SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Local Development Order
Wellfield Road, Hatfield
Colin Haigh - Head of Planning
Town centre
University
Business Park
Railway station
Hatfield
New Town
Good range of
services but
needs a bit of
regeneration
Galleria
Hatfield House
Wellfield Road site
 0.9 hectare factory site
 Makes cosmetics applicators for high-end companies
 Identified as deliverable/developable in SHLAA
 Promoted for about 90 dwellings
 Lack of land use or environmental designations
 Subject to positive pre-application discussions
 Mix of local architectural styles = scope for range of
masterplan, landscape, design approaches
Council mentality
 New Director and Head of Planning in summer 2014
 Strong emphasis on pre-application advice and PPAs
 Local Plan raising challenging green belt issues
 Desire to bring forward brownfield sites
 Hatfield seen as bridesmaid to Welwyn Garden City
 Chance to explore new development mechanism
Caressa Kahn / Wakelin Associates
 Caressa Kahn in Hatfield for 50+ years
 Specialist manufacturing, complicated to relocate
 Ambition to grow but constrained by site size
 Want to leave legacy on site once gone
 Want to maximise value to cover relocation costs
 Most evidence already exists to support plan app
 Wakelin keen to explore new ways of working
 But hesitant about working with others, particularly
in respect of masterplanning/design issues
LDO Objectives
 Quality – to deliver exemplar scheme and at least as
good as through conventional plan app process
 Speed – to adopt LDO within timescales and deliver
scheme earlier than 2018, to demonstrate that LDOs
can boost delivery and free-up officer time
 Ease of replication – to gain experience of how best
to prepare an LDO and establish standard structure
Governance
 Political leadership = Executive Member for Planning
 Project manager = Head of Planning
 Project officers = from Policy and Dev Management
 Input from Wakelin Associates
 Input from URS on behalf of PAS
 Regular updates to Cabinet Planning Panel, with
expectation that LDO will be approved by DM Cmte
in same way as normal planning application
Process
 Sept 14 = Agreement with landowners and agents to
submit nomination. Wakelin Associates enthusiastic.
 Oct 2014 = Early preparation of clear project plan
with agreed milestones
 Nov 2014 = Initiation meeting and site
visit between Council, PAS, URS,
landowner, agents and ward cllrs.
First time all parties had met.
Process
 Dec 2014 = Landowner/agent worried that LDO will
be slower than plan app and ultimately less profit.
 Jan 2015 = Council, PAS, landowner/agent meeting
to offer reassurance. Agreement that indicative
masterplan and LDO will be prepared
in parallel to reassure landowner of
most profitable scheme.
Process
 Feb 2015 = Finalisation of clear project plan, agreed
milestones and use of project funding
 Feb 2015 = Council advise that LDO is far cheaper
than plan app route, which would cost circa £3,000
pre-app advice plus £24,000 plan fee
 Feb 2015 = Funding received from CLG
and project gets properly underway
Next steps
 Complete technical contamination evidence (Feb)
 Commission joint viability appraisal (Feb)
 Jointly prepare indicative masterplan &LDO (March)
- Absolutes such as building heights, overlooking distances
- Parameters such as number of units, density
- Palettes such as design styles, construction materials
 Informal local consultation (March)
 Prepare and consult on draft LDO (April)
 Agree final LDO at DM Cmte (June)
Timetable
8th
15th
22nd
29th
5th
12th
19th
26th
2nd
9th
16th
23rd
2nd
9th
16th
23rd
30th
6th
13th
20th
27th
4th
11th
18th
25th
1st
8th
15th
22nd
29th
6th
13th
20th
27th
Project Plan
Scoping of LDO and Project Plan
Project partner agreement to Project Plan
Preparatory work
Prepare brief for viability work
Appoint viability consultant
Viability work carried out
Stakeholder meetings
Contamination Assessment
Site survey work
Graphic design work
Preparation of the LDO
Drafting the core LDO wording
Producing the design aspects of the LDO
Revisions to the LDO
Communication and consultation
Prepare consultation materials
Mailouts and publish advert
Consultation period
Consultation events
Press releases
Post to PASHousing LDOs website
Formal LDO milestones
Draft reports
DMC - Approval for consultation
DMC - Report back consultation amendments
Cabinet - Adoption of LDO
Notify Secratary of State of adoption
June 2015 July 2015Dec 2014 Jan 2015 Feb 2015 Mar 2015 Apr 2015 May 2015
Scheme
Flatted blocks of 2,
3, 4 storeys
Modern architecture
and flat roofs
Parking courtyards
Landscaping
LDO Costs
 £12,000 for joint viability appraisal
 £1,500 for desktop contamination survey
 £650 for newspaper adverts
 £500 for letters to surrounding residents
 £250 for consultation boards / material
 £7,500 for graphic design work and more detailed
contamination evidence if needed
 Total £24,640 inc 10% contingency
Ambitions
 Learning experience
 Looking for transferable principles
 Template format with standardised headings and
text, so can be easily copied and re-applied to other
brownfield and potentially green belt sites
 Scope to be cheaper third alternative:
1) straight plan app = plan app fee
2) pre-app advice = pre-app fee + plan app fee
3) prepare LDO = joint work fee but free plan app
Risks
 LDO results in inappropriate development
 Difficult for supporters/objectors to comment on all
aspects of scheme if LDO enables flexibility
 LDO contains loopholes that are exploited
 LDO is incorrect or ineffective
 LDO preparation is delayed
 LDO is not seen as giving residents a voice
 Viability appraisal concludes that scheme does not
deliver sufficient returns

