Femoral vs Radial: A Critical Appraisal of the Evidence

1. !"#$%&'()*+(,&-.&'/((
0(1%.2.3&'(044%&.*&'($5(26"(7).-"83"!
"#$$%&#'!('#))#*+!,-+!,.!
!
/0'%*!12+!3415!

2. 9.*3'$*:%"*(
67$89*:;$:<!
(#'9)7!,#=%>;*!
?78:7$!.>%#$:%&%>!
.:@!"9=#!

3. 0(;.22'"(<.*2$%=(
1ABCD.:%E!F;=$#'!=7#8!;7':7E';)!G%;!;!>9:D=7H$!7&!:I#!
';=%;*!;':#'J!
1A2CD,;87$!.7$#8!
;$E%7E';)+!0#'&#>:8!K';>I%;*!>9:D=7H$!
1AL3DM7H;'=!F%>N#::8!;$=!M#'K#':!/K';)8!O.:;$&7'=P!
=#8>'%K#!0#'>9:;$#798!:';$8&#)7';*!;00'7;>I!%$!I9);$8!
1ALQD,#*G%$!"9=N%$8!=#8>'%K#8!0#'>9:;$#798!:';$8&#)7';*!
;00'7;>I!O.#*=%$E#'!:#>I$%R9#P!
!
F;=$#'!#:!;*@!/>:;!F;=%7*!1ABCS3A<1QCDC4!
F%>N#::8!#:!;*@!"/,/!1AL3S1C1<L34D3B!
?'98>IN#!#:!;*@!"!/)!67**!6;'=%7*!344AS2B<315A BB!

4. <.*2$%.3&'(>"%*4"32.)"(
1ACADT9>%#$!6;)0#;9!'#07':8!7$!;!0#'>9:;$#798!';=%;*!
;':#'J!;00'7;>I!&7'!>7'7$;'J!;$E%7E';0IJ!
1AA3DU#'=%$;$=!V%#)#$#%W!'#07':8!7$!&%'8:!:';$8';=%;*!X6Y!
!
!
Y$!344Q+!Z.!;=70:%7$!H;8!7$!0;'!H%:I!:I#!,%==*#![;8:!;$=!
/&'%>;!
6;)0#;9+!T@!6;:I#:!6;'=%7G;8>!-%;E$!1ACAS1L<5DQ!
V%#)#$#%W!#:!;*@!6;:I#:!6;'=%7G;8>!-%;E!1AA5S54<1Q5DC!
!

5. 1$#4&%.*$8($5(044%$&36"*(
,&-.&'(
?@ABB(
C%&36.&'(
?@DEE(
!"#$%&'(
?@DEF(
>G)&':"(
H:33"**5:'(1$%$8&%=(
1&88:'&2.$8(
A5! A2@Q! AA@Q! 0]4@441!
>I10(H:33"**( A1@Q! A4@Q! A4@Q! 0^4@CC2!
J&K$%(782%=(H.2"(
1$#4'.3&2.$8*(
4! 3@5! 3@4! 0^4@452!
>%$3"-:%&'(I.#"(
LJ"&8(#.8(MH9N(
B4!_!3B! 5A!_!32! 5C!_!3B! 0^4@L45!
!':$%$*3$4=(I.#"(
LJ"&8(#.8(MH9N(
15!_!11! 13!_!14! 11!_!14! 0^4@4L1!
;"8O26($5(<$*4.2&'(H2&=(
LJ"&8(-&=*(M(H9N(
1@2!_!3@2!
F;$E#!4!:7!12!
1@C!_!5@C!
F;$E#!4!:7!3A!
1@C!_!B@3!
F;$E#!4!:7!5A!
0^`.!
Kiemeneij et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 1997;29:1269-75

6. ,"8"P"-(Q82"%"*2(.8(I,(.8(26"(RH(
6I;$E#!%$!)#=%>;*!8J8:#)!H%:I!;$!#)0I;8%8!7$!
R9;*%:J!;$=!>78:!
T7H#'!K*##=%$E!;$=!G;8>9*;'!>7)0*%>;:%7$8!
-#>'#;8#=!>78:8!
Y$>'#;8#=!0;:%#$:!8;:%8&;>:%7$!
(';=#D7&&8!
T#;'$%$E!>9'G#!
aF;=%;:%7$!#b0789'#!

