SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Perception of
   Saudi Students towards
Using Microblogging (Twitter)


                By
         Mohammed Al Abdulatef

               EDCT 6052
           Dr. Teresa Franklin

              Spring 2012
Introduction
What is the difference between Microblogging and
 Blog
   blogging is “associated with longer, more reflective pieces often
    developed away from the spatial/temporal location where the initial
    thoughts occurred” (Ramsden,2009)

   Microblogging is “restricted to short pieces which are captured and
    immediately posted” (Ramsden,2009)

 Example of Microblogging;
      Twitter
      Pownce
      Tumblr
      MySay
      Frazr
How might micro-blogging be
  used in an educational context?
 Microblogging has been adopted in different
educational settings for a variety of educational
            purposes, for example;
 1.   Just-in-time interaction ( Luo&Franklin,2012; Luo&Gao,2012;
      Ramsden, 2009)
 2.   Communication (Castro, 2009; Hadian, Froese & Sanseverino, 2011)
 3.   Distance Education Tool (Luo&Gao,2012; Perifanou ,2009;
      Ramsden, 2009).
 4.   Informal learning activities (Borau, Ullrich, Feng & Shen, 2009;
      Luo&Gao,2012; Luo&Franklin,2012)
 5.   Collaboration (Borau, Ullrich, Feng & Shen, 2009; Luo&Gao,2012;
      Luo&Franklin,2012)
Purpose of Study

The main purpose of this study is to investigate The
perception of Saudi students towards using
Microblogging (Twitter) for learning. The variable that
will be considered in this study include the gender.
Until now, few research has been conducted to
understand and measure Saudi students' perceptions
towards using Microblogging (Twitter) for learning.
Research questions
   This study attempts to answer the following
                   questions:
1.   What are the perception of Saudi students toward
Microblogging (Twitter)?

2.   From students’ perspective, How do Saudi students use
Microblogging (Twitter) in their classrooms?

3.   What are the advantages and disadvantage of integrating
Microblogging (Twitter) for learning?

4.    Are there significant mean differences in Saudi students
(male, female) and their perceptions toward using Microblogging
(Twitter) for teaching and learning?
Study Method
 Participants
   The participants of the study were group of Saudi
   students from different universities in Saudi Arabia
   during the academic year 2012-2013 . For the
   sample, 223 participants were selected randomly. 29
   participants were female (13%) and 194 (86%) were
   male. Most of the participants were undergraduate
   students.
 Instrument
   The study survey instrument was a questionnaire
   consisted of 33 items with 5 scales (Strongly disagree,
   Disagree, Neutral, Agree, and Strongly Agree). See
   the instrument (Arabic version)
 Analysis
   The researcher used the One-Way Analysis of
   Variance (ANOVA) to test the hypothesis.
Finding and Result
                                                     Descriptives
P_question
                 N        Mean      Std. Deviation   Std. Error      95% Confidence Interval for   Minimum   Maximum
                                                                               Mean
                                                                    Lower Bound    Upper Bound
male            194       3.1885       .37569         .02697           3.1353          3.2417        1.81      4.06
female           29       3.3650       .26211         .04867           3.2653          3.4647        2.77      3.81
Total            223      3.2115       .36730         .02460           3.1630          3.2599        1.81      4.06




                                                         ANOVA
             P_question
                                   Sum of Squares         df          Mean Square          F          Sig.
              Between Groups            .785              1              .785            5.952       .015
               Within Groups          29.164             221             .132
                   Total              29.950             222
Finding and Result
Conclusion
1. The results of this study indicate that Saudi students have relatively positive
   perception towards using Microblogging (Twitter) for learning.
2. The findings also indicate that the majority of Saudi students use
   Microblogging (Twitter) in the classroom for communication, sharing
   information, deliver assignment content, and Informal learning activities.
3. The majority of Saudi students believe that Microblogging (Twitter) is
   efficient, convenient, and includes information with high quality.
4. There was a statistically significant difference between the perception of
   Saudi students and their gender.
Future Implication and
             Recommendation
1. More rigorous methods to measure participation and
  engagement are needed in future research.
2. Research need more investigation about Microblogging
  (Twitter).
3. Before implementing the Twitter in classroom
  , universities should develop educational policy about
  using it in education.
4. Universities should train their students to use
  Microblogging.
Reference
Borau, K., Ullrich, C., Feng, J., & Shen, R. (2009). Microblogging for Language Learning :
    Using Twitter to Train Communicative and Cultural Competence. (M. Spaniol, Q. Li, R.
    Klamma, & R. Lau, Eds.)Applied Linguistics, 5686(500), 78-87. Springer. Retrieved
    from http://www.springerlink.com/index/X71216H278646187.pdf

