3. under-
graduate course that focuses on human resources as the dynamic
founda-
tion for organizational competitiveness in a change-driven
environment.
It examines processes for planning, developing, and managing
human
resources within the context of a partnership relationship among
leaders,
managers, and employees.
The course is structured around three fundamental beliefs: (1)
human
resources represent a critical organizational asset; (2) human
resources
are the linchpin for organizational change; and (3) human
resources are a
source of competitive advantage.
Course Objectives
Human Resources Management has two overall objectives: (1)
to intro-
duce concepts and practices essential to successful human
resources
planning, development, and management and (2) to build your
skills in
critically applying concepts and practices to realistic situations
across a
variety of industries and sectors.
By the conclusion of this course, you should be able to:
resources
from a tactical role of order taker to a strategic role of self-
initiator
4. and manager.
relationship
between management and nonmanagement personnel.
organizational
resources.
Prioritize the external effects of globalization, increased
competition,
and differentiated markets on human resources.
process
change on human resources.
nology on human processes, skills,
and
capabilities within organizational environments.
Syllabus—Course Essentials
S-4
work
force diversity, relationships between labor and management,
and
conflicts between global and local human resource dynamics.
Required Textbook
In addition to the Course Syllabus, you will need the following
textbook
5. to do the work of this course. It is available from the textbook
supplier,
MBS Direct.
Managing Human Resources, 10th ed., by Susan E. Jackson,
Randall S.
Schuler, Steve Werner (Mason, OH: South-Western, 2009).
Course Structure
Human Resources Management is a 12-week, three-credit course
consisting of ten units grouped into four modules, ten analytic
written
responses (written assignments), a midterm examination, and a
final
project in the form of a case analysis. Lesson study assignments
include
readings from the required textbook, the “In-Site” commentaries
and
appendixes at the end of the syllabus, and supplemental
inquiries.
Periodically, you will complete a written assignment and submit
it to
your mentor for correction and grading. See the “Course
Calendar” for
the weekly study assignments and for the dates for submitting
your
written assignments, scheduling your midterm examination, and
submitting your final project.
Required Readings
You will have weekly reading assignments in the Jackson,
Schuler and
Werner text that will include both chapter narratives and case
studies.
6. You will also be required to read the assigned “In-Sites,” which
relate
concepts to practice. In-Sites, which are located in the
“Assignment
Schedule” section of this syllabus, are remarks that highlight or
expand
on readings, enabling you to assess and compare personal or
professional
experiences with readings.
Where indicated, you should study certain textbook chapters for
answers
to specific questions relating to your final project. See the
“Final Project:
Case Analysis” section of the syllabus for more information.
Study assignments also include reading Appendixes A–C of the
syllabus.
Syllabus—Course Essentials
S-5
Supplemental Inquiries
Weeks 2, 4, and 6 each include a supplemental inquiry that
encourages
you to venture beyond the text for additional learning
opportunities. For
the two inquiries that require reading, you may choose
published
(printed or electronic) or unpublished (manuscript) sources. For
the on-
the-job analysis, you will rely on primary (firsthand) research.
7. The purpose of the supplemental readings is to (1) provide you
with
more information on specific topics than exists in the textbook
and (2)
allow you the freedom to select your own reading materials.
Please note that the supplemental inquiries do not require the
writing of
additional papers. Rather, they are meant to enhance your
knowledge.
Written Assignments
Human Resources Management has ten (10) written
assignments. These
assignments are the chief means for demonstrating your
analytic,
assessment, and expressive abilities. Due dates for each
assignment are
listed in the “Course Calendar” and in the “Assignment
Schedule” (see
individual assignment boxes). Read through the assignment
questions
before you begin each unit.
The purpose of the written assignments is threefold: (1) to
provide
experience in data gathering, critical analysis, and realistic
application of
concepts and practice; (2) to present your findings in a written
document
that is professional in content and appearance; and (3) to
reinforce the
textbook, supplemental inquiries, and In-Sites.
The guidelines for preparing and submitting written assignments
8. are for
you to:
respond to
the assignment. Primary research may involve interviews that
you
conduct yourself; secondary research uses published sources of
information.
should
be professionally presented, using clear syntax, correct
grammar, and
correct spelling. You must cite all sources of information
according to
MLA style, APA style, or The Chicago Manual of Style.
course title
and code, and the assignment number.
signments to the mentor by the due date
indicated.
Syllabus—Course Essentials
S-6
Midterm Examination
You are required to take a midterm examination. Consult the
course
Calendar for the official dates of exam weeks.
The midterm is a closed-book, proctored exam. It is two hours
9. long and
covers all material assigned in Weeks 1–5. The exam consists
of four (4)
fictional but realistic mini-cases, or scenarios, in which you
apply
conceptual and practical knowledge to answer questions, solve
problems,
or make recommendations.
For the midterm, you are required to use the College's Online
Proctor
Service (OPS). Please refer to the "Examinations and Proctors"
section of
the Online Student Handbook (see General Information area of
the course
Web site) for further information about scheduling and taking
online
exams and for all exam policies and procedures. You are
strongly advised
to schedule your exam within the first week of the semester.
Online exams are administered through the course Web site.
Final Project: Case Analysis
You are required at the end of the semester to hand in a final
project in
the form of a case analysis, which will be worth 20% of your
final grade
for the course. For details of this assignment, see the “Final
Project: Case
Analysis” section in this syllabus. For the scheduling of this
case analysis
see the “Course Calendar” and “Assignments” sections.
Grading
Your final grade in the course will be determined as follows:
10. Written assignments (10) 50 percent
Midterm examination 30 percent
Final Project 20 percent
Letter grades for assignments and examinations equate to
numerical
grades as follows:
A = 93–100 C+ = 78–79
A– = 90–92 C = 73–77
B+ = 88–89 C– = 70–72
B = 83–87 D = 60–69
B– = 80–82 F = Below 60
Syllabus—Course Essentials
S-7
To receive credit for the course, you must earn a letter grade of
D or
higher on the weighted average of all assigned course work
(e.g., exams,
assignments, projects, papers, etc.). You will receive a score of
0 for any
work not submitted.
Strategies for Success
To succeed in this course, consider following these steps and
study tips:
1. Read carefully the entire “Course Essentials” section of the
syllabus,
11. making sure that all aspects of the course are clear to you and
that
you have all the materials required for the course.
2. Take the time to read the entire Student Handbook. The
handbook
answers many questions about how to proceed through the
course,
how to prepare and submit assignments, how to schedule exams
and
arrange for proctors, and how to get the most from your
educational
experience at Thomas Edison State College.
3. Each week, consult the “Course Calendar” in the syllabus for
an
overview of the week’s assignment. Then proceed to the unit-
by-unit
“Assignment Schedule” for the assignment details, including the
In-
Site commentary and written assignment. The calendar also
indicates
the due dates for submitting written assignments and when you
should schedule your examination. It is essential that you
follow the
calendar each week to ensure that you stay on track throughout
the
course. To fill in the assignment due dates and exam dates, use
the
table of week-by-week dates in the General Course Instructions.
4. You are encouraged to use the end-of-chapter study aids
(“Terms to
Remember,” “Discussion Questions,” and “Projects to Extend
Your
Learning”) in the Jackson, Schuler and Werner text for review.
12. 5. Read carefully the “Final Project: Case Analysis” section of
the
syllabus to make sure you know what is required.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-8
Course Calendar
Using the table of week-by-week dates in the General Course
Instructions,
write the dates for the current semester in the second column. In
the last
column, fill in the actual date for submitting each written
assignment and
taking examinations. All page references for chapters and case
studies are
to the Jackson and Schuler text. See the week-by-week
“Assignment
Schedule” for details about each assignment, including lesson
focus and
highlighted readings within specific chapters. All written
assignments are
to be submitted by Sunday of the week they are due.
Week
/Unit
Dates Study Assignment
Written
13. Assignment/
Examination
Due
Date/
Exam
Date
Module One: Human Resources as the Competitive Edge
1
(Unit
1.1)
Read the following:
-Site: The Human Resource
Continuum—From Follower to Leader
-Site: In Change We (Can) Trust
Written Assignment 1
2
(Unit
1.2)
Read the following:
-70 (Reread)
—From Boss to Peer
14. -Site: Building Blocks—Humans and
Organizational Architecture
Written Assignment 2
Module Two: Organizations in Environments of Change
3
(Unit
2.1)
Read the following:
-Site: Who's on First?
Written Assignment 3
4
(Unit
2.2)
-read Chapter 3
Inquiry—Job Analysis
-Site: Guest Commentary (Donna
Engelson)
Written Assignment 4
15. Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-9
Week
/Unit
Dates Study Assignment
Written
Assignment/
Examination
Due
Date/
Exam
Date
Module Three: Human Resources as Organizational Strategy
5
(Unit
3.1)
Read the following:
Escorts)
-Site: Starting Here, Starting Now
-Site: The Interview
Written Assignment 5
16. 6
(Unit
3.2)
Read the following:
Pay close attention to the real world
examples of "Managing Human
Resources at Ritz-Carlton Hotel
Company" (p. 269), "Managing Ethics:
J.M. Smucker & Co." (p. 273), "Managing
With Metrics: IBM Evaluates Its Training"
(p. 279), "Managing The Multicultural
Workforce: John W. Thompson CEO and
Mentor" (p.295), and "Managing
Globalization: PricewaterhouseCooper"
(p. 307)."
