SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 61
SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION (SABIC)
LOCATION
Sabic is located in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia with its major
industrial operations in the industrial city of Al-Jubail on the
Arabian Gulf, as well as in Yanbu on the Red Sea.
ESTIMATED SIZE OF WORKFORCE
The company has operations in over 40 countries with a global
workforce of over 40,000 talented individuals.
MISSION STATEMENT
Our mission is to responsibly provide quality products and
services through innovation, learning and operational excellence
while sustaining maximum value for our stakeholders.
VISION STATEMENT
Sabic’s vision is to be the preferred world leader in chemicals.
COMPETITORS
The Olayan group that has a diversified set of operations
including manufacturing of plastic and metal products which
include plastic and metal pipes
Sadara chemical company that produces chemicals targeting the
same market space as Sabic is.
CORE BELIEFS/GUIDING PRINCIPLES/PILLARS OF
SUCCESS
With uncompromising integrity as its foundation Sabic will:
Inspire Engage, Create and Deliver.
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT ACTIVIES.
Sabic develops employees at all professional levels through:
on-the-job coaching where by employees are trained as they
proceed with about the required instructions, mentoring
programs where by more knowledgeable individuals help new
employees learn how to do certain tasks and formal educational
opportunities where by training and development is done in
class room mostly in universities.
Works Cited
Operations in Saudi Arabia & the Middle East. (n.d.). Retrieved
5 31, 2015, from olayan: http://www.olayan.com/Operations
Our Company. (n.d.). Retrieved 5 31, 2015, from sabic:
http://www.sabic.com/corporate/en/ourcompany/
This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the
questions
1169 responses
Summary
Time and energy needed to create them
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
1
17
2
94
3
542
4
516
516
Not Useful at all: 1
17
1.5%
2
94
8%
3
542
46.4%
Extremely Useful: 4
516
44.1%
Accurately measures the quality of student work
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
1
6
2
99
3
523
4
541
...
Not Useful at all: 1
6
0.5%
2
99
8.5%
3
523
44.7%
Extremely Useful: 4
541
46.3%
The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
1
5
2
105
3
581
4
478
...
Not Useful at all: 1
5
0.4%
2
105
9%
3
581
49.7%
Extremely Useful: 4
478
40.9%
Number of daily responses
05101520
Aug 11, 2014
This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the
questions
1169 responses
Summary
Time and energy needed to create them
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
1
17
2
94
3
542
4
516
Not Useful at all: 1
17
1.5%
2
94
8%
3
542
46.4%
Extremely Useful: 4
516
44.1%
Accurately measures the quality of student work
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
1
6
2
99
3
523
4
541
Not Useful at all: 1
6
0.5%
2
99
8.5%
3
523
44.7%
Extremely Useful: 4
541
46.3%
The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them
12340100200300400500
Question
Count
This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the
questions
1169 responses
Summary
Time and energy needed to create them
12340100200300400500
Question Count
1 17
2 94
3 542
4 516
Not Useful at all: 1 17 1.5%
2 94 8%
3 542 46.4%
Extremely Useful: 4 516 44.1%
Accurately measures the quality of student work
12340100200300400500
Question Count
1 6
2 99
3 523
4 541
Not Useful at all: 1 6 0.5%
2 99 8.5%
3 523 44.7%
Extremely Useful: 4 541 46.3%
The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them
12340100200300400500
Question Count
-
P
a
ge 13-
V
ol. 1, R
W
R
, F
a
ll 2
0
0
0
E
x
em
pla
rs
271 P
oker H
ill R
d., U
nderhill, V
T
05489
P
hone 800-450-4050
E
x
em
p
la
rs
T
M
W
e Set the Standards!
RWR Reading Rubric
Reading
Reading multiple sources or texts
Inference
Interpretation: i.e., literal, implied, figurative language
Evaluates information and ideas
Novice • Reads information from several texts, only if
supported by directions/activities.
• Understands basic information contained in texts, with
assistance.
• Uses models for evaluation or questioning texts, with
assistance if necessary.
Apprentice • Gathers details or additional information by
reading several texts.
• Develops a comprehensive, yet literal interpretation of
materials collected.
• Evaluates or questions information with assistance.
Practitioner • Develops an extended understanding of the topic
based on using multiple sources (primary and
secondary texts, literature, art, artifacts).
• Infers meanings and interprets age appropriate texts.
• Understands both literal and figurative meaning in a text.
• Begins to evaluate or question sources independently or in a
peer group.
Expert • Synthesizes a varied body of information including
primary and secondary sources, literature,
artifacts, etc.
• Interprets and uses challenging texts. Comprehends mature
vocabulary.
• Understands and integrates the literal and figurative meanings
of a text; reads textual materials
with empathy.
• Analyzes sources critically and objectively, cross-checking for
differences, conflicts, etc.
R
u
b
ric
Exemplars® Standards-Based Math Rubric
Problem Solving Reasoning and Proof Communication
Connections Representation
Novice No strategy is chosen, or a strategy is chosen that will
not lead to a solution.
Little or no evidence of en-
gagement in the task present.
Arguments are made with no
mathematical basis.
No correct reasoning nor
justification for reasoning is
present.
No awareness of audience or
purpose is communicated.
No formal mathematical terms
or symbolic notations are evi-
dent.
No connections are made
or connections are math-
ematically or contextually
irrelevant.
No attempt is made to
construct a mathemati-
cal representation.
Apprentice A partially correct strategy is chosen, or a correct
strategy
for only solving part of the
task is chosen.
Evidence of drawing on some
relevant previous knowledge
is present, showing some
relevant engagement in the
task.
Arguments are made with
some mathematical basis.
Some correct reasoning or
justification for reasoning is
present.
Some awareness of audience or
purpose is communicated.
Some communication of an
approach is evident through
verbal/written accounts and
explanations.
An attempt is made to use for-
mal math language. One formal
math term or symbolic notation
is evident.
A mathematical connec-
tion is attempted but is
partially incorrect or lacks
contextual relevance.
An attempt is made to
construct a mathemati-
cal representation to re-
cord and communicate
problem solving but is
not accurate.
Copyright ©2001, revised 2014 by Exemplars, Inc. All rights
reserved.
Exemplars® Standards-Based Math Rubric (Cont.)
Problem Solving Reasoning and Proof Communication
Connections Representation
Practitioner A correct strategy is cho-sen based on the math-
ematical situation in the
task.
Planning or monitoring of
strategy is evident.
Evidence of solidifying
prior knowledge and
applying it to the
problem-solving situation
is present.
Note: The Practitioner must
achieve a correct answer.
Arguments are construct-
ed with adequate math-
ematical basis.
A systematic approach
and/or justification of
correct reasoning is pres-
ent.
A sense of audience or pur-
pose is communicated.
Communication of an ap-
proach is evident through a
methodical, organized, coher-
ent, sequenced and labeled
response.
Formal math language is used
to share and clarify ideas. At
least two formal math terms or
symbolic notations are evi-
dent, in any combination.
A mathematical connection
is made. Proper contexts are
identified that link both the
mathematics and the situation
in the task.
Some examples may include
one or more of the following:
• clarification of the mathe-
matical or situational context
of the task
• exploration of mathematical
phenomenon in the context
of the broader topic in which
the task is situated
• noting patterns, structures
and regularities
An appropriate and
accurate mathemati-
cal representation is
constructed and refined
to solve problems or
portray solutions.
Expert An efficient strategy is chosen and progress
towards a solution is
evaluated.
Adjustments in strategy, if
necessary, are made along
the way, and/or alterna-
tive strategies are consid-
ered.
Evidence of analyzing the
situation in mathematical
terms and extending prior
knowledge is present.
Note: The Expert must achieve a
correct answer.
Deductive arguments are
used to justify decisions
and may result in formal
proofs.
Evidence is used to justify
and support decisions
made and conclusions
reached.
A sense of audience and pur-
pose is communicated.
Communication at the Prac-
titioner level is achieved, and
communication of argument
is supported by mathematical
properties.
Formal math language and
symbolic notation is used to
consolidate math thinking
and to communicate ideas. At
least one of the math terms or
symbolic notations is beyond
grade level.
Mathematical connections are
used to extend the solution
to other mathematics or to a
deeper understanding of the
mathematics in the task.
Some examples may include
one or more of the following:
• testing and accepting or
rejecting of a hypothesis or
conjecture
• explanation of phenomenon
• generalizing and extending
the solution to other cases
An appropriate math-
ematical representa-
tion is constructed to
analyze relationships,
extend thinking and
clarify or interpret phe-
nomenon.
Copyright ©2001, revised 2014 by Exemplars, Inc. All rights
reserved.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 1
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Comparing
Selects items that are
inappropriate to the basic
objective of the
comparison.
Selects characteristics that
are trivial or do not address
the basic objective of the
comparison. Selects
characteristics on which
the items cannot be
compared.
Makes many significant
errors in identifying the
major similarities and
differences among the
identified characteristics.
Selects items that satisfy
the basic requirements of
the comparison but create
some difficulties for
completing the task.
Selects characteristics that
provide for a partial
comparison of the items
and may include some
extraneous characteristics.
Makes some important
errors in identifying the
major similarities and
differences among the
identified characteristics.
Selects items that provide
a means for successfully
addressing the basic
objective of the
comparison.
Selects characteristics that
provide a vehicle for
meaningful comparison of
the items and address the
basic objective ed of the
comparison.
Accurately assesses the
major similarities and
differences among the
identified characteristics.
Selects items that are
extremely suitable for
addressing the basic objective
of the comparison and that
show original or creative
thinking.
Selects characteristics that
encompass the most essential
aspects of the items and
present a unique challenge or
provide an unusual thought.
Accurately assesses all
identified similarities and
differences for each item on
the selected characteristic.
Additionally, the student
provides inferences from the
comparison that were not
explicitly requested in the
task description.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 2
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Classifying
Selects trivial items or
items that have no
relationship to the task.
Creates categories that
address only trivial aspects
of the items.
Identifies characteristics
that do not accurately
describe the categories.
Makes frequent and
significant errors in
assigning items to
categories and does not
show how the items have
the characteristics of their
assigned categories.
Selects items of little
