SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
2010-12-08
Working Seminar #5
Bekhan Tchapanov
Progress
Table of contents
The Introduction
Obstacles
Timeframe
What needs to be done
Introduction          Completed
Method                Completed
Theory                Satisfactory, close
                      to conclusion
Empirical framework   Satisfactory. Will be
                      taking shape this
                      week
Interview arranged
Introduction revised accordingly
      to feedback received




 New subcategories in theory
Structural changes made:
     - Chapters subcategorized, content
       restructured, determined sourcing method
       (Harvard).
    - Sharper and clearer RQ. Preliminary RQ
      were made in order to provide clearer
      guideline for Theory.
The “Decentralized companies”, no longer the target
Grammatical errors and excessive use of the word “I”
addressed
Missing sources in the beginning filled in
The Problem and Purpose revised:
     - BSC isn’t something new..
     - It was difficult to understand the main point of
       the study
Introduction – RQ’s constantly under magnifying glass
               Certain difficulties in following of
               Delimitations
Frame of reference – What is most relevant?
                      Constant revision
Empirical framework – Varying and at times vague
                       Stressing importance of the
                       Interview
Important to dispose
wisely of the time left

What is important? What is less
important?

Quality of the research
needs to be kept high
Develop a new schedule, time is short
Prioritize future efforts and time on Empirical
framework
Arrange a second interview (Swedbank, Nordea)
Conclude the frame of reference THIS WEEK
Go over the extensive amount of empirical data
Preliminary questions:
  What are the differences separating traditional budgeting
  from BSC?
  What are the signs of budget insufficiencies in today’s business
  environment and can these insufficiencies be resolved by
  implementing BSC?

Research Questions:
  Is it viable to completely replace budgets with BSC?
  If not, than to what extent can it replace traditional
  budgeting?

More Related Content

What's hot

Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11
Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11
Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11Rachel Chung
 
ERAU Keys to Capstone Success
ERAU Keys to Capstone SuccessERAU Keys to Capstone Success
ERAU Keys to Capstone SuccessERAUWebinars
 
Elements of a proposal
Elements of a proposalElements of a proposal
Elements of a proposalDierdre McKee
 
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurvey
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurveyHow to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurvey
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurveySogolytics
 
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]Fahad Mahmud Mirza
 
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2Christian Glahn
 
Final focus project - Jade
Final focus project - JadeFinal focus project - Jade
Final focus project - Jadesaja1111
 
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report Guide
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report GuideDigital Literacies Projects Interim Report Guide
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report GuideJay Allyson Dempster
 
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7sheenaindicio
 
Grant Writing Workshop
Grant Writing WorkshopGrant Writing Workshop
Grant Writing WorkshopHopkinsCFAR
 

What's hot (12)

Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11
Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11
Mff715 w1 0_course_intro_fall11
 
ERAU Keys to Capstone Success
ERAU Keys to Capstone SuccessERAU Keys to Capstone Success
ERAU Keys to Capstone Success
 
Elements of a proposal
Elements of a proposalElements of a proposal
Elements of a proposal
 
Case Study Method
Case Study MethodCase Study Method
Case Study Method
 
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurvey
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurveyHow to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurvey
How to launch an employee pulse survey program | SoGoSurvey
 
Assessment fyfa cmg
Assessment fyfa cmgAssessment fyfa cmg
Assessment fyfa cmg
 
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]
Project Proposal Basics [JUNE 2006]
 
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2
Getting Ready for the ECTEL Doctoral Consortium, Part 2
 
Final focus project - Jade
Final focus project - JadeFinal focus project - Jade
Final focus project - Jade
 
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report Guide
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report GuideDigital Literacies Projects Interim Report Guide
Digital Literacies Projects Interim Report Guide
 
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7
IT for higher thinking skills and creativity Lesson7
 
Grant Writing Workshop
Grant Writing WorkshopGrant Writing Workshop
Grant Writing Workshop
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (13)

Cuenta Conmigo
Cuenta ConmigoCuenta Conmigo
Cuenta Conmigo
 
Rosary outline
Rosary outlineRosary outline
Rosary outline
 
Colour Me Badd
Colour Me BaddColour Me Badd
Colour Me Badd
 
поп арт, соц-арт
поп арт, соц-артпоп арт, соц-арт
поп арт, соц-арт
 
Halloween page1
Halloween page1Halloween page1
Halloween page1
 
ибрагимова
ибрагимоваибрагимова
ибрагимова
 
Budder Oil
Budder OilBudder Oil
Budder Oil
 
Bret zine
Bret zineBret zine
Bret zine
 
Whitney Houston
Whitney HoustonWhitney Houston
Whitney Houston
 
We've Got to Stop Meeting Like This!
We've Got to Stop Meeting Like This!We've Got to Stop Meeting Like This!
We've Got to Stop Meeting Like This!
 
