SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
57% of volunteers over 50
surveyed agree that
volunteering enlarged their
social circle, and 56% said
that they did more social
activities as a result of
volunteering*
Contributing to your community increases
the quantity & quality of social connections
*Source: Morrow-Howell N, Hong SI, Tang F. (2009) Who benefits from volunteering? Variations in perceived benefits. Gerontologist.
Rate of formal and informal
volunteering fluctuate very
little across age groups.
1/3 people aged 75 and over
provide unpaid help and
support to friends or
neighbours at least once a
month – the same as for
those aged 16 - 49*
*Source: Community Life Survey 2015-16
Age does not affect the likelihood of
making a contribution
34%
29%
38%
36%
% of people who carry out informal volunteering
16 - 49 50 - 64 65 - 74 75+
Grandparents who provide
substantial care for their
grandchildren are 1.5 times
more likely to undertake
formal volunteering than
grandparents who provide
no regular care for their
grandchildren*
*Source: Bulanda and Jendrek (2016) Grandparenting roles and volunteer activity, Journals of Gerontology: Series B
Caring and volunteering often go hand in
hand
32%
84%
Among people aged 50
and over, those in the
richest 20% are more than
three times more likely to
engage in formal volun-
teering than those in the
poorest 20%*
Nazroo, J. and Matthews, K. (2012) The impact of volunteering on well-being in later life, London: WRVS
% of people who volunteer
% of people who do not volunteer
Income & volunteering are closely connected
£££
£
Community contributions and
acts of neighbourliness bring
people together and help
build social connections, as
well as increasing wellbeing,
life satisfaction and give
people a sense of purpose*
*Source: The Benefits of Making a Contribution to Your Community in Later Life, 2016; Centre for Ageing Better
Reciprocity
Social connections
Feedback and
validation
Structure and
purpose
Wellbeing
Life satisfaction
Quality of life
Mental health
Access to
mutual / peer
support
The benefits of
community
contributions
Informal volunteering has
been shown to have a positive
impact on life satisfaction &
wellbeing*
Making contributions can also
help provide a sense of
pupose for those in later life**
Community contributions & acts of neighbourliness
increase wellbeing and give people a sense of
purpose
*Source: De Wit et al., 2015 **Source: Bradley, 2000; Narushima 2005

More Related Content

What's hot

Initiatives of Generation Citizen
Initiatives of Generation Citizen Initiatives of Generation Citizen
Initiatives of Generation Citizen
Samuel Zurier
 
Paul McGarry
Paul McGarryPaul McGarry
Paul McGarry
NMJones
 
The Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
The Impact of Sports on Criminal BehaviorThe Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
The Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
Keith Clinkscales
 
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of ChangeAdvancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
Bill Ryerson (Immigration)
 

What's hot (20)

Community Development and Health
Community Development and HealthCommunity Development and Health
Community Development and Health
 
RIWC_Lord Filkin
RIWC_Lord FilkinRIWC_Lord Filkin
RIWC_Lord Filkin
 
RIWC_ Charlotte Clarke revised
RIWC_ Charlotte Clarke revisedRIWC_ Charlotte Clarke revised
RIWC_ Charlotte Clarke revised
 
Initiatives of Generation Citizen
Initiatives of Generation Citizen Initiatives of Generation Citizen
Initiatives of Generation Citizen
 
Paul McGarry
Paul McGarryPaul McGarry
Paul McGarry
 
Ageing Well - Paul McGarry's Leadership Academy presentation
Ageing Well - Paul McGarry's Leadership Academy presentationAgeing Well - Paul McGarry's Leadership Academy presentation
Ageing Well - Paul McGarry's Leadership Academy presentation
 
The opportunities of an ageing society: looking beyond the challenges
The opportunities of an ageing society: looking beyond the challengesThe opportunities of an ageing society: looking beyond the challenges
The opportunities of an ageing society: looking beyond the challenges
 
Community development in end of life care
Community development in end of life careCommunity development in end of life care
Community development in end of life care
 
Andrus award release
Andrus award releaseAndrus award release
Andrus award release
 
City Council Presentation 1
City Council Presentation 1City Council Presentation 1
City Council Presentation 1
 
Use of volunteer, Social Support and Self Help Groups
Use of volunteer, Social Support and Self Help GroupsUse of volunteer, Social Support and Self Help Groups
Use of volunteer, Social Support and Self Help Groups
 
What is Public Policy and How Does it Affect me? | Jenn Galandy
What is Public Policy and How Does it Affect me? | Jenn Galandy What is Public Policy and How Does it Affect me? | Jenn Galandy
What is Public Policy and How Does it Affect me? | Jenn Galandy
 