-317
s Appendixes B and C
—Motivation
-Site: Outgrowing Your Organization
-Site: The Pushmi-Pullyu
-Site: Give Me Money, That's What I
Want (Not?)
Written Assignment 6
7
17. MIDTERM EXAMINATION
(covers materials assigned through Week 5)
8
(Unit
3.3)
Read the following:
-Site: Goodies
Written Assignment 7
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-10
Week
/Unit
Dates Study Assignment
Written
Assignment/
Examination
Due
Date/
18. Exam
Date
9
(Unit
3.4)
Read the following:
-Site: One Size Doesn't Fit All
-Site: Just Rewards
Written Assignment 8
10
(Unit
3.5)
Read the following:
Pay close attention to the paragraphs
about UPS on page 507 and Union's
Involvement Enhances Competitiveness
on page 509."
-Site: Squeaky Wheels
-Site: Have I Got a Deal for You!
Written Assignment 9
19. Module Four: Human Resources as a Profession
11
(Unit
4)
–28
-of-Text Case, pp. 560–575 (Lincoln
Electric)
-Site: Strategic Thinking, Future Tense
Written Assignment 10
12 FINAL PROJECT DUE
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-11
Assignment Schedule
MODULE ONE: HUMAN RESOURCES AS THE
COMPETITIVE EDGE
20. Unit 1.1 ________
Focal Points
—from plowhorse to
stakeholder: (1) multiple stakeholders, (2) stakeholders as
partners,
and (3) productivity as the stakeholder-partner common goal.
for
human resources management: (1) globalization of markets, (2)
technological change, and (3) cultural diversity (differences in
country
cultures).
Study Assignment
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-12
se Study: "Levi Strauss
&
Company," pages 70-71 (read only).
In-Site: The Human Resource Continuum—From
Follower to Leader
Our first commentary looks at human resources historically to
highlight
21. two changing perceptions: the way organizations see markets
and the
way they use human beings as a resource to serve markets'
needs.
The reliance on mechanical, repetitive production triggered by
the
industrial revolution created a "volume" mindset in almost
every kind of
enterprise. As an inevitable result, markets were seen in terms
of
numbers, whether the marketplace was composed of individual
or
organizational consumers. Human resources were "workers,"
part of the
machinery, with a largely tactical role. They completed
assigned tasks to
meet organizational goals, also driven by numbers: the amount
of goods
or services produced. The underlying belief was that
production, not
sales, was the objective. Initiative was an exclusive right of
management.
Production, of course, does not guarantee that any market will
want to
buy what has been produced. Thus, the production era of
enterprise
slowly moved into the second stage—the sales era. During this
period, it
was recognized that an intentional selling effort was critical to
achieving
those desired "volume" results. Much of the enterprise's
resources,
including its personnel, were devoted to generating market
awareness
22. and interest in purchasing its products or services. This was the
first time
that advertising was used in any planned, coherent manner. The
primary
means of selling, however, was salespeople, and each
salesperson
operated against quotas. The role of human resources was still
tactical,
yet there were changes away from order taking to order
generating.
Successful salespeople had some freedom to select their own
method-
ologies and to communicate and negotiate. Enterprises evolved
from
having production (output) as the goal to sales (consumption) as
the goal.
Initiative was still largely in the hands of management.
The problem was that there was no real knowledge of market
behaviors.
On the contrary, the sales era created the "faceless" concept of
mass
marketing, in which economies of selling were achieved by
treating every
market the same. As consumers became more aware of their own
needs
and wants—and their inherent rights in consumer-based
economies—
enterprises were forced to become students of the marketplace.
Thus, we
entered our current era—the market era, in which anyone doing
business
acknowledges the need to conduct market research, identify and
priori-
tize market targets, develop appropriate marketing
communications, and
23. Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-13
let the market drive the decisions on which products or services
to
develop.
Not all of this last era developed at once, and human beings as a
resource
tended to lag behind in the sales era, until dramatic changes in
communi-
cations and competition forced another rethinking: How do we
use our
work forces most effectively? Can and should they have a role
different
from the tactical, in which they respond and follow directions?
Can they
be the initiators instead of the followers? Can they be partners
in the
organization? As you may know, the biggest changes in human
resources
have been concurrent with organizational reinvention, in which
enterprises in every sector and industry are restructuring and
redefining
processes to achieve and maintain competitiveness. The work
force is
now being seen as an organizational asset and ally, as necessary
a part of
the short-range and long-range plans as all other physical and
capital
assets. The inclusion of human resources in planning allows it
to assume
a strategic partnership rather than a tactical role, and its
24. importance as an
asset encourages initiative to move downward from management
to
diffuse throughout the organization.
In-Site: In Change We (Can) Trust
We read and hear about it constantly—the dangers of change to
individuals and organizations. Change is frightening, puts us at
risk,
undermines our assumptions, and is generally "bad news."
Given such
onerous warnings, it may appear ridiculous to suggest that
"change" is
something that we can trust. But we can—and should.
Change, after all, is an element of newness or the unknown in
any
situation. It represents "dynamics" or the process of movement.
As all
human beings and systems are inherently dynamic, then change
should
represent a natural component of life, not an oddity. What really
makes
change so fearful in the workplace is the tendency to want to
remain
static and to avoid predicting, quantifying, or managing change
well
when it does occur.
Why the desire to remain static? Isn't repetition boring? Can't
organizations, and the people who work in them, create
processes and
structures that handle change well?
Organizational processes and structures can indeed be altered.
25. Organizations can integrate into their systems everything from
"new
venture" departments—to plan and manage new product
development—
to change agents—people with formal responsibility for
identifying and
championing behavioral change within specific areas. The
human capa-
bility to change is there! What makes change really upsetting,
however, is
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-14
that it forces us to think rather than act out of habit, and in
many
organizations moving away from habit is punished rather than
rewarded.
Change shifts the core of planning from a reliance on habit to a
reliance
on thinking. Change-driven thinking, in turn, requires that we
look inside
and outside our workplaces through reinvestigation, reanalysis,
and
reassessment. It demands that our human resources be creative
rather
than redundant, and be allowed to take the risks inherent in
creativity. It
also pushes us to perceive change in terms of opportunities
rather than
threats and to recognize that change is ongoing; it doesn't just
happen
once. If we plan and manage change properly, we can trust it to
26. make us
smarter as individuals and organizations. In most cases, the
marketplace
will thank us for it.
Written Assignment 1
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Case Study About Managing Human Resources
Read the case study "Managing Human Resources at Barden
Bearings"
on pages 110-111 of the textbook and respond to Case
Questions 1–3.
Submit by Sunday of Week 1 _____ according to the
instructions in the
Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
Unit 1.2 ________
Focal Point
manage-
ment: (1) organizational change, (2) key process change, (3)
organizational cultural development, and (4) individual work to
teamwork.
27. Study Assignment
Schuler and Werner, chapter 3.
-70.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-15
Structure/Process."
—From Boss to Peer: Find and read two
(2) print
or electronic articles on the shift in authority and decision
making
from managers to nonmanagers in any organization or industry.
In-Site: Building Blocks—Humans and Organizational
Architecture
Structure is the framework of any organization and, like the
frame of a
house, holds the organization together. Houses, however, are
not
dynamic; organizations are. As you may already realize from
your
readings, organizations are open systems in which structure
drives the
division of labor. The division of labor, in turn, determines the
critical
processes of authority, decision making, and communications.
An
28. effective structure is one that maintains positive goal-reaching
dynamics
while being flexible enough to absorb change. If we use the
example of
"building blocks," a good structure can handle a certain amount
of
process change—building or rebuilding—without total collapse.
Process is the complement to structure and the means by which
goals are
achieved within those "frameworks." Organizational processes
are
typically sequential (chronological) or concurrent (occurring at
the same
time) or a combination of both.
You may be asking, Where does technology fit in, as every
organization
today is employing technology? Despite the way we use the
word
technology in everyday conversation, technology is not separate
from
other processes. In management theory and practice, technology
is
actually the combination of human and mechanical processes
that
together result in output.
Where does the human resource fit into this picture? By
definition, the
human resource is the work force, and it may exist inside the
organization as employees, outside of it as contractors, or both.
If we
accept that human resources are shifting from a tactical to a
strategic
partnership role, can they be considered part process, part
29. structure, or
both?
Of greatest importance is determining whether your workplace's
struc-
ture and processes—its architecture—are compatible with
organizational
goals and whether they use human resources most effectively in
estab-
lishing and meeting those goals.
Written Assignment 2
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-16
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
External and Organizational Challenges on Your Workplace
Write an on-the-job analysis and assessment of your
organization and
the impact of any one of the following external or
organizational
challenges (pressures):
1. globalization of markets
2. technological change
3. differences in country cultures
4. organizational change
5. key process change
30. 6. organizational cultural development (company culture)
7. individual work to teamwork.
