This document provides guidance on assessing failing, struggling, or underperforming association programs through a thorough review process. It outlines key steps, including: defining goals for the review by getting input from stakeholders; exploring the original program goals and how it has changed over time; researching through historical documents, opinions, and behavior data; measuring outputs, outcomes, and impacts; assessing efficiency and finances; determining who to involve in the implementation; and clearly communicating the results and recommendations. The overall lessons are to seek to understand the program's purpose and evolution, make decisions based on comprehensive data collection, and plan for changes resulting from the review.