This report looks at the different ways globalization has been framed and offers suggestions for how to address systemic risks in our rapidly changing world through better storytelling.
As you read these words there is a group of people shaping how global humanity will think about the economy for the next few decades. No, there’s not a conspiracy theory unfolding here. What I am referring to is the United Nations process for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG)—where a course is being set for the next fifteen years of intergovernmental coordination for our economic system. This process has been quietly unfolding in the background for several years and will come to completion this fall in New York City.
I am a language researcher who cares about the future of humanity. And I share concern about the risks associated with globalization that currently threaten our collective future—climate disruption, soil depletion, widespread inequality and poverty, regional conflict, rigged financial systems, and more—the very same risks that concern many of the people involved in the SDG process. My primary responsibility at TheRules.org is to study cultural patterns of understanding and unpack their significance. This includes the use of frame analysis where I closely scrutinize the words used to think and talk about important issues.
Frame analysis is the study of mental models for human understanding. The concepts we have in our minds are structured in ways that can be systematically explored to reveal implicit assumptions, logical inferences, value judgments, and moral sentiments. An example relevant to the SDG process is the diversity of mental representations for poverty.
Poverty can be conceptualized as a disease that spreads like an epidemic, a prison to be liberated from, the condition of being incomplete or broken, a magical number measured in some predefined way, and more. We might talk about poverty eradication (treat it like a disease) or as a war (battle with and defeat it). Each meaning brings its own basic assumptions, constraining what poverty is understood to be about and how to deal with it.
Importantly, these meanings can be incorrect, inadequate, and problematic yet still be widely used. Poverty can be treated as merely a part of the natural world, for instance, which conceals the history of poverty creation throughout the last few hundred years where it came into being as a core feature of economic development.
When I looked at the language used to talk about the SDGs I was struck by how much hidden meaning can be found there. The analysis that follows is based on written text for the proposed sustainable development goals. It reveals a great deal about the faulty assumptions that remain uncritically accepted in the process. These assumptions jeopardize the entire effort by leaving out many of the structural factors that create poverty and directly contribute to ecological devastation.
No credible use of the word sustainable would perform in this way. In the following pages I make the case that the SDG process is fundamentally compromised and carries within it the seeds of its own
In this report we analyze the public discourse on poverty, inequality, charity, and aid to show how to get beyond the broken narratives that have hindered foundations and NGO's for the last three decades.
Recommendations are given for running campaigns based on our key findings...
What Are the Grand challenges for Cultural Evolution?Joe Brewer
An ad hoc steering committee initiated steps to form the Cultural Evolution Society (CES) in the summer of 2015. As part of the inaugural proceedings, a survey of CES members was conducted to identify a suite of "grand challenge" problems of broad scientific and social interest that can drive cutting-edge research and practice within the field of cultural evolutionary studies for future decades.
Over the course of several weeks, a total of 236 CES members from around the world completed an online questionnaire in which they could nominate up to ten such challenges, providing a brief description and rationale for each. Additionally, CES members were also asked to indicate their level of understanding and mode of training in core domains (cultural studies and evolutionary theory), how they see their current work fitting into the wider world of cultural evolutionary studies, and how they see themselves contributing to the grand challenges facing the society.
The responses to the initial grand challenges survey are summarized below.
As you read these words there is a group of people shaping how global humanity will think about the economy for the next few decades. No, there’s not a conspiracy theory unfolding here. What I am referring to is the United Nations process for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG)—where a course is being set for the next fifteen years of intergovernmental coordination for our economic system. This process has been quietly unfolding in the background for several years and will come to completion this fall in New York City.
I am a language researcher who cares about the future of humanity. And I share concern about the risks associated with globalization that currently threaten our collective future—climate disruption, soil depletion, widespread inequality and poverty, regional conflict, rigged financial systems, and more—the very same risks that concern many of the people involved in the SDG process. My primary responsibility at TheRules.org is to study cultural patterns of understanding and unpack their significance. This includes the use of frame analysis where I closely scrutinize the words used to think and talk about important issues.
Frame analysis is the study of mental models for human understanding. The concepts we have in our minds are structured in ways that can be systematically explored to reveal implicit assumptions, logical inferences, value judgments, and moral sentiments. An example relevant to the SDG process is the diversity of mental representations for poverty.
