7. A good essay takes a position,
supports that position with evidence,
anticipates and respects objections
or counterarguments and maintains
momentum throughout
anticipates and respects objections
or counterarguments
takes a position
supports that position with evidence
momentum throughout
maintains
8.
9. Introduction
Hooks the reader;
positions the topic within the wider
field; explains how YOU will be
answering the question (your
position and a road map); defines
any key terms.
11. Main body The main body is
where you build
your argument
using several
points
Point 1
Point 2
Point 3
Point 4
12. Conclusion
Q: Compare and contrast the
ability of hierarchical and flat
organisational structures to
reduce waste
Summarises the
essay and draws
conclusions to
address the
question
14. References
Complete
Everything you
have referred to
in the text
Correct
Formatted how
your subject
area needs it
Consistent
Even if it
consistently
wrong!
It is not included in the word count.
17. Break down the essay title
Download the key
instruction word glossary
Analyse the role of effective leadership in the
implementation of lean project management
“Instruction” word
18. Discuss the implications for organizational design
and management of shortening a product cycle.
Here is another example:
“Instruction” word
Download the key
instruction word glossary
21. Decide your position
You will mention this in your introduction and it will be a
crucial element of your conclusion
Spectrum of relevant debate
Author A Author C
YOU Another
Student
Author B
23. How many points will you need?
Example for a 2000 word essay
200 words = introduction
200 words = conclusion
1,600 words = main body paragraphs
1,600/200-300 = 6-8 main body paragraphs
= 6-8 substantial points in your essay
24. How many points should you have in a
3,500 word essay?
350 words = introduction
350 words = conclusion
2,800 words = main body paragraphs
2,800/200-300 = 9-14 main body paragraphs
= 9-14 substantial points in your essay
38. “You can always fix crap.
You can’t fix a
blank page.”
Christina Dodd
39. Your first draft
is about getting
your ideas on
paper – don’t
worry about the
English
Introduction
Point 1
Point 2
Point 3
Point 4
Conclusion
40. Main body
paragraphs
should use the
PEEL structure
(other similar acronyms exist)
Point one
Evidence
Explanation
Link
Point two
Evidence
Explanation
Link
Point three
Evidence
Explanation
Link
41. Paragraph should follow PEEL
structure
Point Introduce the point (make a claim)
Evidence Support the point with references
Explanation
How does the evidence support the point?
Why is the point itself relevant?
Link
Link back to the topic of the essay, forward
to your conclusion or onto the next
paragraph
42. Example (this is from Sociology)
Point One type of explanation for rising divorce has
focused on changes in laws relating to marriage.
Evidence
How laws relating to marriage have changed – give
information from Bilton et al. (1987); Conner &
Armitage (1998); Van der Pligt & De Vries (2007).
Explanation
Divorce is easier to obtain – less blame is now
attached.
Problem – doesn’t explain why laws change
Fundamental changes in society come first.
Link Examples of these changes will be considered next.
43. Using storytelling in educational settings can enable educators to connect with their
students because of inborn tendencies for humans to listen to stories. Written languages
have only existed for between 6,000 and 7,000 years before then, and continually ever
since in many cultures, important lessons for life were passed on using the oral tradition
of storytelling. These varied from simple informative tales, to help us learn how to find
food or avoid danger, to more magical and miraculous stories designed to help us see
how we can resolve conflict and find our place in society Oral storytelling traditions are
still fundamental to native American culture and Rebecca Bishop, a native American public
relations officer believes that the physical act of storytelling is a special thing because
children will automatically stop what they are doing and listen when a story is told.
Professional communicators report that this continues into adulthood. This means that
storytelling can be a powerful tool for connecting with students of all ages in a way that a
list of bullet points in a PowerPoint presentation cannot. The emotional connection and
innate, almost hardwired, need to listen when someone tells a story means that educators
can teach memorable lessons in a uniquely engaging manner that is common to all
cultures, as will be illustrated next.
44. Using storytelling in educational settings can enable educators to connect with their students
because of inborn tendencies for humans to listen to stories. Written languages have only
existed for between 6,000 and 7,000 years (Daniels & Bright, 1995) before then, and
continually ever since in many cultures, important lessons for life were passed on using the
oral tradition of storytelling. These varied from simple informative tales, to help us learn how
to find food or avoid danger, to more magical and miraculous stories designed to help us see
how we can resolve conflict and find our place in society (Zipes, 2012). Oral storytelling
traditions are still fundamental to native American culture and Rebecca Bishop, a native
American public relations officer (quoted in Sorensen, 2012) believes that the physical act of
storytelling is a special thing because children will automatically stop what they are doing and
listen when a story is told. Professional communicators report that this continues into
adulthood (Simmons, 2006; Stevenson, 2008). This means that storytelling can be a powerful
tool for connecting with students of all ages in a way that a list of bullet points in a PowerPoint
presentation cannot. The emotional connection and innate, almost hardwired, need to listen
when someone tells a story means that educators can teach memorable lessons in a uniquely
engaging manner that is common to all cultures, as will be illustrated next.
