SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 74
O R I G I N A L P A P E R
A Mental Health Needs Assessment of Urban American Indian
Youth and Families
Amy E. West • Ellen Williams • Eli Suzukovich •
Kathlene Strangeman • Douglas Novins
Published online: 5 October 2011
� Society for Community Research and Action 2011
Abstract American Indian (AI) youth experience sig-
nificant mental health disparities. The majority of AI youth
live in urban areas, yet urban AI youth are underserved and
unstudied. This manuscript describes a qualitative study of
community mental health needs in an urban population of
AI youth, conducted as part of the planning process for a
system of care (SOC). Participants included 107 urban AI
youth and families that participated in one of 16 focus
groups assessing mental health needs and services. Forty-
one percent of participants were youth or young adults.
Data were coded and analyzed using qualitative software
and then further analyzed and interpreted in partnership
with a community research workgroup. Results indicated
various community characteristics, mental health and
wellness needs, and service system needs relevant to
developing a system of care in this community. Key
community, cultural, and social processes also emerged,
reinforcing the importance of broader system changes to
promote a sustainable SOC. These systems/policy changes
are reviewed in the context of previous literature proposing
necessary systems change to support behavioral health care
in AI communities as well as to ensure that SOC imple-
mentation is consistent with core values and philosophy
across all communities.
Keywords American Indian � Urban � Children and
adolescents � Mental health � System of care � Qualitative
Introduction
American Indian (AI)
1
youth are among the most vulner-
able children and adolescents in the United States with
rates of poverty, exposure to violence, mental health issues,
and suicide/death rates that are staggering (Sarche and
Spicer 2008; U.S. DHHS 2001). Extant research indicates
that AIs are at higher risk than any other ethnic group for
mental health problems (Costello et al. 1998; Moncher
et al. 1997). AI youth experience exceedingly high rates of
depression, anxiety, trauma, substance abuse, and suicide
(Stiffman et al. 2003) and are at high risk for a variety of
poor outcomes, including teen pregnancy, school drop out,
out of home placement, and accidental death (Witko 2006).
Statistics illuminate tragic and disturbing behavioral and
mental health disparities experienced by AIs, and espe-
cially AI youth. These disparities have emerged in the
context of social, political, cultural, and historical dynam-
ics since colonization. AI people were subject to one of the
most significant and systematic genocides in world history
(D’Andrea 1994), and have endured prolonged exploita-
tion, unimaginable loss, and profound suffering during the
past 500 years. A legacy of trauma, poverty, disenfran-
chisement, discrimination, and failed US policies aimed at
annihilation and then assimilation is compounded by cul-
tural differences compared to mainstream Western culture,
a lack of adequate epidemiological and health-related data,
and competition for scarce resources, which together
A. E. West (&) � E. Williams � E. Suzukovich
Institute for Juvenile Research, Department of Psychiatry,
University of Illinois at Chicago, 1747 W. Roosevelt Rd.
Rm 155, Chicago, IL 60608, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
K. Strangeman
American Indian Center of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA
D. Novins
University of Colorado Denver, Denver, CO, USA
1
American Indian, or AI, is used throughout this manuscript to
refer
to people of American Indian or Alaska Native descent.
123
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
DOI 10.1007/s10464-011-9474-6
contribute to the current physical, behavioral and mental
health crisis for AIs. While the majority of AI youth now
live in urban settings (Witko 2006), urban AI youth rep-
resent an almost completely unstudied, and essentially
invisible group of vulnerable children and adolescents with
regard to mental health (or any other) issues. Substantial
need exists for research examining the unique experience
of urban AI youth in order to inform models of mental
health promotion and intervention development.
The system of care (SOC) philosophy for mental health
service delivery proposes a coordinated network of com-
munity-based services and supports that are organized to
meet the challenges of youth with serious mental health
needs and their families. In recognition of the unique and
specific needs of AI communities in planning to implement
SOCs, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services
Administration (SAMHSA) launched the Circles of Care
(COC) grant program in 1998. This program provides
resources for community-based infrastructure development
and planning for SOCs in AI communities. The commu-
nity-based focus of COC is particularly important as pre-
vious research in AI communities has demonstrated that
methodological approaches must be culturally-driven and
leverage AI cultural strengths, belief systems, and
competencies (Poupart et al. 2009). Such research is best
pursued when communities and researchers form authentic
partnerships, which are embodied in the principles and
practice of community-based participatory research
(CBPR) (Green and Mercer 2001; Israel et al. 1998).
Authentic partnerships are ones in which partners exhibit
respect, collaboration, equal authority in decision-making,
and open communication. Founded in CBPR principles, the
purpose of a COC grant is to provide tribal and urban AI
communities with resources to design holistic, community-
based systems of care to support mental health and well-
ness for their youth and families.
The first step in developing a system of care is to assess
the needs of the specific community that the SOC is
expected to serve. This manuscript describes a qualitative
study of community mental health and wellness needs in an
urban population of AI youth that was conducted as part of
a COC grant awarded to the American Indian Center of
Chicago (AIC). The AIC is the oldest urban Indian center
in the country and the primary community agency serving
the large Chicago AI community. The current study had the
following primary objectives: (1) to actively involve the AI
community in Chicago in a community-based participatory
research project, and (2) to determine the mental health and
service needs of AI youth and families in the Chicago
community in order to develop culturally-appropriate ser-
vices to meet these needs. The purpose of collecting these
data was to inform the conceptualization, development, and
implementation of an SOC for this community. Key study
findings indicated a range of important community needs,
but also highlighted various systemic challenges and
broader social and conceptual shifts that may need to occur
in SOC policy in order to develop a successful SOC in this
community. Therefore, a third objective of this study
became to (3) recognize community, cultural, and social
processes (e.g. historical trauma, political divides, stigma
and distrust, cultural relevance, and community readiness
for change) that are critical in developing an effective
system of care in this community, as well as indicate
broader systemic changes needed to support diverse fami-
lies and communities.
The Need for Systems of Care in Urban AI
Communities
According to the U.S. Census Bureau (2008), there are 4.5
million people who identify themselves as AI in the United
States, of which approximately 30% are under the age of
18. There are over 500 federally recognized tribes and over
100 state recognized tribes, each of which has unique
social and cultural systems. In addition, approximately
67% of the AI population in the United States lives in
urban areas rather than on reservations (U.S. Census
Bureau 2000). Chicago has one of the largest urban AI
populations: 20,898 in Cook County and up to 50,000 in
the larger metropolitan area (U.S. Census Bureau 2000).
Mental Health Disparities in American Indian Youth
AIs are at higher risk than any other cultural group for
mental illness and AI youth may be at high risk for various
psychiatric disorders, including substance abuse, depres-
sion, anxiety, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
(ADHD), conduct disorder, and suicide (Beals et al. 1997,
2005; Costello et al. 1997, 1998; Moncher et al. 1997;
Whitbeck et al. 2008; Zvolensky et al. 2001). Evidence
suggests a rapid increase in the prevalence of psychiatric
disorders over the course of adolescence in AI youth.
Whitbeck et al. (2008) reported an increase in the preva-
lence of a single lifetime disorder from 25.6% at ages 10–12
to 44.8% at ages 13–15 in their longitudinal study of AI
youth on four reservations. In addition, AI people have the
highest suicide rates of any ethnic group in the United
States; data from the Indian Health Service (2003) indicate
that suicide is the 2nd leading cause of death for AI youth
aged 15–24 and is 3.5 times higher than the national aver-
age. As a whole, AI youth are more likely to: die before they
reach adulthood, die an accidental death, die as the result of
homicide, commit suicide, be in court-ordered foster care,
be in federal custody, experience violent victimization, and
drop out of school when compared to youth in any other
ethnic group (Sarche and Spicer 2008; Witko 2006).
442 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
American Indian Youth in Urban Communities
Consistent with efforts to assimilate AIs into mainstream
society, federal legislation was enacted in the 1950s and 60s
to relocate AIs to urban settings, where inter-tribal diversity
and integration would dilute AI culture and force assimi-
lation to the mainstream. AIs were promised economic
opportunity and job training, which stimulated a migration
of AIs to cities. However, once these AIs arrived they were
met with little governmental support, leading to unem-
ployment, poverty, and social and cultural isolation (Witko
2006). Separated from their tribal homeland, urban AI
families found themselves facing these problems, including
oppression and racism, with limited coping skills, no eco-
nomic security, and the absence of the tight-knit social
support of their tribal communities (Clark and Witko 2006).
These factors contributed to feelings of alienation, disem-
powerment, and hopelessness (Clark and Witko 2006).
We know very little regarding the current psychosocial
contexts of urban AI communities. The few studies spe-
cifically focused on urban AIs have found high rates of
substance abuse, depression, anxiety, suicidality, and
trauma, compounded by poverty, unemployment, family
and community violence, and low rates of service utiliza-
tion (Evaneshko 1999). Indeed, a recent report on urban AI
health documented that urban AIs experience extreme
poverty, demonstrate significant health and mental health
disparities, face numerous challenges trying to access
quality health care services, and are largely ignored by
the American health care system (UIHC 2007). AI youth in
urban settings, who are likely the children or grandchildren
of those relocated, may be affected by historical trauma
and accumulated stress, and they may experience loss of
traditional cultural heritage, stress over negotiating their
ethnic and cultural identity, racism, and oppression. They
must also deal with the multiple stresses of urban living,
including their disadvantaged economic status. Data from
the Youth Risk Behavior Survey (CDC 1996) indicate that
urban AI youth are more likely to engage in a variety of
high risk behaviors than their European American coun-
terparts, including illegal drug use, early initiation of sex-
ual intercourse, use of tobacco, alcohol, and marijuana,
carrying weapons, physical fights at school, and school
avoidance (Rutman et al. 2008).
The Chicago American Indian Community
Although there is limited epidemiological data specific to
Chicago, previous efforts suggest that this AI community
suffers from the same problems (disadvantaged
socioeconomic status, high-risk status of youth, and
behavioral and mental health disparities) that have been
documented in other urban AI communities (UIHI 2009;
U.S. Census Bureau 2008). A general health needs
assessment conducted in Chicago by the Urban Indian
Health Institute/Seattle Indian Health Board (2009) indi-
cated that substance abuse, anxiety/stress, depression, sui-
cide, financial problems, unemployment, accidents, teen
pregnancy, community violence, domestic violence, hous-
ing issues, legal problems, and insurance and health care
access issues were significant problems, and concluded that
the Chicago community had substantial health needs as
well as social and economic factors that put community
members at risk for not receiving needed services. The
study described in this manuscript comprised a qualitative
needs assessment study to further assess the specific needs
of youth in the Chicago AI community in order to plan for
an SOC. In addition, our CBPR and qualitative methods
facilitated the examination of important community, cul-
tural, and social processes that may affect the development
and implementation of an SOC in urban AI communities
and have implications for broader system changes needed
to sustain an effective SOC in other communities.
Methods
This study was conducted using a CBPR approach and
utilized a culturally-informed methodology. To develop
our focus group guide, we adapted the Community Story
Framework, a culturally-informed qualitative methodology
developed for use with AI communities (The Four Worlds
Centre for Development Learning 2000). The Community
Story Framework was developed as a tool for participatory
analysis in AI communities and brings people together in
small groups to discuss important issues in community life,
such as the well-being of youth and families, in the context
of such domains as family life, social life, emotional life,
and cultural/spiritual life. Our structured focus group guide
included additional questions assessing three main
domains: (1) the mental health/positive development needs
of urban AI youth in Chicago, (2) the available support
systems, mental health services, and service utilization, and
(3) potential cultural and historical parameters that might
drive the development of innovative service approaches to
meet community needs. Sample questions from the focus
group guide include: ‘‘What are some of the problems that
youth in our community face today?’’, ‘‘What do you hear
about mental health services in our community?’’, and
‘‘What would life be like for youth in a healthy family and
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 443
123
community?’’ A community workgroup actively partici-
pated in the development of the focus group guide.
Participants for this study were recruited through com-
munity announcements, networking at events and pow-
wows, posted flyers, and word-of-mouth. Sixteen focus
groups were completed with a total of 107 youth and
families participating. Informed consent, parental permis-
sion for youth under 18, and youth assent was obtained
prior to participation. One hundred percent of participants
identified as AI. Forty-one percent of participants were
under the age of 25, and 14% were under age 18. Eighteen
percent of participants were community elders (a commu-
nity elder is generally defined as a senior community
member with cultural wisdom and a commitment to shar-
ing and teaching). Sixty-six percent of participants were
female. Each group had 6-12 participants and lasted
2 hours. Groups were organized by age group (e.g., teens,
young adults, adults, elders) and generally included a mix
of genders. Groups were facilitated by two of the authors of
this manuscript (AW and KS), who are in leadership roles
on the COC grant and have working relationships with the
AIC (one is an AIC staff member, the other is on the AIC
Board) and experience working in this community. The
structure of the groups was standardized; facilitators asked
questions in the same manner and sequence across all 16
groups. The research protocol was approved by the Uni-
versity of Illinois at Chicago IRB.
Each focus group was audio recorded and professionally
transcribed. A coding structure was developed based on
eight core domains of interest that represented areas of
interest for analysis. The eight codes were: (1) community
characteristics; (2) community demographics; (3) indica-
tors of health and mental health; (4) risk and protective
factors; (5) definitions of mental illness; (6) service system
needs; (7) barriers to accessing services; and (8) accept-
ability of existing services. Two authors (EW and ES), who
also have relationships with AIC and are from the Chicago
AI community, served as coders on the project. They
established reliability by double coding three transcripts,
and completed the analysis of the transcripts using AtlasTi
software. Data analysis involved coding text, producing
text reports by code, and identifying and counting themes
from text through an iterative process of reviewing code
reports. After initial coding by the research team, code
reports were reviewed by our community research work-
group, a committee of community members who volun-
teered to assist with study design and data analyses.
Community workgroup members reviewed the code reports
and discussed findings with project staff in bi-weekly
committee meetings. This process served to validate coding
completed by initial coders as well as facilitating discus-
sion to ensure that codes were adequately discussed in
depth and considered in context when interpreting themes.
Results
Data were coded to determine the primary themes emerg-
ing for each of the codes. The themes for each code are
listed in Table 1. While all identified themes are listed in
the table, results discussed below were limited to those that
may be most pertinent to developing SOC components.
These themes were identified by the research team and
agreed upon by the community research committee during
analysis and consensus meetings.
Community Characteristics
The first two codes were developed to assess community
demographics as well as specific community, cultural, or
social factors that characterize the Chicago AI community.
Specifically, the community characteristics code was used
to capture characteristics such as historical influences,
identity issues, politics, relocation effects, dynamics in
community, aspects of urban AI culture, and traditions/
practices in community. Participants reported (1) increased
dispersion of the AI population across the Chicago metro-
politan area over the past 20–30 years. Gentrification has
forced the AI community out of its original geographical
location and families are now located across the expansive
city and suburbs. Participants associated this phenomenon
with a perceived invisibility of AI people in the larger
Chicago community as well as with other aspects of cultural
dispersion, such as mixed heritage due to inter-race coupling,
decreased knowledge of language and participation in cul-
tural traditions, and the stresses of trying to ‘‘live between
two worlds.’’ For example, one participant noted the effect of
dispersion and integration within the urban community as
contributing to a potential loss of cultural knowledge:
I believe there needs to be some working on that
particular issue in that living on the reservation and
then leaving as a product of Indian relocation- the
only way I would get a lot of the cultural things was
to go back to my reservation and spend summers
there. A lot of things became a void and I had to
relearn those as an adult because I found importance
in those things. And so living in an urban environ-
ment you lose those things, unless there is a concerted
effort to take that cultural information and impart that
to the youth because they are living in their own
world. They go play basketball after school and they
get integrated with other races and stuff, there is a
pan racial, ethnic thing in an urban area.
Second, participants highlighted (2) a sense of division in
the AI community. They noted physical dispersion, inter-
tribal diversity, tensions between community leaders and
organizations, and the diminished interdependence that
444 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
Table 1 Needs assessment themes
General themes Themes from youth groups
Community
characteristics
Historic nostalgia
Dispersion of population
Division within community
Importance of tribal identity
Need for community cohesion
Importance of cultural practice
Community demographics Violence
Financial instability
Single and teen parenting
Alcohol/drug use
Invisibility as ethnic population
Gangs
Violence
Peer pressure
Mental health indicators Positive:
Healthy lifestyle
Spiritual strength and
practice
Balance
Coping skills
Happiness
Positive relationships
Negative:
Alcohol and drug use
Violence
Gangs
Negative lifestyle
behavior
Stress and anxiety
Poverty
Positive:
Cultural and spiritual health
Connection with elders
Good relationship with school,
teachers
Negative:
Peer pressure
Lack of adult role models
Factors of risk and/or
protection
Protection:
Sense of belonging
Extended family
Extended family
Involved community
Risk:
Negative coping skills
Lack of structure and
guidance
Chronic stress
Community division
Lack of connection
Poor communication
Sense of loss
Apathy
Protection:
Positive reinforcement from
adults
Sense of community
Accountability from adults
Pride in culture
Risk:
Poor communication,
gossip
Lack of accountability
from adults
Hopelessness, alienation
Lack of support and trust
Definitions of mental
illness
Achieving balance Balance
Stigma of mental illness Lack of support and caring from adults
Need for culturally-relevant definition Alienation and isolation
Alienation from family and community Lack of expression and
communication
Trauma
Service system needs Funding for programs Funding
Improvements in infrastructure Need for health services
Specific services for youth mental health Lack of support
Cultural relevance
Promotion of general wellness
Lack of education, behavioral health, and recreational
activities
Barriers to accessing
services
Poor communication/lack of knowledge Shame, embarrassment
Practical barriers Mistrust, fear
Stigma Need to be proud and strong
Lack of trust Lack of adults modeling help-seeking
Preference for community supports Lack of culturally-sensitive
providers
Acceptability of existing
services
Need for perceptive clinicians Need for cultural sensitivity
A trusting clinical relationships Need for perceptive clinicians
Absence of quality services Traditional healing
Community politics
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 445
123
once existed, as contributing to feelings of disconnection
