SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT
2015
Taco Bell Website
Assessment
COMMUNICATION DASHBOARD PROJECT
Northeastern University
CMN 6910: Organizational Communication
Assessment
Bozhura Angelova
December 19, 2015
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Communication vehicle and company information ....................................................... 2
Marketing and Communications Objectives ............................................................... 10
Marketing strategy & organizational environment ...................................................... 11
Benchmarks ............................................................................................................... 21
Best practices............................................................................................................. 27
KPIs............................................................................................................................ 29
Measurement Tools and Key Findings....................................................................... 30
Analysis and Recommendations ................................................................................ 34
Dashboard visuals...................................................................................................... 39
References................................................................................................................. 42
Appendices ................................................................................................................ 45
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 2
COMMUNICATION VEHICLE AND COMPANY INFORMATION
ABOUT THE ORGANIZATION
After leaving the Marines at 23, Glen Bell opened a hot dog stand in his home town - San
Bernardino, California. He was not interested however in selling the typical fast food staples like
burgers and hot dogs, so he began selling tacos for 19 cents from a side window of his hot dog
stand. The tacos were very well received, so he started opening Taco Tia stands where tacos
were the main menu item. (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-a, para. 1)
In 1962, Bell sold the Taco Tia brand to his partners and opened the first Taco Bell in Downey,
California. Franchising began two years later. (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-a, para. 1)
Since its founding, Taco Bell has become the second most profitable brand in the U.S. and one of
the leading Mexican-style fast food chains in the country (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-b, para.1 ).
The Yum!Brands subsidiary offers made to order and customizable tacos, burritos, quesadillas,
gorditas, nachos, chalupas, beverages, desserts and sides, and other specialty items (“Company
Overview”, n.d., para. 1).
The restaurant serves more than 36 million customers at its nearly 6,000 American locations.
Taco Bell primarily operates in the U.S. market, but Yum!Brands is planning to make the
company its third global brand (along with KFC and Pizza Hut).
Outside of the U.S., there are currently around 300 Taco Bell restaurants in 20 countries.
In 2014, Taco Bell ranked #4 on the 50 QSR (Quick Service Restaurants) list and in 2013 it was
named Ad Age “Marketer of the Year” for reaching over $1 billion in sales of Doritos® Locos
Tacos (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-b, para. 3).
COMMUNICATION VEHICLE
In 2015, Taco Bell introduced its redesigned website which expands “the availability of order
and pay ahead capabilities and customization options which were previously available only via
the brand’s mobile app” (Jennigs, 2015).
In addition to using the traditional www.tacobell.com, users can now reach the website by
simply typing ‘ta.co.’ in their browser address bar, which according to company officials makes
the website fun and easier to access (Jennigs, 2015).
Taco Bell’s VP for digital innovation and on demand, Tressie Lieberman, says the brand’s new
URL is supposed to remind of an emoji in its simplicity. The brand aims to create simple and
pain-free experience as they believe that “ease is the new loyalty” (Jennigs, 2015).
Taco Bell’s new website gives the full brand experience – users can find nearby Taco Bell
locations, place and customize an order, check its nutritional value and even buy Taco Bell gear.
The website also provides opportunities to engage with the brand through their “The Feed” tab
and social media buttons which are located at the bottom of almost every page.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 3
HOMEPAGE STRUCTURE
1. Top section – This section of the website allows visitors to search Taco Bell’s menu, login or
create a user profile and review their order by clicking the shopping cart button.
2. Side navigation – This is the main website navigation where users can browse the menu,
order food, find Taco Bell locations and learn about the company and its initiatives.
- The ‘Food’ menu item opens up a sub navigation allowing users to look up different food
categories.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 4
- ‘Locations’ opens a map that lets visitors find their nearest Taco Bell by typing a zip code or
using their current location.
- ‘The Feed’ provides curated content and blog posts that appear to be an entertaining and
casual way to “start a conversation” with the audience.
- ‘More’ opens up a submenu that allows users to access Taco Bell’s fan store website
(http://www.livemasstore.com/storefrontB2CWEB/), Taco Bell’s career website
(http://jobs.tacobell.com/), nutrition information (letter from the company and their registered
dietician, nutrition calculator, full nutrition info, allergen info, ingredient statements &
FAQs), company information and initiatives (history, news, careers, franchise). From the
‘More’ tab users can also register and use gift cards and contact the company with comments
and suggestions.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 5
3, 4 & 5 Main body
3. Taco Bell’s website is designed mostly as a one-page, infinite scrolling website – currently
the most functional design for mobile and small screen browsing (Cao, 2015). The home
page provides a quick glimpse of some highlighted sections of the website. There is very
little text and a lot of visuals.
Taco Bell’s homepage currently includes a large picture (promoted food item) with a button
for quick ordering. Clicking the button opens up a page that allows the visitor to fully
customize the product and also read through a short entertaining intro formatted as a blog
post.