significance or presents a
routine sorting problem.
Creates categories that
provide for some analysis
of the items but may not
include all the important
characteristics of the items.
Describes the defining
characteristics of
categories in a way that
results in some overlap or
confusion between
categories, or describes
characteristics that are
unrelated to the rules for
category membership.
Makes some errors in
assigning items to their
appropriate categories, or
does not describe the
extent to which each item
has the characteristics of
the category, when it is
clearly appropriate for the
task.
Selects significant items
for classification that
present some challenge in
classification
Creates categories that
focus on the significant
characteristics of the items.
Clearly specifies the
defining characteristics of
the categories and
addresses any questions of
overlap in characteristics.
Correctly sorts each of the
items into the categories
and, when appropriate,
describes the extent to
which each item has the
characteristics ascribed to
the categories.
Specifies the items to be
classified and selects
significant items that present
some interesting challenge in
classification.
Creates categories that
provide a useful way of
looking at the items at an
unusual level of depth.
Provides a clear and
complete specification of the
defining characteristics of
each category. Describes the
defining characteristics in
such a way as to provide a
unique or unusual way of
looking at the items.
Correctly sorts each of the
items into the categories and
describes the extent to which
each item has the
characteristics ascribed to
the categories. Describes
insights gained during the
sorting process.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 3
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Inductive Reasoning
Selects unimportant or
trivial information for the
induction.
Significantly misinterprets
the information. Makes
interpretations that have no
bearing on the area or a re
clearly illogical.
Draws many erroneous
conclusions from the
selected information or
observations and cannot
satisfactorily describe the
rational behind the
conclusions.
Includes some information
that is not important to the
induction or does not
accurately identify the
important information
from which the
induction(s) could be
made.
Provides some
interpretations that are
based on significant
misunderstandings of the
subject matter.
Presents some conclusions
that reflect erroneous
interpretations made from
the information or
observations.
Specifies all relevant
information from which to
make inductions. Selects
information that is
important to the general
topic.
Provides interpretations
that, with few exceptions,
are valid and say
something important about
the topic.
Presents conclusions that,
with few exceptions,
follow logically from the
selected information or
observations.
Clearly and accurately
identifies all relevant
information from which to
make inductions. The type of
information selected reflects
c creative insight and a
careful analysis of the
situation.
Provides accurate
interpretations that illustrate
insight into the information
from which they were made.
The interpretations reflect a
study of or a familiarity with
the particulars of the topic.
Draws conclusions that
reflect clear and logical links
between the information or
observations and the
interpretations made from
them. The rationale for the
interpretations shows a
thoughtful and accurate
attention to the process of
induction.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 4
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Deductive Reasoning
Selects generalizations or
principles that do not have
significant bearing on the
material and do not
contribute to the
understanding of the
subject.
Demonstrates an incorrect
understanding or
interpretation of the
generalizations or
principles.
Identifies consequences
that have little significance
and are not logical or
relevant to the topic.
Selects generalizations or
principles that generally
relate to the information
available but that may not
have significant
explanatory power.
Demonstrates a somewhat
inaccurate understanding
of the generalizations or
principles.
Includes important
consequences of the
generalizations or
principles, but identifies
consequences that may not
be relevant to the topic; or
makes logical errors in
identifying the
consequences.
Selects important
generalizations or
principles that contribute
to the understanding of the
topic.
Demonstrates an
understanding of the
generalizations or
principles that is accurate
and contributes to an
understanding of the topic.
With few errors, accurately
identifies the consequences
of the generalizations or
principles. The
consequences relate
closely to the subject area
and are worthwhile
subjects for discussion.
Selects generalizations or
principles that show extreme
insight into the topic.
Demonstrates an
understanding of the
generalizations or principles
that is not only accurate but
provides a unique
perspective on the topic.
Accurately identifies logical
conclusions implied by the
generalizations or principles.
Recognizes more subtle
inferences that could have
important effects on the
subject area.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 5
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Error Analysis
Recognizes only
insignificant errors or
mistakes valid points for
errors
Does not correctly assess
the effects of the errors, or
describes effects that do
not exist
Does not accurately
describe how to correct the
errors
Fails to recognize some
important errors or
identifies some points that
are not errors
Describes the effects of the
errors, but omits some
important consequences;
or does not accurately
describe all the effects of
the errors
Provides an approach for
correcting the errors. The
approach addresses some
of the major errors, though
it may not be the best or
most appropriate response
to the situation.
Accurately identifies all
critical errors in the
information process under
study and makes clear why
the points identified are
errors
Provides an accurate
analysis of the effects of
the errors, omitting few
details
Provides a workable way
of correcting the errors.
The response addresses the
major concerns raised by
the errors.
Accurately identifies all
errors in the information or
process under study and
makes clear why the points
identified are errors. Also
identifies subtle but
important errors that are
difficult to recognize
Provides an accurate
analysis of the effects of the
errors, including a complete
description of the effects of
the errors beyond the most
obvious levels of impact.
Provides a highly thoughtful
or creative approach for
correcting the errors.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 6
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Constructing Support
Identifies information that
does not require support
and fails to identify a claim
that should have support
Fails to provide convincing
evidence for the claim.
Does not address
qualifications or
restrictions for the claim.
Identifies a claim that
requires support but may
mistakenly include
information that does not
require support.
Provides evidence for the
claim, but may not address
all necessary aspects.
Qualifies or restricts the
claim, but leaves out
important aspects of the
qualifications or
restrictions.
Accurately identifies a
claim that requires support
and does not confuse the
claim with any other
information.
With no major errors,
presents all relevant
evidence needed to support
the claim.
Provides accurate
qualifications or
restrictions for the claim,
with the result being a
well-defended claim.
Accurately identifies a claim
that requires support. The
identified claim has been
mistaken by many others for
a fact that requires no
support.
Presents a clear and accurate
treatment of all available
evidence that addresses the
central point of the claim.
Considers what evidence is
missing and how it should
affect an evaluation of the
claim.
Provides careful and
reasoned qualifications or
restrictions for the claim in
such a way that the argument
provides a unique
perspective on the claim.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 7
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Abstracting
Identifies trivial
information having no
identifiable pattern that can
be used in the abstracting
process
Does not create a general
or abstract pattern that
accurately represents the
information or situation
selected
Selects another situation or
set of information that
does not conform in any
way to the general or
abstract pattern identified.
Identifies information that
seems unimportant but
does have a pattern that
can be used in the
abstracting process.
Creates a general or
abstract pattern that may
not be a completely
accurate representation of
the information or situation
from which it was drawn
but does focus on its most
important elements.
Identifies another situation
or set of information that
does perfectly match the
general or abstract form
but has some similarities
Identifies significant
information that also has a
pattern that lends itself to
the abstracting process.
Constructs a general or
abstract pattern that
accurately represents the
information from which it
came.
Correctly identifies
another situation or set of
information that contains
the essential characteristics
of the general or abstract
form and provides a
worthwhile subject for
study.
Identifies a situation or
information that provides a
rich source of material for
abstracting, which may not
be commonly used, but has a
pattern that could be
powerful when abstracted.
Identifies a general or
abstract pattern that provides
novel insights into the
information studied. The
pattern furnishes the means
for seeing other material
from a unique perspective.
Demonstrates creativity in
the selection of another
situation or information that
contains a similar general or
abstract form. The situation
or information is important
and provides a suitable
subject for analysis.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 8
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Analyzing Perspectives
Ignores explicit and
implicit points of
disagreement.
Does not articulate a
clear position.
Does not articulate
a clear opposing position.
Identifies and articulates
issues that are not points of
disagreement as important
points of disagreement.
Articulates a position but
does not present a clear
line of reasoning behind it.
Articulates an opposing
position, but does not
present a clear line of
reasoning behind it.
Identifies and articulates
explicit points of
disagreement that cause
conflict.
Articulates a position and
the basic reasoning
underlying the position.
Does not address or
incompletely addresses the
errors or holes in the
reasoning
.
Articulates an opposing
position and the basic
reasoning underlying it.
Does not address or
incompletely addresses the
errors or holes in the
reasoning.
Identifies and articulates
implicit points of
disagreement that are not
obvious but are the
underlying cause of conflict.
Articulates a detailed
position and the reasoning
behind it and, if a strong line
of reasoning does not
underlie the position,
articulates the errors or holes
in the reasoning.
Articulates a detailed
opposing position and the
reasoning behind it. If a
strong line of reasoning does
not underlie the position,
articulates the errors or holes
in the reasoning.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 9
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Decision Making
Selects alternatives that are
clearly not relevant to the
decision.
Identifies few or no criteria
that are relevant to the
decision task.
Does not address the
extent to which the
