current	
  price	
  
is	
  $2.25M.	
  
The	
  probability	
  neutral	
  
price	
  is	
  $1.75M,	
  given	
  
current	
  informaDon.	
  
In	
  this	
  example,	
  you	
  will	
  
need	
  to	
  determine	
  how	
  
to	
  move	
  your	
  price	
  
$500K.	
  
9	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
Current	
  Price	
  Comparison	
  shows	
  your	
  price	
  compared	
  
to	
  compeDtors’	
  likely	
  prices	
  
This	
  appears	
  to	
  be	
  
a	
  balanced	
  price	
  
posiDon,	
  but	
  the	
  
Probability	
  of	
  Win	
  
at	
  Current	
  Home	
  
Price	
  is	
  only	
  1.74%.	
  	
  
10	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
The	
  probability	
  of	
  winning	
  is	
  dependent	
  on	
  the	
  amount	
  of	
  
uncertainty	
  about	
  compeDtors’	
  prices.	
  The	
  tornado	
  chart	
  
breaks	
  down	
  the	
  sources	
  of	
  uncertainty	
  to	
  guide	
  efforts	
  to	
  
gain	
  beder	
  informaDon	
  about	
  compeDtors’	
  prices.	
  
11	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
You	
  have	
  high	
  
confidence	
  in	
  
these	
  elements.	
  
Focus	
  your	
  adenDon	
  on	
  gegng	
  beder	
  informaDon	
  here	
  
Home	
  Price	
  Sensi:vity	
  to	
  Cost	
  Elements	
  shows	
  priority	
  
of	
  adenDon	
  for	
  adjusDng	
  your	
  price	
  to	
  a	
  neutral	
  price	
  
12	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
AdjusDng	
  this	
  element	
  moves	
  price	
  fastest	
  in	
  desired	
  direcDon	
  
Final	
  Price	
  Comparison	
  shows	
  all	
  final	
  price	
  esDmates	
  
aner	
  price	
  adjustments	
  are	
  made	
  
13	
  Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
  
Benefits	
  of	
  Using	
  the	
  Incite!	
  RFP	
  CompeDDve	
  Price	
  
Forecast	
  Engine	
  	
  
•  Develop	
  more	
  informed	
  RFP	
  pricing	
  
•  Avoid	
  the	
  risk	
  of	
  pricing	
  too	
  low	
  (leaving	
  
money	
  on	
  the	
  table)	
  or	
  too	
  high	
  
(reducing	
  price	
  compeDDveness)	
  
•  Focus	
  more	
  adenDon	
  on	
  providing	
  
intangible	
  benefits	
  that	
  differenDate	
  
your	
  offering	
  
•  Win	
  more	
  deals	
  at	
  a	
  higher	
  profit	
  
Incite!	
  Decision	
  Technologies,	
  LLC	
  Copyright	
  ©	
  2013	
  All	
  Rights	
  Reserved	
   14	
  