Poverty can be conceptualized as a disease that spreads like an epidemic, a prison to be liberated from, the condition of being incomplete or broken, a magical number measured in some predefined way, and more. We might talk about poverty eradication (treat it like a disease) or as a war (battle with and defeat it). Each meaning brings its own basic assumptions, constraining what poverty is understood to be about and how to deal with it.
Importantly, these meanings can be incorrect, inadequate, and problematic yet still be widely used. Poverty can be treated as merely a part of the natural world, for instance, which conceals the history of poverty creation throughout the last few hundred years where it came into being as a core feature of economic development.
When I looked at the language used to talk about the SDGs I was struck by how much hidden meaning can be found there. The analysis that follows is based on written text for the proposed sustainable development goals. It reveals a great deal about the faulty assumptions that remain uncritically accepted in the process. These assumptions jeopardize the entire effort by leaving out many of the structural factors that create poverty and directly contribute to ecological devastation.
No credible use of the word sustainable would perform in this way. In the following pages I make the case that the SDG process is fundamentally compromised and carries within it the seeds of its own
In this report we analyze the public discourse on poverty, inequality, charity, and aid to show how to get beyond the broken narratives that have hindered foundations and NGO's for the last three decades.
Recommendations are given for running campaigns based on our key findings...
What Are the Grand challenges for Cultural Evolution?Joe Brewer
An ad hoc steering committee initiated steps to form the Cultural Evolution Society (CES) in the summer of 2015. As part of the inaugural proceedings, a survey of CES members was conducted to identify a suite of "grand challenge" problems of broad scientific and social interest that can drive cutting-edge research and practice within the field of cultural evolutionary studies for future decades.
Over the course of several weeks, a total of 236 CES members from around the world completed an online questionnaire in which they could nominate up to ten such challenges, providing a brief description and rationale for each. Additionally, CES members were also asked to indicate their level of understanding and mode of training in core domains (cultural studies and evolutionary theory), how they see their current work fitting into the wider world of cultural evolutionary studies, and how they see themselves contributing to the grand challenges facing the society.
The responses to the initial grand challenges survey are summarized below.
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI) is an international journal intended for professionals and researchers in all fields of Humanities and Social Science. IJHSSI publishes research articles and reviews within the whole field Humanities and Social Science, new teaching methods, assessment, validation and the impact of new technologies and it will continue to provide information on the latest trends and developments in this ever-expanding subject. The publications of papers are selected through double peer reviewed to ensure originality, relevance, and readability. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online.
COVID 19 lockdown! A breeding ground for online radicalization to violent ext...Belayneh Zelelew
The COVID-19 pandemic may cause a mass crisis in Ethiopia and other African countries and heightening existing tensions, reopening old wounds, and creating new grievances. Covid-19 lack-down become a fertile ground for Extremism
HQ Asia leading in a season of populismSara Moulton
Given the rise of geopolitical instability over the last two years, populism is now making headlines. The Human Capital Leadership Institute (HCLI) reviewed available literature and came up with the three essential 'C's for business leaders.
Digital Natives with a Cause newsletter - Changing Face Of Citizen ActionNilofar Ansher
In this issue of the newsletter, we explore the mechanics of activism aided by media: web, social, digital, and traditional. What do we understand by a cause and how does it find resonance at the local and global platforms? Is the digital native a community player or a global citizen? How do digital natives connect, collaborate, mobilize and bring about their visions of change? The aim is to not establish or reinforce these dichotomies, if indeed they exist, but to understand the dimensions of the stage the digital natives operate on and if that stage is a synecdoche for global youth-led civic action. http://cis-india.org/digital-natives/citizen-activism-the-past-decade
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's ManualJoe Brewer
The inaugural election will be held online starting on Monday, July 11th and ending six weeks later on August 22nd. During this time, CES members will have the opportunity to fill out a ballot to select their preferred candidates for the 13 positions on the Executive Committee.
You can use this manual to do the following:
1. Learn about the selection process for nominating and recruiting candidates for this election.
2. Read personal statements from each of the candidates to make informed decisions about which candidate you prefer for each officer position.
The first section, titled Full Disclosure of Election Procedures, explains the steps we took to ensure a fair election while striving to meet an ambitious set of diversity criteria. It is written in the spirit of radical transparency and inclusion to get this society started with the openness and integrity that will be essential to our long-term success as a multidisciplinary scientific (and practitioner) community.
This is followed by another section, called Get to Know Your Candidates, that provides brief bios and personal statements from the 23 candidates running for office in this election. Use these materials to become familiar with the excellent lineup of people who have expressed the passion and commitment to run for one of the officer positions: president, secretary, treasurer, member-at-large, or student representative.
