2. Zoom
Keep your picture hidden from others.
Study your picture. Each picture contains important
information to solve the problem.
Challenge: As a group, sequence the pictures in the correct
order without looking at each other’s pictures.
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
ACTIVITY TIME: 8 minutes
5. Overview
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Essential Questions:
How can I use the district-
sponsored curriculum
products to plan for
instruction?
How can curriculum
alignment across the district
fuel student achievement?
Participants will..
be able to explain the three-
stage approach to
curriculum design.
apply their understanding
of the curriculum
development process to
planning a lesson.
6. Agenda
Area of Focus Approximate Time
Introduction, Overview & Agenda 25 minutes
Planning Overview 16 minutes
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results 20 minutes
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence 20 minutes
Stage 3: Learning Plan 3 minutes
Closing 6 minutes
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Output: 3-2-1 Closing
7. Department Plan
(4 years)
Course Plan
(1-2 semesters)
Lesson Plan
(1+ days)
Unit Plan
(1-10 weeks)
What should students understand after completing the
full course sequence?
How does each course build upon the previous and
prepare students for the next?
What is the logical clustering of standards and sequence
of topics for the course?
How will students interact with the content to develop
proficiency?
8. “Twin Sins”
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Activity-
Oriented
Teaching
Coverage
Jay McTighe, author of
Understanding by Design
For a month every spring, 9th grade students
participate in a unit centered on Romeo and
Juliet. During the unit, students watch a
biography of Shakespeare and take notes on
the time period. They draw a family coat of
arms with a small group and create paper
bag puppets to use while reading the play
aloud in class. After they have read the play,
they watch a movie that shows a modern
version of the play. To earn their grade at the
end of the unit, students dress up, memorize
their lines, and act out a scene from the play.
They also take a test that asks them
questions about the reading, which they are
supposed to answer from memory to check if
they action read/listened to the play.
9. For a month every spring, 9th grader students
participate in a unit centered on Romeo and
Juliet. On days when students will be reading
the play in class, the teacher begins by
introducing and modeling a reading
comprehension or literary analysis strategy
using a small section of the text. While
students are reading in small groups and
independently, they practice applying newly
learned skills to the play. Throughout the
unit, they complete several oral and written
assignments that require them to think
critically, answering “how” and “why”
questions. To earn their grade at the end of
the unit students write about and orally
present on the play’s applicability to today’s
world.
“Twin Sins”
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Activity-
Oriented
Teaching
Coverage
10. Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Activity-
Oriented
Teaching
Coverage
“Twin Sins”
Each year, the World History teachers begin
by teaching students about the first human.
They discuss Mesopotamia, Israel, Ancient
Greece, India and China. By mid-September
they transition from B.C. to A.D. They lecture
and assign readings about Greek Gods,
Ancient Rome, Islam, early African
civilizations, the Roman World, European
Kingdoms, the Crusades, the Middle Ages,
the Americas, Renaissance, and the
Reformation all before winter break. In
second semester they touch on Exploration,
Asia, Enlightenment, the French Revolution,
Industrialism, Nationalism, WWI, WWII, and
brief topics from recent history. By the end of
the year, students have heard all of history.
11. Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Activity-
Oriented
Teaching
Coverage
“Twin Sins”
Each year, the World History teachers explore
a series of topics with students. Teachers
framed learning around questions, such as:
What are the positive and negative
consequences of globalization? How did early
people adapt to change and create
civilization? How can the power of ideas
shape society and culture? Students read
historical and contemporary documents to
explore the ideas. They apply their learning
to different civilizations and time periods.
Ultimately, students use the understanding
they gain about the past and the formations
of and changes in different societies to write
about and orally present an answer to the
overarching question: How has the past
shaped the present?
12. Traditional Planning Phases
Identify the content being taught…
“What chapters in the book should I cover?”
“What terms should they know?”
Brainstorm activities and methods…
“What activities can I do that will be fun and keep
their interest?”