Hadian, S., Froese, M.E. & Sanseverino, M. (2011). The Use of Micro-Blogging in the
     Teaching and Learning Process. In T. Bastiaens & M. Ebner (Eds.), Proceedings of
     World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia and Telecommunications
     2011 (pp. 2451-2456). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Retrieved from
     http://www.editlib.org/p/38203.
Luo, T. & Franklin, T. (2012). “You got to be follow-worthy or I will unfollow you!”
     Students’ Voices on Twitter integration into classroom settings. In P. Resta
     (Ed.), Proceedings of Society for Information Technology & Teacher Education
     International Conference 2012 (pp. 3685-3688). Chesapeake, VA: AACE.

Ramsden, A. (2009). Using micro-blogging (Twitter) in your teaching and learning: An
   introductory guide. Read. University of Bath. Retrieved from
   http://opus.bath.ac.uk/15319/

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

FINAL CV (Shei)
FINAL CV (Shei)FINAL CV (Shei)
FINAL CV (Shei)
Shei Queyquep
 
Experiencias en sillicon valley
Experiencias en sillicon valleyExperiencias en sillicon valley
Experiencias en sillicon valley
Comisión Pymes Cluster Córdoba Technology
 
people who i admire....
people who i admire....people who i admire....
people who i admire....
Kelita Chagua
 
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONOMATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
Pipit Wijaya
 
SATB-Magz (Prototype)
SATB-Magz (Prototype)SATB-Magz (Prototype)
SATB-Magz (Prototype)
Randi Pratama M
 
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...Pipit Wijaya
 
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATI
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATIMATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATI
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATIPipit Wijaya
 
Landasan pendidikan
Landasan pendidikanLandasan pendidikan
Landasan pendidikanPipit Wijaya
 
Our school 195, Catalina, Bianca
Our  school 195, Catalina, BiancaOur  school 195, Catalina, Bianca
Our school 195, Catalina, Bianca
mepetrescu
 
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
Pipit Wijaya
 
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
Pipit Wijaya
 

Viewers also liked (11)

FINAL CV (Shei)
FINAL CV (Shei)FINAL CV (Shei)
FINAL CV (Shei)
 
Experiencias en sillicon valley
Experiencias en sillicon valleyExperiencias en sillicon valley
Experiencias en sillicon valley
 
people who i admire....
people who i admire....people who i admire....
people who i admire....
 
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONOMATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
MATERI LANDASAN PENDIDIKAN PROF MARYONO
 
SATB-Magz (Prototype)
SATB-Magz (Prototype)SATB-Magz (Prototype)
SATB-Magz (Prototype)
 
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...
Perbandingan Pembelajaran Matematika Melalui Ceramah Dengan Pembelajaran Mela...
 
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATI
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATIMATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATI
MATERI landasan filosofis pendidikan Dr. DIMYATI
 
Landasan pendidikan
Landasan pendidikanLandasan pendidikan
Landasan pendidikan
 
Our school 195, Catalina, Bianca
Our  school 195, Catalina, BiancaOur  school 195, Catalina, Bianca
Our school 195, Catalina, Bianca
 
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
Peningkatan Kualitas Guru Untuk Mencetak Peserta Didik Berkualitas Demi Penca...
 