More Related Content

What's hot

Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering Housing
Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering HousingZoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering Housing
Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering HousingPAS_Team
 
Swindon LDO PAS presentation
Swindon LDO PAS presentationSwindon LDO PAS presentation
Swindon LDO PAS presentationPAS_Team
 
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106PAS_Team
 
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development Orders
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development OrdersMark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development Orders
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development OrdersPAS_Team
 
Stuart Minty PPA presentation
Stuart Minty PPA presentationStuart Minty PPA presentation
Stuart Minty PPA presentationPAS_Team
 
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable Energy
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable EnergyDan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable Energy
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable EnergyPAS_Team
 
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy Experiences
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy ExperiencesAngie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy Experiences
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy ExperiencesPAS_Team
 
Planning and sustainability v3
Planning and sustainability v3Planning and sustainability v3
Planning and sustainability v3PAS_Team
 
CIL vs S106 vs S108
CIL vs S106 vs S108CIL vs S106 vs S108
CIL vs S106 vs S108PAS_Team
 
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experience
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experienceNeighbourhood Planning East Devon experience
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experiencePAS_Team
 
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike M
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike MPreston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike M
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike MPAS_Team
 
Making CIL Work
Making CIL WorkMaking CIL Work
Making CIL WorkPAS_Team
 
Pas Cil operation Gerard Coll
Pas   Cil operation  Gerard CollPas   Cil operation  Gerard Coll
Pas Cil operation Gerard CollPAS_Team
 
S106 ATLAS
S106 ATLASS106 ATLAS
S106 ATLASPAS_Team
 
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.Alexandra Dobson
 
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable Drainage
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable DrainageRobin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable Drainage
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable DrainagePAS_Team
 
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021PAS_Team
 
Keep on planning presentation final
Keep on planning presentation finalKeep on planning presentation final
Keep on planning presentation finalPAS_Team
 

What's hot (20)

Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering Housing
Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering HousingZoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering Housing
Zoe Willcox, Bristol CC - Positive Planning - Delivering Housing
 
Swindon LDO PAS presentation
Swindon LDO PAS presentationSwindon LDO PAS presentation
Swindon LDO PAS presentation
 
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106
Peter Ollivere, Durham County Council Experience of Section 106
 
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development Orders
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development OrdersMark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development Orders
Mark Cawood, NE Lincs CC - Local Development Orders
 
Stuart Minty PPA presentation
Stuart Minty PPA presentationStuart Minty PPA presentation
Stuart Minty PPA presentation
 
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable Energy
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable EnergyDan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable Energy
Dan Stone, Centre for Sustainable Energy - Renewable Energy
 
B5 A Miraculous Transformation
B5 A Miraculous TransformationB5 A Miraculous Transformation
B5 A Miraculous Transformation
 
