SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Identifying Errors

1- I ate my dinner quick.


2- I ate my dinner quickly.
1- Emily moved to a new house in 12th
street.


2- Emily moved to a new house on 12th
street.
1- Every girl in the party tried to look
their best.


2- Every girl in the party tried to look her
best.
1- Last summer, the heat brought
hundreds of people to the ocean.


2- Last summer, the heat will have
brought hundreds of people to the ocean.
1- If I was to see a movie with Mom and
Dad, I would risk my reputation.


2- If I were to see a movie with Mom and
Dad, I would risk my reputation.
Universal Grammar

Language is governed by a set of highly abstract
  principles that provide parameters which are
  given particular settings in different languages.




                                   Noam Chomsky
“The actress blamed herself.”
  A S         V      RP

English permits “local – binding”

“Emily knew the actress would blame herself.”
   S    V A DO M                V     RP

English prohibits “long – distance binding”
But cross – linguistically,

Japanese Translation:
“Sono eiga star wa jibunga warui to omotteiru
  that actress       -self bad       blame

koto o nga Emily ga shitemasu.”
   about Emily        knows
Result: Japanese learners of L2 English need to
learn that reflexive in English permit only local
binding.

Trivial issue: Whether learners whose L1 permits
both local and long – distance binding of
reflexives can learn that a language like English
permits only local binding.

Real Issue: Is L2 learnable?
Learnability
               English to
               Japanese?
Poverty Of The Stimulus (POTS) –
insufficiency of input or innate knowledge of
language


             “You are happy.”


             “Are you happy?”

Both rules have the same result.
Positive Evidence – provides information
about what is grammatical in the language



Negative Evidence - input that provides
direct evidence of what is ungrammatical in a
language
“Is anyone who interested can see me later?”


   “Can anyone who is interested see me
                later?”

1 is ungrammatical
2 is grammatical
CRITICAL      PERIOD
   HYPOTHESIS



Period during which
language acquisition is
easy and complete
People who lost their linguistic abilities due
to accident regain language before puberty

Deprived childhood

Young immigrants who achieve much
higher level of grammar fluency

Not all learners are subject to critical
period
Access to Language Fluency
Complete Access
can switch from L1 – L2

No Access
UG is not available to adult L2 learners

Partial Access
have access to part of UG but not others

Dual Access
make use of both UG and gen. learning strategies
Markedness
  – general idea that some structures are more
       natural than the other structures

Marked Structure          Unmarked Structure
-lie outside UG           -common in the
                          world’s languages
                          -governed by UG

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Universal grammar a reflection
Universal grammar a reflectionUniversal grammar a reflection
Universal grammar a reflectionShirley Guillermo
 
Ug part4 2nd lgacq
Ug part4 2nd lgacqUg part4 2nd lgacq
Ug part4 2nd lgacqazimtyping
 
Nargis Present New 6
Nargis Present New 6Nargis Present New 6
Nargis Present New 6umer6717
 
5 complicatedproblems
5 complicatedproblems5 complicatedproblems
5 complicatedproblemsHywel Evans
 
Language and its components
Language and its componentsLanguage and its components
Language and its componentsMIMOUN SEHIBI
 
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...Namreen Fiaz
 
Universal grammar very important
Universal grammar very importantUniversal grammar very important
Universal grammar very importantasifullahnuml
 
Chomskyan linguistics 2
 Chomskyan linguistics 2 Chomskyan linguistics 2
Chomskyan linguistics 2Hina Honey
 
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cook
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cookChomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cook
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cookMarcelo Fernández
 
Key Concepts in ELT
Key Concepts in ELTKey Concepts in ELT
Key Concepts in ELTESL Reading
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Universal grammar a reflection
Universal grammar a reflectionUniversal grammar a reflection
Universal grammar a reflection
 
Behaviorism vs universal grammar
Behaviorism vs universal grammarBehaviorism vs universal grammar
Behaviorism vs universal grammar
 
Universal Grammar
Universal GrammarUniversal Grammar
Universal Grammar
 
Universal grammar
Universal grammarUniversal grammar
Universal grammar
 
Ug part4 2nd lgacq
Ug part4 2nd lgacqUg part4 2nd lgacq
Ug part4 2nd lgacq
 
Nargis Present New 6
Nargis Present New 6Nargis Present New 6
Nargis Present New 6
 
Comparative essay-betancur_troncoso
Comparative essay-betancur_troncosoComparative essay-betancur_troncoso
Comparative essay-betancur_troncoso
 
Our Reflection
Our ReflectionOur Reflection
Our Reflection
 
Ling may19
Ling may19Ling may19
Ling may19
 
Nargis
NargisNargis
Nargis
 
5 complicatedproblems
5 complicatedproblems5 complicatedproblems
5 complicatedproblems
 
Language and its components
Language and its componentsLanguage and its components
Language and its components
 
Formal approaches (3)
Formal approaches (3)Formal approaches (3)
Formal approaches (3)
 
UG
UGUG
UG
 
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...
Ren Hulin, X. N. (2014). A study of Chomsky's Universal Grammar in Second Lan...
 
