Hosting Online Journal Club Events on a Global Scale
1. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Hosting Online Journal
Club Events on a Global
Scale using Moodle: A
Report from the
ResearchIC Project
Dr. Jingjing Lin
Assistant professor, Center for
IT-based Education, Toyohashi
University of Technology
1
3. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Summary
• Budget and spending
• Technical aspects
• Event management using Moodle
• Project management using Moodle
• Research design and outputs
• Course on educational research literacy
Access Online Journal Club events on https://www.researchic.com 3
8. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Hosting
• HawkHost
• 1 GB of physical memory usage
• Unlimited MySQL and PostgreSQL disk space
and databases
• Database server: MariaDB
• Web server: PHP version 7.4.33
• phpMyAdmin 4.9.7
• Unlimited bandwidth
• Using Acronis backup software executes a 7-
day rolling snapshot of all files, emails, and
databases
• cPanel 106.0.13
Moodle
• Moodle version 4.0.2 (Build:
20220711)
• Moodle theme "Maker” (produced by
3rdwavemedia.com
8
08/13/2022 - 08/12/2024:
143.82 USD
Single App license: 269 USD
9. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Authentication
• OAuth 2 services login
• Google
• LinkedIn
• Facebook
• Email-based registration
Moodle plugins
• Course templates plugin
(https://moodle.org/plugins/localcourse
templates)
• BigBlueButton plugin
(https://moodle.org/plugins/mod_bigblu
ebuttonbn)
9
BlueSky project VPS: Osaka
Customization
• “Language customization” function
• The term of “course” -> the term of
“event”
10. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Chrome Extension 'Google
Scholar OJC Checker'
10
• Outsource the development to a
freelancer engineer
• Post job calls on upwork, codementor.io,
and fiverr.
• A developer from Sri Lanka was chosen to
do the job.
• Two-month development completed the
job and get the extension published on
Chrome Web Store.
11. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Chrome Extension 'Google Scholar OJC Checker'
11
This extension connects ResearchIC.com to Google Scholar, which will allow users to check if there is existing
Online Journal Club events on ResearchIC.com related to found academic publications on Google Scholar. It
also allows the user to create a new Online Journal Club event on ResearchIC, if there isn't a record.
13. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Event development
13
Host & Attend
Online Journal Club Events
For: researchers and research students
In: doing education-related research
To: demonstrate scholarly reading strategies
By: reading classic & influential journal articles
With: a global audience
100 OJC Events 2023
14. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
100 OJC Events
1. Create empty events
• Upload courses in bulk using CSV
file: Site administration –
Courses – Upload courses
• Format: kickstart
14
Access Online Journal Club events on https://www.researchic.com/courses
15. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
100 OJC Events (continued)
2. Create a standard event template
• Welcome to this OJC event
• Pre-test of ERLRT
• Researcher ScreenSharing: How to
read this paper?
• Researcher Talk: Sail with education
research literature
• Social reading and community
engagement
• Post-test of ERLRT
15
16. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
100 OJC Events (continued)
3. Backup and associate the event
template
• Backup the template event
• Associate the template to the plugin
• Courses -> Course templates -> Edit
template -> Select the created event
template (.mbz file)
16
23. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Researcher recruiting
Source Geography Research areas Invitation Acceptance rate
1 World Scientists on
Alper-Doger Scientific
Index
Worldwide Education Email 5/117
2 Conferences Worldwide Education Conference presentation 2/unknown
3 Personal network Worldwide Educational technologies LinkedIn, WeChat 4/unknown
4 Referrals Worldwide Educational technologies Invited by participating
researchers or acquittance
4/unknown
5 Manual collection from
university websites
China, Japan Educational technologies Work Email Ongoing/91
6 Manual collection from
Computers and
Education journal on
Scopus
Worldwide Educational technologies Mailchimp 1/1512
(453 opened, 60
clicked, 171 bounced)
23
24. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Access Online Journal Club events on https://www.researchic.com 24
1200+ site visitors, 67 registered users:
17 OJC Hosts, from 14 Universities, in 9 Nations & Regions
27. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Video creation
27
Video A:
to demonstrate through a video recording of their interaction
with the article's pages (a minimum of 15 minutes' video) and
show how they read and interpret the selected paper (classic or
highly cited journal articles).
Video B:
to explicitly explaining/discussing their reading strategies as
experienced readers of educational research literature in a
minimum of 15-minute short video. They used the video to
answer the questions:
What are your literature identification strategies?
What are your frequently used reading strategies?
How do you organize literature and knowledge as a
researcher?"
28. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Submissions of videos and files
• Cohort enrolment & Self
enrolment to the action guide
course
• Each researcher creates the two
videos independently and
uploads them to a Drive in the
cloud
• Each researcher pastes the links
to the video files in the
assignments
28
29. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Editing and publishing videos
• Download the videos from the Drive
• Import videos to Camtasia software for editing
• Export videos to local disk (1080px)
• Upload videos to YouTube channel of ResearchIC
• Embed videos into each event
29
31. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Team
• Lead: Dr. Jingjing Lin, Assistant Professor, Toyohashi University of Technology
• Volunteers:
• Ms. Cindy Liang, Learning designer, The University of Hong Kong
• Ms. Nikky Chu Ji, Master’s student in IT in Education, The University of Hong Kong
• Ms. Yidan Liu, Master’s student in IT in Education, The University of Hong Kong
31
34. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Development activities
• Development logs
34
This place lists development logs from the system.
