SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
1
Unmanned Multirotor Applications with Renewable Energy
Systems for Variable Environments
Wayne Yandell1 and Joshua Danny2
Haskell Indian Nations University
Gabriel Brien3
Turtle Mountain Community College
Kirsch Davis4
Navajo Technical University
Jessica William5
Northwest Indian College
Fayetta Clawson6
Navajo Technical University
Nomenclature
APM = APM mission planner
CC = clockwise
CCW = counter-clockwise
FPV = first person view
kv = brushless motor revolutions per minute generated per volt
mA = milliamps
MV = multirotor
NART = Native American Research Team
REQS = Renewable Energy Quadrotor System
RotCFD = Rotor Computational Fluid Dynamics
rpm = revolutions per minute
UAV = unmanned aerial vehicle
I. Abstract
Applications of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) have typically been restricted to short term, limited range fly-
by missions. Fixed-wing UAVs tack the limits of mission range; however, these have less maneuverability and adaptability
than multirotor systems.These UAVs cannot monitor many types of systems because oflimited maneuverability and
necessity for recharging or refueling at a home base.Multirotor (MV) UAVs solve the maneuverability problem; however,
they have their own drawbacks of limited range and on-station time due to motors and equipment that rely upon batteries.
As a solution to meet these problems, data acquisition in difficult areas, and limited flight time, the Native American
Research Team (NART) has designed,simulated, and tested aspects ofa proof-of-concept MV model with integrated solar
and wind technology designated REQS or Renewable Energy Quadrotor System. Autonomous operations as well as human -
controlled operation are also key features of this concept for long term, long range missions with and without human
interaction.
1 Student, Mathematics, Haskell Indian Nations University
2 Student, Aerospace Engineering, Haskell Indian Nations University
3 Student, Civil Engineering, Turtle Mountain Community College
4 Student, Renewable Energy and Electrical Engineering, Navajo Technical University
5 Student, Information Technology,Northwest Indian College
6 Student, Industrial Engineering, Navajo Technical University
2
II. Mission
Design a functional unmanned aerial vehicle to perform extended, autonomous operations in a variety of
conditions and environments.
III. Mission Requirements
The specifications required by REQS fell into a series of systems and sub-systems.
Systems and Sub-system Requirements
Airframe
 Able to perform mission in wide-ranging precipitation, temperature, and wind environments
 Capable of landing in multiple environments
 Durable
 Compact, light, and easy to transport
 Cargo capacity of 10 pounds
 At least 100 square inches of storage/mounting space
Propulsion
 Extended flight and mission range
 Redundancy
 Reliability
Navigation and Control
 Autonomous flight capability
 Stable flight in hoverand directional flight
 Human control override capability at all distances and conditions during flight
 Capable of being controlled through on-board cameras
 Cruise speed of 10 mph
 Maximum speed of 15 mph
 Maneuverable
Renewable Energy
 Ability to find energy from sources that would not require human intervention
 Energy efficient
 Multiple energy sources
 Minimal recharge time
Data Acquisition
 Multiple sensors
 Multiple sensormounting areas
 Visual data acquisition capabilities
IV. Baseline Concept and Alternatives
A Renewable Energy Quadrotor System(REQS) design was chosen to test the feasibility of renewable energy
systems on unmanned multirotors to answer the problems in varying terrains and restrictive conditions.The REQS is a step
toward energy sustainable machines and an alternative approach to scientific exploration. This concept combines both
MV/UAV technology and renewable energy, which results in indefinite range for the vehicle and a variety of data
acquisition possibilities. The REQS will use an integrated systemof sustainable energy generators to prolong flight time by
charging the batteries while in flight and charging the batteries when landed and preparing for the next flight leg. The
appendices contain information about each piece of equipment selected.
3
Decision and Alternatives
To determine the best design for a variable environment vehicle which would meet the mission requirements,
comparisons between various type of aircraft and available systems were made.
Fixed-wing or rotary-wing?
The advantages offixed-wing aircraft over rotorcraft for renewable energy integration: Higher Fuel/energy
efficiency through lift from wings requiring only energy discharge for horizontal movement, higher forward velocity, able
to carry large payloads.
Advantages ofrotary-wing vehicles over fixed-wing: Low-energy vertical take-off and landing, efficient hover
capability, ability to change direction of flight in short time/space, handling capabilities in low airspeeds.
Rotary-wing, but what kind?
Helicopter: low number of motors leverages energy efficiency, auto-rotational capability for recovery, highest
stability in wind, lower vibration, lower cost,variable-pitch necessity requires mechanical complexity, lack of usable
surface area for renewable energy systems mounting, lower payload capacity.
Multirotor(MV): higher payload capacity, mechanical simplicity, extensible mounting area, more able to withstand
collisions, compact-able for transport,able to maneuver in tighter spaces.
For variable environments and renewable energy systems mounting, MVs make most functional sense.
Multirotor(MV) Options
Tricopters: least cost-prohibitive, simple construction,least stable,not as robust (tail servo and mechanics), low
lifting power and flight time (because the motors have to run faster to hold it all in the air). No engine out
capability. Low-medium surface area for mounting.
Quadcopters:mechanically simpler, nearly 1/3 more lift, more stable (no servo issues),longer flight time (they can
either lift larger batteries or fly more economically because the weight is spread across 4 motors and not just 3).
Still no engine out capability. Medium-large surface area for mounting.
Hexacopters: similar pros to quadcopters,plus more power and more lifting capability, limited engine out
capability, though larger and more cost-prohibitive. Medium-large surface area for mounting.
Octocopters and heavier: similar pros and cons to hexacopters, plus true engine out ability, es pecially large and
cost-prohibitive, high power consumption requiring large or multiple battery/fuel systems,large area for renewable energy
systemand instrumentation.
Decision: REQS, a Renewable Energy Quadrotor System
For the purpose of this mission and determining feasibility of future applications, a quadrotorsystemwas chosen
as containing the most dimension to perform according to the mission requirements and being least space-, complexity-, and
cost-prohibitive. From this finding, a choice of specific quadrotorframes was narrowed down to a stretched 'X-frame' or
and an 'X-frame'. An "H"-frame (Figure 1) configured quadcopterwould best fulfill mission requirements. Its large platform
offered ample space for an FPV system, for the electronics, the sensors,the wind turbines, and the solar panels.
4
Figure 1. REQS Concept Design without Solar Panels
The rotors in this configuration are arranged as opposite pairs. One pair of rotors rotate clockwise and the other pair rotat e
counterclockwise. This configuration (Figure 2) cancels torque when all rotors are revolving at the same speed.
Figure 2. MotorPosition and Propeller/Rotor Rotation
Pitch is achieved by adjusting the power of the front rotor pair relative to the rear pair. If the rear pair is rotating
faster than the front, the MV will pitch forward and vice versa. The MV will move in the direction of the negative pitch.
5
Yaw is achieved by having dissimilar rotation between diagonal rotor pairs. Roll is similarly achieved by dissimilar rotation
between the right rotor pair and the left rotor pair.
V. Proof of Concept Testing
The NART decided that constructing a proof of concept scaled model at 50%, would help us determine the overall
feasibility of a sustainable electric powered UAV quadcopter.The proof of concept design will have to be as light in weight
as possible, aerodynamic, energy efficient, self-sustaining, mechanically simple and highly maneuverable.
Airframe
With these design parameters, the “H” shaped frame quad copter design was chosen due to its high degree of
stability, and large instrument mounting platform area. NART built the “H” shaped frame out of ¾ inch thick wood planks
and 3/16” birch plywood to determine if we had adequate space to place all of our electronics. The frame model dimensions
are 24" X 36" with a top deck area of 144 square. The “H” shaped frame was stable and rigid enough for a proof-of-concept
test platform (Figure 3. "H" Frame with Loopwing Wind Turbines
).
Figure 3. "H" Frame with Loopwing Wind Turbines
Propulsion
The motors were, Cobra C-3525-18 Brushless, which have a relatively low power draw of 430 kv that would still
meet the lift standards.Rotors/propellers were Xoar 18x8 PJT Hollow Carbon Fiber Propellers which give increased lift by
being larger, having a greater pitch and slower rpm. Using these would further minimize the battery draw by reducing motor
revolutions.
Navigation and Control
Long range control of the craft was a functional requirement. Research indicated that a Long-range control requires
feedback from the REQS in order to track its position and otherflight data. The REQS proof-of-concept will utilize open
source autopilot technology to transmit telemetry data, receive GPS, and autonomously provide stable flight. A typical
autonomous flight using Mission Planner (APM) enables users to create waypoints and to command REQS to perform
certain actions such as holding altitude, loitering at a way point, auto-takeoff, and auto-landing. Other features of APM are:
 Point-and-click waypoint entry, using Google Maps.
 Select mission commands from drop-down menus
 Download mission log files and analyze them
 Interface with a PC flight simulator to create a full hardware-in-the-loop UAV simulator.
 See the output from APM's serial terminal
At any time during the mission a human pilot can take command and have REQS respond to orders from the pilot.
The NART elected to obtain visual data from REQS by integrating a 4G capable cell phone that would give video footage,
6
and would provide virtually unlimited range depending on cell tower relay. An Arducopter() utilizing the APM autopilot
Figure 4 was used for mission planning and flight testing.
Figure 4. APM Wiring Configuration
Renewable energy
The arms and the top platform will be equipped with solar cells to charge the on-board batteries. During the
landing phase while REQS is immobile, it will enter a charging state and prepare itself for flight once again. The battery th at
generated the highest power to weight ratio, and had the longest life was a Turnigy nano-tech 6000mah 4S 25~50C Lipo
Pack battery. To complete the sustainable cycle, and to give the quad the overall recharging ability a combination of both
solar panels and wind turbines was used.The solar panels were the very light 6.7 V 30 mA Micro Power! BEAM Solar
Battery Solar Panels. Efficient radiance of solar cells in a area 3.5"x10.6" operate at 7.2 volts and 100 mA. The total area of
cells (8) on the test model give an area of 28"x85" providing an output wired in parallel of 800 mA at a maximum state of
charge to the battery of 7.5 hours and weighing a 6.8g. Given the inefficiency of available solar panels relative to the