alternatives meet the
criteria or is inaccurate in
assessing how well the
alternatives meet the
criteria.
Makes a selection that
does not appear reasonable
or cannot be justified by
the student’s evaluation of
the alternatives.
Identifies some
alternatives that are
important and others that
aren’t.
Identifies some important
criteria by which the
identified alternatives will
be assessed. However,
some important criteria are
omitted, or criteria are
included that may not be
important to the task.
Does not completely
address all the criteria; or
applies all appropriate
criteria to the alternatives
but is not completely
accurate in assessing how
well the criteria have been
met
Selects an alternative that
does not entirely conform
to the student’s assessment
of the alternatives.
Identifies alternatives that
represent most of the
important possible
alternatives.
Clearly identifies the
criteria by which the
identified alternatives will
be assessed. With no
significant exceptions, the
criteria are important to the
decision task.
Presents an accurate
assessment of the extent to
which the alternatives
possess the identified
criteria
Successfully answers the
decision question by
selecting an alternative that
meets or exceeds
established criteria.
Presents a comprehensive list
of the most important
possible alternatives and
describes each in detail
Clearly identifies the criteria
by which the identified
alternatives will be assessed.
The criteria reflect an
unusually thorough
understanding of the nature of
the decision task.
Provides a thorough, fully
developed assessment of each
alternative based upon the
criteria. Exceeds the demands
of the decision task by
comparing and contrasting the
alternatives to provide greater
insights
Selects an alternative that
meets or exceeds the criteria
and represents a well-
supported answer to the initial
decision question. Provides a
useful discussion of issues
and insights that arose during
the selection process.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 10
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Investigation
Presents little or no
accurate and important
information about what is
already known or agreed
upon about the topic.
Fails to accurately identify
any important confusions,
uncertainties, or
contradictions surrounding
the topic.
Presents an
unsubstantiated and
implausible resolution to
the confusions,
uncertainties, or
contradictions.
Presents information on
what is already known or
agreed upon abut the topic
being studied; however the
information may not be
complete in all particulars,
or the student may
introduce some
inaccuracies.
Identifies confusion,
uncertainties, or
contradictions associated
with the topic. The
problems identified
include some, but not all,
of the most critical issues.
Develops and presents a
resolution to the problems
associated with the
concept. The resolution is
satisfactory, but lacks
thorough treatment and
accuracy.
Presents an accurate
account, with no important
omissions, of what is
already known or agreed
upon about the topic being
studied.
Identifies, with no
important errors,
significant confusions,
uncertainties, or
contradictions surrounding
the topic.
Presents a clear resolution
to the problems associated
with the concept. The
resolution is a logical and
plausible outcome of the
investigation.
Presents a thorough and
correct account of what is
already known. Supplies
information that may not be
commonly known, but that
has some bearing on the
topic being studied.
Identifies the important
confusions, uncertainties or
contradictions surrounding
the topic. Brings to light
misconceptions or
confusions that are
commonly overlooked.
Provides a logical and well-
developed resolution to the
confusions, uncertainties, or
contradictions. The
resolution reflects creative
thinking as well as
thoughtful attention to the
details of the problem.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 11
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Problem Solving
Omits the most significant
constraints and obstacles.
Presents solutions that fail to
address critical parts of the
problem.
Does not satisfactorily test
the selected solutions.
Describes and illogical
method for determining the
relative value of the
alternatives. The student
does not present a reasonable
review of the strengths and
weaknesses of the alternative
solutions that were tried and
abandoned.
Identifies some constraints or
obstacles that are accurate
along with some that are not
accurate.
Presents alternative solutions
for dealing with the obstacles
or constraints, but the
solutions do not all address
the important difficulties.
Tries out the alternatives, but
the trials are incomplete and
important elements are
omitted or ignored.
Describes the processes that
led to the ordering of
secondary solutions. The
description does not provide a
clear rational for the ordering
of alternatives that were tried.
Accurately identifies the most
important constraints or
obstacles.
Proposes alternative solutions
that appear plausible and that
address the most important
constraints or obstacles.
Puts the selected alternative
to trials adequate to
determine their utility.
Describes the process that led
to the ordering of secondary
solutions. The description
offers a clear, defensible
rational for the ordering of
alternatives, and the final
selection.
Accurately and thoroughly
describes the relevant constraints
or obstacles. Addresses obstacles
or constraints that are not
immediately apparent.
Identifies creative but plausible
solutions to the problem under
consideration. The solutions
address the central difficulties
posed by the constraint or
obstacle.
Engages in effective, valid, and
exhaustive trials of the selected
alternatives. Trials go beyond
those required to solve the
problem and show a
commitment to an in-depth
understanding of the problem.
Provides a clear, comprehensive
summary of the reasoning that
led to the selection of secondary
solutions. The description
includes a review of the
decisions that produced the order
of selection and how each
alternative fared as a solution.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 12
Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Experimental Inquiry
Leaves out key facts,
concepts, or principles in
explaining phenomenon, or
does not use appropriate
facts, concept, or principles
to explain the phenomenon.
Makes a prediction that
cannot be verified.
Sets up and carries out an
activity or experiment that
does not test the central
features of the prediction.
The experimental design is
seriously flawed and the
collection of data is unlikely.
Provides an inaccurate
highly flawed explanation of
how the outcome relates to
the original explanation.
Explains the phenomenon
but misapplies or omits facts,
concepts, or principles that
are important for
understanding the
phenomenon.
Makes a prediction that
reflects a misunderstanding
of some aspects of the facts,
concepts, or principles used
to explain the phenomenon,
or makes a prediction that
presents difficulties for
verification.
Sets up and carries out an
activity or experiment that
addresses some important
aspects of the prediction, but
omits others. The design of
the activity or experiment
produces some errors in data
collection or interpretation.
Provides a general
explanation of the outcome
of the activity or experiment
but omits one or two
important aspects, or may not
effectively relate the
outcome to the facts,
concepts, or principles used
to generate the prediction.
Provides and accurate
explanation of the
phenomenon. The facts,
concepts, or principles used
in the explanation are
appropriate to the
phenomenon and accurately
applied, with no significant
errors.
Makes a prediction that
follows from the facts,
concepts, or principles used
to explain the phenomenon.
The prediction can be
verified.
Sets up and carries out an
activity or experiment that is
a fair test of the prediction
and addresses the most
important questions raised by
the prediction. The activity
or experiment provides
accurate data for evaluation.
Provides a complete
explanation of the outcome
of the activity or experiment
with no important errors.
Presents the explanation in
terms of the relevant facts,
concepts, or principles.
Provides and accurate explanation of
the phenomenon. The facts,
concepts, or principles used for the
explanation are appropriate to the
phenomenon and accurately applied.
The explanation reflects thorough
and careful research or
understanding.
Makes a verifiable prediction that
reflects insight into the character of
the phenomenon. The prediction is
entirely appropriate to the facts,
concepts, or principles used to
explain the phenomenon.
Sets up and carries out an
experiment that is a complete and
valid test of the prediction and
addresses all important questions
raised by the prediction. The
activity or experiment is designed to
provide complete and accurate data
and a model of the experimental
design.
Provided a complete and accurate
explanation of the outcome of the
activity or experiment and does so in
terms of the relevant facts, concepts,
or principles. Provides insights into
the nature of the phenomenon
studied or the facts, concepts, and
principles used to explain it.
CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric
Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking
Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from
Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 13
Thinking/Reasoning
Skill
Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
Invention
Proposes a process or product
that has little or no relation to
the unmet need.
Establishes criteria that fail to
address the most important
purpose of the invention.
Sets standards so low that
little quality can be expected.
Makes few, if any attempts at
revision and appears satisfied
with the initial process or
product, although obvious
difficulties still remain.
Finishes revising the process
or product before it has met
minimal standards. The
process or product does not
meet many important criteria
and fails in its purpose.
Proposes a process or product
that will not adequately
satisfy the unmet need.
Identifies criteria for the
invention that may not be
completely appropriate for the
product or sets standards that
do not ensure a worthwhile or
completed product.
Revises the process or
product but attempts to
address only the most obvious
difficulties
Revises the process or
product until it meets
minimum standards.
Proposes a process or product
that provides a good answer
to the unmet need.
Establishes an appropriate set
of criteria for the invention
Revises the process or
product in ways that serve the
purpose of the process or
product.
Continues revising the
process or product until it
meets all standards and
criteria. The process or
product successfully serves
the purpose for which it was
designed.
Proposes a process or product
that provides a unique solution to
an unmet need. The proposed
process or product reflects a high
level of creativity.
Sets out rigorous criteria well
suited to the purpose of the
invention. The student identifies
only the highest achievable
standards of quality as acceptable
outcomes.
Reviews the process or product
at a considerable level of detail.
The revisions or improvements
clearly bring the process or
product closer to fulfilling the
purpose for which it was
designed. The student’s attention
to the details of the draft or
model makes a high-quality
product likely.
Develops a final process or
product that meets the criteria
established at a demanding level
of quality. The process or
product fulfills the purpose for
which it was designed. In
addition, the process or product
reflects creativity and establishes
a model for creative work of high
quality.