and division between community members. One partici-
pant stated:
Well, one thing I see about a lot of Natives is that
they are separate. My tribe is this and your tribe is
this. And we talk about each other. And we don’t
really come together as Native people. If you are a
Native, you are a Native. I don’t care whether you are
from north, south, east or west, because we should
love each other being Native, Native people.
The community demographics code was used to capture
sociodemographic characteristics such as housing, employ-
ment rate, poverty, neighborhood issues, school drop-out, and
family structure. One prominent theme was (1) violence in
community, most notably violence associated with aspects of
inner city living such as gangs, drugs, and dangerous neigh-
borhoods. One participant illustrated this theme, stating:
And my big concern is, the kids in this neighborhood-
you know, we saw three shootings out here about
6 months ago. One young man died on that doorstep
over there. That makes an impact on you, you know. So
it is like gangs and drugs are eating our children up and
spitting them out and putting them into incarceration.
They do not belong there. What I see is, it takes a whole
village to raise a child. And I think we try to do that.
In addition, participants noted (2) financial instability,
including lack of employment, relying on public assistance,
housing problems, and youth having to contribute to family
finances. Finally, participants discussed the (3) challenges
related to parenting, including the prevalence of single par-
ents, extended family raising children, and teen parenting.
Mental Health and Wellness
The next set of codes was designed to capture themes
associated with conceptualizations and experience of
mental health and wellness in the AI community in Chi-
cago. First, the mental health indicators code was used to
capture indicators of community health or mental health
such as arrest rates, substance abuse, gang violence, foster
care placements, HIV, and chronic illnesses. We chose to
focus on both indicators of positive mental health in
addition to negative mental health. Indicators of positive
mental health and wellness included (1) healthy lifestyle
behaviors, such as healthy eating and youth/family par-
ticipation in sports activities and athletics; (2) spiritual
strength, which participants described as having the spiri-
tual grounding to weather life’s challenges; (3) regular
spiritual practice, which included prayer, participation in
ceremony, and teaching youth spiritual traditions; and (4)
positive and healthy coping skills. Indicators of negative
mental health noted by participants included (1) alcohol
and drug usage; (2) violence; (3) gangs; (4) unhealthy
lifestyle behaviors, such as poor diet, lack of exercise, and
mismanagement of chronic illnesses; (5) stress and anxi-
ety; and (6) the negative impact of poverty. In general,
participants noted the high prevalence of indicators of
negative mental health, such as violence (both community
violence as well as violence occurring within families),
poverty, substance abuse, and high stress levels, and the
need for more focus on promoting indicators of positive
mental health and wellness, such as using spirituality to
promote a sense of purpose and balance, the development
of good coping skills, and fostering healthy relationships.
The risk and protection codes were used to capture
community strengths (e.g. use of Native language, tradi-
tional practices, close-knit families, programs for youth,
academic achievement, positive role models) and risks (e.g.
spiritual problems, stressful life events, poverty, trauma and
historical trauma, racism). Themes emerging related to
community protective factors included: (1) the importance
of a sense of belonging—to family, to community, and to
society; (2) having a strong connection to extended family
members who provide nurturing relationships for youth; and
(3) having a supportive, involved community that prioritizes
the healthy development of youth and maintenance of
healthy families. Themes related to community risk included
(1) negative coping skills, such as alcohol and anger/
violence; (2) a lack of structure and guidance for youth;
(3) chronic stress; (4) community division; (5) a lack of
connection to community; and (5) poor communication.
Although some of these themes (e.g. negative coping skills,
stress) may appear to be individual-level risk factors, the
focus of this discussion was on how these factors were per-
vasive enough throughout community that they represented
community-level risk factors influencing overall youth and
family wellness. In general, participants noted that many of
the core aspects of protection from risk, such as a strong
sense of family and the importance of community life, exist
but are diminished by exposure to risk factors such as chronic
stressors, lack of good communication, and a sense of loss. In
particular, participants noted that compounded risk factors
contribute to a lack of sense of purpose and direction for
many community youth. One young adult stated:
I think lack of direction is always just at the root of so
many struggles with youth, period. Especially in this
community, I’ve been in this community my entire life.
And I just think maybe, for many different reasons,
family or just lack of resources, lack of a place to even
just go…But there’s no sense of direction of what a
person wants to do, or where to go, or what to do with
their time constructively. I think there’s maybe not
enough encouragement. I think there are in certain
446 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
arenas. Everyone says ‘‘go to school, go to school.’’ But
then for a lot of people, you don’t have the money to go
to school… So then what do you do then? So I think that
causes a lot of despair and then you kind of give up.
The definition of mental illness code was used to
capture any discussion relevant to local definitions of
wellness, mental health, or emotional health. There was not
much explicit discussion of mental illness by participants
in this study. When asked to describe the meaning of
mental or emotional health, the predominant response was
(1) achieving balance, with the predominant description of
a lack of mental health as being out of balance. Other
discussion coded in this domain indicated (2) stigma and
distrust related to mainstream mental illness diagnoses.
Participants also emphasized a preference for (3) more
culturally-relevant definitions, such as balance and holistic
wellness. One participant illustrated this theme by stating:
People have a tendency these days to identify you by
your sicknesses, so you become a collection of sick-
nesses that people are managing…I think the idea
should be that good wellness should look at sickness as
disease, but not disease as in a thing, but disease as in
disease. The disease is you have gotten out of balance.
There is something that is not making your life work
the way it should be and we are going to move you from
that uneasy place again to a healthy place.
In addition, participants tended to focus on root causes of
behavioral or emotional difficulties, such as (4) feelings of
alienation and disconnection from family and community.
Finally, (5) the experience of trauma, both individually and
collectively as a community, emerged as a major theme related
to emotional and behavioral difficulties experienced by youth.
The discussion of trauma ranged from community violence,
such as gangs and drug violence, to sexual abuse within
families, to the collective historical trauma experienced by the
urban AI community in Chicago and AI peoples as a whole.
Service Needs
The final group of codes was designed to assess perspec-
tives about the current service system and what community
members perceive to be the gaps and unmet service needs.
The first code, service system needs, was used to capture
what kinds of services are (or are not) available in the
community and to assess gaps in services, unavailability of
services or programs, and problems with available services.
Participants noted a significant need for (1) funding for
programs and (2) improvements in infrastructure. Partici-
pants described lack of funding and infrastructure chal-
lenges such as lack of staffing and/or expertise needed as
contributing to a sparse and constantly changing menu of
available health and mental health services within com-
munity. Participants also discussed (3) the need for specific
services aimed at mental and behavioral wellness for
youth; (4) the need for services that are culturally-relevant
(e.g. that incorporate traditional medicine or spiritual
practices) and based within their community; and (5) the
need for more services and programs that facilitate healthy
social interaction and promote general wellness. Speaking
specifically about what is needed in terms of services, one
participant stated:
Creating more opportunities for the healing process
and exposure to all of those things [traditional prac-
tices]. Spirituality, there’s a lot of connections with
medicine men and women in the community now.
There are more opportunities for other clinical work.
And finding a balance that works for families that is
culturally appropriate helps a lot.
The barriers to accessing services code was used to
assess any difficulties accessing current services. The themes
emerging under this code included (1) poor communication
and lack of knowledge about accessing mental and behav-
ioral health services; (2) practical barriers such as insur-
ance, financial issues, and transportation; (3) stigma related
to accessing services; and (4) impact of barriers such as lack
of trust. In particular, participants reported not accessing
services for fear of being called crazy or being the subject of
gossip, as well as having concerns about confidentiality,
especially when utilizing local community agencies where
others might see them arriving for appointments or where
other community members might be employed. Participants
also discussed not trusting non-AI practitioners or providers
not familiar with AI culture to understand their unique needs
and value systems. Finally, participants discussed (5) a
preference for utilizing community supports and family
members or peers when in distress, rather than accessing
mainstream mental health services. One participant descri-
bed this phenomenon by saying:
I think that the mental health services that we used to
have came from everybody else’s community. And if
you wanted something the chances are there was
someone else in the community you were going to
run into when you were waiting…that was going
through the same thing or had the same thing and
they helped you out with it…family meant a lot more.
And you had family wherever you looked. And that
was your mental health services. It was either your
peers or your age group or someone else that was
walking around the streets, just the way you were.
The final code in this group, acceptability of existing
services assessed the acceptability of existing services,
including the cultural appropriateness and quality of
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 447
123
available services. Participants highlighted the importance of
having providers that are (1) perceptive to their unique needs;
and (2) with whom they can build a trusting relationship.
Participants agreed on (3) the general absence of quality
services available for youth and also discussed (4) the com-
munity politics (e.g. relationship dynamics and history
between community leaders and agencies) driving the utili-
zation of different programs and services within community.
Youth-Specific Findings
As 41% of the sample was under the age of 25, the findings
discussed above generally characterize the findings of youth
and young adults that were sampled in this study. However,
when youth data were analyzed separately, a few additional
youth-specific themes emerged. Youth-specific themes
included (1) developing skills to cope with stress and neg-
ative situations; and (2) the need for positive role models
within family and community. Within the community
characteristics codes, youth identified (1) tribal identity as
important because it provides a sense of community and
belonging and enhances knowledge of language and tradi-
tions. Youth also discussed (2) the interplay between com-
munity cohesion and maintaining cultural ties, while also
maintaining individual identities and being free to have their
own ideas and perspectives as an important characteristic of
community life. Finally, youth identified (3) peer pressure
as underlying many of the other community characteristics
identified, such as substance use, gangs, violence, and teen
pregnancy. Peer pressure was also a prominent theme within
the mental health and wellness codes, where it was
identified to impede wellness and healthy coping through
serving as a mechanism through which youth become
involved in abusing substances, violent behavior, and join-
ing gangs. In addition, youth participants discussed the need
for (1) role models to demonstrate healthy coping and
healthy lifestyle behaviors, and who were interested in being
involved in youth’s lives and teaching culture. Many youth
identified the importance of (2) cultural and spiritual health
and their desire to connect or re-connect with cultural and
spiritual traditions. For example, one youth stated:
Having a culture, having traditions kind of gives you,
maybe, a purpose or something, to take care of or
something to hold. And, having something like that,
you know, a form of responsibility, kind of makes
you stronger. You know, having responsibility to
carry traditions and to uphold the culture, you know,
it gives you something to do, to care about, you know
what I mean, an outlet in itself.
Finally, youth stressed the need for (3) positive reinforce-
ment from adults and teachers; (4) accountability from adults
and organizations; and (5) the need for individuals and
institutions in their lives to promote a sense of cultural pride.
All these things were identified as coping mechanisms or
buffers that would help them manage the intense risk factors
and stressors in their daily lives. Within the service needs
codes, one interesting additional theme that emerged specific
to youth responses was the barrier presented by (1) the
message that youth need to be strong and proud (particularly
males), which causes shame and embarrassment and
prevents youth from seeking help when they need it.
Community, Cultural, and Social Processes
There were several subtle yet powerful themes that emerged in
our analyses that did not fit neatly into our coding domains, or
were so consistent throughout many coding domains that they
were deemed to represent pervasive and significant processes
within community experience that may relate to youth and
family mental health and community needs. These themes
were either discussed explicitly during focus groups or
emerged through the integration of data and discussion with
community research workgroup members. They included (1)
the impact of historical trauma (i.e. the collective emotional
and psychological injury, both over the life course and across
generations, resulting from catastrophic history of genocide);
(2) political divisiveness within community and community
organizations; (3) the need for a sense of belonging; (4)
challenges in the cultural connection between youth and
adults/elders; (5) stigma about mental and behavioral health,
(6) internalized oppression (i.e. accepting the oppressor’s
perception of you), (7) strained interactions with outside
systems (e.g. public schools, health care); and (8) fear of loss of
culture and tradition. The examination of these community,
cultural, and social processes was identified to be critical in
developing meaningful, sustainable, and effective interven-
tions or systems of services to promote mental health and well-
being for urban AI youth and families in Chicago. Of these, the
most significant and overarching theme discussed by partici-
pants and by research team and workgroup members analyz-
ing data was the impact of trauma on community life in the
Chicago AI community. It was proposed that historical trauma
is a powerful psychological, social, and structural phenome-
non that contributes to community dynamics, including:
divisiveness and disconnection within community; self-
focused and parallel oppression (i.e. oppressing one’s own
people); the loss of culture through dispersion, forgetting or
assimilation; a sense of inferiority and different-ness that
separates youth from their non-AI peers and society; tension
between AI communities and outside systems; and a pervasive
sense of alienation, anxiety, and depression that characterizes
a typical trauma response. One participant stated:
There is so much grief and it is not expressed. It is
acted out. And grief sometimes turns into anger. And
448 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
then you’ve got anger, and these kids growing up
[thinking] ‘I don’t want to be around here. These
people are mad at me.’ And they [youth] don’t know
that they are not causing it.
It was also noteworthy that, although discussion often
centered on challenges, needs, and barriers, as this was an
important objective of this study, participants and work-
group members also emphasized the capacity for resiliency,
adaptation, and cultural renewal evidenced by AI peoples.
There was a sense conveyed by participants that AI cultural
strengths and resources could heal the community, shape
positive youth development, and enhance relationships
between the Chicago AI community and the broader system
if properly understood and leveraged. One participant
illustrated the importance of leveraging community
strengths, beliefs, and values to heal by saying: ‘‘And it’s the
people that will heal each other from the inside…it’s the
people who will heal other people from the inside’’.
Discussion
Our discussion is organized around four prominent themes
emerging from this study that we believe are relevant to
systems change for this and other AI communities: (1) the
need to address the role of historical trauma and internalized
oppression in shaping divisions within community and
affecting a community’s readiness for change, (2) the
importance of extensive community mobilization efforts to
address community politics, factions of the community, and
organizational alliances, (3) the need to honor locally-
meaningful conceptualizations of mental health and
wellness, and (4) the need for community-based and cul-
turally-relevant clinical services and programs. We address
the broader implications of these findings in our conclusions.
Addressing Historical Trauma and Internalized
Oppression
Throughout the implementation of this study, participants
acknowledged that the collective trauma experienced by AI
people over the life course and across generations related to
genocide has contributed to the social, political, cultural,
and historical dynamics within Indian country (and
between Indian country and mainstream society) since
colonization. In addition, internalized oppression was rec-
ognized to contribute to the politics, divisions, disconnec-
tion, perceived loss of culture, invisibility and strained
interactions with outside systems. Participants in this study
perceived that historical trauma may directly relate to
community risk factors, mental health issues, environ-
mental stressors, and stigma about mental health. In
addition, participants perceived that a legacy of trauma and
oppression may contribute to the tendency for community
members to sometimes divide and work against rather than
with each other, even when shared commitment and pas-
sion is evident, or to become disconnected and burned out.
To address the impact of historical trauma, an SOC could
include education, training, and opportunities for open dia-
logue. This could take the form of outreach, trainings for
community leaders, program directors and community
members on historical trauma, its impact on AI communities
and organizations, and methods for addressing and healing
from its effects. There are national models for community
building and healing from historical trauma (for exam-
ples, see http://historicaltrauma.com/interventions.html) that
could be incorporated into the planning and program devel-
opment phases of an SOC. An SOC could also incorporate
culturally-based training in methods of effective communi-
cation and relationship-building to help address the divi-
siveness and burn-out associated with effects of historical
trauma. Such programs exist; for example, the Healthy
Native Communities Fellowship (http://www.hncpartners.
org) brings teams of AI community members from around the
country together for intensive training to become change
agents creating wellness strategies for their communities
grounded in AI cultural and spiritual teachings. Finally, an
SOC may include regular community talking circles or group
sessions conducted by trained community facilitators to
bring community members together to discuss sensitive
topics, such as trauma, racism, and oppression, as well as
empower them to problem-solve and plan for the future in a
safe and structured setting. The incorporation of these SOC
components would constitute a focus on community devel-
opment and empowerment, prevention, and a reliance on
indigenous ways of knowing and supports in order to heal.
Mobilizing Community to Heal Relationships
and Division
There was a sense from study participants that the trauma
of relocation, combined with the stresses of urban living,
the dispersion of the community throughout the metro-
politan area, and divisions between AI-serving organiza-
tions competing for constituents and resources has led
some community members to feel disconnected, uncertain
of their place within community, or simply too over-
whelmed and stressed to participant in community life in
the way they would like. The data also indicated that
promoting a sense of belonging to community was a key
component in achieving family mental health and wellness.
Therefore, an SOC would need to include innovative
methods to mobilize community and address barriers such
as geographical dispersion, divisions among community
members and agencies, and the invisibility of the AI
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 449
123
http://historicaltrauma.com/interventions.html
http://www.hncpartners.org
http://www.hncpartners.org
population within the larger urban service system. To
address geographic dispersion and disconnection, commu-
nity members indicated that recreational activities planned
and sponsored by multiple organizations would help to
bring people together, build community, create a sense of
belonging and empowerment, and enable the sharing of
information. To address divisions between community
agencies, an SOC might include the creation of a cross-
