SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper
NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPrimary care of women aging with
HIVWomen are living longer with HIV infection, but their life expectancy remains shorter
than for women in the general population. How best to manage the multiple comorbidity
and poly pharmacy that are common in individuals with HIV has not been studied. This
article explores areas where the primary care of women with HIV may differ from that of
aging women in the general population. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
Paper We also discuss aspects of care that may not commonly be considered in those under
the age of 65, specifically multi morbidity and poly pharmacy. Incorporating a
gerontological approach in the care of these women may optimize outcomes until research
provides more definitive answers for how best to collaborate with women with HIV in order
to provide them with optimal care.ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREWomen need
specialized care throughout their lives. Northern Light Women’s Health practices provide
that personal care and perspective that help you lead your best life. We understand your
needs and are here with you every step of the way, from childhood all the way through your
adult life. We believe a strong relationship leads to the best care for you.At Northern Light
Health, we have specialized women’s practices that meet your needs instead of applying a
universal medical point of view. We encourage you to learn more and see if this approach
feels right for your care. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPrimary Care
and WomenHealthcare for women in the primary care setting requires up-to-date, gender-
specific knowledge regarding disease prevention and disease management. In addition,
women often look to their healthcare provider for information to help them look and feel
healthy throughout their life span. This summary describes the highlights of several of the
primary care-focused sessions devoted to wellness, disease states affecting women, and
health-enhancing strategies. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperChronic
Fatigue SyndromeAutoimmune disease affects women at a higher rate than men. Chronic
fatigue syndrome (CFS) is classified as an autoimmune disease, affecting women at 2 to 3
times the rate of men.[1] In her presentation, "Hunting Zebra: Understanding and Treating
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome," Marianne Nihart, MA, ARNP, CS, BC, who is in private practice
in Pacifica, California, and a member of the Clinical Faculty at University of California at
Davis, provided a helpful overview of this complex condition. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research PaperFatigue is a common symptom, reported by as many as 20% of
individuals seeking medical care. Typically, fatigue is transient, self-limiting, and
circumstantial. CFS, on the other hand, is associated with debilitating fatigue and a cluster of
symptoms that predominantly feature impaired concentration, impaired short-term
memory, sleep disturbances, and musculoskeletal pain. The high prevalence of fatigue in the
primary care setting places a barrier to diagnosis of CFS.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research Paper Nihart's presentation dispels 3 myths regarding CFS.Myth 1: CFS is
a relatively rare disorder. In reality, CFS has a prevalence of approximately 200-500 per
100,000, twice the prevalence of multiple sclerosis. Yet only about 16% of those with
symptoms have been accurately diagnosed.[1]Myth 2: The highest prevalence is among
young, affluent, white professional women. CFS does affect women more frequently than
men. It is most commonly diagnosed in women aged 20 to 40 years, and affects black and
Hispanic individuals, as well as whites.[1]Myth 3: CFS is a form of depression. Often, the
onset of CFS occurs with influenza. Most women affected by CFS do not have a history of
depression, nor does depression seem to occur in CFS clusters or outbreaks. Fatigue is the
primary complaint in CFS, although depression may occur later, after the onset of
disease.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper CFS is a diagnosis of
exclusion. According to the 1994 international case definition from the US Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), CFS is characterized by the following
criteria:Persistent or relapsing fatigue lasting 6 months or longer, which is sufficiently
severe to reduce the person's ability to perform 1 or more aspects of daily lifeMust be
unexplained by other medical or psychiatric conditionsAccompanied by 4 or more of the
following symptoms:Impaired memorySore throatTender cervical or axillary lymph
nodesMuscle painMulti-joint painNew headachesUnrefreshing sleepPost-exertional malaise
lasting more than 24 hours[2]Because CFS is a diagnosis of exclusion, the road to an
accurate diagnosis can be long and frustrating. Clinicians who approach the diagnostic
process with nonjudgmental empathy, compassion for the struggle, systematic investigative
skills, and the ability to instill hope and empower self care are the most likely to successfully
work with the CFS patient.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
Paper Generally, the patient will present with fatigue as the chief complaint. During the
initial interview, it is helpful to obtain a detailed history, including a review of medications
that can cause fatigue. In addition to the symptoms listed in the CDC International Case
Definition above, the symptom checklist should include unexplained, generalized muscle
weakness, generalized fatigue lasting longer than 24 hours, generalized headaches,
migratory painful joints without redness or swelling, areas of lost or depressed vision,
visual light intolerance, forgetfulness, excessive irritability, confusion, and an inability to
concentrate. Depression may also be present, though not as a primary, defining
symptom.Laboratory screening may include urinalysis, complete blood count and
differential, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) or C-reactive protein, alanine
aminotransferase or aspartate transaminase serum level, albumin, globulin, alkaline
phosphatase, glucose, calcium, phosphorus, thyroid-stimulating hormone and free T4, and
rheumatoid factor if arthritic complaints are present.[1,2] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research Paper Before CFS can be confirmed, the clinician must rule out a myriad
of other diagnoses as diverse as eating disorders, Lyme disease, cancer, psychiatric
disorders, and other autoimmune diseases.[1,2] Common differential diagnoses include
multiple sclerosis or systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).Laboratory or physical findings,
as well as disease progression, can help to refine the diagnosis. Other diagnoses to consider
include chronic multiple symptom illness (Gulf War illness) and fibromyalgia. Gulf War
illness can be differentiated through a history of chemical exposures in the Gulf War.
Patients with fibromyalgia tend to present with an emphasis on musculoskeletal pain rather
than debilitating fatigue.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Optimal
treatment results are achieved with a multidisciplinary approach that emphasizes
education, cognitive behavioral therapy, exercise, stress management, and attention to
associated symptoms. Pharmacologic treatment using tricyclic antidepressants for sleep
disturbances and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) or mild narcotics for pain
management may be helpful. Complementary therapies, such as massage, biofeedback, and
meditation, may also help in symptom relief.[1,3,4] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women
Research Paper Longitudinal studies show that although 17% to 64% of patients with CFS
improve, less than 10% fully recover, and 10% to 20% worsen during follow-up. Older
persons, and those with longer illness duration and comorbid psychiatric conditions, are at
risk for poorer prognosis.[1-3]Skin Care: Preserving the Fountain of YouthWomen in the
primary care setting often express concern regarding the effects of aging on the appearance
of their skin. In "Preserving the Fountain of Youth," Julie M. Countess, MD, a dermatologist
with Florida Skin Cancer & Dermatology Specialists, PA in Gainesville, Florida, provided an
overview of topical anti-aging skin care regimens with known clinical benefit, and an update
on minimally invasive procedures, such as botulinum toxin (Botox), fillers, and chemical
peels.[5]Signs of aging on the face include increased pigmentation, telangiectasia (spider
veins), and rougher skin texture, as well as wrinkles and sagging due to fat loss. Popular
cosmeceutical ingredients purported to combat the signs of aging consist of vitamin A
preparations, including Retin A and retinoids, alpha-hydroxy acids, and the antioxidants --
vitamins C and E, lipoic acid, coenzyme Q-10, green tea, kinetin, and idebenone.[5]But what
works? According to Dr. Countess, the retinoids, alpha-hydroxy acid, and some antioxidants
can have a beneficial effect on skin. Retinoids treat photoaging by reversing cellular atypia,
increasing epidermal thickness, and increasing collagen synthesis. This action may result in
improved skin texture, reduced pigmentation and fine lines, and smaller pores. Side effects,
including peeling and irritation (retinoid dermatitis), redness, and dryness, are more
common with the prescription preparations.In the appropriate vehicle and concentration,
according to Dr. Countess, over-the-counter preparations may be as effective as
prescription products, with fewer side effects. Dr. Countess recommends applying only a
"pea sized" amount of the retinoid preparation about 20 minutes after washing the face,
initially at every-other-day intervals. Reading labels is important, as retinyl palmitate is not
biologically active in the skin.[5]The alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs) are the most popular anti-
aging product. Like the retinoids, AHAs increase skin thickness, improve skin texture, and
treat pigmentation problems. In addition to their moisturizing effect, AHAs are also helpful
in increasing collagen synthesis and enhancing the quality of elastic fibers. AHAs have a
known potential for photosensitivity and irritation, so they should be used with an SPF
sunscreen product.[5,6] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper ORDER A
PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREThe free-radical theory suggests that the effects of free
radicals, lipid peroxidation, DNA damage, and inflammation play a role in aging. The
antioxidants work to prevent free-radical damage. Evidence suggests that vitamin C
functions as an antioxidant by decreasing free radicals. It has been shown to increase
collagen synthesis and decrease pigmentation problems. However, there is less evidence
regarding topical vitamin C's effect on improvement of wrinkles, which may be due to
irritation and dermal edema. In addition to being very expensive to properly formulate,
most vitamin C preparations are unstable when exposed to air or light, and many
formulations do not penetrate the top layers of skin.[5]Vitamin E is considered to be an
excellent moisturizer. Benefits related to prevention of skin cancer and anti-aging have not
been established. Contact dermatitis is a common side effect, with a 20% to 33% rate of
contact dermatitis occurring when vitamin E is applied to surgical scars.[5]Other
antioxidant preparations under consideration include lipoic acid and green tea. Topical
application of 3% lipoic acid has been shown to reduce redness induced by sun exposure,
which suggests that topical lipoic acid could prevent free-radical damage. The polyphenols
in green tea have antioxidant properties. Sun-induced redness seems to be decreased in
skin treated with green tea components. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperCurrently, the "cosmeceutical" advantage of these products is unclear.[5] However,
kinetin, another new product, seems to be a safe moisturizer with antioxidant properties
that improves fine lines and wrinkles. Although it is not as effective as the retinoids, it may
be useful as an adjunct to retinoid therapies.[5,6]Regardless of skin care regimen, Dr.
Countess says that daily use of sunscreen is essential to skin health. A broad-spectrum
sunscreen is best. She recommends SPF 15 for everyday use and SPF 30 for outdoor activity.
Patients with sensitive skin may need physical blockers.[5,6]In terms of daily skin care, Dr.
Countess recommends a simple morning and evening regimen to cleanse, treat, and protect
the skin. In the morning, begin by cleansing with a gentle cleanser, or a cleanser with
hydroxyl acid. Follow with an antioxidant cream, and protect with sunscreen. At the end of
the day, cleanse the face again with the same product, protect with a retinoid, and apply
moisturizer, particularly if there are problems with dryness.[5,6] Women should discuss
skin care concerns with their healthcare provider.Although topical agents may help with
skin texture, pigmentation problems, and pores, they will not treat "dynamic lines" -- the
furrow between the eyebrows, or fat loss and sagging. Botox, fillers, and radiofrequency
treatments may be an option for some conditions. Laser treatments may be considered for
treatment of spider veins.[5] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
Paper Rheumatic DiseasesRheumatic diseases are among the most prevalent chronic
conditions in the United States. Although the primary cause is unknown, gender and age
appear to play a role. Women account for more than two thirds of those affected by
rheumatic disease.[7] In a general session on rheumatic diseases, Joyce P. Carlone, MN,
CFNP, Nurse Practitioner at Emory University, Department of Medicine/Division of
Rheumatology, Atlanta, Georgia, provided an overview of the disease process, diagnosis, and
treatment of 3 common rheumatoid diseases that affect women.Rheumatoid
ArthritisRheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, inflammatory, systemic disease that is 2.5
times more common in women than in men. In RA, the synovial membrane is inflamed, and
there is destruction of the periarticular bone and cartilage. Multiple joints may be affected
and joint deformities may be present.[7,8] A diagnosis of RA is made when 4 or more of the
following criteria are present for at least 6 weeks: NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women
Research PaperMorning stiffness lasting 1 hour or moreArthritis of 3 joint areasArthritis of
the hand jointsSymmetric arthritisRheumatoid nodulesSerum rheumatoid factorPresence
of bony erosions on x-rayIncreased ESR correlates with the degree of synovial
inflammation. A positive rheumatoid factor in the absence of other symptoms is not
diagnostic for RA. Some persons unaffected by RA, the elderly without RA, or persons with
other disease states, such as Sjögren's syndrome, may also have positive serum rheumatoid
factor.[7,8]Pharmacologic treatment of RA includes NSAIDs, such as ibuprofen, naproxen, or
celecoxib. Disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs, including hydroxychloroquine, gold,
leflunomide, sulfasalazine, methotrexates, and biologics, are also used to treat RA.
Leflunomide and methotrexate are category X drugs that have been linked to spontaneous
abortion, cleft palate, and hydrocephaly when used prenatally. Men and women both must
be off of leflunomide for a minimum of 3 months before trying to conceive. It is also
contraindicated during lactation.[8]Systemic Lupus ErythematosusSLE is a relatively
uncommon illness, with an estimated prevalence rate of 15 to 52/100,000. Women are
disproportionately affected, approximately 8 to 10 times more frequently than men.[7] The
prevalence is even higher in blacks, occurring at a rate of 400/100,000.[7]SLE is a chronic
inflammatory disease of unknown etiology. It is characterized by the production of
autoantibodies. Simply put, the T cells fail to recognize the "self" antigens and the B cells are
hyperactive. Patients with SLE may present with constitutional symptoms, such as low-
grade fever, weight loss, swollen glands, fatigue, and aching. Raynaud's phenomenon may
also be present. Approximately 50% of patients present with symptoms such as
musculoskeletal complaints/polyarthritis, skin changes, hair loss, cognitive dysfunction,
and serositis. The other 50% of patients exhibit symptoms indicative of internal organ
involvement, such as blood value changes and central nervous system, heart, and lung
symptoms. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe 1997 American
College of Rheumatology revised criteria for SLE can be remembered using the acronym
SOAP BRAIN MD:SerositisOral ulcersArthritis (deformity can be reduced with
SLE)PhotosensitivityBlood disorder (hemolytic anemia, leukopenia, lymphopenia,
thrombocytopenia)Renal disorderANA (antinuclear antibodies)Immunologic
disorderNeurologic disorderMalar rash (butterfly rash)Discoid rash (hyperpigmentation
and scarring)[9]Laboratory work may be helpful, but is not diagnostic. The ANA is sensitive,
but has low specificity for SLE. The autoantibodies to the human-like SM protein (anti LSM)
and antibodies to double-stranded DNA (anti-ds DNA) are more specific for SLE.[8]SLE can
improve, worsen, or stay the same during pregnancy. Pregnancy in SLE is associated with
higher rates of miscarriage, stillbirth, premature birth, intrauterine growth restriction, and
pre-eclampsia. The best pregnancy outcomes occur when the disease is not active at the
time of conception.[7,8] Some women with SLE are also affected by antiphospholipid
syndrome, which is characterized by recurrent arterial/venous thrombosis, fetal losses,
thrombocytopenia plus the presence of anticardiolipin antibodies, or lupus anticoagulant.
NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperAntiphospholipid syndrome is
suspected when women experience 1 or more miscarriages after the 10th week of gestation
with normal fetal morphology, 3 or more miscarriages prior to 10 weeks with hormonal and
genetic causes excluded, or 1 or more preterm births at less than 34 weeks' gestation.
Treatment of antiphospholipid syndrome in pregnancy includes daily low-dose (81 mg)
aspirin, and heparin 5000 - 10,000 U subcutaneously twice
daily.[8]SclerodermaScleroderma, or systemic sclerosis (SS), is a connective tissue disease
characterized by degenerative, inflammatory, fibrotic changes of the skin, blood vessels,
joints, tendons, skeletal muscle, gastrointestinal tract, lungs, heart, and kidneys.[10] SS
affects approximately 150 patients/million, and many more females than males are
affected.[8]The 2 major subtypes of SS are diffuse scleroderma and limited scleroderma.
Diffuse scleroderma is more severe, with a 5-year survival rate of approximately 75%.
Limited scleroderma has a 5-year survival rate of 80% to 85%.[8] Patients with SS
experience tightening and thickening of the skin, usually beginning with the hands, fingers,
and face. Raynaud's phenomenon is present in most cases. The internal organs are also
affected. Organ damage worsens as the skin damage worsens, with internal organ damage
linked to the extent and progression of skin thickening.[8,10]Treatment is directed at
controlling symptoms. Supportive therapy and monitoring for organ involvement are the
foundation of management. Calcium channel blockers, angiotensin-converting enzyme
inhibitors, and low-dose aspirin may be prescribed for cardiovascular effects. A number of
gastrointestinal effects occur with SS. Esophageal changes may result in dysphagia or
gastroesophogeal reflux, which is often treated with proton pump inhibitors. Low-dose
prednisone or NSAIDs may help to control arthritis symptoms. Patients receiving
prednisone or NSAIDs should be monitored carefully for gastrointestinal bleeding. Nitrate
cream helps vasodilatation in the finger vessels and is often recommended for daily skin
care.[8,10]Pregnancy tends to aggravate gastrointestinal and cardiopulmonary symptoms,
and poses an increased threat of renal crisis for the mother. Pregnant women with SS
require high-risk obstetric care and monitoring. Because women with SS are at greater risk
of vasoconstriction, vascular occlusion, and clotting, estrogen-containing contraceptives are
contraindicated. Barrier and progestin-only methods would be appropriate.[8] NURS 6551 -
Primary Care of Women Research Paper SummaryRheumatic diseases disproportionately
affect women. Diagnosis may be delayed due to the complex nature of the symptoms and
diagnostic processes. NPs working with women in OB/GYN practices as well as other
primary care practices need to be aware of the diagnostic criteria and initial management
parameters for these diseases. In addition to their role in disease management, NPs who
provide care to women also provide important health-promotion and disease-prevention
information, designed to enhance physical and emotional health and self esteem. This
article blends important information about disease state management and health
promotion, a combination that reflects women's primary healthcare needs.These days
patient care in the primary care setting can be a daunting task. With the influx of patients
who had, until the Affordable Care Act (ACA), been largely neglected and had gone
untreated now presenting with a myriad of ailments and an array of complicated and
muddled complaints, the Primary Care Provider (PCP) is being challenged like never
before.Confounding our critical time limitations, much of which is spent in efforts geared
toward determining what will be covered by the patient’s insurance, is the challenge to
implement the most progressive and effective standards of care given the complexity of
judging the benefits and risks of modalities that may not be considered as traditional areas
of focus for the PCP. Perhaps no other treatment modality has sparked more debate then