More Related Content

Similar to SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION (SABIC)LOCATIONSabic is loc.docx

School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docx
School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docxSchool of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docx
School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docxjeffsrosalyn
 
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015Liz Norman
 
Goal setting and objectives
Goal setting and objectivesGoal setting and objectives
Goal setting and objectivesdonwashburn
 
Assessment 072
Assessment 072Assessment 072
Assessment 072fogleman
 
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015Liz Norman
 
Arte387 Ch5
Arte387 Ch5Arte387 Ch5
Arte387 Ch5SCWARTED
 
Coherence assess share
Coherence assess shareCoherence assess share
Coherence assess shareEdAdvance
 
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015Liz Norman
 
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdfIvyAnnLeizelQuintas
 
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learning
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learningAssessment in a constructivist, technology supported learning
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learningNur-Aisha Pasandalan
 
Ppt on assessment of knowledge
Ppt on assessment of knowledgePpt on assessment of knowledge
Ppt on assessment of knowledgeArushi Negi
 
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers Ta.docx
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers  Ta.docxCOURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers  Ta.docx
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers Ta.docxrobert345678
 

Similar to SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION (SABIC)LOCATIONSabic is loc.docx (20)

School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docx
School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docxSchool of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docx
School of IT and BusinessHV4702 Bachelor of Applied Busine.docx
 
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015
Grading criteria and marking schemes liz norman anzcvs 2015
 
Product
ProductProduct
Product
 
Goal setting and objectives
Goal setting and objectivesGoal setting and objectives
Goal setting and objectives
 
Assessment 072
Assessment 072Assessment 072
Assessment 072
 
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions liz norman anzcvs 2015
 
Arte387 Ch5
Arte387 Ch5Arte387 Ch5
Arte387 Ch5
 
Creating Meaningful Rubrics
Creating Meaningful Rubrics Creating Meaningful Rubrics
Creating Meaningful Rubrics
 
Coherence assess share
Coherence assess shareCoherence assess share
Coherence assess share
 
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015
Blueprinting and drafting questions Liz Norman ANZCVS 2015
 
Week 29(2) (3).pptx
Week 29(2) (3).pptxWeek 29(2) (3).pptx
Week 29(2) (3).pptx
 
Kto12 assessment and rating
Kto12 assessment and ratingKto12 assessment and rating
Kto12 assessment and rating
 
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf
2.26.15-CEIT-Assessment-Rubric-Development-PowerPoint.pdf
 
Math and the Common Core
Math and the Common CoreMath and the Common Core
Math and the Common Core
 
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learning
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learningAssessment in a constructivist, technology supported learning
Assessment in a constructivist, technology supported learning
 
