SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 54
Workshop on
World Programme for the Census of Agriculture 2020
Bangkok, Thailand
19-23 September 2016
Jairo Castano
Senior Statistician
Leader, Agricultural Census and Survey Team
FAO Statistics Division
Methodological Considerations
Technical Session 3
1
2
Contents
• Background
• Overview of census modalities: description, implementation
steps, advantages, disadvantages and requirements
1. Classical approach
2. Modular approach
3. Integrated census/survey modality
4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative
sources
• Country examples
Background
• The present Programme broadens the approaches
introduced in the previous one, acknowledging that the
census of agriculture can be conducted in different ways,
using four main modalities:
Classical approach
Modular approach
Integrated census and survey programme
Combined census with use of administrative sources
• Main aim is to help countries to implement a census in
most efficient way, taking into account countries’
particular conditions.
Overview of census modalities
i) The classical approach: a census conducted in a single one-off operation
(usually by complete enumeration) comprising the universe of agricultural
holdings. It should cover all essential items and may include additional
items.
ii) Modular approach: comprises: a) a core module undertaken by complete
enumeration including all frame items and eventually other items; and b)
supplementary modules targeting specific populations identified through the
frame provided by the core module.
iii) The integrated census and survey programme: integrates a multi-year
programme of censuses and surveys. One option is AGRIS, a modular
survey programme which has to be articulated with the agricultural
census programme and conducted on an annual basis between two censuses.
iv) Combined census with use of admin sources: registers and other
administrative sources are used as a source of census data in combination
with field data collection.
Comparison of census modalities
Classical Modular Integrated
census/survey
Combined
with admin
Enumeration
phases
One-off field
operation
Multiple phases:
a) core module
b) supplementary
module(s)
Multiple phases:
a) census core module
b) rotating thematic
modules
One or more field
operations and use
of admin sources
Coverage of
items
All census
items collected
during a one-
off operation
Core module
includes items
required at the
lowest geo/admin
level, and those to
establish frames for
the supplementary
module(s)
Census core-module
includes items
required at the lowest
geographic/admin
level, and those to
establish frames for
rotating thematic
module(s)
Census items are
collected through
field operation and
use of administrative
sources.
Enumeration
method
Complete
enumeration
exclusively or
combined with
sample
enumeration
Complete
enumeration for
core module and
sample
enumeration for
supplementary
modules(s)
Complete enumeration
for census core module
and sampling
for rotating thematic
modules
Complete
enumeration
exclusively or
combined with
sample enumeration
Alternative census modalities
• The classical approach is the most extensively used census
modality. However, more and more countries would use
alternative census modalities in the near future.
• There are important reasons for using alternative census
modalities:
i. budget limitation for census,
ii. need to produce more frequent and timely agricultural statistics,
iii. fast growing digital and mobile technology;
iv. increasing availability and access to data from administrative
sources and technical capacities to handle such data;
v. reluctance of some population groups to participate in the census
and need to reduce respondent burden.
Some common issues for any
census modality
• Identify data content of the census:
o The minimum requirement for a census, is to include all essential items,
in order to enable international comparison and frame items for census
modules or/and follow up surveys
o The final list of census items should be established in consultation with
main stakeholders depending on country’s requirements, availability of
reliable administrative and other data sources, financial and other
resources
o In countries with well-developed registers, the use of administrative
data sources (ADS) to cover census data items should be considered .
Some common issues for any
census modality (cntd.)
• The frame for the agric. census must be carefully established
to ensure that all holdings are covered with no omissions or
duplications.
•Use of sample enumeration
 efficiency considerations (precision versus costs), other elements should be taken into
account, such as:
 desired level of aggregation for census data
 use of the census as a frame for ongoing sample surveys
 data content of the census and
 capacity to deal with sampling methods and subsequent statistical analysis based on
Some common issues for any
census modality (cntd.)
•Use of thresholds
oIn many countries, a minimum size limit is
adopted for holdings included in the census.
oThe rationale for this could be:
in the country there is a large number of very small
holdings which make a marginal contribution to
total agricultural production but
their inclusion in the census greatly increases the
workload and census budget.
1. The classical approach
• May be considered as a census conducted as a
single one-off operation in which all the census
information is recorded. By extension, this approach
also includes the short-long questionnaire concept.
• Should include all “essential” items and may
include “additional” items depending on: a)
country’s requirements; b) other data sources (e.g.
non-structural items); and c) available resources.
• Can be conducted by complete enumeration, sample
enumeration, or by a combination of both.
1. The classical approach (contd.)
This approach is appropriate when countries:
•Wish to conduct a single one-off operation
•Have an integrated census and survey
programme (e.g. no need for supplementary
modules)
•Wish to collect some additional items at low
administrative levels.
1. The classical approach: main
features
• Enumeration is conducted as a single one-off
operation, during a specified enumeration period,
providing a snapshot of the entire population at a
specified period.
• However, certain regions of a country may be
enumerated at different times of the year because
of seasonal and agricultural conditions.
• The classical approach also includes cases where
(under the short-long questionnaire concept) the
long questionnaire is completed at a second visit.
1. The classical approach: ways
and steps for its implementation
The following questions arise:
1) Will complete enumeration be used in exclusivity
or in combination with sample enumeration?
2) If complete enumeration is used in combination
with sampling, what part of the population will be
sampled? Is a reliable sample frame available?
3) Will a single questionnaire be administered to all
agricultural holdings, or different questionnaires,
e.g. will a short-long questionnaire concept be
applied?
1. The classical approach:
complete enumeration
• Exhaustive enumeration of all agricultural
holdings above a threshold (if any).
• It is the most costly and challenging in
terms of planning and organization. It is
much less demanding in respect of the
characteristics contained in the frame than a
sample-based census and is often the most
practical way to conduct a census and build
up a statistical farm register.
1. The classical approach:
sample & complete enumeration
• A part of the target population is enumerated on exhaustive basis
and another part using sample. This method aims at increasing cost-
efficiency but the sampled part will not provide reliable statistics at
the smallest administrative level.
• Ways to combine:
◦ Use complete enumeration in some regions (agriculturally important and/or
easy access) and sample enumeration in other regions;
◦ Use complete enumeration for some types of holdings (large holdings,
commercial holdings or holdings above the threshold) and sample
enumeration for the remaining holdings;
◦ Use of complete enumeration for key census items (such as essential and
frame items) and sample enumeration to collect additional information. This
is a special case of the short-long questionnaire concept.
1. The classical approach: sample
enumeration
• A large sample of holdings (large enough to generate sub-national
data) is selected and enumerated in one-off operation.
• It is less costly in terms of field work and reduces the respondent
burden in comparison with complete enumeration.
• However, a reliable sampling frame with adequate auxiliary
information (e.g. area of holding, number of livestock) is required,
as well as high-level expertise in survey organization and sampling.
• The probability sample of agricultural holdings for sample
enumeration can be drawn from the sampling frame built-up based
on a recent population and housing census, a statistical farm
register and/or other statistical and administrative sources.
1. The classical approach:
types of questionnaires
• Single questionnaire: administered to all agricultural holdings covered
by the census without regard of their type. It is easy to apply in the field.
• Short-long questionnaire: In many cases (mainly when an updated
census frame is not available) the classical approach involves the short-
long questionnaire modality:
­ Short questionnaire administered to screen the target population and collects basic
information on all households and identifies holdings meeting a given threshold;
­ Long questionnaire administered only to holdings identified above the threshold (or to
a sample of such holdings) to collect more detailed information from the holdings.
• Other types of questionnaires: specific census questionnaires to fit
different segments of the target population (such as household and non-
household based holdings). Or for different provinces when these differ
considerably in cropping and livestock systems, and in agricultural
practices.
1. The classical approach: Data
collection from holdings in the household
sector and in the non-household sector
• Two types of agricultural holdings:
- In the household sector - in the non-household sector.
• Special holdings such as large commercial holdings, usually are in the non-
household sector and are “self-enumerated” or interviewed face-to-face.
• The enumeration period for special holdings should be similar to that
established for the other holdings. When self-enumeration methods are used,
census questionnaires should be sent well in advance to allow timely provision
of data.
• Household-based holdings, in developing countries are commonly enumerated
using face-to-face interviews.
1. The classical approach:
advantages
• Provides a snapshot of the entire target population at a specified period and
comprehensive data sets are available at the lowest geographical level.
• Data can be produced at lowest administrative and geographical levels with
no sampling error. Tabulations can be done in line with high user’s
requirements, including data for small administrative units and information
on rare events, such as emerging crops, rare crops and types of livestock.
• When taken with complete enumeration it is much less demanding in respect
of the characteristics contained in the frame than the sample-based census.
• The classical census taken by complete enumeration can constitute a good
basis for building up a statistical farm register and an exhaustive sampling
frame for subsequent regular agricultural surveys.
1. The classical approach:
disadvantages
• Cost and administrative complexity (mainly if it is taken
by complete enumeration);
• It implies a high burden on respondents;
• There is the risk to overburden the census questionnaire
because of the high pressure from some policy makers or
other stakeholders to include detailed items to collect
