SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
CLUE - Edinburgh Workshop 14th March 2013
Workshop 2 Indicators

Ursel Lünsmann-Pielke
Ministry of Urban Development and Environment
Coordination Center for Climate Issues
Guiding Questions WS 2 Indicators

1. How do you develop indicators for climate neutral urban districts?
   Top down/bottom-up, collaboration

2. How do you measure indicators for climate neutrality on a district
   level? How is the data collected, with which resolution is it possible in
   your region to find data or measure relevant parameters and who
   owns ist?

3. How are the indicators presented? Are the indicators for climate
   neutrality public or only used for planning….?

4. Who ist responsible for the indicators? (Organization that is
   responsible for the development of them as for collecting data?

5.    How do you connect indicators for climate neutrality with
      sustainability
                                                                                2
                                                                     Absender
Indicators: example Green City Index




                                                  3
                                       Absender
Green City Index portraits of 12 German cities




                                                            4
                                                 Absender
Indicators Green City Index



-CO2
-Energy
-Buildings
-Transport
-Water
-Waste and land use
-Air quality
-Environmental
      governance


                                         5
                              Absender
Example   reMAC tool




                       Absender
reMAC - two alternatives for being adviced




                                             Absender
Why reMAC




            Absender
On which data reMAC is based




                               Absender
How to run reMAC data and assumptions




                                        Absender
reMAC navigation structure




                             Absender
example: changes in the residential sector




                                             Absender
Example: CO2- Tool for urban districts


                                    data (to add)

                                    Number of new dwellings units
                                    Average net dwelling area per
                                    dwelling
                                    Number of residents

                                    Additional Energy standard to
                                    Renewable Ordinanace
                                    Demand of warm water
                                    Type of heating (percentage of
                                    decentral combined power and
                                    heating station or district heat)




                                                                Absender

More Related Content

Similar to Session 2 indicators ursel lunsmann pielke

SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - Semanco
SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - SemancoSEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - Semanco
SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - SemancoARCSalle
 
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...IRJET Journal
 
Calculator Overview97 2003
Calculator Overview97 2003Calculator Overview97 2003
Calculator Overview97 2003JeromeLengkeek
 
Template Instructions1
Template Instructions1Template Instructions1
Template Instructions1mandika
 
Smart City Expo: Making cities work
Smart City Expo: Making cities workSmart City Expo: Making cities work
Smart City Expo: Making cities workSiemens España
 
Task 214 Cres Endraft3
Task 214 Cres Endraft3Task 214 Cres Endraft3
Task 214 Cres Endraft3mandika
 
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112wlambert_2001
 
IRJET- Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...
IRJET-  	  Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...IRJET-  	  Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...
IRJET- Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...IRJET Journal
 
Carbon credi business
Carbon credi businessCarbon credi business
Carbon credi businessAmish Shah
 
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part ISFMI
 
Pili & Saiu - input2012
Pili & Saiu - input2012Pili & Saiu - input2012
Pili & Saiu - input2012INPUT 2012
 
Green Key Performance Indicators for Healthcare
Green Key Performance Indicators for HealthcareGreen Key Performance Indicators for Healthcare
Green Key Performance Indicators for HealthcareGraham Takata
 
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129RCREEE
 
Energy Management for Retail
Energy Management for RetailEnergy Management for Retail
Energy Management for RetailEnergent
 
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...Leonardo ENERGY
 
Energy Benchmarking in DC
Energy Benchmarking in DCEnergy Benchmarking in DC
Energy Benchmarking in DCDominiqueHinton
 

Similar to Session 2 indicators ursel lunsmann pielke (20)

Carbon Benefits4
Carbon Benefits4Carbon Benefits4
Carbon Benefits4
 
SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - Semanco
SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - SemancoSEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - Semanco
SEMANCO Workshop Theme1 - Semanco
 
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
 
Calculator Overview97 2003
Calculator Overview97 2003Calculator Overview97 2003
Calculator Overview97 2003
 
Template Instructions1
Template Instructions1Template Instructions1
Template Instructions1
 
Smart City Expo: Making cities work
Smart City Expo: Making cities workSmart City Expo: Making cities work
Smart City Expo: Making cities work
 
Session 69 Geoff Richards
Session 69 Geoff RichardsSession 69 Geoff Richards
Session 69 Geoff Richards
 
Task 214 Cres Endraft3
Task 214 Cres Endraft3Task 214 Cres Endraft3
Task 214 Cres Endraft3
 
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112
Patrick Costello Green Guide Presentation Final 032112
 
IRJET- Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...
IRJET-  	  Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...IRJET-  	  Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...
IRJET- Indian Water Pollution Monitoring and Forecasting for Anomaly with...
 
