2. Structuring a Scientific Paper
1. Graphs, tables, maps (your data)
2. Results
3. Methods
4. Discussion
5. Conclusion
6. Introduction
7. Abstract
8. Title
3. In general the structure of a paper is
organised in sections
Section Length Readers
Title < 16 words 1,000
Abstract 250 words 100
Introduction 1-2 pages 100
Methods 3 pages 3
Results, Discussion 1-2 pages 10
Conclusion 1 page 2
4. The first step
Before writing a research paper one needs
to ask what is the idea that the paper is
intended to communicate
5. Therefore, an idea should be
infectious, e.g.,
A new way of looking at objects, ‘model’
New way of manipulating objects (i.e.,
technique)
New information – update our knowledge
base
6. Second step
Identify the relevant community which may
find the idea useful
Experts working in the area
Current and future researchers
Decision-makers, policy makers
9. Ideally your paper should just have one clear
sharp idea
So if you have lots of ideas, write lots of
papers
10. To write effectively, tell a story
Here is a problem
It’s an interesting problem
It is an unsolved problem
I wish to know how to solve the problem (hook)
Introduction
11. Explain how your new idea solves
the problem
Here is my idea
Methods:
Details
12. Show how useful your idea is
My idea works
Here is how my idea compares to other people’s approaches
Results &
Discussion
13. In the Introduction
Describe the problem briefly
Nail or state your contributions
Make certain the reader is in no doubt what the
idea is.
e.g., the main idea of this paper is…
Properties of
your solution
14. Use examples to introduce the
problem and your idea
Consider this program, which has an interesting
bug, …
We will show an automatic technique for identifying
and removing such bugs
15. Make your contributions explicit
We have built a GUI toolkit in, …and used it to….
The result is half the length of a Java …
Or the innovative features of our model are …
16. Avoid putting related work in the
introduction
Rather new stuff should come first
READER
IDEA
17. The role of body of the paper is to:
provide evidence to support claims
made in the introduction
18. Discussion: Move 1
State the study’s major findings that provide the
answer to the question stated in the introduction
Explain the meaning and importance of your
findings
Consider potential explanations of the findings
Give results
meaning
19. Discussion: Move 2
Compare and contrast your findings with those of
other published results
Explain any discrepancies and unexpected results
State the limitations, strengths of your study
Provide
research context
20. Dealing with related work
But do not downplay the work of others
Be generous to the competition
e.g., we improve on their earlier work in the following
ways
Our work differs from …
21. Discussion: Move 3
Close the paper
Indicating the importance of the work by stating
applications, implications, …
22. Listen to your readers
Get your paper read by as many friendly guinea pigs as is
possible
Ask them to show you where they are getting lost or get
unmotivated
Suppose I explain it to your this way
23. Getting expert help
When you think you are done, send the draft to
the competition.
You could write “can you help me to ensure
that I describe your work fairly”