data at the national level and at the lowest administrative
level;
• Very large number of enumerators and supervisors
required (complete enumeration);
• The amount of data to be processed is larger.
1. The classical approach:
requirements
• Good organization capacity and planning.
• Sufficient and timely budget allocation during census
preparation, field operation, data processing & dissemination
needs to be ensured.
• Availability of sufficient number of qualified field staff.
• Involvement of all relevant public authorities, in particular at
local level, is essential for successful field operations
(enumeration, publicity campaign).
• If the classical census is conducted on sample basis, additional
requirements are:
Availability of a good survey organization capacity of the
census agency, including adequate sampling expertise.
Availability of a reliable sampling frame.
2. Modular census: main
features
• This modality has a clearly distinguishable core module (on a
complete enumeration basis) and one or more supplementary
modules (on a sample basis).
• An essential condition: data from the core module used as
frame for the supplementary module(s). The census using the
short-long questionnaire in one operation is not considered as
modular census (no frame use).
• A ‘module’ is defined as a group of data items to be collected
on a specific target population (e.g. holdings with livestock).
• All essential items should be covered by the core and
supplementary module(s).
2. Modular census: main
features (contd.)
• Core module must include the items required at the lowest
geographic or administrative levels, and/or needed to establish
sampling frames for the supplementary module(s).
• The core module should include all frame items. This module
should also cover rare events (unusual crops or livestock), which
would not be possible to estimate from supplementary modules
conducted on sample basis because of high sampling errors.
• Supplementary modules use the frame generated by the core
module to target specific populations and should include the rest of
the agreed census items that are not included in the core module.
2. Modular census modality: ways
and steps for implementation
• Two ways of implementing the modular approach:
i. implementing core and supplementary modules
separately
ii. implementing the core module and the supplementary
module(s) as part of a single data collection operation
(difficult in practice).
• Sources of frame data for supplementary modules:
a) The census core module;
b) An agricultural module/section of the population census;
c) Administrative registers.
2 a). Core module with complete
enumeration as frame for supplementary
module(s)
(i) Implementing core and supplementary modules separately. It implies two
phases:
 Phase 1: the core module is first implemented and questionnaires are returned to the office for
processing and building frame (s) for the supplementary module(s);
 Phase 2: enumerators return to the field to carry out the census supplementary module(s) on the
selected sample (s) of holdings for the module(s)
(ii) Implementing the core module and the supplementary module(s) as part of a
single data collection operation. It implies:
 Collect data for the core census module;
 Apply specific sampling procedures, based on responses to the core module questions, to
determine holdings to include in the supplementary module(s);
 If the holding is included in the sample for the supplementary module(s), proceed to apply the
supplementary module(s). Otherwise, the interview is finished.
2 b). Modular census: Agricultural
data from a recent population census
as frame for supplementary modules
When an agricultural module/section is included in the
population census, two possible situations arise:
Only few agricultural items were included in the population census,
not enough to provide frame items needed for all supplementary
modules. In this case, a lighter core module is needed to collect missing
frame items and any other item suitable for the core.
Most of the frame items have been collected in the agricultural
module/section of the population census. Therefore, the country may
use this information to implement the supplementary modules.
2 c). Modular census :
Administrative sources as frame
data for supplementary modules
• In countries where administrative data is well
organised and of good quality data may be
available to provide a large proportion of all
essential data items, including frame data for
supplementary modules.
• This information can be therefore used to
implement one or more supplementary modules
to collect the rest of the essential data or specific
data of interest to the country.
2. Modular census: special
holdings
• In the modular census, special holdings (large commercial farms,
holdings in the non-household sector, etc.) may be covered during the
first or second phase field operation (supplementary modules).
• All required information (core and supplementary) should be collected
in one operation only by dedicated staff using a specific questionnaire
for such holdings. The timing will depend on the availability of
dedicated staff for collecting the data.
• Efforts should be made to cover these special holdings as closely as
possible to the implementation of the core module in the household
sector to ensure that the same reference period is used for all items
collected.
2. Modular census modality:
advantages
• The combination of core and supplementary items allows the modular
census to produce a more extensive and country-specific range of
data compared with the classical census modality, for which small
area estimates are not important.
• More effective use of available budget to collect country relevant
information.
• Allows a focused and more detailed training of field personnel.
• Countries with a not well established system of agricultural surveys
and limited budget may find the modular approach as a logical first
step towards the creation of a system of integrated agricultural
censuses and surveys.
2. Modular census modality:
disadvantages
• Risk of having a core module with too many items (due to pressure from stakeholders) at
low geographical level.
• The lack of well trained professional staff in sampling.
• If supplem. modules are undertaken at the same time as the core module there exists the
risk of loss of data quality if not properly organized.
• There are limitations in terms of cross-tabulation between variables in the core and in the
supplementary modules or between variables in different supplementary modules not
conducted jointly.
• If the time lag between the implementation of the core and supplem. modules is too long,
the benefit of having a good frame from the core module disappears. An frame update
would be needed adding to the cost.
• If the core module is largely covered in a population census it could be difficult to
mobilize additional funds for supplementary modules.
• In the absence of a rigorous programming, the conducting of the core module and
publication of results can jeopardize a better preparation of complementary and thematic
modules.
2. Modular census modality:
requirements
• Good planning and survey organization capacity, including minimum
sampling expertise.
• Adequate budget allocation between core and supplementary modules
• Capacity and resources to conduct core module and supplementary modules
with a short time lag
• Availability of field staff with minimum level of qualification that can be
mobilized to conduct sometimes complex surveys for supplementary modules
• A good cooperation and coordination of census activities between interested
institutions and good partnership in the organization of a comprehensive
census publicity communication/public awareness campaign.
3. Integrated Census/survey
modality
• This new modality features a census core module (to be conducted
on a complete enumeration basis) and a number of several rotating
thematic modules (to be conducted annually or periodically on
sample basis over a 10-year period). An example of rotating
modules is the new Agricultural Integrated Survey programme
(AGRIS).
• The recommended data items to be covered in this census modality
are the same as all other modalities (essential, frame and additional
items).
• The census core module should mainly provide frame data needed
to implement rotating thematic modules.
3. What is AGRIS?
• The AGRIS is a modular survey program which is to be
articulated with the agricultural census programme and
conducted on an annual basis between two censuses.
• It consists of one annual core module (crop and livestock
production) and four rotating modules: ‘economy’,
‘labour force’, ‘machinery and equipment’, and
‘production methods and environment’. Additional
modules can be added as needed.
• In the integrated census and survey modality, AGRIS is
synchronized with the agricultural census core module
and operates over a 10-year cycle.
Example of possible modules and timing of their implementation (illustration)
POSSIBLE MODULES
YEARS
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Agricultural census core module (and AGRIS core module
where relevant and possible)
•
AGRIS Core Module
Crop production  • • • • • • • • •
Livestock production  • • • • • • • • •
AGRIS Rot. Module 1 Economy • • • •
AGRIS Rot. Module 2 Labour force • • •
AGRIS Rot. Module 3 Machinery and equipment • •
AGRIS Rot. Module 4
Production methods and
environment
• • •
3. Integrated Census/survey
modality: illustration
 denotes optional implementation in year 1
3. Integrated Census/survey modality:
ways and steps for the implementation
• The implementation of the integrated
census/survey modality will start with a census
core module (on a complete enumeration).
• As with other modalities, there could be three
sources of frame data for the rotating thematic
module(s):
a) census core module (on complete enumeration)
b) An agricultural module/section in the population
census
c) Administrative registers
3 a). Integrated census/survey modality:
census core module as frame for rotating
thematic module(s)
• The census core module and the rotating thematic modules will be conducted as follow:
• During the first year the census core module is implemented through complete
enumeration. The frame data collected is processed and analyzed to build required frames
for the subsequent rotating thematic modules and AGRIS core module.
• The frame is used to design the surveys that will be implemented in the following years
to collect data for the rotating thematic modules and AGRIS core module until the next
complete enumeration exercise.
• From year 2, AGRIS core will be implemented annually while each rotating thematic
module will be implemented every 2 or 3 years. Therefore, each year there will be a
survey covering AGRIS core and one or more rotating thematic modules. Annual surveys
will therefore be a combination of farm structure data and current production data
providing continuous flow of data and allowing more frequent update of some structural
information.
3 b) and c). Integrated census/survey
modality: population census and
admin sources as frame for
rotating thematic modules and
AGRIS core
• Similar to earlier modalities.
3. Integrated census/survey
modality: advantages
• Effective use of available budget to collect
country relevant information on an annual basis
• More detailed information available on topics of
interest
• Focused training of field staff
• Wider set of census items
• Decisive step towards the establishment of a
system of integrated censuses and surveys
3. Integrated census/survey
modality: limitations
• The risk of expanding too much the census core module resulting in
high cost which will reduce the relative benefits of this census
modality.
• The challenge of conducting the census core module and AGRIS core
at the same time (when relevant). This requires good survey planning
and sampling capacity.