agency collaborative working committee to develop a plan
for outreach, education, and coordinated efforts to deliver
services. To address the issue of AI invisibility within the
larger political and social service system landscape, an
SOC would include structures (e.g., the creation of a
stakeholder network) to facilitate community mobilization
and organizing in order to more effectively advocate about
the needs of the community to policy makers at the city and
state level. Consistent with Cook and Kilmer’s (2010a)
work emphasizing the importance of an ecological
approach to SOC delivery, such community building and
coordination efforts would require that an SOC take an
ecological perspective on mental health, one that honored
the holistic impact of family and community factors, and
allowed for the promotion of healthy systems in addition to
healthy individuals.
Honoring Local Definitions of Mental Health
and Wellness
Participants noted that a sense of belonging to community,
a strong and stable connection to family and extended
family, and youth’s belief that community members were
supportive and involved in their lives did or could lead to
helping youth and families achieve a sense of balance,
healthy lifestyle practices, spiritual health, positive coping
skills, and feelings of purpose and happiness. Participants
discussed the need to promote wellness and prevention, to
address the powerful stigma associated with mental illness,
and to embrace culturally-relevant conceptualizations of
mental health and wellness from a holistic worldview.
To address these needs, an SOC may need to be framed
more from a wellness promotion/prevention perspective,
rather than as a method to address youth with severe dis-
orders or difficulties. SOCs are traditionally focused on
coordinating services for youth with severe emotional
and behavioral disorders (‘‘SEBD’’). This deficit-based
approach may need to be eliminated and replaced with one
that promotes a strength-based approach, prevention, and a
holistic wellness perspective. A focus on promoting well-
ness, balance, support and strengthening of the entire family
system within the community context is far more consistent
with AI values of interdependence, spiritual strength, and
holistic well-being than a traditional mental health model
focused on identifying a ‘‘patient’’ and creating a plan for
clinical services to address deficits and illness in that indi-
vidual. For example, an SOC that was consistent with AI
values might identify a child/family in need of services
based on a constellation of risk factors and engage the
family in wrap-around services and supports embedded
within community and mainstream systems (e.g. school,
community agencies). Children/families who already
demonstrate emotional or behavioral difficulties could have
additional clinical services added to their wrap-around plan.
This shift would be consistent with what has been proposed
by Kilmer et al. (2010) in order to address the disconnect
between principles and practice and bring SOCs more in
line with their family-centered philosophy. In addition, this
approach would decrease stigma by promoting the notion
that all children and families need supports and services for
healthy development and by embedding most services in
systems that were mainstream and familiar to families. On
the whole, our data suggest that in order for an SOC to be
embraced by AI youth and families, it may require a shift
from the more traditional systems of deficit-based clinical
care and case management services to encompass a broader
range of community-based programs and practices that are
empowering, health promoting, and holistic.
Implementing Community-Based
and Culturally-Relevant Clinical Services
The most common service need discussed was funding for
programs and services. The perception was that programs
and services within community are fleeting, coming and
going with different grants or individuals, but not sustain-
able due to precarious funding streams and lack of con-
sistent infrastructure. Participants noted barriers such as
poor communication between service providers, frag-
mented services that do not address multiple important
contributors to mental health problems (e.g., family stress,
community violence, poverty, and unemployment), stigma
about mental health services, a lack of trust in providers,
and the absence of quality, culturally-informed mental
health services for youth. Notably, despite identifying
service needs and barriers regarding clinical services, the
prevailing notion among participants was that people in
community, including youth, prefer to draw on community
supports and indigenous relationships (peers, family, and
community members) in times of need rather than seeking
out mainstream clinical services. This finding is consistent
with previous literature summarizing the lack of informal
and everyday supports reported by a range of families
participating in SOCs despite the importance attributed to
these factors by families (Cook and Kilmer 2010b).
Findings from this study indicate that a successful SOC
for urban AIs would have secure funding, sufficient infra-
structure, coordinated and collaborative high-quality
450 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
services with providers and agencies that work together,
well-disseminated information about available programs
and services, clinicians who were sensitive to the unique
needs of this community and knowledgeable about AI
culture (if not AI themselves), and components to address
barriers such as lack of insurance and transportation.
However, the tendency to rely on indigenous community
supports versus the health care system to address mental
health issues suggests that programs that build capacity
within community, address the various stressors that chal-
lenge family wellness (e.g. economic distress, unemploy-
ment) and empower community members to take leadership
roles in promoting health and wellness through informal
support systems would be effective. Services typically
incorporated into SOC wrap-around models (but not usually
considered traditional mental health services), might
emphasize prevention and wellness promotion components
such as job preparation and financial literacy programs,
violence prevention, youth mentorship programs, educa-
tion/school support, parent training, and culture-based
interventions (e.g. drumming, arts, Native games, story-
telling, ceremony) that promote cultural identity and pride.
Such an approach would require that SOCs take a family-
centered preventative approach to mental health, allowing
for services to be provided to entire families and to youth at-
risk (vs. only to an ‘‘identified patient’’) and to provide
funding to strengthen indigenous resources and supports.
Systems and Policy Changes
These findings also highlight several system/policy chan-
ges specific (or at least particularly warranted) in AI
communities. First, the expansion of mechanisms of
reimbursement to include traditional healers would allow
SOCs serving AI communities to formally incorporate
traditional ceremony and spiritual practices into their array
of behavioral health services, a need consistently identified
by AI communities (Gone 2007). Second, the training and
reimbursement of paraprofessionals to deliver services
would enable capacity-building within communities so that
community members knowledgeable about community and
cultural issues were able to serve their own communities.
The approach of using paraprofessionals has proven a
successful method of service delivery in AI communities
(Walkup et al. 2009) and also helps address the issue of a
lack of trained providers in rural or remote AI communi-
ties. Third, policies could be enacted that facilitate the
incorporation of mental health services within existing
structures and build on informal supports already available
in the community, such as primary care facilities, schools,
cultural/community centers, and families. This will foster a
more integrated approach and help address barriers related
to the serious stigma associated with seeking traditional
Western mental health services in many AI communities.
Fourth, the alteration of policy to further support preven-
tion services as a primary focus of SOCs will support the
incorporation of mechanisms to address historical trauma,
institutionalized racism, and the current realities of many
AI communities, including poverty and unemployment, so
that these issues can be addressed before they manifest in
emotional or behavioral difficulties, or diagnosable mental
health problems. Finally, policies could be established that
require those funded to plan and implement SOCs to
include formal, articulated methods of ensuring that their
work is consistent with an authentic community-based
participatory process, empowering families and commu-
nities to support and promote their own indigenous prac-
tices, and helping communities to develop an evidence
base to support their culturally-based methods of healing
and wellness promotion (i.e. a practice-based evidence vs.
evidence-based practice approach). These recommended
system/policy changes are supported by our data, but also
consistent with previous recommendations for systemic
policy changes to behavioral health systems based on a
comprehensive review of behavioral health and healthcare
in AI communities nationwide (Goodkind et al. 2010).
Strengths of this study include its focus on a unique and
underserved population and use of an innovative qualita-
tive methodology to assess community needs. However,
there are limitations in that study design and data analysis
that are worthy of note. First, this study relied on partici-
pants to self-select their participation and the sample rep-
resents only a fraction of the total community. Thus, the
study sample may not be representative of the entire urban
AI population in Chicago. In addition, though the use of
focus groups stimulated discussion, relationship-building,
and consensus, some participants may have been uncom-
fortable discussing more sensitive topics in a group format
and thus, may have limited what they shared. Finally, as
with all qualitative analysis, though we used a structured
coding system and data analytic software to enhance the
rigor of the study, coding was completed by two commu-
nity research assistants and is therefore subjective based on
their perceptions of how the text fit with different codes.
This bias was alleviated somewhat by the use of a com-
munity research workgroup who also reviewed transcripts
and completed their own process of identifying themes,
which was then compared to what the original coders had
identified.
Conclusions
Taken together, findings from this study indicate that an
effective SOC for the AI community in Chicago would
incorporate methods to strengthen community and family
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 451
123
ties, heal relationships within community, re-connect
families to traditional ways, focus on prevention, empower
community members to drive program development, and
enhance community-based supports. These findings are
consistent with community psychology theory, which
emphasizes the importance of ecology, community devel-
opment, diversity, context, collaboration, empowerment,
prevention, and participatory action (Rappaport and Seid-
man 2000) in affecting individual and social change. Also
evident in these findings is the importance of promoting a
psychological sense of community (Sarason 1974). These
findings are consistent with SOC values that emphasize
diverse and coordinated community-based services and
supports, families as important decision-makers, and the
conceptualization of the child from within an ecological
perspective (Cook and Kilmer 2010a; Kilmer et al. 2010).
However, it has been consistently demonstrated that there
is a substantial gap between SOC philosophy and values
and actual practice and that this gap may at least partially
explain the mixed outcomes in SOC research (Kilmer et al.
2010). In particular, it has been noted that the family-
centered care philosophy of SOC is not supported by
current policy (Kilmer et al. 2010); SOC implementation
does not always take into account the ecological perspec-
tive, especially as related to the incorporation of preven-
tion and informal supports for families (Cook and Kilmer
2010a, b); that most current behavioral health systems and
policies do not support the implementation of a compre-
hensive wrap-around model (Bruns et al. 2010); and that
SOCs are not always developed and implemented using an
authentic community-based participatory process (Pullman
2009).
In the context of this previous research, the current study
adds support to the notion that systems/policy changes
need to occur in order to support the implementation of
SOCs that meet the needs of diverse communities and
reflect core values of SOC philosophy. Specifically, con-
sistent with previous literature that has proposed specific
system/policy changes in SOC delivery (Cook and Kilmer
2010a; Kilmer et al. 2010), the findings of this study sug-
gest: (1) support for an ecological focus—a shift away
from a sole or primary focus on clinical services for an
identified patient, to address a broader range of programs
and services for at-risk youth and families, (e.g., commu-
nity stressors, poverty, unemployment) with funding to
support prevention and the strengthening of informal sup-
ports for families; and (2) support for a community-based,
family-centered care approach—an emphasis on family-
centered care and family-based decision-making supported
by funding for services to parents, siblings and other family
care-takers, an authentic involvement of family members
in care-planning, and funding to support community
development practices that support a sense of community
belonging and well-being. The translation of these values,
which already define SOC philosophy, into actual policy
changes would support the sustainability of SOCs such as
the one desired by AI community members—one that is
holistic, focused on wellness and prevention, provides
services to address broader community stressors, such as
poverty and unemployment, and supports the entire family
system.
Given the resonance of these findings with both com-
munity psychology theory and work on the implementation
of SOC in diverse communities, it is likely that these
system and policy recommendations have considerable
relevance beyond AI communities. Indeed, they may rep-
resent critical next steps for transforming behavioral health
systems of care so that they meet the needs of diverse
communities, fully reflect the philosophies and values by
which SOCs were originally conceptualized, and promote
effective and sustainable SOCs that produce consistent
positive outcomes for youth and families.
Acknowledgments The authors would like to acknowledge fol-
lowing members of the community research workgroup that
assisted
with data analyses and interpretation: Bobbie Bellinger, Megan
Bang, and Shannon Cobe. We would like to express our
gratitude to
youth, families, and elders who participated in this study and to
all the
community members who provided input throughout its
implemen-
tation. We would also like to acknowledge sponsors who
provided
funding to support this study: the Substance Abuse and Mental
Health
Services Administration (SAMHSA) and the Great Cities
Institute at
the University of Illinois at Chicago.
References
Beals, J., Novins, D. K., Whitesell, N. R., Spicer, P., Mitchell,
C. M.,
Manson, S. M., et al. (2005). Prevalence of mental disorders
and
utilization of mental health services in two American Indian
reservation populations: Mental health disparities in a national
context. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 162, 1723–1732.
Beals, J., Piasecki, J., Nelson, S., Jones, M., Keane, E.,
Dauphinais,
P., et al. (1997). Psychiatric disorder among American Indian
adolescents: Prevalence in northern plains youth. Journal of the
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36,
1252–1259.
Bruns, E. J., Walker, J. S., Zabel, M., Matarese, M., Estep, K.,
Harburger, D., et al. (2010). Intervening in the lives of youth
with complext behavioral health challenges and their families:
The rold of the wraparound process. American Journal of
Community Psychology, 46, 314–331.
Center for Disease Control. (1996). YRBSS: Youth risk
behavior
surveillance system. Retrieved June 3, 2010, from: http://
www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/.
Clark, R. L., & Witko, T. M. (2006). Growing up Indian:
Treatment
with urban Indian adolescents. In T. M. Witko (Ed.), Mental
health care for urban Indians: Clinical insights from native
practitioners (pp. 173–187). Washington, DC: American Psy-
chological Association.
Cook, J. R., & Kilmer, R. P. (2010a). Defining the scope of
systems of
care: An ecological perspective. Evaluation and Program
Planning, 33, 18–20.
452 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
123
http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/
http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/
Cook, J. R., & Kilmer, R. P. (2010b). The importance of context
in
fostering responsive community systems: Supports for families
in systems of care. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 80(1),
115–123.
Costello, E. J., Farmer, E. M. Z., Angold, A., Burns, B. J., &
Erkanli,
A. (1997). Psychiatric disorders among American Indian and
white youth in Appalachia: The Great Smoky Mountains study.
American Journal of Public Health, 87, 827–832.
Costello, E. J., Messer, S. C., Bird, H. R., Cohen, P., &
Reinherz, H.
Z. (1998). The prevalence of serious emotional disturbance: A
re-analysis of community studies. Journal of Child and Family
Studies, 7, 411–432.
D’Andrea, M. (1994). The concerns of Native American youth.
Journal
of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 22, 173–181.
Evaneshko, V. (1999). Mental health needs assessment of
Tucson’s
urban Native American population. American Indian and Alaska
Native Mental Health Research, 8, 41–61.
Gone, J. P. (2007). ‘‘We never was happy living like a
Whiteman’’:
Mental health disparities and the postcolonial predicament in
American Indian communities. American Journal of Community
Psychology, 40, 290–300.
Goodkind, J. R., Ross-Toledo, K., John, S., Hall, J. L., Ross, L.,
Freeland, L., et al. (2010). Promoting healing and restoring
trust:
Policy recommendations for improving behavioral health care
for American Indian/Alaska Native adolescents. American
Journal of Community Psychology, 46, 386–394.
Green, L. W., & Mercer, S. L. (2001). Can public health
researchers
and agencies reconcile the push from funding bodies and the
pull
from communities? American Journal of Public Health, 91,
1926–1929.
Israel, B. A., Schulz, A. J., Parker, E. A., & Becker, A. B.
(1998).
Review of community-based research: Assessing partnership
approaches to improve public health. Annuals of Research in
Public Health, 19, 173–202.
Kilmer, R. P., Cook, J. R., & Munsell, E. P. (2010). Moving
from
principles to practice: Recommended policy changes to promote
family-centered care. American Journal of Community Psychol-
ogy, 46, 332–341.
Moncher, M. S., Holden, G. W., & Trimble, J. E. (1997).
Substance
abuse among Native-American youth. Washington, DC: Amer-
ican Psychological Association.
Poupart, J., Baker, L., & Horse, J. R. (2009). Research with
American
Indian communities: The value of authentic partnerships.
Children and Youth Services Review, 31, 1180–1186.
Pullman, M. D. (2009). Participatory research in systems of care
for
children’s mental health. American Journal of Community
Psychology, 44, 33–53.
Rappaport, J., & Seidman, E. (2000). Handbook of community
psychology. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
Rutman, S., Park, A., Castor, M., Taualii, M., & Forquera, R.
(2008).
Urban American Indian and Alaska native youth: Youth risk
behavior survey 1997–2003. Maternal and Child Health Jour-
nal, 12, S76–S81.
Sarason, S. B. (1974). The psychological sense of community:
Prospects for community psychology. San Francisco: Jossey-
Bass.
Sarche, M., & Spicer, P. (2008). Poverty and health disparities
for
American Indian and Alaska native children. Annals of the New
York Academy of Sciences, 1136, 126–136.
Stiffman, A., Striley, C., Brown, E., Limb, G., & Ostmann, E.
(2003).
American Indian youth: Who southwestern urban and reserva-
tion youth turn to for help with mental health or addictions.
Journal of Child and Family Studies, 12, 319–333.
The Four Worlds Centre for Development Learning. (2000). The
community story framework. Retrieved January 15, 2008 from
http://www.fourworlds.ca/pdfs/Com_Story_Framework.pdf.
Urban Indian Health Commission (UIHC). (2007). Invisible
tribes:
Urban Indians and their health in a changing world. Seattle,
WA: Urban Indian Health Commission.
Urban Indian Health Institute (UIHI). (2009). Bemidji area
urban
American Indian/Alaska native needs assessment. Seattle, WA:
Seattle Indian Health Board.
U.S. Census Bureau (2000). 2000 census. Retrieved June 3,
2010,
from: http://www.census.gov/main/www/cen2000.html.
U.S. Census Bureau (2008). The 2008 statistical abstract.
Retrieved
June 3, 2010, from http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2001). Mental
health: Culture, race, and ethnicity. A supplement to mental
health: A report of the surgeon general (No. SMA01–3613).
Washington, DC: Office of the Surgeon General, Public Health
Service, U.S. Government Printing Office.
Walkup, J. T., Barlow, A., Mullaney, B. C., Pan, W., Goklish,
N.,
Hasting, R., et al. (2009). Randomized controlled trial of a
paraprofessional-delivered in-home for young reservation-based
American Indian mothers. Journal of the American Academy of
Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 48(6), 591–601.
Whitbeck, L. B., Yu, M., Johnson, K. D., Hoyt, D. R., & Walls,
M. L.
(2008). Diagnostic prevalence rates from early to mid-adoles-
cence among indigenous adolescents: First results from a
longitudinal study. Journal of the American Academy of Child
and Adolescent Psychiatry, 47, 890–900.
Witko, T. M. (Ed.). (2006). Mental health care for urban
Indians:
Clinical insights from native practitioners. Washington, DC:
American Psychological Association.
Zvolensky, M. J., McNeil, D. W., Porter, C. A., & Stewart, S.
H.
(2001). Assessment of anxiety sensitivity in young American
Indians and Alaska natives. Behaviour Research and Therapy,
39, 477–493.
Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 453
123
http://www.fourworlds.ca/pdfs/Com_Story_Framework.pdf
http://www.census.gov/main/www/cen2000.html
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab
Copyright of American Journal of Community Psychology is the
property of Springer Science & Business
Media B.V. and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users
may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.

