SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
Download to read offline
Can we win the tank-to-tire CO2 challenge?


               Phil Gott, Managing Director
                IHS Automotive Consulting
         Internal Combustion Engine Roundtable
                   Challenge Bibendum
               Rio de Janeiro, May 30, 2010
2
                                     Commercial Viabilities of Most Advanced IC
                                     Engine Technologies Are Reasonably
                                     Probable
                                                      Probability of Goals Being Achieved by 2030
                                                                                                                    NA SI
                                                                                                                    Diesel
                                                                         Glossary                                   SI IVT
                               100%                          NA = Naturally Aspirated                               BEV
                                                             SI = spark Igntion                       DISI
           Technology & Fuel




                               80%                           IVT = Infinitely flexible intake                   DNSZ SI
                                                             Valve throttling
                                                                                                                    LTE
                               60%                           DI = Direct injection
                                                             DNSZ = Downsize (about 30%)
                                                             and boosted
                               40%
                                                             LTE = Low Temperature Engine
                                                             BEV = Battery electric Vehicle
                               20%
                                                             λ = Fuel-air ratio

                                0%
                                 GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR



                                      0%                           25%                    50%   75%          100%
                                                                   "Toxic" Emissions Compliance


Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
3



                                      Some Are Much More Cost Effective...


                                             Expected Locus of Cost vs Energy & Tailpipe CO2 Benefit

                                40%

                                                                           DISI (λ<1)
                                30%
                    Benefit




                                                                                        LTE
                                                          DNSZ SI (λ1)
                                20%                                                DNSZ SI (λ<1)
                                                                                                      Diesel

                                                                          SI CNG
                                10%
                                                  DISI (λ1)      SI IVT

                                   0%          NA SI
                                             0%
                              GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR
                                                          10%        20%           30%        40%   50%        60%
                                                                            Cost Penalty
                      Cost Penalty and Benefit = % difference from NA SI engine



Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
4
                                                 … But Some of the Most Attractive Are the Most Risky.
                                                 The Lowest Risk, Lowest Cost Technologies Will Be Fully
                                                 Exploited before More Expensive Types Are Adopted
                                                                     Risk - Attractiveness
                                                                             2030
                                                  2
                          Attractiveness Index



                                                                 DNSZ SI (λ1)



                                                                  DISI
                                                  1
                                                      CNG                                       LTE
                                                      SI IVT
                                                                         DNSZ SI (<λ1)
                                                      Diesel
                                                      CNG
                                                  0
                      NA SI          GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR


                                                  0.00%                          25.00%                             50.00%
                                                                                  Risk
                                                                          Attractiveness = Fuel Benefit/Cost Penalty
                                                                          Risk = 1- Probability( Technology & Fuel x “Toxic” Emissions )
Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
5

                                     Hybrids Beg for Definition but Actually Fall
                                     along a Continuum                                                         Rationale


                    •         Micro—Stop/start operation
                                 –       ~ 7 percent fuel consumption benefit
                                 –       ~ 10 percent cost penalty


                    •         Mild—~25 percent of total driveline power delivered electrically
                                 – Integrated Starter Alternator
                                 – ~ 20 percent fuel consumption benefit
                                 – ~ 25 percent cost penalty

                    •         Full—~ 50 percent of total driveline power delivered electrically
                                 – Integrated Starter Alternator with motor assist
                                 – ~ 30 percent fuel consumption benefit
                                 – ~ 50 percent cost penalty

                    •         Plug-in—Sufficient onboard electrical energy stored to yield pure-electric
                              driving for 100 percent of the majority of typical daily duty cycles. The
                              GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR
                              balance is driven as a full hybrid (series architecture likely).
                                 –       ~ 60 km per charge
                                 –       ~ 50 percent CO2 or fuel consumption benefit on test cycles assumed
                                 –       ~ 100 percent cost penalty
                                 –       Market limited to those people with easy access to grid power


Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
2030 Outlook: Engines in Europe, US,
                                    Japan and China still mostly gasoline
• Overall movement towards advanced                                             CO2 Regulations, Avg. g/km Equivalent
  gasoline engines (~60% of the                                                                  2015        2020         2025    2030
  market)                                                                      U.S/Canada         160         140          125     110
                                                                               Europe             130          95           95      75
• Electrified (hybrid) drivelines account                                      Japan              138         120          110     100
                                                                               China              174         150          120      90
  for 1/3 of the market, with 1/6 of the
  market fully electric
                                                           Global Outlook: Planning Scenario
                                     Sales                47,915,199 46,686,543 60,608,869 64,882,907   68,944,193   73,392,567
                                        Overall Market      2006        2010        2015     2020         2025         2030
                                                                              ENGINE
                                   Conventional λ1 SI       76%         71%         45%      26%          16%           9%
                                   λ1 SI w/ Full IVT         0%          1%          2%      10%           9%           9%
                                   λ1 Boost DI               0%          1%          4%       7%           9%           6%
                                   λ1 NA DI                  0%          4%          9%       4%           3%           2%
                                   DNSZ λ1 Boost DI          1%          4%         17%      28%          37%          42%
                                   LTE                       0%          0%          0%       1%           2%           3%
                                   Diesel                   23%         19%         19%      17%          14%          12%
                              GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR
                                   BEV                       0%          0%          2%       5%          10%          17%
                                   CNG                       0%          0%          1%       1%           1%           2%
                                                                              HYBRID
                                     Direct Drive           99%         91%         57%      32%          29%          27%
                                     Micro-HEV               0%          7%         32%      49%          43%          36%
                                     Mild- HEV               0%          0%          4%       7%          10%          10%
                                     Full-HEV                1%          1%          4%       8%          10%          13%
                                     PI-HEV                  0%          0%          2%       4%           9%          14%
Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
Meanwhile, the vehicle parc doubles…

                                                                     Regional Light Duty Vehicle Parc
                                             1,800

                                             1,600
                                                                                                               Africa
                                             1,400
                                                                                                               Middle East
                                             1,200
                                                                                                               Euraisa
                                             1,000
                           Million                                                                             OECD Asia
                           Vehicles
                                              800
                                                                                                               Latin America
                                              600
                                                                                                               Non OECD Asia
                                              400
                                                                                                               Europe
                                              200
                                                                                                               North America
                                                 -
                              GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR


                                                     2000   2005   2010    2015      2020       2025    2030

    OECD = Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Chile, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France,
    Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Korea, Luxembourg, Mexico, the
    Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovak Republic, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland,
    Turkey, United Kingdom, United States.
Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
… And Tank-to-Tire CO2 begins to
                                          decline after 2020 in the four regions

                                                              Global Tank-to-Wheel CO2
                                          2.00
                                          1.80
                                          1.60
                        109 Tons/yr CO2




                                          1.40                                                    CNG
                                          1.20                                                    Electricity*
                                          1.00                     Forecast includes certain      Ethanol
                                          0.80                       assumptions including:
                                                                                                  Diesel
                                          0.60                 • Modest shifts to smaller cars
                                                                                                  Gasoline
                                          0.40                 • ~20% reduction in energy
                                                                 intensity per average vehicle
                                          0.20
                                  GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR    • Mild reductions in Avg VMT
                                          0.00
                                             00

                                             03

                                             06

                                             09

                                             12

                                             15

                                             18

                                             21

                                             24

                                             27

                                             30
                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20
                                                                                                 * Source to tank

Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
Thank you!

Phil Gott, Managing Director
 Automotive Science and Technology
     IHS Automotive Consulting
           +1 781 301 9141
   philip.gott@ihsglobalinsight.com


                     Extracted from Preliminary findings;
                            IHS Global Scenarios Project
10



                                    Engine Options

                •         Conventional λ1 Spark Ignition (SI): Naturally Aspirated Spark Ignition
                             –       Variable and optimized cooling rates at different operating conditions,
                             –       Variable valve timing (Miller/Atkinson cycles),
                             –       Reduced mechanical friction losses
                             –       Pre-mixed

                •         SI IVT: λ1 Spark Ignition with Infinitely Flexible Valve Timing and Boosting
                             –       Intake valve throttling