Chomsky2
 Chomsky2 Chomsky2
Chomsky2
 
Universal grammar very important
Universal grammar very importantUniversal grammar very important
Universal grammar very important
 
Chomskyan linguistics 2
 Chomskyan linguistics 2 Chomskyan linguistics 2
Chomskyan linguistics 2
 
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cook
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cookChomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cook
Chomsky's universal grammar 3rd edition cook
 
Key Concepts in ELT
Key Concepts in ELTKey Concepts in ELT
Key Concepts in ELT
 

Similar to Identifying Errors in Grammar and Language Acquisition

Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)
Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)
Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)Edi Brata
 
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.ppt
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.pptLaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.ppt
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.pptDan Lhery Gregorious
 
Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisitionhelen torres
 
Bilingualism
Bilingualism Bilingualism
Bilingualism Al Alva
 
Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis
Contrastive Analysis HypothesisContrastive Analysis Hypothesis
Contrastive Analysis HypothesisShona Whyte
 
Bilingualism
BilingualismBilingualism
BilingualismM R
 
Critical period hypothesis (2)
Critical period hypothesis (2)Critical period hypothesis (2)
Critical period hypothesis (2)Miss EAP
 
1 Feral Children Presentation
1 Feral Children Presentation1 Feral Children Presentation
1 Feral Children Presentationzmiers
 
Feral Children Presentation
Feral Children PresentationFeral Children Presentation
Feral Children Presentationzmiers
 
Learning to language learning
Learning to language learningLearning to language learning
Learning to language learningLaura Palacio
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas languageDiego M.
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas languageJEZS88
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas languageJEZS88
 
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?Nathacia Lucena
 
Didactica first and second_language_acquisition
Didactica first and second_language_acquisitionDidactica first and second_language_acquisition
Didactica first and second_language_acquisitionkarencita259025
 
Applied linguistics seminar oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisition
Applied linguistics seminar   oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisitionApplied linguistics seminar   oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisition
Applied linguistics seminar oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisitionRhaíza Bastos
 
Age and L2 acqusition.pptx
Age and L2 acqusition.pptxAge and L2 acqusition.pptx
Age and L2 acqusition.pptxSarabAlAkraa
 

Similar to Identifying Errors in Grammar and Language Acquisition (20)

Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)
Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)
Intro. to Linguistics_16 Psycholinguistics 2 (Language Acquisition)
 
Language Acquisition
Language AcquisitionLanguage Acquisition
Language Acquisition
 
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.ppt
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.pptLaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.ppt
Laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaing 390 Intro.ppt
 
Second language acquisition
Second language acquisitionSecond language acquisition
Second language acquisition
 
Innateness hypothesis
Innateness hypothesisInnateness hypothesis
Innateness hypothesis
 
Bilingualism
Bilingualism Bilingualism
Bilingualism
 
Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis
Contrastive Analysis HypothesisContrastive Analysis Hypothesis
Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis
 
Bilingualism
BilingualismBilingualism
Bilingualism
 
Critical period hypothesis (2)
Critical period hypothesis (2)Critical period hypothesis (2)
Critical period hypothesis (2)
 
Ofelia García åhörarkopior från Symposium 2015
Ofelia García åhörarkopior från Symposium 2015Ofelia García åhörarkopior från Symposium 2015
Ofelia García åhörarkopior från Symposium 2015
 
1 Feral Children Presentation
1 Feral Children Presentation1 Feral Children Presentation
1 Feral Children Presentation
 
Feral Children Presentation
Feral Children PresentationFeral Children Presentation
Feral Children Presentation
 
Learning to language learning
Learning to language learningLearning to language learning
Learning to language learning
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas language
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas language
 
Popular ideas language
Popular ideas languagePopular ideas language
Popular ideas language
 
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?
Class6 - How Do We Acquire Language?
 
