SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 55
Historical Comparative Acoustics and Prosodic Reanalysis: The Case of Tibetan Prosodic Typology: State of the Art and Future Prospects February 24-26, 2010 Berlin, German Nancy J. Caplow University of North Texas [email_address]
Methods
History
 
 
Phonological classification ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Dialect variation and classification ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Comparing monosyllabic words ‘ arrow’ mda′ ‘ horse’ rta ‘ fire’ me / myi ‘ medicine’ sman Archaic  Dialects Innovative  Dialects Nda ɕta Nda  xta ta̱  tā me  sman nyi  ʰmɛn me̱  mē
Dialects
What are archaic dialects? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Correspondence with WT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Correspondences with  WT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Correspondences with  WT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Correspondences with  WT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Note:  tonal [ ʈʰ ] + L <  WT   gr ,  dr , and  sbr cold      grang.mo  [ gra χ .'mo ]    [ ʈʰa̱ŋ.mo ]
Correspondences with  WT ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Note:  tonal [ l ] + H <  WT   rl ,  gl ,  bl, sl flute      gl ing.bu   [ χ lɛm.'bu ]    [ lɪ̄ŋ.bū ]
Characteristics of Proto-Tibetan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Geographic distribution is intriguing  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Tournadre and Dorje 2003
after Tournadre and Dorje 2003 Rebkong Amdo Balti Tokpe Gola
The similarity of the peripheral dialects ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Previous accounts of genesis of tone ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Universal physiological correlations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implications ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Summarization ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Disyllabic Non-verbs
Tone in Disyllabic Non-Verbs willow tree lcang.ma bridge zam.pa brain klad.pa Balti (West) Amdo (East) ɬtʃa χ .'ma tʃāŋ.mā Tokpe Gola (Central) xtʃaŋ.'ma zam.'pa sa̱m.pā sam.'pa xlat.'pa lɛ̄t.tā ᵊ lai.'pa nak.'po sar.'pʰa na̱k.pū sām.pā nox.' χ u sʰo.'ma black nag.po new gsar.pa
σ 2 always high  in Tokpe Gola loose, floppy flat young, young person fire arrow gun, rifle leg, foot arm, hand limbs (legs and arms) lhug.lhug leb.leb gzhon.gzhon me mda′ me. mda′ rkang.pa lag.pa rkang.lag HH LH LH L L LH HH LH HH
Tone vs. Stress in Disyllabic Non-Verbs willow tree lcang.ma bridge zam.pa brain klad.pa black nag.po new gsar.pa Balti (West) Amdo (East) ɬtʃa χ .'ma tʃāŋ.mā Tokpe Gola (Central) xtʃaŋ.'ma zam.'pa sa̱m.pā sam.'pa xlat.'pa lɛ̄t.tā ᵊ lai.'pa nak.'po sar.'pʰa na̱k.pū sām.pā nox.' χ u sʰo.'ma
Stress reported for Balti ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Stress reported for Amdo ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Stress reported for Amdo ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Minimal pairs for stress in Balti N V N V N V A V brain to be tired rope to grind bread to carry rare to clothe xlat.'pa 'xlat. pa tʰak.'pa 'tʰak. pa kʰur.'pa 'kʰur. pa ʂkøn.'mo 'skøn.ma
Borrowed nouns in Balti hotel teacher school film hospital ho.'ʈɨl  ʈi.'tʃɚ  su.'kul  ɸi.'lim  hɑs.pɨ.'ʈal
Disyllabic words in Amdo willow tree star shooting star new flat N + verbalizer: (to) snow (to) answer (to) shoot an arrow lcang.ma skar.ma skar.zla leb.leb gangs.babs lan.gyab mda′.phen
Stress patterns in Proto-Tibetan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Taking this a step further… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Amdo ‘willow tree’ σ 2 slope = -33 Hz / 100msec
Pitch findings – Balti Non-verbs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pitch findings – Rebkong Non-verbs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Pitch slope contrasts for speaker AR_05 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Amdo ‘willow tree’ σ 2 slope = -33 Hz / 100msec
F0 findings (pitch & pitch slope) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
F0 as a correlate of stress in Proto-Tibetan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Considering intensity… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Intensity does not convey stress in PT ,[object Object],[object Object]
Acoustic correlates of stress ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Solution to the puzzle of tone in disyllabic  non-verbs in the tonal dialects of Tibetan
 
 
 
 
 
 
Questions?
References ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

Demonstration theory part. summary
Demonstration  theory part. summaryDemonstration  theory part. summary
Demonstration theory part. summarymora-deyanira
 
Linguistics handnote ucla
Linguistics handnote uclaLinguistics handnote ucla
Linguistics handnote ucladebasmitakona
 
