SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Employment Law Issues
for the Gig Economy
Silicon Valley, San Francisco, Los Angeles
rroyse@rroyselaw.com
www.rroyselaw.com
Lisa Chapman is an experienced employment attorney
and litigator. In her employment law practice she helps
startup and mid-size companies navigate and comply with
federal and state employment laws and regulations. This
includes laws related to wage and hour requirements,
sexual harassment and retaliation, worker classification
(independent contractor vs. employee status) and overtime
laws, among others.
Alan Haus focuses his practice on intellectual property
protection, licensing and commercial transactions, and
employment law. Mr. Haus represents clients ranging from
start-ups to multinational companies, including food and
other consumer products companies, and e-commerce,
software and entertainment companies. Mr. Haus has been
outside general counsel to many companies over the
course of his career and has an unusually broad range of
skills beyond his core practice areas.
Pamela Lambert is a transactional attorney practicing in
the firm’s corporate and securities group. She assists and
advises a wide variety of clients ranging from emerging
growth to mid-market companies and the venture capital
funds investing in those entities. Her practice focuses on
matters including entity formation, corporate governance,
securities compliance, private financings, M&A and
general corporate compliance.
3
OUTLINE
1. MISCLASSIFICATION: INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR VS.
EMPLOYEE
2. MANAGING RISK: WHAT ARE THE DIRECT & INDIRECT
COSTS
3. STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION
4. CHANGES IN THE LEGAL LANDSCSAPE
4
MISCLASSIFICATION: INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR
VS. EMPLOYEE
5
EMPLOYMENT STATUS: THE LAW
• The presumption is that the worker is an
Employee (Cal. Lab. Code §3357)
• Different agencies/jurisdictions have different
tests
– IRS
– DOL/FLSA
– CA Common Law and EDD
– Statutory Employees
6
EMPLOYMENT STATUS: THE LAW
• IRS: The Control Test
– Behavioral Control
– Financial Control
– Type of Relationship
• DOL/FLSA: Economic Realities Test/Silk Factors
– Focus is on the degree of control the Company has over the worker performing the service.
The key inquiry is the right to control not whether the Company actually exercises the control.
– In July 2015 DOL issued administrative guidance and explained that the test focuses on
whether the worker is economically dependent on the hiring entity or is in business for
herself/himself.
• CA Common Law/EDD: S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v Dept. of Industrial Relations (1989)
48 Cal.3d 341
– This is a multi-factored test with the most significant factor considered is whether the
principal has control or the right to control the worker as to the work done and the manner
and means in which it is performed.
• Statutory Employees
7
MANAGING RISK: WHAT ARE THE DIRECT &
INDIRECT COSTS?
8
DIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING
• Unpaid back federal, state and local income tax withholdings
• Unpaid back Social Security and Medicare contributions
• Unpaid federal and state unemployment insurance taxes
• Unpaid workers’ compensation premiums
• Unpaid back overtime compensation and/or minimum wages
– Overtime and Minimum Wage Penalties
• Unpaid work-related expenses
• Unpaid sick and vacation pay
• Waiting Time Penalties (Cal. Lab. Code §203)
• Cal. Lab. Code §226.3 (Failure to Provide Accurate Wage Statements)
– $250 per employee per violation in an initial citation; $1,000 per employee for each subsequent
violation
• SB 459 (Cal. Lab. Code §226.8 & §2753)
– Willful misclassification – Penalties range from $5,000 - $15,000 PER violation. If an entity is in
engaged in a “pattern or practice” of misclassification fines increase to $10,000 - $25,000 per
violation
– Joint and Several Liability with Employer for knowingly advising misclassification (exception for
practicing attorneys and persons advising his/her employer)
– “Willful misclassification” means “voluntarily and knowingly misclassifying that individual as an
independent contractor”. This has not yet been interpreted by a court.
9
DIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING
• Attorney Fee Shifting Statutes
– Minimum Wage/Overtime (Cal. Lab. Code §1194)
– Nonpayment of Wages/Benefits (Cal. Lab. Code §218.5)
– Enforcement of Public Interest (Cal. Lab. Code §1021.5)
– Cal. FEHA Fees (Cal. Gov’t. Code §12965(b)
• Criminal Penalties
– Failure to procure workers’ compensation insurance (Cal. Lab. Code §3700.5)
– Knowingly and Intentionally Violating Cal. Lab. Code §226 (Failure to provide wage statements)
– Potential Insurance Premium Fraud
• Intentionally underreporting payroll or misclassifying workers to avoid workers’ compensation
premiums
– Example:
• T.B. Concrete – charged with 15 felony counts of submitting false payroll reports and
misclassifying employees to avoid payroll taxes and workers’ compensation expenses. State
claimed that 111 (85% of the Company’s payroll) were underreported.
• Stop Orders and Penalty Assessments under Cal. Lab. Code §3710.1
• PAGA Claims
– Allows plaintiffs’ attorneys to bring suit on behalf of individuals as a stand-in for the attorney general
in order to seek any civil penalty that the LWDA or its departments could seek for a violation of the
Labor Code. There is a “default penalty” of $100.00 per violation.
– They must give the employer 33 days to “cure” the “violation” before bringing a PAGA claim.
10
INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING
SHORT TERM COSTS & BENEFITS
– Employers save around 30% on payroll and related taxes by utilizing
Independent Contractors
• Do not need to provide:
– Health Benefits
– Retirement Benefits
– Paid Time Off
– Employees have:
• Flexible Work Schedules
• Supplemental Income
• No Benefits