Шевченко у світі
Шевченко у світіШевченко у світі
Шевченко у світі
 
Case Iguatemi Salvador
Case Iguatemi SalvadorCase Iguatemi Salvador
Case Iguatemi Salvador
 
Rock
RockRock
Rock
 

Similar to Are Budgets Irreplaceable

Ba 550 1 Introduction
Ba 550 1 IntroductionBa 550 1 Introduction
Ba 550 1 Introductionbatestoota
 
MBA Project Report as per Osmania University
MBA Project Report as per Osmania UniversityMBA Project Report as per Osmania University
MBA Project Report as per Osmania UniversityHammaduddin
 
What is capstone
What is capstoneWhat is capstone
What is capstoneRodz Tech
 
Writingyourmanagementprojectreport
WritingyourmanagementprojectreportWritingyourmanagementprojectreport
Writingyourmanagementprojectreportabhirajpriya
 
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_semjenrefamonte
 
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...Charleston Conference
 
About assignment #4
About assignment #4About assignment #4
About assignment #4adavis46
 
How To Write Dissertations
How To Write Dissertations How To Write Dissertations
How To Write Dissertations Kuhu Pathak
 
U koersythesis&evaluation
U koersythesis&evaluationU koersythesis&evaluation
U koersythesis&evaluationloumcgill
 
NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com
 NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com
NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.comjonhson142
 
2012 report writing
2012 report writing2012 report writing
2012 report writingcherylyap61
 
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...UCLA CTSI
 
Managing Process Improvement
Managing Process ImprovementManaging Process Improvement
Managing Process ImprovementBill Fox
 
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docx
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docxMBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docx
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docxandreecapon
 
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.comPROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.commyblue101
 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com myblue41
 
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.comPROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.commyblue72
 
Advanced presentation skills
Advanced presentation skillsAdvanced presentation skills
Advanced presentation skillswaleed abdallah
 

Similar to Are Budgets Irreplaceable (20)

Ba 550 1 Introduction
Ba 550 1 IntroductionBa 550 1 Introduction
Ba 550 1 Introduction
 
MBA Project Report as per Osmania University
MBA Project Report as per Osmania UniversityMBA Project Report as per Osmania University
MBA Project Report as per Osmania University
 
What is capstone
What is capstoneWhat is capstone
What is capstone
 
Writingyourmanagementprojectreport
WritingyourmanagementprojectreportWritingyourmanagementprojectreport
Writingyourmanagementprojectreport
 
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem
02 proposal report_preparation_2nd_sem
 
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...
Rebuilding the Plane While Flying: Library/Vendor Strategies for Approval Pla...
 
About assignment #4
About assignment #4About assignment #4
About assignment #4
 
Murphy
MurphyMurphy
Murphy
 
How To Write Dissertations
How To Write Dissertations How To Write Dissertations
How To Write Dissertations
 
U koersythesis&evaluation
U koersythesis&evaluationU koersythesis&evaluation
U koersythesis&evaluation
 
NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com
 NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com
NR 451 Inspiring Innovation/tutorialrank.com
 
2012 report writing
2012 report writing2012 report writing
2012 report writing
 
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...
How to Write the “Specific Aims” Section of a Grant Application by Catherine ...
 
Managing Process Improvement
Managing Process ImprovementManaging Process Improvement
Managing Process Improvement
 
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docx
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docxMBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docx
MBA 6503 GLOBAL STRATEGY & COMPETITIVENESSCAPSTONE BUS.docx
 
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.comPROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587 Creative and Effective/newtonhelp.com
 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com 
PROJ 587 Extraordinary Life/newtonhelp.com 
 
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.comPROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.com
PROJ 587  Focus Dreams/newtonhelp.com
 
Writing a dissertation
Writing a dissertationWriting a dissertation
Writing a dissertation
 
Advanced presentation skills
Advanced presentation skillsAdvanced presentation skills
Advanced presentation skills
 

Are Budgets Irreplaceable

  • 2. Progress Table of contents The Introduction Obstacles Timeframe What needs to be done
  • 3. Introduction Completed Method Completed Theory Satisfactory, close to conclusion Empirical framework Satisfactory. Will be taking shape this week Interview arranged
  • 4. Introduction revised accordingly to feedback received New subcategories in theory
  • 5. Structural changes made: - Chapters subcategorized, content restructured, determined sourcing method (Harvard). - Sharper and clearer RQ. Preliminary RQ were made in order to provide clearer guideline for Theory.
  • 6. The “Decentralized companies”, no longer the target Grammatical errors and excessive use of the word “I” addressed Missing sources in the beginning filled in The Problem and Purpose revised: - BSC isn’t something new.. - It was difficult to understand the main point of the study
  • 7. Introduction – RQ’s constantly under magnifying glass Certain difficulties in following of Delimitations Frame of reference – What is most relevant? Constant revision Empirical framework – Varying and at times vague Stressing importance of the Interview
  • 8. Important to dispose wisely of the time left What is important? What is less important? Quality of the research needs to be kept high
  • 9. Develop a new schedule, time is short Prioritize future efforts and time on Empirical framework Arrange a second interview (Swedbank, Nordea) Conclude the frame of reference THIS WEEK Go over the extensive amount of empirical data
  • 10.
  • 11. Preliminary questions: What are the differences separating traditional budgeting from BSC? What are the signs of budget insufficiencies in today’s business environment and can these insufficiencies be resolved by implementing BSC? Research Questions: Is it viable to completely replace budgets with BSC? If not, than to what extent can it replace traditional budgeting?