Ppt on assessment of knowledge
Ppt on assessment of knowledgePpt on assessment of knowledge
Ppt on assessment of knowledge
 
Intro to rubrics
Intro to rubricsIntro to rubrics
Intro to rubrics
 
Intro to rubrics
Intro to rubricsIntro to rubrics
Intro to rubrics
 
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers Ta.docx
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers  Ta.docxCOURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers  Ta.docx
COURSE CODE MCO 105 COURSE NAME Data Analysis for Managers Ta.docx
 
Day1acttraining
Day1acttrainingDay1acttraining
Day1acttraining
 

More from kenjordan97598

You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docx
You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docxYou are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docx
You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docxkenjordan97598
 
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docx
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docxYou are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docx
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docx
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docxYou are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docx
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docx
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docxYou are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docx
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docx
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docxYou are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docx
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docx
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docxYou are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docx
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docx
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docxYou are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docx
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docx
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docxYou are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docx
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docx
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docxYou are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docx
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docx
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docxYou are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docx
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docx
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docxYou are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docx
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docx
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docxYou are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docx
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docx
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docxYou are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docx
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docx
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docxYou are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docx
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docx
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docxYou are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docx
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docxkenjordan97598
 
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docx
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docxYou are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docx
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docx
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docxYou are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docx
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docx
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docxYou are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docx
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docx
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docxYou are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docx
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docxkenjordan97598
 
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docx
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docxYou are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docx
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docxkenjordan97598
 

More from kenjordan97598 (20)

You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docx
You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docxYou are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docx
You are the Nursing Director for the medical-surgical area of a .docx
 
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docx
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docxYou are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docx
You are the newly appointed director of the Agile County Airport.docx
 
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docx
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docxYou are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docx
You are working on an address book database with a table called Cont.docx
 
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docx
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docxYou are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docx
You are the new Security Manager for a small bank in Iowa. They are .docx
 
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docx
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docxYou are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docx
You are working in a rural Family Planning Health clinic and a 16 y.docx
 
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docx
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docxYou are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docx
You are working in a family practice when your newly diagnosed T.docx
 
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docx
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docxYou are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docx
You are working for the Chief of Staff (CoS) for a newly elected Gov.docx
 
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docx
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docxYou are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docx
You are working at Johnson and Cohen law firm and have recently .docx
 
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docx
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docxYou are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docx
You are working for a community counseling agency, and you are taske.docx
 
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docx
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docxYou are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docx
You are working as the software tester for a big enterprise comp.docx
 
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docx
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docxYou are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docx
You are working as HelpDesk Support for an organization where your u.docx
 
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docx
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docxYou are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docx
You are working as an APRN in your local primary care office. Th.docx
 
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docx
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docxYou are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docx
You are the new Public Information Officer (PIO) assigned by the.docx
 
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docx
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docxYou are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docx
You are welcome to go to the San Diego Zoo any time you would li.docx
 
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docx
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docxYou are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docx
You are visiting one of your organization’s plants in a poor nation..docx
 
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docx
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docxYou are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docx
You are to write a four-page (typed, double-spaced) essay addressing.docx
 
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docx
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docxYou are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docx
You are to write a 7-page Biographical Research Paper of St Franci.docx
 
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docx
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docxYou are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docx
You are to write a 1050 to 1750 word literature review (in a.docx
 
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docx
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docxYou are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docx
You are to take the uploaded assignment and edit it. The title shoul.docx
 
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docx
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docxYou are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docx
You are to use a topic for the question you chose.WORD REQUIRE.docx
 

Recently uploaded

Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatYousafMalik24
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxHow to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxmanuelaromero2013
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,Virag Sontakke
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerunnathinaik
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxsocialsciencegdgrohi
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdf
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdfPharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdf
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdfMahmoud M. Sallam
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceSamikshaHamane
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxJiesonDelaCerna
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTiammrhaywood
 
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxTypes of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxEyham Joco
 
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitolTechU
 
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementmkooblal
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media ComponentMeghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
Meghan Sutherland In Media Res Media Component
 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptxHow to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
How to Make a Pirate ship Primary Education.pptx
 
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini  Delhi NCR
9953330565 Low Rate Call Girls In Rohini Delhi NCR
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developerinternship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
internship ppt on smartinternz platform as salesforce developer
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
 
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdf
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdfPharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdf
Pharmacognosy Flower 3. Compositae 2023.pdf
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
 
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPTECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - LONG FORM TV DRAMA - PPT
 
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptxTypes of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
Types of Journalistic Writing Grade 8.pptx
 
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptxCapitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
Capitol Tech U Doctoral Presentation - April 2024.pptx
 
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
 

SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION (SABIC)LOCATIONSabic is loc.docx

