SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
The Role of Science




What kind of Science is Joe Interested in?

Objective: begin to investigate the role of
Science in the narrative of Enduring Love.
• Re-read page 48, beginning with this passage: ‘In three
  hours I could break the back of my piece on narrative in
  science. I already had the outlines of a theory ...’.

• In pairs, write a list of Joe’s thoughts, and identify any
  ideas that you find difficult to understand or explain.




• Now consider McEwan’s use of oxymorons,
  metaphors, symbolism, contrast and diction
  on this page. What do you find interesting
  about Joe’s reflections? Create a map of
  techniques below, remembering to include
  quotes:
• Now read the passage on page 50 beginning:
     ‘What I had written wasn’t true. It wasn’t
     written in the pursuit of truth, it wasn’t
     science ...’
   • Using details from pages 49 and 50, what, for
     Joe, is the key difference between science and
     storytelling? Write a list of key word quotes to
     show the differences between the two. A
     couple of examples have been done for you:


Science                                         Storytelling
Re-read the passages on pp.69–70, which explain
neo-Darwinism.

• 4. Summarise neo-Darwinism in your own words
  from Joe’s information


• 5. Why do you think that neo-Darwinism is so
  attractive for Joe?
Areas of social science




                          McEwan
                                         Links
    “Pathological         uses Joe’s
                          character    between
     Extensions           to explore
                          both of      humanity
                          these
      of Love”                            and
                                       animality
‘The Pathological Extensions of Love’
•   1994 – Mullen and Pathe
•   Parts of their report are quoted by McEwan in the narrative (Enduring Love was published in 1997)


Abstract
BACKGROUND Clarification is still required of the nature of pathological love.

METHOD A series is presented of 16 personally assessed cases with pathologies of
love (erotomania).

RESULTS The pathologies of love usually involve a mixture of morbid infatuation and a
morbid belief in being loved. They occur both in a symptomatic form, as part of an
underlying mental illness, as well as in a pure form, where their emergence is to some
extent understandable in a vulnerable personality. These disorders often go
unrecognised to the detriment of clinical management.

CONCLUSIONS Pathologies of love create distress and disruption to the patient, and
place the objects of their unwarranted affection at risk of at best harassment and at
worst violence. Although this series of cases, which is drawn predominantly from
forensic practice, overemphasises the risk of overt violence, the distress occasioned by
pursuit and harassment alone should not be underestimated.
Chapter 8
Jed keeps vigil outside the apartment. Joe reports
this 'stalking' to the police and receives 29 answer
phone messages from Jed.

• In what way is this chapter ' a starting point' in
  the story?
• How has Jed's obsession developed by the end of
  the chapter?
• What do we learn about Joe's career and sense of
  failure? Why might this be important?
Chapter 9
This chapter marks a narrative shift. It is told in the
third person from Clarissa's point of view; the
narrator says, 'at least from that point as I later
construed it.' Clarissa and Joe argue about Jed.
• Why do you think McEwan has changed the
  narrative style at this point in the novel?
• What does this chapter reveal about the different
  viewpoints of Clarissa and Joe?
• How has Parry already begun to come between
  them?
• Does this chapter alter your view of events or
  change your sympathies?
• Humans’ simultaneous civilised distance from
  and animal closeness to their evolutionary
  past.
• The narrative of life on earth – one of the
  goals of Enduring Love is to convey the value
  of viewing human evolution and existence as
  part of and in terms of the planet’s natural
  world.
After Xmas
•   Group work: presentations
•   In groups, you will be exploring a significant passage from the novel. You should
    consider how best to present your ideas and notes to the rest of the class.
•   Group A
•   Explore what your passage reveals about Joe’s perspective (pp.55–56 – Joe re-
    analyses
•   the accident).
•   Group B
•   Explore what your passage contributes to the development of the plot as a whole
•   (pp.75–77 – Joe tells the story of his career).
•   Group C
•   Explore what your passage reveals about the benefits or disadvantages of looking
    at the
•   world ‘scientifically’ (pp. 163–165 – the discussion about genetics in the
    restaurant).