Submit by Sunday of Week 2 _____ according to the
instructions in the
Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
MODULE TWO: ORGANIZATIONS IN
ENVIRONMENTS OF CHANGE
Unit 2.1 ________
Focal Point
ternal
and internal
change and (2) impact of change on employee fairness.
Study Assignment
In-Site: Who's on First?
"Who's my boss today?" "Initiative of the month." "This week's
fad."
You're undoubtedly familiar with at least one of the comments
above, as
they are common in organizations undergoing change. At best
they
remind us of the old Abbott and Costello routine "Who's on
31. First?" At
worst they are far more serious than a comical skit. Upheaval in
processes
has the greatest potential to cause long-term damage in an
organization,
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-17
creating insecurity in the marketplace as it generates fear among
the work
force.
Of all the process changes occurring today, diffusion of
authority may
have the greatest impact. "Authority" is the ability to compel
action on the
part of others, and traditionally authority has rested with
management. A
combination of structural downsizing (removing layers of
management)
and process change (group work) has resulted in
nonmanagement
employees taking on authority roles for the first time. They
have done so
through the twin processes of delegation (a formal transfer of
responsibility) and empowerment (the transfer of decision
making
authority to nonmanagers). Both processes are key to achieving
real
partnership with employees.
Such change can be daunting, especially for longtime employees
who are
32. accustomed to responding to authority rather than sharing in it
or
initiating authority through self-management. When added to
the
strangeness of working differently—such as in groups rather
than
individually—the effects can range from disruption to
dysfunction. It can
similarly frighten newer employees, who do not have the
requisite skills
or knowledge or who are reluctant to take the risk that decision
making
implies.
Written Assignment 3
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in the
"Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Workplace Privacy Laws and Policies
Prepare a paper that discusses workplace privacy; limit yourself
to
policies related to workplace communications—by e-mail,
Internet, and
telephone. Using the privacy policies of your own workplace as
a starting
point, explain why each policy was put in place—if you know
why—and
discuss whether employees generally agree or disagree with the
policy.
Then conduct research to learn about the latest workplace
privacy policies
and related legislation. Include the results of your research in
33. your paper
and explain whether, given the policies/legislation you found,
employees
are adequately protected or whether employers have too much
freedom to
monitor communications. Support your opinions with facts.
Submit by Sunday of Week 3 _____ according to the
instructions in the Student
Handbook section of the Course Manual.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-18
Unit 2.2 ________
Focal Point
analyzing
jobs and tasks in times of strategic organizational change and
(2)
achieving strategic "fit" between goals and work to be done.
Study Assignment
Inquiry—Job Analysis: Consider one (1) case
34. of task-
oriented job analysis or competency modeling (worker-oriented
job
analysis) within your workplace. Analyze the impact it has had
on an
existing job or set of jobs.
In-Site: Guest Commentary
This week we are joined by Donna Engelson, a partner in The
Leadership
Edge, a Virginia-based company specializing in organizational
and
employee needs analysis, skill and job matching, and strategic
job design.
Donna Engelson:
Have you ever hired a person who did not meet your
expectations?
Whether you have hired only a few people or thousands, you no
doubt
must answer that question with a yes—and perhaps with
frustration as
well. All of us have selected individuals, some of whom turned
out to be
"stars" and some of whom turned out to be marginal performers
at best—
and yet we selected them with equal expectations for success.
How—and
why—does this happen, and what can we do to hire more "stars"
and
fewer "duds"?
There are three places to solve people challenges: first, at the
front door,
during the selection process; second, through training and
35. development;
and last, at the back door, if efforts to make the individual "fit"
are not
successful. Obviously, selection and job fit make the most
positive impact
on the individual, the organization, and the bottom line.
Traditional selection processes have focused on the past
(résumé,
experience, and references) and the present (interview). These
remain
good but incomplete sources of information. What is missing is
the
future—does this person have the ability to learn? Does he or
she want
this job, as it may grow and change? Does this candidate have
the right
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-19
personality to do the job? All too often we hire people on the
basis of
competency, but then find they do not "fit."
So how can we determine if a candidate is a "fit"? A
combination of
technology and psychometric assessment makes it possible for
us to
enhance significantly our chances of selecting the right person
for the
right job. After developing a benchmark for any position, we
can
determine an individual's match for the job and explore this
36. further with
interviewing.
Having the technical skills to do a job is not enough. When the
individual
has "job fit," the result is a challenged and fully engaged
employee who is
more productive and therefore more profitable to the
organization. J. W.
Marriott said it well: "Put the right person in the right job, train
and
motivate them, give them an opportunity for advancement, and
your
company will grow and prosper."
Written Assignment 4
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Case Study About Change
Read the case study "Aligning HR with the Business at SBC" on
pages
32-33 of the textbook and respond to Case Questions 1–3.
Submit by Sunday of Week 4 _____according to the instructions
in
the Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
MODULE THREE: HUMAN RESOURCES AS
ORGANIZATIONAL STRATEGY
37. Unit 3.1 ________
Focal Points
Study Assignment
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-20
Patient
Escorts," page 266 (read only).
Anathema to Corporate Loyalty?" page 226 (read only).
In-Site: Starting Here, Starting Now
How does one plan and implement a human resources strategy
so that
interviewing, selection, and recruitment are as efficient as
possible?
The most sensible (and sane) approach is to target your efforts,
38. as you
would target a specific market for an equally specific
promotion. Effective
planning does not occur in a vacuum, nor is it driven solely by
grand
designs. Rather, it is a continuum of problem identification and
problem
solution.
Starting here and now, where are your human resource needs the
greatest
and most critical in the short term? At what level (management,
nonmanagement), in what department, division, or function do
they
exist? What is the scope (internal reach) of your needs? Are the
needs
most apparent in your organizational structure (gaps in the
framework),
process (gaps in the methods or means), or both?
Once you answer these questions, you can ask: What individual
or group
capabilities and capacities do we need within our designated
problem
areas? What kind of attitudes, behaviors, expectations, and
experiences
should our best candidates have? What resources will be
required to
support our efforts? What should management's role be?
As you undoubtedly suspect, the here and now is the starting
point, not
the end. There really is no end, as planning is an ongoing
process, not a
one-shot deal. Taking the long view demands the ability to
identify likely
39. causes of external and internal change, and integrate them into
the
planning process.
In-Site: The Interview
Interviews frequently represent the initial contact between an
employer
and potential employee. Despite their strategic importance to
any
organization, interviews are frequently conducted "by the seat
of one's
pants," without the planning necessary to maximize chances for
effectiveness. Why?
One surprising reason is that interviewing is misunderstood as a
unique
kind of communication. Consider the roots of the word: inter
'between'
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-21
and view 'vision'. From a practical standpoint, interview should
have as
its foundation a shared purpose among the communicants.
Typically, the
interview also will have restrictions such as time frame, the
overall context
in which the interview is conducted, and potential for
distractions that
may occur. Regrettably, in practice many interviews consist of
one person
talking and the other listening, which omits the key dynamic of
40. "between."
Beyond purpose, the most important element in interviewing is
the
communication strategy itself. Is it appropriate to have "closed"
ques-
tions, which generate yes or no answers, or open-ended ones, in
which
the interviewee is free to think out loud, express opinions, and
make
suggestions? Who is actually leading the interview, and will the
roles of
"asker" and "respondent" shift?
As is true with all oral and written communication, interviews
require
planning to meet specific goals. It is essential for the
interviewer to
determine the interview's goal and to rank the goals in
importance if
there are more than one. Audience analysis may also be
necessary, even if
the audience consists of one individual. What might that
individual's
prior interview experiences be, and what might his or her
attitudes and
expectations be as a result?
The rapidity of change within organizations suggests that
interviews may
be conducted more than once with the same individuals, but for
different
purposes, creating an interview history or continuum. In most
workplaces, interviewing supports initial hiring, but also assists
in
performance appraisal, disciplinary action, and positive rewards
41. such as
promotions. It is critical to determine up front what the reasons
are for
the interview and what results are expected.
Written Assignment 5
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Human Resource Planning
Conduct primary or secondary research, and write a summative
report on human resource planning in your industry or sector.
(Note:
A summative report "adds up" and restates what you have read;
it
does not provide critical analysis.)
Submit by Sunday of Week 5 _____ according to the
instructions in the
Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-22
Unit 3.2 ________
Focal Points
42. through
socialization, training, and development.
f the work force is accomplished: should it
be
through compelling action or encouraging participation?
competitive
pressures, (3) equity, and (4) communicating the plan.
Study Assignment
Read Jackson, Schuler and Werner, chapter 8.
Pay close attention to the real world examples of "Managing
Human
Resources at Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company" (p. 269), "Managing
Ethics: J.M. Smucker & Co." (p. 273), "Managing With Metrics:
IBM
Evaluates Its Training" (p. 279), "Managing The Multicultural
Workforce: John W. Thompson CEO and Mentor" (p.295), and
"Managing Globalization: PricewaterhouseCooper" (p. 307)."
