Streamlining Python Development: A Guide to a Modern Project Setup
Β
Europe User Conference: Albemarle FCC-SIM calibration best practices
1. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
How Can I Use FCC-SIM
to Monitor My
FCC Unit Regularly?
Alan Kramer
Global FCC Modeling Specialist
KBC Software User Group Conference
2018
London
2. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
The Questions
2
β’What are the important calibration
factors?
β’How does catalyst affect calibration
factors?
β’How can I tell if my calibration factors
are any good?
β’How should I select which casesβ
calibration factors to use?
Calibration
β’How can I tell if I need to manually
tune the model?
β’How do I know what factor to adjust?
Tuning
3. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
The Questions
3
β’What are the important calibration
factors?
β’How does catalyst affect calibration
factors?
β’How can I tell if my calibration factors
are any good?
β’How should I select which casesβ
calibration factors to use?
Calibration
β’How can I tell if I need to manually
tune the model?
β’How do I know what factor to adjust?
Tuning
14. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Are My Calibration Factors Any Good?
14
β’ Correlate back to calibration input data
β’ Correct data or eliminate case
β’ Check for coincidence with catalyst change
β’ Correlate back to calibration input data
β’ Theoretically these should be flat with little variation
β’ Correlate back to calibration input data
β’ Use best judgment on input data
17. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Factor Trendplots β Flyers Example #1
17
18. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Factor Trendplots β Flyers Example #1
18
CORREL function vs Calibration Input Rows
=ABS(CORREL(range1,range2))
19. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Factor Trendplots β Flyers Example #1
19
20. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Factor Trendplots β Flyers Example #2
20
21. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Factor Trendplots β Flyers Example #2
21
25. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Which Calibration Cases to Use?
25
β’As many as possible
β’Always consider catalyst formulation
β’Averaging calibration factors
dampens variation effects
β’Superday / single-day use may
amplify variations
Which Cases Should I Use?
β’Significantly different feed rate
β’Different combustion mode
β’Catalyst transition
β’Different catalyst
Which cases should I avoid?
26. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Superday vs. Average Projection
26
β’ FCC-SIM Experiment
β’ 22 cases (weekly averages)
β’ Questionable daily data removed
1. Calibrate model for all 22 cases
2. Predict 22 cases
Β» Independent variables = same for all, average for all 22 cases
Β» Calibration factors = each casesβ individual
3. Predict 1 more case
Β» Independent variables = same as above, average for all 22 cases
Β» Calibration factors = average for all 22 cases
4. Analyze the variability in the predicted yields
27. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Superday vs. Average Projection
27
Wt% Yield Ranges Predicted with Case Calibration Factors
Yield, wt% Min -1 sigma Average
Calibration
Factors
+1 sigma Max
H2 0.1 0.10 0.12 0.13 0.15
Dry Gas 2.12 2.23 2.36 2.50 2.64
LPG 16.55 17.30 18.14 18.98 19.73
C5 β 430F
C5 β 221C
47.06 47.97 49.19 50.41 51.77
430-650F
221-343C
14.61 15.80 16.64 17.48 17.87
650F+
343C+
5.11 5.86 6.5 7.14 7.55
Regen Temp F
Regen Temp C
1270
688
1296
703
1313
712
1330
721
1336
724
28. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Superday vs. Average Projection
28
Delta wt% From Yields Predicted with Average Calibration Factors
Yield, wt% Min -1 sigma Average
Calibration
Factors
+1 sigma Max
H2 -0.02 -0.014 0.014 0.03
Dry Gas -0.24 -0.13 0.13 0.28
LPG -1.59 -0.84 0.84 1.59
C5 β 430F
C5 β 221C
-2.13 -1.22 1.22 2.58
430-650F
221-343C
-2.03 -0.84 0.84 1.23
650F+
343C+
-1.39 -0.64 0.64 1.05
Regen Temp F
Regen Temp C
-43F
-24C
-17F
-9C
17F
9C
23
13C
29. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Calibration Summary
β’ Focus on the key calibration factors.
β’ Trendplot key calibration factors always after calibrating.
β’ Calibration factor trendplots should be flat over time.
β’ Fix flyers & variability. Understand the reason for trends.
β’ Use the CORREL function to help relate calibration factors to calibration inputs.
β’ When choosing calibration cases to average:
β Use as many as possible.
β Consider the base catalyst, feed rate, combustion mode.
β’ Donβt use superdays.
29
30. Proprietary Information of Albemarle Corporation.
Revisit The Questions
30
β’What are the important calibration
factors?
β’How does catalyst affect calibration
factors?
β’How can I tell if my calibration factors
are any good?
β’How should I select which casesβ
calibration factors to use?
Calibration
β’How can I tell if I need to manually
tune the model?
β’How do I know what factor to adjust?
Tuning