More Related Content

Similar to Assessing Mental Health Needs of Urban American Indian Youth

Research methods final project
Research methods final projectResearch methods final project
Research methods final projectHayoung Cho
 
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestyles
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestylesCare in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestyles
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestylesPiia Tiilikainen
 
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docx
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docxGrowing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docx
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docxshericehewat
 
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de Oca
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de OcaThe Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de Oca
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de OcaUniversity of Texas at San Antonio
 
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptx
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptxRacial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptx
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptxRasha Seif
 
community health method.docx
community health method.docxcommunity health method.docx
community health method.docxstudywriters
 
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docx
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docxResearch is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docx
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docxwrite4
 
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxSanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxanhlodge
 
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...TÀI LIỆU NGÀNH MAY
 
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxDo you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxelinoraudley582231
 
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCH
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCHCase Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCH
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCHScott Mills
 
Mental Health in Schools Act Memo
Mental Health in Schools Act MemoMental Health in Schools Act Memo
Mental Health in Schools Act MemoTim Shieh
 
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health Care
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health CareClass 8, Part I Aging And Health Care
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health Carejcarlson1
 
Information needs of women in developing countries
Information needs of women in developing countriesInformation needs of women in developing countries
Information needs of women in developing countriesFrancesca Coraggio
 
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012Angie Aguirre
 
The stall stigma coalition
The stall stigma coalition The stall stigma coalition
The stall stigma coalition lara blanks
 
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)eriesase
 
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...Jim Bloyd, DrPH, MPH
 

Similar to Assessing Mental Health Needs of Urban American Indian Youth (20)

Research methods final project
Research methods final projectResearch methods final project
Research methods final project
 
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestyles
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestylesCare in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestyles
Care in China - a study of senior citizens' wellbeing lifestyles
 
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docx
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docxGrowing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docx
Growing Old Under the One-Child Policy Current Challenges.docx
 
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de Oca
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de OcaThe Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de Oca
The Aging in Mexico and the Role of the CSO's - Veronica Montes de Oca
 
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptx
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptxRacial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptx
Racial-Equity-and-Health-final-deckFINAL030521.pptx
 
JRelig
JReligJRelig
JRelig
 
community health method.docx
community health method.docxcommunity health method.docx
community health method.docx
 
SMA16-4969
SMA16-4969SMA16-4969
SMA16-4969
 
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docx
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docxResearch is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docx
Research is so important to psychology because it helps researchers.docx
 
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docxSanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
Sanctuary Cities Pros and ConsSanctuary Cities usually limit th.docx
 
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...
Social integration and the mental health needs of lgbtq asylum seekers in nor...
 