-317.
, Schuler and Werner, chapter 10.
Capabilities/Capacities."
43. (immediately
below) for the final project that you must submit at the end of
the
semester.
section of
this syllabus that relate to chapters 8, 9 and 10 in your textbook.
—Motivation: Find and read two (2)
printed or
electronic articles that discuss either motivational theories or
motivational practices in a specific workplace, industry, or
sector.
Determine whether the examples reflect strategies that (a)
compel
employees to act or (b) encourage them to participate.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-23
Case Analysis Strategies for Success
At the end of the semester you are required to submit a final pro
ject in the
form of a case analysis which will be based on the information a
bout
Southwest Airlines contained in your textbook (pp. 544‐559).
44. Before you complete your analysis you will need to master the c
ourse
material presented in this and all subsequent weeks and units. T
his does
NOT mean however, that you should leave your project to the e
nd of the
semester; you need to start preparing now. Review the followi
ng
strategies for preparing your case analysis of Southwest Airline
s and
work on it incrementally as you complete your reading and writt
en
assignments for the rest of the semester.
It is important to do the following:
Study thoroughly the Southwest Airlines case description in the
text, including the two appendices (pp. 544‐559).
Review the chapters of the text listed as references for particula
r
questions.
Identify how concepts and practices in the referred chapters link
45. to the story of Southwest Airlines.
Search for connections, examples and research mentioned in the
text as likely explanations for what has occurred at Southwest
Airlines.
In-Site: Outgrowing Your Organization
If you are determined to develop your workplace capabilities
over the
long term—and seek employer-sponsored learning to do so—
you may
have been met with overt or hidden dismay. "Oh, sure, we'll
provide the
training, and then she or he will leave!" Embedded in that
dismay are
hints about the differences between training and development,
as well as
a fear that really good employees will outgrow their respective
organizations.
Let's look at training and development first. The simplest form
of
training, and the one in which employers make the greatest
commitment,
is "skills training." This is the workplace learning whose goals
are to fill
technical or procedural skill gaps, or at best to prepare for new
skill needs
in the short term. Skills training is comparatively easy to define
and
46. Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-24
quantify, since it is based on current and present needs and can
be
conceptualized as the organization is, right now.
Organizational training represents the next scope and asks
trainees to
look beyond their own skills, tasks, and responsibilities to the
workplace
as a whole. Such training is growing in demand as organizations
recognize the need for cross-functional capabilities as well as a
systemic
mindset. Because the emphasis remains within the specific
organization,
management can be convinced of its short- and longer-term
value.
The next two phases of workplace learning, however, represent
significantly greater risk to the sponsor. Industry-focused
development
exposes trainees to what's going on in their industry or sector,
thus
making them potentially more valuable to the competition as
well as the
current employer. Professional development has the broadest
and
deepest scope of all, requiring participants to examine their own
capabilities, capacities, and interests, and opening the
possibility that they
may switch industries, sectors, or both.
47. What if you introduced one of these phases of learning in your
work-
place? Which would sell, and at what point would
management—or
potential trainees—balk? The likelihood of "outgrowing the
organization"
increases with the "reach" of the learning experiences. If you
manage
human resources at any level, or are in a position to recommend
formalized workplace learning, it is important to recognize
these
substantive differences. Effective advocacy for workplace
learning may
demand that you introduce training and development in a way
that
maximizes learning opportunities while minimizing the chances
for
managerial resistance.
In-Site: The Pushmi-Pullyu
Remember the Pushmi-Pullyu, the fictional two-headed animal
in the
film Dr. Dolittle? The creature was forever being pulled in two
directions
at once. As you examine motivation and its role in workplace
performance, you may feel that motivational ideas can be
pulling or
pushing people in contradictory directions. It's wise to
recognize common
elements across motivation's seemingly disparate theories.
By definition, motivation is a "trigger or reason to act." Action
can be on
the part of an individual, group, or organization or a
combination. In each
48. case, several factors likely operate in concert to create the
motivational
mindset.
In the workplace a chief motivational factor is "prior
experience." Largely
positive experiences may indeed create happier people than
negative
experiences do, but another element comes into play—the
environment of
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-25
each specific workplace. Work environments may change
dramatically
from one job to another, and the groundwork for happiness can
be
undermined or eroded.
Whether positive or negative, prior experience and environment
together
create "expectations" or the assumption that similar situations
will foster
similar results. Such expectations can cause trouble. Consider
Individual
X who is in a senior creative job in an advertising agency. As
an industry,
advertising agencies are known for the relative behavioral
freedoms they
grant their employees in exchange for tolerating stressful client-
driven
pressures and wildly inconsistent workloads. Suppose that same
individual accepts a position of parallel responsibility in a
49. corporate
marketing department. The responsibilities may be equivalent,
but the
work environment has shifted from "freewheeling agency" to
"uptight
corporation." How much of that individual's motivational
impetus just
disappeared? Can he or she switch attitudinal gears, and, if so,
under
what conditions?
As you ponder motivational variables, please consider these
alternatives:
avoiding
action
invisibility
ugh capture of power/authority, as
opposed to diffusion of power/authority
succeeding
through the efforts of others.
In-Site: Give Me Money, That's What I Want (Not?)
Compensation is inevitably linked to motivation. If you recall
our earlier
examination of the eras of enterprise, then certainly the sales
era
represented "motivation by compensation" at its maximum.
Successful
50. salespeople made their money via quota-driven commissions,
and it was
presumed that money was what they wanted. Period.
The punctuation is changing. It would be absurd to think that
money
never matters to any work force, but compensation as a strategy
is
moving well beyond money alone. First, "money" can be a
larger concept
than cash. Profit-sharing, employer contributions to tax-
sheltered
investments, employer payment of health insurance premiums,
and the
like all represent either cash-in-kind or expense-offloading,
thereby
wedding compensation to other benefits. Second, regardless of
the
compensation strategy selected, it must make sense with the
risks and
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-26
responsibilities undertaken by employees, or it will not be seen
as a
reward.
Consider the following real example. In the mid-1980s a leading
snack
food company reorganized its sales force away from
geographical
territories to type-of-reseller. The change was rational and
reflected
51. differences in need between type of reseller and location of
reseller. The
new territories distinguished between traditional supermarkets,
deep
discount/hypermarkets, convenience stores, and mom-and-pop
independents. Salespeople were asked to change their selling
strategy at
the same time, moving away from order taking and quota
fulfillment to a
more consultative role, assisting customers with displays and
other
promotional tactics.
This double change required considerable risk taking.
Employees lost
many of their best-known customers, with whom they had
established
relations, and had to replace them using newly learned
strategies and
tactics. To complicate matters, the consultative approach to
selling was
expected to take longer, resulting in a greater time gap between
initial
sales call and closed sale.
The company's response to the increased risk was to change the
sales
force's compensation—the wrong way. Almost all commissions
were
eliminated, leaving an uncompetitive base salary, insufficient to
support
many people, and tearing out a well-ingrained motivational
component
that might have encouraged risk taking. The result was
demotivational,
triggering massive turnover and poor morale among survivors
52. for at least
two years after the sales reorganization took place.
Written Assignment 6
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Total Compensation System
After having studied chapter 10, explain how an organization's
total
compensation system can help the organization be effective or
prevent
it from being effective.
Submit by Sunday of Week 6 _____ according to the
instructions in the
Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-27
Unit 3.3 ________
Focal Points
focus on compensating the work force:
benefits
53. and services.
establishing formats and practices, (3) rating and measuring,
and (4)
providing feedback.
Study Assignment
Schuler and Werner, chapter 12.
Benefiting?"
page 471 (read only).
In-Site: Goodies
Historically, employee benefits have been perceived by
employers as an
"extra," a pot sweetener whose underlying strategy may be
defensive—to
offset employee turnover or undercut demands for
unionization—or
offensive—to beat out the competition. At the same time,
employees and
prospects alike have often seen them from a "shopper's" vantage
point,
comparing them to judge one employer against another.
As we've moved from an assembly line to an entrepreneurial
mindset,
however, many of the underlying reasons and assumptions about
creating benefits have shifted as employee characteristics and
expecta-
tions have changed. Moreover, the notion of "services" to
54. employees is a
newer and less comfortable concept than that of "benefits,"
since it
upends traditional perceptions of who is working for whom.
Examples of
services include on-site day care for employees' children,
assistance with
health care for elderly parents dependent on employees, and
access to
educational or travel opportunities. These services broaden the
notion of
"benefits" from those targeting individuals to those supporting
individ-
uals as parts of families and communities.
Despite best intentions, however, benefits and services can be
ill-
conceived and poorly implemented. What is their status in your
work-
place? Given overall organizational goals and the workplace's
competi-
tive position in its industry or sector, do the benefits and
services make
sense? If you had the chance to design them anew, what would
your
choices be?
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-28
Written Assignment 7
55. For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in the
"Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Benefits
In this assignment, look at the number and type of benefits
currently being
offered by employers. Limit your research to benefits that are
provided
voluntarily by employers, such as health care, retirement
savings plans,
child care facilities, and coverage for domestic partners. You
may include
the benefits that your own workplace offers.