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015Adverbials and other related matters work 2015
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015Viana Nacolonha
 
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak Syllables
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak SyllablesCopy (2) Of Presentation On Weak Syllables
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak SyllablesDr. Cupid Lucid
 
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]Dr. Shadia Banjar
 
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013barsenijevic
 
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles IRESH3
 
Loser of everything
Loser of everythingLoser of everything
Loser of everythingRamesh Pvr
 
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptx
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptxTools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptx
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptxDr. Shadia Banjar
 
M1 lesson 5.1 slides
M1 lesson 5.1 slidesM1 lesson 5.1 slides
M1 lesson 5.1 slidesAnh Le
 

What's hot (18)

Demonstration theory part. summary
Demonstration  theory part. summaryDemonstration  theory part. summary
Demonstration theory part. summary
 
Methodology for Oral Didactic: Retroflex Consonants of Indo-Aryan Languages
Methodology for Oral Didactic: Retroflex Consonants of Indo-Aryan Languages Methodology for Oral Didactic: Retroflex Consonants of Indo-Aryan Languages
Methodology for Oral Didactic: Retroflex Consonants of Indo-Aryan Languages
 
Linguistics handnote ucla
Linguistics handnote uclaLinguistics handnote ucla
Linguistics handnote ucla
 
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015Adverbials and other related matters work 2015
Adverbials and other related matters work 2015
 
Intonation
IntonationIntonation
Intonation
 
Role Of Stress
Role Of StressRole Of Stress
Role Of Stress
 
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak Syllables
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak SyllablesCopy (2) Of Presentation On Weak Syllables
Copy (2) Of Presentation On Weak Syllables
 
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]
Syntax & syntactic analysis,lec.1, dr. shadia.ppt [compatibility mode]
 
Syntactic analysis.pptx
Syntactic analysis.pptxSyntactic analysis.pptx
Syntactic analysis.pptx
 
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013
Simonovic arsenijevic - in and out of paradigms - bcn2013
 
Adverb and adverb phrase.2pptx
Adverb and adverb phrase.2pptxAdverb and adverb phrase.2pptx
Adverb and adverb phrase.2pptx
 
INTONATION AND ITS FUNCTIONS
INTONATION AND ITS FUNCTIONSINTONATION AND ITS FUNCTIONS
INTONATION AND ITS FUNCTIONS
 
335 chpt 7 summary
335   chpt 7 summary335   chpt 7 summary
335 chpt 7 summary
 
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles
Unit 3 sections a and b grammar and style sentence styles
 
Loser of everything
Loser of everythingLoser of everything
Loser of everything
 
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptx
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptxTools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptx
Tools of Syntactic Analysis, by Dr. Shadia Yousef Banjar.pptx
 
M1 lesson 5.1 slides
M1 lesson 5.1 slidesM1 lesson 5.1 slides
M1 lesson 5.1 slides
 
Section A PT3
Section A PT3Section A PT3
Section A PT3
 

Similar to My Version

phonetics and phonology
phonetics and phonologyphonetics and phonology
phonetics and phonologyWu Heping
 
Consonants and vowels
Consonants and vowelsConsonants and vowels
Consonants and vowelsMohsan Raza
 
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of LanguagePhonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of LanguageBabylen Arit
 
Phonological processes
Phonological processesPhonological processes
Phonological processesRiceli Mendoza
 
Kirchner on phonology
Kirchner on phonologyKirchner on phonology
Kirchner on phonologyHina Honey
 
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdfDrTawas1
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsDr. Cupid Lucid
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsDr. Cupid Lucid
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsDr. Cupid Lucid
 
2 phonetics slides final
2 phonetics slides final2 phonetics slides final
2 phonetics slides finalJasmine Wong
 
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!Phoentics slideshow of English Language!
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!OtabekSadiridinov
 
Study Of English Stress And Intonation
Study Of English Stress And IntonationStudy Of English Stress And Intonation
Study Of English Stress And Intonationsatheesh hendhino
 

Similar to My Version (20)

Phonology333
Phonology333Phonology333
Phonology333
 
phonetics and phonology
phonetics and phonologyphonetics and phonology
phonetics and phonology
 
Consonants and vowels
Consonants and vowelsConsonants and vowels
Consonants and vowels
 
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of LanguagePhonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
Phonology: The Sound Patterns of Language
 
Phonological processes
Phonological processesPhonological processes
Phonological processes
 
Kirchner on phonology
Kirchner on phonologyKirchner on phonology
Kirchner on phonology
 
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf
03- Phonetics and Phonology- with GLOSSARY.pdf
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
 