Carbon credi business
Carbon credi businessCarbon credi business
Carbon credi business
 
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I
2012 Critical Issues Summit Energy Panel, Part I
 
Pili & Saiu - input2012
Pili & Saiu - input2012Pili & Saiu - input2012
Pili & Saiu - input2012
 
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 2: Stuart White)
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 2:  Stuart White)UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 2:  Stuart White)
UTSpeaks: Our Fragile Cities (Part 2: Stuart White)
 
Green Key Performance Indicators for Healthcare
Green Key Performance Indicators for HealthcareGreen Key Performance Indicators for Healthcare
Green Key Performance Indicators for Healthcare
 
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129
Med enec building ee indicators f visser121129
 
Energy Management for Retail
Energy Management for RetailEnergy Management for Retail
Energy Management for Retail
 
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...
Advanced weather forecasting for RES applications: Smart4RES developments tow...
 
SEI Smart City Offers Catalogue
SEI Smart City Offers CatalogueSEI Smart City Offers Catalogue
SEI Smart City Offers Catalogue
 
Energy Benchmarking in DC
Energy Benchmarking in DCEnergy Benchmarking in DC
Energy Benchmarking in DC
 

More from Olena Tatarchenko

Report from the expert workshop in edinburgh
Report from the expert workshop in edinburghReport from the expert workshop in edinburgh
Report from the expert workshop in edinburghOlena Tatarchenko
 
Preparation material clue expert workshop
Preparation material clue expert workshopPreparation material clue expert workshop
Preparation material clue expert workshopOlena Tatarchenko
 
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årman
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årmanSession 1 introduction to indicators louis årman
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årmanOlena Tatarchenko
 
Session 2 indicators stefan geier
Session 2 indicators stefan geierSession 2 indicators stefan geier
Session 2 indicators stefan geierOlena Tatarchenko
 
Expert workshop edinburgh attendees
Expert workshop edinburgh attendeesExpert workshop edinburgh attendees
Expert workshop edinburgh attendeesOlena Tatarchenko
 

More from Olena Tatarchenko (9)

Report from the expert workshop in edinburgh
Report from the expert workshop in edinburghReport from the expert workshop in edinburgh
Report from the expert workshop in edinburgh
 
Session 1 nils brandt
Session 1 nils brandtSession 1 nils brandt
Session 1 nils brandt
 
Preparation material clue expert workshop
Preparation material clue expert workshopPreparation material clue expert workshop
Preparation material clue expert workshop
 
Session 1 stefan johansson
Session 1 stefan johanssonSession 1 stefan johansson
Session 1 stefan johansson
 
Expert network slide
Expert network slideExpert network slide
Expert network slide
 
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årman
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årmanSession 1 introduction to indicators louis årman
Session 1 introduction to indicators louis årman
 
Session 2 indicators stefan geier
Session 2 indicators stefan geierSession 2 indicators stefan geier
Session 2 indicators stefan geier
 
Session 2 scenarios
Session 2 scenariosSession 2 scenarios
Session 2 scenarios
 
Expert workshop edinburgh attendees
Expert workshop edinburgh attendeesExpert workshop edinburgh attendees
Expert workshop edinburgh attendees
 

Session 2 indicators ursel lunsmann pielke

  • 1. CLUE - Edinburgh Workshop 14th March 2013 Workshop 2 Indicators Ursel Lünsmann-Pielke Ministry of Urban Development and Environment Coordination Center for Climate Issues
  • 2. Guiding Questions WS 2 Indicators 1. How do you develop indicators for climate neutral urban districts? Top down/bottom-up, collaboration 2. How do you measure indicators for climate neutrality on a district level? How is the data collected, with which resolution is it possible in your region to find data or measure relevant parameters and who owns ist? 3. How are the indicators presented? Are the indicators for climate neutrality public or only used for planning….? 4. Who ist responsible for the indicators? (Organization that is responsible for the development of them as for collecting data? 5. How do you connect indicators for climate neutrality with sustainability 2 Absender
  • 3. Indicators: example Green City Index 3 Absender
  • 4. Green City Index portraits of 12 German cities 4 Absender
  • 5. Indicators Green City Index -CO2 -Energy -Buildings -Transport -Water -Waste and land use -Air quality -Environmental governance 5 Absender
  • 6. Example reMAC tool Absender
  • 7. reMAC - two alternatives for being adviced Absender
  • 8. Why reMAC Absender
  • 9. On which data reMAC is based Absender
  • 10. How to run reMAC data and assumptions Absender
  • 12. example: changes in the residential sector Absender
  • 13. Example: CO2- Tool for urban districts data (to add) Number of new dwellings units Average net dwelling area per dwelling Number of residents Additional Energy standard to Renewable Ordinanace Demand of warm water Type of heating (percentage of decentral combined power and heating station or district heat) Absender