7. S%$P26($5(,&-.&'(>1Q(.8(RH(

8. 1$#4'.3&2.$8*($5(!"#$%&'(033"**(
c'7%$!I#);:7);!
`#9'70;:IJ!!
c'7%$!Y$&#>:%7$!!
(I'7)K78%8dY8>I#)%;!!
/':#'%;*!=%88#>:%7$!
X8#9=7;$#9'J8)!
/De!&%8:9*;!
F#:'70#'%:7$#;*!I#);:7);!
! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!/$E%7!!!!X6Y!
.);**!O]2>)P!!!!!!1Q!!!!51!
,7=!O2D14>)P!!!!!!L!!!!!11!
T;'E#!Of14>)P!!!!4@2!!!!!3!
Berry et al. Am J Cardiol 2004;94:361-363
033"**(*.2"(3$#4'.3&2.$8*(%"4'&3"-(.*36"#.3(
3$#4'.3&2.$8*(&*(26"(#$*2(5%"T:"82(3$#4'.3&2.$8*($5(
3&%-.&3(3&26"2"%.U&2.$8(

9. 9"3%"&*"(.8(!"#$%&'(1$#4'.3&2.$8*(
-#80%:#!;!24!=#>*%$#!%$!K7:I!8#b#8+!H7)#$!>7$:%$9#!:7!
I;G#!;!DGAV!%$>'#;8#=!'%8N!7&!K*##=%$E!;$=!G;8>9*;'!
>7)0*%>;:%7$8!>7)0;'#=!H%:I!)#$!
Ahmed et al. Circ Cardiovasc Interv 2009;2:423-429
>46,000
consecutive PCI
patients from the
NNE PCI Registry
2002-2007
OR 2002: 2.63 (2.02 to 3.45)
OR 2007: 2.61 (1.73 to 3.91)

10. ,"-:3"-(W'""-.8OX)&*3:'&%(3$#4'.3&2.$8*(
`7$D';$=7)%g#=!=;:;!I;8!8I7H$!;!8%E$%&%>;$:!'#=9>:%7$!
%$!K*##=%$E!;$=!G;8>9*;'!>7)0*%>;:%7$8!H%:I!(F/!
F;7!#:!;*@!"!/)!67**!6;'=%7*!Y$:G!344CS1<5QADCL!

11. 1$82"#4$%&%=(I,Q(>%&32.3"(.8(RH(
!

12. 1$#4&%.*$8($5(044%$&36"*(
,#:;D;$;*J8%8!7&!35!F6(8!H%:I!Q434!0;:%#$:8!9$=#'E7%$E!
>7'7$;'J!=%;E$78:%>!;$=!%$:#'G#$:%7$;*!0'7>#=9'#8!
"7**J!#:!;*@!/)!M#;':!"!344AS12Q<153DB4!

13. ,"3"82('&%O"(,1I*(
FYe/T!O/6.!:'%;*P!
F#=9>#=!0'%);'J!79:>7)#!O>7)078%:#!7&!=#;:I+!,Y+!6e/+!7'!
$7$D6/?cD'#*;:#=!);W7'!K*##=%$E!;:!54!=;J8P!H%:I!';=%;*!%$!
.([,Y!E'790!OMF!4@L4+!A2!6Y!4@5C!:7!4@ABS!0^4@43LP!
FYUT[!O.([,Y!:'%;*P!
F;=%;*!;887>%;:#=!H%:I!*7H#'!>;'=%;>!)7':;*%:J!O2@3!G8@!A@3+!
0^4@434P+!K*##=%$E!OQ@C!G8@!13@3+!0^4@43LP+!;$=!8I7':#'!
I780%:;*!8:;J!O0^4@45P!
(I#!.([,YDF;=%;*!:'%;*!O(6(!3413P!
,;W7'!K*##=%$E!7'!;>>#88!8%:#!>7)0*%>;:%7$8!H#'#!'#=9>#=!%$!
:I#!';=%;*!E'790!O1@B!G8@!Q@3+!0]@4441P+!;8!H#**!;8!
>7$:';8:!G7*9)#!;$=!*#$E:I!7&!Y6Z!8:;J!
Jolly et al. Lancet 2011;377:1409 20
Romagnoli et al. JACC 2012;60:2481-9
Bernat et al. Presented at TCT 2012

14. I,Q(5$%(HI7JQ(
,#:;D;$;*J8%8!7&!13!F6(8!%$G7*G%$E!553B!0;:%#$:8!
(';$8';=%;*!!
.%E$%&%>;$:*J!*7$E#'!&*97'78>70%>!:%)#!!
.%E$%&%>;$:*J!)7'#!&'#R9#$:!>'788D7G#'!!
.%E$%&%>;$:!'#=9>:%7$!%$!'%8N!7&!);W7'!K*##=%$E!!
.%E$%&%>;$:!'#=9>:%7$!%$!>7)078%:#!7&!=#;:I+!,Y+!7'!8:'7N#!
.%E$%&%>;$:!'#=9>:%7$!%$!)7':;*%:J!
.%E$%&%>;$:*J!8I7':#'!I780%:;*!8:;J!
`7!=%&&#'#$>#!%$!-3?!7'!0'7>#=9';*!:%)#!
!
e7'7K>89N!#:!;*@!/)!M#;':!"!344AS12C<C1BD31!

