SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Planning and executing your
                                    first eye-tracking study
                                                              BayCHI BoF meeting
                                                                   June 22, 2010




Frances Karandy, Lead UER Researcher | eBay, Inc.
Prasad Kantamneni, Principal Architect: Human Perception Center of Excellence | Yahoo, Inc.
Agenda

• When is eye tracking useful?

• The top 5 things I learned…

• Q & A discussion
About us…

Frances Karandy                            Prasad Kantamneni
• Recently, joined        as Lead          • Principal architect of the eye-
  UER Researcher, BEX (2010)                 tracking platform at

• Formerly, Staff Researcher,          ,   • Has run dozens of eye tracking
  AdUx, Applications & Platforms             tests for multiple Y! products
  (2005-2010)                                across the globe

• Has run a few eye tracking studies
So, when is eye tracking useful?

 • To bridge gaps between behavioral
   and qualitative data



 • For obtaining information that is
   normally difficult to get from
   participants

 • For providing an accelerated
   learning curve in a domain
Top 5 things I learned in my first study…

1. Planning will define your success

2. Focus on the models, not the details

3. Think iteratively on hypothesis and study approach

4. Corroborate your study with other studies –powerful when
   done right!

5. Don’t expect to get it right the first time, or the second…
Planning will define your success
• A fly without wings cannot hear!
   – Think of the principles driving
     behaviors
Planning will define your success
• Illusion of functionality is important
   – Level of functionality or fidelity
     needed depends on your question


• Test for contrasting conditions

• Consider natural vs. canned tasks
   – Bar increases as you get closer to
     launch!
Focus on the models, not the details

• Eye-tracking is extremely effective in building mental models
   – Step back to get the bigger picture
   – Even if you have specific study objectives, larger context will
     provide rationale for details and actions
   – You may generate a whole new set of insights, or research
     questions…
Think iteratively on hypothesis and approach

 • Take a data-to-theory (inductive)
   approach
    – Start out with initial hypotheses
    – Use the data to organically inform,
      change, and narrow your
      hypothesis


 • Think in terms of series of studies
   to allow for stimuli refinement

 • Set expectations upfront with
   stakeholders to plan for additional
   resources (time, participants, etc.)
Corroborate your study with other studies
 • Eye tracking is not a good standalone source of truth

 • Must triangulate this data with other methods and proof
   points
    – What one participant says → across other participants
    – What you are observing in the data → supported with
      theory
    – Aligning eye tracking results → established findings
      from qualitative , quantitative and/or behavioral data

 • Thoughtful planning, execution, and analysis can lead to
   dramatic improvements in the user experience and
   revenue in a very short period of time!
Don’t expect to get it all right the first time…

                        • Give yourself extra time and the
                          room to develop skills!
                           – If something can go wrong it will
                           – Learning curve is not the same as
                             e.g., usability testing
                           – As a manager, give your reports
                             the time to learn
 …or even the second!
                        • Don’t over generalize findings and
                          observations, or you may risk
                          credibility
Discussion | Q & A




Frances Karandy, fkarandy (at) ebay.com
Prasad Kantamneni, kprasad (at) yahoo-inc.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2
Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2
Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2TSTC Publishing
 
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
Scholarship of Teaching and LearningScholarship of Teaching and Learning
Scholarship of Teaching and LearningStaci Trekles
 
Talk for 360 Camera ITS
Talk for 360 Camera ITSTalk for 360 Camera ITS
Talk for 360 Camera ITSBC Chew
 
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...Center for Evidence-Based Management
 
Active learning strategies in the era of distance
Active learning strategies in the era of distanceActive learning strategies in the era of distance
Active learning strategies in the era of distanceHannah Darcy
 
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus Nurse
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus NurseCritical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus Nurse
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus NurseThe Higher Education Academy
 
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations: Why we need it and why some...
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations:  Why we need it and why some...Evidence-based decision-making in organizations:  Why we need it and why some...
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations: Why we need it and why some...Center for Evidence-Based Management
 
Portigal 2011 uie vs preview
Portigal 2011 uie vs previewPortigal 2011 uie vs preview
Portigal 2011 uie vs previewUIEpreviews
 
Web tools for inquiry learning
Web tools for inquiry learningWeb tools for inquiry learning
Web tools for inquiry learningvcrouch
 
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program   tanejaHow to succeed in the AU REU program   taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program tanejaShubbhi Taneja
 
Web tools for inquiry learning ozelive
Web tools for inquiry learning ozeliveWeb tools for inquiry learning ozelive
Web tools for inquiry learning ozelivevcrouch
 

What's hot (18)

Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2
Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2
Taking Charge (2nd ed.), Chapter 5.2
 
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
Scholarship of Teaching and LearningScholarship of Teaching and Learning
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
 
Talk for 360 Camera ITS
Talk for 360 Camera ITSTalk for 360 Camera ITS
Talk for 360 Camera ITS
 
Fontys - EBMgt Master Healthy Ageing
Fontys - EBMgt Master Healthy AgeingFontys - EBMgt Master Healthy Ageing
Fontys - EBMgt Master Healthy Ageing
 
Slide
SlideSlide
Slide
 
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...
Bridging The Research-Practice Gap Through Evidence-Based Management And Syst...
 