In your paper, discuss the advantages and disadvantages of
providing a
broad range of benefits and services versus adopting a
minimalist
approach. Discuss which approach you favor and explain why.
Be sure to
support your ideas with research.
Submit by Sunday of Week 8 _____ according to the
instructions in the Student
Handbook section of the Course Manual.
Unit 3.4 ________
Focal Point
56. studying the
use of performance-based compensation to enhance motivation.
Study Assignment
rner, chapter 9.
section of
this syllabus that relates to chapter 9 in your textbook.
-Degree
Appraisals," page 352 (read only).
ackson, Schuler and Werner, chapter 11.
section of
this syllabus that relates to chapter 11 in your textbook.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-29
In-Site: One Size Doesn't Fit All
Changes in work force characteristics and responsibilities
suggest that
individuals need to be evaluated on a wide variety of work-
related
activities, not all of which are easily observed or quantified.
Such skills as
"the ability to think strategically and solve problems creatively"
57. are more
difficult to pinpoint than visible action. To complicate matters,
evaluation
is now extending into group work, meaning that the dynamics of
interpersonal relations at the group level must be analyzed and
assessed.
New ways of doing business—through strategic partnerships,
alliances,
and joint ventures—may even cause evaluators to look beyond
their own
organizations to determine the effectiveness of collaborative
efforts.
Just as products and services are no longer developed for a mass
market
of mirror-image consumers, so performance evaluation must
become
more specific and goal-directed to be effective. Cookie-cutter
approaches
are unlikely to provide meaningful information or encourage
employees
to correct performance problems. As you investigate your
workplace's
methods of performance evaluation, please consider:
—the content of activities, the style
or method
in which they are conducted, or both?
and is he or she in a position to
be
objective?
organizational
goals, or at odds with them?
58. beforehand?
ough to analyze and assess
all
parties to the work?
both?
as a
reasonable time frame for corrective action?
In-Site: Just Rewards
"I love working in my underwear!"
I heard this exclamation some time ago at a trade association
function,
during a conversation about home-based businesses. The
business owner
was extolling the virtues of a home office, defending himself
against a
colleague who was making jokes about working at home. The
implication
was that there were rewards to performance in an atypical
setting.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-30
Today, rewards aren't limited to change of venue. Employees of
59. large,
well-established enterprises with multiple sites may have the
opportunity
to telecommute—submitting work electronically—or engage in
flexible
schedules.
Having some percentage of the work force away is nothing new,
as sales-
people have frequently spent much of their time on the road.
What is
novel is the variety and volume of personnel who now have the
option of
working out of the office. What might this mean for the
workplace as a
whole? Would it create perceived preferential treatment, thus
creating a
new conflict? Or might it relieve pressure on resources, thus
resolving an
old conflict?
Consider the case of Sun Microsystems. This reseller of high-
end com-
puter workstations has grown from an entrepreneurial start-up
to a series
of five companies underneath a holding corporation, with more
than
30,000 employees in fifty countries. In the past few years, it has
changed
from fairly traditional processes for directing, communicating
with, and
motivating personnel to a widely scattered, virtual environment
in which
salespeople rarely see sales managers, product developers
announce
updates via internal, access-protected Web sites, and many of
60. the old
parameters for judging work—being "on the job physically"—
are gone.
Instead, people have been awarded a much greater degree of
trust,
allowing them more freedom to plan and implement work at the
same
time that external pressures are increasing.
Sun's changes, which really represent delegation and
empowerment, can
be the foundation for a partnership between managers and those
whom
they manage.
Written Assignment 8
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in the
"Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Human Performance
Select one (1) performance management problem you have
experienced as a
manager or nonmanager, and write a fictional proposal to solve
it, using
and defending one (1) performance management strategy.
Submit by Sunday of Week 9 _____ according to the
instructions in the Student
Handbook section of the Course Manual.
61. Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-31
Unit 3.5 ________
Focal Point
safety and
health.
p
concept
home.
Study Assignment
Pay close attention to the paragraphs about UPS on page 507
and
Union's Involvement Enhances Competitiveness on page 509."
section of
this syllabus that relates to chapter 14 in your textbook.
62. In-Site: Squeaky Wheels
"The squeaky wheel gets the grease." This old axiom suggests
that overt
complainers get the most notice and the greatest number of
"fixes." It also
implies that there is conflict somewhere in the workplace, or the
wheels
would not need to squeak to get attention. Efforts are increasing
to avoid
conflict before it becomes overt, since conflict represents one of
the largest
health-related concerns in the contemporary workplace.
There are several phases of conflict in organizations. The
earliest, and
most difficult to detect, is the preliminary stage, during which
problems
may be generated but hide under cover. They may be isolated as
well,
involving very few people or organizational components.
"Trouble
bubbling under the surface" is a common description, and
spotting the
early signs may take individuals experienced in observing
covert,
nonverbal behaviors.
Like the flu, unresolved early problems can spread across the
organiza-
tion and rise toward the surface, taking conflicts to the next
stage. This is
the point at which negative behaviors can be seen, but their full
impact
63. Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-32
may still be unclear. A frequent reaction is that "it's just
temporary, ignore
it, don't cater to it, and it will go away."
It rarely does. By the third stage, unresolved problems can burst
into
overt conflict that is far broader and deeper than the initial
problems ever
suggested. Waiting until this stage to effect repairs is extremely
risky and
costly to the organization as a whole. Therefore, it's wise to
remember
what typically creates conflicts in the workplace, so that the
wheels are
caught at first squeak. Key causes of organizational conflict
include:
-term versus long-term goals
ce or internal
diversity
-office practices versus outpost practices
64. What do these mean in real terms? "Policy versus practice"
conflicts occur
when there is a significant difference between what the
organization
states formally and what it actually does. "Short-term versus
long-term
goals" can clash if and when the short-term needs for resources,
and
pressures for profit, actually impede longer-term growth and its
respec-
tive demands. "Allocation of resources" commonly creates
conflict among
individuals and groups because access to resources represents
power and
preference within any system. "Organizational uniformity
versus external
or internal diversity" is an emerging source of conflict. As
organizations
decentralize and diffuse their operations, and markets and the
work force
both become increasingly diverse, the forces of uniformity
needed to
maintain consistency can butt heads with the elements of
diversity
needed to establish flexibility.
The causes we've just listed tend to be organization wide.
However, two
other conflict triggers particularly affect individuals and
groups.
"Responsibility versus authority" is an old one and refers to the
collision
that occurs when an individual or group is held responsible for a
process
without having the authority to make decisions about that same
65. process.
A traditional example is being held accountable for profit and
loss of a
specific department or division without having authority over
the
budget.
A much newer entrant is "risk taking versus risk aversion."
Because we
are in an unstable, change-driven competitive environment, risk
taking
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-33
has become a necessity. Many members of the work force,
however, did
not gain their experience in such an environment, and may be
averse to
taking risks. If organizational goals demand risk taking and the
work
force doesn't comply, or the work force perceives a lack of
rewards for
taking risks, then there can be something even worse than
conflict—a
vacuum of inaction. Applying grease to keep the organizational
wheels
conflict-resistant is most difficult when we deal with embedded
attitudes
and expectations.
In-Site: Have I Got a Deal for You!
Labor-management relations represent an evolutionary process,
66. moving
from one of confrontation to one of collaboration. Or is that
revolutionary, representing drastic rather than incremental
change?
Let's consider the catch phrase, "Have I got a deal for you!"
Traditionally,
a deal from management to labor had the goal of ending current
or
impending conflict. The statement implied that labor would be
provided
something irresistible and difficult to turn down. Such a tactic
sounds
easy, but it wasn't then and isn't now. Even in a more
cooperative
environment, what if the wrong deal is offered and is met with a
yawn?
How does one identify and qualify what the work force will find
irresistible in any given situation?
Think about your current or recent workplace. Remembering
your
readings and this week's previous In-Site (about conflict), what
kind of
deals would appeal? Are they tangible or intangible, driven by
benefits or
not? Are they grounded in rewards or security? Current or
future
compensation? What if the basis for offering an attractive deal
suddenly
disappears?
Remember that much of the "future fulfillment" inherent in
long-term
deals is gone. As organizations flatten, it is becoming
increasingly
67. difficult to promise anyone a career ladder up to the executive
suite—and
climbing the ladder is an ingrained image of success. As your
organization engages in formal or informal negotiation with
employees,
unionized or not, a preliminary understanding of "what
constitutes a
deal" is absolutely essential.
Written Assignment 9
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
Staying Healthy
Conduct primary or secondary research, and write a summative
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-34
report on strategies that your industry or sector uses to protect
the
safety and health of its work force.
Submit by Sunday of Week 10 _____ according to the
instructions in the
Student Handbook section of the Course Manual.
68. MODULE FOUR: HUMAN RESOURCES
AS A PROFESSION
Unit 4 ________
Focal Point
competencies,
code of ethics, certifications, job specifications, and earnings.
Study Assignment
–28.
-of-Text Case: "The
Lincoln
Electric Company," pages 560-575 (read only).