RFP Competitive Price Forecasting Engine

  • 1.
    RFP Competitive Price ForecastEngine   win  more  deals  profitably   Robert  D.  Brown  III   678.947.5997   rdbrown@incitedecisiontech.com   www.incitedecisiontech.com  
  • 2.
    Sales  groups  employ  a  number  of  means  to  develop   compeDDve  RFP  response  bids   •  One  approach:  compare  “best   guess”  compeDtors’  prices  to   an  iniDal  home  price.   •  Adjust  the  home  price  unDl  it   undercuts  the  compeDtors’   prices.   Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved   2   $Price   IniDal  Home   Price   “Best  Guess”   CompeDtor   Price   Readjusted   Home  Price  
  • 3.
    What  can  go  wrong  with  this  approach?   •  One  rarely  knows  the  compeDtors’  price   with  certainty.   •  “Best  guesses”  are  based  on  bias,  caveats   &  anecdotes.   •  CompeDtors’  actual  price  is  based  on   uncertain  underlying  cost  components  &   desired  margins,  leading  to  compounded   uncertainty.   •  Uncertainty  leads  to  ambiguity  about  the   right  direcDon  to  adjust  price.   •  Price  compeDDon  and  margin-­‐destroying   commodiDzaDon  escalates.   Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved   3   “Boy,  that  escalated  quickly.  I  mean,   that  really  got  out  of  hand  fast!”  
  • 4.
    With  the  Incite!  RFP  CompeDDve  Price  Forecast  Engine,   you  can   •  Compare  your  price  against  the  likely  range   of  compeDtors’  prices.   •  Focus  prioriDzed  adenDon  on  which   compeDtors’  price  components  affect  your   ability  to  win  on  price.   •  IdenDfy  the  most  effecDve  areas  to  adjust   your  costs  to  price  neutrality  to  focus  on   delivering  intangible  benefits  that  customers   value  more.   •  Avoid  leaving  value  on  the  table  and  cugng   margins  by  pricing  too  low.     4  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 5.
    The  Incite!  RFP  CompeDDve  Price  Forecast  Engine   follows  a  three-­‐stage  iteraDve  process     Prepare   Analysis   Calibrate   CompeDtor   Cost   AssumpDons   Supply  Your   Cost   AssumpDons   Adjust  Your   Price  to  Win  at   Probability  of   Award   Can   CompeDtor   InformaDon   be   Improved?   Can  Your   Price  be   Improved?   No   IdenDfy  Most   SensiDve   Inputs  on   Tornado  Chart   Recalibrate   Inputs  with   Improved   InformaDon   Yes   IdenDfy  Most   SensiDve   Inputs  on  Your   Price   Readjust   Inputs  to   Narrow  Price   Gap   Yes   End   No   1.   2.   3.   1.  Capture  iniDal  cost  informaDon   2.  PrioriDze  areas  of  greatest   uncertainty,  gain  intelligence,   then  recalibrate  accordingly   3.  Modify  your  costs  to  reach  price   indifference   5  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 6.
    Capture  cost  data  according  to  your  unique  template   price  formula   6  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 7.
    Capture  &  document  raDonales  for  compeDtors’  price   components.  Calibrate  with  80th  percenDle  predicDon  ranges.   7  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 8.
    The  user  interface  imports  the  pricing  data  and   provides  key  results   8  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 9.
    Home  Price  Probability  of  Win  shows  the   corresponding  likelihood  of  winning  at  a  given  price   Your  current  price   is  $2.25M.   The  probability  neutral   price  is  $1.75M,  given   current  informaDon.   In  this  example,  you  will   need  to  determine  how   to  move  your  price   $500K.   9  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 10.
    Current  Price  Comparison  shows  your  price  compared   to  compeDtors’  likely  prices   This  appears  to  be   a  balanced  price   posiDon,  but  the   Probability  of  Win   at  Current  Home   Price  is  only  1.74%.     10  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 11.
    The  probability  of  winning  is  dependent  on  the  amount  of   uncertainty  about  compeDtors’  prices.  The  tornado  chart   breaks  down  the  sources  of  uncertainty  to  guide  efforts  to   gain  beder  informaDon  about  compeDtors’  prices.   11  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved   You  have  high   confidence  in   these  elements.   Focus  your  adenDon  on  gegng  beder  informaDon  here  
  • 12.
    Home  Price  Sensi:vity  to  Cost  Elements  shows  priority   of  adenDon  for  adjusDng  your  price  to  a  neutral  price   12  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved   AdjusDng  this  element  moves  price  fastest  in  desired  direcDon  
  • 13.
    Final  Price  Comparison  shows  all  final  price  esDmates   aner  price  adjustments  are  made   13  Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved  
  • 14.
    Benefits  of  Using  the  Incite!  RFP  CompeDDve  Price   Forecast  Engine     •  Develop  more  informed  RFP  pricing   •  Avoid  the  risk  of  pricing  too  low  (leaving   money  on  the  table)  or  too  high   (reducing  price  compeDDveness)   •  Focus  more  adenDon  on  providing   intangible  benefits  that  differenDate   your  offering   •  Win  more  deals  at  a  higher  profit   Incite!  Decision  Technologies,  LLC  Copyright  ©  2013  All  Rights  Reserved   14