                •         DISI: Direct Injection Turbocharged Gasoline Engine
                             –       Combustion system development for stratified operation across entire part load range
                             –       Lean with NOx treatment (20 percent risk) or Stoichiometric (5 percent risk)

                •         DNSZ SI: Downsized, highly boosted DISI
                             –       30 percent reduction in displacement
                             –       Turbocharged
                             –       Lean with NOx treatment (30 percent risk) or Stoichiometric (10 percent risk)

                •         HSDI: (High Speed) Direct Injection Diesel (lean)
                             – Turbocharged—perhaps multistage
                             – Lean NOx exhaust gas treatment
                             GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR

                             – Diesel particulate filter

                •         LTE: Low Temperature Engine (lean)
                             –       Also known as HCCI, PCCI or CAI
                             –       Power boosting – perhaps electrically assisted turbocharger
                             –       Advanced controls including start of combustion sensing
                             –       Low-temperature oxidation catalyst
Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
11


                                    Global Segment Sales

               (Millions)

                  30                                                         Multi-car ownership
                                                                             starts in growth markets       Fiscal-induced downsizing
                           Dominant growth segment in Asia
                                                         Affordability for grey population, parking hassle factor
                  25




                  20
                                             Virtual mobility squeeze
                                                                                                                              Mega urban
                  15                                                                                                          agglomerations
                                                                                                                              Japan like
                                                                                               Technology load pricing

                  10




                    5
                               GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR




                                                                                              Age dependency, change to footprint not mass
                    0
                        2000                      2005            2010           2015            2020          2025          2030          2035

                           A                  B            C       D         E          MPV         OTHER        PUP        CUV         FF SUV


Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
Vehicle Miles Traveled more than
                                    doubles!

       20,000
       18,000
       16,000                                                      Africa
                                                                   Middle East
       14,000
                                                                   Eurasia
       12,000
                                                                   OECD Asia
       10,000
                                                                   Latin America
          8,000
                                                                   Non OECD Asia
          6,000
                                                                   Europe
          4,000
                                                                   NAFTA
          2,000
                       0      GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR




                         2000 2004 2008 2012 2016 2020 2024 2028



Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
… And Tank-to-Tire CO2 begins to level
                                          off around 2030

                                                              Global Tank-to-Wheel CO2
                                          5.00
                                          4.50
                                          4.00
                        109 Tons/yr CO2




                                          3.50                                                    CNG
                                          3.00                                                    Electricity*
                                          2.50                     Forecast includes certain      Ethanol
                                          2.00                       assumptions including:
                                                                                                  Diesel
                                          1.50                 • Modest shifts to smaller cars
                                                                                                  Gasoline
                                          1.00                 • ~20% reduction in energy
                                                                 intensity per average vehicle
                                          0.50
                                  GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR    • Mild reductions in Avg VMT
                                          0.00
                                             00

                                             03

                                             06

                                             09

                                             12

                                             15

                                             18

                                             21

                                             24

                                             27

                                             30
                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20
                                                                                                 * Source to tank

Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...
1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...
1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...Michelin Challenge Bibendum
 
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusionsMichelin Challenge Bibendum
 
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...Michelin Challenge Bibendum
 
Free zones in the uae 2009
Free zones in the uae 2009Free zones in the uae 2009
Free zones in the uae 2009Raj Kadam
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Challenge bibendum berlin 2011 key finding
Challenge bibendum berlin 2011 key findingChallenge bibendum berlin 2011 key finding
Challenge bibendum berlin 2011 key finding
 
1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...
1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...
1 4 Making biomass derived fuels a sustainable business case for road mobilit...
 
Wks 1 12 gas in the automotive industry
Wks 1 12 gas in the automotive industryWks 1 12 gas in the automotive industry
Wks 1 12 gas in the automotive industry
 
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions
1 5 identifying technical breakthroughs conclusions
 
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...
1 10 Information and communication technologies and services for a connected ...
 