This manual was prepared by the CES Elections Committee to assist with inaugural elections. We hope you find it helpful as you vote for the first Executive Council of the Cultural Evolution Society.
Globalization Essay
Introduction Globalization
Essay on Cultural Globalization
An Introduction to Globalization Essay
Essay on Globalization
Essay on The History of Globalization
Essay On Globalisation
Advantages of Globalization Essay
Essay on Globalization Is Good
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI) is an international journal intended for professionals and researchers in all fields of Humanities and Social Science. IJHSSI publishes research articles and reviews within the whole field Humanities and Social Science, new teaching methods, assessment, validation and the impact of new technologies and it will continue to provide information on the latest trends and developments in this ever-expanding subject. The publications of papers are selected through double peer reviewed to ensure originality, relevance, and readability. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online.
COVID 19 lockdown! A breeding ground for online radicalization to violent ext...Belayneh Zelelew
The COVID-19 pandemic may cause a mass crisis in Ethiopia and other African countries and heightening existing tensions, reopening old wounds, and creating new grievances. Covid-19 lack-down become a fertile ground for Extremism
HQ Asia leading in a season of populismSara Moulton
Given the rise of geopolitical instability over the last two years, populism is now making headlines. The Human Capital Leadership Institute (HCLI) reviewed available literature and came up with the three essential 'C's for business leaders.
Digital Natives with a Cause newsletter - Changing Face Of Citizen ActionNilofar Ansher
In this issue of the newsletter, we explore the mechanics of activism aided by media: web, social, digital, and traditional. What do we understand by a cause and how does it find resonance at the local and global platforms? Is the digital native a community player or a global citizen? How do digital natives connect, collaborate, mobilize and bring about their visions of change? The aim is to not establish or reinforce these dichotomies, if indeed they exist, but to understand the dimensions of the stage the digital natives operate on and if that stage is a synecdoche for global youth-led civic action. http://cis-india.org/digital-natives/citizen-activism-the-past-decade
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's ManualJoe Brewer
The inaugural election will be held online starting on Monday, July 11th and ending six weeks later on August 22nd. During this time, CES members will have the opportunity to fill out a ballot to select their preferred candidates for the 13 positions on the Executive Committee.
You can use this manual to do the following:
1. Learn about the selection process for nominating and recruiting candidates for this election.
2. Read personal statements from each of the candidates to make informed decisions about which candidate you prefer for each officer position.
The first section, titled Full Disclosure of Election Procedures, explains the steps we took to ensure a fair election while striving to meet an ambitious set of diversity criteria. It is written in the spirit of radical transparency and inclusion to get this society started with the openness and integrity that will be essential to our long-term success as a multidisciplinary scientific (and practitioner) community.
This is followed by another section, called Get to Know Your Candidates, that provides brief bios and personal statements from the 23 candidates running for office in this election. Use these materials to become familiar with the excellent lineup of people who have expressed the passion and commitment to run for one of the officer positions: president, secretary, treasurer, member-at-large, or student representative.
This manual was prepared by the CES Elections Committee to assist with inaugural elections. We hope you find it helpful as you vote for the first Executive Council of the Cultural Evolution Society.
Globalization Essay
Introduction Globalization
Essay on Cultural Globalization
An Introduction to Globalization Essay
Essay on Globalization
Essay on The History of Globalization
Essay On Globalisation
Advantages of Globalization Essay
Essay on Globalization Is Good
Essay on Globalization
Globalization
Essay about Globalization and Localization
Globalization
Globalization Essay
Globalization Essay
globalisation
Globalization (Term Paper)
An Introduction to Globalization Essay
Globalization Essay
An Overview of Globalization Essay
Globalization Essay
Bounds for the P value(c) what Conclusions can you draw abo.docxhartrobert670
Bounds for the P value?
(c) what Conclusions can you draw about differences in the factor level means?
1035
Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice
Volume 4(2), 2012, pp. 1035–1040, ISSN 1948-9137
Views on the Process of Globalization
and its Effects on Human Beings
Oana GĂLĂŢEANU
[email protected]
Dunărea de Jos University, Galatzi
ABSTRACT. Today we live in so-called “era of globalization.” More we talk about
it, more concerned we become, but nevertheless, there is no universal definition
assigned to this accepted phenomenon. This is due, perhaps, to the fact that global-
ization comprises an extensive range of complex processes occurring in different
areas of contemporary society. Specifically, globalization is the term currently used
to describe those changes recorded in companies of world’s economy, changes
arising from the large increase of international trade and exchanges taking place.
