Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)

IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
in an era of Post Truth
Information Literacy
AUTHENTIC
@acarbery
CONTEXT
Embedded instruction reaching every student
SEVEN TIMES
throughout their undergraduate studies
EVERY STUDENT,
EVERY STUDENT,
SEVEN TIMES
EVERY STUDENT,
SEVEN TIMES
(in some cases, 9)
Program of instruction that relies on
15 UNIQUE, SEPARATE
information literacy lessons
EVER
Luckiest librarian
We’re teaching
BUT ARE STUDENTS LEARNING?
AUTHENTIC
Assessment
to understand students’ information literacy
Leveraging
ACTUAL STUDENT COURSEWORK
When asked to do so, students generally choose
academic, peer-reviewed sources
for their research papers
Students generally
CITE & ATTRIBUTE
their sources when the assignment is designed
to encourage them to do so
In other words…
In other words…
When a student is specifically
asked to do something,
In other words…
When a student is specifically
asked to do something,
when there are real grades at stake,
In other words…
When a student is specifically
asked to do something,
when there are real grades at stake,
they are more likely to perform
positively in information literacy
But what about when they’re not specifically
asked?
How much of our teaching actually sticks?
What about the
long-term
applicability
of our
instructional
efforts?
NEWS EVER!
MOST
DEPRESSING
RUDIMENTARY CONCEPTS
Early in their development, students can display
of information literacy
“This author is credible,
because they have a PhD”
But what does that mean for the
real-world context?
“This article is from the
New York Times,
therefore it's credible.”
Or well known?
CREDIBLE?
How "simplistic" is our approach to
teaching information literacy?
SCHOLARLY
vsPOPULAR
SCHOLARLY
vsPOPULAR
(resist the binary)
How much of our
teaching is library centric?
Do we care that our users know
what the definition of a periodical
is? How to search the OPAC?
How much of our teaching is
academic-centric?
Is our information literacy instruction
GENUINE, MEANINGFUL
and AUTHENTIC?
We ride the coattails of “lifelong
learning”, but can we genuinely
claim success in this?
showing students how to search
EBSCO & Proquest products.
HOURS OF TEACHING EFFORT
We're spending
How is this setting them up for
workplace success? Success in
the real world? Prepared for
civic duty?
When they're unlikely to have access
to EBSCO & Proquest after they
graduate?!?
What does it look like for us to be info-
centric instead of library-centric?
critical information literacy
REAL WORLD
Using our profession to impact
our community
Highlighting issues of
RACISM & PREDJUDICE
in information landscapes
What does the
western perspective
look like?
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
“EVILS OF CHINESE IMMIGRATION”
human
trafficking
IL for understanding
from a local perspective
facilitating access to
survivor stories
not often heard
as perpetuated in information
GENDER INEQUALITY
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Ideas of power
in gender, as expressed
through information
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
information literacy for
SOCIAL JUSTICE
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
our students care
about these issues
Jan 23rd 2017
This is a real-world
information literacy
problem
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Speaking truth to power
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
in the unlikeliest places…
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
your move,
mainstream media
your move,
scholars
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Information Literacy as it impacts our
EVERYDAY LIVES
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
2017: The year the filter bubble chicken
came home to roost
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Fake News: ANNOYING
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Fake News: OXYMORON
Fake News?
Fake News:
EVOLVING CONCEPT
evolving concept
DANGEROUSLY
When did we start talking
about fake news?
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Actually, just in the last 6 months
IFLA’s Guide to
Spotting
FAKE NEWS
false information
Fake news is
NO LONGER ABOUT
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Fake news can no longer
be fixed by a
CRAP test or a LibGuide
Fake news as a moniker for
“I don’t agree with you”
and I REJECT your premise,
outright.
As consumers, we've positioned
ourselves to discount the credibility
of information just because we
disagree with it.
TO CONSUME IDEAS
& INFORMATION
We've lost the ability
that we don't agree with.
filter bubble!
We’ve created an
analog version of our
is an information literacy problem
THIS
A REAL-WORLD
information literacy problem
Despite overwhelming
evidence, what makes us vote
against our best interests?
Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)
Information as distraction
The consumption of
information is evolving
in complex & new ways
How do we to
teach strategies
to address this?
CURIOSITY & INQUIRY
question-centric
teaching
Imagine a scenario where we're
teaching information literacy, not to
know how to use the library, or search
a database, or find information...
but instead, we’re
teaching students to be
questioning,
open & curious;
that we're teaching information literacy so our
students are asking & answering questions about
the world.
Imagine information literacy
as a tool or a mechanism
for curiosity and inquiry
to become engaged,
informed global citizens
Information literacy at
the heart of learning
Information literacy at
the heart of citizenship
We can construct
this world
Do not let
STRUCTURE & TRADITION
be the thing that guides your values as an educator
Alan Carbery
@acarbery
acarbery@champlain.edu
1 of 120