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy Experiences
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy ExperiencesAngie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy Experiences
Angie Jukes, Stockport MBC - Stockport Renewable Energy Experiences
 
Planning and sustainability v3
Planning and sustainability v3Planning and sustainability v3
Planning and sustainability v3
 
CIL vs S106 vs S108
CIL vs S106 vs S108CIL vs S106 vs S108
CIL vs S106 vs S108
 
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experience
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experienceNeighbourhood Planning East Devon experience
Neighbourhood Planning East Devon experience
 
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike M
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike MPreston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike M
Preston Implementing CIL Jan 2016 – Mike M
 
Making CIL Work
Making CIL WorkMaking CIL Work
Making CIL Work
 
Pas Cil operation Gerard Coll
Pas   Cil operation  Gerard CollPas   Cil operation  Gerard Coll
Pas Cil operation Gerard Coll
 
S106 ATLAS
S106 ATLASS106 ATLAS
S106 ATLAS
 
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.
What is Regulation 19? OPDC's draft Local Plan, pre-consultation event.
 
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable Drainage
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable DrainageRobin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable Drainage
Robin Campbell & Paul Davies - Planning for Sustainable Drainage
 
A5 Form Based Codes
A5 Form Based CodesA5 Form Based Codes
A5 Form Based Codes
 
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021
PAS Biodiversity Net Gain London Borough Workshop 15 July 2021
 
Keep on planning presentation final
Keep on planning presentation finalKeep on planning presentation final
Keep on planning presentation final
 

Similar to Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hatfield

Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...
Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...
Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...PAS_Team
 
Adam Turnell CV & Sample Portfolio
Adam Turnell CV & Sample PortfolioAdam Turnell CV & Sample Portfolio
Adam Turnell CV & Sample PortfolioAdam Turnell
 
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16Lyn Roberts
 
Introducing lo cus for potential new partners
Introducing lo cus   for potential new partnersIntroducing lo cus   for potential new partners
Introducing lo cus for potential new partnersl0Cusproject
 
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010Franklin Matters
 
Document 1
Document 1Document 1
Document 1Erik Ong
 
Pre-application good practice
Pre-application good practicePre-application good practice
Pre-application good practicePAS_Team
 
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nsw
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In NswEcoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nsw
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nswdavidjrca
 
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015Vincent Lasseaux
 
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010jelutharas
 
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_PublicRichard B. Petch
 
Our pre application offer at Croydon Council
Our pre application offer at Croydon CouncilOur pre application offer at Croydon Council
Our pre application offer at Croydon CouncilPAS_Team
 
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa Tsemtsidis
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa TsemtsidisUpdated CV 29th August 2016 Costa Tsemtsidis
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa TsemtsidisCosta Tsemtsidis
 
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - General
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - GeneralIAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - General
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - GeneralIan Herbert
 
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best Practice
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best PracticeCommunity Revitalization Planning Implementation Best Practice
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best PracticePeter Bass, LEED AP, PMP
 
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon Session
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon SessionBuilding a Resilient Environment - Afternoon Session
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon SessionSustainability East
 
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications services
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications servicesPhillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications services
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications servicesPAS_Team
 
Irene CV for October 2016
Irene CV for October 2016Irene CV for October 2016
Irene CV for October 2016irene O'Reilly
 

Similar to Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hatfield (20)

Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...
Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...
Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hat...
 
Adam Turnell CV & Sample Portfolio
Adam Turnell CV & Sample PortfolioAdam Turnell CV & Sample Portfolio
Adam Turnell CV & Sample Portfolio
 
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16
Marcus.Roberts.CV.14.11.16
 
Introducing lo cus for potential new partners
Introducing lo cus   for potential new partnersIntroducing lo cus   for potential new partners
Introducing lo cus for potential new partners
 
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010
Downtown Improvement Project 1/20/2010
 
Document 1
Document 1Document 1
Document 1
 
Pre-application good practice
Pre-application good practicePre-application good practice
Pre-application good practice
 
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nsw
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In NswEcoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nsw
Ecoforum 2011 Dave Johnson Brownfield Regeneration In Nsw
 
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015
CV Vincent Lasseaux December 2015
 
Not Your Grandfather's DOT: The FDOT District 5 and PennDOT Experiences--Bria...
Not Your Grandfather's DOT: The FDOT District 5 and PennDOT Experiences--Bria...Not Your Grandfather's DOT: The FDOT District 5 and PennDOT Experiences--Bria...
Not Your Grandfather's DOT: The FDOT District 5 and PennDOT Experiences--Bria...
 