In-Site: Strategic Thinking, Future Tense
When change and risk are constant, it is difficult enough to
think ahead in
the short term—the next couple of calendar or fiscal years.
What about
the long-term future? How do we plan for that, and where do
human
resources fit in? Is there a middle ground between expecting
complete
stability at one end (unrealistic) and no definable or measurable
future at
the other (unmanageable)?
For human resources professionals, focusing on "performance"
69. can find
that middle ground. Remember that any kind of planning
instinctively
depends on prior experience, and ongoing change makes such
experience
unreliable. Strategic thinking, however, is targeted toward the
big
picture, focusing on the broad competitive and market positions
the
organization wants to have. Once strategies are defined, tactical
thinking
follows, at which point "actions" become imperative. Actions
demand
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-35
maximum use of every resource, including human. At the point
that
strategy flows into tactics, we can and should distinguish
between the
experiences, capabilities, and skills we can rely on, and those
we can't.
"Can't" represents performance gaps that new resources must
fill, if the
strategic goals are to be met.
If performance gap identification and closure seem abstract as
the means
to thinking in the future tense, then try using the following
questionnaire
to examine your own workplace's situation. Consider turning the
questionnaire into a worksheet.
70. 1. How is human performance currently defined?
2. Does that definition reflect organizational strategies and
goals? If yes,
how? If no, why not?
3. What short-term performance gaps can you describe as
knowledge-
based? As skill-based?
4. What is likely to drive change in your organization in the
next 3–5
years? In the next decade?
5. How might the current performance gaps interact with the 3–
5 year
change? With the decade-long change?
6. What do you perceive as long-term performance gaps?
7. How can you relate long-term organizational strategies and
goals to
long-term performance gap closure, so that they complement
each
other?
Written Assignment 10
For assignment purpose and guidelines, see "Written
Assignments" in
the "Course Essentials" section of the syllabus.
HR Competencies
71. In this assignment, explain whether you agree with the list of
five
major competencies given on page 20 of the Jackson, Schuler
and Werner
text. In addition, include whether you agree with the weighting
assigned each competency in terms of its impact on business
performance.
If you agree, explain why. If you do not agree, state why you do
not
and give the competencies you feel are needed for human
resources
staff to be effective. Give reasons for your choices. Be sure to
support
your ideas with research.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-36
Submit by Sunday of Week 11 _____
Final Project: Case Analysis
You are required at the end of the semester to submit a case ana
lysis that
focuses on Southwest Airlines. This case analysis will be a vehi
72. cle
through which you can demonstrate your ability to apply human
resources management concepts in determining the role of such
concepts
to an actual organization’s practices.
You will build your case analysis by answering a series of quest
ions listed
below. These questions are associated with specific chapters in
your
textbook and in order to answer them properly you will need to
demonstrate your mastery of the material covered in those chapt
ers.
The starting point for your case analysis is your textbook, which
contains
information about Southwest Airlines on pages 544‐559. The fi
rst thing
you should do is to read this information and become familiar w
ith it.
As you progress through the course you should review the quest
ions
below and begin to formulate your answers as you read the asso
73. ciated
chapters in your textbook.
The questions below are designed for you to demonstrate an
understanding of key human resources management concepts as
they
pertain to Southwest Airlines. For each of your responses to the
se
questions, be sure to link specifics in the Southwest Airlines cas
e to
human resources management concepts from the text.
There is no specific length that your case analysis should be, bu
t you
should aim to answer each question as thoroughly as possible.
For
information on how your work will be judged see the “Assessme
nt
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-37
Guidelines for Southwest Airlines Case Analysis”, below. Use t
he criteria
74. listed there as a guide when working on your case analysis.
Your case analysis should contain the following:
Title page with your name, date, course code, and name of your
mentor.
to your case analysis.
The main body of your analysis (i.e. your answers to the questio
ns
below).
(your answer to the last question below).
Southwest Airlines Case Analysis Questions
Your answers to the following questions will form the main bod
y of your
case analysis. Formulate your answers after reading the textboo
k
chapters listed. You should identify how the concepts and pract
ices in
the relevant chapters link to the story of Southwest Airlines. Se
arch for
connections, examples and research mentioned in the textbook a
s likely
75. explanations for what has occurred at Southwest Airlines.
Answer after studying textbook chapter 8
How were training and development of strategic importance to
Southwest Airlines? What actions taken by Southwest Airlines
support
your response?
Answer after studying textbook chapter 9
Using Expectancy Theory, explain how the management practic
es at
Southwest Airlines help motivate the company’s employees to h
igh levels
of performance.
Answer after studying textbook chapters 10 and 11
What particular aspects of how Southwest Airlines compensates
and
rewards its employees likely are connected to the company’s lo
w
76. turnover rate? Be specific.
Southwest Airlines has been described as having a unique cultur
e. What
specific aspects of its culture make it unique? How have these
aspects
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-38
played a significant part in Southwest Airlines’ effectiveness as
an
organization?
Answer after studying textbook chapter 14
In the Southwest Airlines Integrative Case’s Appendix SA.3 on
p. 558, Joe
Harris, Vice President of Labor and Employee Relations, descri
bes the
cooperative relationship Southwest Airlines has had with labor
unions.
He says that Southwest’s greatest challenge ahead is keeping co
sts under
control. What other future challenges might there be for South
77. west Air
related to labor relations? Explain with supporting material fro
m
Chapter 14 or any other sources you choose to use. Please cite a
ny outside
references you use.
Answer after completing the questions above
What recommendations would you make to Southwest Airlines t
o help
deal with future labor union challenges?
Assessment Guidelines for Southwest Airlines Case Analysis
Your case analysis will be judged according to the following cri
teria.
Keep these points in mind when putting together your case anal
ysis
and use them as a guide for your work.
78. Excellent to Exemplary
Your analysis is thorough and reflects critical thinking. It exce
eds the
parameters of the questions by showing subtle insights into sign
ificant
points in the case. Your analysis strongly links course concepts
to events
and situations in the case. Thoughts are expressed clearly and l
ogically,
with few if any, errors in grammar and writing mechanics. Resp
onses to
the case questions venture beyond the case description to identif
y
relevant current information on Southwest Airlines that pertain t
o human
resources management. References for these additional points a
re
reputable sources and properly cited.
Syllabus—Assignment Schedule
S-39
79. Satisfactory to Very Good
Your analysis is thorough. It answers the questions sufficiently
and
demonstrates an acceptable understanding of related course con
cepts.
Thoughts are expressed clearly and logically, demonstrating a c
ollege‐
level awareness of grammar and writing mechanics. Analytical s
kills are
applied. If any outside references are used they are from reputab
le
sources, suitably cited.
Marginally Acceptable to Satisfactory
Your analysis is at times incomplete, or fails to demonstrate an
understanding of how course concepts relate to information in t
he case. It
shows a lack of analytical skills. Thoughts throughout are expre
ssed
awkwardly and illogically. Your work contains errors in gramm
ar and
80. writing mechanics. There are no attempts to include current inf
ormation
on Southwest Airlines.
Minimal Pass to Marginally Acceptable
Your analysis is incomplete and fails to demonstrate an understa
nding of
course concepts. It fails to demonstrate analytical skills. Thou
ghts
throughout are expressed awkwardly and illogically. Errors in g
rammar
and writing mechanics distract the reader.
Fail
Your analysis is incomplete. Responses to questions are brief an
d without
an understanding of the case and related course concepts. The re
sponses
lack the use of analytical skills. Thoughts are expressed awkwar
dly and
illogically. Many errors in grammar and writing mechanics dist
ract the
81. reader. Insufficient links between the case and the course reflect
a lack of
effort. .
Syllabus—Appendix A
S-40
Appendix A
Organizational Structure/Process
Structure: Process:
framework for action means for action
Structure and process drive:
82. Syllabus—Appendix B
S-41
Appendix B
Human Capabilities/Capacities
Capability: here-and-now skills and knowledge
Capacity: the willingness to learn new things
Motivation: the incentive or reason to act
Capability+ Capacity+ Positive Motivation
=Maximum Performance
Syllabus—Appendix C
S-42
83. Appendix C
Theories of Motivation
Parallels among Popular Theories of Motivation
There are many parallels among the popular theories of Maslow
(original
hierarchical theory and revised dual-level theory), Alderfer,
Herzberg,
and McGregor. The needs at the top of the model all lead
toward
approach behaviors, while those on the bottom propel people
toward
avoidance behaviors if not adequately obtained. Those in the
middle
(Maslow's belonging and Alderfer's relatedness) are potentially
unstable
and can direct behavior in either direction, depending on the
circumstance.
Maslow
(hierarchy)
Maslow
(revised)
Alderfer Herzberg McGregor
85. needs
Hygiene factors
(dissatisfiers)
Theory
X
Source: Curtis W. Cook, Phillip L. Hunsaker, and Robert E.
Coffey, Management
and Organizational Behavior, 2d ed. (Boston: Irwin/McGraw
Hill, 1997), exhibit 6-
4, p. 194. Reproduced with permission of The McGraw-Hill
Companies.