amount of sunlight they receive, multiple units had to be linked in order to generate maximum output.Additional power
sources were small loopwing wind turbines on top of the main platform. The loopwing was chosen for the design, because
the loopwing blades create no tip vortices. These wind generators were Loopwing Windpower kits, would generate power
effectively in relatively light winds. Furthermore, the turbines were only 6 inches high, and after some modification they
were able to be mounted to the frame. Integrating the wind turbine into the design changed REQS aerodynamic structure.
RotCFD is used in the rotorcraft industry as a design tool that can carry out aerodynamic simulations. Additional analysis
was done with RotCFD by running simulation for REQS in order to view the simulated flow dynamics for the wind turbine
placement. Of primary concern was potential flight degradation because of the loopwing rotor wash. RotCFD indicated that
the loopwing creates minimal wake vortices therefore not substantially impacting the flight motors lifting capabilities
(Figure 5. Velocity Vectors for REQS while at Hover
and Figure 6. Velocity Pressures for REQS during Forward Flight
)
7
Figure 5. Velocity Vectors for REQS while at Hover
Figure 6. Velocity Pressures for REQS during Forward Flight
Data Acquisition
Two Arduino sensor systems were built to mount on REQS, a temperature and a barometric pressure sensor (
Figure 7. Arduino Temperature Sensor Build
Furthermore, an off-the-shelf data logging instrument from T and D Corporation, the TR-74Ui fit the mission
requirements for measuring temperature, humidity, UV and irradiance (Figure 8).
8
Figure 8. TandD TR 74Ui Module
VI. Technical Challenges and Design Considerations
As the project progressed,the NART members began to understand the complexities involved. Each systemand
subsystemneeded to be analyzed in greater detail and a testing process needed to be developed for each. Questions for each
systemneed to be examined. Here are several.
Airframe
Durability
Protection from the elements
Reparability
Propulsion
Power consumption versus power generation
What if a motor fails?
Motor, battery, electric speed controller matching
Navigation and Control
Radio and video transmission and reception range verification for manual control
Obstacle avoidance
Aircraft avoidance
What if the GPS fails?
What if a motor fails?
Renewable energy
Power consumption versus power generated
Charging times
Data Acquisition
On-board storage versus data transmission
Sensor robustness
VII. Future Work
This research has determined the likely feasibility of renewable energy system implementation on small to medium
sized unmanned MVs. Some of the applications and future research possibilities inspired by this study are as follows.
9
A. Arctic Data Acquisition
With design customizations in the form of glacier or water based landing systemand a reinforced payload housing,
valuable and high demand scientific data can be acquired at a much lower cost than limited human based expeditions and at
much greater depth than current fixed-wing UAV options especially in spring to early summer months where solar
irradiance is at its highest and the days are almost literally without end, allowing for quick recharge times and more
missions per day. Instrumentation can be attached to specialized REQS(Renewable Energy Quadrotor System) for land and
air data acquisition to monitor and model thawing permafrost and resulting carbon releases as well as glacial ice
deterioration. Also, with sampling capabilities and integrated photo-acoustic sensors,a REQS could gather data over large
areas of the arctic for modeling concentrations and effects of black carbon in arctic ecosystems and their global
implications. Due to their implied design maneuverability, FPV(First Person View) options,and ability to recharge for
multiple missions from wind(with scaled loopwing customized for frozen particle winds) and/orsolar energy, REQS can
also be utilized to map deep and complex underwater rock formations allowing for determination of arctic oil reserves,
collect baseline data, and assist in the mapping of coastal and near shore environments, as well as collecting terrestrial
imagery and elevation data. Infrared sensors could be outfitted on the REQS to track behaviors of elements in arctic
ecosystems.
B. Planetary Surface Exploration
The varying and inhibitive topographies of planetary surfaces present an array of challenges to any land -based data
acquisition systemwhich can be mechanically complex or in certain cases implausible to overcome. A low altitude
multirotor systemlike a REQS could be customized—such as components designed for specific thermal and pressure
ranges,proprietary energy storage,wind turbines with self-stalling and dust combative components for various particle
laden winds such as on Mars—and utilized to navigate at low altitudes and collect data above or on the surface over large
distances of variable environments with its “hop-charge/collect-hop” capability. Similarly, with varying air densities,
gravity, and solar irradiance, the integration of wind and solar charging makes a REQS much more adaptable for both
surface and subterranean exploration especially with multiple energy storage systems and implementation of adv anced wind
and solar technology. A REQS equipped with variable-pitch actuators and propellers could operate underhigh duress and
with formidable maneuverability in high velocity winds as well as utilize autorotation in original landing and in the event o f
motor failure or energy disruption in flight. Recently developed optical sensors and autonomous flight control systems such
as those tested on both a small-scale RC helicopter and an auto-piloted UH-60 Blackhawk including obstacle mapping and
evasion and safe landing area determination would allow programming of long term autonomous navigation and data
acquisition missions for virtually any kind of surface where rotorcraft can fly with surface-specific landing gear.
C. Agricultural Monitoring and Response
A REQS could serve as an all-in-one agricultural monitoring system. With set mission parameters, the REQS
could be implemented to fly scheduled autonomous missions with instrumentation to detect healthy growth, solar irradiance,
moisture, anhydrous ammonia, carbon dioxide, etc. and even be outfitted with a nutrient delivery system. With only off-
the-shelf components including battery and free mission planner, a REQS could be scheduled to run two to six missions per
day over 6 km each while recording and transmitting data between land recharges, requiring little to no interaction from an
operator within the lifespan of the battery for months of completely autonomous monitoring and support of crops.
Similarly, a REQS could be instrumented to autonomously monitor behavior or health of livestock at a similar or higher
frequency of fly-by data collection missions.
D. Disaster Response
With the low noise and maneuverability of small multirotors, a REQS could provide quick data support to
emergency responders on the ground at varying altitudes. Typical data acquisition by manned helicopters is loud as well as
disruptive to the ground and altitude limits restrict collection of some data which are all mitigated by the utility of a sin gle,
small instrumented REQS or a team of coordinated REQS providing data urgently for the greatest aptitude of life
preservation. Hazard-resistant REQSs could be deployed rapidly on arrival with gps and remote telemetry with obstacle
evasion to perform hovering or translational flight maneuvers in rural or urban environments to collect precise data in or
around hurricane or tornado disasterzones or virtually any event from fires to firefights with proprietary solar and wind
technology,multiple/capacious batteries, or fuel cells requiring little recharge time between missions at a cost much lower
than requisition of manned helicopters or commercial UAVs.
10
E. Short Range Delivery
A weather resistant REQS could prove to be a valuable asset for both public and commercial local delivery . With large
propellers and low KV motors as well as basic GPS way-point navigation and a servo release or mounting system, a REQS
could carry a rather large payload to a destination and return or make multiple low-mid weight deliveries on a single charge
before recharging for the next flight. Lower altitude navigation may require the use of obstacle detection/evasion and for
complete autonomy, a landing zone detection system.This would be most effective with a “team” of off-the-shelf
constructed REQSs which would be much quicker and cost-effective than delivery by automobile by person for various
products. This kind of delivery could also gather data geographical market penetration or automated marketing solutions
such as leaving brochures in a novel and inexpensive way. Additionally, a REQS could be instrumented with modem-router
configurations to act as a ground,roof, or even air based hotspot,delivering connectivity to devices in range or acting as
part of a daisy-chain network replacing implausibility of permanent equipment mounting or providing greater portability
and maintenance access than a permanently mounted systemoften requiring medium- to high-risk, i.e. cost-prohibitive
maintenance solutions which are power- and attention-intensive.
VIII. Concluding Remarks
To meet the demands of scientific and public communities, the NASA Ames Native American Research Team has
designed a proof-of-concept model of an unmanned multirotor with integrated renewable energy systems. This
advancement allows for further research in environments of varying hazards and terrains. The simulations and proof-of-
concept have determined that it is feasible to implement renewable energy systems on scalable multirotor systems to
achieve greater distances and extensible mission parameters than current UAVconfigurations. With increased longevity of
flight and mission distance through its “hop-charge/collect-hop” paradigm, REQS could be implemented to collect data or
deliver resources for human-inhibitive environments or as supplements to human gathered intelligence. Further research
into lightweight and efficient renewable energy systems positioned outside the vortexes of the propellers, as well as
frame/design, would allow for additional broad-reaching applications and eventuality of completely sustainable unmanned
aerial labs. These would have particular benefits in environmental research, aerospace exploration, and even day -to-day
public life.
IX. Acknowledgments
The Native American Research team would like to extend big thank you to all of our mentors, NASA Ames
Research Center, our fellow interns, and all those who helped make this project possible. There are so many people to
thank and acknowledge for their role in making this project come togetherand the experience enjoyable.
Without the guidance and jovial care of Dr. Bill Warmbrodt, Chief of the NASA Ames Aeromechanics Branch,
this project would have been impossible. Not just in the sense that without his approval and agreement to offer all of the
aeromechanics branch interns to have a place, subject, and opportunities to study and enjoy, but that his personal attention
and good nature inspired us to do our best.
Gary Brandt, our team mentor and esteemed educatorat Northwest Indian College, represented and supported u s in
ways no one else could have. His positive attitude,expertise, and consideration for modern indigenous strengths and
struggles gave NART its back-bone and kept us showing up each morning though we were often anxious and self-effacing.