“What things can I do to get through all the
material?”
Come up with an assessment…
“Let’s see what I’ve taught so I’ll know what to put
on the test.”
“How can I write this so it will assess everything
we’ve learned?”
13. TUHSD Design Phases
Identify desired outcomes…
“What is essential that students understand by the
end of the unit/year?”
“What should they be able to do with that
knowledge?”
Determine acceptable evidence…
“What counts as proof that students have gained
new knowledge/skills?”
“How can I be sure they can use their new
learning?”
Plan learning experience and instruction…
“What are the most effective ways to get students
there?”
14. Think-Write-Pair-Share
Think about a time that you have used or experienced either
activity-based planning or coverage.
Why do you think you or the teacher relied on that “twin sin”?
Why is it important to plan with outcomes in mind?
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
ACTIVITY TIME: 1 minute
Think-Write-Pair-Share
Handout #1
15. Benefits
Our lessons, units and courses should be logically inferred from
the results sought, not derived from the methods, books and
activities with which we are most comfortable. Curriculum
should lay out the most effective way of achieving specific
results. It is analogous to travel planning. Our frameworks
should provide a set of itineraries deliberately designed to
meet cultural goals rather than a purposeless tour of all the
major sites in a foreign country. In short, the best designs
derive backward from the learnings sought.
-Grant Wiggins & Jay McTighe, Understanding by Design, 2005, p. 14
Clearer goals and defined teaching and learning targets
Greater coherence among desired results and key performances
Better student performance
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
16. Above All…
STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
Consistent learning expectations for all students
Rigorous learning experiences for all students
Authentic learning experiences for all students
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
17. Three-Stage Design Process
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Stage 1:
Identify
Desired
Results
Stage 2:
Determine
Acceptable
Evidence
Stage 3:
Create
Learning Plan
18. Agenda
Area of Focus Approximate Time
Introduction, Overview & Agenda 25 minutes
Planning Overview 16 minutes
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results 20 minutes
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence 20 minutes
Stage 3: Learning Plan 3 minutes
Closing 6 minutes
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Output: 3-2-1 Closing
19. Stage 1: Desired Results
In stage 1 of the planning process, the teacher
determines the learning goals, enduring
understandings and essential questions, and the
knowledge and skills students should have at the
end of the unit.
Established Goals
Understandings
Essential Questions
Knowledge & Skills
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
20. Established Goals
What relevant goals will this course/unit
address? Use content standards to
determine these goals.
When choosing standards consider:
state standards
school/district/state assessments
data on student performance
amount of time available
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
21. Meaning
Essential questions and
understandings help students
create purpose for the learning
experiences.
(2:38-4:50)
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
22. Understandings
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
A simple rule of thumb about understandings is that they are
prone to common misunderstandings. That’s what makes
them not so obvious and not truisms. So it is always wise to
consider the most likely student misunderstanding when
teaching for understanding…
(Wiggins & McTighe, 2012, p. 62)
o The modern novel overturns many traditional story elements and norms
to provide a more authentic and engaging narrative.
o Democracy requires a free and courageous press, willing to question and
investigate authority.
o A muscle that contracts through its full range of motion will generate
more force.
23. Essential Questions
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
The best questions evolve from being one that a teacher asks
to one that thoughtful people consider on their own. It isn’t
until the learners ‘own’ the question so as to proactively
explore the issues and challenges as they arise that we have
succeeded as designers and teachers.
(Wiggins & McTighe, 2012, p. 54)
o Who is my audience, and what follows for what I say and how I say it?
o What should I do when I’m stuck or fearful of making a mistake?
o How much power should leaders have?
o How can I turn this problem into something familiar/easier to work with?
o How much debt should I/we/the nation take on?
25. Examples
Understandings
Effective users of technology
have access to many
perspectives but must be
discerning as they gather
information.
Technology has changed
communication from more
face-to-face and time-bound
interactions to a more flexible
and fluid atmosphere.