45. Remember that your introduction and
conclusion deserve a lot of attention too
Introduction
Point 1
Point 2
Point 3
Point 4
Conclusion
What
order you
write
them in is
a personal
choice
46. Recap: the introduction should…
Set the scene
(not too much)
Define terms
(if necessary)
Map your route
Destination
State your
destination
47. Recap: the conclusion should…
Restate your
position
Summarise your
points
Show how
your points
link
Destination
(we made it!)
Indicate the
wider
importance
48. Are there any questions about the initial
writing process?
49.
50. You can edit
your draft on
several levels:
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
Adapted from http://writingcenter.unc.edu/handouts/editing-and-proofreading/
51. Check your assignment
guidance – have you
covered everything?
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
52. Does the order of
your main
paragraphs make a
logical narrative?
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
53. Highlight the P-E-E-L
parts of each
paragraph to make
sure they are all
present
in a nutshell
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
54. Are you signposting
enough to help the
reader know where
your argument is
heading?
Moreover
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
55. Exercise is essential for maintaining health
Many exercise
activities involve
positive social
interaction
= Addition
Furthermore, many
exercise activities
involve positive
social interaction
56. Discount supermarkets offer better value for
consumers.
The big four
supermarkets offer a
greater selection of
products at a range
of price points.
Cause/effect? Comparison? Contrast? Addition? Examples?
Lidl has introduced
an in-store bakery
which undercuts both
high-street bakeries
and larger
supermarkets.
The big four are
taking steps to
further increase their
competitiveness.
However, the big four
supermarkets offer a
greater selection of
products at a range
of price points.
In the case of Lidl, the
new in-store bakeries
undercut both high-
street bakeries and
larger supermarkets.
Consequently, the big
four are taking steps
to further increase
their
competitiveness.
57. Linking words/Signposts
Cause/effect Comparison Contrast Addition Examples Conclusion Time
whenever likewise although/but also for example accordingly as soon as
as/as a result similarly alternatively and/and then for instance in brief at the same time
because equally besides/despite in addition in other words in short as long as
consequently as with however/yet moreover in effect in conclusion at length/at last
hence compared to nevertheless too in this case on the whole meanwhile
since equivalent to on the other
hand
further in particular to sum up secondly/once
so on the contrary furthermore specifically throughout first of all/first(ly)
thus whereas again such as in all finally/eventually
therefore while/whilst the following in the case of overall initially/next
accordingly in contrast what is more to show that in summary after(wards)
until otherwise as well as significantly to conclude subsequently
conversely henceforth
See also: http://www.qub.ac.uk/directorates/sgc/learning/FileStore/Filetoupload,628191,en.pdf
58. Is your writing in
academic style?
(Not colloquial or
flowery)
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
60. Be concise
Do not use lots of extra words that you
really do not need as they are not adding
anything to your argument and will only
be unnecessarily using up precious word
count.
61. Are all your sources
clearly referenced?
Are they all present
and formatted
correctly in the
reference list?
(Check them all!)
Content
Overall structure
Paragraph structure
Flow
Style
Citations and references
65. Proofreading is not reading
Normally we read for:
Content, to ascertain
the information the
text contains
When we proofread
we should:
Read for the medium
and not the message
66. Read Look through several times, checking
for different problems each time
Spelling
Sentence fragments
Sentence length
Apostrophes
Contractions
Comma splices
67. top proofreading tips:
Print your document
Read your text out loud
Don’t trust MS Word – but don’t ignore it
Separate text into different sentences
Don’t trust yourself – get another pair of eyes
Proof reading for common errors
5
68. If you struggle with things like grammar,
use our grammar resource
Link to all our
SkillsGuides
Link to Grammar
Resource
69. Finally…
When tutors set essays, they are not
interested in what you know…
…they are interested in how well you can
argue your point
Editor's Notes
First we must answer this basic question
At school, an essay may have been described as this first point – however at university it is more.
The second point shows the main difference – you need to defend a stance – i.e. tell the reader what your position is and why.
An essay never says “Write everything you know about x”. There will be a specific question to answer
Takes a position – already talked about that a little – there is no sitting on the fence in a good essay.
Supports with evidence – you MUST persuade the reader why your position is a valid one by providing reliable evidence to support it.
Anticipates and respects objections and counterarguments – you cannot ignore other possible positions. You must show that you have taken these into consideration when deciding on your own and explain why you have rejected them or revised your own in light of them.
Maintains momentum – the argument you are making throughout the essay should flow logically from point to point, you don’t want to be back-tracking too much or go off on side paths or you will lose the forward momentum that it needs. It needs a clear structure.
Most students are quite poor at writing introductions. They are often too short and don’t actually introduce the essay, just give background information.
So…
The important word here is BUILD. It is essential that the essay builds towards your conclusion – there should be a clear narrative (story) that leads you from paragraph to paragraph. It should not just be a random group of paragraphs about the topic in question. For longer essays, it may be subdivided into sections – we will look at this again in a moment.
Answer any question set in the title (if it is a pros and cons essay, you will need to say which argument is stronger).
Link back to introduction (show that you did what you said you would do)
Summarise the main points.