Didactica first and second_language_acquisition
Didactica first and second_language_acquisitionDidactica first and second_language_acquisition
Didactica first and second_language_acquisition
 
Applied linguistics seminar oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisition
Applied linguistics seminar   oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisitionApplied linguistics seminar   oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisition
Applied linguistics seminar oct 6th 2009 - age of acquisition
 
Age and L2 acqusition.pptx
Age and L2 acqusition.pptxAge and L2 acqusition.pptx
Age and L2 acqusition.pptx
 

More from Edison Dela Merced (13)

Vocabulary in valentine witch
Vocabulary in valentine witchVocabulary in valentine witch
Vocabulary in valentine witch
 
Debate on junkfood
Debate on junkfoodDebate on junkfood
Debate on junkfood
 
School terms
School termsSchool terms
School terms
 
Suicide
SuicideSuicide
Suicide
 
Vocab guppyfish
Vocab guppyfishVocab guppyfish
Vocab guppyfish
 
Jobs
JobsJobs
Jobs
 
Guess what video-games
Guess what video-gamesGuess what video-games
Guess what video-games
 
Present perfect
Present perfectPresent perfect
Present perfect
 
Zombies
ZombiesZombies
Zombies
 
Development of Visual Arts in the Phils.
Development of Visual Arts in the Phils.Development of Visual Arts in the Phils.
Development of Visual Arts in the Phils.
 
Idioms with gold
Idioms with goldIdioms with gold
Idioms with gold
 
Philippine Churches Architechture
Philippine Churches ArchitechturePhilippine Churches Architechture
Philippine Churches Architechture
 
Brain bats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Brain bats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Brain bats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Brain bats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Identifying Errors in Grammar and Language Acquisition

  • 1. Identifying Errors 1- I ate my dinner quick. 2- I ate my dinner quickly.
  • 2. 1- Emily moved to a new house in 12th street. 2- Emily moved to a new house on 12th street.
  • 3. 1- Every girl in the party tried to look their best. 2- Every girl in the party tried to look her best.
  • 4. 1- Last summer, the heat brought hundreds of people to the ocean. 2- Last summer, the heat will have brought hundreds of people to the ocean.
  • 5. 1- If I was to see a movie with Mom and Dad, I would risk my reputation. 2- If I were to see a movie with Mom and Dad, I would risk my reputation.
  • 6. Universal Grammar Language is governed by a set of highly abstract principles that provide parameters which are given particular settings in different languages. Noam Chomsky
  • 7. “The actress blamed herself.” A S V RP English permits “local – binding” “Emily knew the actress would blame herself.” S V A DO M V RP English prohibits “long – distance binding”
  • 8. But cross – linguistically, Japanese Translation: “Sono eiga star wa jibunga warui to omotteiru that actress -self bad blame koto o nga Emily ga shitemasu.” about Emily knows
  • 9. Result: Japanese learners of L2 English need to learn that reflexive in English permit only local binding. Trivial issue: Whether learners whose L1 permits both local and long – distance binding of reflexives can learn that a language like English permits only local binding. Real Issue: Is L2 learnable?
  • 10. Learnability English to Japanese?
  • 11. Poverty Of The Stimulus (POTS) – insufficiency of input or innate knowledge of language “You are happy.” “Are you happy?” Both rules have the same result.
  • 12. Positive Evidence – provides information about what is grammatical in the language Negative Evidence - input that provides direct evidence of what is ungrammatical in a language
  • 13. “Is anyone who interested can see me later?” “Can anyone who is interested see me later?” 1 is ungrammatical 2 is grammatical
  • 14. CRITICAL PERIOD HYPOTHESIS Period during which language acquisition is easy and complete
  • 15. People who lost their linguistic abilities due to accident regain language before puberty Deprived childhood Young immigrants who achieve much higher level of grammar fluency Not all learners are subject to critical period
  • 16. Access to Language Fluency Complete Access can switch from L1 – L2 No Access UG is not available to adult L2 learners Partial Access have access to part of UG but not others Dual Access make use of both UG and gen. learning strategies
  • 17. Markedness – general idea that some structures are more natural than the other structures Marked Structure Unmarked Structure -lie outside UG -common in the world’s languages -governed by UG

Editor's Notes

  1. Japanese Translation: “Sonoeiga starwajibungawarui toomotteiru that actress -self bad blame koto o ngaEmily gashitemasu.” about Emily knows
  2. Period during which language acquisition is easy and complete