1. Review of Condition Assessment
Technologies in Pipelines
Cliff Jones
February 23, 2012
LOOK BEFORE YOU DIG!!
2. Condition Assessment
All pipes/ pipe materials leak
All pipes can break
1 in 10 leaks will result in a break
Industry figures show you can expect to
find one leak a mile in DI or CI transmission
mains (>16”)
Condition assessment helps you proactively
manage pipelines
Control helps you reduce the cost of main
breaks
3. Control Asset Usability
60% is National
Average Usability
2 of 5 valves on average
are not usable
4. What our experience has taught us
40% of all water valves are unusable
12% of all hydrants are unusable; including
inadequate flow
11% of all valves are paved over
9% of all distribution valves are found in the
wrong position: shut & open
Spatial offsets > 30 feet
5. Control Asset Usability
“As-Designed”… three valves to control a main
“As-Is”… five ++ valves to control a main
Find the (right) valve
Access the right valve
Shut/open the right valve
6. So What?
You can only replace or repair a certain
percentage of pipe each year.
You still need to manage the system
What happens to the other 95%?
Condition Assessment and Repair of a
pipeline is typically 10-12% of the
replacement cost.
If the technology or the repair is such that
this number grows to >25% - you should
replace the line
8. Investigator™ Technology
Simplified pipeline condition
assessment technology
Designed for distribution mains
Non destructive inspection
No disruption to service
Single pass acoustic, CCTV video
and sonde mapping
In-line system increases accuracy
9. Quebec Ski Village – Saint Sauveur
Investigator™ inspection of low
pressure issues
6” and 12” metallic mains
Identified significant
tuberculation build-up on 6” line
Validated that 12” line was in
good condition
9 insertions completed with
average distance of 150 feet
Provided utility with information
to target CIP investments on
problem areas
10. Buffalo Grove, IL
8” and 20” metallic mains
Over 20 insertions
Waterous hydrants Launch tube flange option allows for:
Correction of as-built drawings
- Longer distance inspections
Pre-construction valve asset
- Larger diameter main inspections
identification (road paving) Wachs Water Services can conduct hydrant
Pipeline diameter confirmation maintenance in parallel with water main
inspections
Visual, in-line valve exercising
11. Montreal Suburb – Dollard des Ormeaux
Investigator™ inspection of
main prior to road re-paving
6”, 8”, 12” metallic lines
installed in 1960’s
5 insertions on lined and
unlined pipe
One line had substantial
sediment and we validated Tuberculation at T-joint
need for flushing program
Lined main in good condition
but tuberculation identified on
unlined T-joints
Cable insertions averaged 15 to
180 feet depending on internal
pipe conditions
Liner in good condition
12. Texas Client was concerned about low flow
conditions in pipe and wondered about
tuberculation
Photo taken of inspection
screen –
Showing magnesium mineral
deposits
13. Operator Control
Simultaneous Video and Acoustic
Clear Peak
Over Leak Site
14. Client Issue
PVC pipe, up to 12 ft deep
Correlators and leak
sounding did not work
Turned to Investigator™
Acoustic/CCTV in-line
technology
31 insertions through fire
hydrants (top insertion)
Each insertion inspected
up to 600ft of main
Pressure in pipe ranged
from 75 to 180 PSI
15. Example 1
Concern about leak
under culvert
Two leaks discovered on either side of
a T-joint at a depth of 18ft leading to
18ft the culvert. Investigator™ was able to
clearly distinguish individual leak
sounds prior to challenging
Investigator™ confirmed that there was
excavation/repair.
no leak under culvert…but…
16. Example 2
Water main installation issues identified
Visible gasket with a tear at a Significant debris in pipe despite
misaligned pipe joint. Leak identified at flushing and cleaning resulted in water
higher pressures. quality issues.
17. Example 3
Acoustic and video confirmation of leaks at two
pipe joints. Accurate leak locating with Sonde.
Sonde Mark
Leak
18. Value of video
Visual identification of installation defects at
the Point of Interest
Kink in pipe wall and poor joint connection. Joint gaskets exposed over 3 consecutive
No current leak. pipe sections. No current leak.