• The limitations in terms of cross-tabulation between variables in the
core and in the rotating thematic modules or between variables in
different rotating thematic modules not conducted jointly.
• Difference in the reference period for different census items collected
in the census core and the items in the rotating thematic modules.
3. Integrated census/survey
modality: requirements
• The need for maintaining and updating the sampling frame
is critical as the frame becomes gradually obsolete over
time.
• A mechanism should be put in place to ensure its validity.
• It requires well trained personnel in sampling methods, an
additional cost.
• It requires a continuous flow of resources. In countries
where funding is mainly from external sources, there may
be budgetary and other administrative constraints for
commitments over such a long period as 10 years.
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of administrative sources: main
features
• A meaningful part of the census items for the
entire population of the census of agriculture (or
for part of it) comes from existing administrative
sources created for non-statistical purposes.
• The data could come from one or several
administrative sources. It could be also used in
combination with field data collection.
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of admin sources: main features
(contd.)
• An important feature of the data from administrative sources is that
the information is not primarily collected for statistical purposes.
• Administrative sources may be for selective items or may target a
specific population.
• Thus the definition of the population of interest and the data collection
protocols is out of the control of the census office.
• There is a substantial difference in the organisational approach of the
census when using administrative data as compared to other
approaches.
• As the objects already exist in the data source, a selection need to be
made of objects (holders or holdings) and variables that are relevant to
the census.
4. Combined agriculture census with use
of admin sources: Quality considerations
• Some information in administrative sources could be of low importance for administrative
purposes which may result in lower statistical quality.
• The purpose and method used to collect data should also be taken into account to detect
possible systematic errors or systematic bias in the register
• The following quality aspects need to be carefully considered:
­ Relevance (content) of the administrative data sources.
­ Accuracy: an admin source is of good quality if a large proportion of the variables
required for the census exists in the register and corresponding data are reliable.
­ One important accuracy category is related to the data coverage: under-coverage or
over-coverage of units, multiple listings, and misclassification of items.
­ Completeness
­ Unreported events: data related to the reference period is not available in the source
referring to an event from which parameters are to be derived: e.g. births, deaths or
loss, sales, etc. of livestock.
• The information from administrative sources has to be coherent and comparable with
data from other sources or over time.
• The timeliness dimension (difference between the reference period and the availability of
the results) when using administrative data source.
• Accessibility in terms of physical access to the information in the admin source.
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of admin sources: Ways of
using admin data in this modality
1. The starting point (like in all census modalities) is to define the data content of the census in terms
of data items to be covered.
2. Next step is to decide on the way to use the admin source. Possible ways or approaches are:
 Split data approach: admin sources are used to provide some of the variables for all of the
holdings.
 Split population approach: Data from admin sources are used for some holdings where these
data are of sufficient quality, and other statistical sources are used for the remainder of the
holdings.
 Combining the two approaches: administrative sources replace the field data collection for
some of the variables for part of the holdings.
 Pre-filling answers in the questionnaires which are to be checked by respondents during the
census.
 Totally replacing the census data collection, on all census characteristics and for all units in the
census population with data coming from one or more admin sources (no very common).
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of admin sources: Steps for
implementation
1. Assess the usability of the source/register;
2. Detailed analysis of the quality of the administrative source in terms
of:
 Legal basis: Analize the kind of legislation needed to allow access to,
transfer and use of administrative data at unit level for statistical
purposes.
 Consultations between owner and user organizations to understand the
opportunities and difficulties: Which definitions were used? What is the
scope? What is the coverage; Which are the reference periods; What are
the identifiers used? etc.
 Public support: It is important to make clear the differences between
statistical and non-statistical utilization of administrative data files both in
professional and public groups of society.
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of administrative sources:
Steps for implementation (contd.)
 Design a government-wide project well in advance as a good
organisational way to outline responsibilities and the necessary work:
 Make an inventory of all available admin data sources including the
evaluation of its content in terms of usability and quality.
 Develop the content and the conceptual framework for the utilization of
administrative records for the census.
 Decide what items are to be produced from what kind of data sources.
 Determine step by step how the data sets are to be prepared for
interconnection / linking.
 Develop the synchronization relations of information systems and the
commonly accepted data management and data security regulations.
 Plan the budget for the particular preparatory work related to the use of
administrative sources for the agricultural census
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of administrative sources:
Advantages
Reduction of cost of census data production;
Reduction of the burden on respondents;
By combining the data collected in the field with the data from administrative
sources, new derived variables can be created;
It allows compilation and publication more frequently and faster;
Non-response rate can be either significantly reduced or eliminated (when data on
the entire target census population is included in the administrative sources);
It could significantly improve the quality of the source and leads to a substantial
harmonization of certain information between different institutions.
 As a result of more efficient and faster operation the public perception of
statistics may become more favourable.
4. Combined agriculture census with
use of administrative sources:
disadvantages
Linkage of data sets can be difficult (or impossible) if legal background is unclear;
It could be very difficult to establish a good cooperation with register owners;
The cost for the access to the admin data could be too high.
When there is different population coverage, admin sources can be used for pre-filling the
questionnaires only on common population while other units need to be enumerated;
Incoherence of concepts, definitions, classification and reference periods could hamper the
use of admin sources;
Problems related to linking data from various data sources;
Problems on quality or risks concerning stability may arise due to political changes;
Timeliness and punctuality;
If an admin source is abolished, it is difficult to provide comparable statistical data series;
Substantive or technical changes in the admin sources may not be detected immediately;
Comparability over time is strongly influenced by the change in the level of coverage in
the different years and can give misleading results.
4. Combined agriculture census
with use of admin sources:
requirements
Availability of relevant Registers and Administrative database/s with good quality data at
individual holding level, clear and harmonised definitions and appropriate frequency for data
update
Availability of sufficient competent experts with good IT infrastructure knowledge and
database management skills at the initial stage of the census preparation.
Existence of an Agreement established between the census office (user) and administrative
body (owner) defining methodological and technical details about the access and use of admin
sources.
Public appreciation of the benefits of using register sources for statistical purposes.
Availability of a good legal basis and governance infrastructure, involvement of public
authorities and administrative sources owners, and an established system for data control.
Good IT infrastructure;
Unified identification system through all data sources.
Country examples
Uruguay National Agricultural Census 2011:
Classical approach, complete enumeration, one-off
operation
•The total agricultural area of the country (163,572 km2
out of a total country surface of 176,000 km2
) was
divided in 637 enumeration sectors that were canvassed
during 4 months taken information from 44,781
agricultural holdings of 1 ha and over of total area.
•An unique census questionnaire was used containing
12 sections and more than 250 questions.
Country examples
Gambia 2011-2012 Census of agriculture: sampled-based census.
•The 2011/2012 Census of Agriculture was a sample survey of
approximately 15% of rural households in the 2003 Census of Population.
•The sampling design was a stratified two-stage design with districts
forming the strata and the first-stage units being the EAs. First stage units
were selected systematically in proportion to the 2003 total number of
households. The second-stage sampling units were the holders (of
agricultural holdings) within EAs from which a systematic random sample
of five (5) holders was selected for enumeration.
•The enumeration period spanned for 7 months.
•Seven structured questionnaire forms were used (listing, demographic, area
measurement-GPS, harvest, community, groundnut, mango).
Country examples
Bangladesh Census of Agriculture 2008: Modular approach.
The census was taken in two phases:
• First phase (11-25 May 2008) for the core module (complete enumeration);
• Second phase (15 Nov - 4 Dec 2008) for the supplementary modules (on
sample basis).
The core module covered all households managing more than 0.05 acres of
land. It comprised all recommended items for the core module in the WCA
2010 Programme.
Six supplementary modules were undertaken by means of a long
questionnaire applied to a sample of holdings identified during the core
module and classified in “small”, “medium” and “large” holdings. The
supplementary modules were:
 equipment and farming system;  agriculture employment;
 irrigated area under crops;  stock of livestock and poultry;
 agriculture credit;  agriculture implements.
Country examples
Netherland Agricultural Census 2010: Combined agricultural census
with use of administrative registers.
•The agricultural census frame for the AC 2010 was the administrative farm
register (AFR) of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Agriculture and
Innovation. Farmers have to register by law. The AFR contains names,
addresses and other characteristics of holders or holdings and a unique
registration number.
•The agricultural census applies a higher threshold than the AFR, thus only
agricultural holdings above the threshold are taken into account.
•This threshold is applied to separate professional from hobby farmers, and
to minimize processing burden.
•Information on the census items existing in the AFR is taken directly from
the register for the whole census population.
MANY THANKS
54