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docxDo you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
Do you feel the assessment was an appropriate tool If so, why, an.docx
 
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCH
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCHCase Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCH
Case Studies & Literature Review * Real Time Crisis Centre Hub #RTCH
 
Mental Health in Schools Act Memo
Mental Health in Schools Act MemoMental Health in Schools Act Memo
Mental Health in Schools Act Memo
 
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health Care
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health CareClass 8, Part I Aging And Health Care
Class 8, Part I Aging And Health Care
 
Information needs of women in developing countries
Information needs of women in developing countriesInformation needs of women in developing countries
Information needs of women in developing countries
 
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012
VP Prelim Plan Recs_May2012
 
The stall stigma coalition
The stall stigma coalition The stall stigma coalition
The stall stigma coalition
 
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)
Sase and Eddy. End of Life Care. Georgetown Public Policy (2016)
 
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...
Public Health, Place and Social Media for Organizing to Eliminate Health Ineq...
 

More from dunhamadell

One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docx
One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docxOne of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docx
One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docx
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docxOne of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docx
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docx
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docxOne of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docx
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docxdunhamadell
 
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docx
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docxOne popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docx
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docxdunhamadell
 
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docx
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docxone paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docx
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docxdunhamadell
 
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docx
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docxOne page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docx
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docxdunhamadell
 
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docx
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docxOne page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docx
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docx
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docxOne of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docx
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docx
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docxOne of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docx
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docx
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docxOne of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docx
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docxdunhamadell
 
One of the examples I chose for my readings was, For Coloured .docx
One of the examples I chose for my readings was,  For Coloured .docxOne of the examples I chose for my readings was,  For Coloured .docx
One of the examples I chose for my readings was, For Coloured .docxdunhamadell
 
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docx
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docxOne of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docx
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docxdunhamadell
 
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docx
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docxone 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docx
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docxdunhamadell
 
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docx
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docxOne complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docx
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docxdunhamadell
 
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docx
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docxOne implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docx
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docxdunhamadell
 
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docx
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docxOn the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docx
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docxdunhamadell
 
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docx
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docxOn the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docx
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docxdunhamadell
 
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docx
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docxOn November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docx
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docxdunhamadell
 
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docx
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docxOn Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docx
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docxdunhamadell
 
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docx
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docxompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docx
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docxdunhamadell
 

More from dunhamadell (20)

One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docx
One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docxOne of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docx
One of the most important ways we can strengthen our relationships w.docx
 
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docx
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docxOne of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docx
One of the five elements of emotional intelligence is self-awareness.docx
 
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docx
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docxOne of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docx
One of the challenges facing the Public Information Officer (PIO.docx
 
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docx
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docxOne popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docx
One popular measure of human capital today is employee engagement, w.docx
 
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docx
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docxone paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docx
one paragraph with intext citation and reference follow up discussio.docx
 
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docx
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docxOne page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docx
One page please!!1. Using conflict perspective, discuss the ca.docx
 
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docx
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docxOne page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docx
One page per question What is a political party How do the tw.docx
 
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docx
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docxOne of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docx
One of the biggest challenges in serial killer investigation has.docx
 
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docx
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docxOne of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docx
One of the main jobs of historians is to interpret the past by revie.docx
 
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docx
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docxOne of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docx
One of the responsibilities of the medical administrator is hand.docx
 
One of the examples I chose for my readings was, For Coloured .docx
One of the examples I chose for my readings was,  For Coloured .docxOne of the examples I chose for my readings was,  For Coloured .docx
One of the examples I chose for my readings was, For Coloured .docx
 
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docx
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docxOne of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docx
One of the many reasons social workers conduct  needs assessment.docx
 
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docx
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docxone 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docx
one 2-3 page essay (typed and double-spaced). Your essay should have.docx
 
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docx
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docxOne complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docx
One complex issue that a public organization has to monitor on a.docx
 
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docx
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docxOne implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docx
One implication of diverse cultures is that elements of one cult.docx
 
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docx
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docxOn the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docx
On the project topic of Phishing. Please complete the below tasks.docx
 
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docx
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docxOn the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docx
On the tomcat drive in folder cosc210 you will find file named Paint.docx
 
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docx
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docxOn November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docx
On November 3, 2020, Californias Privacy Rights Act is on the b.docx
 
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docx
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docxOn Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docx
On Human Capital (250 Words)The neoliberal understanding of h.docx
 
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docx
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docxompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docx
ompile the information you have gathered on your companies in weeks .docx
 

Recently uploaded

Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Krashi Coaching
 
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsScience 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsKarinaGenton
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxRoyAbrique
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...Marc Dusseiller Dusjagr
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxGaneshChakor2
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionSafetyChain Software
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformChameera Dedduwage
 
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  ) Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  )
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application ) Sakshi Ghasle
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxPoojaSen20
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Sapana Sha
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
Kisan Call Centre - To harness potential of ICT in Agriculture by answer farm...
 
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its CharacteristicsScience 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
Science 7 - LAND and SEA BREEZE and its Characteristics
 
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptxContemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
Contemporary philippine arts from the regions_PPT_Module_12 [Autosaved] (1).pptx
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory InspectionMastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
Mastering the Unannounced Regulatory Inspection
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
 
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  ) Hybridoma Technology  ( Production , Purification , and Application  )
Hybridoma Technology ( Production , Purification , and Application )
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docxMENTAL     STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION format.docx
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
Call Girls in Dwarka Mor Delhi Contact Us 9654467111
 