More Related Content

What's hot

Narrative theories and thriller conventions as
Narrative theories and thriller conventions asNarrative theories and thriller conventions as
Narrative theories and thriller conventions asruthers64
 
Seminar 2 Brokeback Mountain
Seminar 2 Brokeback MountainSeminar 2 Brokeback Mountain
Seminar 2 Brokeback MountainEmily Fisher
 
Ewrt 1 c class 26 online
Ewrt 1 c class 26 onlineEwrt 1 c class 26 online
Ewrt 1 c class 26 onlinejordanlachance
 
Narrative theory
Narrative theoryNarrative theory
Narrative theoryremismith
 
Science Fiction Readers Advisory
Science Fiction Readers AdvisoryScience Fiction Readers Advisory
Science Fiction Readers AdvisoryAmy Hartman
 
Literary analysis
Literary analysisLiterary analysis
Literary analysismanske90
 
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literature
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance LiteraturePresentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literature
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literaturepandyakaran1
 
Horror Reader's Advisory
Horror Reader's AdvisoryHorror Reader's Advisory
Horror Reader's AdvisoryAmy Hartman
 

What's hot (10)

Narrative theories and thriller conventions as
Narrative theories and thriller conventions asNarrative theories and thriller conventions as
Narrative theories and thriller conventions as
 
Theory project
Theory projectTheory project
Theory project
 
Seminar 2 Brokeback Mountain
Seminar 2 Brokeback MountainSeminar 2 Brokeback Mountain
Seminar 2 Brokeback Mountain
 
Ewrt 1 c class 26 online
Ewrt 1 c class 26 onlineEwrt 1 c class 26 online
Ewrt 1 c class 26 online
 
Narrative theory
Narrative theoryNarrative theory
Narrative theory
 
Science Fiction Readers Advisory
Science Fiction Readers AdvisoryScience Fiction Readers Advisory
Science Fiction Readers Advisory
 
Literary analysis
Literary analysisLiterary analysis
Literary analysis
 
1 popular fiction
1 popular fiction1 popular fiction
1 popular fiction
 
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literature
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance LiteraturePresentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literature
Presentation Paper 1 - Renaissance Literature
 
Horror Reader's Advisory
Horror Reader's AdvisoryHorror Reader's Advisory
Horror Reader's Advisory
 

Similar to Enduring love 4

Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay jordanlachance
 
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9Ewrt1 a f15 class 9
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9grendel8729
 
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​ (seri.docx
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​  (seri.docx10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​  (seri.docx
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​ (seri.docxchristiandean12115
 
What is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someWhat is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someJen Andreae
 
What is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someWhat is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someJen Andreae
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay jordanlachance
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay jordanlachance
 
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdf
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdfArguments Against Abortion Essay.pdf
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdfJennifer Reese
 
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you! Essay writing skills, Ess...
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you!  Essay writing skills, Ess...Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you!  Essay writing skills, Ess...
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you! Essay writing skills, Ess...Susan Neal
 
Narrative research
Narrative researchNarrative research
Narrative researchEko_Mulyono
 
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdf
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdfDescribe My Best Friend Essay.pdf
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdfErin Byers
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay jordanlachance
 
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essay
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective EssaySamples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essay
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essaybdg8266a
 
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docx
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docxEnglish Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docx
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docxkhanpaulita
 

Similar to Enduring love 4 (20)

Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay
 
Class 9 1 a
Class 9 1 aClass 9 1 a
Class 9 1 a
 
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9Ewrt1 a f15 class 9
Ewrt1 a f15 class 9
 
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​ (seri.docx
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​  (seri.docx10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​  (seri.docx
10 ELEMENTS OF LITERATURE (FROM A TO Z)   1  ​PLOT​ (seri.docx
 
What is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someWhat is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get some
 
What is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get someWhat is analysis and where can i get some
What is analysis and where can i get some
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay
 
Class 20 1 a
Class 20 1 aClass 20 1 a
Class 20 1 a
 
1 a 27
1 a 271 a 27
1 a 27
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay
 
Class 27
Class 27Class 27
Class 27
 
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdf
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdfArguments Against Abortion Essay.pdf
Arguments Against Abortion Essay.pdf
 
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you! Essay writing skills, Ess...
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you!  Essay writing skills, Ess...Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you!  Essay writing skills, Ess...
Games Essay Writing. Video games are good for you! Essay writing skills, Ess...
 