However, globalization displays increasing trade and investment following the dis-
appearance barriers and the interdependence between states. As a result of this
globalization, the world in critical areas has turned into a unique social system,
precisely through the development of those ties of interdependence between states,
which each of us affects us. Referring to globalization is often used in economic
and, almost exclusively, is considering trade, free trade and labor market liberal-
ization. It is true that globalization is achieved by a real link between multi-national
states on plans not only the economic, which include communication and exchange
of information and activity in various fields research and no less true that the
mastery of information is increasingly needed in the competition taking place to rule
territories and possession and exploitation of raw materials and labor. But, we ask
how real is the information we receive and how much it helps us evolve culturally
and spiritually, if we really helps each one of us who are witnessing and without
right of choice involved in this process of globalization, the globalization of society
in which we live? The study presents the views of the author on the effects of
globalization on men and women development as being endowed with intellect,
views that give a negative answer to the question above mentioned, according to
which, as a result of globalization, humans get to live only for the production and
consumption in a state of constant manipulation by those who hold real information,
and default, the power.
Keywords: globalization, global knowledge, human resources
1036
Globalization represents the modern term used in order to describe the
changes that take place within societies and in the world economy that
results from the growing international trade and from the cultural exchanges
that take place. This term describes trade’s and i ...
This is an introduction to the cooperative ownership model for bioregional regeneration in Barichara, Colombia. It explains how we are structuring a relationship between external donors and local stakeholders to engage in territorial-scale reforestation and water security.
Design Institute for Regenerating the EarthJoe Brewer
This is our mission — regenerate ALL degraded lands on Earth to restore planetary health. Coordinated through bioregional learning centers that organize efforts locally while collaborating with each other across regions.
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's FutureJoe Brewer
This document is a synthesis of inquiry that incorporates ideas and inspiration from many people. It grew out of conversations with Federico Bellone, Eduard Müller, Juan Sostheim, Melina Angel, Pramod Parajuli, Luis Camargo, Daniel Wahl, Stuart Cowan, and several others. What I learned from this diverse dialogue—accompanied by extensive reading—is that pedagogy is the most important thing to get right for any educational initiative that seeks to cultivate bioregional regeneration.
Pedagogy refers to the many ways of learning and how people evolve in their thoughts, feelings, actions, and social arrangements. It is a multifaceted concept that draws attention to capacities for cooperation, ability to trust others, perspective-taking, and a lot more that must be carefully addressed (and elegantly integrated) in the design of education programs. Pedagogy is often framed as a way to teach a particular concept or subject. I prefer to turn this around and employ it as a design perspective for how to assist the learning process, even if no teacher happens to be involved.
Shared here are some of the key pedagogical insights and thematic elements that have arisen so far in this inquiry. This learning journey is far from complete and will continue well after these words are written to the page. It is my earnest belief that Bioregional Regenerative Training Centers must emerge all over the world as integrative programs that help spread the practices and mindsets for regeneration of human communities and the ecosystems on which they depend for their survival.
This is a summary document for a training program we are creating at Rancho Margot in northern Costa Rica -- as part of a global effort to birth "bioregional learning centers" for the spread of regenerative practices.
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
This document is a grant application submitted to the John Templeton Foundation proposing the creation of masters and doctoral programs in applied cultural evolution. We have not heard back about whether we will receive funding from them but felt it is worthwhile to share more of our vision with others who might like to collaborate in making this vision a reality.
This is a project outline for the creation of a School for Applied Cultural Evolution that works with the growing network of territorial hubs for bioregional regeneration being launched right now in Costa Rica. It’s purpose is to cultivate and continually improve learning ecosystems spanning across communities that organize their efforts around geographically defined locations where people strive to increase the functional capacities for their landscapes while simultaneously increasing the wellbeing of people living in harmony with them.
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
This slide deck presents an early draft of ideas for creating a school that is dedicated to helping communities learn how to guide their collective evolution toward health and resilience.