Syllabe
SyllabeSyllabe
Syllabe
 
Introduction to Phonetic Science
Introduction to Phonetic ScienceIntroduction to Phonetic Science
Introduction to Phonetic Science
 
The discrete nature of language
The discrete nature of languageThe discrete nature of language
The discrete nature of language
 
Suprasegmental features and Prosody
Suprasegmental features and ProsodySuprasegmental features and Prosody
Suprasegmental features and Prosody
 
Phoneme (2)
Phoneme (2)Phoneme (2)
Phoneme (2)
 
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper HeadingsUse Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
Use Of Stress And Intonation In Newspaper Headings
 
Lsa2+Sherpa+06
Lsa2+Sherpa+06Lsa2+Sherpa+06
Lsa2+Sherpa+06
 
2 phonetics slides final
2 phonetics slides final2 phonetics slides final
2 phonetics slides final
 
Phonology
PhonologyPhonology
Phonology
 
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!Phoentics slideshow of English Language!
Phoentics slideshow of English Language!
 
Study Of English Stress And Intonation
Study Of English Stress And IntonationStudy Of English Stress And Intonation
Study Of English Stress And Intonation
 

My Version

  • 1. Historical Comparative Acoustics and Prosodic Reanalysis: The Case of Tibetan Prosodic Typology: State of the Art and Future Prospects February 24-26, 2010 Berlin, German Nancy J. Caplow University of North Texas [email_address]
  • 4.  
  • 5.  
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Comparing monosyllabic words ‘ arrow’ mda′ ‘ horse’ rta ‘ fire’ me / myi ‘ medicine’ sman Archaic Dialects Innovative Dialects Nda ɕta Nda xta ta̱ tā me sman nyi ʰmɛn me̱ mē
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 19. after Tournadre and Dorje 2003 Rebkong Amdo Balti Tokpe Gola
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 26. Tone in Disyllabic Non-Verbs willow tree lcang.ma bridge zam.pa brain klad.pa Balti (West) Amdo (East) ɬtʃa χ .'ma tʃāŋ.mā Tokpe Gola (Central) xtʃaŋ.'ma zam.'pa sa̱m.pā sam.'pa xlat.'pa lɛ̄t.tā ᵊ lai.'pa nak.'po sar.'pʰa na̱k.pū sām.pā nox.' χ u sʰo.'ma black nag.po new gsar.pa
  • 27. σ 2 always high in Tokpe Gola loose, floppy flat young, young person fire arrow gun, rifle leg, foot arm, hand limbs (legs and arms) lhug.lhug leb.leb gzhon.gzhon me mda′ me. mda′ rkang.pa lag.pa rkang.lag HH LH LH L L LH HH LH HH
  • 28. Tone vs. Stress in Disyllabic Non-Verbs willow tree lcang.ma bridge zam.pa brain klad.pa black nag.po new gsar.pa Balti (West) Amdo (East) ɬtʃa χ .'ma tʃāŋ.mā Tokpe Gola (Central) xtʃaŋ.'ma zam.'pa sa̱m.pā sam.'pa xlat.'pa lɛ̄t.tā ᵊ lai.'pa nak.'po sar.'pʰa na̱k.pū sām.pā nox.' χ u sʰo.'ma
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32. Minimal pairs for stress in Balti N V N V N V A V brain to be tired rope to grind bread to carry rare to clothe xlat.'pa 'xlat. pa tʰak.'pa 'tʰak. pa kʰur.'pa 'kʰur. pa ʂkøn.'mo 'skøn.ma
  • 33. Borrowed nouns in Balti hotel teacher school film hospital ho.'ʈɨl ʈi.'tʃɚ su.'kul ɸi.'lim hɑs.pɨ.'ʈal
  • 34. Disyllabic words in Amdo willow tree star shooting star new flat N + verbalizer: (to) snow (to) answer (to) shoot an arrow lcang.ma skar.ma skar.zla leb.leb gangs.babs lan.gyab mda′.phen
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37. Amdo ‘willow tree’ σ 2 slope = -33 Hz / 100msec
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41. Amdo ‘willow tree’ σ 2 slope = -33 Hz / 100msec
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47. Solution to the puzzle of tone in disyllabic non-verbs in the tonal dialects of Tibetan
  • 48.  
  • 49.  
  • 50.  
  • 51.  
  • 52.  
  • 53.  
  • 55.

Editor's Notes

  1. See Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3 and Figure 4
  2. Refer to handouts for Figure 5
  3. See Handouts Figure 5 and Figure 6, for average Balti Nouns
  4. See Figure 7 and 8, for Amdo nouns
  5. See Figures 10, 11
  6. See Figures 11, 12, 13
  7. See Figure 14, 15, 16, 17, 18