As we scroll down the main body of the homepage we see an oversized animated image (GIF)
and the title of a blog post, which also links to the full text of the post (this specific post is also
part of ‘The Feed’).
4. This section of the homepage provides a quick overview of the newest products and offers
available to registered visitors plus a quick link to the entire menu.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 6
5. ‘The Feed’ – This part of the home page offers a preview of all the short posts published by
Taco Bell under ‘The Feed’ tab. There is one highlighted post that has a prominent position
at the top. The name of the section is a clever word play combining ‘feed’ as the act of giving
food and feed as the ‘news feed’ on social networking sites.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 7
6. Social media follow buttons with a call for action – Stay connected - As Vaughan (2014)
says, these buttons are great for businesses to promote their presence on various social
networking sites and gain new fans/followers.
7. Bottom navigation pane – This navigation panel leads to the same pages that are available
through the ‘More’ button in the main side navigation. Providing access to the same page
from several different places instead of just one specific place makes it easier and quicker to
find the desired information.
8. Additional sub navigation – this pane includes more specialized information such as details
about Taco Bell’s ads, legal notices, privacy policy and terms of use. Since this information
is most likely not something that the general population would read, this pane is
appropriately located at the very bottom of the home page.
SHOPPING EXPERIENCE
The users can order on Taco Bell’s website several different ways. They can search for a specific
food item by typing its name in the search bar at the top. Simply clicking in the search field
opens a list of shortcuts to the most popular categories on the menu: tacos, burritos, breakfast,
combos, etc.
The second way to order is via the main website navigation.
Clicking on ‘Food’ leads the user to the menu, while the button expands to show a list of the
different food categories for easy access. Alternatelively the user can browse through all of them
by simply scrolling down.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 8
There is also more than one way to customize a product and order.
Users can click on the ‘customize’ button under each item to modify the product or buy it as it is
by clicking the shopping cart.
Alternatively, users can click on the picture of the desired item and they are taken to a separate
page where they can fully customize the product by adding ‘tasty upgrades’ or changing what is
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 9
included by default. Once they have finalized the item, they can add it to the order by clicking
the bright pink button. The order can be reviewed in the shopping cart at the top right.
The next steps include putting a desired payment method and selecting a pick-up location.
As a whole, ordering is very straightforward and easy thanks to the intuitive design and
responsiveness of the website.
ENGAGING THE VISITOR
The modern design, responsiveness and freshness of Taco Bell’s website fully resonates with
their target audience of young people – mostly teenagers and millennials.
The first thing that we see as we visit Taco Bell’s website is that it is extremely visual.
According to a Digiday study, 95% of marketers find visual content to be much more effective
than text and almost 10% of them believe it is 10 times more effective (The State of Industry -
Visual Marketing: Scale to Win, 2015).
When we browse through the food menu, we notice something interesting: all food items
pictures are formatted as if someone took a picture of their meal and shared it on social media –
something very typical for millennials. At the same time, the pictures are high-quality and
professionally taken so that the food looks as tempting as possible.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 10
In the few text sections, the language is carefully chosen to sound casual and fun, yet intelligent.
When visitors click on some of the food items on the menu, they are taken to a page focused on
that specific item which allows customization, but also includes a short description of the
product. The description sounds more like a story rather than an advertising message. The text
does not focus as much on the product and its ingredients, but mostly on the emotions and
thoughts that the product can evoke in the audience.
Description of Boss Nachos
Source: www.tacobell.com
“The Feed” tab provides curated content and blog posts and most of them are focused on pop
culture and trending topics and involve Taco Bell in a subtle and unobtrusive way. For example,
one of the newest posts focusses on the recent introduction of the Taco emoji and the post
features a lot of social media messages posted by real people which makes it sound like a story,
casual article or a blog post.
In addition, a prominent section of the ‘Company’ page is named ‘Taco Bell gives back’ and it is
focused on the company’s charitable work.
MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS OBJECTIVES
1. Promote online sales & increase revenue
One of Taco Bell’s key objectives is to increase online sales and overall revenue. Their website
is generally focused on providing a quick and painless way to order, customize your meal and
avoid waiting in line.
According to Jennings (2015), nearly 5 million people visit Taco Bell’s website each month.
The new and improved online platform aims to mimic the elevated experience of Taco Bell’s
mobile app.
Taco Bell was the first company to introduce a mobile app with order and pay-ahead features in
2014 which to date was downloaded by 3.7 million people. The feedback from customers has
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 11
been overwhelmingly positive: they love skipping the line and the customization options
increased average spending by 30% (Jennigs, 2015).
2. Engage users and increase loyalty
Despite the decrease in customer spending and signs of saturation, investment in the fast food
industry remains high with new stores opening across the sector. The convenience of fast food
makes it more important to the customer than a simple source of food, but what really drives
customer loyalty is the investment in brand building (MarketLine Industry Profile: Fast Food in
the United States, January 2012).
