6. Marketing Productivity
Analysis
6
“The use of productivity measurement in relation
marketing function is relatively new. The central
marketing can be expressed as the management
consumer demand and the translation of this
sales and profits. Marketing productivity analysis
important tool in evaluating the performance of
marketing department in carrying out this role. It
the efficiency with which marketing inputs are
generate target levels of marketing outputs.”
7. Marketing Productivity
Analysis
7
“The use of productivity measurement in relation
marketing function is relatively new. The central
marketing can be expressed as the management of
demand and the translation of this demand into
profits. Marketing productivity analysis is an
evaluating the performance of the marketing
carrying out this role. It measures the efficiency
marketing inputs are used to generate target levels
marketing outputs.”
Thomas, Michael J. (1984) “The Meaning of Marketing Productivity
9. Effective vs. Efficient: The
Difference?
9
Effective (adj.): Adequate to accomplish a
purpose; producing the intended or expected
result.
Efficient (adj.): Performing or functioning in
the best possible manner with the least
waste of time and effort.
12. 12
Framework for Marketing Performance
Measurement
Adapted from Lehmann and Reibstein
(2006)
What marketers and competitors do
• Advertising
• Price
• Promotions
• Distribution
What customers think & feel
Awareness Consideration Liking
What customers do
Brand purchases
Direct Effect Feedback Effect
13. 13
Advertising Campaign Testing
Adapted from Lehmann and Reibstein
(2006)
What marketers and competitors do
• Advertising
• Price
• Promotions
• Distribution
What customers think & feel
Awareness Consideration Liking
What customers do
Brand purchases
Direct Effect Feedback Effect
14. 14
Brand Health Tracking
Adapted from Lehmann and Reibstein
(2006)
What marketers and competitors do
• Advertising
• Price
• Promotions
• Distribution
What customers think & feel
Awareness Consideration Liking
What customers do
Brand purchases
Direct Effect Feedback Effect
15. 15
Marketing Mix Modeling
Adapted from Lehmann and Reibstein
(2006)
What marketers and competitors do
• Advertising
• Price
• Promotions
• Distribution
What customers think & feel
Awareness Consideration Liking
What customers do
Brand purchases
Direct Effect Feedback Effect
16. 16
M5: Mindset Metrics and Marketing Mix
Modeling
Adapted from Lehmann and Reibstein
(2006)
What marketers and competitors do
• Advertising
• Price
• Promotions
• Distribution
What customers think & feel
Awareness Consideration Liking
What customers do
Brand purchases
Direct Effect Feedback Effect
17. Return on Marketing Investment: Rearview
Mirror
Marketing
ROI
Marketing
Expenditure
Marketing
Support
Incremental
Contribution
Incremental
Volume
Costs Margins
Model
18. Return on Marketing Investment: Front Dash
Marginal Marketing
ROI
Marginal
Expenditure
Marketing
Support
Marginal
Contribution
Incremental
Volume
Costs Margins
Model
22. 1875: Is This Really Marketing
Mix?
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Galton’s work on inherited
characteristics of sweet peas led to the
initial conceptualization of linear
24. The Birth of Data
1875
Regression
conceptualiz
ed
1923
A.C. Nielsen
Company
Founded
25. The Nielsen Factor
Pioneer in Data Collection
• Inaugurated a National Radio Index for
broadcasters and advertisers in 1942
• Followed by a television ratings service in
1950
• Once TV ratings were available, people
starting experimenting
25
27. First Marketing Mix Model
1875
Regression
conceptualiz
ed
1923
A.C. Nielsen
Company
Founded
1957 1962
Arrow/Nerlo
ve Formalize
Adstock
1975
Little/Lodish
Media
Planning
Calculus MDS
Founded
(1969)
Little
BRAND
AID
Marketi
ng Mix
Model
Dorfma
n/Steine
r
Theroe
m
Vidale/Wolfe
observe
relationship
between sales
and advertising
28. Advertising has a Carryover
Effect
1875
Regression
conceptualiz
ed
1923
A.C. Nielsen
Company
Founded
1957 1962 1975 1979
Little
BRAND
AID
Marketi
ng Mix
Model
Broadbent
Popularize
s Adtsock
Arrow/Nerlo
ve Formalize
Adstock
Little/Lodish
Media
Planning
Calculus MDS
Founded
(1969)
Dorfma
n/Steine
r
Theroe
m
Vidale/Wolfe
observe
relationship
between sales
and advertising
29. Two Dimensions of Adstock
29
Advertising Lag (Decayed
Effect)
Advertising Saturation
(Diminishing Returns Effect)
30. Ten Years After
30
1980
IRI
Found
ed
Nielsen
Launches
Home Video
Index
Guadagni/Lit
tle Logit Mix
Model
1983 1985 1986 1987 1989
IRI
Acquire
s MDS
Duke’s
Marketing
Workbenc
h
IRI’s
Infoscan
Introduc
ed
MMA
Founded
Blattberg/Wisnie
wski How
Promotions Work
32. The Next 10 Years
32
1990 1999
10 Marketing Mix Modeling
firms founded; numerous
consultants and ad agencies
start ROMI practices
So what
happened next?
34. MMM in a Digital World
34
Business Impact
Direct
Business Performance
Sales & Trade
Promotions
Business Impact
Marketing
Paid Search
Impressions
Online Display
Paid Search
Clicks
Social Media
Search Volume
Search Volume
Indirect
Business Impact
Sales