The distinction between an offer and an invitation to treat is often hard to draw as it depends on the elusive criterion of intention
1. The DistinctionBetweenAnOfferAndAnInvitationToTreatIs OftenHard To Draw As ItDependsOn
The Elusive CriterionOf Intention.ButThere Are CertainStereotypedSituationsThatThe DistinctionIs
DeterminedByRulesOf Law"IntroductionAnofferismade whenapersonshowsawillingnesstoenter
intoa legallybindingcontract.Aninvitationtotreat(I.T.T) ismerelyasupplyof informationtotempta
personintomakinganoffer.Howeverthe distinctionbetweenthe two canoftenbe misleadingand
ultimatelymisinterpreted.Whenmisinterpretationsandcomplicationsoccurthenitisdownto the
courts to decide andtodistinguishbetweenthe twoterms,soa personisnotledintoa bindingcontract
of whichhe doesnotwant to be a part of, (HarveyV Facey[1893] A.C552.) but ismerelysupplying
informationtowhichanofferisto be made.OffersandInvitations...
An invitationtotreatisan actioninvitingotherpartiestomake anoffertoform a contract. These
actionsmay sometimesappeartobe offersthemselves,andthe difference cansometimesbe difficultto
determine.The distinctionisimportantbecauseacceptinganoffercreatesabindingcontractwhile
"accepting"aninvitationtotreatis actuallymakinganoffer.
Advertisements are usually invitations to treat, which allows sellers to refuse to sell products at
prices mistakenly marked. Advertisements can also be considered offers in some specific cases.
Auctions are sometimes invitations to treat which allows the seller to accept bids and choose which
to accept. However, if the seller states that there is no reserve price or the reserve price has been
met, the auction will be considered an offer accepted by the highest bidder.
An offer and invitation to offer are two different terms, which must not be
confused with one another. An offer is a proposal while an invitation to
offer (treat) is inviting someone to make a proposal. In an offer, there is an
intention to enter into a contract, of the party, making it and thus it is certain. On
the other hand, an invitation to offer is an act which leads to the offer, which is
made with an aim of inducing or negotiating the terms.
So, in an invitation to offer, the offeror, does not make an offer, rather invites
other parties to make an offer. Hence, before simply responding to an offer, one
must know the difference between offer and invitation to offer, because that
makes a difference in the rights of parties.
2. BASIS FOR
COMPARISON
OFFER
Meaning When one person expresses his will to another person to do or not
something, to take his approval, is known as an offer.
Defined in Section 2 (a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Objective To enter into contract.
Essential to make an
agreement
Yes
Consequence The Offer becomes an agreement when accepted.
Definition of Offer
An offer is an expression of a person showing his willingness to another person to
do or not to do something, to obtain his consent on such expression. The
acceptance of the offer by such person may result in a valid contract. An offer
must be definite, certain and complete in all respects. It must be communicated
to the party to whom it is made. The offer is legally binding on the parties. There
are following types of offer:
General offer: The type of offer which is made to the public at large.
Specific offer: The type of offer made to a particular person.
Cross offer: When the parties to the contract accept each other’s offer in
ignorance of the original offer, it is known as the cross offer.
Counter offer: This is an another type of offer in which the offeree does not accept
the original offer, but after modifying the terms and conditions accept it, it is
termed as a counter offer.
Standing offer: An offer which is made to public as a whole as well as it remains
open for a specific period for acceptance it is known as Standing offer.
Example:`
3. A tells to B,”I want to sell my motorcycle to you at Rs. 30,000, Will you purchase
it?”
X says to Y,”I want to purchase your car for Rs. 2,00,000, Will you sell it to me?”
Definition of Invitation to offer (treat)
An Invitation to Offer is an act before an offer, in which one person induces
another person to make an offer to him, it is known as invitation to offer. When
appropriately responded by the other party, an invitation to offer results in an
offer. It is made to the general public with intent to receive offers and negotiate
the terms on which the contract is created.
The invitation to offer is made to inform the public, the terms and conditions on
which a person is interested in entering into a contract with the other party.
Although the former party is not an offeror as he is not making an offer instead,
he is stimulating people to offer him. Therefore, the acceptance does not amount
to a contract, but an offer. When the former party accepts, the offer made by the
other parties, it becomes a contract, which is binding on the parties.
Example:
Menu card of a restaurant showing the prices of food items.
Railway timetable on which the train timings and fares are shown.
Government Tender
A Company invites application from public to subscribe for its shares.
Recruitment advertisement inviting application.
Key Differences Between Offer and Invitation to Offer
(Treat)
The principal points of difference between offer and invitation to offer are as
follows:
1. An offer is the final willingness of the party to create legal relations. An invitation
to offer is not the final willingness but the interest of the party to invite public to
offer him.
2. An offer is defined in section 2 (a) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Conversely,
an invitation to offer is not defined in the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
3. An offer is an essential element to make an agreement between the parties, but an
invitation to offer is not an important element until it becomes an offer.
4. 4. An offer becomes an agreement when accepted. On the other hand, an invitation
to offer becomes an offer when the public responds to it.
5. The main objective of making an offer is to enter into the contract, whereas the
main objective of an invitation to offer is to negotiate the terms on which the
contract can be made.
Conclusion
Now, you are surely not confused between these two. It is also a characteristic of
an offer that it must be distinct from an invitation to offer. An Invitation to offer
is a very familiar term as we all have dined in a restaurant where menu cards
show the price list of the concerned food items or booked a ticket by viewing the
railway timetable. Two most famous examples are pamphlets of pizza’s showing
their rates and an auction sale advertisement.
The Offer is quite specific term as it is meant to create legal relations as it is an
essential element for making a contract. The ‘intention’ of the party making it, is
the fundamental phenomenon that differentiates the two terms.