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010Single Conversation Slides   15th June 2010
Single Conversation Slides 15th June 2010
 
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public
3rd_NDC_SL_Commercial_Strategy_Public
 
Our pre application offer at Croydon Council
Our pre application offer at Croydon CouncilOur pre application offer at Croydon Council
Our pre application offer at Croydon Council
 
Bdp presentation
Bdp presentationBdp presentation
Bdp presentation
 
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa Tsemtsidis
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa TsemtsidisUpdated CV 29th August 2016 Costa Tsemtsidis
Updated CV 29th August 2016 Costa Tsemtsidis
 
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - General
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - GeneralIAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - General
IAN HERBERT 2016 NZ - General
 
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best Practice
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best PracticeCommunity Revitalization Planning Implementation Best Practice
Community Revitalization Planning Implementation Best Practice
 
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon Session
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon SessionBuilding a Resilient Environment - Afternoon Session
Building a Resilient Environment - Afternoon Session
 
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications services
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications servicesPhillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications services
Phillipa Silcock, PAS, Worthwhile pre-applications services
 
Irene CV for October 2016
Irene CV for October 2016Irene CV for October 2016
Irene CV for October 2016
 

More from PAS_Team

231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf
231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf
231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdfPAS_Team
 
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...PAS_Team
 
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023PAS_Team
 
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdf
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdfGuildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdf
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdfPAS_Team
 
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdf
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdfBNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdf
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdfPAS_Team
 
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptx
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptxPAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptx
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptxPAS_Team
 
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptx
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptxLeeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptx
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptxPAS_Team
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...PAS_Team
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...PAS_Team
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...PAS_Team
 
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23PAS_Team
 
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptx
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptxEOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptx
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptxPAS_Team
 
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptxPAS_Team
 
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdf
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdfPAS Pre-App March 2023.pdf
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdfPAS_Team
 
CBC Monitoring Review.pptx
CBC Monitoring  Review.pptxCBC Monitoring  Review.pptx
CBC Monitoring Review.pptxPAS_Team
 
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptx
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptxPAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptx
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptxPAS_Team
 
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdf
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdfPAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdf
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdfPAS_Team
 
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptx
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptxPAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptx
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptxPAS_Team
 
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptx
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptxPAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptx
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptxPAS_Team
 
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy PAS_Team
 

More from PAS_Team (20)

231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf
231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf
231121 SP slides - PAS workshop November 2023.pdf
 
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...
So you want to apply for the Planning Skills Delivery Fund PAS Events August ...
 
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023
PAS BNG in Local Plans slides June 2023
 
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdf
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdfGuildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdf
Guildford BC BNG Policy June 2023.pdf
 
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdf
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdfBNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdf
BNG at Salford City Council_June 2023.pdf
 
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptx
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptxPAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptx
PAS LNRS and role of Supporting Authorities_23_05_23_PAS slides.pptx
 
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptx
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptxLeeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptx
Leeds Beckett Lecture Career Advice.pptx
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 3 Delivering Affordable ...
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 2 Spending the levy and ...
 
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...
Infrastructure Levy Technical Consultation (Workshop 1 Setting rates and char...
 
