Why Unsubscribe Doesn’t Have to Mean Goodbye -  Unsubscribe Alternatives and Best Practices May 15, 2008 Loren McDonald VP, Industry Relations
Agenda Why People Unsubscribe Unsubscribe Process Checklist  Best  (and not so good) Practices Q & A
Why Goodbye is Good Unsubscribes are a good thing…. If unsubscribing is not easy, you risk: Increased spam complaints ISP blocking Annoyed customers/subscribers Weakened brand reputation
Why Recipients Unsubscribe Too Frequent Irrelevant Content/Offers
So What are the Alternatives? Other Emails Channel Profile/ Preferences Change Email Format Frequency Alternatives
Best Practices Checklist
Unsubscribe Process Best Practices Types of Emails to Include Opt Out: All except transactional Process Best Practices: Web-based unsubscribe  One click to the unsubscribe page (CAN-SPAM requirement) Do not require a password/login (CAN-SPAM requirement) Pre-populate email address/other data on the form List types of communications currently subscribed to Thank and confirm unsubscribe or change in profile immediately after subscriber submits info Do not send an email to confirm unsubscribe (unless using email reply-to unsubscribe process)
Preferences/Unsubscribe Page Checklist Obvious Must Unsubscribe Options/Alternatives Change email address Change format (HTML, text, mobile) Alternate channels (RSS, direct mail/catalog) Update profile/preferences (snow board vs down hill skiing) Frequency (e.g. weekly, monthly, etc) Ask why? (comments box, menu, check boxes) Provide a link/phone number to report problems Timing statement if not immediate unsubscribe
Measure, Analyze and Test Monitor unsubscribes by: Domain Source/offer Demographic Creative approach Determine of there any patterns Correlate with spam complaint rate Test Email/Unsubscribe page creative And regularly test to make sure the unsubscribe process works
Best (and a few not so) Practices From Unsubscribe Link…to Thanks
Minimize Unsubscribes in the First Place Manage expectations on sign-up Adequately explain the content and value proposition Explain frequency/give them a choice Show a sample Give format options Provide preference/profile options Don’t over promise – delivery against  Don’t over mail – particularly in key business periods (holidays) Send targeted/personalized emails Use trigger-based emails Don’t send emails they wouldn’t expect Don’t be too aggressive – watch the language Design for rendering in multiple platforms
Email Unsubscribe – Location and Language
Spam Button Has Prime Real Estate
Does Unsubscribe Link Belong at the Top? Preview Pane is valuable real estate Use for call to action; key info. Use unsub link at top  if high spam complaint ratio Within preview pane But after key info
Make the Unsubscribe Link Obvious Red text means hyperlink Unsub feels secondary
Mr. Magoo Might Opt for the Spam Button Font ratio is out of proportion with rest of the email - Tiny, tiny and buried
Be Careful of Euphemisms Where’s the  unsubscribe  link?
Options Within the Email
RSS, Catalog, Preferences…+ Unsubscribe
Brand the Unsubscribe Page
Not a Good Experience
Paul Frederick
Mailing List/Newsletter Alternatives
Choice of Specific Email or All Little known fact –  CAN-SPAM Requirement
Note on Transactional Messages
Opt-Out Time Frame – Manage Expectations
Note Timing to Minimize Spam Complaints
Frequency Alternatives
Clear & Simple + Flexibility for Sender Frequency caps can impact: Trigger- and behavior-based emails Surveys Specials
Neiman Marcus
Alternate Formats
HTML or Text Text may be preferred by: Mobile users Certain demographics
Update Preferences & Change Address
Old Navy – Demographic Preferences
Crutchfield – Product Type + Location
Passwords Required – FTC Prohibits
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) -   May 12, 2008 (1) Defined the term “person,” to mean individual, business, assoc., partnership, etc.;  (2) Modified the definition of “sender”: Creates a “designated sender” that becomes the agreed upon responsible party in “multi-advertiser” emails Honors opt-out requests made by recipients Includes their physical postal mailing address (3) Post Office boxes and private mailboxes constitute “valid physical postal addresses”  (4)  Ten days  remains the time a sender may take before honoring a recipient’s opt-out request – three days was being proposed  (5) Prohibits the imposition of any fee, any requirement to provide personally identifying information (beyond one’s email address), or any other obligation. FTC CAN-SPAM Update – May 12, 2008
FTC Ruling: Passwords Have to Go CAN-SPAM Ruling now prohibits passwords Separate newsletter subscriptions from membership/account emails
Thanks/Unsubscribe Confirmation
Saying goodbye doesn’t have to be ugly
Golfsmith – Branded and Helpful Names specific list Link to preferences Web site wrapper
Alternate Channels
RSS & Catalog Options
Feedback – Why Are They Saying Adios?
Simple Comments Box
Uno – Drop-Down Menu; Staples – List
Bringing it All Together “ Best of Show”
Staples – Really Good, But Not Perfect Missing: Frequency Option RSS or catalog option Contact info.
And in the end… Make it easy… But help ‘em stay in  the relationship.
Q & A Follow Me Twitter  @LorenMcDonald Columnist Media Post - Email Insider MarketingProfs GetToThePoint Many others… Blogs Silverpop – “Tales” http://marketing-suite.silverpop.com/loren-mcdonald.html Contact: Loren McDonald [email_address] www.silverpop.com