  • 1. SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION (SABIC) LOCATION Sabic is located in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia with its major industrial operations in the industrial city of Al-Jubail on the Arabian Gulf, as well as in Yanbu on the Red Sea. ESTIMATED SIZE OF WORKFORCE The company has operations in over 40 countries with a global workforce of over 40,000 talented individuals. MISSION STATEMENT Our mission is to responsibly provide quality products and services through innovation, learning and operational excellence while sustaining maximum value for our stakeholders. VISION STATEMENT Sabic’s vision is to be the preferred world leader in chemicals. COMPETITORS The Olayan group that has a diversified set of operations including manufacturing of plastic and metal products which include plastic and metal pipes Sadara chemical company that produces chemicals targeting the same market space as Sabic is. CORE BELIEFS/GUIDING PRINCIPLES/PILLARS OF SUCCESS With uncompromising integrity as its foundation Sabic will: Inspire Engage, Create and Deliver. TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT ACTIVIES. Sabic develops employees at all professional levels through: on-the-job coaching where by employees are trained as they proceed with about the required instructions, mentoring programs where by more knowledgeable individuals help new employees learn how to do certain tasks and formal educational
  • 2. opportunities where by training and development is done in class room mostly in universities. Works Cited Operations in Saudi Arabia & the Middle East. (n.d.). Retrieved 5 31, 2015, from olayan: http://www.olayan.com/Operations Our Company. (n.d.). Retrieved 5 31, 2015, from sabic: http://www.sabic.com/corporate/en/ourcompany/ This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the questions 1169 responses Summary Time and energy needed to create them 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 17 2 94 3 542 4 516 516 Not Useful at all: 1 17 1.5% 2
  • 3. 94 8% 3 542 46.4% Extremely Useful: 4 516 44.1% Accurately measures the quality of student work 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 6 2 99 3 523 4 541 ... Not Useful at all: 1 6 0.5% 2 99 8.5% 3 523 44.7% Extremely Useful: 4 541 46.3% The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them 12340100200300400500 Question
  • 4. Count 1 5 2 105 3 581 4 478 ... Not Useful at all: 1 5 0.4% 2 105 9% 3 581 49.7% Extremely Useful: 4 478 40.9% Number of daily responses 05101520 Aug 11, 2014 This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the questions
  • 5. 1169 responses Summary Time and energy needed to create them 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 17 2 94 3 542 4 516 Not Useful at all: 1 17 1.5% 2
  • 6. 94 8% 3 542 46.4% Extremely Useful: 4 516 44.1% Accurately measures the quality of student work 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 6 2 99 3 523
  • 7. 4 541 Not Useful at all: 1 6 0.5% 2 99 8.5% 3 523 44.7% Extremely Useful: 4 541 46.3% The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them 12340100200300400500 Question Count
  • 8. This is the last part of the paper, my response was 3 on all the questions 1169 responses Summary Time and energy needed to create them 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 17 2 94 3 542 4 516 Not Useful at all: 1 17 1.5% 2 94 8% 3 542 46.4% Extremely Useful: 4 516 44.1% Accurately measures the quality of student work 12340100200300400500 Question Count 1 6 2 99 3 523 4 541 Not Useful at all: 1 6 0.5% 2 99 8.5% 3 523 44.7% Extremely Useful: 4 541 46.3% The validity and reliablity of the data derived from them 12340100200300400500 Question Count - P
  • 9. a ge 13- V ol. 1, R W R , F a ll 2 0 0 0 E x em pla rs 271 P oker H ill R d., U nderhill, V T 05489
  • 10. P hone 800-450-4050 E x em p la rs T M W e Set the Standards! RWR Reading Rubric Reading Reading multiple sources or texts Inference Interpretation: i.e., literal, implied, figurative language Evaluates information and ideas Novice • Reads information from several texts, only if supported by directions/activities. • Understands basic information contained in texts, with assistance. • Uses models for evaluation or questioning texts, with assistance if necessary.
  • 11. Apprentice • Gathers details or additional information by reading several texts. • Develops a comprehensive, yet literal interpretation of materials collected. • Evaluates or questions information with assistance. Practitioner • Develops an extended understanding of the topic based on using multiple sources (primary and secondary texts, literature, art, artifacts). • Infers meanings and interprets age appropriate texts. • Understands both literal and figurative meaning in a text. • Begins to evaluate or question sources independently or in a peer group. Expert • Synthesizes a varied body of information including primary and secondary sources, literature, artifacts, etc. • Interprets and uses challenging texts. Comprehends mature vocabulary. • Understands and integrates the literal and figurative meanings of a text; reads textual materials with empathy. • Analyzes sources critically and objectively, cross-checking for differences, conflicts, etc. R u b ric
  • 12. Exemplars® Standards-Based Math Rubric Problem Solving Reasoning and Proof Communication Connections Representation Novice No strategy is chosen, or a strategy is chosen that will not lead to a solution. Little or no evidence of en- gagement in the task present. Arguments are made with no mathematical basis. No correct reasoning nor justification for reasoning is present. No awareness of audience or purpose is communicated. No formal mathematical terms or symbolic notations are evi- dent. No connections are made or connections are math- ematically or contextually irrelevant. No attempt is made to construct a mathemati- cal representation. Apprentice A partially correct strategy is chosen, or a correct
  • 13. strategy for only solving part of the task is chosen. Evidence of drawing on some relevant previous knowledge is present, showing some relevant engagement in the task. Arguments are made with some mathematical basis. Some correct reasoning or justification for reasoning is present. Some awareness of audience or purpose is communicated. Some communication of an approach is evident through verbal/written accounts and explanations. An attempt is made to use for- mal math language. One formal math term or symbolic notation is evident. A mathematical connec- tion is attempted but is partially incorrect or lacks contextual relevance. An attempt is made to
  • 14. construct a mathemati- cal representation to re- cord and communicate problem solving but is not accurate. Copyright ©2001, revised 2014 by Exemplars, Inc. All rights reserved. Exemplars® Standards-Based Math Rubric (Cont.) Problem Solving Reasoning and Proof Communication Connections Representation Practitioner A correct strategy is cho-sen based on the math- ematical situation in the task. Planning or monitoring of strategy is evident. Evidence of solidifying prior knowledge and applying it to the problem-solving situation is present. Note: The Practitioner must achieve a correct answer. Arguments are construct- ed with adequate math- ematical basis.
  • 15. A systematic approach and/or justification of correct reasoning is pres- ent. A sense of audience or pur- pose is communicated. Communication of an ap- proach is evident through a methodical, organized, coher- ent, sequenced and labeled response. Formal math language is used to share and clarify ideas. At least two formal math terms or symbolic notations are evi- dent, in any combination. A mathematical connection is made. Proper contexts are identified that link both the mathematics and the situation in the task. Some examples may include one or more of the following: • clarification of the mathe- matical or situational context of the task • exploration of mathematical phenomenon in the context of the broader topic in which
  • 16. the task is situated • noting patterns, structures and regularities An appropriate and accurate mathemati- cal representation is constructed and refined to solve problems or portray solutions. Expert An efficient strategy is chosen and progress towards a solution is evaluated. Adjustments in strategy, if necessary, are made along the way, and/or alterna- tive strategies are consid- ered. Evidence of analyzing the situation in mathematical terms and extending prior knowledge is present. Note: The Expert must achieve a correct answer. Deductive arguments are used to justify decisions and may result in formal proofs. Evidence is used to justify
  • 17. and support decisions made and conclusions reached. A sense of audience and pur- pose is communicated. Communication at the Prac- titioner level is achieved, and communication of argument is supported by mathematical properties. Formal math language and symbolic notation is used to consolidate math thinking and to communicate ideas. At least one of the math terms or symbolic notations is beyond grade level. Mathematical connections are used to extend the solution to other mathematics or to a deeper understanding of the mathematics in the task. Some examples may include one or more of the following: • testing and accepting or rejecting of a hypothesis or conjecture • explanation of phenomenon • generalizing and extending
  • 18. the solution to other cases An appropriate math- ematical representa- tion is constructed to analyze relationships, extend thinking and clarify or interpret phe- nomenon. Copyright ©2001, revised 2014 by Exemplars, Inc. All rights reserved. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 1 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Comparing
  • 19. Selects items that are inappropriate to the basic objective of the comparison. Selects characteristics that are trivial or do not address the basic objective of the comparison. Selects characteristics on which the items cannot be compared. Makes many significant errors in identifying the major similarities and differences among the identified characteristics. Selects items that satisfy the basic requirements of the comparison but create some difficulties for completing the task. Selects characteristics that provide for a partial comparison of the items and may include some extraneous characteristics.
  • 20. Makes some important errors in identifying the major similarities and differences among the identified characteristics. Selects items that provide a means for successfully addressing the basic objective of the comparison. Selects characteristics that provide a vehicle for meaningful comparison of the items and address the basic objective ed of the comparison. Accurately assesses the major similarities and differences among the identified characteristics. Selects items that are extremely suitable for addressing the basic objective of the comparison and that show original or creative thinking. Selects characteristics that encompass the most essential aspects of the items and
  • 21. present a unique challenge or provide an unusual thought. Accurately assesses all identified similarities and differences for each item on the selected characteristic. Additionally, the student provides inferences from the comparison that were not explicitly requested in the task description. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 2 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Classifying
  • 22. Selects trivial items or items that have no relationship to the task. Creates categories that address only trivial aspects of the items. Identifies characteristics that do not accurately describe the categories. Makes frequent and significant errors in assigning items to categories and does not show how the items have the characteristics of their assigned categories. Selects items of little significance or presents a routine sorting problem. Creates categories that provide for some analysis of the items but may not include all the important characteristics of the items.