Recommended

Embedding information literacy through critical skills and a new curriculum -... by
Embedding information literacy through critical skills and a new curriculum -...Embedding information literacy through critical skills and a new curriculum -...
Embedding information literacy through critical skills and a new curriculum -...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
966 views18 slides
Adopting and developing an information literacy framework at Maynooth Univers... by
Adopting and developing an information literacy framework at Maynooth Univers...Adopting and developing an information literacy framework at Maynooth Univers...
Adopting and developing an information literacy framework at Maynooth Univers...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
1.3K views22 slides
Discovering the reality from the myth – how PGRs “really” find and use inform... by
Discovering the reality from the myth – how PGRs “really” find and use inform...Discovering the reality from the myth – how PGRs “really” find and use inform...
Discovering the reality from the myth – how PGRs “really” find and use inform...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
386 views44 slides
From secondary education to beyond: information literacy to support young peo... by
From secondary education to beyond: information literacy to support young peo...From secondary education to beyond: information literacy to support young peo...
From secondary education to beyond: information literacy to support young peo...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
540 views39 slides
Do faculty and librarians see information literacy in the same way - Chin & W... by
Do faculty and librarians see information literacy in the same way - Chin & W...Do faculty and librarians see information literacy in the same way - Chin & W...
Do faculty and librarians see information literacy in the same way - Chin & W...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
679 views25 slides
Embedding interventions for better critical writing and reading: collaboratio... by
Embedding interventions for better critical writing and reading: collaboratio...Embedding interventions for better critical writing and reading: collaboratio...
Embedding interventions for better critical writing and reading: collaboratio...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
392 views16 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Cultivate the ground before the plant: developing an organic environment for ... by
Cultivate the ground before the plant: developing an organic environment for ...Cultivate the ground before the plant: developing an organic environment for ...
Cultivate the ground before the plant: developing an organic environment for ...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
352 views30 slides
Online reading lists: encouraging staff engagement to improve student informa... by
Online reading lists: encouraging staff engagement to improve student informa...Online reading lists: encouraging staff engagement to improve student informa...
Online reading lists: encouraging staff engagement to improve student informa...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
644 views50 slides
Students as positive disruptors: co-developing an Information and Digital Lit... by
Students as positive disruptors: co-developing an Information and Digital Lit...Students as positive disruptors: co-developing an Information and Digital Lit...
Students as positive disruptors: co-developing an Information and Digital Lit...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
602 views23 slides
Mission Impossible? Transforming library induction into learning - Eveson by
Mission Impossible? Transforming library induction into learning - EvesonMission Impossible? Transforming library induction into learning - Eveson
Mission Impossible? Transforming library induction into learning - EvesonIL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
657 views19 slides
Road mapping the digital jungle - Pickard, Walton, Dobbs & Hepworth by
Road mapping the digital jungle - Pickard, Walton, Dobbs & HepworthRoad mapping the digital jungle - Pickard, Walton, Dobbs & Hepworth
Road mapping the digital jungle - Pickard, Walton, Dobbs & HepworthIL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
699 views21 slides
Talking their language… critical practice and its impact on academic liaison ... by
Talking their language… critical practice and its impact on academic liaison ...Talking their language… critical practice and its impact on academic liaison ...
Talking their language… critical practice and its impact on academic liaison ...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
380 views19 slides

What's hot(20)

Where’s the Librarian? Expanding Beyond the Library Through Research & Techno... by Elizabeth Dolinger
Where’s the Librarian? Expanding Beyond the Library Through Research & Techno...Where’s the Librarian? Expanding Beyond the Library Through Research & Techno...
Where’s the Librarian? Expanding Beyond the Library Through Research & Techno...
Elizabeth Dolinger1.5K views
Leaving the one shot behind . sustainability final by Elizabeth Dolinger
Leaving the one shot behind . sustainability finalLeaving the one shot behind . sustainability final
Leaving the one shot behind . sustainability final
Elizabeth Dolinger1.5K views
Gales secondary resources for NOVELny the basics and more by NassauSLS
Gales secondary resources for NOVELny the basics and moreGales secondary resources for NOVELny the basics and more
Gales secondary resources for NOVELny the basics and more
NassauSLS1.3K views
Unh il lesson plan design & assessment by Elizabeth Dolinger
Unh il lesson plan design & assessment Unh il lesson plan design & assessment
Unh il lesson plan design & assessment
Elizabeth Dolinger1.3K views
Evidence-based Practice for School Libraries by NassauSLS
Evidence-based Practice for School LibrariesEvidence-based Practice for School Libraries
Evidence-based Practice for School Libraries
NassauSLS1.5K views
Transforming Information Literacy Spaces Through Collaboration by Senga White
Transforming Information Literacy Spaces Through CollaborationTransforming Information Literacy Spaces Through Collaboration
Transforming Information Literacy Spaces Through Collaboration
Senga White325 views

