2. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
RECAP FROM LAST WEEK:
The nature of design and creativity is incompatible with
principles of generalism and specialism. Designers
have always crossed boundaries of discipline.
CONTEXT
3. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
CONTEXT
PETER BEHRENS
Clockwise: Portrait, AEG Ventilator (1908),, AEG Turbine Factory (1909), German Embassy in Saint Petersburg
(1912), AEG Corporate Identity (1907), AEG Kettle (1909), The Kiss (1898)
Architect, Industrial Designer, Graphic Designer, Painter
5. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
CONUNDRUM:
How do we describe graphic design within the framework
of disciplinarity? Is graphic design a :
A. Intra-disciplinary practice?
B. Inter-disciplinary practice?
C. Multi-disciplinary practice?
D. Trans-disciplinary practice?
But, wait, what???
DEFINITION
6. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
OUTLINE:
• Introduce disciplinarity [1] within and beyond graphic design practice.
• Define the production of knowledge within and beyond graphic design.
• How the changing creative landscape will shape the creation,
production and use of knowledge within and beyond graphic design.
1. Of or relating to a specific field of study and practice that is a “system of control in the
production of discourse” (Foucault, 1972, P.224)
OUTLINE
7. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
INTRA-DISCIPLINARY:
Process of working within a specific field of knowledge. Origins from the prefix
‘intra’ which means ‘on the inside; within’.
The Invisible Bicycle Helmet
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMAhptqk-4Q
Accessed:20/08/2014
DEFINITIONS
INTRA-DISCIPLINARY
INTER-DISCIPLINARY
MULTI-DISCIPLINARY
TRANS-DISCIPLINARY
DEFINITION
8. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
INTER-DISCIPLINARY:
Process of working between disciplines towards a single process or outcome that crosses
boundaries. Origins from the word ‘inter’ which means ‘between; among’.
Theo Jansen, BMW (South Africa) Redefining Innovation
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a7Ny5BYc-Fs
Accessed: 20/08/15
DEFINITIONS
INTRA-DISCIPLINARY
INTER-DISCIPLINARY
MULTI-DISCIPLINARY
TRANS-DISCIPLINARY
DEFINITION
9. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
MULTI-DISCIPLINARY:
Process of multiple disciplines working together, each drawing on existing knowledge to
produce independent solutions then coming together to produce an outcome.
Singapore Icons by Supermama and Edwin Low
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8tQQMbkBTs
Accessed:20/08/2014
DEFINITIONS
INTRA-DISCIPLINARY
INTER-DISCIPLINARY
MULTI-DISCIPLINARY
TRANS-DISCIPLINARY
DEFINITION
10. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
TRANS-DISCIPLINARY:
Process of different disciplines working together from beginning to create new knowledge
that integrates and moves beyond one single discipline to address a common problem.
DEFINITIONS
INTRA-DISCIPLINARY
INTER-DISCIPLINARY
MULTI-DISCIPLINARY
TRANS-DISCIPLINARY
Kinetic Sculpture, ART+COM, BMW Museum
Source: https://vimeo.com/8554267
Accessed:20/08/2014
DEFINITION
12. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
BEHIND KNOWN BOUNDARIES:
Pre-production Psychology
Gestalt/Semiotics
Primary + Secondary Research
Insights + Analysis
Image Making
Colour Theory
Compositional Form
Tactility (Haptic)
Interactivity
Storytelling
Experience
Rapid Prototyping
Production Print Production
Moving Image Production
Programming
Art Directing
General Client Relations
Public Relations/Marketing
Business management
DEFINITION
13. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
DESIGN IS EVERYTHING BUT DESIGN:
Graphic design is the most ubiquitous of all the arts. It responds to
needs at once personal and public, embraces concerns both
economic and ergonomic, and is informed by numerous disciplines
including art and architecture, philosophy and ethics, literature and
language, politics and performance. Graphic design is everywhere,
touching everything we do, everything we see, everything we buy…
Graphic design is a popular art, a practical art, an applied art and an
ancient art. Simply put, it is the art of visualising ideas.
Jessica Helfand, 2001, P.137
Screen - Essays on Graphic Design, New Media and Visual Culture
“
”
DEFINITION
14. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
John Maeda - Design is at once both intra-disciplinary and inter-disciplinary.