Give a sense of an ending and says why it is significant for the wider field that you started the introduction with.
In essence, it mirrors the introduction.
Every essay should end with a list of the references cited (as all academic writing should).
The key instruction words (‘do’ words) all have different meanings. Download a glossary to help you.
This is one that shows that it isn’t always easy to tell which is the key issue and which is the scope/constraint. The rule of thumb is that if you have had a lecture about it, or if your text book has a chapter on it, it’s probably the key issue. The other part is an aspect of it and so a constraint (maybe a few slides in a lecture or a sub-section in a book).
For any topic, there will be a spectrum of relevant debate with writers at various points along that spectrum. You need to decide where you stand – which author’s writing convinced you most? Does the work of another author pull you slightly in that direction? Another student could take a completely different position along the spectrum.
If we imagine the “essays” question, some authors may suggest essays are fantastic as they are the only way to show critical understanding of complex topics and the ability to argue eloquently and other authors may suggest that they are behind the times in our digital and visual world where employers are looking for more varied communication skills. You would have to way these up and come to your conclusion.
Sometimes you have do to a little maths…
Now you have decided on your position following your initial reading. You need to decide what points you need to make to convince your reader of that position.
There are various ways that you could go about this…
Come up with more than you need – then you can see if you can combine any or just choose the most convincing points (usually the ones you have most evidence to support).
This can help if you like to think more visually.
This is good if you want to be able to move things around easily – it’s very satisfying when you decide not to use one and you can crumple it up and throw it away too!
Now you have the points, you can find specific evidence to back them up. Remember your points CAME from your reading so you will already have some of it. If, in the course of your further reading you come across something that doesn’t fit – consider revising your plan or a counterargument that you can use to explain why you choose not to agree with it.
As you begin to write longer and longer essays, consider using something like RefWorks to help you manage and cite your sources.
This doesn’t need too much work – just write down the main point and then the evidence you have for that.
You don’t necessarily have to write it down, but as you are planning, think about how you are going to write the explanation to the reader. If you can’t think of a way – should you be making that point?
We don’t necessarily draft anymore in the same sense (we have wordprocessors that allow us to continuously edit) but the point is valid. Don’t expect the first version you write to be any good. It isn’t actually supposed to be. Writing is an iterative process that requires lots of editing.
This is self explanatory!
Just write
Exceptions may occur - for example when paragraphs are small and serve as transition paragraphs for emphasis
You may have done this at school – but it still holds true at university. The main difference is the amount of explanation (and evaluation within that). At school, this may be sentence but at university it could be half the paragraph.
First question is easy – where is the point of this paragraph? (tell me the first and last words of the sentence).
Next question, where is the evidence to support that point? I’ve made it harder by taking out the citations. (from where to where – again, tell me the first and last words
Where is the explanation? (Again, tell me the first and last words).
This doesn’t have a direct link as part of the paragraph – that actually came at the top of the next paragraph which went on to talk about the cross-cultural element of storytelling which links to the final sentence here.
Some people like to write a draft conclusion first – it is easier to plan a journey when you know where you are going
Some people like to write a full introduction with a road map before they start – like following written instructions.
Some people like to write their introduction at the end – so they can make it fit what they have already written.
It is all personal choice – try a few options and see what works for you.
Check these one at a time – note that it does not include spelling or punctuation
These are two consecutive points in a paragraph. A good writer will show how they are relate to each other using a signposting word. In this case, the second point is adding to the argument that exercise is a good thing (it is an addition). This can be made really clear by using a suitable signpost at the beginning of the next point; in this case, furthermore.
Now you have a go. How would does each of these points relate to the one at the top and what sort of word can we use to indicate the relationship?
(Hopefully) Some of these will be disputed – it goes to show the important of the signpost in helping your reader understand where you argument is going.
There are lots of words you can use!
Some students appear to think that academic writing must be complex with long words and long sentences. This is not true. Academic writing may cover some complex concepts and some of these may include uncommon terminology but that does not mean the sentences themselves need to be complex. Above all, the writing should be clear and the arguments easy to follow. Admittedly, a lot of the academic papers that you have to read at university do use long sentences but you do not have to emulate these. This is especially true if you are struggling with sentence structure – the longer the sentence, the easier it is to get the structure wrong.
It’s a good idea to sleep on an essay before your final proofreading.
Proofreading is a skill like any other you have to learn.
Content: we want to understand
Medium
We are not reading the essay for the content/understand we are looking at words to spot any errors.
.
Read our your text aloud, this might sound silly but it works. When you hear yourself reading any errors are automatically picked up.
Don’t trust MS Word – never, never trust the processor to spot the errors, it may pick out some but then it can blatantly miss others.
Don’t trust yourself
Our eyes often skim words, we only see part of the word, usually the beginnings and the endings, so we guess the rest by assumption from memory or context rather than by sight. This is one way we fail to spot any mistakes.
Work with a Friend
Try and work with another student/friend, get into the habit of checking each other’s work. Best if this is someone NOT on your course – they they will not be worried about understanding the content and will concentrate on the errors.
Grammar – be careful with grammar. There are lots of words that are commonly confused.