1. Startup Legal 101: Employment Law
Issues
May 31, 2011
Palo Alto, CA
Brian K. Nagatani
(bnagatani@hixsonnagatani.com)
2. Overview
When will you be covered by California’s
employment laws?
Appropriate compensation of early hires
Appropriate classification of contractors and
consultants
2
3. Employment Law Coverage
Wage and hour laws: all employers
• Minimum wage
• Overtime
• Meal and rest periods
Fair Employment & Housing Act: 5 or more
employees
• Harassment
• Discrimination
• Retaliation
3
4. Employment Law Coverage
Leaves of Absence
• FMLA/CFRA: 50 employees within 75 mile radius
• Pregnancy disability leave: 5 or more employees
• Other disability leaves: 5 or more employees
• Other forms of leave: various coverage thresholds
4
5. Wage and Hour Laws
Common Mistakes:
• Classifying employees as contractors/consultants
• Classifying all employees as exempt
• Compensating employees only with stock options
• Deferred compensation
Potential Exposure:
• Class action liability
• Four year statute of limitations
• Plaintiffs’ attorneys’ fees
5
6. Wage and Hour Laws
Recommendations:
• Regardless of employer size, ensure that employees are
appropriately classified for overtime purposes
• Observe all minimum wage, overtime, and meal and rest
period requirements for non-exempt employees
6
7. Exemption Test
2 Requirements (Must Satisfy Both)
• Salary Test
• Duties Test
7
8. “Salary” Requirement
Federal: $23,660/year
California: $33,280/year
• Must Equal or Exceed Monthly Salary for Full-Time
Employment at Two Times the California Minimum Wage
Generally No Deduction for Missing Time During
the Week (Some Exceptions)
8
10. The Executive Exemption
California “Duties” Requirements
• Primarily Engaged in Management of the
Enterprise or Recognized Department or
Subdivision
• Supervises At Least 2 Full Time Employees (or
Equivalent)
• Authority to Hire or Fire (or Strong
Recommendation Authority)
• Discretion and Independent Judgment
10
11. The Administrative Exemption
California “Duties” Requirements
• “Back-Office” Duties
o Not “Production” Work
• Discretion and Independent Judgment
o Distinction: Exercise of Skill
• Work Involves Either:
o Assisting Owner/Executive
o Highly Specialized Technical Tasks, or
o Special Projects
11
12. The Professional Exemption
Can Cover Employees Performing “Production”
Work (Unlike Administrative Exemption)
Exempt Professionals Include:
• Formally Licensed Professionals (Law,
Medicine, Dentistry, Pharmacy, Optometry,
Architecture, Engineering, Teaching, or
Accounting)
12
13. Computer Professionals:
Special Exemption
Duties Test: Same as For Computer Workers
Under the General Professional Exemption
• Excludes entry-level employees, and those who do not
primarily exercise independent judgment and discretion.
What it Adds: Exception to the Rule that Hourly-
Paid Employees Are Non-Exempt
• Minimum Pay Rate: $27.63/Hour
California Computer Professionals:
• $37.94/hour, or
• $79,050/year
• Caution: the California rate may increase each year!
13
14. Other Commonly Used Exemptions
Outside Sales
Certain Commissioned Employees
14
15. Important Classification Issues:
Employee Versus Contractor
Common Mistake: Retaining a Worker as
a “Contractor,” But Treating the Worker
More Like an Employee.
One Misclassification Results in
Simultaneous Violation of Numerous
Laws
15
16. Why It’s Important
Tax ERISA
Breach
Violation Violation
Of Contract
Unemployment
ADA ONE Violation
Violation MISCLASSIFICATION
Workers
FMLA Comp
Violation FLSA Violation
Violation
16
17. The Main Test: “Right to Control”
The worker is a contractor only if he/she
retains the “right to control the manner and
means by which the product is
accomplished” Community for Creative
Non-Violence v. Reid, 490 U.S. 730 (1989)
17
18. Key Factors
Amount of Supervision
Discretion Over When/How Long to Work
Location of Work
Right to Discharge/Quit
Duration of Relationship
• Is the Contractor a Former Employee?
o How Similar is the Work?
18
19. Key Factors
Right to Assign Additional Project
Method of Payment
Skill Required
• How Different than Skills Possessed by
Employees?
Intent of the Parties
• Is There a Signed Contractor Agreement?
19
20. Key Factors
Is Work Part of Company’s Regular
Business?
• Do Employees Perform Same Type of Work?
Does the Worker Own/Come From a
Separate Business?
• Does Worker Perform Work for More than
One Company?
20
21. Key Factors
Is Worker Subject to Risk of Profit or
Loss?
• Are the Workers’ Expenses Reimbursed?
• Who Pays for Assistance?
• Source of Instrumentalities/Tools?
What Support Does the Company Provide?
• E-mail?
• Voice Mail?
• Business Cards?
21