More Related Content

What's hot

Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingCensus Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingFAO
 
Use of Technology CAPI
Use of Technology CAPIUse of Technology CAPI
Use of Technology CAPIFAO
 
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3FAO
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureFAO
 
Community-level data
Community-level dataCommunity-level data
Community-level dataFAO
 
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...FAO
 
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2FAO
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and MethodologyFAO
 
Legal and institutional framework
Legal and institutional frameworkLegal and institutional framework
Legal and institutional frameworkFAO
 
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...FAO
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and MethodologyFAO
 
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...FAO
 
Census communication and publicity
Census communication and publicityCensus communication and publicity
Census communication and publicityFAO
 
Community-level data
Community-level dataCommunity-level data
Community-level dataFAO
 
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural CensusesLinking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural CensusesFAO
 
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020FAO
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureFAO
 
Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
 Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingFAO
 
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologies
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologiesRoundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologies
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologiesFAO
 
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design FAO
 

What's hot (20)

Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingCensus Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
 
Use of Technology CAPI
Use of Technology CAPIUse of Technology CAPI
Use of Technology CAPI
 
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3
Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
 
Community-level data
Community-level dataCommunity-level data
Community-level data
 
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...
Overview of the new features of the WCA 2020. Importance of the WCA in the li...
 
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2
Recent methodological developments (MSF): Technical Session 2
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
 
Legal and institutional framework
Legal and institutional frameworkLegal and institutional framework
Legal and institutional framework
 
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...
Overview of the new features of the WCA2020. Importance of the WCA in the lig...
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
 
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...
Overview of the New Features of World Programme for the Census of Agriculture...
 
Census communication and publicity
Census communication and publicityCensus communication and publicity
Census communication and publicity
 
Community-level data
Community-level dataCommunity-level data
Community-level data
 
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural CensusesLinking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
Linking Population and Housing Censuses with Agricultural Censuses
 
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020
Agenda Item 1.2: THE WORLD PROGRAMME FOR THE CENSUS OF AGRICULTURE 2020
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
 
Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
 Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
 
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologies
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologiesRoundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologies
Roundtable on countries census plans, approaches and methodologies
 
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design
Operational Issues : Technical Session 19a Questionnaire Design
 

Similar to Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3

Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdf
Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdfData collection for agriculture tasks.pdf
Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdfABHILASHCN1
 
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18FAO
 
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...FAO
 
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...ipcc-media
 
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlich
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlichCn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlich
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlichErik van den Elsen
 
AGRIS toolkit
AGRIS toolkitAGRIS toolkit
AGRIS toolkitFAO
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureFAO
 
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15FAO
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and MethodologyFAO
 
project monitoring and evaluation
 project monitoring and evaluation project monitoring and evaluation
project monitoring and evaluationMir Mosharraf Hosain
 
AGRIS Methodology
AGRIS MethodologyAGRIS Methodology
AGRIS MethodologyFAO
 
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...Tariq A. Deen
 
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...
 PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ... PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...NAP Events
 
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingCensus Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingFAO
 

Similar to Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3 (20)

Improving activity data for Tier 2 estimates of livestock emissions: End of W...
Improving activity data for Tier 2 estimates of livestock emissions: End of W...Improving activity data for Tier 2 estimates of livestock emissions: End of W...
Improving activity data for Tier 2 estimates of livestock emissions: End of W...
 
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop Module 4
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop Module 4Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop Module 4
Agriculture Public Expenditure Workshop Module 4
 
Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdf
Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdfData collection for agriculture tasks.pdf
Data collection for agriculture tasks.pdf
 
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18
Census tabulation , archiving and disemmination Technical session 18
 
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
 
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...
Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing Higher Tiers in the National GHG...
 
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlich
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlichCn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlich
Cn 3 wed13_cde_feedback_on_wb3_sessions_schwlich
 
AGRIS toolkit
AGRIS toolkitAGRIS toolkit
AGRIS toolkit
 
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agricultureMain steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
Main steps in developing and implementing the census of agriculture
 
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15
Census Tabulation, Archiving and Dissemination : Technical Session 15
 
Module 6: Measurement, Reporting and Verification (MRV) and adaptation M&E
Module 6: Measurement, Reporting and Verification (MRV) and adaptation M&EModule 6: Measurement, Reporting and Verification (MRV) and adaptation M&E
Module 6: Measurement, Reporting and Verification (MRV) and adaptation M&E
 
RBM for climate change adaptation and mitigation
RBM for climate change adaptation and mitigationRBM for climate change adaptation and mitigation
RBM for climate change adaptation and mitigation
 
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and MethodologyAgricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS):  Rationale and Methodology
Agricultural Integrated Survey (AGRIS): Rationale and Methodology
 
project monitoring and evaluation
 project monitoring and evaluation project monitoring and evaluation
project monitoring and evaluation
 
AGRIS Methodology
AGRIS MethodologyAGRIS Methodology
AGRIS Methodology
 
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & G...
 
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...
 PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ... PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...
PEG M&E tool: a tool for monitoring and reviewing Progress, Effectiveness & ...
 
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and ArchivingCensus Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
Census Tabulation, Dissemination and Archiving
 
CCAFS Low emissions development (LED) activities funded by USAID
CCAFS Low emissions development (LED) activities funded by USAIDCCAFS Low emissions development (LED) activities funded by USAID
CCAFS Low emissions development (LED) activities funded by USAID
 
Operation research
Operation researchOperation research
Operation research
 

More from FAO

Nigeria
NigeriaNigeria
NigeriaFAO
 
Niger
NigerNiger
NigerFAO
 
Namibia
NamibiaNamibia
NamibiaFAO
 
Mozambique
MozambiqueMozambique
MozambiqueFAO
 
Zimbabwe takesure
Zimbabwe takesureZimbabwe takesure
Zimbabwe takesureFAO
 
Zimbabwe
ZimbabweZimbabwe
ZimbabweFAO
 
Zambia
ZambiaZambia
ZambiaFAO
 
Togo
TogoTogo
TogoFAO
 
Tanzania
TanzaniaTanzania
TanzaniaFAO
 
Spal presentation
Spal presentationSpal presentation
Spal presentationFAO
 
Rwanda
RwandaRwanda
RwandaFAO
 
Nigeria uponi
Nigeria uponiNigeria uponi
Nigeria uponiFAO
 
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)FAO
 
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)FAO
 
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water Days
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water DaysAgenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water Days
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water DaysFAO
 
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meeting
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meetingAgenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meeting
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meetingFAO
 
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil Management
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil ManagementThe Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil Management
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil ManagementFAO
 