• Done tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(done))
• Ongoing tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(ongoing))
• To-do tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks (to-
do))
• Canceled tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(canceled))
Please tag your log using the assignee tags:
• task-to-Jingjing
• task-to-Cindy
• task-to-Niki
• task-to-Yidan
35. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Development activities
• Development logs
35
This place lists development logs from the system.
• Done tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(done))
• Ongoing tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(ongoing))
• To-do tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks (to-
do))
• Canceled tasks (standard tag: ResearchIC Dev Tasks
(canceled))
Please tag your log using the assignee tags:
• task-to-Jingjing
• task-to-Cindy
• task-to-Niki
• task-to-Yidan
39. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Research papers
• Lin, J. & Gross Ophoff, J. (2023, ongoing). Commons and Differences between Disciplines in Research
Literacy Research: A Systematic Literature Review. Educational Research Review. Manuscript in progress.
• Lin, J. (2023). Use Online Journal Club Events to Train the Educational Research Literacy: Research and
Development at ResearchIC. Proceedings of annual conference of JSET 2023. March 25-26, 2022, Tokyo,
Japan.
• Lin, J. (2023, upcoming). Hosting Online Journal Club Events on a Global Scale using Moodle: A Report
from the ResearchIC Project. Proceedings of Moodle Moot Japan 2023. February 15-17, 2023, Ibaraki
Christian University, Japan
• Lin, J. (2022). Measuring and Evaluating Research Literacy in Higher Education: A Synthesis of
Mechanisms and Discoveries. Proceedings of The 14th Asian Conference on Education (2022). November
28–December 02, 2022, Toshi Center Hotel, Tokyo, Japan (and Online).
https://papers.iafor.org/submission65228/
• Lin, J. (2022). Impact of Online Journal Club On Educational Research Literacy: Introducing An Ongoing
Project. Proceedings of 2022 IEEE International Conference on Engineering, Technology & Education
(TALE). Dec.4-7, 2022. Hong Kong.
39
40. ResearchIC.com
Empower educational researchers
Access Online Journal Club events on https://www.researchic.com 40
Keynote:
• Lin, J. (2022). Use online journal club events for better
scholarly reading habits and skills: Research and development
at ResearchIC. Keynote in International Conference on
Intelligent Education and Intelligent Research (IEIR),
December 18-22, 2022, Wuhan city, China
Posters:
• Lin, J. (2022). Impact of Online Journal Club On Educational
Research Literacy: Introducing An Ongoing Project. Poster
published in Routledge Open Research.
• Lin, J. (2022). Impact of Online Journal Club On Educational
Research Literacy: Introducing An Ongoing Project. Poster
displayed in the 2022 IEEE International Conference on
Engineering, Technology & Education (TALE). Dec.4-7, 2022.
Hong Kong.
Keynote and posters
Since last month, 17 researchers have joined this initiative and are preparing to launch their online journal club events.
Sessions: 30 minutes as a given period when a user visits the website
Bounce rate: inverse of engagement rate, it is the % of sessions that were not engaged sessions. Average bounce rate: 26% - 70%
Session duration: a session ends after 30-minute user inactivity.
We can see a great overlapping between these two categorizations. The only difference is information literacy, now we know that in the research context, it is the ability to use resources such as electronic media and databases to locate and retrieve research articles. This is a particularly important literacy aspect in the research context for any researcher. Why?
There was also an attempt to propose three literacy aspects of educational research literacy by a group of German scholars, based on the four research processes. As you can see, although naming is different, the four aspects of information search, verbal, visual, and numeracy literacy can be also found here under the skin.
It is the process of reading and understanding verbal, numeracy and visual representation of research publications that truly fascinates me. I want to understand how scholarly reading can be executed effectively and efficiently, and how such a process can be externalized as shareable experience to benefit a greater audience who need such training. The division of literacy into verbal, numeracy, and visual literacy here is not out of vacuum.
For whose who are not familiar with journal club activities, let me give you a short introduction. In its traditional format, journal club involves a group of people who meet weekly or monthly to discuss current research in a topic relevant to their field. The purpose is to get updates from the most recent research. It is like reading newspaper together and discuss its implications in life.
The earliest references to a journal club was mentioned by Sir James Paget, a British surgeon, who describes a group at a local Hospital in London in the mid-19th century as "a kind of club ... where we sit in a room and read the journals.“ The first formalized journal club was created by Sir William Osler at McGill University in Montreal in 1875. The original purpose of Osler's journal club was because he could not afford certain journal subscription fees.
Young researchers need to be introduced to the right space, the right materials, the right tools, and the right procedure, in order to perform scholarly reading tasks and produce satisfying research thinking and outputs.
ResearchIC project organizes online journal club events as the learning space where senior researchers introduce high quality journal articles in the domain as materials, and their reading strategies as procedure. Students are given different tools such as discussion forum, database of user-generated commentary videos, multimedia editor, online meeting room, and twitter hashtag, which will help build student-centered journal club experience.
The project will develop a test called educational research literature reading test, abbreviated as ERLRT. The test will include a deck of mini-tests. Each OJC event will contain one deck of mini-test. When the students complete a certain number of OJC, they will be able to unlock the result of their ERLRT score. The ERLRT score also comes with an evaluation report, which reveals the current level of reading competency of the student, and offer suggestion for improvement. It acts as both a diagnosis and planning tool for students to become a better reader of educational research literature.
Next year, the research focus of this project is to continue doing literature review to support the development of ERLRT test, and to interview 100 educational researchers about their strategies in locating, reading, and organizing literature.
In 2024, a total of 100 online journal club events will be fully running with 100 educational researchers as their hosts. Global research students in education science will be invited to participate as attendees. The effect of these OJC events on attendees’ reading ability development will be evaluated by using the ERLRT tests.