that of Bio identical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT). NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research Paper With the immense interest generated by popular media, social
networking and internet based information, patients often turn to their PCP for evidence
based information and education. For the PCP this presents a unique opportunity as this can
often be a critical period to evaluate risk for future health problems, provide proactive
preventive care guidelines, prevent morbidity and decrease mortality. The primary care
setting is on the front line of healthcare services and often serves to facilitate a cascade of all
future healthcare needs of the patient. Proper evaluation and diagnosis is essential in
providing efficient and effective care. In a time when financial expenditure, budgets and
profits are an unfortunate reality of healthcare the decisions made at the primary care level
can impact not only the patient but the entire health care system. [1]The aim of this paper is
to specifically discuss BHRT in menopausal women and the unique role of the Primary Care
Provider in assessment, evaluation, initiation and follow up of such patients in the primary
care setting. Due to limitations in space and the reader’s time, this conversation will be
restricted to discussion of basic protocols and guidelines that can be easily implemented in
a primary care setting. The main goal is to familiarize the PCP with typical characteristics a
patient may present with who may be an appropriate candidate for hormonal therapy that
may otherwise, in less astute eyes, be incorrectly assessed thus leading to needless
exposure to redundant diagnostic evaluation, inappropriate interventions and pointless
therapeutic modalities. [2]Women and the Physiology of AgingAging is the natural change
in structure and function that results from the passage of time in absence of known
pathology and disease. During the transition from reproductive years through menopause
and beyond women experience many physiological changes that are normal consequences
of the aging process. Although the observed changes around the time of menopause are
often due to the natural decline in hormone production, these signs and symptoms may
often mimic and erroneously be mistaken for, signs of illness or disease. [3] NURS 6551 -
Primary Care of Women Research PaperMenopause represents the permanent cessation of
menses. Most women reach menopause between the ages of 45 and 55, with average onset
in the Western world being at age 52. Due to the relatively wide age range for natural
menopause, chronological age may not be an adequate indicator of the beginning or end of
the transition process. Although menopause is perhaps the most obvious and expected
physical event, general knowledge about the process, symptoms and effective management
is often inadequate. [4] Thus this presents a unique opportunity for the primary care
provider to effectively and efficiently manage what could potentially influence a woman’s
perceived well being, overall quality of life and health status. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research PaperMidlife Physiological Changes: Is this Disease or Menopause?All
women will experience menopause. However, each will do so in a very individual and
unique way. Although the majority of women will report experiencing common symptoms
in relation to the physiologic hormonal changes associated with menopause (night sweats,
hot flashes and menstrual irregularities) there are numerous other presenting
symptomology that may otherwise mimic alternate pathology and disease. Depression,
anxiety, fatigue, muscle and joint pain, hair loss and/or growth, skin changes, dry eye
syndrome, hearing impairment, onset of periodontal disease, memory changes, insulin
resistance, cardiac palpitations and other cardiovascular related ailments are often
generalized complaints patients present with in midlife. [5] Since such symptomology may
easily be attributed to an array of possible pathologies including autoimmune disease, heart
disease, diabetes and possible cancer related disorders, women and their primary care
providers may be challenged to distinguish whether such symptoms are attributable to
onset of midlife pathology or simply menopause related changes. The PCP, working in
collaboration with the female patient, can be a vital influence in helping guide the female
patient in evaluation of personal health practices, facilitate improvement and enhance an
overall sense of well being and self-determination.Baseline Diagnostic Hormonal
EvaluationIn addition to the general laboratory tests that are commonly performed as part
of a complete health care evaluation (lipid panel, comprehensive metabolic panel, fasting
blood sugar, etc.) hormonal evaluation can be an important component in compiling a
complete profile of a woman presenting with a barrage of symptoms and complaints. NURS
6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPresently, a single test of ovarian function
capable of predicting or confirming menopause does not exist. Therefore, a comprehensive
history review (including a complete review of the patient’s medical and menstrual history)
accompanied by a complete laboratory profile will be vital in confirming menopause status
and for ruling out other causes of presenting symptoms. [6] For the PCP in the primary care
setting, baseline levels of ovarian related function would be beneficial in helping attain a
complete picture and analysis of the patient. The following are commonly included in the
baseline hormonal panel: Estradiol, Testosterone, Progesterone, SHBG (sex hormone
binding globulin), Thyroid panel (TSH, T3, T4, TPO)Implementing Hormone Therapy in the
Primary Care SettingThe effective management of menopause related symptoms requires a
collaborative approach between the patient and the PCP. A thorough discussion of
symptomology, goals, expectations and areas of concern is essential between the patient
and health care professional. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Based
on the review of labs the PCP can affectively counsel the patient as to the basic guidelines
for initiation of bio identical hormone therapy (BHT). This also serves as an opportunity for
the PCP to determine whether to continue in the role of a primary coordinator of care or to
better refer to someone more experienced in the treatment modalities. [7] Once again there
is opportunity for a unique collaborative moment in the relationship between the patient
and PCP that will extend into future interactions between the professional and the
patient.As it is beyond the scope of this article to discuss the specifics regarding precise
individualized BHRT dosage it is left to the PCP to seek relevant evidence based approaches
as to the nuances of prescribing BHRT regimens. Multiple references at the end of this
commentary provide excellent guidelines that may be of interest and can help guide the
provider in development of standardized institutional protocols for BHRT
management.Basic guidelines for initiation and follow up recommend that first follow-up be
scheduled 3 months post regimen initiation. At that visit the PCP needs to revisit the
patient’s initial presenting symptoms, discuss progress in symptom management, and
discuss any new or persistent concerns. Adjustments in dosage based on presenting
symptoms should be done at that time. Lab tests to be performed at these follow up visits
should correspond with the prescribed BHT regimen. [8] Routine labs should be checked
annually. If changes in therapy are required a 3 month follow up is recommended. If no
changes are needed follow up visits can be extended for 6 months. After that annual visits
are appropriate and serve to continue the collaborative relationship between the patient
and the PCP provider. [9] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperConclusionIn consensus with the latest recommendations from the North American
Menopause Society the objective of hormone therapy in women having gone through
menopause is to provide relief of symptoms found to be disruptive of normal activities of
living. While conventional medical therapies often provide a simple cookie cutter approach
to patient management, BHRT is a more holistic, individualized approach that not only helps
manage symptomology but also provides a comprehensive and prevention based approach
that encompasses medical, lifestyle and behavioral based therapies in effort to prevent
initiation and progression of chronic disease associated with the aging process.BHRT is a
unique tool that assists in caring for women not only during the transition years, where the
PCP is first likely to encounter the patient in the primary care setting, but also into later
years when age and menopause related symptoms progress into development of chronic
age related disease.10 It is often in the primary care setting where non-experienced care
providers may feel that their role is no more effective than merely the band aiding of
superficial symptoms. In this setting there is often missed opportunity to treat the
underlying cause and instead there exists a reliance on providing treatment to merely
adequately mask the symptoms the patient presents with. How often has a middle aged
female patient presented with complaint of headache? Depression? Weight gain? Fatigue or
anxiety…and we quickly conclude that a prescription for an anti-depressant, or pain
medication, or muscle relaxer, or an appetite suppressant is the appropriate prescription to
write the patient after a 7 min conversation? Could it be that we as PCP’s are missing an
opportunity to make a difference and are, instead, settling on providing only temporary and
often ineffective resolutions? NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe
science of BHRT is constantly evolving so it is important that the primary care provider stay
informed and keep an open mind/perspective as the understanding of such agents expands
and improves. Since a large percentage of menopausal women will suffer the consequences
of age related disorders further innovative, evidence based research regarding the role of
BHRT is needed. As primary care providers, we must not miss the opportunity to be in the
forefront of care in coordinating the needs of the menopausal patient. PCP is the
gatekeepers in the health care arena. We should not take this role casually.Women's
Primary CareBecause women have unique health concerns, Bay front Health Seven Rivers
offers specialized care to address the needs of women of all ages, from adolescence through
menopause. Whether you need preventive care and annual screenings or need a specialist
to manage osteoporosis, heart disease or another condition, we offer comprehensive
services to meet all your health needs.Bay front Health Seven Rivers offers a full range of
services for women, including:Comprehensive gynecological care, including contraceptive
counseling, care for urinary incontinence, menopause management and moreMinimally
invasive treatment options including laparoscopic and robotic gynecologic
surgeryOsteoporosis screening and treatmentPreventive screenings and education on
cancer, heart disease and other diseases that affect womenWell-woman care, including Pap
tests, and pelvic and breast examsORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HERETraditionally,
women’s health has been synonymous with obstetrics and gynecology. With the exception
of Family Medicine physicians who are trained in obstetric and gynecologic issues, most
primary care physicians have received little training in reproductive health issues even
though they care for women and girls. In recent years, there has been growing recognition
that sex differences do exist between the organ systems of women and men, and research
about male and female physiologic differences has bolstered the growing body of
knowledge about sex differences. Women’s Health: A Handbook for Primary Care presents
the most recent changes in current research and provides the reader with an easily
accessible reference to common women. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperThe organization of the health care system to emphasize managed care has placed the
primary care provider in an ideal position to assess the impact of intimate partner violence
(IPV) on the health of women. Much of the earlier work on IPV in health care settings has
focused on battered women's injuries and their use of emergency departments (ED) and
prenatal clinics. Less attention has been given to the physical and non-physical complaints
of battered women who seek primary health care.Primary care practice provides a setting
in which women can develop an ongoing relationship with their health care providers
where they feel safe to discuss IPV and possible options to improve their lives. Women's
health and safety could be dramatically improved if primary care providers were prepared
to assess, intervene and appropriately refer women who are in violent relationships. The
purpose of this article is to describe the prevalence of IPV in primary care populations and
review the known physical, mental health and pregnancy consequences of abuse. The
implications of women battering on primary care practice will be described. For the
purposes of this paper, IPV (domestic violence or battering) means repeated physical
and/or sexual assault from an intimate partner within a context of coercive control.1 It is
estimated that approximately 90% of all intimate partner violence is battering of the female
partner, 6–7% is mutual violence and 2–3% is battering of the male partner.1,2 NURS 6551
- PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Intimate partner violence in primary
careEach year in the United States approximately 4 million women are battered by an
intimate partner.2,3 Among these women, a large number are regularly seen by primary
care providers for health care related to illness, routine health maintenance and prenatal
care. Recent research has begun to document the extent to which battered women are seen
in primary care settings.Estimates of the prevalence of patients in primary care practices
who are currently experiencing IPV range from 12 to 29%.4–8 The lifetime prevalence of
IPV in primary care settings, that is patients who have experienced IPV sometime in their
lives, ranges from 20 to 39%. Rath, Jarett and Leonardson8 found that 44% of battered
women in two urban primary care practices had experienced “minor” physical abuse and
28% had experienced “severe” physical abuse. Research report-ing prevalence of abuse has
been based on questions included in the patient history form, distribution of questionnaires
specifically about IPV or patient report on questioning. Table 1 summarizes the relevant
studies. These studies suggest that women who use primary care practice clinics experience
high levels of battering.Few women are asked directly about physical violence by their
primary care provider. Ferris and Tudivier9 reported that 70% of providers in their survey
believed fewer than 50% of the battered women in their practices were identified. In a
study by Hamburger, Sanders and Hovey,6 only 2% of female patients surveyed had been
asked directly about physical violence. However, as many as one-third of women reported
that their physicians had asked them about relationship problems or stressors in their
lives.6 Further, studies have documented that less than 4% of the identified IPV cases had
been documented in the patient's medical record.7,8 Freund, Bak and Blackhall10 described
the dramatic increase in identification of IPV cases by providers, from zero cases
documented in medical records to 12% identification rate during their study of
identification in an internal medicine clinic. Elliot and Johnson4 found that none of the
women who reported currently being in a battering relationship were seen for routine
health maintenance visits, while more than half of the women “never battered” were seen
for routine health maintenance. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperIntimate partner violence and prenatal careThere are now many studies documenting
physical abuse in pregnant women. Incidence of abuse during pregnancy is reported to
range from 1 to 17%, and the prevalence of abuse in the year before pregnancy ranges from
3 to 9%, with the lowest prevalence found in a private prenatal clinic in an affluent
community.11–14 However, in two additional studies using both private and public
patients, income level did not affect prevalence.13 Parker and colleagues15 found a
significantly higher prevalence of battering during pregnancy in adolescents (20.7%) than
in adult women (15%). However, the severity of the abuse was greater for adult women
than for adolescents.Identification of battering varied according to how the question was
asked and who made the inquiry. The highest reporting occurred when the primary
prenatal care nurse asked patients during each visit the four questions on the Abuse
Assessment Screen.16 Also, the identification rate increased from 7 to 29% using interview
assessment during each visit rather than self-report on intake or history form.16 NURS
6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER The prevalence of battering during
pregnancy is equal to or greater than many other possible complications of pregnancy (e.g.
toxaemia). Women who are abused during pregnancy experience more frequent and severe
violence and have increased risk factors for homicide than women battered prior to but not
during their pregnancy.17 Battering during pregnancy warrants routine assessment for
abuse as standard prenatal and postpartum care.Health effects of abuse during
pregnancySubstance abuse, smoking, less than optimal weight gain and eating an unhealthy
diet were correlates of battering in pregnancy.18 These may be interpreted as factors
related to stress. These risk factors further increase a woman's risk of poor pregnancy
outcome when she enters prenatal care during the last trimester.There are now at least two
studies that have documented an association of low birth weight (LBW) with battering
during pregnancy while controlling for other risk factors.18,19 Newberger and
colleagues20 hypothe-sized that there is a direct causal path to LBW through abdominal
trauma and consequent placenta damage, uterine contractions and/or premature rupture of
membranes. There may also be the risk of infection related to forced sex. Trauma or the
stress associated with abuse may also cause exacerbation of hypertension, diabetes or other
chronic conditions of the mother. Indirect causes of LBW from abuse would be through the
mechanisms of stress and through the association of abuse with other risk factors for LBW
such as smoking, substance abuse, poor weight gain and late entry into prenatal care. NURS
6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper In Bullock and McFarlane's19 study, there
was a stronger association of LBW with women delivering in a private hospital than those
delivering in a public hospital. The authors suggest that the presence of fewer risk factors
for LBW in middle class women may strengthen the detectable effect of battering on infant
status. This explanation is consistent with findings from the Gielen and O'Campo21 study of
low-income women, where no association was found between LBW and abuse during
pregnancy. There have also been indications of abuse related to inadequate prenatal care in
at least two studies.12,22A search of the literature has not revealed studies on postpartum
depression that specifically measured partner abuse, although lack of support from a
partner is a risk factor for post-partum depression.23 Given the association of battering and
depression in other women, it is reasonable to assume that some women diagnosed as
manifesting postpartum depression may be experiencing abuse from an intimate partner.In
the only longitudinal study of abuse throughout the prenatal and postpartum periods,
investigators Gielen and O'Campo24 found that 10% of 265 women experienced moderate
or severe violence prenatally, compared with 19% in the first 6 months postpartum. For the
69 women who experienced abuse during the childbearing years, 23% experienced abuse
only prenatally, 16% experienced abuse in both prenatal and postpartum periods, and 61%
experienced abuse only in the postpartum period.Another aspect of outcomes of abuse
during and after pregnancy is the risk of child abuse. There appears to be a significant
overlap of child abuse and wife abuse.25 Logically, the risk of child abuse would be
especially severe in families where wife abuse began or became more severe during
pregnancy, during the postpartum period or where the anger was directed toward the
unborn child during pregnancy.26Physical health sequelae from batteringBattering is a
significant risk factor for a variety of physical health problems frequently treated by family
physicians. Data from a national random survey reveal that severely battered women had
almost twice the number of days in bed due to illness than other women and were
significantly more likely to describe their health as fair or poor.3 Injuries or the aftermath of
injuries from abuse such as pain, broken bones, lacerations, facial trauma (e.g. fractured
mandibles), tendon or ligament injuries, and arthritis are usually followed in out-patient
settings.27–30 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Since battered
women frequently report untreated loss of consciousness because of abuse, the chronic
headaches often described by battered women may be inadequately diagnosed sequelae of
neurological damage from battering.3 Undiagnosed hearing, vision and concentration
problems reported by battered women also suggest possible neurological trauma resulting
from battering.31,32Symptoms and conditions associated with the stress and fear of living
with an abusive partner result in health complaints that bring battered women into contact