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23
PAS Natural England Biodiversity Net Gain update 18_04_23
 
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptx
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptxEOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptx
EOR Webinar PAS presentation slidesFINAL.pptx
 
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx
230329 IL Technical Consultation - launch event.pptx
 
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdf
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdfPAS Pre-App March 2023.pdf
PAS Pre-App March 2023.pdf
 
CBC Monitoring Review.pptx
CBC Monitoring  Review.pptxCBC Monitoring  Review.pptx
CBC Monitoring Review.pptx
 
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptx
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptxPAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptx
PAS Salford Pre App Journey March 2023 JC.pptx
 
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdf
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdfPAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdf
PAS BNG and Nature Recovery Autumn 2022 Events Evaluation.pdf
 
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptx
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptxPAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptx
PAS NERC guidance events Nov 22 web.pptx
 
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptx
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptxPAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptx
PAS Nature Recovery for LAs 8 Dec Post Event.pptx
 
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy
PAS BNG and NR policy and strategy
 

Recently uploaded

(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Serviceranjana rawat
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...ranjana rawat
 
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Christina Parmionova
 
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptx
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptxEDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptx
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptxaaryamanorathofficia
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomishabajaj13
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 272024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27JSchaus & Associates
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up NumberMs Riya
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...Suhani Kapoor
 
Climate change and safety and health at work
Climate change and safety and health at workClimate change and safety and health at work
Climate change and safety and health at workChristina Parmionova
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related Topics
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related TopicsCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related Topics
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related TopicsCongressional Budget Office
 
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...Suhani Kapoor
 
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxIncident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxPeter Miles
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escortsaditipandeya
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...Suhani Kapoor
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTaccounts329278
 

Recently uploaded (20)

(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(SUHANI) Call Girls Pimple Saudagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(TARA) Call Girls Sanghavi ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(PRIYA) Call Girls Rajgurunagar ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
(DIYA) Call Girls Saswad ( 7001035870 ) HI-Fi Pune Escorts Service
 
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...
The Most Attractive Pune Call Girls Handewadi Road 8250192130 Will You Miss T...
 
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.Climate change and occupational safety and health.
Climate change and occupational safety and health.
 
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptx
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptxEDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptx
EDUROOT SME_ Performance upto March-2024.pptx
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jatin Das Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 272024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 27
 
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas  Whats Up Number
##9711199012 Call Girls Delhi Rs-5000 UpTo 10 K Hauz Khas Whats Up Number
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
VIP High Class Call Girls Amravati Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Serv...
 
Climate change and safety and health at work
Climate change and safety and health at workClimate change and safety and health at work
Climate change and safety and health at work
 
Rohini Sector 37 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 37 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 37 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 37 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related Topics
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related TopicsCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related Topics
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research on Health-Related Topics
 
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
VIP High Profile Call Girls Gorakhpur Aarushi 8250192130 Independent Escort S...
 
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxIncident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Incident Command System xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Ishita 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
 
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...
VIP Call Girls Service Bikaner Aishwarya 8250192130 Independent Escort Servic...
 
Call Girls In Rohini ꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
Call Girls In  Rohini ꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCeCall Girls In  Rohini ꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
Call Girls In Rohini ꧁❤ 🔝 9953056974🔝❤꧂ Escort ServiCe
 
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CTFair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
Fair Trash Reduction - West Hartford, CT
 

Colin Haigh, Welwyn Hatfield BC - Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hatfield