Active learning strategies in the era of distance
Active learning strategies in the era of distanceActive learning strategies in the era of distance
Active learning strategies in the era of distance
 
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus Nurse
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus NurseCritical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus Nurse
Critical thinking in action. The case study approach - Angus Nurse
 
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations: Why we need it and why some...
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations:  Why we need it and why some...Evidence-based decision-making in organizations:  Why we need it and why some...
Evidence-based decision-making in organizations: Why we need it and why some...
 
Evidence-Based Practice, Evidence From Key Domains: Management
Evidence-Based Practice, Evidence From Key Domains: ManagementEvidence-Based Practice, Evidence From Key Domains: Management
Evidence-Based Practice, Evidence From Key Domains: Management
 
Portigal 2011 uie vs preview
Portigal 2011 uie vs previewPortigal 2011 uie vs preview
Portigal 2011 uie vs preview
 
Web tools for inquiry learning
Web tools for inquiry learningWeb tools for inquiry learning
Web tools for inquiry learning
 
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program   tanejaHow to succeed in the AU REU program   taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
 
Web tools for inquiry learning ozelive
Web tools for inquiry learning ozeliveWeb tools for inquiry learning ozelive
Web tools for inquiry learning ozelive
 
Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Teaching Evidence-Based ManagementTeaching Evidence-Based Management
Teaching Evidence-Based Management
 
Game Learning Webinar by Greenbooks & Gamelearn
Game Learning Webinar by Greenbooks & GamelearnGame Learning Webinar by Greenbooks & Gamelearn
Game Learning Webinar by Greenbooks & Gamelearn
 
2015 ed psy 510 #7
2015 ed psy 510 #72015 ed psy 510 #7
2015 ed psy 510 #7
 
Posters Evidence-Based Management, AOM Philadelphia 2014
Posters Evidence-Based Management, AOM Philadelphia 2014Posters Evidence-Based Management, AOM Philadelphia 2014
Posters Evidence-Based Management, AOM Philadelphia 2014
 

Similar to Planning your first eye-tracking study

Gold standards for frog
Gold standards for frogGold standards for frog
Gold standards for frogJacquiT
 
How to do research?
How to do research?How to do research?
How to do research?Xiao Qin
 
Project manual
Project manualProject manual
Project manualSyed Awais
 
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation Phase
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation PhaseIBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation Phase
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation PhaseSteven Gaynor
 
Honours presentation Version 1
Honours presentation Version 1Honours presentation Version 1
Honours presentation Version 1vogmae
 
Training Program Evaluation
Training Program EvaluationTraining Program Evaluation
Training Program EvaluationLaura Pasquini
 
Collaborative action research
Collaborative action researchCollaborative action research
Collaborative action researchJohan Koren
 
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11MattLumley
 
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship ProgramsTools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship ProgramsWest Muse
 
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_full
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_fullSelling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_full
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_fullAllison Bloodworth
 
Digital learning: an overview
Digital learning: an overviewDigital learning: an overview
Digital learning: an overviewMartin Bazley
 
Learn Learning + Prototype Testing
Learn Learning + Prototype TestingLearn Learning + Prototype Testing
Learn Learning + Prototype TestingDave Hora
 
AdvaMed Summit
AdvaMed SummitAdvaMed Summit
AdvaMed SummitKarl Kapp
 
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2 22.01.15
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2   22.01.15Working Scientifically - Investigations 2   22.01.15
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2 22.01.15Barnsleytsa
 
Metodologi penelitian 1 adli anwar
Metodologi penelitian 1   adli anwarMetodologi penelitian 1   adli anwar
Metodologi penelitian 1 adli anwarHarwindra Yoga
 
Action research
Action researchAction research
Action researchAJAL A J
 
Crocker.lori
Crocker.loriCrocker.lori
Crocker.loriNASAPMC
 
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after Time
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after TimeBecoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after Time
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after TimeLambda Solutions
 

Similar to Planning your first eye-tracking study (20)

Gold standards for frog
Gold standards for frogGold standards for frog
Gold standards for frog
 
How to do research?
How to do research?How to do research?
How to do research?
 