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
foundations of education student text tenth edition 2007
 

Similar to Twiteer p

CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
Vanessa Dennen
 
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
Fabrizio Fornara
 
Research proposal
Research proposalResearch proposal
Research proposal
Mozoh Al Kaabi
 
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance LearningTeachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
AJHSSR Journal
 
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
Syed Jamal Abd Nasir Syed Mohamad
 
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshareSocial learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
Mike Sharples
 
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
The Higher Education Academy
 
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
Neil Morris
 
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSNHigh-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
naomi tutticci
 
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
johnroseadams1
 
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
rhetttrevannion
 
Aect fall16 vegas9
Aect fall16 vegas9Aect fall16 vegas9
Aect fall16 vegas9
Kelly Elander, PhD
 
Marrakech 2018
Marrakech 2018Marrakech 2018
Marrakech 2018
isidromj
 
Critical issues in contemporary open education research
 Critical issues in contemporary open education research Critical issues in contemporary open education research
Critical issues in contemporary open education research
Robert Farrow
 
Response to Intervention
Response to Intervention Response to Intervention
Response to Intervention
Scot Headley
 
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research BazzarDean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
Jorge Zamora
 
longhorn research bazaar poster
longhorn research bazaar posterlonghorn research bazaar poster
longhorn research bazaar poster
Jorge Zamora
 
Making the most of moodle
Making the most of moodleMaking the most of moodle
Making the most of moodle
rachelsaffer
 
Core skills 2 teaching small groups
Core skills 2 teaching small groupsCore skills 2 teaching small groups
Core skills 2 teaching small groups
JordanNapier1
 
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe..."Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
eraser Juan José Calderón
 

Similar to Twiteer p (20)

CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
CSCL 2013: Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Preservice Teachers Notice?
 
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
Modeling #Twitter Use: Do Students Notice?
 
Research proposal
Research proposalResearch proposal
Research proposal
 
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance LearningTeachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
Teachers’ Experiences in the Implementation of Modular Distance Learning
 
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
AN ANALYSIS OF LEARNING STYLES OF DISTANCE LEARNERS AT THE INSTITUTE OF EDUCA...
 
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshareSocial learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
Social learning at massive scale LWMOOCs 2015 slideshare
 
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
Undergraduate accounting students’ perceptions of using Twitter as a practica...
 
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
Keynote at 4th International Conference for e-Learning and Distance Learning,...
 
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSNHigh-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
High-fidelity simulation_Descriptive analysis of student learning styles_CSN
 
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
Stephanie McKendry 'The conflicting priorities of blended and inclusive learn...
 
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
3.3 - Discussion Gulf Oil Spill PHAFor this module discussi.docx
 
Aect fall16 vegas9
Aect fall16 vegas9Aect fall16 vegas9
Aect fall16 vegas9
 
Marrakech 2018
Marrakech 2018Marrakech 2018
Marrakech 2018
 
Critical issues in contemporary open education research
 Critical issues in contemporary open education research Critical issues in contemporary open education research
Critical issues in contemporary open education research
 
Response to Intervention
Response to Intervention Response to Intervention
Response to Intervention
 
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research BazzarDean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
Dean's Research Insititute Project for Research Bazzar
 
longhorn research bazaar poster
longhorn research bazaar posterlonghorn research bazaar poster
longhorn research bazaar poster
 
Making the most of moodle
Making the most of moodleMaking the most of moodle
Making the most of moodle
 
Core skills 2 teaching small groups
Core skills 2 teaching small groupsCore skills 2 teaching small groups
Core skills 2 teaching small groups
 
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe..."Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
"Exploring Student Perceptions of Flipgrid in Online Courses. Patrick R. Lowe...
 