– PTO, Health or Retirement
• No Legal Protection
– No workers’ compensation or wage and hour law protection
• No Job Security
11
INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING
LONG TERM COSTS & BENEFITS
• How is this new labor market impacting Company culture?
• Potential Impact on Hiring – Who will join your Company?
• Limited to No Training of Workers Classified as Independent Contractors
–  Affects Quality Control
• Employee Loyalty
– Independent Contractors will work for competitors
– Risk of Trade Secret Theft
• Impact on Investor Funding
– Red flag in due diligence, concern with litigation risk
VS
– Focused on financial benefits; want startups to keep costs low
12
INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING
• LITIGATION COSTS
– Statute of Limitations
• Varies upon jurisdiction, generally 2-3 years
– No Waiver of Wage and Hour Law Claims in a
Release
• Many Releases include language directly asserting
that wage and hour law claims are not waived
• Can include language preventing collection of
monetary relief from wage and hour claims
– Attorney’s Fees
• Fee Shifting Statutes make litigating potentially
extremely expensive
– Liquidated Damages
13
STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION
14
STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION
• If the Company desires to utilize independent contractors:
– Re-evaluate current independent contractors to ensure status is
still applicable.
• Remember status can change over time
– Draft an independent contractor agreement that establishes real
independence
– Structure the day to day work relationships to follow the
independent contractor agreement and be sure that the daily
activities reflect actual independence
– If status of a worker or group of workers looks like a “close call” or
falls into the “legal grey area” consider classifying as an employee
(part-time, temporary, etc.)
– Consider using a Staffing Agency or Workforce management firm
• CAUTION – recent case law has held joint and several liability
for Company with staffing agency/workforce management
firm for indirect control over worker– NLRB v. Browning-Ferris
Industries of California, Inc., 362 NLRB No. 186 (Aug. 27,
2015)
15
CHANGES IN THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE
16
RECENT CASE LAW
• Uber
• There are couple of different Uber decisions. A trend that
has appeared from these cases is “the modern tendency
is to find employment when the work being done is an
integral part of the regular business of the employer,
and when the worker, relative to the employer, does not
furnish an independent business or professional
service”. The rulings have stated that because Uber’s
business would not exist without the drivers they are
integral to Uber’s business and when the worker is
integral to the business, there is a tendency to find
employment status.
• Recent $100 million settlement rejected by San
Francisco federal judge
17
RECENT CASE LAW
• Lyft
• Lawsuit settles 2013 misclassification lawsuit for $12.25
million
• Change Terms of Service to comply with California law
• No longer deactivated without warning.
• Deactivation must be for a specific reason listed in
the TOS
• Drivers must be given opportunity to fix the problem
before deactivation
• Amazon
• Filed in U.S. District Court in Washington State on
October 4, 2016
• Alleges Amazon has misclassified delivery drivers as
independent contractors when they are actually
employees, thereby violating the FLSA.
18
HYBRID WORKER CLASSIFICATION
• “Dependent Contractor”
– Receives some but not all employee protections
– Canada
• Employers are required to provide the worker with
reasonable notice upon termination - Keenan (c.o.b.
Keenan Cabinetry) v. Canac Kitchens, a Division of
Kohler Ltd (“Canac”)
• Ultimate factors are: exclusivity and economic
dependence
– 80% or more of income from a single source
– Germany
• Worker that is economically dependent on his or her
job and has been working with one entity for several
years
• 50% of income from a single source
• “Minijobs” are permitted for part-time workers
where the worker earns no more than €450 per
month and the income is tax free
19
NEW ADMINISTRATION
• Hillary Clinton
– Spoken out against employers who misclassify
independent contractors by promising to crack down on
the “bosses misclassifying workers as contractors”
– Believes the on-demand or gig economy is “creating
exciting opportunities and unleashing innovation, but is
raising hard questions about workplace protection”
• Donald Trump
– No direct statements on gig economy but has proposed a
federal tax plan that would be favorable to independent
contractors by lowering the corporate tax rate to 15%. He
includes independent contractors among the business
entities that would benefit from the reduced corporate
tax rate.
The Innovation Network supports companies focused on
creating new technologies for the ag and food industries
Royse University: Providing business, tax, technology and
personal finance ideas to founders and executives.
Royse Law Presents: Supporting the Tech and legal
community through events, networking, and webinars
Royse Law Incorporator: Incorporate your company the
Silicon Valley way.
RoyseLawIncorporator.com
RoyseUniversity.com
RoyseAgTech.com
RoyseLawPresents.com
21
ROYSE LAW FIRM, PC
Contact Us
PALO ALTO
1717 Embarcadero Road
Palo Alto, CA 94303
LOS ANGELES
11150 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 1200
Los Angeles, CA 90025
SAN FRANCISCO
135 Main Street
12th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
Palo Alto Office: 650-813-9700
CONTACT US
www.rroyselaw.co
m
SILICON VALLEY
149 Commonwealth Drive,
Suite 1001
Menlo Park, CA 94025
LOS ANGELES
445 S Figueroa St
31st Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071
SAN FRANCISCO
135 Main Street
12th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
Silicon Valley Office: 650-813-9700
CONTACT US
www.rroyselaw.com
@RoyseLaw