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forward
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forwardGLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forward
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forwardFAO
 
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)FAO
 
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019GSP developments of regional interest in 2019
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019FAO
 

More from FAO (20)

Nigeria
NigeriaNigeria
Nigeria
 
Niger
NigerNiger
Niger
 
Namibia
NamibiaNamibia
Namibia
 
Mozambique
MozambiqueMozambique
Mozambique
 
Zimbabwe takesure
Zimbabwe takesureZimbabwe takesure
Zimbabwe takesure
 
Zimbabwe
ZimbabweZimbabwe
Zimbabwe
 
Zambia
ZambiaZambia
Zambia
 
Togo
TogoTogo
Togo
 
Tanzania
TanzaniaTanzania
Tanzania
 
Spal presentation
Spal presentationSpal presentation
Spal presentation
 
Rwanda
RwandaRwanda
Rwanda
 
Nigeria uponi
Nigeria uponiNigeria uponi
Nigeria uponi
 
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 2)
 
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)
The multi-faced role of soil in the NENA regions (part 1)
 
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water Days
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water DaysAgenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water Days
Agenda of the launch of the soil policy brief at the Land&Water Days
 
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meeting
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meetingAgenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meeting
Agenda of the 5th NENA Soil Partnership meeting
 
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil Management
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil ManagementThe Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil Management
The Voluntary Guidelines for Sustainable Soil Management
 
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forward
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forwardGLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forward
GLOSOLAN - Mission, status and way forward
 
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)
Towards a Global Soil Information System (GLOSIS)
 
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019GSP developments of regional interest in 2019
GSP developments of regional interest in 2019
 

Recently uploaded

Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptx
Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptxWellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptx
Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptxJisc
 
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning PresentationSOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentationcamerronhm
 
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsKarakKing
 
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...Pooja Bhuva
 
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.MaryamAhmad92
 
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please PractiseSpellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please PractiseAnaAcapella
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...ZurliaSoop
 
Understanding Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding  Accommodations and ModificationsUnderstanding  Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding Accommodations and ModificationsMJDuyan
 
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptxTowards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptxJisc
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxDenish Jangid
 
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.christianmathematics
 
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan FellowsOn National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan FellowsMebane Rash
 
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...Poonam Aher Patil
 
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - English
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - EnglishGraduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - English
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - Englishneillewis46
 
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptx
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptxHow to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptx
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptxCeline George
 
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...Pooja Bhuva
 
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdfUGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdfNirmal Dwivedi
 
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docxPython Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docxRamakrishna Reddy Bijjam
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptx
Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptxWellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptx
Wellbeing inclusion and digital dystopias.pptx
 
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning PresentationSOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
SOC 101 Demonstration of Learning Presentation
 
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functionsSalient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
Salient Features of India constitution especially power and functions
 
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
How to Create and Manage Wizard in Odoo 17
 
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
Sensory_Experience_and_Emotional_Resonance_in_Gabriel_Okaras_The_Piano_and_Th...
 
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.
ICT role in 21st century education and it's challenges.
 
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please PractiseSpellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
Spellings Wk 3 English CAPS CARES Please Practise
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
Jual Obat Aborsi Hongkong ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan...
 
Understanding Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding  Accommodations and ModificationsUnderstanding  Accommodations and Modifications
Understanding Accommodations and Modifications
 
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptxTowards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
Towards a code of practice for AI in AT.pptx
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
 
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan FellowsOn National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
On National Teacher Day, meet the 2024-25 Kenan Fellows
 
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
 
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - English
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - EnglishGraduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - English
Graduate Outcomes Presentation Slides - English
 
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 3pptx.pptx
 
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptx
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptxHow to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptx
How to setup Pycharm environment for Odoo 17.pptx
 
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
Beyond_Borders_Understanding_Anime_and_Manga_Fandom_A_Comprehensive_Audience_...
 
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdfUGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
UGC NET Paper 1 Mathematical Reasoning & Aptitude.pdf
 
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docxPython Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
 