with their providers for such conditions as chronic irritable bowel syndrome, sleep
disorders and hypertension.33–38 Although suppression of the immune system from
chronic stress has been investigated in other populations, the role of stress in the aetiology
of the frequent communicable diseases in battered women and their children has not been
investigated.35Approximately 40–45% of all battered women are forced into sex by their
male partners.39 Forced sex has been associated with increased pelvic inflammatory
disease, increased risk of sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS, vaginal and
anal tearing, dysmenorrhea, bladder infections, sexual dysfunction, pelvic pain and other
genital–urinary-related health problems documented in several studies of battered
women.33,38–40 Eby and colleagues32 reported that battered women experienced
increased risk for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), including HIV/AIDS. Sixty-seven per
cent of the women interviewed reported not using protection during intercourse either
because of their partner's insistence or when sex was forced.32 This percentage was higher
than reported by women who have multiple casual sexual partners or intravenous drug use.
That study also specifically linked violent forced sex by batterers with physical health
problems of women, a link not displayed elsewhere because of a general failure to examine
sexual abuse within the context of intimate partner abuse.32 Recent evidence that cervical
cancer is a viral disease that may be secondary to STDs may have implications for the health
care of battered women, given their potential exposure from their partners.41 NURS 6551 -
PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER The battered women in Hamberger,
Saunders and Hovey's6 study reported unexplained vaginal bleeding. But the possible links
of abuse with conditions such as fibroids or other pathology that may result in
hysterectomies has not been investigated. The Mexican-American women in Rodriguez's40
study specifically listed hysterectomy as a health problem resulting from abuse. Battered
women frequently will not report to health care providers sex-related injuries. However,
women will respond to questions related to forced sex without objection when directly
asked, suggesting the importance of including sexual abuse assessment by health
professionals.Mental health consequences of batteringThe mental health problems resulting
from abuse prompt many women to seek health care services as frequently as for physical
health problems. Depression is the primary mental health response of women who are or
have been battered, and depression is frequently treated in managed care settings. In a
sample of 394 adult women seeking medical care at a primary care practice medical center,
depression was the strongest indicator of intimate partner abuse.42 Gleason43 found a
significantly higher prevalence of major depression in 62 battered women than in a
comparison group of non-battered women. The same study reported a higher prevalence of
major depression (63%) than post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (40%) in the sample of
women.43 In comparison, depression in the general population of women is estimated at
9.3% point prevalence and 20–25% lifetime risk. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women
Research PaperControlled studies using a variety of instruments in health care settings have
reported battered women to be consistently more depressed than other women.44–46
Significant predictors of depression in battered women include the frequency and severity
of abuse, stress and women's ability to care for themselves.47–49 These predictors are
more strongly related to depression than prior history of mental illness or demographic,
cultural or childhood characteristics. Another important correlate of depression in battered
women is low self-esteem, often occurring because women blame themselves for the abuse.
In a military sample of violent couples, 30–40% of the women blamed themselves for the
relationship violence.50Suicide attempts are correlated with IPV. Higher rates of PTSD have
also been documented in battered women using shelters than in other women.43,51
However, the association of PTSD and battering has primarily been documented only in the
violence literature rather than in health or mental health literature. In primary practice
settings, PTSD may manifest itself as irritability, sleep disorders or lack of concentration. It
is probable that a significant number of women who have symptoms which indicate PTSD
are being missed by their primary provider because the presence of battering has never
been assessed. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperSubstance abuse is a
frequent manifestation of PTSD and may be another indicator of battering.52 Abuse of
alcohol, prescription or illegal drugs was found to be a correlate of battering during
pregnancy.11,12,18 There have been surprisingly few investigations of substance abuse in
battered women. However, two medical emergency room studies (one American and one
Swedish) do show an association between alcoholism and being assaulted by a partner.
Using patient records in a psychiatric emergency department, Stark and Flitcraft53 found
that 16% of battered women were alcoholic compared with 1% in the general population.
Seventy-four per cent of women's alcoholism emerged after the onset of intimate partner
abuse. Stark and Flitcraft53 also found there was no more drug abuse in battered women
before physical abuse began than in non-battered women. However, they found nine times
greater than expected rates of drug abuse after the onset of battering. Bergman and
colleagues54 found in interviews with 49 emergency department patients who had been
battered that 51% reported heavy alcohol use and 25% admitted alcohol dependence.
These women also used sedatives and hypnotics.54 These findings may reflect a tendency
for battered women who use emergency rooms to have greater problems with substance
abuse.In a review of the literature for risk markers of battered women, three studies found
a positive association between drug abuse (mainly prescription drugs) and IPV, while two
found no association.55 One study seeking to describe the history of violence among drug-
abusing women found that the prevalence of abuse was higher than in the general
population.56 The results are limited since they did not discriminate sexual and physical
abuse or specify whether the abuse occurred during childhood or adulthood. A controlled
study of female alcoholics found significantly higher rates of intimate partner violence than
in a random sample of women in the community.19 Spouses of the alcoholic women were
also more likely to be problem drinkers.19 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN
RESEARCH PAPER Cultural variations in intimate partner violenceThere has been limited
research investigating the relationship of race, ethnicity and culture to intimate partner
violence, and even less research that assists health professionals in providing culturally
competent interventions for abused women.Studies of intimate partner abuse during
pregnancy have used samples of low-income White14 and African-American women.12,24
These studies reported no differences in prevalence, correlates or dynamics according to
ethnicity in utilization of health care or health status. However, McFarlane, Parker, Soeken
and Bullock22 recruited a low-income, ethnically diverse sample to examine similarities
and differences among White, African-American and Latina (primarily Mexican-American)
women. The study found a prevalence of physical and/or sexual abuse during pregnancy
similar for both African-American and White women (19%) but a significantly lower
(although still high) prevalence (14%) in Latina women. Using the Index of Spouse Abuse
(ISA), the authors also found White women to be the most severely and frequently abused,
followed by Latina women, with African-American women reporting to be the least
seriously abused.In the National Institute of Justice's National Crime Survey,2 there was no
significant difference in incidence of intimate partner violence among the three major racial
groups represented: White, African-American and Latino. However, there was significantly
more intimate violence against poor women. Generally, the differences in rates of abuse
between racial and ethnic groups disappear when income is controlled for.57 NURS 6551 -
PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER In communities that fear and distrust law
enforcement officers and other official systems and for women who are recent or illegal
immigrants, there is likely to be significant underreporting of intimate partner violence. It is
clear that additional research is needed in this area, and until a more extensive body of
knowledge is accumulated, definite statements about the influence of race and ethnicity on
the prevalence, severity or effects of intimate partner violence are premature.58ORDER A
PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREMedical care utilization and costBattered women who are
unidentified or do not receive appropriate interventions have increased health problems
compared with women who are not battered. Unaddressed health-related needs result in
increased ED visits, hospitalizations and use of out-patient health care facilities.28,29,33 In
an 18-year longitudinal study period of 117 abused women, Bergman, Brismar and
Nordin59 found that there were 70 hospital admissions for traumatic diagnoses and 284
admissions for non-traumatic diagnoses compared with 18 and 96 admissions respectively
for a matched control group. Goldberg and Tomlanovich27 found that most ED patients who
reported previous IPV were being treated for medical complaints such as joint and muscle
pain or inability to sleep, rather than for trauma. Forty per cent of battered women seen in
an ED, the most expensive setting for health care delivery, had previously required medical
care for their abuse.60 Battered women and their children were found to use Health
Maintenance Organizations (HMO) 6–8 times more often than did controls.8According to a
study conducted at Rush Medical Center in Chicago, the cost of health care services averages
$1633 per patient per year.61 This translates to an estimated national cost of $857 million
that is attributable to intimate partner violence.62 These findings highlight the
overwhelming economic cost of IPV. Early identification and interventions do not only
provide a means for preventing further stress and injury, but also can significantly reduce
long-term suffering, disability and health care costs. These findings further demonstrate the
need to assess for abuse in all primary care settings and intervene as early as possible.
NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperImplications for primary care
practiceThe tremendous effect of battering on women's health has major implications for
primary care practice. Three areas will be discussed: eliminating barriers to identification,
assessing IPV and education.Eliminating barriers to identificationThere are a number of
barriers that prevent women from disclosing and physicians from asking about IPV. Even
where battered women have been identified within the health care system, several
researchers have found evidence of an inappropriate response from providers, such as
being treated impersonally or insensitively, and/ or having their abuse
minimized.31,54,63,64 Health care professionals have also been found to focus only on the
physical results of battering, to be paternalistic and distancing, and to subtly blame battered
women for the abuse.63,65,66 In addition, a survey of 74 battered women who had been
treated in EDs, 45% revealed that the type of insurance they had influenced how the ED
staff treated them and 22% felt that racism affected their treatment.31Sugg and Inui67
related asking women about IPV to opening ‘Pandora's box’. In their interviews with 38
primary care practice physicians they found that “close identification with their clients”,
“fear of offending patients”, “frustration and feelings of inadequacy when discussing
interventions” and the “constraints of time in a busy primary care practice” were common
feelings preventing physicians from discussing IPV with their patients. NURS 6551 -
Primary Care of Women Research PaperMany women report finding it difficult to start a
discussion with health care providers about violence but are willing to disclose the abuse if
asked.68 McFarlane and her colleagues16 found that four times as many women reported
experiencing intimate partner violence when asked by a nurse than responded positively to
questions about abuse on a history or intake form.Fear that patients do not want to be
asked about IPV appears to be unfounded. Seventy-eight per cent of the women surveyed
favoured being directly asked about physical abuse and 68% favoured routine inquiry
about sexual abuse.60,69 Reluctance to reveal abuse can be due to fear of being blamed,
shame, or concerns about loss of confidentiality or health insurance. The lack of education
has left many providers unsure or unprepared to address IPV in their practices.Assessing
intimate partner violencePrimary care settings offer an ideal place for identification of and
interventions with battered women, but first the client must develop a trusting relationship
with the provider. Many women in the early stages of battering are not yet ready to identify
themselves as abused and often do not associate their physical and mental symptoms with
battering. As with other diagnostic challenges, the primary care provider who has
developed a trusting relationship with the patient is in an ideal position to take a thorough
history, assess mental and physical health, including the psychosocial context, and link
physical symptoms with the underlying abuse. Also, pregnancy offers a particular “window
of opportunity” in which early intervention and prevention of battering can be practiced.22
Three innovative hospital-based intimate partner violence programmes have found that
many abused women clients state that they prefer to obtain interventions for abuse in a
health care setting rather than a shelter. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperThe research on health care providers' responses to intimate partner violence has
documented a lack of appropriate identification of battered women in primary care
settings.6,27 Of nearly 400 women, only six reported they had been asked about violence by
their provider.1 Several prior studies suggest that neither women nor their health care
providers accurately link many health problems to prior or ongoing intimate partner abuse,
and battered women frequently report health problems for which they are not being
treated.31,37,38,70Intimate partner violence presents in many forms in primary care
practice, and therefore all patients should be routinely questioned about abuse as part of
any health assessment, not just those who present with an injury or a history of injuries.
Abuse assessment screening should be completed at every visit as patients may be reluctant
to reveal IPV when first questioned or their abuse status may change between visits.71
NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Research has shown that
training combined with screening can significantly increase the detection of battered
women.63,72,73 After the addition of one intimate partner violence question to a health
history form in a primary care clinic, Freund and colleagues10 found that their rate of
identification of abused women increased from 0 to 12%. Similar results have been found in
other settings: McFarlane and her colleagues16 found a 17% increase in prenatal care
settings and Tilden74 found a 21% increase in an emergency department setting. However,
periodic educational updates are needed: for example, a follow-up of one emergency
department found that identification rates had slipped back to near pre-training levels after
8 years.71When questioning women about abuse, direct questions are the most effective.
Patients who are informed that abuse assessment screening is routine are less likely to be
opposed to such questioning. The Abuse Assessment Screen (Figure 1) is being used in
many primary care settings to screen for abuse. It has psychometric support, has been
translated into Spanish and has been recommended for use by the March of Dimes.22 The
Abuse Assessment Screen is made up of three to five questions and can be easily used in
clinical settings. Reports of abuse are best documented on the record in the patient's own
words (e.g. “My husband hit me”) and include the partner's name if it is a boyfriend.
Research on documentation of abuse in the medical records in primary care clinics has
found that less than 10% of the records indicated that the patient had been asked or
reported intimate partner violence.6 Any risks to the patient's safety should also be
documented in the record. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper It is not
known if identification or lack of identification varies by ethnicity, but it has been
documented that health care professionals are more likely to assess for child abuse if
families are poor and/or of minority ethnic heritage.75EducationIn a survey of battered
women who had ended the violence in their lives, women reported that medical
professionals were the least-effective source of help among all formal support systems
encountered.76 Most health care providers have received little formal education on
violence. A national survey of violence education in primary care practice residency
programmes found that nearly 60% of the programmes surveyed reported that violence
education was not present or minimally present in their formal curriculum.77 This study
noted that most programmes did report having teaching activities related to child abuse.
The presence of child abuse and the legal obligation to report identified and suspected cases
of child abuse may explain this phenomenon. A survey of medical schools in the United
States and Canada found less than half included any curriculum content concerning family
violence.78Tilden and her colleagues74 found that in a survey of 1521 health care
providers, including social workers, one-third had no educational content in child, spouse or
elder abuse. Rose and Saunders68 found that physicians and nurses from several settings
did not find the label ‘abuse of women’ justified; however, the degree of negative attitudes
toward abused women was related to the gender of provider and general attitudes toward
women more than to specific discipline or degree of training. The results suggested that
those with positive attitudes toward women were more likely to seek out training. A survey
of medical personnel in the Army Medical Corps found that more than half (57%) of the
nurses, physicians and corpsman surveyed reported having no professional experience with
IPV. These studies highlight one of the major barriers in identifying and intervening in
battering, the absence of awareness and the lack of formal education on the health
consequences of intimate partner violence. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research
PaperInterventionThe role of the primary care provider in intervening in battering is to
support women's decisions about the relationship and with the patient, review options and
develop a plan for safety. Women's options include staying in the relationship and getting
treatment for the abuser, referral to support groups and advocacy programmes for the
woman, or ending the relationship. Some women may have already ended the relationship
before seeking health care. Providers need to be aware that women are at greatest risk of
homicide after ending or leaving a battering man.79 Identifying dangers and helping
women develop a strategic response will help to reduce the risk of danger whether or not
the woman stays in the relationship.Often an abuser will harass a woman after she leaves
the relationship. An abuse hotline number can be a valuable resource to the woman should
harassment occur (1-800-799-SAFE). Identifying specific resources available in the
patient's community and how she can contact these resources is essential. Women desire
greater referral and discussion of community resources.60 Possible resources may include
local shelters, support groups, counseling, victim advocacy groups, court companion or legal
services.The causes, consequences and remedies for IPV must be seen within the context of
a society that permits violence and/or fails to punish individuals that perform acts of
violence against women.1 Primary prevention of health problems is now a key focus of
health care. Prevention of violence against women should be no different. Community-
based primary prevention and educational program mes need to be available to members of
our society. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperSummaryIdentification of
those at high risk for battering or those with a history of battering is important in ensuring
that health care interventions can be initiated early, focusing on eliminating the abuse.
Primary care practice provides a profile of the battered woman very different from the
stereotyped image of a woman with injuries being seen in the emergency department.
Identification and treatment of battered women in primary care centers is a challenge and
opportunity that has only recently been recognized by health care professionals. Over the
past five years it has become the standard of care to identify abused women in emergency
departments. The potential role of primary care provider in preventing further abuse has
only begun to be examined. Primary care practice providers may be the first opportunity for
a battered woman to find support, assistance or protection. Appropriate intervention can
prevent more serious and continued health care problems. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of
Women Research Paper