More Related Content

What's hot

Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices ActForeign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
jaikaran550
 
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical IndustryThe Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
dominiclai
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices ActForeign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Gray International
 

What's hot (20)

Top tax issues for startup companies (10 3-16 revision)
Top tax issues for startup companies (10 3-16 revision)Top tax issues for startup companies (10 3-16 revision)
Top tax issues for startup companies (10 3-16 revision)
 
Fcpa anti corruption due diligence - (pwc)
Fcpa anti corruption due diligence - (pwc)Fcpa anti corruption due diligence - (pwc)
Fcpa anti corruption due diligence - (pwc)
 
Business Law Training | State and Local Taxes: Key Developments That Will Aff...
Business Law Training | State and Local Taxes: Key Developments That Will Aff...Business Law Training | State and Local Taxes: Key Developments That Will Aff...
Business Law Training | State and Local Taxes: Key Developments That Will Aff...
 
International Foreign Investment in US Real Estate
International Foreign Investment in US Real EstateInternational Foreign Investment in US Real Estate
International Foreign Investment in US Real Estate
 
Employment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
Employment Law Issues for the Gig EconomyEmployment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
Employment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
 
FCPA Ppt
FCPA PptFCPA Ppt
FCPA Ppt
 
FCPA Overview.pptx
FCPA Overview.pptxFCPA Overview.pptx
FCPA Overview.pptx
 
Fcpa bullet points
Fcpa bullet pointsFcpa bullet points
Fcpa bullet points
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Compliance (Series: Corporate & Regulatory Comp...
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Compliance (Series: Corporate & Regulatory Comp...Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Compliance (Series: Corporate & Regulatory Comp...
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Compliance (Series: Corporate & Regulatory Comp...
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices ActForeign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices
Foreign Corrupt PracticesForeign Corrupt Practices
Foreign Corrupt Practices
 
Accounting for Different Business Entities
Accounting for Different Business EntitiesAccounting for Different Business Entities
Accounting for Different Business Entities
 
FCPA Compliance for Sales Representatives
FCPA Compliance for Sales RepresentativesFCPA Compliance for Sales Representatives
FCPA Compliance for Sales Representatives
 
Corporate Compliance Overview
Corporate Compliance OverviewCorporate Compliance Overview
Corporate Compliance Overview
 
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical IndustryThe Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Pharmaceutical Industry
 
Managing International Risks + Corporate Investigations
Managing International Risks + Corporate InvestigationsManaging International Risks + Corporate Investigations
Managing International Risks + Corporate Investigations
 
Risk Containment: Tailoring Contract Provisions with Third Parties to Minimiz...
Risk Containment: Tailoring Contract Provisions with Third Parties to Minimiz...Risk Containment: Tailoring Contract Provisions with Third Parties to Minimiz...
Risk Containment: Tailoring Contract Provisions with Third Parties to Minimiz...
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices ActForeign Corrupt Practices Act
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
 
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) Compliance Webinar
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) Compliance WebinarForeign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) Compliance Webinar
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) Compliance Webinar
 
FCPA Overview
FCPA OverviewFCPA Overview
FCPA Overview
 

Viewers also liked

WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership DevelopmentWILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
Genevieve Whitaker
 

Viewers also liked (18)

Royse Law Firm, PC - Trade Secret Missteps and Surprises
Royse Law Firm, PC - Trade Secret Missteps and SurprisesRoyse Law Firm, PC - Trade Secret Missteps and Surprises
Royse Law Firm, PC - Trade Secret Missteps and Surprises
 
July 24 Top Ten Legal Mistakes Startups Make
July 24 Top Ten Legal Mistakes Startups MakeJuly 24 Top Ten Legal Mistakes Startups Make
July 24 Top Ten Legal Mistakes Startups Make
 
Royse Law Firm to present “Public Relations Services Agreements” at the 2013 ...
Royse Law Firm to present “Public Relations Services Agreements” at the 2013 ...Royse Law Firm to present “Public Relations Services Agreements” at the 2013 ...
Royse Law Firm to present “Public Relations Services Agreements” at the 2013 ...
 