When it comes to rising above the competition relationship to customers plays an incredibly
important role. According to Paine (2011) companies who have good relationships with their
clients are more likely to be forgiven when they make a mistake. Also, companies who listen and
tend to their customers’ needs are the one to prosper and rise above the competition. (p.5)
3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation
With today’s increasing focus on healthy lifestyle and wellbeing, fast food chains are struggling
to find a way to capitalize on this trend.
The endless customization options including fresh and vegetarian choices available through their
website and mobile app is enabling Taco Bell to attract this new health-conscious crowd and
change the perception of the brand.
MARKETING STRATEGY & ORGANIZATIONAL ENVIRONMENT
MARKETPLACE
The fast food market in the U.S. accounts for 32.5% of the global fast food market value and has
been steadily growing since 2009. The market volume is expected to reach 52.4 billion
transactions by the end of 2016 (multiple purchases made during the same visit are counted as
one transaction) with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of nearly 3% for the 2011-2016
period (MarketLine, 2012, p.10-12).
In 2016, the fast food market value is expected to reach $93,600.3 million - an increase of almost
14% since 2011 (MarketLine, 2012).
In 2011, the restaurant-QSR segment was one of the most profitable with total revenues of nearly
$70 billion, which accounts for almost 80% of the market’s overall value (MarketLine, 2012).
The tables below illustrate the development in terms of industry ratios, number of establishments
and industry sales for the period 2013-2017.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 12
Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513)
Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513)
Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513)
COMPETITION
The fast food market is highly competitive with a rather low concentration, apart from the burger
segment which is ruled by Burger King and McDonalds (MarketLine, 2012).
There are moderately low barriers to entry, as the U.S. fast food market does not require large
capital outlay and major companies can reduce the cost of expanding by utilizing the franchise
model (MarketLine, 2012).
New entrants could expect retaliation by existing players (such as the launch of a price war),
especially in more concentrated segments (MarketLine, 2012).
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 13
In any case, the considerable brand strength of the major chains should not be underestimated
and it may diminish much of the effect of low switching costs (MarketLine, 2012).
“Price competition is prevalent amongst industry players, especially between value meals. In
particular, the value meals within the $1-$2 range are a reaction to shifting consumer trends and
a larger focus on competition amongst industry players. This form of price dumping has become particularly
prevalent as a result of a fragile wider economic environment. “(MarketLine, 2012, p.16)
As a whole, brand power forms the greatest competition in the fast food market, with McDonalds
spending hundreds of millions of dollars on global advertising for example (MarketLine, 2012).
MARKETING STRATEGY
Yum!Brands, Taco Bell’s parent company, is one of the major players in the fast food industry
and Taco Bell is its most profitable brand in the U.S. Taco Bell’s current marketing strategy is
focused on changing the perception of food and promoting the concept of food as experience
(Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 01:13-01:20).
The company’s strong marketing team which is known for some of the best lines in the business
(‘run for the border’; ‘yo quiero Taco Bell’ and ‘think outside the bun’) does not hold on to the
past. Instead, they pay attention to customers’ evolving taste and preferences and respond
accordingly. (Niccol & Brandt, 2014) As a result Taco Bell is quickly turning into a social media
sensation despite its rather unfavorable reputation from the recent past. (Lutz, 2014).
For instance, Taco Bell still uses television as part of their marketing mix, but they also realize
that today’s millennial consumers need to be engaged and talked to, so the brand utilized new
channels such as Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Vine, etc. (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 01:44-
02:15).
As a consequence, Taco Bell has 10 million followers on Facebook, 1 million followers on
Twitter and they are the number one food brand on Instagram. Further, with their newly
established Snapchat presence, they helped define how brands are supposed to be using this
channel (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 02:54-03:04).
However, engagement rather than mere numbers is what matters to Taco Bell’s executives: ‘It’s
not just about likes or clicks… What I really like to see is do people co-create off this? Do they
repeat the story?” (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 03:20-03:32)
One of the biggest advantages of social media for marketers according to Taco Bell’s senior
management is that it enables companies to get real-time, unfiltered reactions from customers as
opposed to the past when the only indicators were the sales numbers or consumer research
studies (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 04:02-04:15).
Along with the changes in its marketing strategy and approach, Taco Bell implemented changes
in other major aspects of the business (Lutz, 2014).
First, the brand revamped its menu – in 2012, they introduced Doritos Locos Tacos, which
turned out to be a major success (1 billion units sold in the first year). The company also
revealed a healthier ‘fresco’ menu as a response to the shift to healthier lifestyle (Lutz, 2014).
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 14
In 2014, Taco Bell went on to reinvent breakfast. Not only did the company launch unusual
items such as the waffle taco, the biscuit taco and the A.M. crunch wrap (bacon, cheese, eggs and
hash brown all in one place), they went after McDonalds with a hard-hitting marketing
campaign. The ad featured real people named Ronald McDonald trying the new morning items
and announcing their newly found love for Taco Bell’s breakfast (Morrison, 2014).