15. I"#4$%&'(I%"8-($5(I,(5$%(HI7JQ(
Baklanov et al. JACC 2013;61:420-6

16. !.8&83.&'(H&).8O*(
.;)#!-;J!X6Y!!
#8:%);:#=!8;G%$E8!:7!I#;*:I>;'#!8J8:#)!^!!h1@C!K%**%7$!;$$9;**J!
(7:;*!;=W98:#=!>78:8!&;G7'#=!
(FY!KJ!h225!O0^4@455P!
-;J!7&!0'7>#=9'#!>78:8!H#'#!
8%)%*;'!(UY!;$=!(FY!
678:8!&'7)!:I#!&7**7H%$E!
=;J!:7!=%8>I;'E#!H#'#!
8%E$%&%>;$:*J!*7H#'!H%:I!(FY+!
0'%);'%*J!=9#!:7!;!
=#>'#;8#=!Ti.!O34!
;::'%K9:;K*#!:7!=#>'#;8#!
K*##=%$E!>7)0*%>;:%7$8P!
Safley et al. Am Heart J 2013;165:303-309
Resnic. Circulation 2007;115:2248-2250

17. >&2."82(H&2.*5&32.$8(
/)7$E!:I#!0;:%#$:8!HI7!I;=!K7:I!)#:I7=8+!:I#!:';$8';=%;*!
)#:I7=!H;8!8:'7$E*J!0'#&#''#=!%$!C4!;$=!)7=#';:#*J!
0'#&#''#=!%$!Q+!H%:I!7$*J!3!0'#&#''%$E!:';$8&#)7';*!
>;:I#:#'%g;:%7$!
6770#'!#:!;*@!/)!M#;':!"!1AAAS15C<B54DB5L!
Happy patients
good for business

18. >&2."82(H&2.*5&32.$8(
U'7)!FYe/T!!

19. ;"&%8.8O(3:%)"/(9.&O8$*2.3(1&*"*(
T77%!#:!;*@!/)!"!6;'=%7*!3411S14C<14A3 14A2!

20. ;"&%8.8O(3:%)"/(9.&O8$*2.3(1&*"*(
[G#$!H%:I!)7=#8:!
0'7>#=9';*!$9)K#'8!
Oj5L!%$!&%'8:!A!)7+!L5!
KJ!13!)7P+!:#>I$%>;*!
=%&&#'#$>#8!=#>'#;8#!
';0%=*J!;8!$7$D';=%;*!
#b0#':8!E;%$!)7'#!
#b0#'%#$>#!!
!
T77%!#:!;*@!/)!"!6;'=%7*!3411S14C<14A3 14A2!

21. ;"&%8.8O(1:%)"(5$%(I,Q(
(FDX6Y!89>>#88!=#0#$=8!7$!70#';:7'!#b0#'%#$>#!
(I#!7==8!7&!&;%*9'#!=#>*%$#!89K8:;$:%;**J!90!:7!24!>;8#8+!;$=!
&9':I#'!=#>*%$#!;&:#'!144!>;8#8!%8!8);**!
(FY!&;%*9'#!%8!8%E$%&%>;$:*J!;887>%;:#=!H%:I!>;8#!G7*9)#+!$7:!
70#';:7'!8:;:98!
?;**!#:!;*@!6%'>!6;'=%7G;8>!Y$:#'G!3411SB<55LD5B1!

22. <.O6"%(,&-.&2.$8(7V4$*:%"(
U7'!X6Y!KJ!#b0#'%#$>#=!70#';:7'8+!';=%;:%7$!#b0789'#!
%8!I%EI#'!#G#$!%$!:I#!&;>#!7&!#R9%G;*#$:!&*97'7!:%)#!
Lange et al. CCI 2006;67:12-16

23. ,&-.&2.$8(7V4$*:%"(
X'7>#=9';*!G7*9)#!
H;8!;!)7'#!
%)07':;$:!0'#=%>:7'!
7&!';=%;:%7$!=78#!
:I;$!;>>#88!8%:#!!
[b0#'%#$>#!H;8!:I#!
)78:!%)07':;$:!
&;>:7'!%$!'#=9>%$E!
';=%;:%7$!#b0789'#!
&'7)!>7'7$;'J!
0'7>#=9'#8!
'#E;'=*#88!7&!
HI#:I#'!';=%;*!7'!
&#)7';*!;>>#88!H;8!
0#'&7')#=! "7**J!#:!;*@!"!/)!67**!6;'=%7*!Y$:G!3415SL<32CDLL!

24. 1$83':*.$8*(
67)0;'#=!H%:I!:I#!';=%;*!;00'7;>I+!:I#!&#)7';*!
;00'7;>I!!
M;8!*#88!>'788D7G#'!
/$!#;8%#'!*#;'$%$E!>9'G#!
X'7K;K*J!*#88!';=%;:%7$!
?9:+!:I#!=;:;!;*87!8I7H8!98!:I;:!:I#!&#)7';*!;00'7;>I!%8!
;887>%;:#=!H%:I!!
M%EI#'!K*##=%$E!;$=!G;8>9*;'!>7)0*%>;:%7$8+!0;':%>9*;'*J!%$!
.([,Y!0;:%#$:8!
M%EI#'!>78:8!
T7H#'!0;:%#$:!8;:%8&;>:%7$!