Summerschool Design our future with data https://www.kennislabvoorurbanisme.nl/project/summerschool-aug-2019/

1. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
ENERGY TRANSITION
Image source: Antea Group

2. Image source: Antea Group, Trouw

3. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!
Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
LUNCH!!!!!
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!

4. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones

5. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Participation
imbalance

6. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Participation
imbalance
Inquality between
goals and livability

7. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Inquality between
goals and livability
Participation
imbalance
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness

8. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Data as a cold
measurement
Participation
imbalance
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement

9. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Inquality between
goals and livability
Participation
imbalance
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as a
service, not an
indicator

10. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
The political
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Participation
imbalance
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as a
service, not an
indicator
Societal
responsebillity

11. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Unbalance of
participationUnbalance of
participation
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as a
service, not an
indicator
Societal
responsebillity
“We are the floor drain. Greed is blinding”
Jan Nieboer, Activist
Image source: Antea Group, Trouw

12. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
“The minister is just barging right through us”
Renee Smit, Citizen
Image source: Antea Group, Trouw
Participation
imbalance
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as a
service, not an
indicator
Societal
responsebillity

13. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Societal
responsebillity
“Due to wind energy my company has
a future again”
Harbert ten Have, Farmer
Image source: Antea Group, Trouw
Participation
imbalance
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as a
service, not an
indicator

14. Real estate as a
driving mechanism
in inducing spatial
quality
struggle between
private and public
We all want happy
people but at
what cost?
Ethics:
WHO HAS
THE RIGHT
TO THE CITY?
Involve citizes!Lies gave a good
insight into the
financial and
societal aspects of
(city) development
- and the balance
of the city
Measuring
“happiness”as
apposed to the
direct query or
quality of life
The wicked problem
of“happiness”
How do we measure
it? And who do we
want to make happy?
Challenges
and qualities of
the PoZH
Aron had a
good talk about
leefbaarheids-
report and it’s
LIMITATIONS
the underlying
data
Placemaking in a
time of being
everywhere.
Being present is
a place to protect!
Smart city
-
Service Orientated
Smart -city as
a connected
network
Design the regiontrough networks(and facilities)
Be carefull
how you
interpret data.
One can perceive
it in a different
way!
Making something
10x better instead
of 10% better!
Different expertise
bring different
perspectives on
data and the use
of it.
Digital twins:
Develop ONE
system not
parrallel ones
Inbalance of
participation
Inquality between
goals and livability
The pursuit
of happiness
Data as a cold
measurement
Data as an
service instead of a
indicator
Responsibility
towards society
“Is there no other solution than leaning back
and waiting? ”
Hans Mentink, Farmer
Image source: Antea Group, Trouw

15. How can we measure the impact of
sustainable energy goals
on citizen happiness?
Image source: Antea Group

16. Happiness Wind energy
Image source: Noun Project

17. Happiness Wind energy
Quality of life Livability of space
Image source: Noun Project

18. Happiness Wind energy
Quality of life Livability of space
Human environment
Image source: Noun Project

19. Image source: staatvan.zuid-holland.nl

20. Image source: Noun Project

21. Image source: Noun Project

22. Image source: Noun Project

23. Image source: Noun Project

24. Image source: Noun Project

25. Image source: Noun Project

26. 1. Average price decrease of 1.4-2.6%
2. Addition of turbines has minimal effect
3. Beyond 2km the effect dissipates statistically
4. Price drops happen already after
announcement, not just placement.
Source: Tinbergen Institute

27. Step 3. The proposed turbines
Esri NederlandProvincie Zuid-Holland

28. 640 million

29. Do’s and don’ts
- Do expand existing parks
- Do use smaller turbines (if possible)
- Don’t sprawl wind parks

30. ?

31. 1- Place identity and intangible characteristics of the site and surroundings are present in a public space
2- Encourage the use of the place by people of different age groups
3- Presence of sport activities
4- Feeling of freedom -> participatie, overruling
5- Balance between nature, landscape and equipment
6- Presence of water
7- Presence of art, because it causes emotions favouring a condition of happiness
8- The presence of sculptures, gamers or ether elements which promotes a state of happiness
9- Natural lighting during day and artificial light at other moments
10- State of cleanliness and maintenance must be maintained.
11- Sense of security and safety to those who are in "public space"
12- Noise by public transport is minimized or absent.
13- Possibility of perceiving naturally occuring smells
14- Direct contact with natural materials -
15- The possibility of doing actions in public space
16- The feeling of being able to contribute to the life of that place. This increases the sense of belonging
17- The possibility to make a space a bit of their own
18- Educational function in a place
19- Using space in different seasons and under varied weather conditions improves liveability and willingness to contribute
20- The possibility of using new technology to increase knowledge about a place. Source: Wittpress.com

32. 1- Place identity and intangible characteristics of the site and surroundings are present in a public space
2- Encourage the use of the place by people of different age groups
3- Presence of sport activities
4- Feeling of freedom ->
5- Balance between nature, landscape and equipment
6- Presence of water
7- Presence of art, because it causes emotions favouring a condition of happiness
8- The presence of sculptures, gamers or ether elements which promotes a state of happiness
9- Natural lighting during day and artificial light at other moments
10- State of cleanliness and maintenance must be maintained.
11- Sense of security and safety to those who are in "public space"
12- Noise by public transport is minimized or absent.
13- Possibility of perceiving naturally occuring smells
14- Direct contact with natural materials -
15- The possibility of doing actions in public space
16- The feeling of being able to contribute to the life of that place. This increases the sense of belonging
17- The possibility to make a space a bit of their own
18- Educational function in a place
19- Using space in different seasons and under varied weather conditions improves liveability and willingness to contribute
20- The possibility of using new technology to increase knowledge about a place. Source: Wittpress.com
1- Place identity and intangible characteristics of the site and surroundings are present in a public space
4- Feeling of freedom
5- Balance between nature, landscape and equipment
9- Natural lighting during day and artificial light at other moments
16- The feeling of being able to contribute to the life of that place. This increases the sense of belonging
17- The possibility to make a space a bit of their own

33. Source: Wittpress.com
1- Place identity and intangible characteristics of the site and surroundings are present in a public space
4- Feeling of freedom
5- Balance between nature, landscape and equipment
9- Natural lighting during day and artificial light at other moments
16- The feeling of being able to contribute to the life of that place. This increases the sense of belonging
17- The possibility to make a space a bit of their own
AUTONOMY

36. Participatie