Wheneverwe got into trouble or pulled something off that seemed almost expertly, Gary’s genius, kindness,and grin were
present.
Larry Young, an engineer of NASA Ames Aeromechanics Branch, gave us gentle advice and pushed us to be
creative in our research endeavors. Every week he met with us and shared his work as well as good will and the
fundamentals of being an engineer. His meetings and notes shared with NART what life is like as an engineer at NASA: the
privileges, excitement, and realities, and how to be good at it.
To share our journey and provide numerous angles of assistance and concepts,Needa Lin, a Mechanical
Engineering student from UC Davis and an experienced Aeromechanics intern, was with us the whole way. Though she
already maintained a heavy workload of summer schooland projects of her own, Needa took time out of her long days to
push and prod our designs,offer solutions and new ways of thinking, and learn new renewable energy and aerodynamic
concepts alongside us.
Similarly, Sumeet Singh, Willie Costa, and Natalia Larrea Brito shared their aerodynamic insights and research
with us, giving us just what we need to keep moving forward with our designs and the possibilities.
11
Acknowledgments and thanks to Kurt Long and the gang at the Fluid Mechanics Lab including but not limited to
Hannah Spooner, Katrina Hui, and Mike Harrington for their hospitality, attitudes,and support of our experiments in NASA
Ames Fluid Mechanics Lab.
As current undergraduate students we would like to thank staff at our respective universities for their help and
encouragement: Dr. Dan Wildcat and Lucas Miller with Haskell Indian Nations University, Dr. Jim Davis and Audrey
Lavallie with Turtle Mountain Community College, Heather Yazzie Kinalchini and Dr. Casmir Agbaraji with Navajo
Technical College, and Nathanael Davis with Northwest Indian College.
Finally, it has been our honorto participate in the Tribal College Undergraduate Program as members of the Native
American Research Team. Our gratitude and esteemgo out to Alex Grandon and supporting members of the American
Indian Higher Education Consortium which granted us support and allowed us the opportunity to research at NASA Ames
Research Center.
Works cited
Careaga, Andrew. “New method for connecting solar panels may increase efficiency.” Missouri S&T News &
Events. Web. Jul 26, 2013.
DIY DRONES. “DIY Drones The Leading Community for Personal UAVs.” DIY Drones. n.d. Web. 28 Jul 2013.
Engi-nerd-extraordinaire. “Quad rotor Propulsion System.” Engi-nerd extraordinaire. n.d. Web. 28 Jul 2013
Hoffman, G.; Huang, H., Waslander,S.L., Tomlin, C.J. (20–23 August 2007). "Quadrotor Helicopter Flight
Dynamics and Control: Theory and Experiment". In the Conference of the American Institute of Aeronautics and
Astronautics.Hilton Head, South Carolina.
Jethro Hazelhurst. “Typical Quadcopter Layout.” ArducopterImage. Arducopter, connecting you RC input and
motors. 28 Jul. 2013.
Pounds,P.; Mahony,R., Corke, P. (December 2006). "Modelling and Control of a Quad-Rotor Robot".In the
Proceedingsof the Australasian Conference on Robotics and Automation.Auckland, New Zealand.
Powerfilm Solar. “Thin, Flexible Solar Panels Keeping the power of Film/RC7/2-75 PSA.” n.d. Web.27 Jul. 2013.
Rotorcraft Flying Handbook. U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Flights
Standards Service. 2000 Print.
12
Appendix I. Autopilot
The ArduPilot Mega 2.5 is a complete open source autopilot systemand the bestselling technology that won the
prestigious 2012 Outback Challenge UAV competition. It allows the userto turn any fixed, rotary wing or multirotor
vehicle (even cars and boats)into a fully autonomous vehicle; capable of performing programmed GPS missions with
waypoints. Available with top or side connectors.
Please note that this listing is for the APM with on board compass,thus compatible with the Mediatek GPS only
(also compatible with the previous version of the 3DR GPS uBlox LEA-6 without compass).
Features
Arduino Compatible!
Can be ordered with top entry pins for attaching connectors vertically, or as side entry pins to slide your connectors
in to either end horizontally
Includes 3-axis gyro, accelerometer and magnetometer, along with a high-performance barometer
Onboard 4 MegaByte Dataflash chip for automatic datalogging
Digital compass powered by Honeywell's HMC5883L-TR chip, now included on the main board.
Optional off-board GPS, Mediatek MT3329 or uBlox LEA-6H module. Mediatek module included in base price;
choose otheroptions at right (subtract $20 for no GPS or add $50 for the better uBlox module)
One of the first open source autopilot systems to use Invensense's 6DoF Accelerometer/Gyro MPU-6000.
Barometric pressure sensorupgraded to MS5611-01BA03, from Measurement Specialties.
Atmel's ATMEGA2560 and ATMEGA32U-2 chips for processing and usb functions respectively.
13
Appendix II. Battery
Battery
More than just a fancy name. TURNIGY nano-tech lithium polymer batteries are built with an LiCo nano-
technology substrate complex greatly improving power transfer making the oxidation/reduction reaction more
efficient, this helps electrons pass more freely from anode to cathode with less internal impedance.
In short; less voltage sag and a higher discharge rate than a similar density lithium polymer (non nano-
tech) battery.For those that love graphs, it means a straighter, longer curve. For pilots it spells stronge r throttle
punches and unreal straight-up performance. Excellent news for 3D pilots!
Unfortunately with other big brands; numbers, ratings and graphs can be fudged. Rest assured,TURNIGY nano-
techs are the real deal, delivering unparalleled performance!
Spec.
Capacity: 6000mAh
Voltage: 4S1P / 4 Cell / 14.8V
Discharge: 25C Constant / 50C Burst
Weight: 623g (including wire, plug & case)
Dimensions: 175x49x38mm
Balance Plug: JST-XH
Discharge Plug: 4mm bullet-connector
14
Appendix III. Camera
Camera – Droid Incredible 4g lite
Product Information
A powerful 1.2 GHz dual-core processormakes the HTC Droid Incredible 4G LTE smartphone adept at crunching
through graphically intensive games. Operating on Android 4.0 OS, this HTC cell phone supports a wide range of
applications. Thanks to the 4-inch capacitive multi-touch display of this smartphone, you can easily navigate your way
through its highly versatile options or enjoy your favorite game to the fullest. This HTC cell phone�s 8 MP camera lets you
capture yourmemorable moments on the spur. Be it staying in the loop with push email or chatting with friends on
WhatsApp and Facebook, the HTC Droid Incredible 4G LTE has it all.
Product Identifiers
Brand HTC
MPN ADR6410L
Carrier Verizon
Model Droid Incredible 4G LTE
UPC 044476822124
Type Smartphone
Key Features
Storage Capacity 8 GB
Color Black
Network Generation 4G
Network Technology LTE
Camera 8.0 MP
Memory
Supported Flash Memory Cards MicroSD, MicroSDHC
Battery
Battery Capacity 1700 mAh
Display
Display Technology HD Super AMOLED
Diagonal Screen Size 4 in.
Other Features
Touch Screen Yes
Bluetooth Yes
Digital Camera Yes
GPS Yes
Email Access Yes
Internet Browser Yes
Speakerphone Yes
15
Appendix IV. Electronic Speed Controller (ESC)
I. Cobra 33 Amp Speed Controller Specifications:
 Weight (With Output Connectors) ................. 37.1 grams (1.31 oz)
 Max Continuous Current ............................................... 33 Amps
 Burst Current rating (15s) ............................................. 41 Amps
 Operating Voltage Range ......................................... 6 to 17 Volts
 Number of Li-Po cells ................................................. 2 to 4 cells
 Number of Ni-XX cells .............................................. 6 to 12 cells
 Number of Li-Fe cells ................................................. 2 to 4 cells
 BEC Output .................................................. 3 amps @ 5.5 Volts
 ESC Size (inc. Caps) ........ 56 x 25 x 10mm (2.20 x 0.98 x 0.39 in)
16
Appendix V. Propeller/Rotor
GemFan Paddle Style Propeller
These carbon fiber DJI S800 style props have a 3-hole hub configuration to fit on the DJI S800 or any of the
RcTiger MN series motors.
Come as a pair, one right and one left rotation.
As with any propeller for your UAV these propellers should be balanced to reduce vibration, balancing will
improve flight characteristics, motor performance, provide clearer, cleaner photo and video results.
These Propellers have a low pitch, paddle style configuration to improve efficiency.
Weight: 24 grams
17
Appendix VI. GPS
u-blox 6 GPS, QZSS, GLONASS and Galileo modules
LEA-6 modules bring the high performance u-blox 6 position engine to the industry standard
LEA form factor. u-blox 6 has been designed for low power consumption and low costs, independent of
which satellite constellation is used (e.g. GLONASS, Galileo). Intelligent power management is a
breakthrough for low-power applications. The versatile, standalone LEA-6 receivers combine an
extensive array of features with flexible connectivity options. Their ease of integration results in fast
time-to-market for a wide range of automotive and industrial applications.
LEA-6 modules work with all available satellite positioning systems:LEA-6H is ready to
support theEuropean Galileo systemvia a simple firmware upgrade; LEA-6N combines full feature GPS performance with the QZSS
regional satellite system. LEA-6N also targets the Russian market, featuring thelowest power GLONASS functionality in theindustry,
and is designed for ERA-GLONASS.
18
Appendix VII.Solar Cell
This unit is equipped with a Pressure Sensitive Adhesive or (PSA) backing. Simply expose the adhesive layer, by
removing the protective film on the backside, and firmly place this solar cell on the wing or fuselage of your airplane.
 Voltage 7.20V
 Current 100mA (0.10A)
 Voltage (oc) 10.5V
 Current (sc) 120mA (0.12A)
 Thickness 0.2"
 Total Size 3.5 x 10.6"
 Aperture Size 3.0 x 9.5"
 Weight 0.3 oz
19
Appendix VIII. Telemetry
The RFD900 is a high performance 900MHz, ISM band radio modem covering the 902 - 928 MHz frequency
band. It is designed for long range serial communications applications requiring best in class radio link performance
Key features:
Long range >40km depending on antennas and GCS setup
2 x RP-SMA RF connectors, diversity switched.
1 Watt (+30dBm) transmit power.
Transmit low pass filter.
> 20dB Low noise amplifier.
RX SAW filter.
Passive front end band pass filter.
Open source firmware / tools, field upgradeable, easy to configure.
Small, light weight.
Compatible with 3DR / Hope-RF radio modules.
License free use in Australia, Canada, USA, NZ.
Specifications:
Frequency Range: 902 - 928 MHz (USA) / 915 - 928 MHz (Australia)
Output Power:1W (+30dBm)
Receive Sensitivity:>121 dBm at low data rates, high data rates (TBA)
Size: 30 mm (wide) x 57 mm (long) x 12.8 mm (thick) - Including RF Shield, Heatsink and connector extremeties
Weight: 14.5g
Mounting: 3 x M2.5 screws, 3 x header pin solder points
Power Supply:+5 V nominal, (+3.5 V min, +5.5 V max), ~800 mA peak at maximum power
Temp. Range: -40 to +85 deg C
20
Appendix IX. Brushless Motors
TIGER MOTOR MN4010-11 475KVNAVIGATOR SERIES
The Tiger T-Motor MN-4010-11 475kv multi rotor motor is a powerful motor specifically
designed for multi-rotors. All MN/MT Motors come with prop adapters included.
21
Appendix X. Loopwing Wind Turbine
The perfect kit to learn some basic engineering principals while having eco fun! The windmill features a loop-wing
design that can be rotated by the slightest breeze.
Loopwing Wind Turbine achieves high safety, low noise and low vibration.
The Kit comes with everything includes motor, mini charge car, wind turbine and English manual.
After assemble size: 9 inches x 9 inches x 10 inches

