1. 1
1
Clean Sky Projects on the More
Electric Aircraft
Giuseppe Pagnano
Coordinating Project Officer / CTO
MORE ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT Conference
Hamburg, 3-5 December 2014
2. Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
1. Background
2. Clean Sky organization; ITDs
3. Discussion:
1) Importance of MOA technologies for next generation A/C
2) Main achievements in Clean Sky:
a) Eco Design
b) Systems for Green Operations
c) Green Regional Aircraft
d) Green Rotorcraft
e) Electrical test rigs
4. Project evolution in H2020 / Clean Sky 2
5. Concluding remarks
Summary
3. 1. Background: The ACARE SRA Goals for 2020
October 2002 SRA-1
June 2000: Vision 2020
February 2008
Take-Off
October 2004 SRA-2
NOX emissions
reduced by 80%
Noise reduced
by 50%
CO2 emissions
reduced by 50%
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
4. Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Reaching the ACARE Goals
50%CO2
80% NOx
50% noise
Green
design..
5. 5
5
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
2 - Clean Sky Integrated Technology Demonstrators
(ITD)
EUROCONTROL
EASA
Smart Fixed Wing Aircraft
Airbus (F, D, UK, E)
SAAB (SE)
Green Regional Aircraft
Alenia Aeronautica (I)
EADS CASA (E)
Green Rotorcraft
AgustaWestland (I, UK)
Eurocopter (F, D)
Sustainable and Green Engines
Rolls-Royce (UK, D)
Safran (F)
Systems for Green Operation
Thales (F)
Liebherr (D)
Ecodesign
Dassault Aviation (F)
Fraunhofer Gesellschaft (D)
Technology Evaluator
Thales
DLR
6. 6
6
Clean Sky 2 Programme Set-up
Large
Systems
ITDs
Vehicle
IADPs
Integr. Aircraft
Demonstr
Platforms
TechnologyEvaluator(TE)
GermanAerospaceCenter(DLR)
Building on Clean Sky, going further into integration at full aircraft level
And developing new technology streams for the next generations of aircraft
Eco-Design
FraunhoferGesellschaft
Regional
Aircraft
Alenia
Aermacchi
Fast
Rotorcraft
Agusta
Westland
Eurocopter
Engines ITD
Safran – Rolls-Royce – MTU
Systems ITD
Thales – Liebherr
Airframe ITD
Dassault – EADS-CASA – Saab
SmallAirTransport
Evektor–Piaggio
1.8b€ Total EU
Funding Proposed
Large
Passenger
Aircraft
Airbus
EU Funding Decision
1.755bn€
(1.716bn€ “net”)*
* After running costs
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
7. 7
7
3 – MEA in Clean Sky
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Work Plans in different ITDs
•In Clean Sky
•In Clean Sky 2
MEA Test rigs
Comparison of conventional architectures vs.
More electric or All electric ones
As results are still in process, the process is
described as applied in CS, with public domain
examples and results
8. 8
8
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
background
Chakraborty, I., Trawick, D., Mavris, D.N., Emeneth, M., and Schneegans, A. (2014).
A Requirements-driven Methodology for Integrating Subsystem Architecture Sizing and Analysis into the Conceptual
Aircraft Design Phase.
14th AIAA Aviation Technology, Integration, and Operations Conference. 16-20 June 2014, Atlanta (GA), USA
9. 9
9
3 – MEA in Clean Sky
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Work Plans in different ITDs
1. SGO
2. GRA
3. GRC
4. ECO
MEA Test rigs
1. COPPER Bird
2. PROVEN test rig
3. TTB (Thermal Test Bench)
4. AVANT
5. GETI
10. 10
10
SGO - Management of Aircraft Energy
SGO Technology Development & Validation of
Electrical Aircraft Systems
Stakeholders in the WP
► Management of Aircraft Energy
(MAE) aims at developing
electrical system technologies and
energy management functions to
reduce aircraft fuel consumption
through
• Development of more-electrical
system architectures and
equipment
• Validation and maturation of
electrical technologies by large
scale ground and flight
demonstrations
Member and Partner Know-How from previous R&T
projects
Electrical
Equipment
Thermal Management
Equipment
Load Management
Functions
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
11. Systems for Green Operations
CLEANSKYSGOProprietaryandConfidential
Demonstration
REDUCED SCALE IWT TESTS
April 11th 2013
Clean Sky Icing Workshop
Page 11
FULL SCALE IWT TESTS
SYSTEM BENCH
12. 12
12
E-ECS pack
New Alternator
and:
• New AC Primary Electrical Distribution
• Cabin Electrical & E-ECS power racks
• 270VDC Electrical Energy Management
Power Center (E-EM EPC)
• Simulated Resistive Load (SREL)
• EMAs electrical loads (in cabin)
• FTI/Flight Test Station (FTES)
Green Regional Aircraft ITD
A/C Mods for AEA Technologies In flight demonstration
270 HVDC
network
demo channel
Electrical
Energy Management
logics validation
EMA/Bench test
on A/C Demo (x 2)
AEA Modifications:
EPGS Mod: Electrical Power – Modification of ACWF
generation and distribution
E-EMS Mod: Electrical Power – Installation of 270V DC