Free zones in the uae 2009
Free zones in the uae 2009Free zones in the uae 2009
Free zones in the uae 2009
 

Rt1 gott.p ihsgi sl

  • 1. Can we win the tank-to-tire CO2 challenge? Phil Gott, Managing Director IHS Automotive Consulting Internal Combustion Engine Roundtable Challenge Bibendum Rio de Janeiro, May 30, 2010
  • 2. 2 Commercial Viabilities of Most Advanced IC Engine Technologies Are Reasonably Probable Probability of Goals Being Achieved by 2030 NA SI Diesel Glossary SI IVT 100% NA = Naturally Aspirated BEV SI = spark Igntion DISI Technology & Fuel 80% IVT = Infinitely flexible intake DNSZ SI Valve throttling LTE 60% DI = Direct injection DNSZ = Downsize (about 30%) and boosted 40% LTE = Low Temperature Engine BEV = Battery electric Vehicle 20% λ = Fuel-air ratio 0% GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% "Toxic" Emissions Compliance Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 3. 3 Some Are Much More Cost Effective... Expected Locus of Cost vs Energy & Tailpipe CO2 Benefit 40% DISI (λ<1) 30% Benefit LTE DNSZ SI (λ1) 20% DNSZ SI (λ<1) Diesel SI CNG 10% DISI (λ1) SI IVT 0% NA SI 0% GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Cost Penalty Cost Penalty and Benefit = % difference from NA SI engine Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 4. 4 … But Some of the Most Attractive Are the Most Risky. The Lowest Risk, Lowest Cost Technologies Will Be Fully Exploited before More Expensive Types Are Adopted Risk - Attractiveness 2030 2 Attractiveness Index DNSZ SI (λ1) DISI 1 CNG LTE SI IVT DNSZ SI (<λ1) Diesel CNG 0 NA SI GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR 0.00% 25.00% 50.00% Risk Attractiveness = Fuel Benefit/Cost Penalty Risk = 1- Probability( Technology & Fuel x “Toxic” Emissions ) Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 5. 5 Hybrids Beg for Definition but Actually Fall along a Continuum Rationale • Micro—Stop/start operation – ~ 7 percent fuel consumption benefit – ~ 10 percent cost penalty • Mild—~25 percent of total driveline power delivered electrically – Integrated Starter Alternator – ~ 20 percent fuel consumption benefit – ~ 25 percent cost penalty • Full—~ 50 percent of total driveline power delivered electrically – Integrated Starter Alternator with motor assist – ~ 30 percent fuel consumption benefit – ~ 50 percent cost penalty • Plug-in—Sufficient onboard electrical energy stored to yield pure-electric driving for 100 percent of the majority of typical daily duty cycles. The GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR balance is driven as a full hybrid (series architecture likely). – ~ 60 km per charge – ~ 50 percent CO2 or fuel consumption benefit on test cycles assumed – ~ 100 percent cost penalty – Market limited to those people with easy access to grid power Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 6. 2030 Outlook: Engines in Europe, US, Japan and China still mostly gasoline • Overall movement towards advanced CO2 Regulations, Avg. g/km Equivalent gasoline engines (~60% of the 2015 2020 2025 2030 market) U.S/Canada 160 140 125 110 Europe 130 95 95 75 • Electrified (hybrid) drivelines account Japan 138 120 110 100 China 174 150 120 90 for 1/3 of the market, with 1/6 of the market fully electric Global Outlook: Planning Scenario Sales 47,915,199 46,686,543 60,608,869 64,882,907 68,944,193 73,392,567 Overall Market 2006 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 ENGINE Conventional λ1 SI 76% 71% 45% 26% 16% 9% λ1 SI w/ Full IVT 0% 1% 2% 10% 9% 9% λ1 Boost DI 0% 1% 4% 7% 9% 6% λ1 NA DI 0% 4% 9% 4% 3% 2% DNSZ λ1 Boost DI 1% 4% 17% 28% 37% 42% LTE 0% 0% 0% 1% 2% 3% Diesel 23% 19% 19% 17% 14% 12% GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR BEV 0% 0% 2% 5% 10% 17% CNG 0% 0% 1% 1% 1% 2% HYBRID Direct Drive 99% 91% 57% 32% 29% 27% Micro-HEV 0% 7% 32% 49% 43% 36% Mild- HEV 0% 0% 4% 7% 10% 10% Full-HEV 1% 1% 4% 8% 10% 13% PI-HEV 0% 0% 2% 4% 9% 14% Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 7. Meanwhile, the vehicle parc doubles… Regional Light Duty Vehicle Parc 1,800 1,600 Africa 1,400 Middle East 1,200 Euraisa 1,000 Million OECD Asia Vehicles 800 Latin America 600 Non OECD Asia 400 Europe 200 North America - GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 OECD = Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Chile, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Korea, Luxembourg, Mexico, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovak Republic, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, United Kingdom, United States. Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 8. … And Tank-to-Tire CO2 begins to decline after 2020 in the four regions Global Tank-to-Wheel CO2 2.00 1.80 1.60 109 Tons/yr CO2 1.40 CNG 1.20 Electricity* 1.00 Forecast includes certain Ethanol 0.80 assumptions including: Diesel 0.60 • Modest shifts to smaller cars Gasoline 0.40 • ~20% reduction in energy intensity per average vehicle 0.20 GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR • Mild reductions in Avg VMT 0.00 00 03 06 09 12 15 18 21 24 27 30 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 * Source to tank Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 9. Thank you! Phil Gott, Managing Director Automotive Science and Technology IHS Automotive Consulting +1 781 301 9141 philip.gott@ihsglobalinsight.com Extracted from Preliminary findings; IHS Global Scenarios Project
  • 10. 10 Engine Options • Conventional λ1 Spark Ignition (SI): Naturally Aspirated Spark Ignition – Variable and optimized cooling rates at different operating conditions, – Variable valve timing (Miller/Atkinson cycles), – Reduced mechanical friction losses – Pre-mixed • SI IVT: λ1 Spark Ignition with Infinitely Flexible Valve Timing and Boosting – Intake valve throttling • DISI: Direct Injection Turbocharged Gasoline Engine – Combustion system development for stratified operation across entire part load range – Lean with NOx treatment (20 percent risk) or Stoichiometric (5 percent risk) • DNSZ SI: Downsized, highly boosted DISI – 30 percent reduction in displacement – Turbocharged – Lean with NOx treatment (30 percent risk) or Stoichiometric (10 percent risk) • HSDI: (High Speed) Direct Injection Diesel (lean) – Turbocharged—perhaps multistage – Lean NOx exhaust gas treatment GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR – Diesel particulate filter • LTE: Low Temperature Engine (lean) – Also known as HCCI, PCCI or CAI – Power boosting – perhaps electrically assisted turbocharger – Advanced controls including start of combustion sensing – Low-temperature oxidation catalyst Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 11. 11 Global Segment Sales (Millions) 30 Multi-car ownership starts in growth markets Fiscal-induced downsizing Dominant growth segment in Asia Affordability for grey population, parking hassle factor 25 20 Virtual mobility squeeze Mega urban 15 agglomerations Japan like Technology load pricing 10 5 GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR Age dependency, change to footprint not mass 0 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 A B C D E MPV OTHER PUP CUV FF SUV Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 12. Vehicle Miles Traveled more than doubles! 20,000 18,000 16,000 Africa Middle East 14,000 Eurasia 12,000 OECD Asia 10,000 Latin America 8,000 Non OECD Asia 6,000 Europe 4,000 NAFTA 2,000 0 GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR 2000 2004 2008 2012 2016 2020 2024 2028 Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.
  • 13. … And Tank-to-Tire CO2 begins to level off around 2030 Global Tank-to-Wheel CO2 5.00 4.50 4.00 109 Tons/yr CO2 3.50 CNG 3.00 Electricity* 2.50 Forecast includes certain Ethanol 2.00 assumptions including: Diesel 1.50 • Modest shifts to smaller cars Gasoline 1.00 • ~20% reduction in energy intensity per average vehicle 0.50 GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE SEMINAR • Mild reductions in Avg VMT 0.00 00 03 06 09 12 15 18 21 24 27 30 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 * Source to tank Copyright © 2010 IHS. All Rights Reserved.