Se mainstreaming
Se mainstreamingSe mainstreaming
Se mainstreaming
 
The State of Inequality in Dallas
The State of Inequality in DallasThe State of Inequality in Dallas
The State of Inequality in Dallas
 
Lawrence County Historical Society Overview
Lawrence County Historical Society OverviewLawrence County Historical Society Overview
Lawrence County Historical Society Overview
 
Conditions of the senior citizens in india today
Conditions of the senior citizens in india todayConditions of the senior citizens in india today
Conditions of the senior citizens in india today
 
The Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
The Impact of Sports on Criminal BehaviorThe Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
The Impact of Sports on Criminal Behavior
 
EOA2015: Unleashing the Power of Local Non profits
EOA2015: Unleashing the Power of Local Non profitsEOA2015: Unleashing the Power of Local Non profits
EOA2015: Unleashing the Power of Local Non profits
 
Praxe as Spaces and Times for Interactions among Peers: Participation, voice ...
Praxe as Spaces and Times for Interactions among Peers: Participation, voice ...Praxe as Spaces and Times for Interactions among Peers: Participation, voice ...
Praxe as Spaces and Times for Interactions among Peers: Participation, voice ...
 
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of ChangeAdvancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
Advancing Society through PMC’s Theory of Change
 

Similar to Community Contributions Infographic

12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
EttaBenton28
 
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
ChantellPantoja184
 
Forms of community participation among older people luana valletta
Forms of community participation among older people luana vallettaForms of community participation among older people luana valletta
Forms of community participation among older people luana valletta
Luana Valletta
 
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
CSV_UK
 
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
RV Rikard
 
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd reviewBHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
Leon Delpech
 
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-HelferichA-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
Samantha Helferich
 

Similar to Community Contributions Infographic (20)

Community contributions in later life
Community contributions in later lifeCommunity contributions in later life
Community contributions in later life
 
Community Contributions in Later Life
Community Contributions in Later LifeCommunity Contributions in Later Life
Community Contributions in Later Life
 
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
 
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
12Survey QuestionsDefinitionsCommunity service- a proje
 
Volunteering - the new alchemy - AVM Conference 2014
Volunteering - the new alchemy - AVM Conference 2014Volunteering - the new alchemy - AVM Conference 2014
Volunteering - the new alchemy - AVM Conference 2014
 
Ipsos-Mori Survey - Summary Presentation
Ipsos-Mori Survey - Summary PresentationIpsos-Mori Survey - Summary Presentation
Ipsos-Mori Survey - Summary Presentation
 
Forms of community participation among older people luana valletta
Forms of community participation among older people luana vallettaForms of community participation among older people luana valletta
Forms of community participation among older people luana valletta
 
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
Professor Jane South, Leeds Metropolitan University
 
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
2007 Southern Soc. Society - "The Strength of Strong Ties for Older Adults: I...
 
Youth Social Action in the UK - 2014
Youth Social Action in the UK - 2014Youth Social Action in the UK - 2014
Youth Social Action in the UK - 2014
 
Recruitment and Retention of Volunteers Presentation
Recruitment and Retention of Volunteers PresentationRecruitment and Retention of Volunteers Presentation
Recruitment and Retention of Volunteers Presentation
 
Attitudes and Action: How do young people understand and engage with voluntee...
Attitudes and Action: How do young people understand and engage with voluntee...Attitudes and Action: How do young people understand and engage with voluntee...
Attitudes and Action: How do young people understand and engage with voluntee...
 
Eurokid involves in the society needs theory
Eurokid involves in the society needs theoryEurokid involves in the society needs theory
Eurokid involves in the society needs theory
 
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd reviewBHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review
 
Youth Philanthropy: Empowering Youth to Become Contributing Members of Society
Youth Philanthropy: Empowering Youth to Become Contributing Members of SocietyYouth Philanthropy: Empowering Youth to Become Contributing Members of Society
Youth Philanthropy: Empowering Youth to Become Contributing Members of Society
 
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-HelferichA-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
 
A Study of Older Australians Volunteering and Quality of Life Empirical Evi...
A Study of Older Australians  Volunteering and Quality of Life  Empirical Evi...A Study of Older Australians  Volunteering and Quality of Life  Empirical Evi...
A Study of Older Australians Volunteering and Quality of Life Empirical Evi...
 
Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Poverty in Southwest PA - A Strategy for Stoppi...
Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Poverty in Southwest PA - A Strategy for Stoppi...Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Poverty in Southwest PA - A Strategy for Stoppi...
Pittsburgh Nonprofit Summit - Poverty in Southwest PA - A Strategy for Stoppi...
 