This proved to be a successful step as Yum!Brands second quarter earnings showed that
breakfast was responsible for 7% of Taco Bell’s sales in the quarter and was expected to add
between $70,000 and $120,000 in annual sales per restaurant (Morrison, 2014).
Moreover, the company improved the quality of its ingredients. According to Brandt, Taco Bell
now uses higher quality beef and rice and prepares a real pico de gallo, which had a big impact
on the bottom line – the brand’s sales rose by 5% in 2013 (Lutz, 2014).
To a great extent, Taco Bell’s success is connected to adequately responding to trends. For
example, in response to millennials’ love for snacking Taco Bell started ‘Happier Hour’, which
offers deals on Loaded Grillers and drinks, as well as ‘FourthMeal’, a sampling of Taco Bell
menu items (Epstein, 2014).
Earlier in 2015, Taco Bell announced their plan to start serving alcohol in selected locations as
part of their rebranding efforts. The first U.S. based Taco Bell restaurant to serve beer, wine and
cocktails is in Chicago and will be similar to their existing upscale locations in the U.K., Seoul
and Tokyo (Poppick, 2015).
Unlike other fast food companies, Taco Bell successfully tends to the needs of the
vegan/vegetarian community as well. The brand offers a 13-item vegetarian menu “that has been
certified meat-free by the American Vegetarian Association (AVA)” (Prater, 2015, para. 2). Taco
Bell has 35 certified vegetarian ingredients on its menu and 26 of them are vegan.
In a statement, Brian Niccol, Taco Bell’s CEO, announced the brand’s plans to start paying more
attention to vegetarian items and to demonstrate the brand’s commitment to “deliver food that
fits the customers’ evolving lifestyles” (Prater, 2015, para. 3).
In an interview from 2015, Brian Niccol also said that Taco Bell is working to eliminate artificial
colors, high-fructose corn syrup and trans fats from 95% of its menu (Giammona, 2015).
AUDIENCE PROFILE:
Source: Alexa.com
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 15
According to data from Alexa.com (2015), visitors seem engaged with Taco Bell’s website. The
bounce rate is comparatively low and the time spent on the website is well above the average
(Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). From this data, we can assume that the website is easy to use
and navigate and visitors seem to be finding what they are looking for.
Source: Alexa.com
Alexa.com (2015) indicates that female visitors are almost twice as much as male vistors and
men are generally underrepresented on Taco Bell’s website. According to QSR Magazine (2014)
women are one of the most powerful economic forces in the world. They represent 51% of the
U.S. population, possess as much as $7 trillion in purchasing power and are responsible for 85%
of consumer spending. The article further maintans that the rise of healthy eating and the
increase in women’s purchasing power are interconnected. Women typically care about fresh,
quality ingredients as well as customization options (Omazic, 2014). These findings seem to
reflect Taco Bell’s new concept, which may be an explanation of the growing number of female
visitors on their website.
The most represented age groups are 18-24 and 25-34 which shows that Taco Bells millenial-
focused marketing is paying off. However, we notice that all age groups are well represented and
are almost reaching the internet average point.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 16
Visitors with children are underrepresented,
which makes sense as most of Taco Bell’s
customers are teenagers, students or young
professionals.
Source: Alexa.com
The educational profile of visitors is equally
distributed between those with some college
education and those holding a college degree. This
data also corresponds with Taco Bell’s target group.
Source: Alexa.com
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 17
Source: Alexa.com
In terms of visitors’ income, we see that all income levels are well represented. The most active
group of visitors are the ones making between $30K-$60K a year. Similar to all fast food
restaurants, Taco Bell offers food items starting at $1 targeted at people with lower income. At
the same time, visitors who use the customization options may end up paying $6-$7 per item.
This array of prices may be a possible explanation of the wide range of income levels
represented.
As far as ethnicity goes, we can see a very strong preference from African Americans and
Caucasians toward Taco Bell – about twice the internet average. Taco Bell offers an
Americanized Mexican food. This may explain the lack of more Hispanics as they might prefer
more authentic Mexican cuisine.
While we still see some Hispanic visitors on Taco Bell’s website, Asian, African and Middle
Eastern nationals are extremely underrepresented.
According to Wong (2013), ethnicity is the strongest predictor of taste when it comes to fast
food. To a certain extent, the ethnic variation can result from the geographic concentration of fast
food chains in a specific area. Based on that, we can assume that many Taco Bell restaurants
might be located in areas where most of the population is African American or Caucasian.
In addition, the article reveals that another reason could lie in marketing targeted specifically to
reach certain ethnicity groups (Wong, 2013). Taco Bell’s marketing is mostly age-focused, so
this might explain the lack of diversity in terms of ethnicity.