Assessing Mental Health Needs of Urban American Indian Youth

  • 1. O R I G I N A L P A P E R A Mental Health Needs Assessment of Urban American Indian Youth and Families Amy E. West • Ellen Williams • Eli Suzukovich • Kathlene Strangeman • Douglas Novins Published online: 5 October 2011 � Society for Community Research and Action 2011 Abstract American Indian (AI) youth experience sig- nificant mental health disparities. The majority of AI youth live in urban areas, yet urban AI youth are underserved and unstudied. This manuscript describes a qualitative study of community mental health needs in an urban population of AI youth, conducted as part of the planning process for a system of care (SOC). Participants included 107 urban AI youth and families that participated in one of 16 focus groups assessing mental health needs and services. Forty- one percent of participants were youth or young adults.
  • 2. Data were coded and analyzed using qualitative software and then further analyzed and interpreted in partnership with a community research workgroup. Results indicated various community characteristics, mental health and wellness needs, and service system needs relevant to developing a system of care in this community. Key community, cultural, and social processes also emerged, reinforcing the importance of broader system changes to promote a sustainable SOC. These systems/policy changes are reviewed in the context of previous literature proposing necessary systems change to support behavioral health care in AI communities as well as to ensure that SOC imple- mentation is consistent with core values and philosophy across all communities. Keywords American Indian � Urban � Children and adolescents � Mental health � System of care � Qualitative Introduction American Indian (AI) 1
  • 3. youth are among the most vulner- able children and adolescents in the United States with rates of poverty, exposure to violence, mental health issues, and suicide/death rates that are staggering (Sarche and Spicer 2008; U.S. DHHS 2001). Extant research indicates that AIs are at higher risk than any other ethnic group for mental health problems (Costello et al. 1998; Moncher et al. 1997). AI youth experience exceedingly high rates of depression, anxiety, trauma, substance abuse, and suicide (Stiffman et al. 2003) and are at high risk for a variety of poor outcomes, including teen pregnancy, school drop out, out of home placement, and accidental death (Witko 2006). Statistics illuminate tragic and disturbing behavioral and mental health disparities experienced by AIs, and espe- cially AI youth. These disparities have emerged in the context of social, political, cultural, and historical dynam- ics since colonization. AI people were subject to one of the most significant and systematic genocides in world history
  • 4. (D’Andrea 1994), and have endured prolonged exploita- tion, unimaginable loss, and profound suffering during the past 500 years. A legacy of trauma, poverty, disenfran- chisement, discrimination, and failed US policies aimed at annihilation and then assimilation is compounded by cul- tural differences compared to mainstream Western culture, a lack of adequate epidemiological and health-related data, and competition for scarce resources, which together A. E. West (&) � E. Williams � E. Suzukovich Institute for Juvenile Research, Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, 1747 W. Roosevelt Rd. Rm 155, Chicago, IL 60608, USA e-mail: [email protected] K. Strangeman American Indian Center of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA D. Novins University of Colorado Denver, Denver, CO, USA 1 American Indian, or AI, is used throughout this manuscript to refer
  • 5. to people of American Indian or Alaska Native descent. 123 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 DOI 10.1007/s10464-011-9474-6 contribute to the current physical, behavioral and mental health crisis for AIs. While the majority of AI youth now live in urban settings (Witko 2006), urban AI youth rep- resent an almost completely unstudied, and essentially invisible group of vulnerable children and adolescents with regard to mental health (or any other) issues. Substantial need exists for research examining the unique experience of urban AI youth in order to inform models of mental health promotion and intervention development. The system of care (SOC) philosophy for mental health service delivery proposes a coordinated network of com- munity-based services and supports that are organized to meet the challenges of youth with serious mental health
  • 6. needs and their families. In recognition of the unique and specific needs of AI communities in planning to implement SOCs, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) launched the Circles of Care (COC) grant program in 1998. This program provides resources for community-based infrastructure development and planning for SOCs in AI communities. The commu- nity-based focus of COC is particularly important as pre- vious research in AI communities has demonstrated that methodological approaches must be culturally-driven and leverage AI cultural strengths, belief systems, and competencies (Poupart et al. 2009). Such research is best pursued when communities and researchers form authentic partnerships, which are embodied in the principles and practice of community-based participatory research (CBPR) (Green and Mercer 2001; Israel et al. 1998). Authentic partnerships are ones in which partners exhibit respect, collaboration, equal authority in decision-making,
  • 7. and open communication. Founded in CBPR principles, the purpose of a COC grant is to provide tribal and urban AI communities with resources to design holistic, community- based systems of care to support mental health and well- ness for their youth and families. The first step in developing a system of care is to assess the needs of the specific community that the SOC is expected to serve. This manuscript describes a qualitative study of community mental health and wellness needs in an urban population of AI youth that was conducted as part of a COC grant awarded to the American Indian Center of Chicago (AIC). The AIC is the oldest urban Indian center in the country and the primary community agency serving the large Chicago AI community. The current study had the following primary objectives: (1) to actively involve the AI community in Chicago in a community-based participatory research project, and (2) to determine the mental health and service needs of AI youth and families in the Chicago
  • 8. community in order to develop culturally-appropriate ser- vices to meet these needs. The purpose of collecting these data was to inform the conceptualization, development, and implementation of an SOC for this community. Key study findings indicated a range of important community needs, but also highlighted various systemic challenges and broader social and conceptual shifts that may need to occur in SOC policy in order to develop a successful SOC in this community. Therefore, a third objective of this study became to (3) recognize community, cultural, and social processes (e.g. historical trauma, political divides, stigma and distrust, cultural relevance, and community readiness for change) that are critical in developing an effective system of care in this community, as well as indicate broader systemic changes needed to support diverse fami- lies and communities. The Need for Systems of Care in Urban AI Communities
  • 9. According to the U.S. Census Bureau (2008), there are 4.5 million people who identify themselves as AI in the United States, of which approximately 30% are under the age of 18. There are over 500 federally recognized tribes and over 100 state recognized tribes, each of which has unique social and cultural systems. In addition, approximately 67% of the AI population in the United States lives in urban areas rather than on reservations (U.S. Census Bureau 2000). Chicago has one of the largest urban AI populations: 20,898 in Cook County and up to 50,000 in the larger metropolitan area (U.S. Census Bureau 2000). Mental Health Disparities in American Indian Youth AIs are at higher risk than any other cultural group for mental illness and AI youth may be at high risk for various psychiatric disorders, including substance abuse, depres- sion, anxiety, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), conduct disorder, and suicide (Beals et al. 1997, 2005; Costello et al. 1997, 1998; Moncher et al. 1997;
  • 10. Whitbeck et al. 2008; Zvolensky et al. 2001). Evidence suggests a rapid increase in the prevalence of psychiatric disorders over the course of adolescence in AI youth. Whitbeck et al. (2008) reported an increase in the preva- lence of a single lifetime disorder from 25.6% at ages 10–12 to 44.8% at ages 13–15 in their longitudinal study of AI youth on four reservations. In addition, AI people have the highest suicide rates of any ethnic group in the United States; data from the Indian Health Service (2003) indicate that suicide is the 2nd leading cause of death for AI youth aged 15–24 and is 3.5 times higher than the national aver- age. As a whole, AI youth are more likely to: die before they reach adulthood, die an accidental death, die as the result of homicide, commit suicide, be in court-ordered foster care, be in federal custody, experience violent victimization, and drop out of school when compared to youth in any other ethnic group (Sarche and Spicer 2008; Witko 2006). 442 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453
  • 11. 123 American Indian Youth in Urban Communities Consistent with efforts to assimilate AIs into mainstream society, federal legislation was enacted in the 1950s and 60s to relocate AIs to urban settings, where inter-tribal diversity and integration would dilute AI culture and force assimi- lation to the mainstream. AIs were promised economic opportunity and job training, which stimulated a migration of AIs to cities. However, once these AIs arrived they were met with little governmental support, leading to unem- ployment, poverty, and social and cultural isolation (Witko 2006). Separated from their tribal homeland, urban AI families found themselves facing these problems, including oppression and racism, with limited coping skills, no eco- nomic security, and the absence of the tight-knit social support of their tribal communities (Clark and Witko 2006). These factors contributed to feelings of alienation, disem-
  • 12. powerment, and hopelessness (Clark and Witko 2006). We know very little regarding the current psychosocial contexts of urban AI communities. The few studies spe- cifically focused on urban AIs have found high rates of substance abuse, depression, anxiety, suicidality, and trauma, compounded by poverty, unemployment, family and community violence, and low rates of service utiliza- tion (Evaneshko 1999). Indeed, a recent report on urban AI health documented that urban AIs experience extreme poverty, demonstrate significant health and mental health disparities, face numerous challenges trying to access quality health care services, and are largely ignored by the American health care system (UIHC 2007). AI youth in urban settings, who are likely the children or grandchildren of those relocated, may be affected by historical trauma and accumulated stress, and they may experience loss of traditional cultural heritage, stress over negotiating their ethnic and cultural identity, racism, and oppression. They
  • 13. must also deal with the multiple stresses of urban living, including their disadvantaged economic status. Data from the Youth Risk Behavior Survey (CDC 1996) indicate that urban AI youth are more likely to engage in a variety of high risk behaviors than their European American coun- terparts, including illegal drug use, early initiation of sex- ual intercourse, use of tobacco, alcohol, and marijuana, carrying weapons, physical fights at school, and school avoidance (Rutman et al. 2008). The Chicago American Indian Community Although there is limited epidemiological data specific to Chicago, previous efforts suggest that this AI community suffers from the same problems (disadvantaged socioeconomic status, high-risk status of youth, and behavioral and mental health disparities) that have been documented in other urban AI communities (UIHI 2009; U.S. Census Bureau 2008). A general health needs assessment conducted in Chicago by the Urban Indian
  • 14. Health Institute/Seattle Indian Health Board (2009) indi- cated that substance abuse, anxiety/stress, depression, sui- cide, financial problems, unemployment, accidents, teen pregnancy, community violence, domestic violence, hous- ing issues, legal problems, and insurance and health care access issues were significant problems, and concluded that the Chicago community had substantial health needs as well as social and economic factors that put community members at risk for not receiving needed services. The study described in this manuscript comprised a qualitative needs assessment study to further assess the specific needs of youth in the Chicago AI community in order to plan for an SOC. In addition, our CBPR and qualitative methods facilitated the examination of important community, cul- tural, and social processes that may affect the development and implementation of an SOC in urban AI communities and have implications for broader system changes needed to sustain an effective SOC in other communities.
  • 15. Methods This study was conducted using a CBPR approach and utilized a culturally-informed methodology. To develop our focus group guide, we adapted the Community Story Framework, a culturally-informed qualitative methodology developed for use with AI communities (The Four Worlds Centre for Development Learning 2000). The Community Story Framework was developed as a tool for participatory analysis in AI communities and brings people together in small groups to discuss important issues in community life, such as the well-being of youth and families, in the context of such domains as family life, social life, emotional life, and cultural/spiritual life. Our structured focus group guide included additional questions assessing three main domains: (1) the mental health/positive development needs of urban AI youth in Chicago, (2) the available support systems, mental health services, and service utilization, and (3) potential cultural and historical parameters that might
  • 16. drive the development of innovative service approaches to meet community needs. Sample questions from the focus group guide include: ‘‘What are some of the problems that youth in our community face today?’’, ‘‘What do you hear about mental health services in our community?’’, and ‘‘What would life be like for youth in a healthy family and Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 443 123 community?’’ A community workgroup actively partici- pated in the development of the focus group guide. Participants for this study were recruited through com- munity announcements, networking at events and pow- wows, posted flyers, and word-of-mouth. Sixteen focus groups were completed with a total of 107 youth and families participating. Informed consent, parental permis- sion for youth under 18, and youth assent was obtained prior to participation. One hundred percent of participants
  • 17. identified as AI. Forty-one percent of participants were under the age of 25, and 14% were under age 18. Eighteen percent of participants were community elders (a commu- nity elder is generally defined as a senior community member with cultural wisdom and a commitment to shar- ing and teaching). Sixty-six percent of participants were female. Each group had 6-12 participants and lasted 2 hours. Groups were organized by age group (e.g., teens, young adults, adults, elders) and generally included a mix of genders. Groups were facilitated by two of the authors of this manuscript (AW and KS), who are in leadership roles on the COC grant and have working relationships with the AIC (one is an AIC staff member, the other is on the AIC Board) and experience working in this community. The structure of the groups was standardized; facilitators asked questions in the same manner and sequence across all 16 groups. The research protocol was approved by the Uni- versity of Illinois at Chicago IRB.
  • 18. Each focus group was audio recorded and professionally transcribed. A coding structure was developed based on eight core domains of interest that represented areas of interest for analysis. The eight codes were: (1) community characteristics; (2) community demographics; (3) indica- tors of health and mental health; (4) risk and protective factors; (5) definitions of mental illness; (6) service system needs; (7) barriers to accessing services; and (8) accept- ability of existing services. Two authors (EW and ES), who also have relationships with AIC and are from the Chicago AI community, served as coders on the project. They established reliability by double coding three transcripts, and completed the analysis of the transcripts using AtlasTi software. Data analysis involved coding text, producing text reports by code, and identifying and counting themes from text through an iterative process of reviewing code reports. After initial coding by the research team, code reports were reviewed by our community research work-
  • 19. group, a committee of community members who volun- teered to assist with study design and data analyses. Community workgroup members reviewed the code reports and discussed findings with project staff in bi-weekly committee meetings. This process served to validate coding completed by initial coders as well as facilitating discus- sion to ensure that codes were adequately discussed in depth and considered in context when interpreting themes. Results Data were coded to determine the primary themes emerg- ing for each of the codes. The themes for each code are listed in Table 1. While all identified themes are listed in the table, results discussed below were limited to those that may be most pertinent to developing SOC components. These themes were identified by the research team and agreed upon by the community research committee during analysis and consensus meetings. Community Characteristics
  • 20. The first two codes were developed to assess community demographics as well as specific community, cultural, or social factors that characterize the Chicago AI community. Specifically, the community characteristics code was used to capture characteristics such as historical influences, identity issues, politics, relocation effects, dynamics in community, aspects of urban AI culture, and traditions/ practices in community. Participants reported (1) increased dispersion of the AI population across the Chicago metro- politan area over the past 20–30 years. Gentrification has forced the AI community out of its original geographical location and families are now located across the expansive city and suburbs. Participants associated this phenomenon with a perceived invisibility of AI people in the larger Chicago community as well as with other aspects of cultural dispersion, such as mixed heritage due to inter-race coupling, decreased knowledge of language and participation in cul- tural traditions, and the stresses of trying to ‘‘live between
  • 21. two worlds.’’ For example, one participant noted the effect of dispersion and integration within the urban community as contributing to a potential loss of cultural knowledge: I believe there needs to be some working on that particular issue in that living on the reservation and then leaving as a product of Indian relocation- the only way I would get a lot of the cultural things was to go back to my reservation and spend summers there. A lot of things became a void and I had to relearn those as an adult because I found importance in those things. And so living in an urban environ- ment you lose those things, unless there is a concerted effort to take that cultural information and impart that to the youth because they are living in their own world. They go play basketball after school and they get integrated with other races and stuff, there is a pan racial, ethnic thing in an urban area. Second, participants highlighted (2) a sense of division in
  • 22. the AI community. They noted physical dispersion, inter- tribal diversity, tensions between community leaders and organizations, and the diminished interdependence that 444 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 123 Table 1 Needs assessment themes General themes Themes from youth groups Community characteristics Historic nostalgia Dispersion of population Division within community Importance of tribal identity Need for community cohesion Importance of cultural practice Community demographics Violence Financial instability
  • 23. Single and teen parenting Alcohol/drug use Invisibility as ethnic population Gangs Violence Peer pressure Mental health indicators Positive: Healthy lifestyle Spiritual strength and practice Balance Coping skills Happiness Positive relationships Negative: Alcohol and drug use Violence Gangs
  • 24. Negative lifestyle behavior Stress and anxiety Poverty Positive: Cultural and spiritual health Connection with elders Good relationship with school, teachers Negative: Peer pressure Lack of adult role models Factors of risk and/or protection Protection: Sense of belonging Extended family Extended family
  • 25. Involved community Risk: Negative coping skills Lack of structure and guidance Chronic stress Community division Lack of connection Poor communication Sense of loss Apathy Protection: Positive reinforcement from adults Sense of community Accountability from adults Pride in culture Risk:
  • 26. Poor communication, gossip Lack of accountability from adults Hopelessness, alienation Lack of support and trust Definitions of mental illness Achieving balance Balance Stigma of mental illness Lack of support and caring from adults Need for culturally-relevant definition Alienation and isolation Alienation from family and community Lack of expression and communication Trauma Service system needs Funding for programs Funding Improvements in infrastructure Need for health services Specific services for youth mental health Lack of support Cultural relevance
  • 27. Promotion of general wellness Lack of education, behavioral health, and recreational activities Barriers to accessing services Poor communication/lack of knowledge Shame, embarrassment Practical barriers Mistrust, fear Stigma Need to be proud and strong Lack of trust Lack of adults modeling help-seeking Preference for community supports Lack of culturally-sensitive providers Acceptability of existing services Need for perceptive clinicians Need for cultural sensitivity A trusting clinical relationships Need for perceptive clinicians Absence of quality services Traditional healing Community politics Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 445 123