  • 1. Local Development Order Wellfield Road, Hatfield Colin Haigh - Head of Planning
  • 2. Town centre University Business Park Railway station Hatfield New Town Good range of services but needs a bit of regeneration Galleria Hatfield House
  • 3.
  • 4. Wellfield Road site  0.9 hectare factory site  Makes cosmetics applicators for high-end companies  Identified as deliverable/developable in SHLAA  Promoted for about 90 dwellings  Lack of land use or environmental designations  Subject to positive pre-application discussions  Mix of local architectural styles = scope for range of masterplan, landscape, design approaches
  • 5. Council mentality  New Director and Head of Planning in summer 2014  Strong emphasis on pre-application advice and PPAs  Local Plan raising challenging green belt issues  Desire to bring forward brownfield sites  Hatfield seen as bridesmaid to Welwyn Garden City  Chance to explore new development mechanism
  • 6. Caressa Kahn / Wakelin Associates  Caressa Kahn in Hatfield for 50+ years  Specialist manufacturing, complicated to relocate  Ambition to grow but constrained by site size  Want to leave legacy on site once gone  Want to maximise value to cover relocation costs  Most evidence already exists to support plan app  Wakelin keen to explore new ways of working  But hesitant about working with others, particularly in respect of masterplanning/design issues
  • 7. LDO Objectives  Quality – to deliver exemplar scheme and at least as good as through conventional plan app process  Speed – to adopt LDO within timescales and deliver scheme earlier than 2018, to demonstrate that LDOs can boost delivery and free-up officer time  Ease of replication – to gain experience of how best to prepare an LDO and establish standard structure
  • 8. Governance  Political leadership = Executive Member for Planning  Project manager = Head of Planning  Project officers = from Policy and Dev Management  Input from Wakelin Associates  Input from URS on behalf of PAS  Regular updates to Cabinet Planning Panel, with expectation that LDO will be approved by DM Cmte in same way as normal planning application
  • 9. Process  Sept 14 = Agreement with landowners and agents to submit nomination. Wakelin Associates enthusiastic.  Oct 2014 = Early preparation of clear project plan with agreed milestones  Nov 2014 = Initiation meeting and site visit between Council, PAS, URS, landowner, agents and ward cllrs. First time all parties had met.
  • 10. Process  Dec 2014 = Landowner/agent worried that LDO will be slower than plan app and ultimately less profit.  Jan 2015 = Council, PAS, landowner/agent meeting to offer reassurance. Agreement that indicative masterplan and LDO will be prepared in parallel to reassure landowner of most profitable scheme.
  • 11. Process  Feb 2015 = Finalisation of clear project plan, agreed milestones and use of project funding  Feb 2015 = Council advise that LDO is far cheaper than plan app route, which would cost circa £3,000 pre-app advice plus £24,000 plan fee  Feb 2015 = Funding received from CLG and project gets properly underway
  • 12. Next steps  Complete technical contamination evidence (Feb)  Commission joint viability appraisal (Feb)  Jointly prepare indicative masterplan &LDO (March) - Absolutes such as building heights, overlooking distances - Parameters such as number of units, density - Palettes such as design styles, construction materials  Informal local consultation (March)  Prepare and consult on draft LDO (April)  Agree final LDO at DM Cmte (June)
  • 13. Timetable 8th 15th 22nd 29th 5th 12th 19th 26th 2nd 9th 16th 23rd 2nd 9th 16th 23rd 30th 6th 13th 20th 27th 4th 11th 18th 25th 1st 8th 15th 22nd 29th 6th 13th 20th 27th Project Plan Scoping of LDO and Project Plan Project partner agreement to Project Plan Preparatory work Prepare brief for viability work Appoint viability consultant Viability work carried out Stakeholder meetings Contamination Assessment Site survey work Graphic design work Preparation of the LDO Drafting the core LDO wording Producing the design aspects of the LDO Revisions to the LDO Communication and consultation Prepare consultation materials Mailouts and publish advert Consultation period Consultation events Press releases Post to PASHousing LDOs website Formal LDO milestones Draft reports DMC - Approval for consultation DMC - Report back consultation amendments Cabinet - Adoption of LDO Notify Secratary of State of adoption June 2015 July 2015Dec 2014 Jan 2015 Feb 2015 Mar 2015 Apr 2015 May 2015
  • 14. Scheme Flatted blocks of 2, 3, 4 storeys Modern architecture and flat roofs Parking courtyards Landscaping
  • 15.
  • 16. LDO Costs  £12,000 for joint viability appraisal  £1,500 for desktop contamination survey  £650 for newspaper adverts  £500 for letters to surrounding residents  £250 for consultation boards / material  £7,500 for graphic design work and more detailed contamination evidence if needed  Total £24,640 inc 10% contingency
  • 17. Ambitions  Learning experience  Looking for transferable principles  Template format with standardised headings and text, so can be easily copied and re-applied to other brownfield and potentially green belt sites  Scope to be cheaper third alternative: 1) straight plan app = plan app fee 2) pre-app advice = pre-app fee + plan app fee 3) prepare LDO = joint work fee but free plan app
  • 18. Risks  LDO results in inappropriate development  Difficult for supporters/objectors to comment on all aspects of scheme if LDO enables flexibility  LDO contains loopholes that are exploited  LDO is incorrect or ineffective  LDO preparation is delayed  LDO is not seen as giving residents a voice  Viability appraisal concludes that scheme does not deliver sufficient returns