AUDIENCE PROFILE COMPARISON
Pain (2011) advises to benchmark against two or three competitors: “a stretch goal, a peer
company, and an underdog (…).” (p.37) For the sake of this analysis, McDonalds could play the
role of a stretch goal and Chipotle could be seen as the underdog.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 18
In 2014, McDonalds had nearly three times more locations than Taco Bell (≈15,000) and almost
five times more sales (nearly $35 billion) (The QSR 50, 2015).
On the other hand, Chipotlle Mexican Grill is considerably smaller with only 1,755 locations and
$4 billion in sales compared to Taco Bell’s nearly 6,000 restaurants and $8 billion in sales (The
QSR 50, 2015).
Source: Alexa.com
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 19
Source: Alexa.com
The first difference we can see is in the educational level of visitors: most of McDonalds’
visitors have some or no college education, other educational levels (graduate school and
college) are underrepresented.
In terms of age, McDonalds has a wider range of overrepresented visitors where 45-54, 55-64
and 65+ are the most active groups (above the internet average), as opposed to Taco Bell’s
audience that is mosly between 18 and 35 years old.
In terms of income the metrics look rather identical, however McDonalds’ most active group is
$60K-$100K which correlates with the average age of McDonalds website visitors.
McDonalds’ visitors with children and without children are equally distribited whereas in Taco
Bell’s case people without children prevail.
Ethnicity data is also very similar, with African Americans and Caucasians being the most
frequest visitors.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 20
Source: Alexa.com
When we compare Taco Bell and Chipotle, the first difference is in the gender section. Chipotle
is visited by an overwhelming number of females – possible reason is the perception of the brand
as all natural and higher quality than Taco Bell.
The age section looks similar with the exception that Chipotle also attracts a large amount of
people between 35-44 years of age.
Chipotle has an almost equal distribution of people with and without children with a slight
majority of people with no children.
In terms of education level, Chipotle attracts a vast number of people with college degree which
corresponds with the average age of visitors.
Again, most likely connected to age, the income level of Chipotle visitors is higher: people with
income between $60K and $100K+ are overrepresented. On a side note, Chipotle doesn’t have
any dollar options and most items are over $6.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 21
As far as ethnicity goes, there is one significant difference – Hispanics are overrepresented at
Chipotle’s website. A possible explanation might be the quality of the food and its authenticity.
Aside from Caucasians and African Americans, other ethnicity groups are extremely
underrepresented similarly to McDonalds and Taco Bell.
BENCHMARKS
INTERNAL BENCHMARKS
“A key point to remember about any evaluation program is that measurement is a comparative
tool; to decide if you are successful you compare your results to something else.” (Paine, 2011,
p.37)
According to Paine (2011), comparing a company to its past performance is one of the most
effective benchmarks. She advises against simply choosing a random date in the past and
recommends to select a benchmark that is related to a significant event. (p.37)
To measure Taco Bell’s performance, I think it is important to analyze several key indicators
before and after two significant events for the company – the website redesign in 2015 and the
lauch of its mobile app in 2014. Thus, it will be interesting to compare financial results in 2013
vs. 2015.
Some of the indicators we can evaluate are:
Sales & Revenue:
 Total sales in 2013/Total sales in 2015
 Sales made through the mobile app to date
 Sales made through the website to date
 Most popular products in 2013/Most popular products in 2015
 Average value of customers’ orders 2013 vs. 2015
 Cost of customer aquisition in 2013 vs. 2015
Engagement & Awareness
 How many followers on social media in 2013/How many followers in 2015
 How visitors find us on social media
 Most popular content on website/Facebook/Instagram/Twitter/etc. – assess all different
channels
 How far into the website visitors are going in 2015 vs. 2013
 How many user profiles created on website/mobile app
 Average time spent on website in 2013/Average time spent on website in 2015
 Daily page views (average) in 2013/Daily page views (average) in 2015
 Unique website visitors per day in 2013 (average)/ Unique website visitors per day in
2015 (average)
 How many returning visitors 2015 vs. 2013
 How many website items shared on social media 2013 vs. 2015
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 22
EXTERNAL BENCHMARKS
For external benchmarking, I will once again use McDonalds and Chipotle.
Taco Bell, Chipotle and McDonalds experience very different traffic levels with McDonalds
getting the highest numbers and Taco Bell being the least visited website (in the past 6 months).
I chose to look at data from the past 6 months because I wanted it to be relevant to Taco Bell’s
new website, which was introduced in September 2015.
It is interesting to note that Chipotle’s traffic is closer to that of McDonalds (especially from
June to August) even though it is the smallest company of the three.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 23
Source: Alexa.com
From this data, it looks like Taco Bell’s visitors are the most engaged – the site has the smallest
bounce rate and the largest number of daily page views per visitor. In terms of daily time on site,
Chipotle and Taco Bell differ by only 3 seconds.
Chipotle and Taco Bell have lower than the average bounce rate and more than the average daily
time on site (Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). What is concerning in Taco Bell’s case however is
that the bounce rate percentage grew by 19%.