Essential Questions
How is technology impacting
the way in which people
gather information?
Is communication helped or
hindered by 21st Century
tools?
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
ACTIVITY TIME: 5 minutes
26. Knowledge & Skills
What should students know and be able to do as a
result of this unit?
When delineating the knowledge and skills, consider:
chosen content standards
students’ prior knowledge
Bloom’s taxonomy levels
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
28. Examples
Knowledge
Key vocabulary: audience,
digital
Search engines, qualities of
reliable information
Skills
How to select key words for
a search
How to use multiple sources
to write about a topic
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
ACTIVITY TIME: 5 minutes
31. Agenda
Area of Focus Approximate Time
Introduction, Overview & Agenda 25 minutes
Planning Overview 16 minutes
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results 20 minutes
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence 20 minutes
Stage 3: Learning Plan 3 minutes
Closing 6 minutes
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Output: 3-2-1 Closing
32. Stage 2 Design: Acceptable Evidence
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
In stage 2 of the planning process,
the teacher determines what he or
she will accept as evidence that
students have met the desired
results outlined in stage 1, including
performance tasks and other
assessments.
33. Self-Assessment
Turn to Sources of Assessment Evidence.
Reflect upon your use of different types of assessment.
Rate the use of each.
Consensus:
Blue=Type of assessment you would most like to try – or try to
increase the use of
Red=Type of assessment you currently use most often
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
ACTIVITY TIME: 4 minutes
Handout #3
35. Assessment Plan Considerations
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Alignment
Performance
Tasks
Jay McTighe, author of
Understanding by Design
36. Authentic Tasks
“…we want students to be able to apply what they know
flexibly and effectively to address new and realistically
contextualized issues and problems. With this end in mind,
we recommend that teachers set up genuinely rich and
realistically messy contexts for many unit and course
assessments, for it is when students are able to apply their
learning thoughtfully and flexibly under real-world
conditions that true understanding is demonstrated. A
benefit is that such tasks tend to be more meaningful and
motivating for students.” (Wiggins & McTighe, 2012, p. 71)
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
37. Authentic Tasks
Math: Using past performance in the men’s and women’s
marathon, predict the men’s and women’s marathon times for
2020.
Wellness: As the fitness consultant for a local fitness club,
design a program for a client. The program should be 16
weeks and build the strength, flexibility, and endurance of
your client. Include a description of your client’s beginning
fitness levels, and the expected fitness levels at the
conclusion of this program.
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
38. Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Aligned and
Unauthentic
Aligned and
Authentic
Misaligned
and
Unauthentic
Misaligned
and
Authentic
ACTIVITY TIME: 5 minutes
Handout #4
39. Agenda
Area of Focus Approximate Time
Introduction, Overview & Agenda 25 minutes
Planning Overview 16 minutes
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results 20 minutes
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence 20 minutes
Stage 3: Learning Plan 3 minutes
Closing 6 minutes
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Output: 3-2-1 Closing
40. Backwards Design: Stage 3
In stage 3 of the planning process, the teacher
sequences the learning experiences and develops
specific objectives. At the unit level, the teacher
designs learning activities.
Course Guide – delineation of units
Unit Plans – sequence of objectives
Teacher Lesson Plans – learning activities
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
41. Agenda
Area of Focus Approximate Time
Introduction, Overview & Agenda 25 minutes
Planning Overview 16 minutes
Stage 1: Identify Desired Results 20 minutes
Stage 2: Determine Acceptable Evidence 20 minutes
Stage 3: Learning Plan 3 minutes
Closing 6 minutes
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Output: 3-2-1 Closing
42. 3-2-1 Closing
What are three big ideas related to this curriculum
development process?
What are two questions you have about the process?
What is one aspect of this process you think will most impact
student achievement?
Susan Carmody, Instructional Leadership Coordinator-English & Social Studies
Handout #5