Unsubscribe Alternatives Best Practices

  • 1.
    Why Unsubscribe Doesn’tHave to Mean Goodbye - Unsubscribe Alternatives and Best Practices May 15, 2008 Loren McDonald VP, Industry Relations
  • 2.
    Agenda Why PeopleUnsubscribe Unsubscribe Process Checklist Best (and not so good) Practices Q & A
  • 3.
    Why Goodbye isGood Unsubscribes are a good thing…. If unsubscribing is not easy, you risk: Increased spam complaints ISP blocking Annoyed customers/subscribers Weakened brand reputation
  • 4.
    Why Recipients UnsubscribeToo Frequent Irrelevant Content/Offers
  • 5.
    So What arethe Alternatives? Other Emails Channel Profile/ Preferences Change Email Format Frequency Alternatives
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Unsubscribe Process BestPractices Types of Emails to Include Opt Out: All except transactional Process Best Practices: Web-based unsubscribe One click to the unsubscribe page (CAN-SPAM requirement) Do not require a password/login (CAN-SPAM requirement) Pre-populate email address/other data on the form List types of communications currently subscribed to Thank and confirm unsubscribe or change in profile immediately after subscriber submits info Do not send an email to confirm unsubscribe (unless using email reply-to unsubscribe process)
  • 8.
    Preferences/Unsubscribe Page ChecklistObvious Must Unsubscribe Options/Alternatives Change email address Change format (HTML, text, mobile) Alternate channels (RSS, direct mail/catalog) Update profile/preferences (snow board vs down hill skiing) Frequency (e.g. weekly, monthly, etc) Ask why? (comments box, menu, check boxes) Provide a link/phone number to report problems Timing statement if not immediate unsubscribe
  • 9.
    Measure, Analyze andTest Monitor unsubscribes by: Domain Source/offer Demographic Creative approach Determine of there any patterns Correlate with spam complaint rate Test Email/Unsubscribe page creative And regularly test to make sure the unsubscribe process works
  • 10.
    Best (and afew not so) Practices From Unsubscribe Link…to Thanks
  • 11.
    Minimize Unsubscribes inthe First Place Manage expectations on sign-up Adequately explain the content and value proposition Explain frequency/give them a choice Show a sample Give format options Provide preference/profile options Don’t over promise – delivery against Don’t over mail – particularly in key business periods (holidays) Send targeted/personalized emails Use trigger-based emails Don’t send emails they wouldn’t expect Don’t be too aggressive – watch the language Design for rendering in multiple platforms
  • 12.
    Email Unsubscribe –Location and Language
  • 13.
    Spam Button HasPrime Real Estate
  • 14.
    Does Unsubscribe LinkBelong at the Top? Preview Pane is valuable real estate Use for call to action; key info. Use unsub link at top if high spam complaint ratio Within preview pane But after key info
  • 15.
    Make the UnsubscribeLink Obvious Red text means hyperlink Unsub feels secondary
  • 16.
    Mr. Magoo MightOpt for the Spam Button Font ratio is out of proportion with rest of the email - Tiny, tiny and buried
  • 17.
    Be Careful ofEuphemisms Where’s the unsubscribe link?
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Not a GoodExperience
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Choice of SpecificEmail or All Little known fact – CAN-SPAM Requirement
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Opt-Out Time Frame– Manage Expectations
  • 27.
    Note Timing toMinimize Spam Complaints
  • 28.
  • 29.
    Clear & Simple+ Flexibility for Sender Frequency caps can impact: Trigger- and behavior-based emails Surveys Specials
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
    HTML or TextText may be preferred by: Mobile users Certain demographics
  • 33.
    Update Preferences &Change Address
  • 34.
    Old Navy –Demographic Preferences
  • 35.
    Crutchfield – ProductType + Location
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Notice of ProposedRulemaking (NPRM) - May 12, 2008 (1) Defined the term “person,” to mean individual, business, assoc., partnership, etc.; (2) Modified the definition of “sender”: Creates a “designated sender” that becomes the agreed upon responsible party in “multi-advertiser” emails Honors opt-out requests made by recipients Includes their physical postal mailing address (3) Post Office boxes and private mailboxes constitute “valid physical postal addresses” (4) Ten days remains the time a sender may take before honoring a recipient’s opt-out request – three days was being proposed (5) Prohibits the imposition of any fee, any requirement to provide personally identifying information (beyond one’s email address), or any other obligation. FTC CAN-SPAM Update – May 12, 2008
  • 38.
    FTC Ruling: PasswordsHave to Go CAN-SPAM Ruling now prohibits passwords Separate newsletter subscriptions from membership/account emails
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Saying goodbye doesn’thave to be ugly
  • 41.
    Golfsmith – Brandedand Helpful Names specific list Link to preferences Web site wrapper
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
    Feedback – WhyAre They Saying Adios?
  • 45.
  • 46.
    Uno – Drop-DownMenu; Staples – List
  • 47.
    Bringing it AllTogether “ Best of Show”
  • 48.
    Staples – ReallyGood, But Not Perfect Missing: Frequency Option RSS or catalog option Contact info.
  • 49.
    And in theend… Make it easy… But help ‘em stay in the relationship.
  • 50.
    Q & AFollow Me Twitter @LorenMcDonald Columnist Media Post - Email Insider MarketingProfs GetToThePoint Many others… Blogs Silverpop – “Tales” http://marketing-suite.silverpop.com/loren-mcdonald.html Contact: Loren McDonald [email_address] www.silverpop.com

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Unsubscribe alternatives and best practices: Optimizing your unsubscribe process to provide alternatives to unsubscribing is a key component of minimizing list churn. This Webinar looks at: Why people unsubscribe Provides an unsubscribe process checklist Best practices CAN-SPAM Act update Bad examples Good examples