Methodological considerations for the census design : Technical Session 3

  • 1. Workshop on World Programme for the Census of Agriculture 2020 Bangkok, Thailand 19-23 September 2016 Jairo Castano Senior Statistician Leader, Agricultural Census and Survey Team FAO Statistics Division Methodological Considerations Technical Session 3 1
  • 2. 2 Contents • Background • Overview of census modalities: description, implementation steps, advantages, disadvantages and requirements 1. Classical approach 2. Modular approach 3. Integrated census/survey modality 4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative sources • Country examples
  • 3. Background • The present Programme broadens the approaches introduced in the previous one, acknowledging that the census of agriculture can be conducted in different ways, using four main modalities: Classical approach Modular approach Integrated census and survey programme Combined census with use of administrative sources • Main aim is to help countries to implement a census in most efficient way, taking into account countries’ particular conditions.
  • 4. Overview of census modalities i) The classical approach: a census conducted in a single one-off operation (usually by complete enumeration) comprising the universe of agricultural holdings. It should cover all essential items and may include additional items. ii) Modular approach: comprises: a) a core module undertaken by complete enumeration including all frame items and eventually other items; and b) supplementary modules targeting specific populations identified through the frame provided by the core module. iii) The integrated census and survey programme: integrates a multi-year programme of censuses and surveys. One option is AGRIS, a modular survey programme which has to be articulated with the agricultural census programme and conducted on an annual basis between two censuses. iv) Combined census with use of admin sources: registers and other administrative sources are used as a source of census data in combination with field data collection.
  • 5. Comparison of census modalities Classical Modular Integrated census/survey Combined with admin Enumeration phases One-off field operation Multiple phases: a) core module b) supplementary module(s) Multiple phases: a) census core module b) rotating thematic modules One or more field operations and use of admin sources Coverage of items All census items collected during a one- off operation Core module includes items required at the lowest geo/admin level, and those to establish frames for the supplementary module(s) Census core-module includes items required at the lowest geographic/admin level, and those to establish frames for rotating thematic module(s) Census items are collected through field operation and use of administrative sources. Enumeration method Complete enumeration exclusively or combined with sample enumeration Complete enumeration for core module and sample enumeration for supplementary modules(s) Complete enumeration for census core module and sampling for rotating thematic modules Complete enumeration exclusively or combined with sample enumeration
  • 6. Alternative census modalities • The classical approach is the most extensively used census modality. However, more and more countries would use alternative census modalities in the near future. • There are important reasons for using alternative census modalities: i. budget limitation for census, ii. need to produce more frequent and timely agricultural statistics, iii. fast growing digital and mobile technology; iv. increasing availability and access to data from administrative sources and technical capacities to handle such data; v. reluctance of some population groups to participate in the census and need to reduce respondent burden.
  • 7. Some common issues for any census modality • Identify data content of the census: o The minimum requirement for a census, is to include all essential items, in order to enable international comparison and frame items for census modules or/and follow up surveys o The final list of census items should be established in consultation with main stakeholders depending on country’s requirements, availability of reliable administrative and other data sources, financial and other resources o In countries with well-developed registers, the use of administrative data sources (ADS) to cover census data items should be considered .
  • 8. Some common issues for any census modality (cntd.) • The frame for the agric. census must be carefully established to ensure that all holdings are covered with no omissions or duplications. •Use of sample enumeration  efficiency considerations (precision versus costs), other elements should be taken into account, such as:  desired level of aggregation for census data  use of the census as a frame for ongoing sample surveys  data content of the census and  capacity to deal with sampling methods and subsequent statistical analysis based on
  • 9. Some common issues for any census modality (cntd.) •Use of thresholds oIn many countries, a minimum size limit is adopted for holdings included in the census. oThe rationale for this could be: in the country there is a large number of very small holdings which make a marginal contribution to total agricultural production but their inclusion in the census greatly increases the workload and census budget.
  • 10. 1. The classical approach • May be considered as a census conducted as a single one-off operation in which all the census information is recorded. By extension, this approach also includes the short-long questionnaire concept. • Should include all “essential” items and may include “additional” items depending on: a) country’s requirements; b) other data sources (e.g. non-structural items); and c) available resources. • Can be conducted by complete enumeration, sample enumeration, or by a combination of both.
  • 11. 1. The classical approach (contd.) This approach is appropriate when countries: •Wish to conduct a single one-off operation •Have an integrated census and survey programme (e.g. no need for supplementary modules) •Wish to collect some additional items at low administrative levels.
  • 12. 1. The classical approach: main features • Enumeration is conducted as a single one-off operation, during a specified enumeration period, providing a snapshot of the entire population at a specified period. • However, certain regions of a country may be enumerated at different times of the year because of seasonal and agricultural conditions. • The classical approach also includes cases where (under the short-long questionnaire concept) the long questionnaire is completed at a second visit.
  • 13. 1. The classical approach: ways and steps for its implementation The following questions arise: 1) Will complete enumeration be used in exclusivity or in combination with sample enumeration? 2) If complete enumeration is used in combination with sampling, what part of the population will be sampled? Is a reliable sample frame available? 3) Will a single questionnaire be administered to all agricultural holdings, or different questionnaires, e.g. will a short-long questionnaire concept be applied?
  • 14. 1. The classical approach: complete enumeration • Exhaustive enumeration of all agricultural holdings above a threshold (if any). • It is the most costly and challenging in terms of planning and organization. It is much less demanding in respect of the characteristics contained in the frame than a sample-based census and is often the most practical way to conduct a census and build up a statistical farm register.
  • 15. 1. The classical approach: sample & complete enumeration • A part of the target population is enumerated on exhaustive basis and another part using sample. This method aims at increasing cost- efficiency but the sampled part will not provide reliable statistics at the smallest administrative level. • Ways to combine: ◦ Use complete enumeration in some regions (agriculturally important and/or easy access) and sample enumeration in other regions; ◦ Use complete enumeration for some types of holdings (large holdings, commercial holdings or holdings above the threshold) and sample enumeration for the remaining holdings; ◦ Use of complete enumeration for key census items (such as essential and frame items) and sample enumeration to collect additional information. This is a special case of the short-long questionnaire concept.
  • 16. 1. The classical approach: sample enumeration • A large sample of holdings (large enough to generate sub-national data) is selected and enumerated in one-off operation. • It is less costly in terms of field work and reduces the respondent burden in comparison with complete enumeration. • However, a reliable sampling frame with adequate auxiliary information (e.g. area of holding, number of livestock) is required, as well as high-level expertise in survey organization and sampling. • The probability sample of agricultural holdings for sample enumeration can be drawn from the sampling frame built-up based on a recent population and housing census, a statistical farm register and/or other statistical and administrative sources.
  • 17. 1. The classical approach: types of questionnaires • Single questionnaire: administered to all agricultural holdings covered by the census without regard of their type. It is easy to apply in the field. • Short-long questionnaire: In many cases (mainly when an updated census frame is not available) the classical approach involves the short- long questionnaire modality: ­ Short questionnaire administered to screen the target population and collects basic information on all households and identifies holdings meeting a given threshold; ­ Long questionnaire administered only to holdings identified above the threshold (or to a sample of such holdings) to collect more detailed information from the holdings. • Other types of questionnaires: specific census questionnaires to fit different segments of the target population (such as household and non- household based holdings). Or for different provinces when these differ considerably in cropping and livestock systems, and in agricultural practices.
  • 18. 1. The classical approach: Data collection from holdings in the household sector and in the non-household sector • Two types of agricultural holdings: - In the household sector - in the non-household sector. • Special holdings such as large commercial holdings, usually are in the non- household sector and are “self-enumerated” or interviewed face-to-face. • The enumeration period for special holdings should be similar to that established for the other holdings. When self-enumeration methods are used, census questionnaires should be sent well in advance to allow timely provision of data. • Household-based holdings, in developing countries are commonly enumerated using face-to-face interviews.
  • 19. 1. The classical approach: advantages • Provides a snapshot of the entire target population at a specified period and comprehensive data sets are available at the lowest geographical level. • Data can be produced at lowest administrative and geographical levels with no sampling error. Tabulations can be done in line with high user’s requirements, including data for small administrative units and information on rare events, such as emerging crops, rare crops and types of livestock. • When taken with complete enumeration it is much less demanding in respect of the characteristics contained in the frame than the sample-based census. • The classical census taken by complete enumeration can constitute a good basis for building up a statistical farm register and an exhaustive sampling frame for subsequent regular agricultural surveys.
  • 20. 1. The classical approach: disadvantages • Cost and administrative complexity (mainly if it is taken by complete enumeration); • It implies a high burden on respondents; • There is the risk to overburden the census questionnaire because of the high pressure from some policy makers or other stakeholders to include detailed items to collect data at the national level and at the lowest administrative level; • Very large number of enumerators and supervisors required (complete enumeration); • The amount of data to be processed is larger.
  • 21. 1. The classical approach: requirements • Good organization capacity and planning. • Sufficient and timely budget allocation during census preparation, field operation, data processing & dissemination needs to be ensured. • Availability of sufficient number of qualified field staff. • Involvement of all relevant public authorities, in particular at local level, is essential for successful field operations (enumeration, publicity campaign). • If the classical census is conducted on sample basis, additional requirements are: Availability of a good survey organization capacity of the census agency, including adequate sampling expertise. Availability of a reliable sampling frame.
  • 22. 2. Modular census: main features • This modality has a clearly distinguishable core module (on a complete enumeration basis) and one or more supplementary modules (on a sample basis). • An essential condition: data from the core module used as frame for the supplementary module(s). The census using the short-long questionnaire in one operation is not considered as modular census (no frame use). • A ‘module’ is defined as a group of data items to be collected on a specific target population (e.g. holdings with livestock). • All essential items should be covered by the core and supplementary module(s).
  • 23. 2. Modular census: main features (contd.) • Core module must include the items required at the lowest geographic or administrative levels, and/or needed to establish sampling frames for the supplementary module(s). • The core module should include all frame items. This module should also cover rare events (unusual crops or livestock), which would not be possible to estimate from supplementary modules conducted on sample basis because of high sampling errors. • Supplementary modules use the frame generated by the core module to target specific populations and should include the rest of the agreed census items that are not included in the core module.
  • 24. 2. Modular census modality: ways and steps for implementation • Two ways of implementing the modular approach: i. implementing core and supplementary modules separately ii. implementing the core module and the supplementary module(s) as part of a single data collection operation (difficult in practice). • Sources of frame data for supplementary modules: a) The census core module; b) An agricultural module/section of the population census; c) Administrative registers.
  • 25. 2 a). Core module with complete enumeration as frame for supplementary module(s) (i) Implementing core and supplementary modules separately. It implies two phases:  Phase 1: the core module is first implemented and questionnaires are returned to the office for processing and building frame (s) for the supplementary module(s);  Phase 2: enumerators return to the field to carry out the census supplementary module(s) on the selected sample (s) of holdings for the module(s) (ii) Implementing the core module and the supplementary module(s) as part of a single data collection operation. It implies:  Collect data for the core census module;  Apply specific sampling procedures, based on responses to the core module questions, to determine holdings to include in the supplementary module(s);  If the holding is included in the sample for the supplementary module(s), proceed to apply the supplementary module(s). Otherwise, the interview is finished.
  • 26. 2 b). Modular census: Agricultural data from a recent population census as frame for supplementary modules When an agricultural module/section is included in the population census, two possible situations arise: Only few agricultural items were included in the population census, not enough to provide frame items needed for all supplementary modules. In this case, a lighter core module is needed to collect missing frame items and any other item suitable for the core. Most of the frame items have been collected in the agricultural module/section of the population census. Therefore, the country may use this information to implement the supplementary modules.
  • 27. 2 c). Modular census : Administrative sources as frame data for supplementary modules • In countries where administrative data is well organised and of good quality data may be available to provide a large proportion of all essential data items, including frame data for supplementary modules. • This information can be therefore used to implement one or more supplementary modules to collect the rest of the essential data or specific data of interest to the country.
  • 28. 2. Modular census: special holdings • In the modular census, special holdings (large commercial farms, holdings in the non-household sector, etc.) may be covered during the first or second phase field operation (supplementary modules). • All required information (core and supplementary) should be collected in one operation only by dedicated staff using a specific questionnaire for such holdings. The timing will depend on the availability of dedicated staff for collecting the data. • Efforts should be made to cover these special holdings as closely as possible to the implementation of the core module in the household sector to ensure that the same reference period is used for all items collected.
  • 29. 2. Modular census modality: advantages • The combination of core and supplementary items allows the modular census to produce a more extensive and country-specific range of data compared with the classical census modality, for which small area estimates are not important. • More effective use of available budget to collect country relevant information. • Allows a focused and more detailed training of field personnel. • Countries with a not well established system of agricultural surveys and limited budget may find the modular approach as a logical first step towards the creation of a system of integrated agricultural censuses and surveys.