1017_Engaging Volunteers as Donors.pdf
1017_Engaging Volunteers as Donors.pdf1017_Engaging Volunteers as Donors.pdf
1017_Engaging Volunteers as Donors.pdf
 
blog
blogblog
blog
 

More from Centre for Ageing Better

More from Centre for Ageing Better (20)

The State of Ageing - understanding ethnic inequalities in later life
The State of Ageing - understanding ethnic inequalities in later lifeThe State of Ageing - understanding ethnic inequalities in later life
The State of Ageing - understanding ethnic inequalities in later life
 
How to show ageing from a new perspective
How to show ageing from a new perspectiveHow to show ageing from a new perspective
How to show ageing from a new perspective
 
The State of Ageing 2022
The State of Ageing 2022The State of Ageing 2022
The State of Ageing 2022
 
Community connections as we age: lessons from the pandemic
Community connections as we age: lessons from the pandemicCommunity connections as we age: lessons from the pandemic
Community connections as we age: lessons from the pandemic
 
Best foot forward: Understanding active travel
Best foot forward: Understanding active travelBest foot forward: Understanding active travel
Best foot forward: Understanding active travel
 
The Good Home Inquiry: How to get the homes we want
The Good Home Inquiry: How to get the homes we wantThe Good Home Inquiry: How to get the homes we want
The Good Home Inquiry: How to get the homes we want
 
Keep on movin' - the importance of staying active in your 50s and 60s
Keep on movin' - the importance of staying active in your 50s and 60sKeep on movin' - the importance of staying active in your 50s and 60s
Keep on movin' - the importance of staying active in your 50s and 60s
 
How does digital connectivity enhance a good home webinar
How does digital connectivity enhance a good home webinarHow does digital connectivity enhance a good home webinar
How does digital connectivity enhance a good home webinar
 
Putting age in the frame - webinar slides
Putting age in the frame - webinar slidesPutting age in the frame - webinar slides
Putting age in the frame - webinar slides
 
Digital skills to connect webinar slides
Digital skills to connect webinar slidesDigital skills to connect webinar slides
Digital skills to connect webinar slides
 
Health and work: A healthy ageing webinar
Health and work: A healthy ageing webinarHealth and work: A healthy ageing webinar
Health and work: A healthy ageing webinar
 
Sustaining physical activity
Sustaining physical activitySustaining physical activity
Sustaining physical activity
 
Home improvement survey
Home improvement surveyHome improvement survey
Home improvement survey
 
Good homes for all - who pays? Webinar slides
Good homes for all - who pays? Webinar slidesGood homes for all - who pays? Webinar slides
Good homes for all - who pays? Webinar slides
 
Age inclusive workforces: the business case and putting it into practice
Age inclusive workforces: the business case and putting it into practiceAge inclusive workforces: the business case and putting it into practice
Age inclusive workforces: the business case and putting it into practice
 
Ageing in a rural place webinar
Ageing in a rural place webinarAgeing in a rural place webinar
Ageing in a rural place webinar
 
One year on the impact of COVID-19 on the lives of people approaching later life
One year on the impact of COVID-19 on the lives of people approaching later lifeOne year on the impact of COVID-19 on the lives of people approaching later life
One year on the impact of COVID-19 on the lives of people approaching later life
 
Health inequalities: Healthy ageing webinars
Health inequalities: Healthy ageing webinarsHealth inequalities: Healthy ageing webinars
Health inequalities: Healthy ageing webinars
 
The State of Ageing in 2020
The State of Ageing in 2020The State of Ageing in 2020
The State of Ageing in 2020
 
Lorraine morley slides recording age tech mkt and products
Lorraine morley slides recording  age tech mkt and productsLorraine morley slides recording  age tech mkt and products
Lorraine morley slides recording age tech mkt and products
 

Recently uploaded

Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
Chandigarh Call girls 9053900678 Call girls in Chandigarh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Election 2024 Presiding Duty Keypoints_01.pdf
Election 2024 Presiding Duty Keypoints_01.pdfElection 2024 Presiding Duty Keypoints_01.pdf
Election 2024 Presiding Duty Keypoints_01.pdf
 
Call Girls Nanded City Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Nanded City Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Nanded City Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Nanded City Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
celebrity 💋 Agra Escorts Just Dail 8250092165 service available anytime 24 hour
celebrity 💋 Agra Escorts Just Dail 8250092165 service available anytime 24 hourcelebrity 💋 Agra Escorts Just Dail 8250092165 service available anytime 24 hour
celebrity 💋 Agra Escorts Just Dail 8250092165 service available anytime 24 hour
 
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCCAn Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
 
VIP Model Call Girls Baramati ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to...
VIP Model Call Girls Baramati ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to...VIP Model Call Girls Baramati ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to...
VIP Model Call Girls Baramati ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to...
 