Source: https://twitter.com/johnmaeda/status/435752508334411776
Accessed: 20/08/2015
DEFINITION
15. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
DEFINING OUR PROFESSION:
Graphic design, also known as communication design, is the art and
practice of planning and projecting ideas and experiences with visual
and textual content. The form of the communication can be physical
or virtual, and may include images, words, or graphic forms. The
experience can take place in an instant or over a long period of time.
The work can happen at any scale… It can also be for any purpose,
whether commercial, educational, cultural, or political.
Juliette Cezzar
What is Graphic Design
Source: http://www.aiga.org/what-is-design/
Accessed: 22/08/2015
“
”
DEFINITION
16. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
WHAT DOES IT ALL MEAN:
Graphic design is flexible and adaptive enough to allow designers to work
within (intra and inter-disciplinary) and collaboratively with others (multi
and trans-disciplinary) to produce new and cutting edge work.
FUTURE
22. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
ON BOUNDARIES:
The boundaries between design disciplines, technology and the human
experience will converge into a single seamless experience. This will
require a trans-disciplinary approach to redefine existing and new
problems and scenarios.
BOUNDARIES
23. MULTIDISCIPLINARY
AND BOUNDARIES
BA2S1CCS4
CONCLUSION:
• Graphic design can be at once intra-disciplinary and inter-
disciplinary.
• Graphic design is malleable enough to allow for multi and trans-
disciplinary collaboration.
• The future will see a full convergence of technology, science and
design into one seamless experience.
• Generalists will be needed to navigate this convergence and
specialists to deliver.
BOUNDARIES
Editor's Notes
Recap from last week.
The nature of design is quite fluid and at times defies definition
and designers frequently experiment and operate outside their known disciplines and boundaries.
From other design disciplines to writing and curating.. what we looked at last week
Looked at Peter Behrens - architect, industrial and graphic designer and painter
Alan Fletcher - Ad man, illustrator, graphic designer and writer. How his works spans what we would call specialisms to a lesser extent than Peter Behrens.
Often we’ll see or hear terms like inter-disciplinary or multi-disciplinary etc, but what does it all mean?
Which leads to an eventual question of how do we define graphic design in the framework of disciplinarily?
Briefly describe disciplinarity
Digression to understand the various terminologies.
Instead of graphic design centric examples, we’ll review across the spectrum of design ecology.
A short description and example.
Two industrial designers collaborating to produce a new item.
Art with an engineer’s perspective - through understanding the principles and ideas of art and engineering to produce a single process or outcome.
Synthesis of graphic design, curation and ceramicists in Japan. Each drew on their expertise to work towards a singular outcome.
The synthesis of engineering, design, art, performance and storytelling into a singular piece.
From experience the piece would have included: Architects, industrial designers, graphic designers, engineers, programmers, fabricators and of course, the client.
contextualise graphic design based on existing understanding
existing notions: print, type, ad, interactive etc. the understanding is quite myopic
Exposition behind the known boundaries. Give examples:
1. Each element has specialists in their own right, but graphic designers need to know at least a little about each to inform their practice and how it affects their outcomes/decisions.
Graphic design is at once both intradisciplinary and interdisciplinary.
Examples: Typographers who solely work with type to publication or branding designers who work across several knowledge fields.
Planning and projecting ideas and experience requires us to be able to understand, empathise, study, communicate, synthesise and so forth to produce, shape or design content.
Hence graphic designers are in a well suited position to work in multi-disciplinary or even trans-disciplinary projects to produce cutting edge work.
And so what it can be is really up to you to determine. Will you want to pursue a intra/inter-disciplinary career or a multi/trans-disciplinary one?
We all know what typical intra/inter graphic design is like, but what about multi/trans disciplinary projects? 2 examples
Some of the new terms popping up in the creative landscape are experiential, immersive, service design etc. Here’s an example of how technology meets design to create immersive experiences.
Another example of experiential design
To contextualise graphic design, or design in the future, we have to understand what is happening. Several academics are now talking about how we are entering the third age of industrialisation.
And as we transition from a service economy to a knowledge economy, this will just be the beginning.
Several academics are now putting the idea across of the third industrial age. So how will this inform and shape graphic design?
One example of what the future entails - wearable technology.
While watching, try and notice where you spot graphic design. And while digesting this, also consider where graphic design may play a larger unseen role.
What does it all mean? Boundaries will start to blur and converge on a single point - the human experience. Technology will be seamless and play a critical role in the development of design.