  • 30. 2. Modular census modality: disadvantages • Risk of having a core module with too many items (due to pressure from stakeholders) at low geographical level. • The lack of well trained professional staff in sampling. • If supplem. modules are undertaken at the same time as the core module there exists the risk of loss of data quality if not properly organized. • There are limitations in terms of cross-tabulation between variables in the core and in the supplementary modules or between variables in different supplementary modules not conducted jointly. • If the time lag between the implementation of the core and supplem. modules is too long, the benefit of having a good frame from the core module disappears. An frame update would be needed adding to the cost. • If the core module is largely covered in a population census it could be difficult to mobilize additional funds for supplementary modules. • In the absence of a rigorous programming, the conducting of the core module and publication of results can jeopardize a better preparation of complementary and thematic modules.
  • 31. 2. Modular census modality: requirements • Good planning and survey organization capacity, including minimum sampling expertise. • Adequate budget allocation between core and supplementary modules • Capacity and resources to conduct core module and supplementary modules with a short time lag • Availability of field staff with minimum level of qualification that can be mobilized to conduct sometimes complex surveys for supplementary modules • A good cooperation and coordination of census activities between interested institutions and good partnership in the organization of a comprehensive census publicity communication/public awareness campaign.
  • 32. 3. Integrated Census/survey modality • This new modality features a census core module (to be conducted on a complete enumeration basis) and a number of several rotating thematic modules (to be conducted annually or periodically on sample basis over a 10-year period). An example of rotating modules is the new Agricultural Integrated Survey programme (AGRIS). • The recommended data items to be covered in this census modality are the same as all other modalities (essential, frame and additional items). • The census core module should mainly provide frame data needed to implement rotating thematic modules.
  • 33. 3. What is AGRIS? • The AGRIS is a modular survey program which is to be articulated with the agricultural census programme and conducted on an annual basis between two censuses. • It consists of one annual core module (crop and livestock production) and four rotating modules: ‘economy’, ‘labour force’, ‘machinery and equipment’, and ‘production methods and environment’. Additional modules can be added as needed. • In the integrated census and survey modality, AGRIS is synchronized with the agricultural census core module and operates over a 10-year cycle.
  • 34. Example of possible modules and timing of their implementation (illustration) POSSIBLE MODULES YEARS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Agricultural census core module (and AGRIS core module where relevant and possible) • AGRIS Core Module Crop production  • • • • • • • • • Livestock production  • • • • • • • • • AGRIS Rot. Module 1 Economy • • • • AGRIS Rot. Module 2 Labour force • • • AGRIS Rot. Module 3 Machinery and equipment • • AGRIS Rot. Module 4 Production methods and environment • • • 3. Integrated Census/survey modality: illustration  denotes optional implementation in year 1
  • 35. 3. Integrated Census/survey modality: ways and steps for the implementation • The implementation of the integrated census/survey modality will start with a census core module (on a complete enumeration). • As with other modalities, there could be three sources of frame data for the rotating thematic module(s): a) census core module (on complete enumeration) b) An agricultural module/section in the population census c) Administrative registers
  • 36. 3 a). Integrated census/survey modality: census core module as frame for rotating thematic module(s) • The census core module and the rotating thematic modules will be conducted as follow: • During the first year the census core module is implemented through complete enumeration. The frame data collected is processed and analyzed to build required frames for the subsequent rotating thematic modules and AGRIS core module. • The frame is used to design the surveys that will be implemented in the following years to collect data for the rotating thematic modules and AGRIS core module until the next complete enumeration exercise. • From year 2, AGRIS core will be implemented annually while each rotating thematic module will be implemented every 2 or 3 years. Therefore, each year there will be a survey covering AGRIS core and one or more rotating thematic modules. Annual surveys will therefore be a combination of farm structure data and current production data providing continuous flow of data and allowing more frequent update of some structural information.
  • 37. 3 b) and c). Integrated census/survey modality: population census and admin sources as frame for rotating thematic modules and AGRIS core • Similar to earlier modalities.
  • 38. 3. Integrated census/survey modality: advantages • Effective use of available budget to collect country relevant information on an annual basis • More detailed information available on topics of interest • Focused training of field staff • Wider set of census items • Decisive step towards the establishment of a system of integrated censuses and surveys
  • 39. 3. Integrated census/survey modality: limitations • The risk of expanding too much the census core module resulting in high cost which will reduce the relative benefits of this census modality. • The challenge of conducting the census core module and AGRIS core at the same time (when relevant). This requires good survey planning and sampling capacity. • The limitations in terms of cross-tabulation between variables in the core and in the rotating thematic modules or between variables in different rotating thematic modules not conducted jointly. • Difference in the reference period for different census items collected in the census core and the items in the rotating thematic modules.
  • 40. 3. Integrated census/survey modality: requirements • The need for maintaining and updating the sampling frame is critical as the frame becomes gradually obsolete over time. • A mechanism should be put in place to ensure its validity. • It requires well trained personnel in sampling methods, an additional cost. • It requires a continuous flow of resources. In countries where funding is mainly from external sources, there may be budgetary and other administrative constraints for commitments over such a long period as 10 years.
  • 41. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative sources: main features • A meaningful part of the census items for the entire population of the census of agriculture (or for part of it) comes from existing administrative sources created for non-statistical purposes. • The data could come from one or several administrative sources. It could be also used in combination with field data collection.
  • 42. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of admin sources: main features (contd.) • An important feature of the data from administrative sources is that the information is not primarily collected for statistical purposes. • Administrative sources may be for selective items or may target a specific population. • Thus the definition of the population of interest and the data collection protocols is out of the control of the census office. • There is a substantial difference in the organisational approach of the census when using administrative data as compared to other approaches. • As the objects already exist in the data source, a selection need to be made of objects (holders or holdings) and variables that are relevant to the census.
  • 43. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of admin sources: Quality considerations • Some information in administrative sources could be of low importance for administrative purposes which may result in lower statistical quality. • The purpose and method used to collect data should also be taken into account to detect possible systematic errors or systematic bias in the register • The following quality aspects need to be carefully considered: ­ Relevance (content) of the administrative data sources. ­ Accuracy: an admin source is of good quality if a large proportion of the variables required for the census exists in the register and corresponding data are reliable. ­ One important accuracy category is related to the data coverage: under-coverage or over-coverage of units, multiple listings, and misclassification of items. ­ Completeness ­ Unreported events: data related to the reference period is not available in the source referring to an event from which parameters are to be derived: e.g. births, deaths or loss, sales, etc. of livestock. • The information from administrative sources has to be coherent and comparable with data from other sources or over time. • The timeliness dimension (difference between the reference period and the availability of the results) when using administrative data source. • Accessibility in terms of physical access to the information in the admin source.
  • 44. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of admin sources: Ways of using admin data in this modality 1. The starting point (like in all census modalities) is to define the data content of the census in terms of data items to be covered. 2. Next step is to decide on the way to use the admin source. Possible ways or approaches are:  Split data approach: admin sources are used to provide some of the variables for all of the holdings.  Split population approach: Data from admin sources are used for some holdings where these data are of sufficient quality, and other statistical sources are used for the remainder of the holdings.  Combining the two approaches: administrative sources replace the field data collection for some of the variables for part of the holdings.  Pre-filling answers in the questionnaires which are to be checked by respondents during the census.  Totally replacing the census data collection, on all census characteristics and for all units in the census population with data coming from one or more admin sources (no very common).
  • 45. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of admin sources: Steps for implementation 1. Assess the usability of the source/register; 2. Detailed analysis of the quality of the administrative source in terms of:  Legal basis: Analize the kind of legislation needed to allow access to, transfer and use of administrative data at unit level for statistical purposes.  Consultations between owner and user organizations to understand the opportunities and difficulties: Which definitions were used? What is the scope? What is the coverage; Which are the reference periods; What are the identifiers used? etc.  Public support: It is important to make clear the differences between statistical and non-statistical utilization of administrative data files both in professional and public groups of society.
  • 46. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative sources: Steps for implementation (contd.)  Design a government-wide project well in advance as a good organisational way to outline responsibilities and the necessary work:  Make an inventory of all available admin data sources including the evaluation of its content in terms of usability and quality.  Develop the content and the conceptual framework for the utilization of administrative records for the census.  Decide what items are to be produced from what kind of data sources.  Determine step by step how the data sets are to be prepared for interconnection / linking.  Develop the synchronization relations of information systems and the commonly accepted data management and data security regulations.  Plan the budget for the particular preparatory work related to the use of administrative sources for the agricultural census
  • 47. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative sources: Advantages Reduction of cost of census data production; Reduction of the burden on respondents; By combining the data collected in the field with the data from administrative sources, new derived variables can be created; It allows compilation and publication more frequently and faster; Non-response rate can be either significantly reduced or eliminated (when data on the entire target census population is included in the administrative sources); It could significantly improve the quality of the source and leads to a substantial harmonization of certain information between different institutions.  As a result of more efficient and faster operation the public perception of statistics may become more favourable.
  • 48. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of administrative sources: disadvantages Linkage of data sets can be difficult (or impossible) if legal background is unclear; It could be very difficult to establish a good cooperation with register owners; The cost for the access to the admin data could be too high. When there is different population coverage, admin sources can be used for pre-filling the questionnaires only on common population while other units need to be enumerated; Incoherence of concepts, definitions, classification and reference periods could hamper the use of admin sources; Problems related to linking data from various data sources; Problems on quality or risks concerning stability may arise due to political changes; Timeliness and punctuality; If an admin source is abolished, it is difficult to provide comparable statistical data series; Substantive or technical changes in the admin sources may not be detected immediately; Comparability over time is strongly influenced by the change in the level of coverage in the different years and can give misleading results.
  • 49. 4. Combined agriculture census with use of admin sources: requirements Availability of relevant Registers and Administrative database/s with good quality data at individual holding level, clear and harmonised definitions and appropriate frequency for data update Availability of sufficient competent experts with good IT infrastructure knowledge and database management skills at the initial stage of the census preparation. Existence of an Agreement established between the census office (user) and administrative body (owner) defining methodological and technical details about the access and use of admin sources. Public appreciation of the benefits of using register sources for statistical purposes. Availability of a good legal basis and governance infrastructure, involvement of public authorities and administrative sources owners, and an established system for data control. Good IT infrastructure; Unified identification system through all data sources.
  • 50. Country examples Uruguay National Agricultural Census 2011: Classical approach, complete enumeration, one-off operation •The total agricultural area of the country (163,572 km2 out of a total country surface of 176,000 km2 ) was divided in 637 enumeration sectors that were canvassed during 4 months taken information from 44,781 agricultural holdings of 1 ha and over of total area. •An unique census questionnaire was used containing 12 sections and more than 250 questions.
  • 51. Country examples Gambia 2011-2012 Census of agriculture: sampled-based census. •The 2011/2012 Census of Agriculture was a sample survey of approximately 15% of rural households in the 2003 Census of Population. •The sampling design was a stratified two-stage design with districts forming the strata and the first-stage units being the EAs. First stage units were selected systematically in proportion to the 2003 total number of households. The second-stage sampling units were the holders (of agricultural holdings) within EAs from which a systematic random sample of five (5) holders was selected for enumeration. •The enumeration period spanned for 7 months. •Seven structured questionnaire forms were used (listing, demographic, area measurement-GPS, harvest, community, groundnut, mango).
  • 52. Country examples Bangladesh Census of Agriculture 2008: Modular approach. The census was taken in two phases: • First phase (11-25 May 2008) for the core module (complete enumeration); • Second phase (15 Nov - 4 Dec 2008) for the supplementary modules (on sample basis). The core module covered all households managing more than 0.05 acres of land. It comprised all recommended items for the core module in the WCA 2010 Programme. Six supplementary modules were undertaken by means of a long questionnaire applied to a sample of holdings identified during the core module and classified in “small”, “medium” and “large” holdings. The supplementary modules were:  equipment and farming system;  agriculture employment;  irrigated area under crops;  stock of livestock and poultry;  agriculture credit;  agriculture implements.
  • 53. Country examples Netherland Agricultural Census 2010: Combined agricultural census with use of administrative registers. •The agricultural census frame for the AC 2010 was the administrative farm register (AFR) of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Agriculture and Innovation. Farmers have to register by law. The AFR contains names, addresses and other characteristics of holders or holdings and a unique registration number. •The agricultural census applies a higher threshold than the AFR, thus only agricultural holdings above the threshold are taken into account. •This threshold is applied to separate professional from hobby farmers, and to minimize processing burden. •Information on the census items existing in the AFR is taken directly from the register for the whole census population.