More Related Content

Similar to NURS 6551 Primary Care of Women Research Paper.docx

Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil AgrawalDep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
Swapnil Agrawal
 
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
Ivan Rivera
 

Similar to NURS 6551 Primary Care of Women Research Paper.docx (15)

Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil AgrawalDep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
Dep with medical illness-by Dr.Swapnil Agrawal
 
Brain fag syndrome,hypochondriasis and conversion disorder
Brain fag syndrome,hypochondriasis and conversion disorderBrain fag syndrome,hypochondriasis and conversion disorder
Brain fag syndrome,hypochondriasis and conversion disorder
 
Emotional crisis treatment the balance
Emotional crisis treatment   the balanceEmotional crisis treatment   the balance
Emotional crisis treatment the balance
 
Chapter 14 ap psych- Stress & Health
Chapter 14 ap psych- Stress & HealthChapter 14 ap psych- Stress & Health
Chapter 14 ap psych- Stress & Health
 
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
MAF-WP-Carb-Intolerance-v1.3
 
Codependency addiction treatment the balance
Codependency addiction treatment   the balanceCodependency addiction treatment   the balance
Codependency addiction treatment the balance
 
Hepatitis and and Major Depressive Disorders
Hepatitis and and Major Depressive DisordersHepatitis and and Major Depressive Disorders
Hepatitis and and Major Depressive Disorders
 
Obesity obesity and mental health 11-may-2015
Obesity obesity and mental health 11-may-2015Obesity obesity and mental health 11-may-2015
Obesity obesity and mental health 11-may-2015
 
Ms
MsMs
Ms
 
Obsessive compulsive disorder : ocd treatment the balance
Obsessive compulsive disorder : ocd treatment   the balanceObsessive compulsive disorder : ocd treatment   the balance
Obsessive compulsive disorder : ocd treatment the balance
 
Sex & love addiction treatment the balance
Sex & love addiction treatment   the balanceSex & love addiction treatment   the balance
Sex & love addiction treatment the balance
 
Gambling & gaming addiction treatment the balance
Gambling & gaming addiction treatment   the balanceGambling & gaming addiction treatment   the balance
Gambling & gaming addiction treatment the balance
 
Depression in chronic kidney disease
Depression in chronic kidney diseaseDepression in chronic kidney disease
Depression in chronic kidney disease
 
cushing diseases.pptx
cushing diseases.pptxcushing diseases.pptx
cushing diseases.pptx
 
Shopping addiction treatment the balance
Shopping addiction treatment   the balanceShopping addiction treatment   the balance
Shopping addiction treatment the balance
 

More from 4934bk

You are the information technology manager of an.docx
You are the information technology manager of an.docxYou are the information technology manager of an.docx
You are the information technology manager of an.docx
4934bk
 
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docxYour parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
4934bk
 
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docx
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docxWrite about interactions in the premodern world.docx
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docx
4934bk
 
Write a literary essay based on the.docx
Write a literary essay based on the.docxWrite a literary essay based on the.docx
Write a literary essay based on the.docx
4934bk
 
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docxWhy are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
4934bk
 
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docxWhy and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
4934bk
 
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docxWhy did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
4934bk
 