Narrative research
Narrative researchNarrative research
Narrative research
 
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdf
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdfDescribe My Best Friend Essay.pdf
Describe My Best Friend Essay.pdf
 
Class 10 n concept essay
Class 10 n  concept essay Class 10 n  concept essay
Class 10 n concept essay
 
Ewrt1b class16 qhq
Ewrt1b class16 qhqEwrt1b class16 qhq
Ewrt1b class16 qhq
 
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essay
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective EssaySamples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essay
Samples Of Reflective Essays. Reflective Essay
 
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docx
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docxEnglish Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docx
English Assignments (4 assignments) Description of eac.docx
 
Enduring love pri
Enduring love   priEnduring love   pri
Enduring love pri
 

More from jorawlings

Stretch and Challenge
Stretch and ChallengeStretch and Challenge
Stretch and Challengejorawlings
 
Data presentation for minibite
Data presentation for minibiteData presentation for minibite
Data presentation for minibitejorawlings
 
Challenge toolkit[1]
Challenge toolkit[1]Challenge toolkit[1]
Challenge toolkit[1]jorawlings
 
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)jorawlings
 
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)jorawlings
 
English plc template 9 oct-13
English plc template 9 oct-13English plc template 9 oct-13
English plc template 9 oct-13jorawlings
 
Year 9 lesson 25th june
Year 9 lesson 25th juneYear 9 lesson 25th june
Year 9 lesson 25th junejorawlings
 
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copyjorawlings
 
Planning minibite
Planning minibitePlanning minibite
Planning minibitejorawlings
 
Discussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitDiscussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitjorawlings
 
Green pen mini bite
Green pen mini biteGreen pen mini bite
Green pen mini bitejorawlings
 
Cracking section b
Cracking section bCracking section b
Cracking section bjorawlings
 
Sharing success criteria for language tutorial
Sharing success criteria for language tutorialSharing success criteria for language tutorial
Sharing success criteria for language tutorialjorawlings
 
Lit mats pp copy
Lit mats pp copyLit mats pp copy
Lit mats pp copyjorawlings
 
Section b lucky dip
Section b lucky dipSection b lucky dip
Section b lucky dipjorawlings
 
Tuesday 12 eve of 1
Tuesday 12 eve of 1Tuesday 12 eve of 1
Tuesday 12 eve of 1jorawlings
 
Friday 8th march close textual analysis
Friday 8th march close textual analysisFriday 8th march close textual analysis
Friday 8th march close textual analysisjorawlings
 

More from jorawlings (20)

Stretch and Challenge
Stretch and ChallengeStretch and Challenge
Stretch and Challenge
 
Data presentation for minibite
Data presentation for minibiteData presentation for minibite
Data presentation for minibite
 
Challenge toolkit[1]
Challenge toolkit[1]Challenge toolkit[1]
Challenge toolkit[1]
 
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)
Example of science gcse unit front sheet (zs)
 
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)
Example of science gcse lesson checklist 3 (zs)
 
English plc template 9 oct-13
English plc template 9 oct-13English plc template 9 oct-13
English plc template 9 oct-13
 
Plc's
Plc'sPlc's
Plc's
 
Year 9 lesson 25th june
Year 9 lesson 25th juneYear 9 lesson 25th june
Year 9 lesson 25th june
 
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy
11 e ge1 2013-14 v1[1] copy
 
Planning minibite
Planning minibitePlanning minibite
Planning minibite
 
Discussion toolkit
Discussion toolkitDiscussion toolkit
Discussion toolkit
 
Talk
TalkTalk
Talk
 
Green pen mini bite
Green pen mini biteGreen pen mini bite
Green pen mini bite
 
Cracking section b
Cracking section bCracking section b
Cracking section b
 
Sharing success criteria for language tutorial
Sharing success criteria for language tutorialSharing success criteria for language tutorial
Sharing success criteria for language tutorial
 