Project manual
Project manualProject manual
Project manual
 
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation Phase
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation PhaseIBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation Phase
IBDP Group 4 Project: Bad Science Implementation Phase
 
Honours presentation Version 1
Honours presentation Version 1Honours presentation Version 1
Honours presentation Version 1
 
Training Program Evaluation
Training Program EvaluationTraining Program Evaluation
Training Program Evaluation
 
Collaborative action research
Collaborative action researchCollaborative action research
Collaborative action research
 
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11
Unit 1 research methods worksheet y11
 
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship ProgramsTools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
 
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_full
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_fullSelling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_full
Selling userneedsassessment 7-30-07_full
 
Digital learning: an overview
Digital learning: an overviewDigital learning: an overview
Digital learning: an overview
 
Learn Learning + Prototype Testing
Learn Learning + Prototype TestingLearn Learning + Prototype Testing
Learn Learning + Prototype Testing
 
AdvaMed Summit
AdvaMed SummitAdvaMed Summit
AdvaMed Summit
 
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2 22.01.15
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2   22.01.15Working Scientifically - Investigations 2   22.01.15
Working Scientifically - Investigations 2 22.01.15
 
Metodologi penelitian 1 adli anwar
Metodologi penelitian 1   adli anwarMetodologi penelitian 1   adli anwar
Metodologi penelitian 1 adli anwar
 
Action research
Action researchAction research
Action research
 
Crocker.lori
Crocker.loriCrocker.lori
Crocker.lori
 
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after Time
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after TimeBecoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after Time
Becoming a Data Detective Part 1: Time after Time
 
Research types
Research typesResearch types
Research types
 
Rosenhan "User Research"
Rosenhan "User Research"Rosenhan "User Research"
Rosenhan "User Research"
 

Planning your first eye-tracking study

  • 1. Planning and executing your first eye-tracking study BayCHI BoF meeting June 22, 2010 Frances Karandy, Lead UER Researcher | eBay, Inc. Prasad Kantamneni, Principal Architect: Human Perception Center of Excellence | Yahoo, Inc.
  • 2. Agenda • When is eye tracking useful? • The top 5 things I learned… • Q & A discussion
  • 3. About us… Frances Karandy Prasad Kantamneni • Recently, joined as Lead • Principal architect of the eye- UER Researcher, BEX (2010) tracking platform at • Formerly, Staff Researcher, , • Has run dozens of eye tracking AdUx, Applications & Platforms tests for multiple Y! products (2005-2010) across the globe • Has run a few eye tracking studies
  • 4. So, when is eye tracking useful? • To bridge gaps between behavioral and qualitative data • For obtaining information that is normally difficult to get from participants • For providing an accelerated learning curve in a domain
  • 5. Top 5 things I learned in my first study… 1. Planning will define your success 2. Focus on the models, not the details 3. Think iteratively on hypothesis and study approach 4. Corroborate your study with other studies –powerful when done right! 5. Don’t expect to get it right the first time, or the second…
  • 6. Planning will define your success • A fly without wings cannot hear! – Think of the principles driving behaviors
  • 7. Planning will define your success • Illusion of functionality is important – Level of functionality or fidelity needed depends on your question • Test for contrasting conditions • Consider natural vs. canned tasks – Bar increases as you get closer to launch!
  • 8. Focus on the models, not the details • Eye-tracking is extremely effective in building mental models – Step back to get the bigger picture – Even if you have specific study objectives, larger context will provide rationale for details and actions – You may generate a whole new set of insights, or research questions…
  • 9. Think iteratively on hypothesis and approach • Take a data-to-theory (inductive) approach – Start out with initial hypotheses – Use the data to organically inform, change, and narrow your hypothesis • Think in terms of series of studies to allow for stimuli refinement • Set expectations upfront with stakeholders to plan for additional resources (time, participants, etc.)
  • 10. Corroborate your study with other studies • Eye tracking is not a good standalone source of truth • Must triangulate this data with other methods and proof points – What one participant says → across other participants – What you are observing in the data → supported with theory – Aligning eye tracking results → established findings from qualitative , quantitative and/or behavioral data • Thoughtful planning, execution, and analysis can lead to dramatic improvements in the user experience and revenue in a very short period of time!
  • 11. Don’t expect to get it all right the first time… • Give yourself extra time and the room to develop skills! – If something can go wrong it will – Learning curve is not the same as e.g., usability testing – As a manager, give your reports the time to learn …or even the second! • Don’t over generalize findings and observations, or you may risk credibility
  • 12. Discussion | Q & A Frances Karandy, fkarandy (at) ebay.com Prasad Kantamneni, kprasad (at) yahoo-inc.com