The document summarizes a debate between Mina Shaughnessy and Patricia Cross in the 1960s about open admissions policies at colleges. Cross argued that many new students were unprepared due to lack of effort, not poor schools, and some were not suited for traditional education. Shaughnessy argued that poor preparation was due to race and class prejudice and teachers needed to remediate themselves to help basic writers. The document also lists other experts' views on why poor and minority students struggled, and Cross's view that open enrollment was fraudulent. Shaughnessy outlined four steps for teacher remediation including stopping defending the status quo and seeing students as capable of learning.