Why and how did the loom large in.docx
Why and how did the loom large in.docxWhy and how did the loom large in.docx
Why and how did the loom large in.docx
4934bk
 
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docxWhat similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
4934bk
 
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docxWho invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
4934bk
 
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docxWhich is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
4934bk
 
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docxWhat was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
4934bk
 
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docxWhat stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
4934bk
 

More from 4934bk (20)

You are the information technology manager of an.docx
You are the information technology manager of an.docxYou are the information technology manager of an.docx
You are the information technology manager of an.docx
 
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docxYour parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
Your parents gave you up for adoption at a.docx
 
Writing in the social sciences.docx
Writing in the social sciences.docxWriting in the social sciences.docx
Writing in the social sciences.docx
 
to questions.docx
to questions.docxto questions.docx
to questions.docx
 
Write an essay on the colonial.docx
Write an essay on the colonial.docxWrite an essay on the colonial.docx
Write an essay on the colonial.docx
 
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docx
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docxWrite about interactions in the premodern world.docx
Write about interactions in the premodern world.docx
 
Write about Frontline Video or.docx
Write about Frontline Video or.docxWrite about Frontline Video or.docx
Write about Frontline Video or.docx
 
World War II.docx
World War II.docxWorld War II.docx
World War II.docx
 
work and Chicano.docx
work and Chicano.docxwork and Chicano.docx
work and Chicano.docx
 
Write a literary essay based on the.docx
Write a literary essay based on the.docxWrite a literary essay based on the.docx
Write a literary essay based on the.docx
 
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docxWhy are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
Why are the ancient legends of China of interest to.docx
 
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docxWhy and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
Why and how did the loom large in focus on.docx
 
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docxWhy did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
Why did the Roman Catholic Church consider the sin of.docx
 
Why and how did the loom large in.docx
Why and how did the loom large in.docxWhy and how did the loom large in.docx
Why and how did the loom large in.docx
 
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docxWhat similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
What similarities do you notice between organizations for the.docx
 
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docxWho invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
Who invented the printing and how did it have an.docx
 
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docxWhich is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
Which is the true statement regarding the criteria for prioritizing.docx
 
What.docx
What.docxWhat.docx
What.docx
 
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docxWhat was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
What was the threat posed to western style democracy in.docx
 
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docxWhat stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
What stereotypes did Catholics have of Protestants and Protestants of.docx
 

Recently uploaded

The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lessonQUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
httgc7rh9c
 

Recently uploaded (20)

How to Add a Tool Tip to a Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a Tool Tip to a Field in Odoo 17How to Add a Tool Tip to a Field in Odoo 17
How to Add a Tool Tip to a Field in Odoo 17
 
What is 3 Way Matching Process in Odoo 17.pptx
What is 3 Way Matching Process in Odoo 17.pptxWhat is 3 Way Matching Process in Odoo 17.pptx
What is 3 Way Matching Process in Odoo 17.pptx
 
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
80 ĐỀ THI THỬ TUYỂN SINH TIẾNG ANH VÀO 10 SỞ GD – ĐT THÀNH PHỐ HỒ CHÍ MINH NĂ...
 
How to Manage Call for Tendor in Odoo 17
How to Manage Call for Tendor in Odoo 17How to Manage Call for Tendor in Odoo 17
How to Manage Call for Tendor in Odoo 17
 
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
 
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
 
Tatlong Kwento ni Lola basyang-1.pdf arts
Tatlong Kwento ni Lola basyang-1.pdf artsTatlong Kwento ni Lola basyang-1.pdf arts
Tatlong Kwento ni Lola basyang-1.pdf arts
 
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptxOn_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
On_Translating_a_Tamil_Poem_by_A_K_Ramanujan.pptx
 
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
How to Add New Custom Addons Path in Odoo 17
 
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptxTowards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
 
Accessible Digital Futures project (20/03/2024)
Accessible Digital Futures project (20/03/2024)Accessible Digital Futures project (20/03/2024)
Accessible Digital Futures project (20/03/2024)
 
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptxCOMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
COMMUNICATING NEGATIVE NEWS - APPROACHES .pptx
 
AIM of Education-Teachers Training-2024.ppt
AIM of Education-Teachers Training-2024.pptAIM of Education-Teachers Training-2024.ppt
AIM of Education-Teachers Training-2024.ppt
 
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptxInterdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
Interdisciplinary_Insights_Data_Collection_Methods.pptx
 
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POSHow to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
How to Manage Global Discount in Odoo 17 POS
 
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
 
Details on CBSE Compartment Exam.pptx1111
Details on CBSE Compartment Exam.pptx1111Details on CBSE Compartment Exam.pptx1111
Details on CBSE Compartment Exam.pptx1111
 
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lessonQUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
QUATER-1-PE-HEALTH-LC2- this is just a sample of unpacked lesson
 
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
 
Model Attribute _rec_name in the Odoo 17
Model Attribute _rec_name in the Odoo 17Model Attribute _rec_name in the Odoo 17
Model Attribute _rec_name in the Odoo 17
 