On the other hand, Chipotle has less than the average daily page views, which is about 4.6
(Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.).
While Taco Bell’s and Chipotle’s metrics are very similar, McDonalds seems to be doing a poor
job in terms of engagement. The website bounce rate is very high. If we view this kind of
website as closest to a retail website, the bounce rate should be between 20%-40% (Bounce Rate
Demystified, n.d.). McDonalds should definitely be worried that half of the website visitors leave
almost immediately after they open the site.
Looking at the bounce rate combined with the traffic data shown above, we can assume that
McDonalds gets lot of its website traffic from ads and landing pages.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 24
FUNCTIONALITY COMPARISON
Website functions McDonalds Taco Bell Chipotle
Clear navigation tabs   
Full detailed menu   
Nutrition information   
Ingredients information   
High-quality product
images
  
Food customization
options
  
Order & pay ahead
capabilities
  
Use gift cards   
Shop gear   
Nearest location map   
FAQ section   
Search function   
Join mailing list   
Personal account   
Contact us   
Shopping cart   
Social media buttons   
Company information   
Calls to action   
News   
Mobile version Navigation: food, I’m
loving it(special
offers), careers,
locations; join mailing
list; connect on social
media – website looks
completely different on
mobile
Navigation menu
(minimized): food,
locations, the feed,
more (same as desktop
website, the layout is
optimized for mobile);
mobile app download
link; social media
buttons; sign up/login;
shopping cart
The navigation menu is
minimized, includes the
following tabs: order
now, menu, nutrition,
company news and
information, etc. (same
tabs as desktop version
included); search bar,
locations, email list,
social media – looks
very similar to desktop
website
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 25
The three websites have very similar functionality and options. In my opinion, Taco Bell’s and
Chipotle’s websites look slightly more modern and clean compared to McDonalds’ website.
The location of the main navigation is intuitive on all three sites – McDonalds and Taco Bell
have a left navigation and Chipotle has chosen to position the main navigation at the top.
All three websites have oversized image on their homepages, which is a good decision according
to the best practices research I conducted.
The color scheme of all three websites reinforces the brand identity of each company. All three
websites clearly communicate to the user the type of services that are provided.
All three brands have a detailed and very visual menu, nutrition information and list of
ingredients for all products.
There were some differences as well:
What I found strange on McDonalds website was the location of their search tab, which is kind
of buried in the navigation:
In contrast to McDonalds and Chipotle, it is harder to locate the FAQ section on Taco Bell’s
website. The afore mentioned two sites have placed their FAQ section either as a separate button
in the main navigation or under ‘Talk to us’. In order to find Taco Bell’s FAQs on the other
hand, users have to scroll all the way down to the footer of the website (which is a fairly long
process considering that this is a site with an infinite scrolling feature).
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 26
Both Chipotle and Taco Bell offer online ordering. However, Chipotle’s process in not as simple
as Taco Bell’s.
To order online, Chipotle’s customers have to go to another website by clicking ‘Order now’.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 27
On Taco Bell’s website, customers can order directly from the menu or by clicking on one the
promo pictures.
The customization process also looks slightly different. Taco Bell’s customization is more
visually appealing with pictures of all ingredients whereas Chipotle has only text.
Both Chipotle and Taco Bell require a user profile to order, but Taco Bell has the option to sign
up with Facebook which makes registration easier and faster.
Also, Chipotle’s ‘shopping cart’ doesn’t have a very intuitive position and it isn’t visible at all
times during ordering.
After one item is added to the order, the shopping cart expands and takes half of the screen. In
order to add another item, the user should minimize it which then makes it hard to see. It
minimizes to the bottom of the page, instead of to the side for example where there is a lot of
empty space.
BEST PRACTICES
With its new website functionality and newly established focus on online sales, Taco Bell has
already entered the e-commerce space. Therefore, I believe it would be interesting to explore the
best practices in this field and see how the brand’s website measures up to ecommerce standards.
1. Design
According to Volusion (2014), the look of the website is the first important thing that gets
customers excited, especially for food-related ecommerce sites.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 28
Marketers are advised to use large, professionally taken photos of their products. Stock
photography is not recommended, as differentiation and uniqueness is key in this business
(Volusion, 2014).
Images should have a central position on the homepage to catch the eye of the customer and
attract interest.
According to a case study conducted by Visual Website Optimizer (n.d.) the increase in picture
size may increase sales by 9.46% (Deswal, n.d)
However, the visual aspect of the website doesn’t end with great pictures. Typography is another
detail that should not be underestimated – it can “set the tone of the website (playful,
sophisticated, casual) in a subtle, but powerful way”. (Volusion, 2014)
Visual hierrarchy is another vital component of superior websites. According to Fitt’s law,
human eyes are drawn to larger objects. Therefore, important elements (containing links) should
be made large, as it also makes them more clickable (Macdonald, n.d.).