More Related Content

What's hot

Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626
Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626 Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626
Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626 Nelson Garcia-Polanco
 
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo Transport
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo TransportMajor Tom: Lunar Cargo Transport
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo Transportpenegor
 
Hyperloop VTU Seminar Report
Hyperloop VTU Seminar ReportHyperloop VTU Seminar Report
Hyperloop VTU Seminar ReportUmar Ahmed
 
Vactrain an insight into Hyperloop
Vactrain an  insight into HyperloopVactrain an  insight into Hyperloop
Vactrain an insight into HyperloopAvin Ganapathi
 
The hyperloop by rishabh mishra
The hyperloop by rishabh mishraThe hyperloop by rishabh mishra
The hyperloop by rishabh mishraRishabh Mishra
 
floating.windmill.x
floating.windmill.xfloating.windmill.x
floating.windmill.xChan-Hee Koh
 
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya Karhade
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya KarhadeHyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya Karhade
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya KarhadeAishwarya Karhade
 
Vsf ppt on solar impulse v5
Vsf ppt on solar impulse  v5Vsf ppt on solar impulse  v5
Vsf ppt on solar impulse v5Dr. BP Joshi
 
WFO_SDM_2012_Souma
WFO_SDM_2012_SoumaWFO_SDM_2012_Souma
WFO_SDM_2012_SoumaMDO_Lab
 
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion EnergyTech2015
 
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineering
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineeringUnmanned aerial vehicle- system engineering
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineeringOmkar Rane
 
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation System
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation SystemA Review on Hyperloop Transportation System
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation Systemijtsrd
 

What's hot (20)

Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626
Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626 Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626
Aerodynamic Design of a Micro Air Vehicle SAE 2011 01-2626
 
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo Transport
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo TransportMajor Tom: Lunar Cargo Transport
Major Tom: Lunar Cargo Transport
 
Sanchit
SanchitSanchit
Sanchit
 
Hyperloop VTU Seminar Report
Hyperloop VTU Seminar ReportHyperloop VTU Seminar Report
Hyperloop VTU Seminar Report
 
Hyperloop new
Hyperloop new Hyperloop new
Hyperloop new
 
Hyperloop
HyperloopHyperloop
Hyperloop
 
Vactrain an insight into Hyperloop
Vactrain an  insight into HyperloopVactrain an  insight into Hyperloop
Vactrain an insight into Hyperloop
 
The hyperloop by rishabh mishra
The hyperloop by rishabh mishraThe hyperloop by rishabh mishra
The hyperloop by rishabh mishra
 
Hypersonic aircraft ppt
Hypersonic aircraft pptHypersonic aircraft ppt
Hypersonic aircraft ppt
 
floating.windmill.x
floating.windmill.xfloating.windmill.x
floating.windmill.x
 
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya Karhade
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya KarhadeHyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya Karhade
Hyperloop new transportation system seminar report- Aishwarya Karhade
 
Vsf ppt on solar impulse v5
Vsf ppt on solar impulse  v5Vsf ppt on solar impulse  v5
Vsf ppt on solar impulse v5
 
WFO_SDM_2012_Souma
WFO_SDM_2012_SoumaWFO_SDM_2012_Souma
WFO_SDM_2012_Souma
 
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion
Neil Garrigan: Electric Drive Technology Considerations for Aircraft Propulsion
 
Hyperloop
HyperloopHyperloop
Hyperloop
 
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineering
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineeringUnmanned aerial vehicle- system engineering
Unmanned aerial vehicle- system engineering
 