NURS 6551 Primary Care of Women Research Paper.docx

  • 1. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPrimary care of women aging with HIVWomen are living longer with HIV infection, but their life expectancy remains shorter than for women in the general population. How best to manage the multiple comorbidity and poly pharmacy that are common in individuals with HIV has not been studied. This article explores areas where the primary care of women with HIV may differ from that of aging women in the general population. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper We also discuss aspects of care that may not commonly be considered in those under the age of 65, specifically multi morbidity and poly pharmacy. Incorporating a gerontological approach in the care of these women may optimize outcomes until research provides more definitive answers for how best to collaborate with women with HIV in order to provide them with optimal care.ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREWomen need specialized care throughout their lives. Northern Light Women’s Health practices provide that personal care and perspective that help you lead your best life. We understand your needs and are here with you every step of the way, from childhood all the way through your adult life. We believe a strong relationship leads to the best care for you.At Northern Light Health, we have specialized women’s practices that meet your needs instead of applying a universal medical point of view. We encourage you to learn more and see if this approach feels right for your care. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPrimary Care and WomenHealthcare for women in the primary care setting requires up-to-date, gender- specific knowledge regarding disease prevention and disease management. In addition, women often look to their healthcare provider for information to help them look and feel healthy throughout their life span. This summary describes the highlights of several of the primary care-focused sessions devoted to wellness, disease states affecting women, and health-enhancing strategies. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperChronic Fatigue SyndromeAutoimmune disease affects women at a higher rate than men. Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is classified as an autoimmune disease, affecting women at 2 to 3 times the rate of men.[1] In her presentation, "Hunting Zebra: Understanding and Treating Chronic Fatigue Syndrome," Marianne Nihart, MA, ARNP, CS, BC, who is in private practice in Pacifica, California, and a member of the Clinical Faculty at University of California at Davis, provided a helpful overview of this complex condition. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperFatigue is a common symptom, reported by as many as 20% of individuals seeking medical care. Typically, fatigue is transient, self-limiting, and circumstantial. CFS, on the other hand, is associated with debilitating fatigue and a cluster of
  • 2. symptoms that predominantly feature impaired concentration, impaired short-term memory, sleep disturbances, and musculoskeletal pain. The high prevalence of fatigue in the primary care setting places a barrier to diagnosis of CFS.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Nihart's presentation dispels 3 myths regarding CFS.Myth 1: CFS is a relatively rare disorder. In reality, CFS has a prevalence of approximately 200-500 per 100,000, twice the prevalence of multiple sclerosis. Yet only about 16% of those with symptoms have been accurately diagnosed.[1]Myth 2: The highest prevalence is among young, affluent, white professional women. CFS does affect women more frequently than men. It is most commonly diagnosed in women aged 20 to 40 years, and affects black and Hispanic individuals, as well as whites.[1]Myth 3: CFS is a form of depression. Often, the onset of CFS occurs with influenza. Most women affected by CFS do not have a history of depression, nor does depression seem to occur in CFS clusters or outbreaks. Fatigue is the primary complaint in CFS, although depression may occur later, after the onset of disease.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper CFS is a diagnosis of exclusion. According to the 1994 international case definition from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), CFS is characterized by the following criteria:Persistent or relapsing fatigue lasting 6 months or longer, which is sufficiently severe to reduce the person's ability to perform 1 or more aspects of daily lifeMust be unexplained by other medical or psychiatric conditionsAccompanied by 4 or more of the following symptoms:Impaired memorySore throatTender cervical or axillary lymph nodesMuscle painMulti-joint painNew headachesUnrefreshing sleepPost-exertional malaise lasting more than 24 hours[2]Because CFS is a diagnosis of exclusion, the road to an accurate diagnosis can be long and frustrating. Clinicians who approach the diagnostic process with nonjudgmental empathy, compassion for the struggle, systematic investigative skills, and the ability to instill hope and empower self care are the most likely to successfully work with the CFS patient.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Generally, the patient will present with fatigue as the chief complaint. During the initial interview, it is helpful to obtain a detailed history, including a review of medications that can cause fatigue. In addition to the symptoms listed in the CDC International Case Definition above, the symptom checklist should include unexplained, generalized muscle weakness, generalized fatigue lasting longer than 24 hours, generalized headaches, migratory painful joints without redness or swelling, areas of lost or depressed vision, visual light intolerance, forgetfulness, excessive irritability, confusion, and an inability to concentrate. Depression may also be present, though not as a primary, defining symptom.Laboratory screening may include urinalysis, complete blood count and differential, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) or C-reactive protein, alanine aminotransferase or aspartate transaminase serum level, albumin, globulin, alkaline phosphatase, glucose, calcium, phosphorus, thyroid-stimulating hormone and free T4, and rheumatoid factor if arthritic complaints are present.[1,2] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Before CFS can be confirmed, the clinician must rule out a myriad of other diagnoses as diverse as eating disorders, Lyme disease, cancer, psychiatric disorders, and other autoimmune diseases.[1,2] Common differential diagnoses include multiple sclerosis or systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).Laboratory or physical findings,
  • 3. as well as disease progression, can help to refine the diagnosis. Other diagnoses to consider include chronic multiple symptom illness (Gulf War illness) and fibromyalgia. Gulf War illness can be differentiated through a history of chemical exposures in the Gulf War. Patients with fibromyalgia tend to present with an emphasis on musculoskeletal pain rather than debilitating fatigue.[1] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Optimal treatment results are achieved with a multidisciplinary approach that emphasizes education, cognitive behavioral therapy, exercise, stress management, and attention to associated symptoms. Pharmacologic treatment using tricyclic antidepressants for sleep disturbances and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) or mild narcotics for pain management may be helpful. Complementary therapies, such as massage, biofeedback, and meditation, may also help in symptom relief.[1,3,4] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Longitudinal studies show that although 17% to 64% of patients with CFS improve, less than 10% fully recover, and 10% to 20% worsen during follow-up. Older persons, and those with longer illness duration and comorbid psychiatric conditions, are at risk for poorer prognosis.[1-3]Skin Care: Preserving the Fountain of YouthWomen in the primary care setting often express concern regarding the effects of aging on the appearance of their skin. In "Preserving the Fountain of Youth," Julie M. Countess, MD, a dermatologist with Florida Skin Cancer & Dermatology Specialists, PA in Gainesville, Florida, provided an overview of topical anti-aging skin care regimens with known clinical benefit, and an update on minimally invasive procedures, such as botulinum toxin (Botox), fillers, and chemical peels.[5]Signs of aging on the face include increased pigmentation, telangiectasia (spider veins), and rougher skin texture, as well as wrinkles and sagging due to fat loss. Popular cosmeceutical ingredients purported to combat the signs of aging consist of vitamin A preparations, including Retin A and retinoids, alpha-hydroxy acids, and the antioxidants -- vitamins C and E, lipoic acid, coenzyme Q-10, green tea, kinetin, and idebenone.[5]But what works? According to Dr. Countess, the retinoids, alpha-hydroxy acid, and some antioxidants can have a beneficial effect on skin. Retinoids treat photoaging by reversing cellular atypia, increasing epidermal thickness, and increasing collagen synthesis. This action may result in improved skin texture, reduced pigmentation and fine lines, and smaller pores. Side effects, including peeling and irritation (retinoid dermatitis), redness, and dryness, are more common with the prescription preparations.In the appropriate vehicle and concentration, according to Dr. Countess, over-the-counter preparations may be as effective as prescription products, with fewer side effects. Dr. Countess recommends applying only a "pea sized" amount of the retinoid preparation about 20 minutes after washing the face, initially at every-other-day intervals. Reading labels is important, as retinyl palmitate is not biologically active in the skin.[5]The alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs) are the most popular anti- aging product. Like the retinoids, AHAs increase skin thickness, improve skin texture, and treat pigmentation problems. In addition to their moisturizing effect, AHAs are also helpful in increasing collagen synthesis and enhancing the quality of elastic fibers. AHAs have a known potential for photosensitivity and irritation, so they should be used with an SPF sunscreen product.[5,6] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREThe free-radical theory suggests that the effects of free radicals, lipid peroxidation, DNA damage, and inflammation play a role in aging. The
  • 4. antioxidants work to prevent free-radical damage. Evidence suggests that vitamin C functions as an antioxidant by decreasing free radicals. It has been shown to increase collagen synthesis and decrease pigmentation problems. However, there is less evidence regarding topical vitamin C's effect on improvement of wrinkles, which may be due to irritation and dermal edema. In addition to being very expensive to properly formulate, most vitamin C preparations are unstable when exposed to air or light, and many formulations do not penetrate the top layers of skin.[5]Vitamin E is considered to be an excellent moisturizer. Benefits related to prevention of skin cancer and anti-aging have not been established. Contact dermatitis is a common side effect, with a 20% to 33% rate of contact dermatitis occurring when vitamin E is applied to surgical scars.[5]Other antioxidant preparations under consideration include lipoic acid and green tea. Topical application of 3% lipoic acid has been shown to reduce redness induced by sun exposure, which suggests that topical lipoic acid could prevent free-radical damage. The polyphenols in green tea have antioxidant properties. Sun-induced redness seems to be decreased in skin treated with green tea components. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperCurrently, the "cosmeceutical" advantage of these products is unclear.[5] However, kinetin, another new product, seems to be a safe moisturizer with antioxidant properties that improves fine lines and wrinkles. Although it is not as effective as the retinoids, it may be useful as an adjunct to retinoid therapies.[5,6]Regardless of skin care regimen, Dr. Countess says that daily use of sunscreen is essential to skin health. A broad-spectrum sunscreen is best. She recommends SPF 15 for everyday use and SPF 30 for outdoor activity. Patients with sensitive skin may need physical blockers.[5,6]In terms of daily skin care, Dr. Countess recommends a simple morning and evening regimen to cleanse, treat, and protect the skin. In the morning, begin by cleansing with a gentle cleanser, or a cleanser with hydroxyl acid. Follow with an antioxidant cream, and protect with sunscreen. At the end of the day, cleanse the face again with the same product, protect with a retinoid, and apply moisturizer, particularly if there are problems with dryness.[5,6] Women should discuss skin care concerns with their healthcare provider.Although topical agents may help with skin texture, pigmentation problems, and pores, they will not treat "dynamic lines" -- the furrow between the eyebrows, or fat loss and sagging. Botox, fillers, and radiofrequency treatments may be an option for some conditions. Laser treatments may be considered for treatment of spider veins.[5] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Rheumatic DiseasesRheumatic diseases are among the most prevalent chronic conditions in the United States. Although the primary cause is unknown, gender and age appear to play a role. Women account for more than two thirds of those affected by rheumatic disease.[7] In a general session on rheumatic diseases, Joyce P. Carlone, MN, CFNP, Nurse Practitioner at Emory University, Department of Medicine/Division of Rheumatology, Atlanta, Georgia, provided an overview of the disease process, diagnosis, and treatment of 3 common rheumatoid diseases that affect women.Rheumatoid ArthritisRheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic, inflammatory, systemic disease that is 2.5 times more common in women than in men. In RA, the synovial membrane is inflamed, and there is destruction of the periarticular bone and cartilage. Multiple joints may be affected and joint deformities may be present.[7,8] A diagnosis of RA is made when 4 or more of the
  • 5. following criteria are present for at least 6 weeks: NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperMorning stiffness lasting 1 hour or moreArthritis of 3 joint areasArthritis of the hand jointsSymmetric arthritisRheumatoid nodulesSerum rheumatoid factorPresence of bony erosions on x-rayIncreased ESR correlates with the degree of synovial inflammation. A positive rheumatoid factor in the absence of other symptoms is not diagnostic for RA. Some persons unaffected by RA, the elderly without RA, or persons with other disease states, such as Sjögren's syndrome, may also have positive serum rheumatoid factor.[7,8]Pharmacologic treatment of RA includes NSAIDs, such as ibuprofen, naproxen, or celecoxib. Disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs, including hydroxychloroquine, gold, leflunomide, sulfasalazine, methotrexates, and biologics, are also used to treat RA. Leflunomide and methotrexate are category X drugs that have been linked to spontaneous abortion, cleft palate, and hydrocephaly when used prenatally. Men and women both must be off of leflunomide for a minimum of 3 months before trying to conceive. It is also contraindicated during lactation.[8]Systemic Lupus ErythematosusSLE is a relatively uncommon illness, with an estimated prevalence rate of 15 to 52/100,000. Women are disproportionately affected, approximately 8 to 10 times more frequently than men.[7] The prevalence is even higher in blacks, occurring at a rate of 400/100,000.[7]SLE is a chronic inflammatory disease of unknown etiology. It is characterized by the production of autoantibodies. Simply put, the T cells fail to recognize the "self" antigens and the B cells are hyperactive. Patients with SLE may present with constitutional symptoms, such as low- grade fever, weight loss, swollen glands, fatigue, and aching. Raynaud's phenomenon may also be present. Approximately 50% of patients present with symptoms such as musculoskeletal complaints/polyarthritis, skin changes, hair loss, cognitive dysfunction, and serositis. The other 50% of patients exhibit symptoms indicative of internal organ involvement, such as blood value changes and central nervous system, heart, and lung symptoms. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe 1997 American College of Rheumatology revised criteria for SLE can be remembered using the acronym SOAP BRAIN MD:SerositisOral ulcersArthritis (deformity can be reduced with SLE)PhotosensitivityBlood disorder (hemolytic anemia, leukopenia, lymphopenia, thrombocytopenia)Renal disorderANA (antinuclear antibodies)Immunologic disorderNeurologic disorderMalar rash (butterfly rash)Discoid rash (hyperpigmentation and scarring)[9]Laboratory work may be helpful, but is not diagnostic. The ANA is sensitive, but has low specificity for SLE. The autoantibodies to the human-like SM protein (anti LSM) and antibodies to double-stranded DNA (anti-ds DNA) are more specific for SLE.[8]SLE can improve, worsen, or stay the same during pregnancy. Pregnancy in SLE is associated with higher rates of miscarriage, stillbirth, premature birth, intrauterine growth restriction, and pre-eclampsia. The best pregnancy outcomes occur when the disease is not active at the time of conception.[7,8] Some women with SLE are also affected by antiphospholipid syndrome, which is characterized by recurrent arterial/venous thrombosis, fetal losses, thrombocytopenia plus the presence of anticardiolipin antibodies, or lupus anticoagulant. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperAntiphospholipid syndrome is suspected when women experience 1 or more miscarriages after the 10th week of gestation with normal fetal morphology, 3 or more miscarriages prior to 10 weeks with hormonal and
  • 6. genetic causes excluded, or 1 or more preterm births at less than 34 weeks' gestation. Treatment of antiphospholipid syndrome in pregnancy includes daily low-dose (81 mg) aspirin, and heparin 5000 - 10,000 U subcutaneously twice daily.[8]SclerodermaScleroderma, or systemic sclerosis (SS), is a connective tissue disease characterized by degenerative, inflammatory, fibrotic changes of the skin, blood vessels, joints, tendons, skeletal muscle, gastrointestinal tract, lungs, heart, and kidneys.[10] SS affects approximately 150 patients/million, and many more females than males are affected.[8]The 2 major subtypes of SS are diffuse scleroderma and limited scleroderma. Diffuse scleroderma is more severe, with a 5-year survival rate of approximately 75%. Limited scleroderma has a 5-year survival rate of 80% to 85%.[8] Patients with SS experience tightening and thickening of the skin, usually beginning with the hands, fingers, and face. Raynaud's phenomenon is present in most cases. The internal organs are also affected. Organ damage worsens as the skin damage worsens, with internal organ damage linked to the extent and progression of skin thickening.[8,10]Treatment is directed at controlling symptoms. Supportive therapy and monitoring for organ involvement are the foundation of management. Calcium channel blockers, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, and low-dose aspirin may be prescribed for cardiovascular effects. A number of gastrointestinal effects occur with SS. Esophageal changes may result in dysphagia or gastroesophogeal reflux, which is often treated with proton pump inhibitors. Low-dose prednisone or NSAIDs may help to control arthritis symptoms. Patients receiving prednisone or NSAIDs should be monitored carefully for gastrointestinal bleeding. Nitrate cream helps vasodilatation in the finger vessels and is often recommended for daily skin care.[8,10]Pregnancy tends to aggravate gastrointestinal and cardiopulmonary symptoms, and poses an increased threat of renal crisis for the mother. Pregnant women with SS require high-risk obstetric care and monitoring. Because women with SS are at greater risk of vasoconstriction, vascular occlusion, and clotting, estrogen-containing contraceptives are contraindicated. Barrier and progestin-only methods would be appropriate.[8] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper SummaryRheumatic diseases disproportionately affect women. Diagnosis may be delayed due to the complex nature of the symptoms and diagnostic processes. NPs working with women in OB/GYN practices as well as other primary care practices need to be aware of the diagnostic criteria and initial management parameters for these diseases. In addition to their role in disease management, NPs who provide care to women also provide important health-promotion and disease-prevention information, designed to enhance physical and emotional health and self esteem. This article blends important information about disease state management and health promotion, a combination that reflects women's primary healthcare needs.These days patient care in the primary care setting can be a daunting task. With the influx of patients who had, until the Affordable Care Act (ACA), been largely neglected and had gone untreated now presenting with a myriad of ailments and an array of complicated and muddled complaints, the Primary Care Provider (PCP) is being challenged like never before.Confounding our critical time limitations, much of which is spent in efforts geared toward determining what will be covered by the patient’s insurance, is the challenge to implement the most progressive and effective standards of care given the complexity of