Twiteer p

  • 1. The Perception of Saudi Students towards Using Microblogging (Twitter) By Mohammed Al Abdulatef EDCT 6052 Dr. Teresa Franklin Spring 2012
  • 2. Introduction What is the difference between Microblogging and Blog  blogging is “associated with longer, more reflective pieces often developed away from the spatial/temporal location where the initial thoughts occurred” (Ramsden,2009)  Microblogging is “restricted to short pieces which are captured and immediately posted” (Ramsden,2009)  Example of Microblogging;  Twitter  Pownce  Tumblr  MySay  Frazr
  • 3. How might micro-blogging be used in an educational context? Microblogging has been adopted in different educational settings for a variety of educational purposes, for example; 1. Just-in-time interaction ( Luo&Franklin,2012; Luo&Gao,2012; Ramsden, 2009) 2. Communication (Castro, 2009; Hadian, Froese & Sanseverino, 2011) 3. Distance Education Tool (Luo&Gao,2012; Perifanou ,2009; Ramsden, 2009). 4. Informal learning activities (Borau, Ullrich, Feng & Shen, 2009; Luo&Gao,2012; Luo&Franklin,2012) 5. Collaboration (Borau, Ullrich, Feng & Shen, 2009; Luo&Gao,2012; Luo&Franklin,2012)
  • 4. Purpose of Study The main purpose of this study is to investigate The perception of Saudi students towards using Microblogging (Twitter) for learning. The variable that will be considered in this study include the gender. Until now, few research has been conducted to understand and measure Saudi students' perceptions towards using Microblogging (Twitter) for learning.
  • 5. Research questions This study attempts to answer the following questions: 1. What are the perception of Saudi students toward Microblogging (Twitter)? 2. From students’ perspective, How do Saudi students use Microblogging (Twitter) in their classrooms? 3. What are the advantages and disadvantage of integrating Microblogging (Twitter) for learning? 4. Are there significant mean differences in Saudi students (male, female) and their perceptions toward using Microblogging (Twitter) for teaching and learning?
  • 6. Study Method  Participants The participants of the study were group of Saudi students from different universities in Saudi Arabia during the academic year 2012-2013 . For the sample, 223 participants were selected randomly. 29 participants were female (13%) and 194 (86%) were male. Most of the participants were undergraduate students.  Instrument The study survey instrument was a questionnaire consisted of 33 items with 5 scales (Strongly disagree, Disagree, Neutral, Agree, and Strongly Agree). See the instrument (Arabic version)  Analysis The researcher used the One-Way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) to test the hypothesis.
  • 7. Finding and Result Descriptives P_question N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error 95% Confidence Interval for Minimum Maximum Mean Lower Bound Upper Bound male 194 3.1885 .37569 .02697 3.1353 3.2417 1.81 4.06 female 29 3.3650 .26211 .04867 3.2653 3.4647 2.77 3.81 Total 223 3.2115 .36730 .02460 3.1630 3.2599 1.81 4.06 ANOVA P_question Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig. Between Groups .785 1 .785 5.952 .015 Within Groups 29.164 221 .132 Total 29.950 222
  • 9. Conclusion 1. The results of this study indicate that Saudi students have relatively positive perception towards using Microblogging (Twitter) for learning. 2. The findings also indicate that the majority of Saudi students use Microblogging (Twitter) in the classroom for communication, sharing information, deliver assignment content, and Informal learning activities. 3. The majority of Saudi students believe that Microblogging (Twitter) is efficient, convenient, and includes information with high quality. 4. There was a statistically significant difference between the perception of Saudi students and their gender.
  • 10. Future Implication and Recommendation 1. More rigorous methods to measure participation and engagement are needed in future research. 2. Research need more investigation about Microblogging (Twitter). 3. Before implementing the Twitter in classroom , universities should develop educational policy about using it in education. 4. Universities should train their students to use Microblogging.
  • 11. Reference Borau, K., Ullrich, C., Feng, J., & Shen, R. (2009). Microblogging for Language Learning : Using Twitter to Train Communicative and Cultural Competence. (M. Spaniol, Q. Li, R. Klamma, & R. Lau, Eds.)Applied Linguistics, 5686(500), 78-87. Springer. Retrieved from http://www.springerlink.com/index/X71216H278646187.pdf Hadian, S., Froese, M.E. & Sanseverino, M. (2011). The Use of Micro-Blogging in the Teaching and Learning Process. In T. Bastiaens & M. Ebner (Eds.), Proceedings of World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia and Telecommunications 2011 (pp. 2451-2456). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Retrieved from http://www.editlib.org/p/38203. Luo, T. & Franklin, T. (2012). “You got to be follow-worthy or I will unfollow you!” Students’ Voices on Twitter integration into classroom settings. In P. Resta (Ed.), Proceedings of Society for Information Technology & Teacher Education International Conference 2012 (pp. 3685-3688). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Ramsden, A. (2009). Using micro-blogging (Twitter) in your teaching and learning: An introductory guide. Read. University of Bath. Retrieved from http://opus.bath.ac.uk/15319/