Similar to Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)

Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truth by
Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truthMedia and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truth
Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truthCILIP Ireland
24 views37 slides
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truth by
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truthMedia and information literacy: an inconvenient truth
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truthAlan Carbery
476 views37 slides
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges. by
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges. Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges.
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges. davidshumaker
1.6K views32 slides
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it means by
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it meansPushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it means
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it meanssi641
1.1K views100 slides
How it works by
How it worksHow it works
How it worksAlejandra Ayala
42 views1 slide
Child Well Educated by
Child Well EducatedChild Well Educated
Child Well EducatedMisty Gordon
2 views40 slides

Similar to Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)(20)

Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truth by CILIP Ireland
Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truthMedia and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truth
Media and Information Literacy: an inconvenient truth
CILIP Ireland 24 views
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truth by Alan Carbery
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truthMedia and information literacy: an inconvenient truth
Media and information literacy: an inconvenient truth
Alan Carbery476 views
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges. by davidshumaker
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges. Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges.
Embedded Librarians: Diverse Initiatives, Common Challenges.
davidshumaker1.6K views
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it means by si641
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it meansPushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it means
Pushback: Information literacy does not mean what you think it means
si6411.1K views
The Community Services Librarian At The Chicopee Public... by Lana Stefanich
The Community Services Librarian At The Chicopee Public...The Community Services Librarian At The Chicopee Public...
The Community Services Librarian At The Chicopee Public...
Lana Stefanich2 views
Education Has Lost Touch With Its Origin And Its Meaning... by Jennifer Campbell
 Education Has Lost Touch With Its Origin And Its Meaning... Education Has Lost Touch With Its Origin And Its Meaning...
Education Has Lost Touch With Its Origin And Its Meaning...
Gifted Education And Funding Essay by Jeanne Hall
Gifted Education And Funding EssayGifted Education And Funding Essay
Gifted Education And Funding Essay
Jeanne Hall2 views
Content with your Content? Why Teach Global Issues in ELT? by Susan Hillyard
Content with your Content?  Why Teach Global Issues in ELT?Content with your Content?  Why Teach Global Issues in ELT?
Content with your Content? Why Teach Global Issues in ELT?
Susan Hillyard2.8K views
Students Worlds Quotes by dwarlick
Students Worlds QuotesStudents Worlds Quotes
Students Worlds Quotes
dwarlick1K views
Concept Based Adult Learning Theory by Amanda Gray
Concept Based Adult Learning TheoryConcept Based Adult Learning Theory
Concept Based Adult Learning Theory
Amanda Gray2 views
Sociological Perspective Of False Consciousness by Julie Jones
Sociological Perspective Of False ConsciousnessSociological Perspective Of False Consciousness
Sociological Perspective Of False Consciousness
Julie Jones2 views

More from IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)

Flierl, M. Mis-Information and dis-Information on Social Media: What are we t... by
Flierl, M. Mis-Information and dis-Information on Social Media: What are we t...Flierl, M. Mis-Information and dis-Information on Social Media: What are we t...
Flierl, M. Mis-Information and dis-Information on Social Media: What are we t...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
54 views16 slides
Linsey, S., Southern, L. & Dawson, L. Health Literacy – a Key Life Skill for All by
Linsey, S., Southern, L. & Dawson, L. Health Literacy – a Key Life Skill for AllLinsey, S., Southern, L. & Dawson, L. Health Literacy – a Key Life Skill for All
Linsey, S., Southern, L. & Dawson, L. Health Literacy – a Key Life Skill for AllIL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
24 views1 slide
Jackson, B. Recipe for Success: Delivering bite-size information skills train... by
Jackson, B. Recipe for Success: Delivering bite-size information skills train...Jackson, B. Recipe for Success: Delivering bite-size information skills train...
Jackson, B. Recipe for Success: Delivering bite-size information skills train...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
32 views1 slide
Chen, S. Collaborating with Students: Reflections on University College Cork ... by
Chen, S. Collaborating with Students: Reflections on University College Cork ...Chen, S. Collaborating with Students: Reflections on University College Cork ...
Chen, S. Collaborating with Students: Reflections on University College Cork ...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
25 views1 slide
Hornshaw, R. An Information Literacy skill tree- a tool for engaging students by
Hornshaw, R. An Information Literacy skill tree- a tool for engaging studentsHornshaw, R. An Information Literacy skill tree- a tool for engaging students
Hornshaw, R. An Information Literacy skill tree- a tool for engaging studentsIL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
62 views1 slide
Crow, R. Libraries are not neutral: A pocket sized guide to libraries and the... by
Crow, R. Libraries are not neutral: A pocket sized guide to libraries and the...Crow, R. Libraries are not neutral: A pocket sized guide to libraries and the...
Crow, R. Libraries are not neutral: A pocket sized guide to libraries and the...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
46 views2 slides