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
Let me begin by acknowledging those who came before me. The runner-up for a 1 billion euro grant from the European Union nearly a decade ago was FuturICT with their vision for modeling complex social systems to avoid (or manage) future economic collapses. So I am not the first person to propose that a massive effort is needed to (a) integrate the social sciences; and (b) do so with motivation to apply what is learned to address extremely difficult problems in the world. With that said, let me now offer my billion dollar proposal that follows in FuturICT’s footsteps. At the time they were competing for substantial funding, I was working with the International Centre for Earth Simulation to build its billion dollar (over a decade) vision for a high-performance computing facility that models the entire Earth in its full complexity. It is from these projects that I draw inspiration for this essay.
Also, a fact that should cause you to sit up straight. The annual budget for CERN (the high-energy particle accelerator in Geneva, Switzerland) was roughly 1.2 billion dollars in 2017. So what I am calling for here is what the European Union spends every single year on the search for fundamental particles for all of humanity to instead address the global ecological crisis and safeguard the future of our species.
Think about this for a moment before you continue reading this essay. It really should cause you to pause and reflect about our current priorities as human beings.
What I propose now is a framework for guiding humanity through the sustainability bottleneck as we navigate the planetary-scale systemic collapse outlined in the previous two essays in this series. If you want to hear me talk through this proposal in a recorded talk, I invite you to watch the 90 minute video on YouTube for a version that I presented to the cognitive science department at the University of California, Merced earlier this year. This essay will go into more detail about the vision I’ve been cultivating for a global network of culture design labs that—as argued in previous essays—I no longer believe is possible to build in the world.
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social ChangeJoe Brewer
Let me start by saying that literally every social problem humanity now confronts will benefit from taking a rigorous, evidence-based approach to developing interventions that work. If I believe this—you might wonder—why would I title an article this way?
The answer is simply that I have been trying to manifest into the world a science of large-scale social change for 18 years. During that time I have repeatedly found that almost no one gives preference to being effective over the feeling of “being right.” This has been true as I’ve interacted with academic researchers, the staff of numerous nonprofit organizations, program officers and boards of directors at foundations, government personnel providing public services, and among social-impact businesses of various kinds.
So I am shifting gears and no longer attempting to build this grand visionary work. I simply don’t see it as feasible anymore and am going to introspect deeply about what I might do that is of service in times as serious as these when in my heart I now accept that my life’s work cannot succeed. In the spirit of the foundational challenge named in the opening of this essay, I invite you to prove me wrong. Critique and analyze my assumptions. Gather your own data to confront and challenge the argument laid out here. See if you can find a way to birth such an ambitious vision where I have failed to do so.
I would much rather be wrong and see effective solutions emerge than to be right and feel the hollow gratification of saying “I told you so” as the world goes into full-scale systemic collapse in the next few decades.
Onward, fellow humans.
This is an overview report on a 2013 study we conducted of social media content about global warming. It shows that underlying psychological drivers can be discerned from large data sets to reveal implicit structures of a major social discourse.
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic PlanJoe Brewer
The key to birthing this is human scale. This document outlines a plan and business model for creating the Culture Design Research Center using a simple format and vetted model. The model is “old school” meaning a teacher creates a school of thought by attracting excellent students. It is the students who bring prominence and prestige to the school through their accomplishments.
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social MediaJoe Brewer
Our team at /TheRules set out to birth a meme—the concept of “wetiko” from the Algonquin tradition—in a unique campaign earlier this year. We did this by recruiting artists and writers from around the world to create expressions that capture it. As this report shows, we found the meme has qualities that create resistance to spreading. In the process of watching how various people reacted to it, we learned a great deal about the larger cultural patterns that our work seeks to influence.
Our hope was to cultivate a diversity of expressions for this concept, which roughly translates as cultural cannibalism because it describes how pathologies of culture do psychological and environmental harm. In this regard we can call the campaign a success—an online gallery of photographs, songs, 3D interactive constructs, masks, and more can be found on the campaign website.
Yet when we monitored social media activity and other indicators of popularity, it was equally clear that this is an idea with properties that make it feel alien, mushy, too spiritual or exotic to resonate with many audiences. We ran parallel tracks for content that explicitly named Wetiko and content that expressed its conceptual features (like the core logic of cannibalism) without using the term.
What we learned was that the word itself hinders its spreading. At the same time, the deep cultural critique it offers is highly resonant with people around the world who feel anxiety about the ecological crisis, or have been marginalized and excluded by the dominant economic paradigm.
Read on to learn with us. Together we can apply this knowledge in future social change efforts that connect the dots across social movements and issues around the world.
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election ResultsJoe Brewer
We are excited to announce the results are in for our inaugural election—with clear winners for each of the 13 positions on the Executive Committee. This report provides an overview of the outcomes with commentary on the global nature of participation for our membership.
