George is the lead software developer for a game company facing a tight deadline. He must delegate tasks to complete the project on time. George chooses to teach Lucy, the new graduate, new skills to finish the work. This upsets the more experienced employees Sam and Rodger who wanted to learn. Proper delegation considers employees' skills, willingness, and motivations. Managers must communicate goals and value each employee to avoid resentment from missed opportunities. Overall, delegation can improve efficiency but requires support and development of all staff.
2. Definitions and interpretations
• Defining delegation:
“Grant of authority by one party (the delegator) to another (the
delgatee) for agreed purpose(s). Under the legal concept of vicarious
liability, the delegator remains responsible for the delegatee's acts or
omissions in carrying out the purpose of the delegation”
(BusinessDictionary.com, 2017)
Could be interpreted as:
“The assignment of any responsibility or authority to another person to
carry out specific activities.”
(George Beckley, 2017)
3. The Purpose of Delegation
Organisations and companies are often involved in many activities,
such as: sourcing, distribution and customer service. If work and tasks
are not organised it can affect the efficiency, productivity,
development, employee satisfaction and market share of the company.
• Delegation is needed to:
• Increase efficiency
• Increase development
• Increase productivity
• Increase job satisfaction
4. Delegation & Efficiency
• Delegation allows a manager to spread tasks to employees to speed up tasks,
better quality of a task* and less pressure on a manager with many tasks to
complete.
• *Some employees may not
have the correct skills to produce
quality.
Delegation allows a manager to spread tasks across employees. By assigning
specific tasks to specific employees there is a greater probability of the task being
completed sooner than if one employee had to complete all tasks. If each
employee is given a manageable workload there is a greater chance of the work
produced being of better quality. By assigning specific tasks to specific employees it
can also make employees feel as if they have a role in the business, thus increasing
their job satisfaction and efficiency.
5. Delegation & Development
• A leader or manager can help improve an employee’s skills set by
working with them showing the employee how to do certain tasks. To
solidify the new skills learnt, tasks can be delegated to the employee.
If completed well, this will show the new skill is learnt and the
employee is now able in that skill.
6. The Scenario-Game Software Development
Company
• “Hello there I am the lead software design developer for
VorsecGames, a relatively small company with 10 employees all
together. I have a problem, the deadline for the software is two weeks
away, with the game set for release. However if I continue with the
software development at my current speed it will take me three
weeks to complete. I need to delegate!”
7. Who to delegate to?
• “I have three employees that work under me. They all do the same
software work, but I am the only one who knows how to put finishing
effects and specific coding on software. I will need to teach one
employee out of Sam, Rodger and Lucy this new skills set.”
• Sam has been working here 2 years and is very ambitious, wanting to progress through the
company. Sam is 25 years old.
• Rodger works very hard and has been at the company for 10 years. Rodger is set to retire in 5
years time.
• Lucy has just joined VorsecGames and is the brightest out of the 3. Lucy has just graduated from
university at 23 years old.
8. Positives of Delegation
• “I chose to delegate the task to Lucy. This was a tricky decision, but
Lucy will pick up the skills the fastest to complete the task, helping me
meet the deadline. She will also carry these skills for life. Eventually
she could be the manager for this company one day. I know the other
employees may not agree with my decision.”
• “I am so happy to be learning new skills and doing new tasks that
challenge me. I am motivated to get into the task and give it my best
efforts. Thanks Boss!” Lucy
9. Implications of delegation
• “I am so happy George did not pick me to dump his work on. I hate change in my
work. If he had picked me, I may become unhappy and effect those around me by
being grumpy.” Rodger.
• “I am so angry right now! Lucy has just arrived and is already being taught new
skills. I have worked here two years and George did not trust me with his task? I
feel hurt by his decision and I am really demotivated to work under George. I
deserved to learn the new skills!” Sam.
10. Resolution to Scenario 1
• “Once Sam had found out he was not chosen for the delegated task he was
very angry with me and potentially demotivated to work for this company.
In this situation I need to have a conversation with Sam to make him feel
valued, that there is career progression here, but also make sure he knows
I am his boss.”
• This is a difficult situation for myself, as I need to make assurances that the
employee will develop his skills over time at this organisation. The problem
I have is not having a task to delegate to Sam or when the next task will be.
This was a risky choice for myself, but understood Sam is part of the future
of this organisation and could not risk him leaving for another organisation.
I will also need to help Lucy with the delegated task. Without suitable
support and resources this could lead to anxiety, frustration and the task
being badly done (Hall et al., 2010).
11. Evaluation of Delegation Scenario 1
• Choosing the high skilled worker was most suitable for the need of this delegation. There was
little time for task completion and training someone that will learn fast is less time consuming.
The employees all responded in different ways, positively, negatively and somewhat neutral. The
delegation is positive for the employee that is willing to learn and develop new skills, in this case
Lucy. This is also good for the organisation, as their employees are now at a greater skill level and
more valuable to the business. Delegation can have demotivating effects on employees that have
seen other employees be chosen for delegated work and progress their skills, while they have
not. Neutrally, some employees do not want their job or workload to change.
• This was an efficiency form of delegation, but needed a high skilled employee. A new employee
was picked for the task, making older employees feel distrust towards their manager as I seem to
trust a brand new employee for the task more than Sam or Rodger who had more experience. As
the employees are highly skilled, most want to keep progressing with their skills. This causes a
competitiveness for delegation tasks, potentially leading to employee conflict. To avoid this I
could have made a progress plan where all employees will have a rota format for delegation tasks.