  • 23. Describes the defining characteristics of categories in a way that results in some overlap or confusion between categories, or describes characteristics that are unrelated to the rules for category membership. Makes some errors in assigning items to their appropriate categories, or does not describe the extent to which each item has the characteristics of the category, when it is clearly appropriate for the task. Selects significant items for classification that present some challenge in classification Creates categories that focus on the significant characteristics of the items. Clearly specifies the defining characteristics of the categories and addresses any questions of overlap in characteristics.
  • 24. Correctly sorts each of the items into the categories and, when appropriate, describes the extent to which each item has the characteristics ascribed to the categories. Specifies the items to be classified and selects significant items that present some interesting challenge in classification. Creates categories that provide a useful way of looking at the items at an unusual level of depth. Provides a clear and complete specification of the defining characteristics of each category. Describes the defining characteristics in such a way as to provide a unique or unusual way of looking at the items. Correctly sorts each of the items into the categories and describes the extent to which each item has the characteristics ascribed to
  • 25. the categories. Describes insights gained during the sorting process. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 3 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Inductive Reasoning Selects unimportant or trivial information for the induction. Significantly misinterprets the information. Makes interpretations that have no
  • 26. bearing on the area or a re clearly illogical. Draws many erroneous conclusions from the selected information or observations and cannot satisfactorily describe the rational behind the conclusions. Includes some information that is not important to the induction or does not accurately identify the important information from which the induction(s) could be made. Provides some interpretations that are based on significant misunderstandings of the subject matter. Presents some conclusions that reflect erroneous interpretations made from
  • 27. the information or observations. Specifies all relevant information from which to make inductions. Selects information that is important to the general topic. Provides interpretations that, with few exceptions, are valid and say something important about the topic. Presents conclusions that, with few exceptions, follow logically from the selected information or observations. Clearly and accurately identifies all relevant information from which to make inductions. The type of information selected reflects c creative insight and a careful analysis of the situation. Provides accurate interpretations that illustrate insight into the information
  • 28. from which they were made. The interpretations reflect a study of or a familiarity with the particulars of the topic. Draws conclusions that reflect clear and logical links between the information or observations and the interpretations made from them. The rationale for the interpretations shows a thoughtful and accurate attention to the process of induction. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 4 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
  • 29. Deductive Reasoning Selects generalizations or principles that do not have significant bearing on the material and do not contribute to the understanding of the subject. Demonstrates an incorrect understanding or interpretation of the generalizations or principles. Identifies consequences that have little significance and are not logical or relevant to the topic. Selects generalizations or principles that generally relate to the information available but that may not have significant explanatory power.
  • 30. Demonstrates a somewhat inaccurate understanding of the generalizations or principles. Includes important consequences of the generalizations or principles, but identifies consequences that may not be relevant to the topic; or makes logical errors in identifying the consequences. Selects important generalizations or principles that contribute to the understanding of the topic. Demonstrates an understanding of the generalizations or principles that is accurate and contributes to an understanding of the topic. With few errors, accurately identifies the consequences of the generalizations or principles. The consequences relate closely to the subject area and are worthwhile
  • 31. subjects for discussion. Selects generalizations or principles that show extreme insight into the topic. Demonstrates an understanding of the generalizations or principles that is not only accurate but provides a unique perspective on the topic. Accurately identifies logical conclusions implied by the generalizations or principles. Recognizes more subtle inferences that could have important effects on the subject area. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 5
  • 32. Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Error Analysis Recognizes only insignificant errors or mistakes valid points for errors Does not correctly assess the effects of the errors, or describes effects that do not exist Does not accurately describe how to correct the errors Fails to recognize some important errors or identifies some points that are not errors Describes the effects of the
  • 33. errors, but omits some important consequences; or does not accurately describe all the effects of the errors Provides an approach for correcting the errors. The approach addresses some of the major errors, though it may not be the best or most appropriate response to the situation. Accurately identifies all critical errors in the information process under study and makes clear why the points identified are errors Provides an accurate analysis of the effects of the errors, omitting few details Provides a workable way of correcting the errors. The response addresses the major concerns raised by the errors. Accurately identifies all errors in the information or
  • 34. process under study and makes clear why the points identified are errors. Also identifies subtle but important errors that are difficult to recognize Provides an accurate analysis of the effects of the errors, including a complete description of the effects of the errors beyond the most obvious levels of impact. Provides a highly thoughtful or creative approach for correcting the errors. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 6 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
  • 35. Constructing Support Identifies information that does not require support and fails to identify a claim that should have support Fails to provide convincing evidence for the claim. Does not address qualifications or restrictions for the claim. Identifies a claim that requires support but may mistakenly include information that does not require support. Provides evidence for the claim, but may not address all necessary aspects. Qualifies or restricts the claim, but leaves out important aspects of the qualifications or restrictions.
  • 36. Accurately identifies a claim that requires support and does not confuse the claim with any other information. With no major errors, presents all relevant evidence needed to support the claim. Provides accurate qualifications or restrictions for the claim, with the result being a well-defended claim. Accurately identifies a claim that requires support. The identified claim has been mistaken by many others for a fact that requires no support. Presents a clear and accurate treatment of all available evidence that addresses the central point of the claim. Considers what evidence is missing and how it should affect an evaluation of the claim.
  • 37. Provides careful and reasoned qualifications or restrictions for the claim in such a way that the argument provides a unique perspective on the claim. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 7 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Abstracting Identifies trivial information having no identifiable pattern that can be used in the abstracting
  • 38. process Does not create a general or abstract pattern that accurately represents the information or situation selected Selects another situation or set of information that does not conform in any way to the general or abstract pattern identified. Identifies information that seems unimportant but does have a pattern that can be used in the abstracting process. Creates a general or abstract pattern that may not be a completely accurate representation of the information or situation from which it was drawn but does focus on its most important elements.
  • 39. Identifies another situation or set of information that does perfectly match the general or abstract form but has some similarities Identifies significant information that also has a pattern that lends itself to the abstracting process. Constructs a general or abstract pattern that accurately represents the information from which it came. Correctly identifies another situation or set of information that contains the essential characteristics of the general or abstract form and provides a worthwhile subject for study. Identifies a situation or information that provides a rich source of material for abstracting, which may not be commonly used, but has a pattern that could be powerful when abstracted.
  • 40. Identifies a general or abstract pattern that provides novel insights into the information studied. The pattern furnishes the means for seeing other material from a unique perspective. Demonstrates creativity in the selection of another situation or information that contains a similar general or abstract form. The situation or information is important and provides a suitable subject for analysis. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 8 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced
  • 41. Analyzing Perspectives Ignores explicit and implicit points of disagreement. Does not articulate a clear position. Does not articulate a clear opposing position. Identifies and articulates issues that are not points of disagreement as important points of disagreement. Articulates a position but does not present a clear line of reasoning behind it. Articulates an opposing position, but does not present a clear line of reasoning behind it.
  • 42. Identifies and articulates explicit points of disagreement that cause conflict. Articulates a position and the basic reasoning underlying the position. Does not address or incompletely addresses the errors or holes in the reasoning . Articulates an opposing position and the basic reasoning underlying it. Does not address or incompletely addresses the errors or holes in the reasoning. Identifies and articulates implicit points of disagreement that are not obvious but are the underlying cause of conflict. Articulates a detailed position and the reasoning behind it and, if a strong line of reasoning does not underlie the position,
  • 43. articulates the errors or holes in the reasoning. Articulates a detailed opposing position and the reasoning behind it. If a strong line of reasoning does not underlie the position, articulates the errors or holes in the reasoning. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 9 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Decision Making