One of the most popular design trends of 2014 is the so called ‘flat design’ characterized by
clean and simple forms and appearance. This approach can work great with food stores as it
suggests a “clean, pure environment” and this is exactly the kind of place, from which people
would be inclined to buy food (Volusion, 2014).
Another critical component is the shopping cart. Visitors should always be able to see how many
items they have in their cart and check out quickly and effortlessly.
2. Content
In terms of content, marketers are advised to focus on a “targeted niche” (Volusion, 2014).
Keywords like ‘food’ are too broad, thus they are less likely to deliver any benefits for the
business. On the other hand, optimizing for specific terms such as “gluten-free”, “fair trade”,
“southern cooking” will enable people interested in these topics to find you and learn about your
products and organization.
Providing original and interesting descriptions of products can further differentiate some brands
from the competition. Approaches include telling a story about the product, using bullet points,
answering FAQs, etc. (We Make Websites, 2015).
Having a blog or “knowledge center” for your products is also a good idea. This way, brands can
share recipes, highlight new products, share customers’ reviews and other content that will
attract the attention of visitors (Volusion, 2014).
3. Miscellaneous
 Short and descriptive URLs work better with SEO and are easy to share
 Descriptive page titles
 Site speed is critical – research by KISSmetrics (n.d.) shows that slower loading times
directly affect sales – 40% of people abandon a website that takes more than 3 seconds to
load; 1 second delay in page response results in 7% less conversions and for a website
that makes $100,000 a day it may lead to $2.5 Million in lost sales annually
 Be imaginative
 Use “you” more than “we”
 Include strong calls to action (We Make Websites, 2015)
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 29
KPIS
According to Paine (2011), after we have determined our objectives, target audience and
benchmarks, we are ready to “establish the specific criteria of success, or the key performance
indicators (…).” (p. 37)
In order to find which KPIs would be the most appropriate for Taco Bell’s main marketing and
communication objectives, I carefully analyzed the website functionality and tried to determine
how it relates to the objectives that I identified previously. Looking closely at each website
function enabled me to see its distinctive purpose and the potential attitudes and behaviors that it
may evoke.
The KPIs listed in the matrix below are divided into three distinctive categories: output,
attitudinal and behavioral KPIs and each set of KPIs is linked to a specific marketing objective.
The next step in my process was to determine the most appropriate measurement tools to help
measure each of these specific indicators.
Marketing objective Output KPIs Attitudinal KPIs Behavioral KPIs
Promote online sales
& increase revenue
 Design and convenience of the
order process (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Special offers availability
(amount, variety, frequency of
posting – heuristic assessment)
 Variety of products (number of
products and product categories
– heuristic assessment)
 Ease of customization process
(heuristic assessment, usability
testing)
 Optimization of the order
process for mobile devices
(heuristic assessment, usability
testing)
 Relative ease of
registration/signing in (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Design and reliability of the
location feature (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Accuracy of the ‘use current
location’ feature ((heuristic
assessment)
 Perceived value of
ordering online/via mobile
 Perceived ease of online
ordering (survey, focus
group)
 Degree of motivation to
purchase (survey, focus
group)
 Level of interest in special
offers (survey, focus
group)
 Degree of motivation to
use customization options
 Perceived value of
customization process
(survey, focus group)
 Perception of calls to
action as persuasive
(survey, focus group)
 Number of visitors who use
special offers (website
metrics)
 % of visitors who order food
(website metrics)
 Average value of website
purchase (website metrics)
 % of visitors who use
customization features
(website metrics)
 % of repeat purchase
(website metrics)
 % of abandoned shopping
carts (website metrics)
 Number of profiles created
(website metrics)
 % of total sales generated
online (website and
company metrics)
Engage users and
increase loyalty
 Strength of brand identity
(visuals & messages) (heuristic
assessment)
 Variety of engagement methods
(heuristic assessment)
 Originality of ‘The Feed’ content
(heuristic assessment)
 Understanding of Taco
Bell’s brand (survey,
focus group)
 Level of interest in Taco
Bell (survey, focus group)
 Degree of motivation to
follow the brand on social
media (survey, focus
group)
 Number of returning visitors
(website metrics)
 Number of clicks on social
media links (website
metrics)
 Number of new social
media followers coming
from the website (social
media analytics)
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 30
 Timeliness of content published
in ‘The Feed’ (heuristic
assessment)
 Content mix in ‘The Feed’
(heuristic assessment)
 Consistency of posts in ‘The
Feed’ (heuristic assessment)
 Sharing options for ‘The Feed’
content
 Hashtags that enable users to
join the conversation on social
media
 Perception of website as
entertaining and engaging
(survey, focus group)
 Degree of motivation to
interact with the company
(survey, focus group)
 Degree of motivation to
visit ‘The Feed’ (survey,
focus group)