Some employees like Rodger do not like their job changing, and may be frustrated if chosen for
delegation tasks.
12. Delegation Scenario 2
• “I am the manager here at McDonalds. As part of my job I need to
help my employees develop management skills to help the future of
the business. I am going to delegate a task to Joe, involving cashing up
the tills at the end of the day. I know Joe has the skills to do the
delegated task, but he is not motivated to do it.”
13. Low Skilled Delegation Implications
• “Ugh. George is so annoying. I don’t want to learn management skills,
I just want to work and get paid. Is that too much to ask? George also
says I take too long to cash the tills.” Joe
14. Resolution to Scenario 2
• “I will need to have a meeting with Joe and try to persuade him to do the
delegated tasks.”
• Research by Spetzer (1992) into delegation showed organisations that
managers must take time to explain delegated tasks clearly. Managers
should also tell employees why the delegated task is important. This will
create a shared value between the manager, employee and task delegated
to them (Hall et al., 2010). I needed to explain to Joe that this work is
important for his job progression. We then had a long conversation about
his future ambitions. I believe that I now understand what Joe is looking for
in delegated tasks. All he wanted to know before the task is why he needed
to do the task and not myself. Later this shift myself and Joe cashed the tills
together.
15. Evaluation of Delegation Scenario 2
• In this scenario there is no time restraint on the manager, the pure
purpose of this delegation is for employee development. However,
the employee did not want to do the extra task as he did not want to
learn these new skills, it seemed more like extra work for the
employee. As this is a low skilled working environment many
employees did not choose this job, but needed a living wage more
than anything. This leads to employee demotivation if they are forced
to learn more tasks than what they originally signed up for or are
willing to do. A manager has to be very careful when delegating to
make sure everyone is happy. For Trevor to have successful delegation
and development with myself I will need to first motivate and excite
Joe to be willing to do the tasks.
16. Factors of who to delegate to
Figure 1 shows that delegated tasks takes an employee to both be
willing and high skilled. There are also other ways to get an
employee to delegate tasks to, but is dependant on the employees
willingness and current skill level. With high skill and low willingness
the manager will need to persuade and excite the employee into
wanting to do the delegated tasks.
An employee with high will but low skill, will need guidance on the
task. This will be time consuming for the manager, and will only have
time to delegate tasks if the situation for the manager is not
pressurized.
For a low skill and low willingness worker, this will be difficult to the
manager to delegate tasks to. The employee will need both
motivation and guidance to delegate a task to.
High will and high skill workers are where a manager can trust the
employee to both get the delegated job done and with good quality.
Figure 1: Delegation Model. Sourced
from (Howtodelegate.com, 2017)
17. Elements of Delegation
Responsibility-
Trusting the employee with the task. The
managers assign certain responsibility to the
subordinates for the completion of certain tasks
on there behalf.
Authority-
the manager along with the responsibility also
delegates authority to enable the subordinate to
take decisions independently and accomplish the
task efficiently.
Accountability-
The Accountability cannot be delegated which
means, in the case of non-completion of the task,
the manager will only be held responsible for it,
not the subordinates.Figure 2: Elements of Delegation. Sourced from
(Businessjargons.com, 2017)
18. Advantages of Delegation
• Manager: The essence of delegation process is empowering someone to act for
the manager. The manager shares his burden of work with his subordinates
through delegation. Thus the manager is allowed to concentrate on other works.
• Employees: Delegation allows freedom and expands the wisdom of subordinates.
It enhances the position and status of the subordinates as they are given powers
to exercise.
• Organisation: Grows and expands out of delegation. Delegation speeds up
decision making as power is shared at all levels.
• Team: The behaviour pattern of every individual is improved by delegation.
Granting of freedom to act by the superior shows the confidence of the superior
over tile subordinates.
• Trust: When a manager is on leave the work is taken by subordinates and
provides continuity in functions.
• Team Morale: It motivates the subordinates to do better and perform well.
19. Disadvantages of Delegation
• Time: Can be very time consuming if dealing with unwilling or low
skilled employees to get the job done in a specific time frame.
• Quality of work: There is an element of trust that the job will be done
to a high standard. There is no guarantee tasks will be done to a high
standard.
• Relevance of position: Employees may become frustrated that they
have been given management tasks, while the manager is not doing
their job properly. Employees may question the managers credibility.
• Communication: The manager will have a vision of how a task should
be carried out. The subordinate may have a different view. This is
where miscommunication may occur.
20. References
• Business Jargons. (2017). What are the elements of Delegation of Authority? definition and elements -
Business Jargons. [online] Available at: http://businessjargons.com/elements-of-delegation-of-authority.html
[Accessed 18 Oct. 2017].
• Hall, D., Jones, R., Raffo, C., Anderton, A., Chambers, I. and Gray, D. (2010). Business studies. Harlow: Pearson
Education.
• Merriam-webster.com. (2017). Definition of DELEGATION. [online] Available at: https://www.merriam-
webster.com/dictionary/delegation [Accessed 18 Oct. 2017].
Editor's Notes
Jan Yager, in her book “Work Less, Do More,” (2008) Outlines that for delegation tasks, the manager should always pick the employee best for the task in a short time frame. This is based on characteristics and skills for the task at hand.