SMART BANGLADESH I PPTX I SLIDE IShovan Prita Paul.pptx
SMART BANGLADESH  I    PPTX   I    SLIDE   IShovan Prita Paul.pptxSMART BANGLADESH  I    PPTX   I    SLIDE   IShovan Prita Paul.pptx
SMART BANGLADESH I PPTX I SLIDE IShovan Prita Paul.pptx
 
VIP Model Call Girls Kiwale ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to 2...
VIP Model Call Girls Kiwale ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to 2...VIP Model Call Girls Kiwale ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to 2...
VIP Model Call Girls Kiwale ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K to 2...
 
Hinjewadi * VIP Call Girls Pune | Whatsapp No 8005736733 VIP Escorts Service ...
Hinjewadi * VIP Call Girls Pune | Whatsapp No 8005736733 VIP Escorts Service ...Hinjewadi * VIP Call Girls Pune | Whatsapp No 8005736733 VIP Escorts Service ...
Hinjewadi * VIP Call Girls Pune | Whatsapp No 8005736733 VIP Escorts Service ...
 
Akurdi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For S...
Akurdi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For S...Akurdi ( Call Girls ) Pune  6297143586  Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For S...
Akurdi ( Call Girls ) Pune 6297143586 Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Ready For S...
 
Call Girls Sangamwadi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Sangamwadi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Sangamwadi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Sangamwadi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
The Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) has been advised by the Office...
The Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) has been advised by the Office...The Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) has been advised by the Office...
The Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) has been advised by the Office...
 
Call Girls Chakan Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Chakan Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Chakan Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Chakan Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
 
best call girls in Pune - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8005736733 Neha Thakur
best call girls in Pune - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8005736733 Neha Thakurbest call girls in Pune - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8005736733 Neha Thakur
best call girls in Pune - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8005736733 Neha Thakur
 
(NEHA) Call Girls Nagpur Call Now 8250077686 Nagpur Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Nagpur Call Now 8250077686 Nagpur Escorts 24x7(NEHA) Call Girls Nagpur Call Now 8250077686 Nagpur Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Nagpur Call Now 8250077686 Nagpur Escorts 24x7
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 31
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 312024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 31
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 31
 
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
 
The NAP process & South-South peer learning
The NAP process & South-South peer learningThe NAP process & South-South peer learning
The NAP process & South-South peer learning
 
Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
Russian🍌Dazzling Hottie Get☎️ 9053900678 ☎️call girl In Chandigarh By Chandig...
 
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCCFinance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
Finance strategies for adaptation. Presentation for CANCC
 

Community Contributions Infographic

  • 1. 57% of volunteers over 50 surveyed agree that volunteering enlarged their social circle, and 56% said that they did more social activities as a result of volunteering* Contributing to your community increases the quantity & quality of social connections *Source: Morrow-Howell N, Hong SI, Tang F. (2009) Who benefits from volunteering? Variations in perceived benefits. Gerontologist.
  • 2. Rate of formal and informal volunteering fluctuate very little across age groups. 1/3 people aged 75 and over provide unpaid help and support to friends or neighbours at least once a month – the same as for those aged 16 - 49* *Source: Community Life Survey 2015-16 Age does not affect the likelihood of making a contribution 34% 29% 38% 36% % of people who carry out informal volunteering 16 - 49 50 - 64 65 - 74 75+
  • 3. Grandparents who provide substantial care for their grandchildren are 1.5 times more likely to undertake formal volunteering than grandparents who provide no regular care for their grandchildren* *Source: Bulanda and Jendrek (2016) Grandparenting roles and volunteer activity, Journals of Gerontology: Series B Caring and volunteering often go hand in hand 32% 84%
  • 4. Among people aged 50 and over, those in the richest 20% are more than three times more likely to engage in formal volun- teering than those in the poorest 20%* Nazroo, J. and Matthews, K. (2012) The impact of volunteering on well-being in later life, London: WRVS % of people who volunteer % of people who do not volunteer Income & volunteering are closely connected £££ £
  • 5. Community contributions and acts of neighbourliness bring people together and help build social connections, as well as increasing wellbeing, life satisfaction and give people a sense of purpose* *Source: The Benefits of Making a Contribution to Your Community in Later Life, 2016; Centre for Ageing Better Reciprocity Social connections Feedback and validation Structure and purpose Wellbeing Life satisfaction Quality of life Mental health Access to mutual / peer support The benefits of community contributions
  • 6. Informal volunteering has been shown to have a positive impact on life satisfaction & wellbeing* Making contributions can also help provide a sense of pupose for those in later life** Community contributions & acts of neighbourliness increase wellbeing and give people a sense of purpose *Source: De Wit et al., 2015 **Source: Bradley, 2000; Narushima 2005