  • 28. once existed, as contributing to feelings of disconnection and division between community members. One partici- pant stated: Well, one thing I see about a lot of Natives is that they are separate. My tribe is this and your tribe is this. And we talk about each other. And we don’t really come together as Native people. If you are a Native, you are a Native. I don’t care whether you are from north, south, east or west, because we should love each other being Native, Native people. The community demographics code was used to capture sociodemographic characteristics such as housing, employ- ment rate, poverty, neighborhood issues, school drop-out, and family structure. One prominent theme was (1) violence in community, most notably violence associated with aspects of inner city living such as gangs, drugs, and dangerous neigh- borhoods. One participant illustrated this theme, stating:
  • 29. And my big concern is, the kids in this neighborhood- you know, we saw three shootings out here about 6 months ago. One young man died on that doorstep over there. That makes an impact on you, you know. So it is like gangs and drugs are eating our children up and spitting them out and putting them into incarceration. They do not belong there. What I see is, it takes a whole village to raise a child. And I think we try to do that. In addition, participants noted (2) financial instability, including lack of employment, relying on public assistance, housing problems, and youth having to contribute to family finances. Finally, participants discussed the (3) challenges related to parenting, including the prevalence of single par- ents, extended family raising children, and teen parenting. Mental Health and Wellness The next set of codes was designed to capture themes associated with conceptualizations and experience of mental health and wellness in the AI community in Chi-
  • 30. cago. First, the mental health indicators code was used to capture indicators of community health or mental health such as arrest rates, substance abuse, gang violence, foster care placements, HIV, and chronic illnesses. We chose to focus on both indicators of positive mental health in addition to negative mental health. Indicators of positive mental health and wellness included (1) healthy lifestyle behaviors, such as healthy eating and youth/family par- ticipation in sports activities and athletics; (2) spiritual strength, which participants described as having the spiri- tual grounding to weather life’s challenges; (3) regular spiritual practice, which included prayer, participation in ceremony, and teaching youth spiritual traditions; and (4) positive and healthy coping skills. Indicators of negative mental health noted by participants included (1) alcohol and drug usage; (2) violence; (3) gangs; (4) unhealthy lifestyle behaviors, such as poor diet, lack of exercise, and mismanagement of chronic illnesses; (5) stress and anxi-
  • 31. ety; and (6) the negative impact of poverty. In general, participants noted the high prevalence of indicators of negative mental health, such as violence (both community violence as well as violence occurring within families), poverty, substance abuse, and high stress levels, and the need for more focus on promoting indicators of positive mental health and wellness, such as using spirituality to promote a sense of purpose and balance, the development of good coping skills, and fostering healthy relationships. The risk and protection codes were used to capture community strengths (e.g. use of Native language, tradi- tional practices, close-knit families, programs for youth, academic achievement, positive role models) and risks (e.g. spiritual problems, stressful life events, poverty, trauma and historical trauma, racism). Themes emerging related to community protective factors included: (1) the importance of a sense of belonging—to family, to community, and to society; (2) having a strong connection to extended family
  • 32. members who provide nurturing relationships for youth; and (3) having a supportive, involved community that prioritizes the healthy development of youth and maintenance of healthy families. Themes related to community risk included (1) negative coping skills, such as alcohol and anger/ violence; (2) a lack of structure and guidance for youth; (3) chronic stress; (4) community division; (5) a lack of connection to community; and (5) poor communication. Although some of these themes (e.g. negative coping skills, stress) may appear to be individual-level risk factors, the focus of this discussion was on how these factors were per- vasive enough throughout community that they represented community-level risk factors influencing overall youth and family wellness. In general, participants noted that many of the core aspects of protection from risk, such as a strong sense of family and the importance of community life, exist but are diminished by exposure to risk factors such as chronic stressors, lack of good communication, and a sense of loss. In
  • 33. particular, participants noted that compounded risk factors contribute to a lack of sense of purpose and direction for many community youth. One young adult stated: I think lack of direction is always just at the root of so many struggles with youth, period. Especially in this community, I’ve been in this community my entire life. And I just think maybe, for many different reasons, family or just lack of resources, lack of a place to even just go…But there’s no sense of direction of what a person wants to do, or where to go, or what to do with their time constructively. I think there’s maybe not enough encouragement. I think there are in certain 446 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 123 arenas. Everyone says ‘‘go to school, go to school.’’ But then for a lot of people, you don’t have the money to go to school… So then what do you do then? So I think that causes a lot of despair and then you kind of give up.
  • 34. The definition of mental illness code was used to capture any discussion relevant to local definitions of wellness, mental health, or emotional health. There was not much explicit discussion of mental illness by participants in this study. When asked to describe the meaning of mental or emotional health, the predominant response was (1) achieving balance, with the predominant description of a lack of mental health as being out of balance. Other discussion coded in this domain indicated (2) stigma and distrust related to mainstream mental illness diagnoses. Participants also emphasized a preference for (3) more culturally-relevant definitions, such as balance and holistic wellness. One participant illustrated this theme by stating: People have a tendency these days to identify you by your sicknesses, so you become a collection of sick- nesses that people are managing…I think the idea should be that good wellness should look at sickness as disease, but not disease as in a thing, but disease as in
  • 35. disease. The disease is you have gotten out of balance. There is something that is not making your life work the way it should be and we are going to move you from that uneasy place again to a healthy place. In addition, participants tended to focus on root causes of behavioral or emotional difficulties, such as (4) feelings of alienation and disconnection from family and community. Finally, (5) the experience of trauma, both individually and collectively as a community, emerged as a major theme related to emotional and behavioral difficulties experienced by youth. The discussion of trauma ranged from community violence, such as gangs and drug violence, to sexual abuse within families, to the collective historical trauma experienced by the urban AI community in Chicago and AI peoples as a whole. Service Needs The final group of codes was designed to assess perspec- tives about the current service system and what community members perceive to be the gaps and unmet service needs.
  • 36. The first code, service system needs, was used to capture what kinds of services are (or are not) available in the community and to assess gaps in services, unavailability of services or programs, and problems with available services. Participants noted a significant need for (1) funding for programs and (2) improvements in infrastructure. Partici- pants described lack of funding and infrastructure chal- lenges such as lack of staffing and/or expertise needed as contributing to a sparse and constantly changing menu of available health and mental health services within com- munity. Participants also discussed (3) the need for specific services aimed at mental and behavioral wellness for youth; (4) the need for services that are culturally-relevant (e.g. that incorporate traditional medicine or spiritual practices) and based within their community; and (5) the need for more services and programs that facilitate healthy social interaction and promote general wellness. Speaking specifically about what is needed in terms of services, one
  • 37. participant stated: Creating more opportunities for the healing process and exposure to all of those things [traditional prac- tices]. Spirituality, there’s a lot of connections with medicine men and women in the community now. There are more opportunities for other clinical work. And finding a balance that works for families that is culturally appropriate helps a lot. The barriers to accessing services code was used to assess any difficulties accessing current services. The themes emerging under this code included (1) poor communication and lack of knowledge about accessing mental and behav- ioral health services; (2) practical barriers such as insur- ance, financial issues, and transportation; (3) stigma related to accessing services; and (4) impact of barriers such as lack of trust. In particular, participants reported not accessing services for fear of being called crazy or being the subject of gossip, as well as having concerns about confidentiality,
  • 38. especially when utilizing local community agencies where others might see them arriving for appointments or where other community members might be employed. Participants also discussed not trusting non-AI practitioners or providers not familiar with AI culture to understand their unique needs and value systems. Finally, participants discussed (5) a preference for utilizing community supports and family members or peers when in distress, rather than accessing mainstream mental health services. One participant descri- bed this phenomenon by saying: I think that the mental health services that we used to have came from everybody else’s community. And if you wanted something the chances are there was someone else in the community you were going to run into when you were waiting…that was going through the same thing or had the same thing and they helped you out with it…family meant a lot more. And you had family wherever you looked. And that was your mental health services. It was either your
  • 39. peers or your age group or someone else that was walking around the streets, just the way you were. The final code in this group, acceptability of existing services assessed the acceptability of existing services, including the cultural appropriateness and quality of Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 447 123 available services. Participants highlighted the importance of having providers that are (1) perceptive to their unique needs; and (2) with whom they can build a trusting relationship. Participants agreed on (3) the general absence of quality services available for youth and also discussed (4) the com- munity politics (e.g. relationship dynamics and history between community leaders and agencies) driving the utili- zation of different programs and services within community. Youth-Specific Findings As 41% of the sample was under the age of 25, the findings
  • 40. discussed above generally characterize the findings of youth and young adults that were sampled in this study. However, when youth data were analyzed separately, a few additional youth-specific themes emerged. Youth-specific themes included (1) developing skills to cope with stress and neg- ative situations; and (2) the need for positive role models within family and community. Within the community characteristics codes, youth identified (1) tribal identity as important because it provides a sense of community and belonging and enhances knowledge of language and tradi- tions. Youth also discussed (2) the interplay between com- munity cohesion and maintaining cultural ties, while also maintaining individual identities and being free to have their own ideas and perspectives as an important characteristic of community life. Finally, youth identified (3) peer pressure as underlying many of the other community characteristics identified, such as substance use, gangs, violence, and teen pregnancy. Peer pressure was also a prominent theme within
  • 41. the mental health and wellness codes, where it was identified to impede wellness and healthy coping through serving as a mechanism through which youth become involved in abusing substances, violent behavior, and join- ing gangs. In addition, youth participants discussed the need for (1) role models to demonstrate healthy coping and healthy lifestyle behaviors, and who were interested in being involved in youth’s lives and teaching culture. Many youth identified the importance of (2) cultural and spiritual health and their desire to connect or re-connect with cultural and spiritual traditions. For example, one youth stated: Having a culture, having traditions kind of gives you, maybe, a purpose or something, to take care of or something to hold. And, having something like that, you know, a form of responsibility, kind of makes you stronger. You know, having responsibility to carry traditions and to uphold the culture, you know, it gives you something to do, to care about, you know
  • 42. what I mean, an outlet in itself. Finally, youth stressed the need for (3) positive reinforce- ment from adults and teachers; (4) accountability from adults and organizations; and (5) the need for individuals and institutions in their lives to promote a sense of cultural pride. All these things were identified as coping mechanisms or buffers that would help them manage the intense risk factors and stressors in their daily lives. Within the service needs codes, one interesting additional theme that emerged specific to youth responses was the barrier presented by (1) the message that youth need to be strong and proud (particularly males), which causes shame and embarrassment and prevents youth from seeking help when they need it. Community, Cultural, and Social Processes There were several subtle yet powerful themes that emerged in our analyses that did not fit neatly into our coding domains, or were so consistent throughout many coding domains that they were deemed to represent pervasive and significant processes
  • 43. within community experience that may relate to youth and family mental health and community needs. These themes were either discussed explicitly during focus groups or emerged through the integration of data and discussion with community research workgroup members. They included (1) the impact of historical trauma (i.e. the collective emotional and psychological injury, both over the life course and across generations, resulting from catastrophic history of genocide); (2) political divisiveness within community and community organizations; (3) the need for a sense of belonging; (4) challenges in the cultural connection between youth and adults/elders; (5) stigma about mental and behavioral health, (6) internalized oppression (i.e. accepting the oppressor’s perception of you), (7) strained interactions with outside systems (e.g. public schools, health care); and (8) fear of loss of culture and tradition. The examination of these community, cultural, and social processes was identified to be critical in developing meaningful, sustainable, and effective interven-
  • 44. tions or systems of services to promote mental health and well- being for urban AI youth and families in Chicago. Of these, the most significant and overarching theme discussed by partici- pants and by research team and workgroup members analyz- ing data was the impact of trauma on community life in the Chicago AI community. It was proposed that historical trauma is a powerful psychological, social, and structural phenome- non that contributes to community dynamics, including: divisiveness and disconnection within community; self- focused and parallel oppression (i.e. oppressing one’s own people); the loss of culture through dispersion, forgetting or assimilation; a sense of inferiority and different-ness that separates youth from their non-AI peers and society; tension between AI communities and outside systems; and a pervasive sense of alienation, anxiety, and depression that characterizes a typical trauma response. One participant stated: There is so much grief and it is not expressed. It is acted out. And grief sometimes turns into anger. And
  • 45. 448 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 123 then you’ve got anger, and these kids growing up [thinking] ‘I don’t want to be around here. These people are mad at me.’ And they [youth] don’t know that they are not causing it. It was also noteworthy that, although discussion often centered on challenges, needs, and barriers, as this was an important objective of this study, participants and work- group members also emphasized the capacity for resiliency, adaptation, and cultural renewal evidenced by AI peoples. There was a sense conveyed by participants that AI cultural strengths and resources could heal the community, shape positive youth development, and enhance relationships between the Chicago AI community and the broader system if properly understood and leveraged. One participant illustrated the importance of leveraging community
  • 46. strengths, beliefs, and values to heal by saying: ‘‘And it’s the people that will heal each other from the inside…it’s the people who will heal other people from the inside’’. Discussion Our discussion is organized around four prominent themes emerging from this study that we believe are relevant to systems change for this and other AI communities: (1) the need to address the role of historical trauma and internalized oppression in shaping divisions within community and affecting a community’s readiness for change, (2) the importance of extensive community mobilization efforts to address community politics, factions of the community, and organizational alliances, (3) the need to honor locally- meaningful conceptualizations of mental health and wellness, and (4) the need for community-based and cul- turally-relevant clinical services and programs. We address the broader implications of these findings in our conclusions. Addressing Historical Trauma and Internalized Oppression
  • 47. Throughout the implementation of this study, participants acknowledged that the collective trauma experienced by AI people over the life course and across generations related to genocide has contributed to the social, political, cultural, and historical dynamics within Indian country (and between Indian country and mainstream society) since colonization. In addition, internalized oppression was rec- ognized to contribute to the politics, divisions, disconnec- tion, perceived loss of culture, invisibility and strained interactions with outside systems. Participants in this study perceived that historical trauma may directly relate to community risk factors, mental health issues, environ- mental stressors, and stigma about mental health. In addition, participants perceived that a legacy of trauma and oppression may contribute to the tendency for community members to sometimes divide and work against rather than with each other, even when shared commitment and pas- sion is evident, or to become disconnected and burned out.
  • 48. To address the impact of historical trauma, an SOC could include education, training, and opportunities for open dia- logue. This could take the form of outreach, trainings for community leaders, program directors and community members on historical trauma, its impact on AI communities and organizations, and methods for addressing and healing from its effects. There are national models for community building and healing from historical trauma (for exam- ples, see http://historicaltrauma.com/interventions.html) that could be incorporated into the planning and program devel- opment phases of an SOC. An SOC could also incorporate culturally-based training in methods of effective communi- cation and relationship-building to help address the divi- siveness and burn-out associated with effects of historical trauma. Such programs exist; for example, the Healthy Native Communities Fellowship (http://www.hncpartners. org) brings teams of AI community members from around the country together for intensive training to become change
  • 49. agents creating wellness strategies for their communities grounded in AI cultural and spiritual teachings. Finally, an SOC may include regular community talking circles or group sessions conducted by trained community facilitators to bring community members together to discuss sensitive topics, such as trauma, racism, and oppression, as well as empower them to problem-solve and plan for the future in a safe and structured setting. The incorporation of these SOC components would constitute a focus on community devel- opment and empowerment, prevention, and a reliance on indigenous ways of knowing and supports in order to heal. Mobilizing Community to Heal Relationships and Division There was a sense from study participants that the trauma of relocation, combined with the stresses of urban living, the dispersion of the community throughout the metro- politan area, and divisions between AI-serving organiza- tions competing for constituents and resources has led
  • 50. some community members to feel disconnected, uncertain of their place within community, or simply too over- whelmed and stressed to participant in community life in the way they would like. The data also indicated that promoting a sense of belonging to community was a key component in achieving family mental health and wellness. Therefore, an SOC would need to include innovative methods to mobilize community and address barriers such as geographical dispersion, divisions among community members and agencies, and the invisibility of the AI Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 449 123 http://historicaltrauma.com/interventions.html http://www.hncpartners.org http://www.hncpartners.org population within the larger urban service system. To address geographic dispersion and disconnection, commu- nity members indicated that recreational activities planned