Hyperloop
HyperloopHyperloop
Hyperloop
 
Quadcopter
QuadcopterQuadcopter
Quadcopter
 
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation System
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation SystemA Review on Hyperloop Transportation System
A Review on Hyperloop Transportation System
 
Quadcopter Technology
Quadcopter TechnologyQuadcopter Technology
Quadcopter Technology
 

Similar to 2013 NART Group Paper

NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1
NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1
NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1Faye Clawson
 
The fight characteristics of UAVs
The fight characteristics of UAVsThe fight characteristics of UAVs
The fight characteristics of UAVsLeonid Sopizhenko
 
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite model
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite modelFEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite model
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite modelDhaval Chauhan
 
Airborne Wind Energy System
Airborne Wind Energy SystemAirborne Wind Energy System
Airborne Wind Energy SystemIRJET Journal
 
Dissertation Final Version
Dissertation Final VersionDissertation Final Version
Dissertation Final VersionSamual Knight
 
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applications
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applicationsUltra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applications
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applicationsLiviu Giurca
 
equivalent ciruit nano.pdf
equivalent ciruit nano.pdfequivalent ciruit nano.pdf
equivalent ciruit nano.pdfYosraBOUCHOUCHA2
 
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)LASER AIAA PAPER (1)
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)Austin Gerber
 
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching System
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching SystemElectro Magnetic Aircraft Launching System
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching SystemPremKumar2000
 
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021KennyPham19
 
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robot
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robotModelling and control of a quad rotor robot
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robotPrasanna Ramamurthy
 
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research Paper
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research PaperDesign,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research Paper
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research PaperHashim Hasnain Hadi
 
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)Air borne wind energy system (AWES)
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)Ankit Panghal
 
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_Maldonado
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_MaldonadoNASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_Maldonado
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_MaldonadoVictor Maldonado
 
HAAPS Technology
HAAPS TechnologyHAAPS Technology
HAAPS Technologysmart488
 
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wing
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wingExperimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wing
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wingeSAT Journals
 

Similar to 2013 NART Group Paper (20)

NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1
NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1
NART FINAL group poster Slide Presentation-1
 
The fight characteristics of UAVs
The fight characteristics of UAVsThe fight characteristics of UAVs
The fight characteristics of UAVs
 
RECU_SCITECH
RECU_SCITECHRECU_SCITECH
RECU_SCITECH
 
NART GROUP POSTER
NART GROUP POSTERNART GROUP POSTER
NART GROUP POSTER
 
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite model
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite modelFEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite model
FEA-CFD Optimization of various turbine blades in Electrifying kite model
 
Airborne Wind Energy System
Airborne Wind Energy SystemAirborne Wind Energy System
Airborne Wind Energy System
 
Dissertation Final Version
Dissertation Final VersionDissertation Final Version
Dissertation Final Version
 
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applications
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applicationsUltra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applications
Ultra-compact VTOL aircraft- UVA for civil and military applications
 
equivalent ciruit nano.pdf
equivalent ciruit nano.pdfequivalent ciruit nano.pdf
equivalent ciruit nano.pdf
 
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)LASER AIAA PAPER (1)
LASER AIAA PAPER (1)
 
j.ijhydene.2017.01.137.pdf
j.ijhydene.2017.01.137.pdfj.ijhydene.2017.01.137.pdf
j.ijhydene.2017.01.137.pdf
 
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching System
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching SystemElectro Magnetic Aircraft Launching System
Electro Magnetic Aircraft Launching System
 
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021
Triton UAS Technical Design Paper 2020-2021
 
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robot
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robotModelling and control of a quad rotor robot
Modelling and control of a quad rotor robot
 
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research Paper
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research PaperDesign,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research Paper
Design,Fabrication & Analysis of a Quardcopter___Research Paper
 
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)Air borne wind energy system (AWES)
Air borne wind energy system (AWES)
 
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_Maldonado
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_MaldonadoNASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_Maldonado
NASA_Medevac_ Report-2016_Maldonado
 
HAAPS Technology
HAAPS TechnologyHAAPS Technology
HAAPS Technology
 
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wing
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wingExperimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wing
Experimental study of magnus effect over an aircraft wing
 