19. Value of Investigator™ Video
Despite “blue wash” created by LED light reflection within
PVC pipe, in-line video clearly identified:
Pipe joints
Valves (A)
B
T-joints A
Repairs
Gaskets
Wall kinks (B)
Air pockets
Debris - mud and rocks (C)
Grease at joint connections
Cloudy and clear water conditions C
20. Austin: Does a 36” BF Valve work
properly?
Watching the valve operate
from inside the pipe
23. Tuberculation and Flow
Restrictions
Early stage of tuberculation build- Early stage of tuberculation build-
up at pipe joints and lips up at pipe joints
24. Tuberculation and Flow
Restrictions
Severe flow restrictions due to late stages of tuberculation build up.
Leads to pressure loss.
26. Liner Inspection
Post liner quality inspection and verification.
Prioritization of pipelines to rehabilitate.
27. Validating Leaks with
Investigator
Tap located and confirmed not to be a leak Change of material confirmed not to be a
leak as identified by correlation
29. General Investigations
Contaminant in water main identified Records indicated that pipe segment was
(construction debris) after water lined, investigation proved otherwise.
quality complaints.
30. System Mapping
Critical for accurate uni-
directional flushing plans
and hydraulic modeling
Confirmation of as-built
drawings
Pre-construction planning
Emergency shut-down
planning
Asset mapping of PVC
pipe can only be done
from inside of pipe
32. Condition Assessment
Information
Full data report on
inspection process,
location and findings
Still photos, Video and
audio provided on CD/
DVD
Coming soon - Tuberculation
accumulation grading
33. GIS Integration
Clickable GIS pipeline
attributes
GPS coordinates of
insertion points
Electronic and acoustic
MPEG links
Confirmation of
distance inspected from
location points
36. LDS1000™ Technology
Designed for transmission mains
No disruption to service
Single pass acoustic, CCTV video and
sonde mapping/tracking
In-line system increases accuracy
Builds on in-line leak detection system
developed by WRC over 15 years
Global projects completed in US,
Canada, England, Philippines and
Australia
38. Access to Pipelines
2 inch (ID) tap
Existing Sahara chambers
Air valves
Service fittings
Gate valves
Pressure taps
39. Pipeline Inspection
Operator is in control at all
times
Operator has “eyes and ears”
in the pipe
Operator has ability to stop to
look at features
Inspection typically occurs
during implementation & pull
back
Increases inspection accuracy
and minimize false/positives
40. Advanced Sensor Head
Sensor head allows for simultaneous
acoustic, CCTV and mapping/tracking
Greater locating accuracy as system
does not rely on stationed pinging
Patented Agitator™ deployment
system uses flow of water to push
sensor in less turbulent zone around
pipe wall
Turbulent
Result is increased inspection Zone
efficiencies which reduces cost
41. Superior CCTV Image Quality
High quality CCTV image quality
Stable image due to patented
Agitator™ deployment system
No need for post processing –
see immediate results
Lighting optimized for large
diameter mains
CCTV signal quality does not
degrade due to cable limitations
42. No-Flow Process Overview
Low flow conditions or pipe crawlers can also be used to carry the LDS1000™
cable/sensor down the pipeline.
43. Key Specifications
Investigator
Pipe Material Any
Typical Pipe Diameter* 16” +
Tap Requirement 2” (ID)
Minimum Flow 0.75 ft/sec*
Maximum Flow 10 ft/sec
Maximum Pressure 240 PSI
Inspection Distance 3,200 ft
Degrees of bends >180
* LDS1000™ can operate in a wide variety of flow conditions. Operation can be
achieved in even lower flow conditions but distance and bends capabilities will change.
44. Distribution System Confidence
to Make the Right Investments
Eliminates needs for excavations
Eliminates replacement/lining of pipes that are
still in good condition
Allows for comparison of pipeline degradation
over time
Provides understanding of actual pipe
condition
Maximize aging infrastructure investments
45. Summary
Inspection of all water distribution lines 2”
to 102”+
Identify issues internally
Low cost first pass evaluation
Lines remain in service
Look Before You Dig!!