Current Developments in AgTech Law
Current Developments in AgTech LawCurrent Developments in AgTech Law
Current Developments in AgTech Law
 
IRS Administration of Social Welfare Policy
IRS Administration of Social Welfare Policy IRS Administration of Social Welfare Policy
IRS Administration of Social Welfare Policy
 
Incorporating the Venture Backed LLC
Incorporating the Venture Backed LLCIncorporating the Venture Backed LLC
Incorporating the Venture Backed LLC
 
Mergers & Acquisitions: What VC Investors Should Know
Mergers & Acquisitions: What VC Investors Should KnowMergers & Acquisitions: What VC Investors Should Know
Mergers & Acquisitions: What VC Investors Should Know
 
PAABA Business Law Section NDA Misssteps and Surprises
PAABA Business Law Section NDA Misssteps and SurprisesPAABA Business Law Section NDA Misssteps and Surprises
PAABA Business Law Section NDA Misssteps and Surprises
 
Current Tax Reform Proposals (2017)
Current Tax Reform Proposals (2017)Current Tax Reform Proposals (2017)
Current Tax Reform Proposals (2017)
 
What Licensing Lawyers Should Know About Litigation
What Licensing Lawyers Should Know About LitigationWhat Licensing Lawyers Should Know About Litigation
What Licensing Lawyers Should Know About Litigation
 
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigationHow to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
How to handle a federal tax dispute. audit, appeal and litigation
 
FCDA0915_P
FCDA0915_PFCDA0915_P
FCDA0915_P
 
"Pursue Your Obsolescence": 2005 Commencement Address to Golden Gate Universi...
"Pursue Your Obsolescence": 2005 Commencement Address to Golden Gate Universi..."Pursue Your Obsolescence": 2005 Commencement Address to Golden Gate Universi...
"Pursue Your Obsolescence": 2005 Commencement Address to Golden Gate Universi...
 
WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership DevelopmentWILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
WILD_Women\'s Institute for Leadership Development
 
Social Networking In The Workplace Public Version
Social Networking In The Workplace Public VersionSocial Networking In The Workplace Public Version
Social Networking In The Workplace Public Version
 
San Francisco Labor Landmark Photography
San Francisco Labor Landmark PhotographySan Francisco Labor Landmark Photography
San Francisco Labor Landmark Photography
 
FV@W 2014 Program Book
FV@W 2014 Program BookFV@W 2014 Program Book
FV@W 2014 Program Book
 
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February AgendaSouthwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
 

Similar to Emploment law issues for the gig economy

Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
Jonathan Hyman
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Frank C. Cardenas
 
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
Palmer Kazanjian Wohl Hodson LLP
 
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig ToolkitKdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
Kathy Dotson
 

Similar to Emploment law issues for the gig economy (20)

A Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
A Sea Change in Wage and Hour LawA Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
A Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
 
Tax Issues in App Development
Tax Issues in App DevelopmentTax Issues in App Development
Tax Issues in App Development
 
Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
Top 5 issues employment law breakfast (k0227996 2)
 
FULL SLIDES 2016: The Current & Future State of Independent Contractor Compli...
FULL SLIDES 2016: The Current & Future State of Independent Contractor Compli...FULL SLIDES 2016: The Current & Future State of Independent Contractor Compli...
FULL SLIDES 2016: The Current & Future State of Independent Contractor Compli...
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
 
Minimizing Risk within Your Organization by Auditing Your Employment Policies
Minimizing Risk within Your Organization by Auditing Your Employment PoliciesMinimizing Risk within Your Organization by Auditing Your Employment Policies
Minimizing Risk within Your Organization by Auditing Your Employment Policies
 
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
 
Independent Contractors: Overcoming the Legal Perils and Challenges
Independent Contractors: Overcoming the Legal Perils and ChallengesIndependent Contractors: Overcoming the Legal Perils and Challenges
Independent Contractors: Overcoming the Legal Perils and Challenges
 
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
Avoiding Liability: Legal Dilemmas Presented by Engaging Independent Contract...
 
GC Summit Presentation
GC Summit PresentationGC Summit Presentation
GC Summit Presentation
 
Outside Agents - The Biggest Threat to Your Operation
Outside Agents - The Biggest Threat to Your OperationOutside Agents - The Biggest Threat to Your Operation
Outside Agents - The Biggest Threat to Your Operation
 
Common Wage & Hour Issues in Benefits
Common Wage & Hour Issues in BenefitsCommon Wage & Hour Issues in Benefits
Common Wage & Hour Issues in Benefits
 
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
 
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary WorkersWhite Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
White Paper: Complying With Regulations Regarding Temporary Workers
 
Employment Law Newsletter
Employment Law NewsletterEmployment Law Newsletter
Employment Law Newsletter
 
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
 
Welcome to the Team! Recruiting and Hiring, Including Restrictive Covenants (...
Welcome to the Team! Recruiting and Hiring, Including Restrictive Covenants (...Welcome to the Team! Recruiting and Hiring, Including Restrictive Covenants (...
Welcome to the Team! Recruiting and Hiring, Including Restrictive Covenants (...
 