The election was held online for a six week period starting on Monday, July 11th and ending August 22nd. We choose this extended period for voting as many of our members engage in summer field research projects and we wanted to be inclusive for those who might be delayed in responding to email notifications inviting them to vote.
After receiving 379 completed ballots, the results are in.
Exploring the Tools for Meme PropagationJoe Brewer
In this research report, I explore how we currently monitor cultural trends in our campaign efforts. I also want to begin mapping out the tools and capabilities that will be needed to fully operate as a “meme spreading” organization in the days ahead. We recently launched the One Party Planet pamphlet and have gathered a suite of social analytics that reveal much—both as indicators of spreading and as a demonstration of how much deeper and more nuanced our understandings will need to become as we adopt more sophisticated tools for cultural research moving forward.
The approach I take is to compare the spreading of One Party Planet with several memes that went viral as the United States experienced major racial conflict in the last two weeks. By doing so, we can begin to articulate what kinds of monitoring and analytic tools will be needed to fully implement our mission of taking radical ideas into the mainstream.
Winning frames of the scottish independence movementJoe Brewer
Here's an analysis I did of the narratives and internet memes that seem to be driving Scotland toward independence. How might we all learn from this about the science of social change?
Explore our comprehensive data analysis project presentation on predicting product ad campaign performance. Learn how data-driven insights can optimize your marketing strategies and enhance campaign effectiveness. Perfect for professionals and students looking to understand the power of data analysis in advertising. for more details visit: https://bostoninstituteofanalytics.org/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/
Levelwise PageRank with Loop-Based Dead End Handling Strategy : SHORT REPORT ...Subhajit Sahu
Abstract — Levelwise PageRank is an alternative method of PageRank computation which decomposes the input graph into a directed acyclic block-graph of strongly connected components, and processes them in topological order, one level at a time. This enables calculation for ranks in a distributed fashion without per-iteration communication, unlike the standard method where all vertices are processed in each iteration. It however comes with a precondition of the absence of dead ends in the input graph. Here, the native non-distributed performance of Levelwise PageRank was compared against Monolithic PageRank on a CPU as well as a GPU. To ensure a fair comparison, Monolithic PageRank was also performed on a graph where vertices were split by components. Results indicate that Levelwise PageRank is about as fast as Monolithic PageRank on the CPU, but quite a bit slower on the GPU. Slowdown on the GPU is likely caused by a large submission of small workloads, and expected to be non-issue when the computation is performed on massive graphs.
Show drafts
volume_up
Empowering the Data Analytics Ecosystem: A Laser Focus on Value
The data analytics ecosystem thrives when every component functions at its peak, unlocking the true potential of data. Here's a laser focus on key areas for an empowered ecosystem:
1. Democratize Access, Not Data:
Granular Access Controls: Provide users with self-service tools tailored to their specific needs, preventing data overload and misuse.
Data Catalogs: Implement robust data catalogs for easy discovery and understanding of available data sources.
2. Foster Collaboration with Clear Roles:
Data Mesh Architecture: Break down data silos by creating a distributed data ownership model with clear ownership and responsibilities.
Collaborative Workspaces: Utilize interactive platforms where data scientists, analysts, and domain experts can work seamlessly together.
3. Leverage Advanced Analytics Strategically:
AI-powered Automation: Automate repetitive tasks like data cleaning and feature engineering, freeing up data talent for higher-level analysis.
Right-Tool Selection: Strategically choose the most effective advanced analytics techniques (e.g., AI, ML) based on specific business problems.
4. Prioritize Data Quality with Automation:
Automated Data Validation: Implement automated data quality checks to identify and rectify errors at the source, minimizing downstream issues.
Data Lineage Tracking: Track the flow of data throughout the ecosystem, ensuring transparency and facilitating root cause analysis for errors.
5. Cultivate a Data-Driven Mindset:
Metrics-Driven Performance Management: Align KPIs and performance metrics with data-driven insights to ensure actionable decision making.
Data Storytelling Workshops: Equip stakeholders with the skills to translate complex data findings into compelling narratives that drive action.
Benefits of a Precise Ecosystem:
Sharpened Focus: Precise access and clear roles ensure everyone works with the most relevant data, maximizing efficiency.
Actionable Insights: Strategic analytics and automated quality checks lead to more reliable and actionable data insights.