More from IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)(20)

Recently uploaded

Dance KS5 Breakdown by
Dance KS5 BreakdownDance KS5 Breakdown
Dance KS5 BreakdownWestHatch
68 views2 slides
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx by
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptxmary850239
281 views25 slides
Collective Bargaining and Understanding a Teacher Contract(16793704.1).pptx by
Collective Bargaining and Understanding a Teacher Contract(16793704.1).pptxCollective Bargaining and Understanding a Teacher Contract(16793704.1).pptx
Collective Bargaining and Understanding a Teacher Contract(16793704.1).pptxCenter for Integrated Training & Education
90 views57 slides
Recap of our Class by
Recap of our ClassRecap of our Class
Recap of our ClassCorinne Weisgerber
73 views15 slides
Drama KS5 Breakdown by
Drama KS5 BreakdownDrama KS5 Breakdown
Drama KS5 BreakdownWestHatch
71 views2 slides
Narration ppt.pptx by
Narration  ppt.pptxNarration  ppt.pptx
Narration ppt.pptxTARIQ KHAN
119 views24 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Dance KS5 Breakdown by WestHatch
Dance KS5 BreakdownDance KS5 Breakdown
Dance KS5 Breakdown
WestHatch68 views
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx by mary850239
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx
mary850239281 views
Drama KS5 Breakdown by WestHatch
Drama KS5 BreakdownDrama KS5 Breakdown
Drama KS5 Breakdown
WestHatch71 views
Narration ppt.pptx by TARIQ KHAN
Narration  ppt.pptxNarration  ppt.pptx
Narration ppt.pptx
TARIQ KHAN119 views
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau by DivyaSheta
The Accursed House  by Émile GaboriauThe Accursed House  by Émile Gaboriau
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau
DivyaSheta158 views
Class 10 English lesson plans by TARIQ KHAN
Class 10 English  lesson plansClass 10 English  lesson plans
Class 10 English lesson plans
TARIQ KHAN257 views
The Open Access Community Framework (OACF) 2023 (1).pptx by Jisc
The Open Access Community Framework (OACF) 2023 (1).pptxThe Open Access Community Framework (OACF) 2023 (1).pptx
The Open Access Community Framework (OACF) 2023 (1).pptx
Jisc85 views
OEB 2023 Co-learning To Speed Up AI Implementation in Courses.pptx by Inge de Waard
OEB 2023 Co-learning To Speed Up AI Implementation in Courses.pptxOEB 2023 Co-learning To Speed Up AI Implementation in Courses.pptx
OEB 2023 Co-learning To Speed Up AI Implementation in Courses.pptx
Inge de Waard167 views
Are we onboard yet University of Sussex.pptx by Jisc
Are we onboard yet University of Sussex.pptxAre we onboard yet University of Sussex.pptx
Are we onboard yet University of Sussex.pptx
Jisc77 views
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx by iammrhaywood
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptxAUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx
iammrhaywood69 views
7 NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM.pptx by Sachin Nitave
7 NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM.pptx7 NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM.pptx
7 NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM.pptx
Sachin Nitave58 views
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx by Rommel Regala
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptxCh. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx
Rommel Regala72 views
Community-led Open Access Publishing webinar.pptx by Jisc
Community-led Open Access Publishing webinar.pptxCommunity-led Open Access Publishing webinar.pptx
Community-led Open Access Publishing webinar.pptx
Jisc74 views
Scope of Biochemistry.pptx by shoba shoba
Scope of Biochemistry.pptxScope of Biochemistry.pptx
Scope of Biochemistry.pptx
shoba shoba124 views

Authentic information literacy in an era of post truth - Alan Carbery (LILAC 2017 keynote speaker)