Clean Rivers, Clean Lake 8 -- New Projects on KK and Menomonee Rivers -- Dave Fowler
1. Clean Rivers
Clean Lakes
8th Annual Conference
New Projects on the KK and Menomonee Rivers
David C. Fowler CFM
Association of State Floodplain Managers Region V
Director
Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District Senior Project
Manager
3. Cycle of Increasing Risks
Structure to
Control More
Floods Development
Placed at Risk
Development
at Risk
Changes in the
Watershed
Structure
Rendered
Inadequate • Loss of natural functions & services
• Increased runoff
• Deterioration • Changing climate
• Maintenance Issues 3
26. Menomonee River
Stream Channel Rehabilitation
Objectives:
Improve Fish Passage
Sustain Water Resources
Part of a Sustainable Watershed Plan
26
27. Impacts to Flood Elevations
• MCG Flood
Management Facility
• Valley Park
Floodwall and
Levee
28. Project Design
• Construction Document Preparation
– Topographic Survey
– Structural Evaluations
– Plans and Specifications
– Plan for Contractor Operations
• Construct from Upstream to Downstream
• Maintenance of Normal and High Flows
• Fish Passage Boulder Placement
• Final Restoration
29. Current Conditions
• Concrete Invert with
Low Flow Channel
– Steep Slope
– High Velocities
– Problems for Fish
• Stone Walls
– Significant
Deterioration
• Accessibility Issues
30. Project Design
• Riffle and Pool Layout
– Fish Passage Support
• WPA Wall Repairs
– Areas of Failure and
in Need of General
Repair
• Existing Outfalls to River
– Maintained During
Construction
• Railroad Bridge Issues
– Fragile Abutments
and Structure
• Access During and After
Construction
• Modeling
– HEC-RAS
– Sediment Transport
31. Project Design
• Construction Document Preparation
– Topographic Survey
– Structural Evaluations
– Plans and Specifications
– Plan for Contractor Operations
• Construct from Upstream to Downstream
• Maintenance of Normal and High Flows
• Fish Passage Boulder Placement
• Final Restoration
Physical habitat encompasses all the physical features and attributes that describe the home of creatures that live in a stream. This is similar to the physical shelter a house provides for humans. Healthy stream ecosystems can be identified by some particular habitat features. [VIDEO CLIP OF HEALTHY STREAM WITH OVERHANGING VEGETATION, LOGS, RIFFLES AND POOLS]First, healthy streams have a complex diversity of habitats, provided by a variety of flow and depth combinations, such as shallow and fast in rapids and slow and deep in pools. These variations in flow and depths are accentuated in meandering streams that have many bends and curves.Second, healthy streams offer cover, or hiding places, for fish and insects and also places of refuge where organisms can go during floods. Grass and shrubs along a bank, or boulders and logs in the middle of the channel make good cover. Small tributary entrants, variations in the bank line, or riparian wetlands provide refuge from high velocities and scour during floods. Third, in a healthy stream the stream bottom, or streambed, has a variety of substrate types, from rocks to gravels, with spaces between the larger rocks for food to grow and small creatures to hide [UNDERWATER VIDEO OF GRAVELS (SEE USGS BEDLOAD CORECAST).The specific habitat features in a healthy stream may vary for particular regions, depending on such things as topography, geologic setting, natural vegetation, soils, and climate. Finally, the ability of organisms to move up and down the length of a stream, called longitudinal connection, is also very important. Organisms may use different habitat settings depending on their life cycle requirements for spawning, nursery, or food sources. [SHOW VIDEO OF SALMON SPAWNING]
When waterhsheds become developed, several things can happen to change a stream’s physical habitat. Increases in impervious cover and addition of storm sewers cause the volume and rate of storm runoff to increase, and also change the timing of various types of streamflows. The end result of urban development tends to be streamflows that are more flashy. Flashy streamflows can degrade stream habitats by erosion and scour of streambeds and streambanks. Excessive sediment contributions from construction sites can transport large amounts of sediment into streams during storm events. Streambanks become unstable and start to fall in as the channel is enlarged. Contributions of sediment from construction sites or streambanks bury important habitat features downstream or may clog channels and cause more scour and erosion.When channels unravel from too much runoff they can also result in extensive damage to infrastructure….roads and bridges.[SHOW DIAGRAM OF CHANGES IN RUNOFF HYDROGRAPH?]
MMSD also provides regional flood management protection to residents in the service area.Some people question why the District does flood management projects.These pictures show homes with flood waters around them; if this water enters the basement, it will drain out through the floor drain, which is a direct connection to the MMSD system. This can overload the system causing sewer overflows.
Flood Risk reduced, Reduction of aquatic habitat, public safety issues from “flashy flows”
Current channel, housing encroaching on channel, concrete deteriorating
June 2008flood peak going down
In upcoming years Milwaukee will improve habitat conditions and fish passage in the Kinnickinnick River, the smallest but most densely populated of the three rivers that drain Milwaukee. XX miles of the Kinnickinnick are cement lined, which poses a hazard and eyesore for neighboring residents as well as severely limits use of the stream by any aquatic species. The restoration is starting from the mouth and working its way up stream. The new design channel for the Kinnickinnick has steps and hiding places so that fish and other creatures can move up and down the river corridor. The design includes a low flow channel which keeps the water deep enough for fish to swim in. The rock lined banks are stepped upward to provide some additional flood storage and allowing use by humans. All the designed features are armored with very large rocks to be able to withstand the high flows during floods.[ONSITE VIDEO CLIP –Kinnickinnik cement channel removal in progress]Interview –Tom Chapman, Dave Fowler, Eric (MMSD?) Questions for MMSD – How has MMSD changed their practices over the last couple of years in regard to storm-water management? Why have the changes been done? (mandated or voluntary?). Are there special things that have to be done for cold climates/frozen ground situations in designs? Are there specific stream restoration techniques that both mitigate stormwater effects and improve water quality and physical habitat?What has been the impact of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative on your activities?Has climate change predictions been considered in design?
.
MMSD Objectives, Diverse stakeholder groups, citizens community groups, city SEWRPC, WDNR, business groups, City of Milwaukee (planning and engineering
MMSD Objectives, Diverse stakeholder groups, citizens community groups, city SEWRPC, WDNR, business groups, City of Milwaukee (planning and engineering