Continuous Improvement: Data-driven performance management fosters a culture of learning and continuous improvement.
Sustainable Growth: Empowered by data, organizations can make informed decisions to drive sustainable growth and innovation.
By focusing on these precise actions, organizations can create an empowered data analytics ecosystem that delivers real value by driving data-driven decisions and maximizing the return on their data investment.
1. Why the Framing of
Globalization Matters
Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
Prepared by:
Joe Brewer
Culture Designer
Change Strategist for Humanity T 206.914.8927 joe@culture2inc.com http://www.changestrategistforhumanity.com
2. Purpose of This Report
Last week we looked at the history of the social movements against elites who use globalization
processes to rig political and economic systems in their favor—a sequence of protest events that
draw more people together from around the world with each new wave.1 Common themes include
everyday people versus elites and policy mechanisms used to extract and horde wealth. I noted
that TheRules.org itself is an outgrowth of this evolving cultural process.
Ironically, the rise of these social movements has been made possible by many of the same
globalization processes. The opening of national borders to trade, meteoric adoption curves for
communication technologies, and a new IT backbone (the internet) are all consequences of
globalization.
How can this be? Are social justice activists REALLY opposed to globalization? It was the
corporate-owned media that framed the movement as “anti-globalization”, after all. This label
didn’t come into wide use until after mainstream news reports about the 1999 World Trade
Organization protest in Seattle. Why were socially progressive activists framed as being against
globalization?
More disconcertingly, why did many activist groups adopt this label when it was painted onto them
by the very same corporate actors they oppose? The movements that are converging in this
space have an identity problem. We never took the time to look at the frames of the debate. And
now, we are at odds with ourselves—conceptually in the ways we describe what we are for and
against—making it difficult for us to tell a compelling story that brings all of us together around a
shared agenda.
This points toward the purpose of this report. A comprehensive evaluation of the entire discourse
is beyond our scope. Rather I want to establish a few lines in the sand—map out the largest
structures inherent in the semantic frames that help and hinder us.
Who Is Actually Against Globalization?
I have recently been exploring the systemic risks that arise from globalization. The complexities
that emerge in our vastly interconnected world make it difficult to comprehend the causes for
global events or assign blame when harm occurs. Specifically, I have been reading an excellent
book called The Butterfly Defect: How Globalization Creates Systemic Risk and What to Do About
It by Ian Goldin and Mike Mariathasan.
1 http://www.slideshare.net/joebrewer31/where-did-this-global-movement-come-from
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
3. An argument is presented that globalization is only resisted by right-wing groups with xenophobic
or protectionist sentiments. These are the people who—often motivated by insecurities about local
jobs or racist sentiments—fight against open immigration policies that make it easy for workers to
move across national boundaries.
These people try to shape trade agreements (and domestic
policies) that serve national interests—a frame that conceals
their true intentions—as a pushback against globalization of
the workforce.
This begs the question, What is globalization? For a long
time, it has been equated with neoliberal economic theories
and expansion of corporate power. A correlation does exist.
But are they the same thing?
Said another way, if an activist is against a financial elite that
games the economy to benefit the super rich, does this also
mean they are against open borders and global
communication? I would like to suggest that this confusion
comes about because the frames at play in the discourse
have not been clearly (or intentionally) articulated to make the
differences obvious.
What Is Globalization?
It is important that we answer this question in the generic first. Ideology and worldview can easily
distort our definitions. I decided to look at Google Image Search and see what came up.
This text box was among the first things I
found. Note how the definitions describe
globalization as the removal of geographic
constraints, increase of worldwide
interconnection, and growing
interdependence.
It is historically true that business activities—
and increasingly, multinational corporations
—have driven this globalization process.
What I find interesting is that other cultural
expression arose at the same time,
including:
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
4. ✦ Ethnic mixing and the breakdown of tribal boundaries, promoting the universalist values of
human rights, equality, and shared dignity regardless of race or cultural identity.
✦ A “cosmopolitan” mindset in major cities that is increasingly global in perspective and
inclusive of previously divided social geographies associated with different places.
✦ The idea of the human race, that we are all part of the same global family and are in this
together.
In other words, the cultural dimensions of globalization are where the semantic frames of
universalism arose. It would not be possible to articulate a notion of global social movements
without globalization! Paradoxical, I know.
Some of the Frames for Globalization
The definitions given above are value neutral, by which I mean that they could be good or bad,
depending on how we look at them. Social movements are never value neutral. They always
come from a place of critique or moral transgression.