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig ToolkitKdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
Kdragonfly's Compliant Gig Toolkit
 
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
 
Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors
Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as ContractorsTax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors
Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors
 

More from Roger Royse

More from Roger Royse (20)

Startup Law ACBA.pptx
Startup Law ACBA.pptxStartup Law ACBA.pptx
Startup Law ACBA.pptx
 
Startup Legal Imperatives - Royse.pptx
Startup Legal Imperatives - Royse.pptxStartup Legal Imperatives - Royse.pptx
Startup Legal Imperatives - Royse.pptx
 
2020-02-11 Tax Issues for Startups final.ppt
2020-02-11 Tax Issues for Startups final.ppt2020-02-11 Tax Issues for Startups final.ppt
2020-02-11 Tax Issues for Startups final.ppt
 
Funding 101 02022022.pptx
Funding 101 02022022.pptxFunding 101 02022022.pptx
Funding 101 02022022.pptx
 
Royse - Tax Planning for Technology Transactions.pptx
Royse - Tax Planning for Technology Transactions.pptxRoyse - Tax Planning for Technology Transactions.pptx
Royse - Tax Planning for Technology Transactions.pptx
 
Idea to ipo funding 101 royse - august 11 2020
Idea to ipo funding 101   royse - august 11 2020Idea to ipo funding 101   royse - august 11 2020
Idea to ipo funding 101 royse - august 11 2020
 
Idea to ipo venture capital startup royse - may 10 2020
Idea to ipo venture capital startup   royse - may 10 2020Idea to ipo venture capital startup   royse - may 10 2020
Idea to ipo venture capital startup royse - may 10 2020
 
Legal overview star camp royse - may 2020 4839-7571-5260-1
Legal overview star camp   royse - may 2020 4839-7571-5260-1Legal overview star camp   royse - may 2020 4839-7571-5260-1
Legal overview star camp royse - may 2020 4839-7571-5260-1
 
M&A Tax for 2019
M&A Tax for 2019M&A Tax for 2019
M&A Tax for 2019
 
199 a deduction (00186520xc0cb4)
199 a deduction (00186520xc0cb4)199 a deduction (00186520xc0cb4)
199 a deduction (00186520xc0cb4)
 
Crowdfunding crypto - ic os march 12 2018
Crowdfunding   crypto - ic os march 12 2018Crowdfunding   crypto - ic os march 12 2018
Crowdfunding crypto - ic os march 12 2018
 
Federal Tax reform in 2017: Trump, Ryan and Hatch
Federal Tax reform in 2017: Trump, Ryan and HatchFederal Tax reform in 2017: Trump, Ryan and Hatch
Federal Tax reform in 2017: Trump, Ryan and Hatch
 
Top 10 Legal Mistakes Startups & Entrepreneurs Make
Top 10 Legal Mistakes Startups & Entrepreneurs MakeTop 10 Legal Mistakes Startups & Entrepreneurs Make
Top 10 Legal Mistakes Startups & Entrepreneurs Make
 
SAFEs and LLCs issue re: Contingent Allocations
SAFEs and LLCs issue re: Contingent AllocationsSAFEs and LLCs issue re: Contingent Allocations
SAFEs and LLCs issue re: Contingent Allocations
 
The Future of Farming: Ag Subcommittee Testimony
The Future of Farming: Ag Subcommittee TestimonyThe Future of Farming: Ag Subcommittee Testimony
The Future of Farming: Ag Subcommittee Testimony
 
The Future of Farming: Technological Innovations, Opportunities, and Challeng...
The Future of Farming: Technological Innovations, Opportunities, and Challeng...The Future of Farming: Technological Innovations, Opportunities, and Challeng...
The Future of Farming: Technological Innovations, Opportunities, and Challeng...
 