Lit mats pp copy
Lit mats pp copyLit mats pp copy
Lit mats pp copy
 
Section b lucky dip
Section b lucky dipSection b lucky dip
Section b lucky dip
 
Doc1
Doc1Doc1
Doc1
 
Tuesday 12 eve of 1
Tuesday 12 eve of 1Tuesday 12 eve of 1
Tuesday 12 eve of 1
 
Friday 8th march close textual analysis
Friday 8th march close textual analysisFriday 8th march close textual analysis
Friday 8th march close textual analysis
 

Enduring love 4

  • 1. The Role of Science What kind of Science is Joe Interested in? Objective: begin to investigate the role of Science in the narrative of Enduring Love.
  • 2. • Re-read page 48, beginning with this passage: ‘In three hours I could break the back of my piece on narrative in science. I already had the outlines of a theory ...’. • In pairs, write a list of Joe’s thoughts, and identify any ideas that you find difficult to understand or explain.    
  • 3. • Now consider McEwan’s use of oxymorons, metaphors, symbolism, contrast and diction on this page. What do you find interesting about Joe’s reflections? Create a map of techniques below, remembering to include quotes:
  • 4. • Now read the passage on page 50 beginning: ‘What I had written wasn’t true. It wasn’t written in the pursuit of truth, it wasn’t science ...’ • Using details from pages 49 and 50, what, for Joe, is the key difference between science and storytelling? Write a list of key word quotes to show the differences between the two. A couple of examples have been done for you: Science Storytelling
  • 5. Re-read the passages on pp.69–70, which explain neo-Darwinism. • 4. Summarise neo-Darwinism in your own words from Joe’s information • 5. Why do you think that neo-Darwinism is so attractive for Joe?
  • 6. Areas of social science McEwan Links “Pathological uses Joe’s character between Extensions to explore both of humanity these of Love” and animality
  • 7. ‘The Pathological Extensions of Love’ • 1994 – Mullen and Pathe • Parts of their report are quoted by McEwan in the narrative (Enduring Love was published in 1997) Abstract BACKGROUND Clarification is still required of the nature of pathological love. METHOD A series is presented of 16 personally assessed cases with pathologies of love (erotomania). RESULTS The pathologies of love usually involve a mixture of morbid infatuation and a morbid belief in being loved. They occur both in a symptomatic form, as part of an underlying mental illness, as well as in a pure form, where their emergence is to some extent understandable in a vulnerable personality. These disorders often go unrecognised to the detriment of clinical management. CONCLUSIONS Pathologies of love create distress and disruption to the patient, and place the objects of their unwarranted affection at risk of at best harassment and at worst violence. Although this series of cases, which is drawn predominantly from forensic practice, overemphasises the risk of overt violence, the distress occasioned by pursuit and harassment alone should not be underestimated.
  • 8. Chapter 8 Jed keeps vigil outside the apartment. Joe reports this 'stalking' to the police and receives 29 answer phone messages from Jed. • In what way is this chapter ' a starting point' in the story? • How has Jed's obsession developed by the end of the chapter? • What do we learn about Joe's career and sense of failure? Why might this be important?
  • 9. Chapter 9 This chapter marks a narrative shift. It is told in the third person from Clarissa's point of view; the narrator says, 'at least from that point as I later construed it.' Clarissa and Joe argue about Jed. • Why do you think McEwan has changed the narrative style at this point in the novel? • What does this chapter reveal about the different viewpoints of Clarissa and Joe? • How has Parry already begun to come between them? • Does this chapter alter your view of events or change your sympathies?
  • 10. • Humans’ simultaneous civilised distance from and animal closeness to their evolutionary past. • The narrative of life on earth – one of the goals of Enduring Love is to convey the value of viewing human evolution and existence as part of and in terms of the planet’s natural world.
  • 11. After Xmas • Group work: presentations • In groups, you will be exploring a significant passage from the novel. You should consider how best to present your ideas and notes to the rest of the class. • Group A • Explore what your passage reveals about Joe’s perspective (pp.55–56 – Joe re- analyses • the accident). • Group B • Explore what your passage contributes to the development of the plot as a whole • (pp.75–77 – Joe tells the story of his career). • Group C • Explore what your passage reveals about the benefits or disadvantages of looking at the • world ‘scientifically’ (pp. 163–165 – the discussion about genetics in the restaurant).