Approach
Behaviors
Avoidance
Behaviors
86. Spreadsheet Modeling
& Decision Analysis
A Practical Introduction to Management Science
5th edition
Cliff T. Ragsdale
Modeling and Solving LP Problems in a Spreadsheet
Chapter 3
IntroductionSolving LP problems graphically is only possible
when there are two decision variablesFew real-world LP have
only two decision variablesFortunately, we can now use
spreadsheets to solve LP problems
Spreadsheet SolversThe company that makes the Solver in
Excel, Lotus 1-2-3, and Quattro Pro is Frontline Systems, Inc.
Check out their web site:
http://www.solver.comOther packages for solving MP problems:
AMPLLINDO
CPLEXMPSX
The Steps in Implementing an LP Model in a Spreadsheet
87. 1.Organize the data for the model on the spreadsheet.
2.Reserve separate cells in the spreadsheet for each decision
variable in the model.
3.Create a formula in a cell in the spreadsheet that corresponds
to the objective function.
4.For each constraint, create a formula in a separate cell in the
spreadsheet that corresponds to the left-hand side (LHS) of the
constraint.
Let’s Implement a Model for the
Blue Ridge Hot Tubs Example...
MAX: 350X1 + 300X2} profit
S.T.:1X1 + 1X2 <= 200} pumps
9X1 + 6X2 <= 1566} labor
12X1 + 16X2 <= 2880} tubing
X1, X2 >= 0} nonnegativity
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-1.xls
How Solver Views the ModelTarget cell - the cell in the
spreadsheet that represents the objective functionChanging cells
- the cells in the spreadsheet representing the decision
variablesConstraint cells - the cells in the spreadsheet
representing the LHS formulas on the constraints
Let’s go back to Excel and see how Solver works...
88. Goals For Spreadsheet DesignCommunication - A spreadsheet's
primary business purpose is communicating information to
managers. Reliability - The output a spreadsheet generates
should be correct and consistent.Auditability - A manager
should be able to retrace the steps followed to generate the
different outputs from the model in order to understand and
verify results.Modifiability - A well-designed spreadsheet
should be easy to change or enhance in order to meet dynamic
user requirements.
Spreadsheet Design Guidelines - IOrganize the data, then build
the model around the data.Do not embed numeric constants in
formulas.Things which are logically related should be
physically related.Use formulas that can be copied.Column/rows
totals should be close to the columns/rows being totaled.
Spreadsheet Design Guidelines - IIThe English-reading eye
scans left to right, top to bottom.Use color, shading, borders
and protection to distinguish changeable parameters from other
model elements.Use text boxes and cell notes to document
various elements of the model.
Make vs. Buy Decisions:
The Electro-Poly CorporationElectro-Poly is a leading maker of
slip-rings.A $750,000 order has just been received. The
company has 10,000 hours of wiring capacity and 5,000 hours
89. of harnessing capacity.
Model 1 Model 2Model 3
Number ordered3,0002,000900
Hours of wiring/unit21.53
Hours of harnessing/unit121
Cost to Make$50$83$130
Cost to Buy$61$97$145
Defining the Decision Variables
M1 = Number of model 1 slip rings to make in-house
M2 = Number of model 2 slip rings to make in-house
M3 = Number of model 3 slip rings to make in-house
B1 = Number of model 1 slip rings to buy from competitor
B2 = Number of model 2 slip rings to buy from competitor
B3 = Number of model 3 slip rings to buy from competitor
Defining the Objective Function
Minimize the total cost of filling the order.
MIN:50M1+ 83M2+ 130M3+ 61B1+ 97B2+ 145B3
Defining the ConstraintsDemand Constraints
M1 + B1 = 3,000} model 1
M2 + B2 = 2,000} model 2
M3 + B3 = 900} model 3Resource Constraints
2M1 + 1.5M2 + 3M3 <= 10,000 } wiring
1M1 + 2.0M2 + 1M3 <= 5,000 } harnessingNonnegativity
Conditions
M1, M2, M3, B1, B2, B3 >= 0
90. Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-17.xls
An Investment Problem:
Retirement Planning Services, Inc.A client wishes to invest
$750,000 in the following bonds.
Years to
CompanyReturn MaturityRating
Acme Chemical8.65%111-Excellent
DynaStar9.50%103-Good
Eagle Vision10.00%64-Fair
Micro Modeling8.75%101-Excellent
OptiPro9.25%73-Good
Sabre Systems9.00%132-Very Good
Investment RestrictionsNo more than 25% can be invested in
any single company.At least 50% should be invested in long-
term bonds (maturing in 10+ years).No more than 35% can be
invested in DynaStar, Eagle Vision, and OptiPro.
*
91. Defining the Decision Variables
X1 = amount of money to invest in Acme Chemical
X2 = amount of money to invest in DynaStar
X3 = amount of money to invest in Eagle Vision
X4 = amount of money to invest in MicroModeling
X5 = amount of money to invest in OptiPro
X6 = amount of money to invest in Sabre Systems
Defining the Objective Function
Maximize the total
annual investment return:
MAX: .0865X1+ .095X2+ .10X3+ .0875X4+ .0925X5+ .09X6
Defining the ConstraintsTotal amount is invested
X1 + X2 + X3 + X4 + X5 + X6 = 750,000 No more than 25% in
any one investment
Xi <= 187,500, for all i 50% long term investment restriction.
X1 + X2 + X4 + X6 >= 375,00035% Restriction on DynaStar,
Eagle Vision, and OptiPro.
X2 + X3 + X5 <= 262,500Nonnegativity conditions
Xi >= 0 for all i
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-20.xls
A Transportation Problem: Tropicsun
93. Processing
Plants
21
50
40
35
30
22
55
25
20
Defining the Decision Variables
Xij = # of bushels shipped from node i to node j
Specifically, the nine decision variables are:
X14 = # of bushels shipped from Mt. Dora (node 1) to Ocala
(node 4)
X15 = # of bushels shipped from Mt. Dora (node 1) to Orlando
(node 5)
X16 = # of bushels shipped from Mt. Dora (node 1) to Leesburg
(node 6)
X24 = # of bushels shipped from Eustis (node 2) to Ocala (node
4)
X25 = # of bushels shipped from Eustis (node 2) to Orlando
(node 5)
X26 = # of bushels shipped from Eustis (node 2) to Leesburg
(node 6)
X34 = # of bushels shipped from Clermont (node 3) to Ocala
(node 4)
X35 = # of bushels shipped from Clermont (node 3) to Orlando
(node 5)
X36 = # of bushels shipped from Clermont (node 3) to Leesburg
94. (node 6)
Defining the Objective Function
Minimize the total number of bushel-miles.
MIN:21X14 + 50X15 + 40X16 +
35X24 + 30X25 + 22X26 +
55X34 + 20X35 + 25X36
Defining the ConstraintsCapacity constraints
X14 + X24 + X34 <= 200,000} Ocala
X15 + X25 + X35 <= 600,000} Orlando
X16 + X26 + X36 <= 225,000} LeesburgSupply constraints
X14 + X15 + X16 = 275,000} Mt. Dora
X24 + X25 + X26 = 400,000} Eustis
X34 + X35 + X36 = 300,000} ClermontNonnegativity
conditions
Xij >= 0 for all i and j
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-24.xls
A Blending Problem:
The Agri-Pro CompanyAgri-Pro has received an order for 8,000
pounds of chicken feed to be mixed from the following
feeds.The order must contain at least 20% corn, 15% grain, and
15% minerals.
NutrientFeed 1Feed 2 Feed 3Feed 4
95. Corn30%5%20%10%
Grain10%3%15%10%
Minerals20%20%20%30%
Cost per pound$0.25$0.30$0.32$0.15
Percent of Nutrient in
Defining the Decision Variables
X1 = pounds of feed 1 to use in the mix
X2 = pounds of feed 2 to use in the mix
X3 = pounds of feed 3 to use in the mix
X4 = pounds of feed 4 to use in the mix
Defining the Objective Function
Minimize the total cost of filling the order.
MIN: 0.25X1 + 0.30X2 + 0.32X3 + 0.15X4
Defining the ConstraintsProduce 8,000 pounds of feed
X1 + X2 + X3 + X4 = 8,000Mix consists of at least 20% corn
(0.3X1 + 0.5X2 + 0.2X3 + 0.1X4)/8000 >= 0.2Mix consists of
at least 15% grain
(0.1X1 + 0.3X2 + 0.15X3 + 0.1X4)/8000 >= 0.15Mix consists of
at least 15% minerals
(0.2X1 + 0.2X2 + 0.2X3 + 0.3X4)/8000 >= 0.15Nonnegativity
conditions
X1, X2, X3, X4 >= 0
A Comment About ScalingNotice the coefficient for X2 in the
96. ‘corn’ constraint is 0.05/8000 = 0.00000625As Solver runs,
intermediate calculations are made that make coefficients larger
or smaller.Storage problems may force the computer to use
approximations of the actual numbers.Such ‘scaling’ problems
sometimes prevents Solver from being able to solve the problem
accurately.Most problems can be formulated in a way to
minimize scaling errors...