Code Sec.304 Related Party Stock Sales
Code Sec.304 Related Party Stock SalesCode Sec.304 Related Party Stock Sales
Code Sec.304 Related Party Stock Sales
 
IC-DISC for the Agriculture Industry
IC-DISC for the Agriculture Industry IC-DISC for the Agriculture Industry
IC-DISC for the Agriculture Industry
 
Tax Issues for the New Economy
Tax Issues for the New EconomyTax Issues for the New Economy
Tax Issues for the New Economy
 
Tax Issues for Startup Company
Tax Issues for Startup CompanyTax Issues for Startup Company
Tax Issues for Startup Company
 

Recently uploaded

Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis TestCrime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
AJAYPRATAPSINGHTOMAR2
 
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptxTermination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
BrV
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of DisclaimersBad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
Bad Spaniel's Consumer Survey on the Use of Disclaimers
 
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
Dabholkar-matter-Judgement-1.pdfrefp;sdPp;
 
File Taxes Online Simple Steps for Efficient Filing.pdf
File Taxes Online Simple Steps for Efficient Filing.pdfFile Taxes Online Simple Steps for Efficient Filing.pdf
File Taxes Online Simple Steps for Efficient Filing.pdf
 
Does Apple Neurotechnology Patents Go To Far?
Does Apple  Neurotechnology Patents Go To Far?Does Apple  Neurotechnology Patents Go To Far?
Does Apple Neurotechnology Patents Go To Far?
 
How to Protect Your Children During a Divorce?
How to Protect Your Children During a Divorce?How to Protect Your Children During a Divorce?
How to Protect Your Children During a Divorce?
 
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[kAsif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
Asif_Sultan_Syeda_vs_UT_of_J_K.pdf op[ke[k
 
Sedition Offences against Property 20-5-2024.pptx
Sedition  Offences against Property 20-5-2024.pptxSedition  Offences against Property 20-5-2024.pptx
Sedition Offences against Property 20-5-2024.pptx
 
Mergers and Acquisitions in Kenya - An explanation
Mergers and Acquisitions in Kenya - An explanationMergers and Acquisitions in Kenya - An explanation
Mergers and Acquisitions in Kenya - An explanation
 
Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis TestCrime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
Crime Detection/Prevention and Narco-Analysis Test
 
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
From Scratch to Strong: Introduction to Drafting of Criminal Cases and Applic...
 
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptxTermination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
Termination of Employees under the Labor Code.pptx
 
Rights of Consumers under Consumer Protection Act, 1986.
Rights of Consumers under Consumer Protection Act, 1986.Rights of Consumers under Consumer Protection Act, 1986.
Rights of Consumers under Consumer Protection Act, 1986.
 
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
Skill Development in Law, Para Legal & other Fields and Export of Trained Man...
 
Essential Components of an Effective HIPAA Safeguard Program
Essential Components of an Effective HIPAA Safeguard ProgramEssential Components of an Effective HIPAA Safeguard Program
Essential Components of an Effective HIPAA Safeguard Program
 
REVIVING OUR STAR GOD IMAGES FROM MARRYING OUR 4 HOLY LAWS OF STAR GODS
REVIVING OUR STAR GOD IMAGES FROM MARRYING OUR 4 HOLY LAWS OF STAR GODSREVIVING OUR STAR GOD IMAGES FROM MARRYING OUR 4 HOLY LAWS OF STAR GODS
REVIVING OUR STAR GOD IMAGES FROM MARRYING OUR 4 HOLY LAWS OF STAR GODS
 
Comprehensive Guide on Drafting Directors' Report and its ROC Compliances und...
Comprehensive Guide on Drafting Directors' Report and its ROC Compliances und...Comprehensive Guide on Drafting Directors' Report and its ROC Compliances und...
Comprehensive Guide on Drafting Directors' Report and its ROC Compliances und...
 
Dandan Liu is the worst real estate agent on earth..pdf
Dandan Liu is the worst real estate agent on earth..pdfDandan Liu is the worst real estate agent on earth..pdf
Dandan Liu is the worst real estate agent on earth..pdf
 
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx PresentationTTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
TTD - PPT on social stock exchange.pptx Presentation
 
How Can an Attorney Help With My Car Accident Claim?
How Can an Attorney Help With My Car Accident Claim?How Can an Attorney Help With My Car Accident Claim?
How Can an Attorney Help With My Car Accident Claim?
 
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdklEmbed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
Embed-3-2.pdfkp[k[odk[odk[d[ok[d[pkdkdkl
 