  • 7. judging the benefits and risks of modalities that may not be considered as traditional areas of focus for the PCP. Perhaps no other treatment modality has sparked more debate then that of Bio identical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT). NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper With the immense interest generated by popular media, social networking and internet based information, patients often turn to their PCP for evidence based information and education. For the PCP this presents a unique opportunity as this can often be a critical period to evaluate risk for future health problems, provide proactive preventive care guidelines, prevent morbidity and decrease mortality. The primary care setting is on the front line of healthcare services and often serves to facilitate a cascade of all future healthcare needs of the patient. Proper evaluation and diagnosis is essential in providing efficient and effective care. In a time when financial expenditure, budgets and profits are an unfortunate reality of healthcare the decisions made at the primary care level can impact not only the patient but the entire health care system. [1]The aim of this paper is to specifically discuss BHRT in menopausal women and the unique role of the Primary Care Provider in assessment, evaluation, initiation and follow up of such patients in the primary care setting. Due to limitations in space and the reader’s time, this conversation will be restricted to discussion of basic protocols and guidelines that can be easily implemented in a primary care setting. The main goal is to familiarize the PCP with typical characteristics a patient may present with who may be an appropriate candidate for hormonal therapy that may otherwise, in less astute eyes, be incorrectly assessed thus leading to needless exposure to redundant diagnostic evaluation, inappropriate interventions and pointless therapeutic modalities. [2]Women and the Physiology of AgingAging is the natural change in structure and function that results from the passage of time in absence of known pathology and disease. During the transition from reproductive years through menopause and beyond women experience many physiological changes that are normal consequences of the aging process. Although the observed changes around the time of menopause are often due to the natural decline in hormone production, these signs and symptoms may often mimic and erroneously be mistaken for, signs of illness or disease. [3] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperMenopause represents the permanent cessation of menses. Most women reach menopause between the ages of 45 and 55, with average onset in the Western world being at age 52. Due to the relatively wide age range for natural menopause, chronological age may not be an adequate indicator of the beginning or end of the transition process. Although menopause is perhaps the most obvious and expected physical event, general knowledge about the process, symptoms and effective management is often inadequate. [4] Thus this presents a unique opportunity for the primary care provider to effectively and efficiently manage what could potentially influence a woman’s perceived well being, overall quality of life and health status. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperMidlife Physiological Changes: Is this Disease or Menopause?All women will experience menopause. However, each will do so in a very individual and unique way. Although the majority of women will report experiencing common symptoms in relation to the physiologic hormonal changes associated with menopause (night sweats, hot flashes and menstrual irregularities) there are numerous other presenting symptomology that may otherwise mimic alternate pathology and disease. Depression,
  • 8. anxiety, fatigue, muscle and joint pain, hair loss and/or growth, skin changes, dry eye syndrome, hearing impairment, onset of periodontal disease, memory changes, insulin resistance, cardiac palpitations and other cardiovascular related ailments are often generalized complaints patients present with in midlife. [5] Since such symptomology may easily be attributed to an array of possible pathologies including autoimmune disease, heart disease, diabetes and possible cancer related disorders, women and their primary care providers may be challenged to distinguish whether such symptoms are attributable to onset of midlife pathology or simply menopause related changes. The PCP, working in collaboration with the female patient, can be a vital influence in helping guide the female patient in evaluation of personal health practices, facilitate improvement and enhance an overall sense of well being and self-determination.Baseline Diagnostic Hormonal EvaluationIn addition to the general laboratory tests that are commonly performed as part of a complete health care evaluation (lipid panel, comprehensive metabolic panel, fasting blood sugar, etc.) hormonal evaluation can be an important component in compiling a complete profile of a woman presenting with a barrage of symptoms and complaints. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperPresently, a single test of ovarian function capable of predicting or confirming menopause does not exist. Therefore, a comprehensive history review (including a complete review of the patient’s medical and menstrual history) accompanied by a complete laboratory profile will be vital in confirming menopause status and for ruling out other causes of presenting symptoms. [6] For the PCP in the primary care setting, baseline levels of ovarian related function would be beneficial in helping attain a complete picture and analysis of the patient. The following are commonly included in the baseline hormonal panel: Estradiol, Testosterone, Progesterone, SHBG (sex hormone binding globulin), Thyroid panel (TSH, T3, T4, TPO)Implementing Hormone Therapy in the Primary Care SettingThe effective management of menopause related symptoms requires a collaborative approach between the patient and the PCP. A thorough discussion of symptomology, goals, expectations and areas of concern is essential between the patient and health care professional. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper Based on the review of labs the PCP can affectively counsel the patient as to the basic guidelines for initiation of bio identical hormone therapy (BHT). This also serves as an opportunity for the PCP to determine whether to continue in the role of a primary coordinator of care or to better refer to someone more experienced in the treatment modalities. [7] Once again there is opportunity for a unique collaborative moment in the relationship between the patient and PCP that will extend into future interactions between the professional and the patient.As it is beyond the scope of this article to discuss the specifics regarding precise individualized BHRT dosage it is left to the PCP to seek relevant evidence based approaches as to the nuances of prescribing BHRT regimens. Multiple references at the end of this commentary provide excellent guidelines that may be of interest and can help guide the provider in development of standardized institutional protocols for BHRT management.Basic guidelines for initiation and follow up recommend that first follow-up be scheduled 3 months post regimen initiation. At that visit the PCP needs to revisit the patient’s initial presenting symptoms, discuss progress in symptom management, and discuss any new or persistent concerns. Adjustments in dosage based on presenting
  • 9. symptoms should be done at that time. Lab tests to be performed at these follow up visits should correspond with the prescribed BHT regimen. [8] Routine labs should be checked annually. If changes in therapy are required a 3 month follow up is recommended. If no changes are needed follow up visits can be extended for 6 months. After that annual visits are appropriate and serve to continue the collaborative relationship between the patient and the PCP provider. [9] NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperConclusionIn consensus with the latest recommendations from the North American Menopause Society the objective of hormone therapy in women having gone through menopause is to provide relief of symptoms found to be disruptive of normal activities of living. While conventional medical therapies often provide a simple cookie cutter approach to patient management, BHRT is a more holistic, individualized approach that not only helps manage symptomology but also provides a comprehensive and prevention based approach that encompasses medical, lifestyle and behavioral based therapies in effort to prevent initiation and progression of chronic disease associated with the aging process.BHRT is a unique tool that assists in caring for women not only during the transition years, where the PCP is first likely to encounter the patient in the primary care setting, but also into later years when age and menopause related symptoms progress into development of chronic age related disease.10 It is often in the primary care setting where non-experienced care providers may feel that their role is no more effective than merely the band aiding of superficial symptoms. In this setting there is often missed opportunity to treat the underlying cause and instead there exists a reliance on providing treatment to merely adequately mask the symptoms the patient presents with. How often has a middle aged female patient presented with complaint of headache? Depression? Weight gain? Fatigue or anxiety…and we quickly conclude that a prescription for an anti-depressant, or pain medication, or muscle relaxer, or an appetite suppressant is the appropriate prescription to write the patient after a 7 min conversation? Could it be that we as PCP’s are missing an opportunity to make a difference and are, instead, settling on providing only temporary and often ineffective resolutions? NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe science of BHRT is constantly evolving so it is important that the primary care provider stay informed and keep an open mind/perspective as the understanding of such agents expands and improves. Since a large percentage of menopausal women will suffer the consequences of age related disorders further innovative, evidence based research regarding the role of BHRT is needed. As primary care providers, we must not miss the opportunity to be in the forefront of care in coordinating the needs of the menopausal patient. PCP is the gatekeepers in the health care arena. We should not take this role casually.Women's Primary CareBecause women have unique health concerns, Bay front Health Seven Rivers offers specialized care to address the needs of women of all ages, from adolescence through menopause. Whether you need preventive care and annual screenings or need a specialist to manage osteoporosis, heart disease or another condition, we offer comprehensive services to meet all your health needs.Bay front Health Seven Rivers offers a full range of services for women, including:Comprehensive gynecological care, including contraceptive counseling, care for urinary incontinence, menopause management and moreMinimally invasive treatment options including laparoscopic and robotic gynecologic
  • 10. surgeryOsteoporosis screening and treatmentPreventive screenings and education on cancer, heart disease and other diseases that affect womenWell-woman care, including Pap tests, and pelvic and breast examsORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HERETraditionally, women’s health has been synonymous with obstetrics and gynecology. With the exception of Family Medicine physicians who are trained in obstetric and gynecologic issues, most primary care physicians have received little training in reproductive health issues even though they care for women and girls. In recent years, there has been growing recognition that sex differences do exist between the organ systems of women and men, and research about male and female physiologic differences has bolstered the growing body of knowledge about sex differences. Women’s Health: A Handbook for Primary Care presents the most recent changes in current research and provides the reader with an easily accessible reference to common women. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe organization of the health care system to emphasize managed care has placed the primary care provider in an ideal position to assess the impact of intimate partner violence (IPV) on the health of women. Much of the earlier work on IPV in health care settings has focused on battered women's injuries and their use of emergency departments (ED) and prenatal clinics. Less attention has been given to the physical and non-physical complaints of battered women who seek primary health care.Primary care practice provides a setting in which women can develop an ongoing relationship with their health care providers where they feel safe to discuss IPV and possible options to improve their lives. Women's health and safety could be dramatically improved if primary care providers were prepared to assess, intervene and appropriately refer women who are in violent relationships. The purpose of this article is to describe the prevalence of IPV in primary care populations and review the known physical, mental health and pregnancy consequences of abuse. The implications of women battering on primary care practice will be described. For the purposes of this paper, IPV (domestic violence or battering) means repeated physical and/or sexual assault from an intimate partner within a context of coercive control.1 It is estimated that approximately 90% of all intimate partner violence is battering of the female partner, 6–7% is mutual violence and 2–3% is battering of the male partner.1,2 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Intimate partner violence in primary careEach year in the United States approximately 4 million women are battered by an intimate partner.2,3 Among these women, a large number are regularly seen by primary care providers for health care related to illness, routine health maintenance and prenatal care. Recent research has begun to document the extent to which battered women are seen in primary care settings.Estimates of the prevalence of patients in primary care practices who are currently experiencing IPV range from 12 to 29%.4–8 The lifetime prevalence of IPV in primary care settings, that is patients who have experienced IPV sometime in their lives, ranges from 20 to 39%. Rath, Jarett and Leonardson8 found that 44% of battered women in two urban primary care practices had experienced “minor” physical abuse and 28% had experienced “severe” physical abuse. Research report-ing prevalence of abuse has been based on questions included in the patient history form, distribution of questionnaires specifically about IPV or patient report on questioning. Table 1 summarizes the relevant studies. These studies suggest that women who use primary care practice clinics experience
  • 11. high levels of battering.Few women are asked directly about physical violence by their primary care provider. Ferris and Tudivier9 reported that 70% of providers in their survey believed fewer than 50% of the battered women in their practices were identified. In a study by Hamburger, Sanders and Hovey,6 only 2% of female patients surveyed had been asked directly about physical violence. However, as many as one-third of women reported that their physicians had asked them about relationship problems or stressors in their lives.6 Further, studies have documented that less than 4% of the identified IPV cases had been documented in the patient's medical record.7,8 Freund, Bak and Blackhall10 described the dramatic increase in identification of IPV cases by providers, from zero cases documented in medical records to 12% identification rate during their study of identification in an internal medicine clinic. Elliot and Johnson4 found that none of the women who reported currently being in a battering relationship were seen for routine health maintenance visits, while more than half of the women “never battered” were seen for routine health maintenance. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperIntimate partner violence and prenatal careThere are now many studies documenting physical abuse in pregnant women. Incidence of abuse during pregnancy is reported to range from 1 to 17%, and the prevalence of abuse in the year before pregnancy ranges from 3 to 9%, with the lowest prevalence found in a private prenatal clinic in an affluent community.11–14 However, in two additional studies using both private and public patients, income level did not affect prevalence.13 Parker and colleagues15 found a significantly higher prevalence of battering during pregnancy in adolescents (20.7%) than in adult women (15%). However, the severity of the abuse was greater for adult women than for adolescents.Identification of battering varied according to how the question was asked and who made the inquiry. The highest reporting occurred when the primary prenatal care nurse asked patients during each visit the four questions on the Abuse Assessment Screen.16 Also, the identification rate increased from 7 to 29% using interview assessment during each visit rather than self-report on intake or history form.16 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER The prevalence of battering during pregnancy is equal to or greater than many other possible complications of pregnancy (e.g. toxaemia). Women who are abused during pregnancy experience more frequent and severe violence and have increased risk factors for homicide than women battered prior to but not during their pregnancy.17 Battering during pregnancy warrants routine assessment for abuse as standard prenatal and postpartum care.Health effects of abuse during pregnancySubstance abuse, smoking, less than optimal weight gain and eating an unhealthy diet were correlates of battering in pregnancy.18 These may be interpreted as factors related to stress. These risk factors further increase a woman's risk of poor pregnancy outcome when she enters prenatal care during the last trimester.There are now at least two studies that have documented an association of low birth weight (LBW) with battering during pregnancy while controlling for other risk factors.18,19 Newberger and colleagues20 hypothe-sized that there is a direct causal path to LBW through abdominal trauma and consequent placenta damage, uterine contractions and/or premature rupture of membranes. There may also be the risk of infection related to forced sex. Trauma or the stress associated with abuse may also cause exacerbation of hypertension, diabetes or other
  • 12. chronic conditions of the mother. Indirect causes of LBW from abuse would be through the mechanisms of stress and through the association of abuse with other risk factors for LBW such as smoking, substance abuse, poor weight gain and late entry into prenatal care. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper In Bullock and McFarlane's19 study, there was a stronger association of LBW with women delivering in a private hospital than those delivering in a public hospital. The authors suggest that the presence of fewer risk factors for LBW in middle class women may strengthen the detectable effect of battering on infant status. This explanation is consistent with findings from the Gielen and O'Campo21 study of low-income women, where no association was found between LBW and abuse during pregnancy. There have also been indications of abuse related to inadequate prenatal care in at least two studies.12,22A search of the literature has not revealed studies on postpartum depression that specifically measured partner abuse, although lack of support from a partner is a risk factor for post-partum depression.23 Given the association of battering and depression in other women, it is reasonable to assume that some women diagnosed as manifesting postpartum depression may be experiencing abuse from an intimate partner.In the only longitudinal study of abuse throughout the prenatal and postpartum periods, investigators Gielen and O'Campo24 found that 10% of 265 women experienced moderate or severe violence prenatally, compared with 19% in the first 6 months postpartum. For the 69 women who experienced abuse during the childbearing years, 23% experienced abuse only prenatally, 16% experienced abuse in both prenatal and postpartum periods, and 61% experienced abuse only in the postpartum period.Another aspect of outcomes of abuse during and after pregnancy is the risk of child abuse. There appears to be a significant overlap of child abuse and wife abuse.25 Logically, the risk of child abuse would be especially severe in families where wife abuse began or became more severe during pregnancy, during the postpartum period or where the anger was directed toward the unborn child during pregnancy.26Physical health sequelae from batteringBattering is a significant risk factor for a variety of physical health problems frequently treated by family physicians. Data from a national random survey reveal that severely battered women had almost twice the number of days in bed due to illness than other women and were significantly more likely to describe their health as fair or poor.3 Injuries or the aftermath of injuries from abuse such as pain, broken bones, lacerations, facial trauma (e.g. fractured mandibles), tendon or ligament injuries, and arthritis are usually followed in out-patient settings.27–30 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Since battered women frequently report untreated loss of consciousness because of abuse, the chronic headaches often described by battered women may be inadequately diagnosed sequelae of neurological damage from battering.3 Undiagnosed hearing, vision and concentration problems reported by battered women also suggest possible neurological trauma resulting from battering.31,32Symptoms and conditions associated with the stress and fear of living with an abusive partner result in health complaints that bring battered women into contact with their providers for such conditions as chronic irritable bowel syndrome, sleep disorders and hypertension.33–38 Although suppression of the immune system from chronic stress has been investigated in other populations, the role of stress in the aetiology of the frequent communicable diseases in battered women and their children has not been