Editor's Notes

  1. In the second category, other criteria, such as types of holdings and/or a threshold, are applied to define the use of complete and sample enumeration. Depending on the target population of holdings this category could be further split into two sub-categories: The first sub-category of combination is closer to complete enumeration and refers to cases where complete enumeration is applied to agricultural holdings with the largest contribution to the agricultural production (e.g. above a certain threshold), which usually constitute the bulk of the holdings. The remaining holdings (below a certain threshold or considered small in some other sense) are enumerated on a sample basis to ensure a complete picture of agriculture. The second sub-category refers to cases where complete enumeration is applied for large or “special” holdings (see paragraph 55), which may account for a significant contribution to agricultural production, while the remaining holdings, such as small and medium sized holdings (which usually constitute the bulk of agricultural holdings in countries with developing economies), are covered by sample enumeration. In fact, such a census may be considered as a sample-based census with one complete enumeration stratum and is described below.
  2. Sample-based census under the classical approach differs from the modular approach with supplementary module(s) conducted as part of a single data collection operation. In the former, sample is designed prior to census field work, while in the latter approach the core module provides the sampling frame to carry out the supplementary module(s)
  3. The use of Computer Assisted Personal Interview (CAPI) (see Section 4.2.1) can facilitate the field work. The devices can be programmed to use information collected in the short questionnaires to identify the sub-population to apply the long questionnaires. For example, the device can be programmed in such a way that the long questionnaire pops-up when a holding meets the threshold requirements or criteria related to the subpopulation of interest.
  4. Countries should make this decision depending on their national requirements, taking into account cost and resource availability, including financial and human resources.
  5. It is important that the supplementary module(s) are carried out as closely as possible to the core module so that the frame can be readily used and the same reference period can be kept for all census items. However, in cases where the supplementary modules are carried out over a period of time, some updating of the census frame may be necessary, in advance of the field work.
  6. In addition to those advantages, for countries that do not have a functioning agricultural statistics system, this modality being a 10-year integrated census/survey programme, lays the foundations for the creation of such a system to produce a regular flow of basic data. It will allow the generation of 65% of the Minimum set of core data recommended by the Global Strategy and will also provide basic data for monitoring the relevant Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Finally, AGRIS is expected to generate the flow of quality data required to monitor regional policy frameworks, such as the African Union Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP). Some countries may have 5-year census programme instead of 10-year programme. In this case, the implementation of AGRIS should be adapted to this particular situation with possibly more frequent implementation of the rotating thematic modules. See .......
  7. The cases where only the identification items are taken from administrative sources (such as name, address and location of the holding) are not considered as part of combined census modality, in these cases data from administrative sources can be used for construction of the census frame.
  8. The cases where only the identification items are taken from administrative sources (such as name, address and location of the holding) are not considered as part of combined census modality, in these cases data from administrative sources can be used for construction of the census frame.
  9. Possible problems are: missing data when some or all characteristics for a given unit are missing; errors in the variables when erroneous values for certain variables are registered (e.g., when the respondents give erroneous identification numbers for administrative data sources in the questionnaire).
  10. Pre-filled questionnaires have three main benefits: They help reduce the burden on data suppliers by saving them time (assuming that checking and correcting is quicker than finding and entering data) They allow to check the quality of the administrative data They are very flexible, particularly where the coverage of administrative data is not as complete as would be required for the other ways of use discussed above. They allow an easy data revisions/changes and adding additional information. The main disadvantage is the risk of bias introduced because some respondents may simply accept the pre-filled data without checking them, or may choose not to spend time correcting errors.