  • 51. and sponsored by multiple organizations would help to bring people together, build community, create a sense of belonging and empowerment, and enable the sharing of information. To address divisions between community agencies, an SOC might include the creation of a cross- agency collaborative working committee to develop a plan for outreach, education, and coordinated efforts to deliver services. To address the issue of AI invisibility within the larger political and social service system landscape, an SOC would include structures (e.g., the creation of a stakeholder network) to facilitate community mobilization and organizing in order to more effectively advocate about the needs of the community to policy makers at the city and state level. Consistent with Cook and Kilmer’s (2010a) work emphasizing the importance of an ecological approach to SOC delivery, such community building and coordination efforts would require that an SOC take an ecological perspective on mental health, one that honored
  • 52. the holistic impact of family and community factors, and allowed for the promotion of healthy systems in addition to healthy individuals. Honoring Local Definitions of Mental Health and Wellness Participants noted that a sense of belonging to community, a strong and stable connection to family and extended family, and youth’s belief that community members were supportive and involved in their lives did or could lead to helping youth and families achieve a sense of balance, healthy lifestyle practices, spiritual health, positive coping skills, and feelings of purpose and happiness. Participants discussed the need to promote wellness and prevention, to address the powerful stigma associated with mental illness, and to embrace culturally-relevant conceptualizations of mental health and wellness from a holistic worldview. To address these needs, an SOC may need to be framed more from a wellness promotion/prevention perspective,
  • 53. rather than as a method to address youth with severe dis- orders or difficulties. SOCs are traditionally focused on coordinating services for youth with severe emotional and behavioral disorders (‘‘SEBD’’). This deficit-based approach may need to be eliminated and replaced with one that promotes a strength-based approach, prevention, and a holistic wellness perspective. A focus on promoting well- ness, balance, support and strengthening of the entire family system within the community context is far more consistent with AI values of interdependence, spiritual strength, and holistic well-being than a traditional mental health model focused on identifying a ‘‘patient’’ and creating a plan for clinical services to address deficits and illness in that indi- vidual. For example, an SOC that was consistent with AI values might identify a child/family in need of services based on a constellation of risk factors and engage the family in wrap-around services and supports embedded within community and mainstream systems (e.g. school,
  • 54. community agencies). Children/families who already demonstrate emotional or behavioral difficulties could have additional clinical services added to their wrap-around plan. This shift would be consistent with what has been proposed by Kilmer et al. (2010) in order to address the disconnect between principles and practice and bring SOCs more in line with their family-centered philosophy. In addition, this approach would decrease stigma by promoting the notion that all children and families need supports and services for healthy development and by embedding most services in systems that were mainstream and familiar to families. On the whole, our data suggest that in order for an SOC to be embraced by AI youth and families, it may require a shift from the more traditional systems of deficit-based clinical care and case management services to encompass a broader range of community-based programs and practices that are empowering, health promoting, and holistic. Implementing Community-Based
  • 55. and Culturally-Relevant Clinical Services The most common service need discussed was funding for programs and services. The perception was that programs and services within community are fleeting, coming and going with different grants or individuals, but not sustain- able due to precarious funding streams and lack of con- sistent infrastructure. Participants noted barriers such as poor communication between service providers, frag- mented services that do not address multiple important contributors to mental health problems (e.g., family stress, community violence, poverty, and unemployment), stigma about mental health services, a lack of trust in providers, and the absence of quality, culturally-informed mental health services for youth. Notably, despite identifying service needs and barriers regarding clinical services, the prevailing notion among participants was that people in community, including youth, prefer to draw on community supports and indigenous relationships (peers, family, and
  • 56. community members) in times of need rather than seeking out mainstream clinical services. This finding is consistent with previous literature summarizing the lack of informal and everyday supports reported by a range of families participating in SOCs despite the importance attributed to these factors by families (Cook and Kilmer 2010b). Findings from this study indicate that a successful SOC for urban AIs would have secure funding, sufficient infra- structure, coordinated and collaborative high-quality 450 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 123 services with providers and agencies that work together, well-disseminated information about available programs and services, clinicians who were sensitive to the unique needs of this community and knowledgeable about AI culture (if not AI themselves), and components to address barriers such as lack of insurance and transportation.
  • 57. However, the tendency to rely on indigenous community supports versus the health care system to address mental health issues suggests that programs that build capacity within community, address the various stressors that chal- lenge family wellness (e.g. economic distress, unemploy- ment) and empower community members to take leadership roles in promoting health and wellness through informal support systems would be effective. Services typically incorporated into SOC wrap-around models (but not usually considered traditional mental health services), might emphasize prevention and wellness promotion components such as job preparation and financial literacy programs, violence prevention, youth mentorship programs, educa- tion/school support, parent training, and culture-based interventions (e.g. drumming, arts, Native games, story- telling, ceremony) that promote cultural identity and pride. Such an approach would require that SOCs take a family- centered preventative approach to mental health, allowing
  • 58. for services to be provided to entire families and to youth at- risk (vs. only to an ‘‘identified patient’’) and to provide funding to strengthen indigenous resources and supports. Systems and Policy Changes These findings also highlight several system/policy chan- ges specific (or at least particularly warranted) in AI communities. First, the expansion of mechanisms of reimbursement to include traditional healers would allow SOCs serving AI communities to formally incorporate traditional ceremony and spiritual practices into their array of behavioral health services, a need consistently identified by AI communities (Gone 2007). Second, the training and reimbursement of paraprofessionals to deliver services would enable capacity-building within communities so that community members knowledgeable about community and cultural issues were able to serve their own communities. The approach of using paraprofessionals has proven a successful method of service delivery in AI communities
  • 59. (Walkup et al. 2009) and also helps address the issue of a lack of trained providers in rural or remote AI communi- ties. Third, policies could be enacted that facilitate the incorporation of mental health services within existing structures and build on informal supports already available in the community, such as primary care facilities, schools, cultural/community centers, and families. This will foster a more integrated approach and help address barriers related to the serious stigma associated with seeking traditional Western mental health services in many AI communities. Fourth, the alteration of policy to further support preven- tion services as a primary focus of SOCs will support the incorporation of mechanisms to address historical trauma, institutionalized racism, and the current realities of many AI communities, including poverty and unemployment, so that these issues can be addressed before they manifest in emotional or behavioral difficulties, or diagnosable mental health problems. Finally, policies could be established that
  • 60. require those funded to plan and implement SOCs to include formal, articulated methods of ensuring that their work is consistent with an authentic community-based participatory process, empowering families and commu- nities to support and promote their own indigenous prac- tices, and helping communities to develop an evidence base to support their culturally-based methods of healing and wellness promotion (i.e. a practice-based evidence vs. evidence-based practice approach). These recommended system/policy changes are supported by our data, but also consistent with previous recommendations for systemic policy changes to behavioral health systems based on a comprehensive review of behavioral health and healthcare in AI communities nationwide (Goodkind et al. 2010). Strengths of this study include its focus on a unique and underserved population and use of an innovative qualita- tive methodology to assess community needs. However, there are limitations in that study design and data analysis
  • 61. that are worthy of note. First, this study relied on partici- pants to self-select their participation and the sample rep- resents only a fraction of the total community. Thus, the study sample may not be representative of the entire urban AI population in Chicago. In addition, though the use of focus groups stimulated discussion, relationship-building, and consensus, some participants may have been uncom- fortable discussing more sensitive topics in a group format and thus, may have limited what they shared. Finally, as with all qualitative analysis, though we used a structured coding system and data analytic software to enhance the rigor of the study, coding was completed by two commu- nity research assistants and is therefore subjective based on their perceptions of how the text fit with different codes. This bias was alleviated somewhat by the use of a com- munity research workgroup who also reviewed transcripts and completed their own process of identifying themes, which was then compared to what the original coders had
  • 62. identified. Conclusions Taken together, findings from this study indicate that an effective SOC for the AI community in Chicago would incorporate methods to strengthen community and family Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 451 123 ties, heal relationships within community, re-connect families to traditional ways, focus on prevention, empower community members to drive program development, and enhance community-based supports. These findings are consistent with community psychology theory, which emphasizes the importance of ecology, community devel- opment, diversity, context, collaboration, empowerment, prevention, and participatory action (Rappaport and Seid- man 2000) in affecting individual and social change. Also evident in these findings is the importance of promoting a
  • 63. psychological sense of community (Sarason 1974). These findings are consistent with SOC values that emphasize diverse and coordinated community-based services and supports, families as important decision-makers, and the conceptualization of the child from within an ecological perspective (Cook and Kilmer 2010a; Kilmer et al. 2010). However, it has been consistently demonstrated that there is a substantial gap between SOC philosophy and values and actual practice and that this gap may at least partially explain the mixed outcomes in SOC research (Kilmer et al. 2010). In particular, it has been noted that the family- centered care philosophy of SOC is not supported by current policy (Kilmer et al. 2010); SOC implementation does not always take into account the ecological perspec- tive, especially as related to the incorporation of preven- tion and informal supports for families (Cook and Kilmer 2010a, b); that most current behavioral health systems and policies do not support the implementation of a compre-
  • 64. hensive wrap-around model (Bruns et al. 2010); and that SOCs are not always developed and implemented using an authentic community-based participatory process (Pullman 2009). In the context of this previous research, the current study adds support to the notion that systems/policy changes need to occur in order to support the implementation of SOCs that meet the needs of diverse communities and reflect core values of SOC philosophy. Specifically, con- sistent with previous literature that has proposed specific system/policy changes in SOC delivery (Cook and Kilmer 2010a; Kilmer et al. 2010), the findings of this study sug- gest: (1) support for an ecological focus—a shift away from a sole or primary focus on clinical services for an identified patient, to address a broader range of programs and services for at-risk youth and families, (e.g., commu- nity stressors, poverty, unemployment) with funding to support prevention and the strengthening of informal sup-
  • 65. ports for families; and (2) support for a community-based, family-centered care approach—an emphasis on family- centered care and family-based decision-making supported by funding for services to parents, siblings and other family care-takers, an authentic involvement of family members in care-planning, and funding to support community development practices that support a sense of community belonging and well-being. The translation of these values, which already define SOC philosophy, into actual policy changes would support the sustainability of SOCs such as the one desired by AI community members—one that is holistic, focused on wellness and prevention, provides services to address broader community stressors, such as poverty and unemployment, and supports the entire family system. Given the resonance of these findings with both com- munity psychology theory and work on the implementation of SOC in diverse communities, it is likely that these
  • 66. system and policy recommendations have considerable relevance beyond AI communities. Indeed, they may rep- resent critical next steps for transforming behavioral health systems of care so that they meet the needs of diverse communities, fully reflect the philosophies and values by which SOCs were originally conceptualized, and promote effective and sustainable SOCs that produce consistent positive outcomes for youth and families. Acknowledgments The authors would like to acknowledge fol- lowing members of the community research workgroup that assisted with data analyses and interpretation: Bobbie Bellinger, Megan Bang, and Shannon Cobe. We would like to express our gratitude to youth, families, and elders who participated in this study and to all the community members who provided input throughout its implemen- tation. We would also like to acknowledge sponsors who provided funding to support this study: the Substance Abuse and Mental Health
  • 67. Services Administration (SAMHSA) and the Great Cities Institute at the University of Illinois at Chicago. References Beals, J., Novins, D. K., Whitesell, N. R., Spicer, P., Mitchell, C. M., Manson, S. M., et al. (2005). Prevalence of mental disorders and utilization of mental health services in two American Indian reservation populations: Mental health disparities in a national context. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 162, 1723–1732. Beals, J., Piasecki, J., Nelson, S., Jones, M., Keane, E., Dauphinais, P., et al. (1997). Psychiatric disorder among American Indian adolescents: Prevalence in northern plains youth. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36, 1252–1259. Bruns, E. J., Walker, J. S., Zabel, M., Matarese, M., Estep, K., Harburger, D., et al. (2010). Intervening in the lives of youth with complext behavioral health challenges and their families: The rold of the wraparound process. American Journal of Community Psychology, 46, 314–331.
  • 68. Center for Disease Control. (1996). YRBSS: Youth risk behavior surveillance system. Retrieved June 3, 2010, from: http:// www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/. Clark, R. L., & Witko, T. M. (2006). Growing up Indian: Treatment with urban Indian adolescents. In T. M. Witko (Ed.), Mental health care for urban Indians: Clinical insights from native practitioners (pp. 173–187). Washington, DC: American Psy- chological Association. Cook, J. R., & Kilmer, R. P. (2010a). Defining the scope of systems of care: An ecological perspective. Evaluation and Program Planning, 33, 18–20. 452 Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 123 http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/ http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/yrbs/ Cook, J. R., & Kilmer, R. P. (2010b). The importance of context in fostering responsive community systems: Supports for families in systems of care. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 80(1), 115–123.
  • 69. Costello, E. J., Farmer, E. M. Z., Angold, A., Burns, B. J., & Erkanli, A. (1997). Psychiatric disorders among American Indian and white youth in Appalachia: The Great Smoky Mountains study. American Journal of Public Health, 87, 827–832. Costello, E. J., Messer, S. C., Bird, H. R., Cohen, P., & Reinherz, H. Z. (1998). The prevalence of serious emotional disturbance: A re-analysis of community studies. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 7, 411–432. D’Andrea, M. (1994). The concerns of Native American youth. Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 22, 173–181. Evaneshko, V. (1999). Mental health needs assessment of Tucson’s urban Native American population. American Indian and Alaska Native Mental Health Research, 8, 41–61. Gone, J. P. (2007). ‘‘We never was happy living like a Whiteman’’: Mental health disparities and the postcolonial predicament in American Indian communities. American Journal of Community Psychology, 40, 290–300. Goodkind, J. R., Ross-Toledo, K., John, S., Hall, J. L., Ross, L.,
  • 70. Freeland, L., et al. (2010). Promoting healing and restoring trust: Policy recommendations for improving behavioral health care for American Indian/Alaska Native adolescents. American Journal of Community Psychology, 46, 386–394. Green, L. W., & Mercer, S. L. (2001). Can public health researchers and agencies reconcile the push from funding bodies and the pull from communities? American Journal of Public Health, 91, 1926–1929. Israel, B. A., Schulz, A. J., Parker, E. A., & Becker, A. B. (1998). Review of community-based research: Assessing partnership approaches to improve public health. Annuals of Research in Public Health, 19, 173–202. Kilmer, R. P., Cook, J. R., & Munsell, E. P. (2010). Moving from principles to practice: Recommended policy changes to promote family-centered care. American Journal of Community Psychol- ogy, 46, 332–341. Moncher, M. S., Holden, G. W., & Trimble, J. E. (1997). Substance abuse among Native-American youth. Washington, DC: Amer-
  • 71. ican Psychological Association. Poupart, J., Baker, L., & Horse, J. R. (2009). Research with American Indian communities: The value of authentic partnerships. Children and Youth Services Review, 31, 1180–1186. Pullman, M. D. (2009). Participatory research in systems of care for children’s mental health. American Journal of Community Psychology, 44, 33–53. Rappaport, J., & Seidman, E. (2000). Handbook of community psychology. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum. Rutman, S., Park, A., Castor, M., Taualii, M., & Forquera, R. (2008). Urban American Indian and Alaska native youth: Youth risk behavior survey 1997–2003. Maternal and Child Health Jour- nal, 12, S76–S81. Sarason, S. B. (1974). The psychological sense of community: Prospects for community psychology. San Francisco: Jossey- Bass. Sarche, M., & Spicer, P. (2008). Poverty and health disparities for American Indian and Alaska native children. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1136, 126–136. Stiffman, A., Striley, C., Brown, E., Limb, G., & Ostmann, E.
  • 72. (2003). American Indian youth: Who southwestern urban and reserva- tion youth turn to for help with mental health or addictions. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 12, 319–333. The Four Worlds Centre for Development Learning. (2000). The community story framework. Retrieved January 15, 2008 from http://www.fourworlds.ca/pdfs/Com_Story_Framework.pdf. Urban Indian Health Commission (UIHC). (2007). Invisible tribes: Urban Indians and their health in a changing world. Seattle, WA: Urban Indian Health Commission. Urban Indian Health Institute (UIHI). (2009). Bemidji area urban American Indian/Alaska native needs assessment. Seattle, WA: Seattle Indian Health Board. U.S. Census Bureau (2000). 2000 census. Retrieved June 3, 2010, from: http://www.census.gov/main/www/cen2000.html. U.S. Census Bureau (2008). The 2008 statistical abstract. Retrieved June 3, 2010, from http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2001). Mental health: Culture, race, and ethnicity. A supplement to mental health: A report of the surgeon general (No. SMA01–3613). Washington, DC: Office of the Surgeon General, Public Health Service, U.S. Government Printing Office.
  • 73. Walkup, J. T., Barlow, A., Mullaney, B. C., Pan, W., Goklish, N., Hasting, R., et al. (2009). Randomized controlled trial of a paraprofessional-delivered in-home for young reservation-based American Indian mothers. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 48(6), 591–601. Whitbeck, L. B., Yu, M., Johnson, K. D., Hoyt, D. R., & Walls, M. L. (2008). Diagnostic prevalence rates from early to mid-adoles- cence among indigenous adolescents: First results from a longitudinal study. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 47, 890–900. Witko, T. M. (Ed.). (2006). Mental health care for urban Indians: Clinical insights from native practitioners. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. Zvolensky, M. J., McNeil, D. W., Porter, C. A., & Stewart, S. H. (2001). Assessment of anxiety sensitivity in young American Indians and Alaska natives. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 39, 477–493. Am J Community Psychol (2012) 49:441–453 453
  • 74. 123 http://www.fourworlds.ca/pdfs/Com_Story_Framework.pdf http://www.census.gov/main/www/cen2000.html http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab Copyright of American Journal of Community Psychology is the property of Springer Science & Business Media B.V. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.