  • 13. investigated.35Approximately 40–45% of all battered women are forced into sex by their male partners.39 Forced sex has been associated with increased pelvic inflammatory disease, increased risk of sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS, vaginal and anal tearing, dysmenorrhea, bladder infections, sexual dysfunction, pelvic pain and other genital–urinary-related health problems documented in several studies of battered women.33,38–40 Eby and colleagues32 reported that battered women experienced increased risk for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), including HIV/AIDS. Sixty-seven per cent of the women interviewed reported not using protection during intercourse either because of their partner's insistence or when sex was forced.32 This percentage was higher than reported by women who have multiple casual sexual partners or intravenous drug use. That study also specifically linked violent forced sex by batterers with physical health problems of women, a link not displayed elsewhere because of a general failure to examine sexual abuse within the context of intimate partner abuse.32 Recent evidence that cervical cancer is a viral disease that may be secondary to STDs may have implications for the health care of battered women, given their potential exposure from their partners.41 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER The battered women in Hamberger, Saunders and Hovey's6 study reported unexplained vaginal bleeding. But the possible links of abuse with conditions such as fibroids or other pathology that may result in hysterectomies has not been investigated. The Mexican-American women in Rodriguez's40 study specifically listed hysterectomy as a health problem resulting from abuse. Battered women frequently will not report to health care providers sex-related injuries. However, women will respond to questions related to forced sex without objection when directly asked, suggesting the importance of including sexual abuse assessment by health professionals.Mental health consequences of batteringThe mental health problems resulting from abuse prompt many women to seek health care services as frequently as for physical health problems. Depression is the primary mental health response of women who are or have been battered, and depression is frequently treated in managed care settings. In a sample of 394 adult women seeking medical care at a primary care practice medical center, depression was the strongest indicator of intimate partner abuse.42 Gleason43 found a significantly higher prevalence of major depression in 62 battered women than in a comparison group of non-battered women. The same study reported a higher prevalence of major depression (63%) than post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (40%) in the sample of women.43 In comparison, depression in the general population of women is estimated at 9.3% point prevalence and 20–25% lifetime risk. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperControlled studies using a variety of instruments in health care settings have reported battered women to be consistently more depressed than other women.44–46 Significant predictors of depression in battered women include the frequency and severity of abuse, stress and women's ability to care for themselves.47–49 These predictors are more strongly related to depression than prior history of mental illness or demographic, cultural or childhood characteristics. Another important correlate of depression in battered women is low self-esteem, often occurring because women blame themselves for the abuse. In a military sample of violent couples, 30–40% of the women blamed themselves for the relationship violence.50Suicide attempts are correlated with IPV. Higher rates of PTSD have
  • 14. also been documented in battered women using shelters than in other women.43,51 However, the association of PTSD and battering has primarily been documented only in the violence literature rather than in health or mental health literature. In primary practice settings, PTSD may manifest itself as irritability, sleep disorders or lack of concentration. It is probable that a significant number of women who have symptoms which indicate PTSD are being missed by their primary provider because the presence of battering has never been assessed. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperSubstance abuse is a frequent manifestation of PTSD and may be another indicator of battering.52 Abuse of alcohol, prescription or illegal drugs was found to be a correlate of battering during pregnancy.11,12,18 There have been surprisingly few investigations of substance abuse in battered women. However, two medical emergency room studies (one American and one Swedish) do show an association between alcoholism and being assaulted by a partner. Using patient records in a psychiatric emergency department, Stark and Flitcraft53 found that 16% of battered women were alcoholic compared with 1% in the general population. Seventy-four per cent of women's alcoholism emerged after the onset of intimate partner abuse. Stark and Flitcraft53 also found there was no more drug abuse in battered women before physical abuse began than in non-battered women. However, they found nine times greater than expected rates of drug abuse after the onset of battering. Bergman and colleagues54 found in interviews with 49 emergency department patients who had been battered that 51% reported heavy alcohol use and 25% admitted alcohol dependence. These women also used sedatives and hypnotics.54 These findings may reflect a tendency for battered women who use emergency rooms to have greater problems with substance abuse.In a review of the literature for risk markers of battered women, three studies found a positive association between drug abuse (mainly prescription drugs) and IPV, while two found no association.55 One study seeking to describe the history of violence among drug- abusing women found that the prevalence of abuse was higher than in the general population.56 The results are limited since they did not discriminate sexual and physical abuse or specify whether the abuse occurred during childhood or adulthood. A controlled study of female alcoholics found significantly higher rates of intimate partner violence than in a random sample of women in the community.19 Spouses of the alcoholic women were also more likely to be problem drinkers.19 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Cultural variations in intimate partner violenceThere has been limited research investigating the relationship of race, ethnicity and culture to intimate partner violence, and even less research that assists health professionals in providing culturally competent interventions for abused women.Studies of intimate partner abuse during pregnancy have used samples of low-income White14 and African-American women.12,24 These studies reported no differences in prevalence, correlates or dynamics according to ethnicity in utilization of health care or health status. However, McFarlane, Parker, Soeken and Bullock22 recruited a low-income, ethnically diverse sample to examine similarities and differences among White, African-American and Latina (primarily Mexican-American) women. The study found a prevalence of physical and/or sexual abuse during pregnancy similar for both African-American and White women (19%) but a significantly lower (although still high) prevalence (14%) in Latina women. Using the Index of Spouse Abuse
  • 15. (ISA), the authors also found White women to be the most severely and frequently abused, followed by Latina women, with African-American women reporting to be the least seriously abused.In the National Institute of Justice's National Crime Survey,2 there was no significant difference in incidence of intimate partner violence among the three major racial groups represented: White, African-American and Latino. However, there was significantly more intimate violence against poor women. Generally, the differences in rates of abuse between racial and ethnic groups disappear when income is controlled for.57 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER In communities that fear and distrust law enforcement officers and other official systems and for women who are recent or illegal immigrants, there is likely to be significant underreporting of intimate partner violence. It is clear that additional research is needed in this area, and until a more extensive body of knowledge is accumulated, definite statements about the influence of race and ethnicity on the prevalence, severity or effects of intimate partner violence are premature.58ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HEREMedical care utilization and costBattered women who are unidentified or do not receive appropriate interventions have increased health problems compared with women who are not battered. Unaddressed health-related needs result in increased ED visits, hospitalizations and use of out-patient health care facilities.28,29,33 In an 18-year longitudinal study period of 117 abused women, Bergman, Brismar and Nordin59 found that there were 70 hospital admissions for traumatic diagnoses and 284 admissions for non-traumatic diagnoses compared with 18 and 96 admissions respectively for a matched control group. Goldberg and Tomlanovich27 found that most ED patients who reported previous IPV were being treated for medical complaints such as joint and muscle pain or inability to sleep, rather than for trauma. Forty per cent of battered women seen in an ED, the most expensive setting for health care delivery, had previously required medical care for their abuse.60 Battered women and their children were found to use Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO) 6–8 times more often than did controls.8According to a study conducted at Rush Medical Center in Chicago, the cost of health care services averages $1633 per patient per year.61 This translates to an estimated national cost of $857 million that is attributable to intimate partner violence.62 These findings highlight the overwhelming economic cost of IPV. Early identification and interventions do not only provide a means for preventing further stress and injury, but also can significantly reduce long-term suffering, disability and health care costs. These findings further demonstrate the need to assess for abuse in all primary care settings and intervene as early as possible. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperImplications for primary care practiceThe tremendous effect of battering on women's health has major implications for primary care practice. Three areas will be discussed: eliminating barriers to identification, assessing IPV and education.Eliminating barriers to identificationThere are a number of barriers that prevent women from disclosing and physicians from asking about IPV. Even where battered women have been identified within the health care system, several researchers have found evidence of an inappropriate response from providers, such as being treated impersonally or insensitively, and/ or having their abuse minimized.31,54,63,64 Health care professionals have also been found to focus only on the physical results of battering, to be paternalistic and distancing, and to subtly blame battered
  • 16. women for the abuse.63,65,66 In addition, a survey of 74 battered women who had been treated in EDs, 45% revealed that the type of insurance they had influenced how the ED staff treated them and 22% felt that racism affected their treatment.31Sugg and Inui67 related asking women about IPV to opening ‘Pandora's box’. In their interviews with 38 primary care practice physicians they found that “close identification with their clients”, “fear of offending patients”, “frustration and feelings of inadequacy when discussing interventions” and the “constraints of time in a busy primary care practice” were common feelings preventing physicians from discussing IPV with their patients. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperMany women report finding it difficult to start a discussion with health care providers about violence but are willing to disclose the abuse if asked.68 McFarlane and her colleagues16 found that four times as many women reported experiencing intimate partner violence when asked by a nurse than responded positively to questions about abuse on a history or intake form.Fear that patients do not want to be asked about IPV appears to be unfounded. Seventy-eight per cent of the women surveyed favoured being directly asked about physical abuse and 68% favoured routine inquiry about sexual abuse.60,69 Reluctance to reveal abuse can be due to fear of being blamed, shame, or concerns about loss of confidentiality or health insurance. The lack of education has left many providers unsure or unprepared to address IPV in their practices.Assessing intimate partner violencePrimary care settings offer an ideal place for identification of and interventions with battered women, but first the client must develop a trusting relationship with the provider. Many women in the early stages of battering are not yet ready to identify themselves as abused and often do not associate their physical and mental symptoms with battering. As with other diagnostic challenges, the primary care provider who has developed a trusting relationship with the patient is in an ideal position to take a thorough history, assess mental and physical health, including the psychosocial context, and link physical symptoms with the underlying abuse. Also, pregnancy offers a particular “window of opportunity” in which early intervention and prevention of battering can be practiced.22 Three innovative hospital-based intimate partner violence programmes have found that many abused women clients state that they prefer to obtain interventions for abuse in a health care setting rather than a shelter. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperThe research on health care providers' responses to intimate partner violence has documented a lack of appropriate identification of battered women in primary care settings.6,27 Of nearly 400 women, only six reported they had been asked about violence by their provider.1 Several prior studies suggest that neither women nor their health care providers accurately link many health problems to prior or ongoing intimate partner abuse, and battered women frequently report health problems for which they are not being treated.31,37,38,70Intimate partner violence presents in many forms in primary care practice, and therefore all patients should be routinely questioned about abuse as part of any health assessment, not just those who present with an injury or a history of injuries. Abuse assessment screening should be completed at every visit as patients may be reluctant to reveal IPV when first questioned or their abuse status may change between visits.71 NURS 6551 - PRIMARY CARE OF WOMEN RESEARCH PAPER Research has shown that training combined with screening can significantly increase the detection of battered
  • 17. women.63,72,73 After the addition of one intimate partner violence question to a health history form in a primary care clinic, Freund and colleagues10 found that their rate of identification of abused women increased from 0 to 12%. Similar results have been found in other settings: McFarlane and her colleagues16 found a 17% increase in prenatal care settings and Tilden74 found a 21% increase in an emergency department setting. However, periodic educational updates are needed: for example, a follow-up of one emergency department found that identification rates had slipped back to near pre-training levels after 8 years.71When questioning women about abuse, direct questions are the most effective. Patients who are informed that abuse assessment screening is routine are less likely to be opposed to such questioning. The Abuse Assessment Screen (Figure 1) is being used in many primary care settings to screen for abuse. It has psychometric support, has been translated into Spanish and has been recommended for use by the March of Dimes.22 The Abuse Assessment Screen is made up of three to five questions and can be easily used in clinical settings. Reports of abuse are best documented on the record in the patient's own words (e.g. “My husband hit me”) and include the partner's name if it is a boyfriend. Research on documentation of abuse in the medical records in primary care clinics has found that less than 10% of the records indicated that the patient had been asked or reported intimate partner violence.6 Any risks to the patient's safety should also be documented in the record. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper It is not known if identification or lack of identification varies by ethnicity, but it has been documented that health care professionals are more likely to assess for child abuse if families are poor and/or of minority ethnic heritage.75EducationIn a survey of battered women who had ended the violence in their lives, women reported that medical professionals were the least-effective source of help among all formal support systems encountered.76 Most health care providers have received little formal education on violence. A national survey of violence education in primary care practice residency programmes found that nearly 60% of the programmes surveyed reported that violence education was not present or minimally present in their formal curriculum.77 This study noted that most programmes did report having teaching activities related to child abuse. The presence of child abuse and the legal obligation to report identified and suspected cases of child abuse may explain this phenomenon. A survey of medical schools in the United States and Canada found less than half included any curriculum content concerning family violence.78Tilden and her colleagues74 found that in a survey of 1521 health care providers, including social workers, one-third had no educational content in child, spouse or elder abuse. Rose and Saunders68 found that physicians and nurses from several settings did not find the label ‘abuse of women’ justified; however, the degree of negative attitudes toward abused women was related to the gender of provider and general attitudes toward women more than to specific discipline or degree of training. The results suggested that those with positive attitudes toward women were more likely to seek out training. A survey of medical personnel in the Army Medical Corps found that more than half (57%) of the nurses, physicians and corpsman surveyed reported having no professional experience with IPV. These studies highlight one of the major barriers in identifying and intervening in battering, the absence of awareness and the lack of formal education on the health
  • 18. consequences of intimate partner violence. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperInterventionThe role of the primary care provider in intervening in battering is to support women's decisions about the relationship and with the patient, review options and develop a plan for safety. Women's options include staying in the relationship and getting treatment for the abuser, referral to support groups and advocacy programmes for the woman, or ending the relationship. Some women may have already ended the relationship before seeking health care. Providers need to be aware that women are at greatest risk of homicide after ending or leaving a battering man.79 Identifying dangers and helping women develop a strategic response will help to reduce the risk of danger whether or not the woman stays in the relationship.Often an abuser will harass a woman after she leaves the relationship. An abuse hotline number can be a valuable resource to the woman should harassment occur (1-800-799-SAFE). Identifying specific resources available in the patient's community and how she can contact these resources is essential. Women desire greater referral and discussion of community resources.60 Possible resources may include local shelters, support groups, counseling, victim advocacy groups, court companion or legal services.The causes, consequences and remedies for IPV must be seen within the context of a society that permits violence and/or fails to punish individuals that perform acts of violence against women.1 Primary prevention of health problems is now a key focus of health care. Prevention of violence against women should be no different. Community- based primary prevention and educational program mes need to be available to members of our society. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research PaperSummaryIdentification of those at high risk for battering or those with a history of battering is important in ensuring that health care interventions can be initiated early, focusing on eliminating the abuse. Primary care practice provides a profile of the battered woman very different from the stereotyped image of a woman with injuries being seen in the emergency department. Identification and treatment of battered women in primary care centers is a challenge and opportunity that has only recently been recognized by health care professionals. Over the past five years it has become the standard of care to identify abused women in emergency departments. The potential role of primary care provider in preventing further abuse has only begun to be examined. Primary care practice providers may be the first opportunity for a battered woman to find support, assistance or protection. Appropriate intervention can prevent more serious and continued health care problems. NURS 6551 - Primary Care of Women Research Paper