This can be seen in the images below.
Figure 1 - Cabal of Global Elites
Figure 1 presents one understanding of globalization that members of /The Rules are likely to
sympathize with. A cabal of global elites, all white men in suites, sit around a table and make
decisions that serve themselves.
This is the quintessential back room deal. It is easy for people to operate using clandestine
methods in the absence of transparency and accountability that arise in complex, decentralized,
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
5. multifaceted global systems. The movements around corporate transparency, legitimate
governance, and open access all arise from a perspective like this.
Figure 2 - The Elites Are Sociopaths
Another common story (that I have helped promulgate, for good or ill) is that many of these elite
decision makers are sociopaths. They run the world faster and faster—as depicted in Figure 2—
with no concern for all of the people who get left behind.
This story draws attention to the fact that many leaders are insensitive to the harms they cause.
Their morality is thought to be damaged in some way. Perhaps they are emotionally broken, or just
plain evil. The kernel of truth in this narrative is that globalization HAS INCREASED INEQUALITY
both within countries and globally. The unanswered question (that we address in our frame
analysis on poverty2) is how this happens. The causes are obscured until the right story makes
them clear.
2 http://www.slideshare.net/joebrewer31/the-rules-report-final
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
6. Figure 3 - Unfair Trade to Steal and Plunder
Another depiction of globalization can be seen in Figure 3. Trade agreements have not been set
up to “open markets” on a level playing field. They give strategic advantages to whomever writes
the agreement.
This is how theft and plunder enter the scene. Globalization is a process of increasing
interconnectivity on the world stage. If that interconnectivity is used to extract wealth by powerful
actors, then globalization is a process for creating poverty and increasing inequality. This points to
the rules-of-play and how the game has been rigged.
Figure 4 - Our Connected Humanity
What is missing from these depictions is what Figure 4 is all about—the fact that our world has
become more safe and prosperous (by some important measures, though less so by other
measures) because humanity is now connected across the globe.
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
7. This view of globalization draws attention to the creative potential of 7 billion educated humans. It
is a reminder that everything is connected. What happens in one part of the world will impact
other places—the quintessential lesson of global pollution and climate change.
Our collective knowledge has grown because different cultures interact and share what they learn.
Each of us in these social movements has benefited from this cross-pollination of people and
places. We are definitely not anti-globalization in this specific sense. Indeed, it is our recognition
that all people are worthy of respect that compels us to strive for social justice at home and
abroad.
At the same time, we now must confront new challenges. There have been three global
pandemics since this century began. The current Ebola outbreak is quickly becoming number four.
Studies have shown that previously isolated disease outbreaks can evolve into global pandemics in
three days if an infected person visits a major airport hub.
Similar risks arise in other parts of our globally interconnected system as well—cascading shocks
from natural disasters, disruptions to fragile global supply chains, anonymity in global finance that
lets criminal activity hide within the obscurities of complex networks, and much more.
Addressing these systemic risks of globalization will require cooperation and legitimate governance
at the transnational and global scales. So we need to get clear about which parts of globalization
we are against.
What Can We Learn From This Brief Analysis?
It is very important that we parse the good from the bad when it comes to globalization. Most
activists who stand against corporate power and the rigging of economic and political systems are
our common humanity that comes with our global perspective that is uniquely modern.
Preserving this feature of our conceptual landscape while we scrutinize the illegitimate forms of
governance and systemic effects of globalization will be key to navigating the “wicked problems” in
our midst.
With this in mind, I would like to suggest a few discussion questions:
✦ Why is it important to look at these different frames? What happens when we start
to see the different perspective? How do we gain clarity about effective strategies that lead
to meaningful and substantive change?
✦ What are the features of globalization we support? How do we work with partners
around the world to achieve planetary-scale objectives? What can we do to make these
features more clear where alliances can be forged to achieve our goals?
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014
8. ✦ Specifically, what are we against? Just as importantly, what are we for? How do
we separate wheat from chaff and get really clear about what needs to change?
I hope this brief report helps us begin to clarify what our movements are really about. For myself, I
have come to the conclusion that I support globalization as a process of recognizing our common
humanity and serving each other at the planetary scale. I am opposed to opaque and
unaccountable behaviors that game the global system for personal gain, while placing others at
risk.
Of course, I am curious what comes to mind for you.
Onward,
Joe Brewer
Culture Designer
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters Weekly Research Report for October 15, 2014