Emploment law issues for the gig economy

  • 1. Employment Law Issues for the Gig Economy Silicon Valley, San Francisco, Los Angeles rroyse@rroyselaw.com www.rroyselaw.com
  • 2. Lisa Chapman is an experienced employment attorney and litigator. In her employment law practice she helps startup and mid-size companies navigate and comply with federal and state employment laws and regulations. This includes laws related to wage and hour requirements, sexual harassment and retaliation, worker classification (independent contractor vs. employee status) and overtime laws, among others. Alan Haus focuses his practice on intellectual property protection, licensing and commercial transactions, and employment law. Mr. Haus represents clients ranging from start-ups to multinational companies, including food and other consumer products companies, and e-commerce, software and entertainment companies. Mr. Haus has been outside general counsel to many companies over the course of his career and has an unusually broad range of skills beyond his core practice areas. Pamela Lambert is a transactional attorney practicing in the firm’s corporate and securities group. She assists and advises a wide variety of clients ranging from emerging growth to mid-market companies and the venture capital funds investing in those entities. Her practice focuses on matters including entity formation, corporate governance, securities compliance, private financings, M&A and general corporate compliance.
  • 3. 3 OUTLINE 1. MISCLASSIFICATION: INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR VS. EMPLOYEE 2. MANAGING RISK: WHAT ARE THE DIRECT & INDIRECT COSTS 3. STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION 4. CHANGES IN THE LEGAL LANDSCSAPE
  • 5. 5 EMPLOYMENT STATUS: THE LAW • The presumption is that the worker is an Employee (Cal. Lab. Code §3357) • Different agencies/jurisdictions have different tests – IRS – DOL/FLSA – CA Common Law and EDD – Statutory Employees
  • 6. 6 EMPLOYMENT STATUS: THE LAW • IRS: The Control Test – Behavioral Control – Financial Control – Type of Relationship • DOL/FLSA: Economic Realities Test/Silk Factors – Focus is on the degree of control the Company has over the worker performing the service. The key inquiry is the right to control not whether the Company actually exercises the control. – In July 2015 DOL issued administrative guidance and explained that the test focuses on whether the worker is economically dependent on the hiring entity or is in business for herself/himself. • CA Common Law/EDD: S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v Dept. of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341 – This is a multi-factored test with the most significant factor considered is whether the principal has control or the right to control the worker as to the work done and the manner and means in which it is performed. • Statutory Employees
  • 7. 7 MANAGING RISK: WHAT ARE THE DIRECT & INDIRECT COSTS?
  • 8. 8 DIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING • Unpaid back federal, state and local income tax withholdings • Unpaid back Social Security and Medicare contributions • Unpaid federal and state unemployment insurance taxes • Unpaid workers’ compensation premiums • Unpaid back overtime compensation and/or minimum wages – Overtime and Minimum Wage Penalties • Unpaid work-related expenses • Unpaid sick and vacation pay • Waiting Time Penalties (Cal. Lab. Code §203) • Cal. Lab. Code §226.3 (Failure to Provide Accurate Wage Statements) – $250 per employee per violation in an initial citation; $1,000 per employee for each subsequent violation • SB 459 (Cal. Lab. Code §226.8 & §2753) – Willful misclassification – Penalties range from $5,000 - $15,000 PER violation. If an entity is in engaged in a “pattern or practice” of misclassification fines increase to $10,000 - $25,000 per violation – Joint and Several Liability with Employer for knowingly advising misclassification (exception for practicing attorneys and persons advising his/her employer) – “Willful misclassification” means “voluntarily and knowingly misclassifying that individual as an independent contractor”. This has not yet been interpreted by a court.
  • 9. 9 DIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING • Attorney Fee Shifting Statutes – Minimum Wage/Overtime (Cal. Lab. Code §1194) – Nonpayment of Wages/Benefits (Cal. Lab. Code §218.5) – Enforcement of Public Interest (Cal. Lab. Code §1021.5) – Cal. FEHA Fees (Cal. Gov’t. Code §12965(b) • Criminal Penalties – Failure to procure workers’ compensation insurance (Cal. Lab. Code §3700.5) – Knowingly and Intentionally Violating Cal. Lab. Code §226 (Failure to provide wage statements) – Potential Insurance Premium Fraud • Intentionally underreporting payroll or misclassifying workers to avoid workers’ compensation premiums – Example: • T.B. Concrete – charged with 15 felony counts of submitting false payroll reports and misclassifying employees to avoid payroll taxes and workers’ compensation expenses. State claimed that 111 (85% of the Company’s payroll) were underreported. • Stop Orders and Penalty Assessments under Cal. Lab. Code §3710.1 • PAGA Claims – Allows plaintiffs’ attorneys to bring suit on behalf of individuals as a stand-in for the attorney general in order to seek any civil penalty that the LWDA or its departments could seek for a violation of the Labor Code. There is a “default penalty” of $100.00 per violation. – They must give the employer 33 days to “cure” the “violation” before bringing a PAGA claim.
  • 10. 10 INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING SHORT TERM COSTS & BENEFITS – Employers save around 30% on payroll and related taxes by utilizing Independent Contractors • Do not need to provide: – Health Benefits – Retirement Benefits – Paid Time Off – Employees have: • Flexible Work Schedules • Supplemental Income • No Benefits – PTO, Health or Retirement • No Legal Protection – No workers’ compensation or wage and hour law protection • No Job Security