UPATcopter
UPATcopterUPATcopter
UPATcopter
 

2013 NART Group Paper

  • 1. 1 Unmanned Multirotor Applications with Renewable Energy Systems for Variable Environments Wayne Yandell1 and Joshua Danny2 Haskell Indian Nations University Gabriel Brien3 Turtle Mountain Community College Kirsch Davis4 Navajo Technical University Jessica William5 Northwest Indian College Fayetta Clawson6 Navajo Technical University Nomenclature APM = APM mission planner CC = clockwise CCW = counter-clockwise FPV = first person view kv = brushless motor revolutions per minute generated per volt mA = milliamps MV = multirotor NART = Native American Research Team REQS = Renewable Energy Quadrotor System RotCFD = Rotor Computational Fluid Dynamics rpm = revolutions per minute UAV = unmanned aerial vehicle I. Abstract Applications of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) have typically been restricted to short term, limited range fly- by missions. Fixed-wing UAVs tack the limits of mission range; however, these have less maneuverability and adaptability than multirotor systems.These UAVs cannot monitor many types of systems because oflimited maneuverability and necessity for recharging or refueling at a home base.Multirotor (MV) UAVs solve the maneuverability problem; however, they have their own drawbacks of limited range and on-station time due to motors and equipment that rely upon batteries. As a solution to meet these problems, data acquisition in difficult areas, and limited flight time, the Native American Research Team (NART) has designed,simulated, and tested aspects ofa proof-of-concept MV model with integrated solar and wind technology designated REQS or Renewable Energy Quadrotor System. Autonomous operations as well as human - controlled operation are also key features of this concept for long term, long range missions with and without human interaction. 1 Student, Mathematics, Haskell Indian Nations University 2 Student, Aerospace Engineering, Haskell Indian Nations University 3 Student, Civil Engineering, Turtle Mountain Community College 4 Student, Renewable Energy and Electrical Engineering, Navajo Technical University 5 Student, Information Technology,Northwest Indian College 6 Student, Industrial Engineering, Navajo Technical University
  • 2. 2 II. Mission Design a functional unmanned aerial vehicle to perform extended, autonomous operations in a variety of conditions and environments. III. Mission Requirements The specifications required by REQS fell into a series of systems and sub-systems. Systems and Sub-system Requirements Airframe  Able to perform mission in wide-ranging precipitation, temperature, and wind environments  Capable of landing in multiple environments  Durable  Compact, light, and easy to transport  Cargo capacity of 10 pounds  At least 100 square inches of storage/mounting space Propulsion  Extended flight and mission range  Redundancy  Reliability Navigation and Control  Autonomous flight capability  Stable flight in hoverand directional flight  Human control override capability at all distances and conditions during flight  Capable of being controlled through on-board cameras  Cruise speed of 10 mph  Maximum speed of 15 mph  Maneuverable Renewable Energy  Ability to find energy from sources that would not require human intervention  Energy efficient  Multiple energy sources  Minimal recharge time Data Acquisition  Multiple sensors  Multiple sensormounting areas  Visual data acquisition capabilities IV. Baseline Concept and Alternatives A Renewable Energy Quadrotor System(REQS) design was chosen to test the feasibility of renewable energy systems on unmanned multirotors to answer the problems in varying terrains and restrictive conditions.The REQS is a step toward energy sustainable machines and an alternative approach to scientific exploration. This concept combines both MV/UAV technology and renewable energy, which results in indefinite range for the vehicle and a variety of data acquisition possibilities. The REQS will use an integrated systemof sustainable energy generators to prolong flight time by charging the batteries while in flight and charging the batteries when landed and preparing for the next flight leg. The appendices contain information about each piece of equipment selected.
  • 3. 3 Decision and Alternatives To determine the best design for a variable environment vehicle which would meet the mission requirements, comparisons between various type of aircraft and available systems were made. Fixed-wing or rotary-wing? The advantages offixed-wing aircraft over rotorcraft for renewable energy integration: Higher Fuel/energy efficiency through lift from wings requiring only energy discharge for horizontal movement, higher forward velocity, able to carry large payloads. Advantages ofrotary-wing vehicles over fixed-wing: Low-energy vertical take-off and landing, efficient hover capability, ability to change direction of flight in short time/space, handling capabilities in low airspeeds. Rotary-wing, but what kind? Helicopter: low number of motors leverages energy efficiency, auto-rotational capability for recovery, highest stability in wind, lower vibration, lower cost,variable-pitch necessity requires mechanical complexity, lack of usable surface area for renewable energy systems mounting, lower payload capacity. Multirotor(MV): higher payload capacity, mechanical simplicity, extensible mounting area, more able to withstand collisions, compact-able for transport,able to maneuver in tighter spaces. For variable environments and renewable energy systems mounting, MVs make most functional sense. Multirotor(MV) Options Tricopters: least cost-prohibitive, simple construction,least stable,not as robust (tail servo and mechanics), low lifting power and flight time (because the motors have to run faster to hold it all in the air). No engine out capability. Low-medium surface area for mounting. Quadcopters:mechanically simpler, nearly 1/3 more lift, more stable (no servo issues),longer flight time (they can either lift larger batteries or fly more economically because the weight is spread across 4 motors and not just 3). Still no engine out capability. Medium-large surface area for mounting. Hexacopters: similar pros to quadcopters,plus more power and more lifting capability, limited engine out capability, though larger and more cost-prohibitive. Medium-large surface area for mounting. Octocopters and heavier: similar pros and cons to hexacopters, plus true engine out ability, es pecially large and cost-prohibitive, high power consumption requiring large or multiple battery/fuel systems,large area for renewable energy systemand instrumentation. Decision: REQS, a Renewable Energy Quadrotor System For the purpose of this mission and determining feasibility of future applications, a quadrotorsystemwas chosen as containing the most dimension to perform according to the mission requirements and being least space-, complexity-, and cost-prohibitive. From this finding, a choice of specific quadrotorframes was narrowed down to a stretched 'X-frame' or and an 'X-frame'. An "H"-frame (Figure 1) configured quadcopterwould best fulfill mission requirements. Its large platform offered ample space for an FPV system, for the electronics, the sensors,the wind turbines, and the solar panels.
  • 4. 4 Figure 1. REQS Concept Design without Solar Panels The rotors in this configuration are arranged as opposite pairs. One pair of rotors rotate clockwise and the other pair rotat e counterclockwise. This configuration (Figure 2) cancels torque when all rotors are revolving at the same speed. Figure 2. MotorPosition and Propeller/Rotor Rotation Pitch is achieved by adjusting the power of the front rotor pair relative to the rear pair. If the rear pair is rotating faster than the front, the MV will pitch forward and vice versa. The MV will move in the direction of the negative pitch.
  • 5. 5 Yaw is achieved by having dissimilar rotation between diagonal rotor pairs. Roll is similarly achieved by dissimilar rotation between the right rotor pair and the left rotor pair. V. Proof of Concept Testing The NART decided that constructing a proof of concept scaled model at 50%, would help us determine the overall feasibility of a sustainable electric powered UAV quadcopter.The proof of concept design will have to be as light in weight as possible, aerodynamic, energy efficient, self-sustaining, mechanically simple and highly maneuverable. Airframe With these design parameters, the “H” shaped frame quad copter design was chosen due to its high degree of stability, and large instrument mounting platform area. NART built the “H” shaped frame out of ¾ inch thick wood planks and 3/16” birch plywood to determine if we had adequate space to place all of our electronics. The frame model dimensions are 24" X 36" with a top deck area of 144 square. The “H” shaped frame was stable and rigid enough for a proof-of-concept test platform (Figure 3. "H" Frame with Loopwing Wind Turbines ). Figure 3. "H" Frame with Loopwing Wind Turbines Propulsion The motors were, Cobra C-3525-18 Brushless, which have a relatively low power draw of 430 kv that would still meet the lift standards.Rotors/propellers were Xoar 18x8 PJT Hollow Carbon Fiber Propellers which give increased lift by being larger, having a greater pitch and slower rpm. Using these would further minimize the battery draw by reducing motor revolutions. Navigation and Control Long range control of the craft was a functional requirement. Research indicated that a Long-range control requires feedback from the REQS in order to track its position and otherflight data. The REQS proof-of-concept will utilize open source autopilot technology to transmit telemetry data, receive GPS, and autonomously provide stable flight. A typical autonomous flight using Mission Planner (APM) enables users to create waypoints and to command REQS to perform certain actions such as holding altitude, loitering at a way point, auto-takeoff, and auto-landing. Other features of APM are:  Point-and-click waypoint entry, using Google Maps.  Select mission commands from drop-down menus  Download mission log files and analyze them  Interface with a PC flight simulator to create a full hardware-in-the-loop UAV simulator.  See the output from APM's serial terminal At any time during the mission a human pilot can take command and have REQS respond to orders from the pilot. The NART elected to obtain visual data from REQS by integrating a 4G capable cell phone that would give video footage,