Generation distribution including Electrical Power Center
(EPC) and Simulated Resistive Electrical Load (SREL)
E-ECS Mod: Air Conditioning – Installation of an
Experimental electrical environmental control sys. – E-ECS
(one pack)
EMAs Mod: Installation of two electrical actuator EMAs –
FCS/LG (each mounted on a dedicated test bench, both
located in Cabin)
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
13. 13
13
Topology and Specification
• Energy to dissipate =2MJ
• Maximum speed = ~5000 rpm
• Standard braking period = 40 seconds
• Hold brake static for 48hrs
• Target envelop: Ø290mm x 120mm to
Ø150mm x 300mm (radial diameter x axial
length)
• Maximum mass = 50 kg
• Low maintenance
• High reliability
• Temp. ranges = -55°C min to +85°C
(ambient)
• 270V d.c. compatible with 115V a.c. 3 phase
supply
• 28V d.c. supply for control
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
14. 14
14
COPPER Bird
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
The COPPER BIRD® was created in 2002 to meet the needs of more electrical aircraft, in the context
of the POA (Power Optimised Aircraft) European project to characterize an innovative electrical
architecture and define a new integration methodology for Electrical Aircraft Equipment. With Clean
Sky the Labinal Power systems’ test rig is in its final phase, in accordance with airframers new
requirements, in order to create a new ground Electrical Test Bench for small aircraft and helicopters.
COPPER = Characterization and Optimization of Power Plant Equipment Rig
Former Hispano-Suiza; now Labinal Power Systems
15. 15
15
COPPER Bird – Electrical test Bench
Generic
Configuration
Modular Bench
configuration
ECO-DESIGN
Green
Rotorcraft
Green Regional
Aircraft
SGO
- WP2.3.1
(e-Nacelle)
SGO small aircraft equipment
COPPER BOARD
15
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
16. 16
16
PROVEN Test Rig
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Ground tests of integrated Electrical technologies (starter generator,
power distribution, electrical load management, etc)
17. 17
17
composite cockpit fuselage metallic cabin fuselage
Aircraft Calorimeter (ACC)
Mock-Ups
Components of the Thermal Bench
metallic empennage
Cocoon Ventilation
Cabin Air Emulation
19. 19
19
GETI test Rig
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
To be considered for Clean Sky 2 activities
20. 20
20
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Assessment
Using a reference aircraft, on a standard mission, the
comparison of a Conventional Architecture vs. an Electric
one is possible.
The assessment identifies those system components with
penalties in terms of weight, but balanced by gain at overall
architecture level.
Only by collaboration of systems suppliers and airframers
at architecture level, the assessment is realistic.
Most recent statement by Airbus:
MEA architecture still in strategic axis but postponed
21. 21
21
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
assessment
22. 22
22
Addressing the Horizon 2020 Challenges
• “Smart Green and Integrated Transport”
Resource efficient transport that respects the environment
Ensuring safe and seamless mobility
Building industrial leadership in Europe
Enhancing and leveraging innovation capability across
Europe, with a strong emphasis on SME participation
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
23. Example of CS2 program content
Next Gen. Electrical A/C Systems,
Cockpit Systems & Avionics
Advanced Engine and Aircraft
Configurations
Innovative Physical Integration
Cabin-System-Structure
TRL 4-6
Aircraft Level
Enhanced flight
operations and
functions
Next generation cockpit
Integrated
Structure, Cabin
and Systems
fuselage
Next Generation
Cabin-Cargo
Next Generation
Lower Fuselage
Next Generation
Propulsion system &
integration
New aircraft configuration
Large
Passenger
Aircraft
(LPA)
24. 24
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
Clean Sky is contributing to the achievement of the ACARE environmental
target of Vision 2020 and preparing the development of technologies for
reaching Flightpath 2050 targets; it has allowed the continuation of
projects about More Electric Aircraft of FP6 and FP7 like POA and MOET.
Clean Sky keeps its fundamental role in funding of demonstrators for next
years, covering the More Electric technologies and architectures (from
power generation and distribution; to actuators; to new electrical
systems; wing ice protection.
Only by collaboration of systems suppliers and airframers at architecture
level, the assessment is realistic.
Concluding Remarks
25. 25
Clean Sky - More Electric Aircraft - Hamburg - 3-5Dec14
www.cleansky.eu