Re-Defining the Decision Variables
X1 = thousands of pounds of feed 1 to use in the mix
X2 = thousands of pounds of feed 2 to use in the mix
X3 = thousands of pounds of feed 3 to use in the mix
X4 = thousands of pounds of feed 4 to use in the mix
Re-Defining the
Objective Function
Minimize the total cost of filling the order.
MIN: 250X1 + 300X2 + 320X3 + 150X4
Re-Defining the ConstraintsProduce 8,000 pounds of feed
X1 + X2 + X3 + X4 = 8Mix consists of at least 20% corn
(0.3X1 + 0.5X2 + 0.2X3 + 0.1X4)/8 >= 0.2Mix consists of at
least 15% grain
(0.1X1 + 0.3X2 + 0.15X3 + 0.1X4)/8 >= 0.15Mix consists of at
least 15% minerals
(0.2X1 + 0.2X2 + 0.2X3 + 0.3X4)/8 >= 0.15Nonnegativity
conditions
X1, X2, X3, X4 >= 0
97. Scaling: Before and AfterBefore:
Largest constraint coefficient was 8,000
Smallest constraint coefficient was
0.05/8 = 0.00000625.After:
Largest constraint coefficient is 8
Smallest constraint coefficient is
0.05/8 = 0.00625.The problem is now more evenly scaled!
The Assume Linear Model OptionThe Solver Options dialog box
has an option labeled “Assume Linear Model”. This option
makes Solver perform some tests to verify that your model is in
fact linear. These test are not 100% accurate & may fail as a
result of a poorly scaled model.If Solver tells you a model isn’t
linear when you know it is, try solving it again. If that doesn’t
work, try re-scaling your model.
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-28.xls
A Production Planning Problem:
The Upton CorporationUpton is planning the production of their
heavy-duty air compressors for the next 6 months.
Beginning inventory = 2,750 units
Safety stock = 1,500 units
Unit carrying cost = 1.5% of unit production cost
Maximum warehouse capacity = 6,000 units
12 3456
98. Unit Production Cost$240$250$265$285$280$260
Units Demanded1,0004,5006,0005,5003,5004,000
Maximum Production4,0003,5004,0004,5004,0003,500
Minimum Production2,0001,7502,0002,2502,0001,750
Month
Defining the Decision Variables
Pi = number of units to produce in month i, i=1 to 6
Bi = beginning inventory month i, i=1 to 6
Defining the Objective Function
Minimize the total cost production
& inventory costs.
MIN:240P1+250P2+265P3+285P4+280P5+260P6
+ 3.6(B1+B2)/2 + 3.75(B2+B3)/2 + 3.98(B3+B4)/2
+ 4.28(B4+B5)/2 + 4.20(B5+ B6)/2 + 3.9(B6+B7)/2
Note: The beginning inventory in any month is the same as the
ending inventory in the previous month.
Defining the Constraints - IProduction levels
2,000 <= P1 <= 4,000 } month 1
1,750 <= P2 <= 3,500 } month 2
2,000 <= P3 <= 4,000 } month 3
2,250 <= P4 <= 4,500 } month 4
2,000 <= P5 <= 4,000 } month 5
1,750 <= P6 <= 3,500 } month 6
99. Defining the Constraints - IIEnding Inventory (EI = BI + P - D)
1,500 < B1 + P1 - 1,000 < 6,000 } month 1
1,500 < B2 + P2 - 4,500 < 6,000 } month 2
1,500 < B3 + P3 - 6,000 < 6,000 } month 3
1,500 < B4 + P4 - 5,500 < 6,000 } month 4
1,500 < B5 + P5 - 3,500 < 6,000 } month 5
1,500 < B6 + P6 - 4,000 < 6,000 } month 6
Defining the Constraints - IIIBeginning Balances
B1 = 2750
B2 = B1 + P1 - 1,000
B3 = B2 + P2 - 4,500
B4 = B3 + P3 - 6,000
B5 = B4 + P4 - 5,500
B6 = B5 + P5 - 3,500
B7 = B6 + P6 - 4,000
Notice that the Bi can be computed directly from the Pi.
Therefore, only the Pi need to be identified as changing cells.
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-31.xls
A Multi-Period Cash Flow Problem:
The Taco-Viva Sinking Fund - ITaco-Viva needs a sinking fund
to pay $800,000 in building costs for a new restaurant in the
next 6 months. Payments of $250,000 are due at the end of
months 2 and 4, and a final payment of $300,000 is due at the
100. end of month 6.The following investments may be used.
InvestmentAvailable in MonthMonths to MaturityYield at
Maturity
A1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 611.8%
B1, 3, 523.5%
C1, 435.8%
D1611.0%
Summary of Possible Cash Flows
Investment1234567
A1-11.018
B1-1<_____>1.035
C1-1 <_____><_____> 1.058
D1-1 <_____> <_____> <_____> <_____> <_____> 1.11
A2-11.018
A3-11.018
B3-1 <_____> 1.035
A4-11.018
C4-1 <_____> <_____> 1.058
A5-11.018
B5-1 <_____> 1.035
A6-11.018
Req’d Payments $0$0$250$0$250$0$300
(in $1,000s)
Cash Inflow/Outflow at the Beginning of Month
Defining the Decision Variables
Ai = amount (in $1,000s) placed in investment A at the
101. beginning of month i=1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Bi = amount (in $1,000s) placed in investment B at the
beginning of month i=1, 3, 5
Ci = amount (in $1,000s) placed in investment C at the
beginning of month i=1, 4
Di = amount (in $1,000s) placed in investment D at the
beginning of month i=1
Defining the Objective Function
Minimize the total cash invested in month 1.
MIN: A1 + B1 + C1 + D1
Defining the ConstraintsCash Flow Constraints
1.018A1 – 1A2 = 0 } month 2
1.035B1 + 1.018A2 – 1A3 – 1B3 = 250 } month 3
1.058C1 + 1.018A3 – 1A4 – 1C4 = 0 } month 4
1.035B3 + 1.018A4 – 1A5 – 1B5 = 250 } month 5
1.018A5 –1A6 = 0 } month 6
1.11D1 + 1.058C4 + 1.035B5 + 1.018A6 = 300 } month
7Nonnegativity Conditions
Ai, Bi, Ci, Di >= 0, for all i
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-35.xls
Risk Management:
The Taco-Viva Sinking Fund - IIAssume the CFO has assigned
102. the following risk ratings to each investment on a scale from 1
to 10 (10 = max risk)
InvestmentRisk Rating
A1
B3
C8
D6The CFO wants the weighted average risk to not exceed 5.
Defining the ConstraintsRisk Constraints
1A1 + 3B1 + 8C1 + 6D1
< 5
A1 + B1 + C1 + D1
} month 1
1A2 + 3B1 + 8C1 + 6D1
< 5
A2 + B1 + C1 + D1
} month 2
1A3 + 3B3 + 8C1 + 6D1
< 5
A3 + B3 + C1 + D1
} month 3
1A4 + 3B3 + 8C4 + 6D1
< 5
A4 + B3 + C4 + D1
} month 4
1A5 + 3B5 + 8C4 + 6D1
< 5
A5 + B5 + C4 + D1
103. } month 5
1A6 + 3B5 + 8C4 + 6D1
< 5
A6 + B5 + C4 + D1
} month 6
An Alternate Version of the Risk ConstraintsEquivalent Risk
Constraints
-4A1 – 2B1 + 3C1 + 1D1 < 0 } month 1
-2B1 + 3C1 + 1D1 – 4A2 < 0 } month 2
3C1 + 1D1 – 4A3 – 2B3 < 0 } month 3
1D1 – 2B3 – 4A4 + 3C4 < 0 } month 4
1D1 + 3C4 – 4A5 – 2B5 < 0 } month 5
1D1 + 3C4 – 2B5 – 4A6 < 0 } month 6
Note that each coefficient is equal to the risk factor for the
investment minus 5 (the max. allowable weighted average risk).
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-38.xls
Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA):
Steak & BurgerSteak & Burger needs to evaluate the
performance (efficiency) of 12 units. Outputs for each unit (Oij)
include measures of: Profit, Customer Satisfaction, and
CleanlinessInputs for each unit (Iij) include: Labor Hours, and
Operating CostsThe “Efficiency” of unit i is defined as
follows:
104. Weighted sum of unit i’s outputs
Weighted sum of unit i’s inputs
=
Defining the Decision Variables
wj = weight assigned to output j
vj = weight assigned to input j
A separate LP is solved for each unit, allowing each unit to
select the best possible weights for itself.
Defining the Objective Function
Maximize the weighted output for unit i :
MAX:
Defining the ConstraintsEfficiency cannot exceed 100% for any
unit
Sum of weighted inputs for unit i must equal 1
Nonnegativity Conditions
wj, vj >= 0, for all j
Important Point
When using DEA, output variables should be expressed on a
105. scale where “more is better” and input variables should be
expressed on a scale where “less is better”.
Implementing the Model
See file Fig3-41.xls
Analyzing The
Solution
See file Fig3-48.xls
End of Chapter 3
*