  • 6. 6 and would provide virtually unlimited range depending on cell tower relay. An Arducopter() utilizing the APM autopilot Figure 4 was used for mission planning and flight testing. Figure 4. APM Wiring Configuration Renewable energy The arms and the top platform will be equipped with solar cells to charge the on-board batteries. During the landing phase while REQS is immobile, it will enter a charging state and prepare itself for flight once again. The battery th at generated the highest power to weight ratio, and had the longest life was a Turnigy nano-tech 6000mah 4S 25~50C Lipo Pack battery. To complete the sustainable cycle, and to give the quad the overall recharging ability a combination of both solar panels and wind turbines was used.The solar panels were the very light 6.7 V 30 mA Micro Power! BEAM Solar Battery Solar Panels. Efficient radiance of solar cells in a area 3.5"x10.6" operate at 7.2 volts and 100 mA. The total area of cells (8) on the test model give an area of 28"x85" providing an output wired in parallel of 800 mA at a maximum state of charge to the battery of 7.5 hours and weighing a 6.8g. Given the inefficiency of available solar panels relative to the amount of sunlight they receive, multiple units had to be linked in order to generate maximum output.Additional power sources were small loopwing wind turbines on top of the main platform. The loopwing was chosen for the design, because the loopwing blades create no tip vortices. These wind generators were Loopwing Windpower kits, would generate power effectively in relatively light winds. Furthermore, the turbines were only 6 inches high, and after some modification they were able to be mounted to the frame. Integrating the wind turbine into the design changed REQS aerodynamic structure. RotCFD is used in the rotorcraft industry as a design tool that can carry out aerodynamic simulations. Additional analysis was done with RotCFD by running simulation for REQS in order to view the simulated flow dynamics for the wind turbine placement. Of primary concern was potential flight degradation because of the loopwing rotor wash. RotCFD indicated that the loopwing creates minimal wake vortices therefore not substantially impacting the flight motors lifting capabilities (Figure 5. Velocity Vectors for REQS while at Hover and Figure 6. Velocity Pressures for REQS during Forward Flight )
  • 7. 7 Figure 5. Velocity Vectors for REQS while at Hover Figure 6. Velocity Pressures for REQS during Forward Flight Data Acquisition Two Arduino sensor systems were built to mount on REQS, a temperature and a barometric pressure sensor ( Figure 7. Arduino Temperature Sensor Build Furthermore, an off-the-shelf data logging instrument from T and D Corporation, the TR-74Ui fit the mission requirements for measuring temperature, humidity, UV and irradiance (Figure 8).
  • 8. 8 Figure 8. TandD TR 74Ui Module VI. Technical Challenges and Design Considerations As the project progressed,the NART members began to understand the complexities involved. Each systemand subsystemneeded to be analyzed in greater detail and a testing process needed to be developed for each. Questions for each systemneed to be examined. Here are several. Airframe Durability Protection from the elements Reparability Propulsion Power consumption versus power generation What if a motor fails? Motor, battery, electric speed controller matching Navigation and Control Radio and video transmission and reception range verification for manual control Obstacle avoidance Aircraft avoidance What if the GPS fails? What if a motor fails? Renewable energy Power consumption versus power generated Charging times Data Acquisition On-board storage versus data transmission Sensor robustness VII. Future Work This research has determined the likely feasibility of renewable energy system implementation on small to medium sized unmanned MVs. Some of the applications and future research possibilities inspired by this study are as follows.
  • 9. 9 A. Arctic Data Acquisition With design customizations in the form of glacier or water based landing systemand a reinforced payload housing, valuable and high demand scientific data can be acquired at a much lower cost than limited human based expeditions and at much greater depth than current fixed-wing UAV options especially in spring to early summer months where solar irradiance is at its highest and the days are almost literally without end, allowing for quick recharge times and more missions per day. Instrumentation can be attached to specialized REQS(Renewable Energy Quadrotor System) for land and air data acquisition to monitor and model thawing permafrost and resulting carbon releases as well as glacial ice deterioration. Also, with sampling capabilities and integrated photo-acoustic sensors,a REQS could gather data over large areas of the arctic for modeling concentrations and effects of black carbon in arctic ecosystems and their global implications. Due to their implied design maneuverability, FPV(First Person View) options,and ability to recharge for multiple missions from wind(with scaled loopwing customized for frozen particle winds) and/orsolar energy, REQS can also be utilized to map deep and complex underwater rock formations allowing for determination of arctic oil reserves, collect baseline data, and assist in the mapping of coastal and near shore environments, as well as collecting terrestrial imagery and elevation data. Infrared sensors could be outfitted on the REQS to track behaviors of elements in arctic ecosystems. B. Planetary Surface Exploration The varying and inhibitive topographies of planetary surfaces present an array of challenges to any land -based data acquisition systemwhich can be mechanically complex or in certain cases implausible to overcome. A low altitude multirotor systemlike a REQS could be customized—such as components designed for specific thermal and pressure ranges,proprietary energy storage,wind turbines with self-stalling and dust combative components for various particle laden winds such as on Mars—and utilized to navigate at low altitudes and collect data above or on the surface over large distances of variable environments with its “hop-charge/collect-hop” capability. Similarly, with varying air densities, gravity, and solar irradiance, the integration of wind and solar charging makes a REQS much more adaptable for both surface and subterranean exploration especially with multiple energy storage systems and implementation of adv anced wind and solar technology. A REQS equipped with variable-pitch actuators and propellers could operate underhigh duress and with formidable maneuverability in high velocity winds as well as utilize autorotation in original landing and in the event o f motor failure or energy disruption in flight. Recently developed optical sensors and autonomous flight control systems such as those tested on both a small-scale RC helicopter and an auto-piloted UH-60 Blackhawk including obstacle mapping and evasion and safe landing area determination would allow programming of long term autonomous navigation and data acquisition missions for virtually any kind of surface where rotorcraft can fly with surface-specific landing gear. C. Agricultural Monitoring and Response A REQS could serve as an all-in-one agricultural monitoring system. With set mission parameters, the REQS could be implemented to fly scheduled autonomous missions with instrumentation to detect healthy growth, solar irradiance, moisture, anhydrous ammonia, carbon dioxide, etc. and even be outfitted with a nutrient delivery system. With only off- the-shelf components including battery and free mission planner, a REQS could be scheduled to run two to six missions per day over 6 km each while recording and transmitting data between land recharges, requiring little to no interaction from an operator within the lifespan of the battery for months of completely autonomous monitoring and support of crops. Similarly, a REQS could be instrumented to autonomously monitor behavior or health of livestock at a similar or higher frequency of fly-by data collection missions. D. Disaster Response With the low noise and maneuverability of small multirotors, a REQS could provide quick data support to emergency responders on the ground at varying altitudes. Typical data acquisition by manned helicopters is loud as well as disruptive to the ground and altitude limits restrict collection of some data which are all mitigated by the utility of a sin gle, small instrumented REQS or a team of coordinated REQS providing data urgently for the greatest aptitude of life preservation. Hazard-resistant REQSs could be deployed rapidly on arrival with gps and remote telemetry with obstacle evasion to perform hovering or translational flight maneuvers in rural or urban environments to collect precise data in or around hurricane or tornado disasterzones or virtually any event from fires to firefights with proprietary solar and wind technology,multiple/capacious batteries, or fuel cells requiring little recharge time between missions at a cost much lower than requisition of manned helicopters or commercial UAVs.
  • 10. 10 E. Short Range Delivery A weather resistant REQS could prove to be a valuable asset for both public and commercial local delivery . With large propellers and low KV motors as well as basic GPS way-point navigation and a servo release or mounting system, a REQS could carry a rather large payload to a destination and return or make multiple low-mid weight deliveries on a single charge before recharging for the next flight. Lower altitude navigation may require the use of obstacle detection/evasion and for complete autonomy, a landing zone detection system.This would be most effective with a “team” of off-the-shelf constructed REQSs which would be much quicker and cost-effective than delivery by automobile by person for various products. This kind of delivery could also gather data geographical market penetration or automated marketing solutions such as leaving brochures in a novel and inexpensive way. Additionally, a REQS could be instrumented with modem-router configurations to act as a ground,roof, or even air based hotspot,delivering connectivity to devices in range or acting as part of a daisy-chain network replacing implausibility of permanent equipment mounting or providing greater portability and maintenance access than a permanently mounted systemoften requiring medium- to high-risk, i.e. cost-prohibitive maintenance solutions which are power- and attention-intensive. VIII. Concluding Remarks To meet the demands of scientific and public communities, the NASA Ames Native American Research Team has designed a proof-of-concept model of an unmanned multirotor with integrated renewable energy systems. This advancement allows for further research in environments of varying hazards and terrains. The simulations and proof-of- concept have determined that it is feasible to implement renewable energy systems on scalable multirotor systems to achieve greater distances and extensible mission parameters than current UAVconfigurations. With increased longevity of flight and mission distance through its “hop-charge/collect-hop” paradigm, REQS could be implemented to collect data or deliver resources for human-inhibitive environments or as supplements to human gathered intelligence. Further research into lightweight and efficient renewable energy systems positioned outside the vortexes of the propellers, as well as frame/design, would allow for additional broad-reaching applications and eventuality of completely sustainable unmanned aerial labs. These would have particular benefits in environmental research, aerospace exploration, and even day -to-day public life. IX. Acknowledgments The Native American Research team would like to extend big thank you to all of our mentors, NASA Ames Research Center, our fellow interns, and all those who helped make this project possible. There are so many people to thank and acknowledge for their role in making this project come togetherand the experience enjoyable. Without the guidance and jovial care of Dr. Bill Warmbrodt, Chief of the NASA Ames Aeromechanics Branch, this project would have been impossible. Not just in the sense that without his approval and agreement to offer all of the aeromechanics branch interns to have a place, subject, and opportunities to study and enjoy, but that his personal attention and good nature inspired us to do our best. Gary Brandt, our team mentor and esteemed educatorat Northwest Indian College, represented and supported u s in ways no one else could have. His positive attitude,expertise, and consideration for modern indigenous strengths and struggles gave NART its back-bone and kept us showing up each morning though we were often anxious and self-effacing. Wheneverwe got into trouble or pulled something off that seemed almost expertly, Gary’s genius, kindness,and grin were present. Larry Young, an engineer of NASA Ames Aeromechanics Branch, gave us gentle advice and pushed us to be creative in our research endeavors. Every week he met with us and shared his work as well as good will and the fundamentals of being an engineer. His meetings and notes shared with NART what life is like as an engineer at NASA: the privileges, excitement, and realities, and how to be good at it. To share our journey and provide numerous angles of assistance and concepts,Needa Lin, a Mechanical Engineering student from UC Davis and an experienced Aeromechanics intern, was with us the whole way. Though she already maintained a heavy workload of summer schooland projects of her own, Needa took time out of her long days to push and prod our designs,offer solutions and new ways of thinking, and learn new renewable energy and aerodynamic concepts alongside us. Similarly, Sumeet Singh, Willie Costa, and Natalia Larrea Brito shared their aerodynamic insights and research with us, giving us just what we need to keep moving forward with our designs and the possibilities.