  • 11. 11 INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING LONG TERM COSTS & BENEFITS • How is this new labor market impacting Company culture? • Potential Impact on Hiring – Who will join your Company? • Limited to No Training of Workers Classified as Independent Contractors –  Affects Quality Control • Employee Loyalty – Independent Contractors will work for competitors – Risk of Trade Secret Theft • Impact on Investor Funding – Red flag in due diligence, concern with litigation risk VS – Focused on financial benefits; want startups to keep costs low
  • 12. 12 INDIRECT COSTS OF MISCLASSIFICATION FINDING • LITIGATION COSTS – Statute of Limitations • Varies upon jurisdiction, generally 2-3 years – No Waiver of Wage and Hour Law Claims in a Release • Many Releases include language directly asserting that wage and hour law claims are not waived • Can include language preventing collection of monetary relief from wage and hour claims – Attorney’s Fees • Fee Shifting Statutes make litigating potentially extremely expensive – Liquidated Damages
  • 13. 13 STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION
  • 14. 14 STRATEGIES FOR AVOIDING MISCLASSIFICATION • If the Company desires to utilize independent contractors: – Re-evaluate current independent contractors to ensure status is still applicable. • Remember status can change over time – Draft an independent contractor agreement that establishes real independence – Structure the day to day work relationships to follow the independent contractor agreement and be sure that the daily activities reflect actual independence – If status of a worker or group of workers looks like a “close call” or falls into the “legal grey area” consider classifying as an employee (part-time, temporary, etc.) – Consider using a Staffing Agency or Workforce management firm • CAUTION – recent case law has held joint and several liability for Company with staffing agency/workforce management firm for indirect control over worker– NLRB v. Browning-Ferris Industries of California, Inc., 362 NLRB No. 186 (Aug. 27, 2015)
  • 15. 15 CHANGES IN THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE
  • 16. 16 RECENT CASE LAW • Uber • There are couple of different Uber decisions. A trend that has appeared from these cases is “the modern tendency is to find employment when the work being done is an integral part of the regular business of the employer, and when the worker, relative to the employer, does not furnish an independent business or professional service”. The rulings have stated that because Uber’s business would not exist without the drivers they are integral to Uber’s business and when the worker is integral to the business, there is a tendency to find employment status. • Recent $100 million settlement rejected by San Francisco federal judge
  • 17. 17 RECENT CASE LAW • Lyft • Lawsuit settles 2013 misclassification lawsuit for $12.25 million • Change Terms of Service to comply with California law • No longer deactivated without warning. • Deactivation must be for a specific reason listed in the TOS • Drivers must be given opportunity to fix the problem before deactivation • Amazon • Filed in U.S. District Court in Washington State on October 4, 2016 • Alleges Amazon has misclassified delivery drivers as independent contractors when they are actually employees, thereby violating the FLSA.
  • 18. 18 HYBRID WORKER CLASSIFICATION • “Dependent Contractor” – Receives some but not all employee protections – Canada • Employers are required to provide the worker with reasonable notice upon termination - Keenan (c.o.b. Keenan Cabinetry) v. Canac Kitchens, a Division of Kohler Ltd (“Canac”) • Ultimate factors are: exclusivity and economic dependence – 80% or more of income from a single source – Germany • Worker that is economically dependent on his or her job and has been working with one entity for several years • 50% of income from a single source • “Minijobs” are permitted for part-time workers where the worker earns no more than €450 per month and the income is tax free
  • 19. 19 NEW ADMINISTRATION • Hillary Clinton – Spoken out against employers who misclassify independent contractors by promising to crack down on the “bosses misclassifying workers as contractors” – Believes the on-demand or gig economy is “creating exciting opportunities and unleashing innovation, but is raising hard questions about workplace protection” • Donald Trump – No direct statements on gig economy but has proposed a federal tax plan that would be favorable to independent contractors by lowering the corporate tax rate to 15%. He includes independent contractors among the business entities that would benefit from the reduced corporate tax rate.
  • 20. The Innovation Network supports companies focused on creating new technologies for the ag and food industries Royse University: Providing business, tax, technology and personal finance ideas to founders and executives. Royse Law Presents: Supporting the Tech and legal community through events, networking, and webinars Royse Law Incorporator: Incorporate your company the Silicon Valley way. RoyseLawIncorporator.com RoyseUniversity.com RoyseAgTech.com RoyseLawPresents.com
  • 21. 21 ROYSE LAW FIRM, PC Contact Us PALO ALTO 1717 Embarcadero Road Palo Alto, CA 94303 LOS ANGELES 11150 Santa Monica Blvd. Suite 1200 Los Angeles, CA 90025 SAN FRANCISCO 135 Main Street 12th Floor San Francisco, CA 94105 Palo Alto Office: 650-813-9700 CONTACT US www.rroyselaw.co m SILICON VALLEY 149 Commonwealth Drive, Suite 1001 Menlo Park, CA 94025 LOS ANGELES 445 S Figueroa St 31st Floor Los Angeles, CA 90071 SAN FRANCISCO 135 Main Street 12th Floor San Francisco, CA 94105 Silicon Valley Office: 650-813-9700 CONTACT US www.rroyselaw.com @RoyseLaw