This presentation is from a seminar titled “Key Issues in Wine Regulation” held in San Francisco, California, 18 ~ 19 September 2011.

1. !"#$%&'()*#+$,-.%,-%
/*0,",*$0%1'2'3#('.
!"#$ %&'()*"&
+,"#-*)". /0*#"0&*,)0&' 122&,"3 45"#&5
6(&, /0753*",&' 8*&07&"73 /03*,*5*#
8#9*#$:#" ;<. =>;;

2. !"#$%&'#'()*&(+(,-.#*#%*/'.(
0'.')#&1*%2*3.4")#&1*
0'.')#&1*%2*5'.-.6(
0'.')#&1*%2*7"8+'6*9(-+#$
:

3. 445%63,7,.#*%%
43#8+%9,+$8$0#+$,-%,-%/*0,",*$0%1'2'3#('.%5,-+3,*%
:&';%53$+'3$#<%63,0'=)3'.%#-=%&'>)$3'?'-+.%8,3%/*0,",*%1'2'3#('%
6#0@#('.%,3%6$0+,3$#*%A#B'*.CD#3-$-(%E+#+'?'-+.%,-%A,0#*%,3%
F?7,3+'=%/*0,",*%1'2'3#('.G
;-#(*<&%<%)(4=* :>*0-&6$*:??@
A.#&1*'.#%*(22(6#= B
C"&&(.#*)#-#")= ;&-2#*<&%<%)-+D*6"&&(.#+1*".4(&*
)#"4'()D*&(,'(/)D*<"8+'6*$(-&'.E
FG%#'2'(4*#%*HIJ= :K*L-."-&1*:?K?M
N

4. 5,-+'-+
O<(6'2'()*<-6P-E(*)'Q()*2%&*-+6%$%+'6*8(,(&-E()R
7&%$'8'#)*")(*%2*+-8(+*#$-#*S-1*S')+(-4*6%.)"S(&)*#%*8(+'(,(*#$-#*#$(*
6%.#(.#*6-.*'S<&%,(*$(-+#$*%&*$-)*+%/(&*#%T'6*+(,(+*#$-.*%#$(&*
8&-.4)R
U(V"'&()*'.6+")'%.*'.*#$(*+-8(+*%2*#$(*)#-#(S(.#=*
H!"'%.#*'%,8%#*0,",*$0%B'2'3#('.%+,%7'3.,-.%)-='3%IJ%K'#3.%
,8%#('%$.%73,"$B$+'=%#-=%.)BL'0+%+,%+"'%7'-#*+$'.%,8%,-'MK'#3%
$?73$.,-?'-+%,3%IJ<JJJ%B#"+%8$-'NO
O<(6'2'()*W*#1<()*%2*<'6#%&'-+*+-8(+)*/'#$*/-&.'.E*)#-#(S(.#*2%&*
4')<+-1*%.*<-6P-E()=*-++*W*#1<()*-&(*&(V"'&(4*#%*8(*")(4*-.4*&%#-#(4*
-#*KD???*<-6P-E(*'.#(&,-+)X
PQ'?7+.%+%6-++1*S-4(*%&*'S<%&#(4*-+6%$%+'6*8(,(&-E()*/$'6$*-&(*
4()#'.(4*2%&=
B 4')#&'8"#'%.*%"#*%2*#$(*#(&&'#%&1*%2*I$-'+-.4R
B )<(6'2'6*<"&<%)()*-)*)-S<+()*2%&*#()#'.ED*-.-+1)')D*%&*&()(-&6$R
B .%.B6%SS(&6'-+*8(.(2'#)*'.*#$(*#(&&'#%&1X
Y

5. R%+K7'.%,8%7$0+,3$#*%*#B'*.CS#3-$-(%.+#+'?'-+.
R%+K7'.%,8%7$0+,3$#*%*#B'*.CS#3-$-(%.+#+'?'-+.
!K7'%T H43$-@$-(%0#-%0#).'%*$2'3%0$33",.$.N
>

6. !K7'%I H43$-@%=3$2$-(%0#-%0#).'%=$.#B$*$+$'.%#-=%='#+"N
W

7. !"#$%& '()*+,*+-%./+%0$/1%23%0344%35%.3+4.*364+$44%/+1%$7$+%
0*5$8
!

8. !"#$%9 '()*+,*+-%:/4%1$0$2$)*364%$55$.2%3+%4$;6/0%
#$)53)</+.$8
"

9. !"#$%= '()*+,*+-%./+%0$/1%23%/>64*7$%/+1%1$42)6.2*7$%
>$:/7*36)%23?/)14%3+$@4%4$05%/+1%5/<*0"8
#

10. !"#$%A '()*+,*+-%:/4%>/1%*+506$+.$%3+%.:*01)$+%/+1%<*+3)48
$%

11. !$.:+*./0%B$#3)2C%
D:"%!:/*0/+1%4:3601%:/7$%2:$%#*.23)*/0%?/)+*+-%
0/>$0%3+%/0.3:30*.%>$7$)/-$%#/.,/-$4E
• Alcohol is a Non-ordinary Commodity
• Effectiveness of pictorial warning messages
• Technical evidence f warning messages
for
$$

12. 8(9:36-,(9&+Why pictorial warnings?
!:$"%2$00%<6.:%5/42$)%2:/+%?3)14L%/+1%<6.:%>$22$)M%
NOL%DPQ%RO!7+
FGHIJKF&
• '()*+,-+)((.+/(0+
12*341 541(6)1+,4+
;*<+4*=2+<2*0-+(/+
>0*:4,:2+*9.+:(940(3?+
*:12-+*9.+>*,9@A
$B

13. !"#$%&
'()*
!"