  • 11. 11 Acknowledgments and thanks to Kurt Long and the gang at the Fluid Mechanics Lab including but not limited to Hannah Spooner, Katrina Hui, and Mike Harrington for their hospitality, attitudes,and support of our experiments in NASA Ames Fluid Mechanics Lab. As current undergraduate students we would like to thank staff at our respective universities for their help and encouragement: Dr. Dan Wildcat and Lucas Miller with Haskell Indian Nations University, Dr. Jim Davis and Audrey Lavallie with Turtle Mountain Community College, Heather Yazzie Kinalchini and Dr. Casmir Agbaraji with Navajo Technical College, and Nathanael Davis with Northwest Indian College. Finally, it has been our honorto participate in the Tribal College Undergraduate Program as members of the Native American Research Team. Our gratitude and esteemgo out to Alex Grandon and supporting members of the American Indian Higher Education Consortium which granted us support and allowed us the opportunity to research at NASA Ames Research Center. Works cited Careaga, Andrew. “New method for connecting solar panels may increase efficiency.” Missouri S&T News & Events. Web. Jul 26, 2013. DIY DRONES. “DIY Drones The Leading Community for Personal UAVs.” DIY Drones. n.d. Web. 28 Jul 2013. Engi-nerd-extraordinaire. “Quad rotor Propulsion System.” Engi-nerd extraordinaire. n.d. Web. 28 Jul 2013 Hoffman, G.; Huang, H., Waslander,S.L., Tomlin, C.J. (20–23 August 2007). "Quadrotor Helicopter Flight Dynamics and Control: Theory and Experiment". In the Conference of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics.Hilton Head, South Carolina. Jethro Hazelhurst. “Typical Quadcopter Layout.” ArducopterImage. Arducopter, connecting you RC input and motors. 28 Jul. 2013. Pounds,P.; Mahony,R., Corke, P. (December 2006). "Modelling and Control of a Quad-Rotor Robot".In the Proceedingsof the Australasian Conference on Robotics and Automation.Auckland, New Zealand. Powerfilm Solar. “Thin, Flexible Solar Panels Keeping the power of Film/RC7/2-75 PSA.” n.d. Web.27 Jul. 2013. Rotorcraft Flying Handbook. U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Flights Standards Service. 2000 Print.
  • 12. 12 Appendix I. Autopilot The ArduPilot Mega 2.5 is a complete open source autopilot systemand the bestselling technology that won the prestigious 2012 Outback Challenge UAV competition. It allows the userto turn any fixed, rotary wing or multirotor vehicle (even cars and boats)into a fully autonomous vehicle; capable of performing programmed GPS missions with waypoints. Available with top or side connectors. Please note that this listing is for the APM with on board compass,thus compatible with the Mediatek GPS only (also compatible with the previous version of the 3DR GPS uBlox LEA-6 without compass). Features Arduino Compatible! Can be ordered with top entry pins for attaching connectors vertically, or as side entry pins to slide your connectors in to either end horizontally Includes 3-axis gyro, accelerometer and magnetometer, along with a high-performance barometer Onboard 4 MegaByte Dataflash chip for automatic datalogging Digital compass powered by Honeywell's HMC5883L-TR chip, now included on the main board. Optional off-board GPS, Mediatek MT3329 or uBlox LEA-6H module. Mediatek module included in base price; choose otheroptions at right (subtract $20 for no GPS or add $50 for the better uBlox module) One of the first open source autopilot systems to use Invensense's 6DoF Accelerometer/Gyro MPU-6000. Barometric pressure sensorupgraded to MS5611-01BA03, from Measurement Specialties. Atmel's ATMEGA2560 and ATMEGA32U-2 chips for processing and usb functions respectively.
  • 13. 13 Appendix II. Battery Battery More than just a fancy name. TURNIGY nano-tech lithium polymer batteries are built with an LiCo nano- technology substrate complex greatly improving power transfer making the oxidation/reduction reaction more efficient, this helps electrons pass more freely from anode to cathode with less internal impedance. In short; less voltage sag and a higher discharge rate than a similar density lithium polymer (non nano- tech) battery.For those that love graphs, it means a straighter, longer curve. For pilots it spells stronge r throttle punches and unreal straight-up performance. Excellent news for 3D pilots! Unfortunately with other big brands; numbers, ratings and graphs can be fudged. Rest assured,TURNIGY nano- techs are the real deal, delivering unparalleled performance! Spec. Capacity: 6000mAh Voltage: 4S1P / 4 Cell / 14.8V Discharge: 25C Constant / 50C Burst Weight: 623g (including wire, plug & case) Dimensions: 175x49x38mm Balance Plug: JST-XH Discharge Plug: 4mm bullet-connector
  • 14. 14 Appendix III. Camera Camera – Droid Incredible 4g lite Product Information A powerful 1.2 GHz dual-core processormakes the HTC Droid Incredible 4G LTE smartphone adept at crunching through graphically intensive games. Operating on Android 4.0 OS, this HTC cell phone supports a wide range of applications. Thanks to the 4-inch capacitive multi-touch display of this smartphone, you can easily navigate your way through its highly versatile options or enjoy your favorite game to the fullest. This HTC cell phone�s 8 MP camera lets you capture yourmemorable moments on the spur. Be it staying in the loop with push email or chatting with friends on WhatsApp and Facebook, the HTC Droid Incredible 4G LTE has it all. Product Identifiers Brand HTC MPN ADR6410L Carrier Verizon Model Droid Incredible 4G LTE UPC 044476822124 Type Smartphone Key Features Storage Capacity 8 GB Color Black Network Generation 4G Network Technology LTE Camera 8.0 MP Memory Supported Flash Memory Cards MicroSD, MicroSDHC Battery Battery Capacity 1700 mAh Display Display Technology HD Super AMOLED Diagonal Screen Size 4 in. Other Features Touch Screen Yes Bluetooth Yes Digital Camera Yes GPS Yes Email Access Yes Internet Browser Yes Speakerphone Yes
  • 15. 15 Appendix IV. Electronic Speed Controller (ESC) I. Cobra 33 Amp Speed Controller Specifications:  Weight (With Output Connectors) ................. 37.1 grams (1.31 oz)  Max Continuous Current ............................................... 33 Amps  Burst Current rating (15s) ............................................. 41 Amps  Operating Voltage Range ......................................... 6 to 17 Volts  Number of Li-Po cells ................................................. 2 to 4 cells  Number of Ni-XX cells .............................................. 6 to 12 cells  Number of Li-Fe cells ................................................. 2 to 4 cells  BEC Output .................................................. 3 amps @ 5.5 Volts  ESC Size (inc. Caps) ........ 56 x 25 x 10mm (2.20 x 0.98 x 0.39 in)
  • 16. 16 Appendix V. Propeller/Rotor GemFan Paddle Style Propeller These carbon fiber DJI S800 style props have a 3-hole hub configuration to fit on the DJI S800 or any of the RcTiger MN series motors. Come as a pair, one right and one left rotation. As with any propeller for your UAV these propellers should be balanced to reduce vibration, balancing will improve flight characteristics, motor performance, provide clearer, cleaner photo and video results. These Propellers have a low pitch, paddle style configuration to improve efficiency. Weight: 24 grams
  • 17. 17 Appendix VI. GPS u-blox 6 GPS, QZSS, GLONASS and Galileo modules LEA-6 modules bring the high performance u-blox 6 position engine to the industry standard LEA form factor. u-blox 6 has been designed for low power consumption and low costs, independent of which satellite constellation is used (e.g. GLONASS, Galileo). Intelligent power management is a breakthrough for low-power applications. The versatile, standalone LEA-6 receivers combine an extensive array of features with flexible connectivity options. Their ease of integration results in fast time-to-market for a wide range of automotive and industrial applications. LEA-6 modules work with all available satellite positioning systems:LEA-6H is ready to support theEuropean Galileo systemvia a simple firmware upgrade; LEA-6N combines full feature GPS performance with the QZSS regional satellite system. LEA-6N also targets the Russian market, featuring thelowest power GLONASS functionality in theindustry, and is designed for ERA-GLONASS.
  • 18. 18 Appendix VII.Solar Cell This unit is equipped with a Pressure Sensitive Adhesive or (PSA) backing. Simply expose the adhesive layer, by removing the protective film on the backside, and firmly place this solar cell on the wing or fuselage of your airplane.  Voltage 7.20V  Current 100mA (0.10A)  Voltage (oc) 10.5V  Current (sc) 120mA (0.12A)  Thickness 0.2"  Total Size 3.5 x 10.6"  Aperture Size 3.0 x 9.5"  Weight 0.3 oz
  • 19. 19 Appendix VIII. Telemetry The RFD900 is a high performance 900MHz, ISM band radio modem covering the 902 - 928 MHz frequency band. It is designed for long range serial communications applications requiring best in class radio link performance Key features: Long range >40km depending on antennas and GCS setup 2 x RP-SMA RF connectors, diversity switched. 1 Watt (+30dBm) transmit power. Transmit low pass filter. > 20dB Low noise amplifier. RX SAW filter. Passive front end band pass filter. Open source firmware / tools, field upgradeable, easy to configure. Small, light weight. Compatible with 3DR / Hope-RF radio modules. License free use in Australia, Canada, USA, NZ. Specifications: Frequency Range: 902 - 928 MHz (USA) / 915 - 928 MHz (Australia) Output Power:1W (+30dBm) Receive Sensitivity:>121 dBm at low data rates, high data rates (TBA) Size: 30 mm (wide) x 57 mm (long) x 12.8 mm (thick) - Including RF Shield, Heatsink and connector extremeties Weight: 14.5g Mounting: 3 x M2.5 screws, 3 x header pin solder points Power Supply:+5 V nominal, (+3.5 V min, +5.5 V max), ~800 mA peak at maximum power Temp. Range: -40 to +85 deg C
  • 20. 20 Appendix IX. Brushless Motors TIGER MOTOR MN4010-11 475KVNAVIGATOR SERIES The Tiger T-Motor MN-4010-11 475kv multi rotor motor is a powerful motor specifically designed for multi-rotors. All MN/MT Motors come with prop adapters included.
  • 21. 21 Appendix X. Loopwing Wind Turbine The perfect kit to learn some basic engineering principals while having eco fun! The windmill features a loop-wing design that can be rotated by the slightest breeze. Loopwing Wind Turbine achieves high safety, low noise and low vibration. The Kit comes with everything includes motor, mini charge car, wind turbine and English manual. After assemble size: 9 inches x 9 inches x 10 inches