  • 44. Selects alternatives that are clearly not relevant to the decision. Identifies few or no criteria that are relevant to the decision task. Does not address the extent to which the alternatives meet the criteria or is inaccurate in assessing how well the alternatives meet the criteria. Makes a selection that does not appear reasonable or cannot be justified by the student’s evaluation of the alternatives. Identifies some alternatives that are important and others that aren’t. Identifies some important criteria by which the
  • 45. identified alternatives will be assessed. However, some important criteria are omitted, or criteria are included that may not be important to the task. Does not completely address all the criteria; or applies all appropriate criteria to the alternatives but is not completely accurate in assessing how well the criteria have been met Selects an alternative that does not entirely conform to the student’s assessment of the alternatives. Identifies alternatives that represent most of the important possible alternatives. Clearly identifies the criteria by which the identified alternatives will be assessed. With no significant exceptions, the criteria are important to the decision task. Presents an accurate assessment of the extent to
  • 46. which the alternatives possess the identified criteria Successfully answers the decision question by selecting an alternative that meets or exceeds established criteria. Presents a comprehensive list of the most important possible alternatives and describes each in detail Clearly identifies the criteria by which the identified alternatives will be assessed. The criteria reflect an unusually thorough understanding of the nature of the decision task. Provides a thorough, fully developed assessment of each alternative based upon the criteria. Exceeds the demands of the decision task by comparing and contrasting the alternatives to provide greater insights Selects an alternative that meets or exceeds the criteria
  • 47. and represents a well- supported answer to the initial decision question. Provides a useful discussion of issues and insights that arose during the selection process. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 10 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Investigation Presents little or no accurate and important information about what is already known or agreed upon about the topic.
  • 48. Fails to accurately identify any important confusions, uncertainties, or contradictions surrounding the topic. Presents an unsubstantiated and implausible resolution to the confusions, uncertainties, or contradictions. Presents information on what is already known or agreed upon abut the topic being studied; however the information may not be complete in all particulars, or the student may introduce some inaccuracies. Identifies confusion, uncertainties, or contradictions associated with the topic. The problems identified include some, but not all,
  • 49. of the most critical issues. Develops and presents a resolution to the problems associated with the concept. The resolution is satisfactory, but lacks thorough treatment and accuracy. Presents an accurate account, with no important omissions, of what is already known or agreed upon about the topic being studied. Identifies, with no important errors, significant confusions, uncertainties, or contradictions surrounding the topic. Presents a clear resolution to the problems associated with the concept. The resolution is a logical and plausible outcome of the investigation. Presents a thorough and correct account of what is already known. Supplies information that may not be
  • 50. commonly known, but that has some bearing on the topic being studied. Identifies the important confusions, uncertainties or contradictions surrounding the topic. Brings to light misconceptions or confusions that are commonly overlooked. Provides a logical and well- developed resolution to the confusions, uncertainties, or contradictions. The resolution reflects creative thinking as well as thoughtful attention to the details of the problem. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 11 Thinking/Reasoning
  • 51. Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Problem Solving Omits the most significant constraints and obstacles. Presents solutions that fail to address critical parts of the problem. Does not satisfactorily test the selected solutions. Describes and illogical method for determining the relative value of the alternatives. The student does not present a reasonable review of the strengths and weaknesses of the alternative solutions that were tried and abandoned. Identifies some constraints or obstacles that are accurate along with some that are not accurate.
  • 52. Presents alternative solutions for dealing with the obstacles or constraints, but the solutions do not all address the important difficulties. Tries out the alternatives, but the trials are incomplete and important elements are omitted or ignored. Describes the processes that led to the ordering of secondary solutions. The description does not provide a clear rational for the ordering of alternatives that were tried. Accurately identifies the most important constraints or obstacles. Proposes alternative solutions that appear plausible and that address the most important constraints or obstacles. Puts the selected alternative to trials adequate to determine their utility. Describes the process that led to the ordering of secondary solutions. The description offers a clear, defensible
  • 53. rational for the ordering of alternatives, and the final selection. Accurately and thoroughly describes the relevant constraints or obstacles. Addresses obstacles or constraints that are not immediately apparent. Identifies creative but plausible solutions to the problem under consideration. The solutions address the central difficulties posed by the constraint or obstacle. Engages in effective, valid, and exhaustive trials of the selected alternatives. Trials go beyond those required to solve the problem and show a commitment to an in-depth understanding of the problem. Provides a clear, comprehensive summary of the reasoning that led to the selection of secondary solutions. The description includes a review of the decisions that produced the order of selection and how each alternative fared as a solution.
  • 54. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 12 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Experimental Inquiry Leaves out key facts, concepts, or principles in explaining phenomenon, or does not use appropriate facts, concept, or principles to explain the phenomenon. Makes a prediction that cannot be verified. Sets up and carries out an activity or experiment that does not test the central features of the prediction. The experimental design is seriously flawed and the collection of data is unlikely.
  • 55. Provides an inaccurate highly flawed explanation of how the outcome relates to the original explanation. Explains the phenomenon but misapplies or omits facts, concepts, or principles that are important for understanding the phenomenon. Makes a prediction that reflects a misunderstanding of some aspects of the facts, concepts, or principles used to explain the phenomenon, or makes a prediction that presents difficulties for verification. Sets up and carries out an activity or experiment that addresses some important aspects of the prediction, but omits others. The design of the activity or experiment produces some errors in data collection or interpretation. Provides a general explanation of the outcome
  • 56. of the activity or experiment but omits one or two important aspects, or may not effectively relate the outcome to the facts, concepts, or principles used to generate the prediction. Provides and accurate explanation of the phenomenon. The facts, concepts, or principles used in the explanation are appropriate to the phenomenon and accurately applied, with no significant errors. Makes a prediction that follows from the facts, concepts, or principles used to explain the phenomenon. The prediction can be verified. Sets up and carries out an activity or experiment that is a fair test of the prediction and addresses the most important questions raised by the prediction. The activity or experiment provides accurate data for evaluation. Provides a complete explanation of the outcome
  • 57. of the activity or experiment with no important errors. Presents the explanation in terms of the relevant facts, concepts, or principles. Provides and accurate explanation of the phenomenon. The facts, concepts, or principles used for the explanation are appropriate to the phenomenon and accurately applied. The explanation reflects thorough and careful research or understanding. Makes a verifiable prediction that reflects insight into the character of the phenomenon. The prediction is entirely appropriate to the facts, concepts, or principles used to explain the phenomenon. Sets up and carries out an experiment that is a complete and valid test of the prediction and addresses all important questions raised by the prediction. The activity or experiment is designed to provide complete and accurate data and a model of the experimental design. Provided a complete and accurate explanation of the outcome of the activity or experiment and does so in terms of the relevant facts, concepts,
  • 58. or principles. Provides insights into the nature of the phenomenon studied or the facts, concepts, and principles used to explain it. CFSD 21st Century Learning Rubric Skill: Critical & Creative Thinking Catalina Foothills School District; - 6/06; 6/08 – Adapted from Marzano, Pickering, and McTighe 13 Thinking/Reasoning Skill Novice Basic Proficient Advanced Invention Proposes a process or product that has little or no relation to the unmet need. Establishes criteria that fail to address the most important purpose of the invention.
  • 59. Sets standards so low that little quality can be expected. Makes few, if any attempts at revision and appears satisfied with the initial process or product, although obvious difficulties still remain. Finishes revising the process or product before it has met minimal standards. The process or product does not meet many important criteria and fails in its purpose. Proposes a process or product that will not adequately satisfy the unmet need. Identifies criteria for the invention that may not be completely appropriate for the product or sets standards that do not ensure a worthwhile or completed product. Revises the process or product but attempts to address only the most obvious difficulties Revises the process or product until it meets minimum standards.
  • 60. Proposes a process or product that provides a good answer to the unmet need. Establishes an appropriate set of criteria for the invention Revises the process or product in ways that serve the purpose of the process or product. Continues revising the process or product until it meets all standards and criteria. The process or product successfully serves the purpose for which it was designed. Proposes a process or product that provides a unique solution to an unmet need. The proposed process or product reflects a high level of creativity. Sets out rigorous criteria well suited to the purpose of the invention. The student identifies only the highest achievable standards of quality as acceptable outcomes.
  • 61. Reviews the process or product at a considerable level of detail. The revisions or improvements clearly bring the process or product closer to fulfilling the purpose for which it was designed. The student’s attention to the details of the draft or model makes a high-quality product likely. Develops a final process or product that meets the criteria established at a demanding level of quality. The process or product fulfills the purpose for which it was designed. In addition, the process or product reflects creativity and establishes a model for creative work of high quality.