 Perception of ‘The Feed’
posts
 Level of motivation to
read through ‘The Feed’
(survey, focus group)
 % of followers actively
engaging with the brand
(social media analytics,
website metrics)
 Number of people using
hashtags introduced in ‘The
Feed’
 % of visitors going to “The
Feed” tab (website metrics)
 Average time spend on site
(website metrics)
 Average time spend reading
“The Feed” posts (website
metrics)
 Number of likes and shares
of ‘The Feed’ content
(website/social media
metrics)
 ‘The Feed’ bounce rate
(website metrics)
Change perception
of Taco Bell’s food
& create food
innovation
 Truthful depiction of products
(heuristic assessment)
 Option to remove/replace
fattening ingredients (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Richness of nutrition
information (heuristic
assessment)
 Depth of nutrition content
(heuristic assessment)
 Ease of use of the nutrition
calculator (heuristic assessment,
usability testing)
 Opportunity to get nutrition data
for customized items (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Opportunity to filter menu based
on allergies/diet (heuristic
assessment, usability testing)
 Detailed information about
ingredients and recipes (heuristic
assessment)
(Based on a website visit):
 Level of trust in the brand
(survey, focus group)
 Perception of products as
unique and innovative
(survey, focus group)
 Perception of food as
fresh and healthy (survey,
focus group)
 Perception of ingredients
as high quality (survey,
focus group)
 Level of interest in new
products (survey, focus
group)
 Degree of interest in
nutrition information
 Perception of nutrition
information presentation
 Sales numbers of vegetarian
products (company metrics)
 % of people purchasing new
innovative products (such as
the breakfast items) (website
metrics)
 Number of people talking
about new products on
social media (social media
analytics)
 Number of people sharing
pictures of their Taco Bell
meal with a positive
comment (social media
analytics)
 % of people checking the
nutrition information
(website metrics)
 % of people using the
nutrition calculator (website
metrics)
 Average time spend on
nutrition information pages
MEASUREMENT TOOLS AND KEY FINDINGS
HEURISTIC ASSESSMENT
I have designed a heuristic assessment tool to evaluate the effectiveness of Taco Bell’s website
based on a set of output KPIs which were identified earlier. The major items to be assessed are
the order and customization capabilities and their supporting functions – store locator, sign-
in/registration, etc.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 31
Taco Bell’s website is being evaluated along with two competitor websites – Chipotle and
Panera Bread. My intention was to continue analyzing the same two competitors from the
benchmarking analysis - Chipotle and McDonalds. However, since McDonalds’ website does not
have the order and pay ahead capabilities, I decided to use Panera Bread instead.
The assessment tool has 10 items and each of them is ranked using a score from 1-5 where 1 is
poor and 5 is excellent. The highest possible total score is 50 points.
Fig. 1 below shows the total score for each website. Taco Bell and Panera got an almost perfect
score of 49 points as both websites demonstrated impeccable functionality and responsiveness.
In contrast, Chipotle’s website had a fair number of flaws and unresponsive fields.
Fig. 1 – Total score
Further, Fig. 2 gives a detailed overview of the individual scores for each of the ten items. While
Taco Bell and Panera Bread had excellent scores for almost all 10 items, Chipotle had less than a
perfect score for more than half of them. The main problem for Chipotle comes from
unresponsive buttons and fields that create a frustrating customer experience. Chipotle’s website
is mobile friendly, i.e. users are able to open and browse the website without significant
difficulties. However, the website is not optimized for mobile devices. As a result, visitors need
to constantly zoom in and out in order to be able to use the website functionality, which once
again leads to an unsatisfactory website experience. The existence of Chipotle mobile app for
online ordering probably made website ordering on mobile less of a priority for the company.
By way of contrast, Taco Bell and Panera have perfectly optimized websites despite the fact that
they have mobile apps with the same functionality.
36
38
40
42
44
46
48
50
Taco Bell Panera Chipotle
Heuristic Assessment
Total Score
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 32
Fig. 2 Detailed overview
The full heuristic assessment tool can be found in Appendix 1 at the end of this document.
SURVEY
The second measurement tool that I employed as part of this communication dashboard project is
an online survey. The purpose of this measurement tool was to evaluate the attitudes and
emotional responses of visitors to Taco Bell’s website. The aforementioned survey was designed
to measure numerous attitudinal KPIs which were previously identified and listed in the KPIs
section of this document.
My goal with this survey was to not only get a general idea of visitors’ attitudes toward the
website, but to also explore their point of view on two specific website sections on which I
focused in my KPI matrix – ‘The Feed’ and the nutrition information section.
The survey comprises 10 questions and eight of them utilize a 5-point positive/negative Likert
scale. All questions use a verbal scale to avoid any ambiguity. Further, one question was a yes/no
question and one was a multiple choice question.
The full survey can be found in Appendix 2.
The majority of people who received the survey are between 17-35 years old which corresponds
very well with Taco Bell’s target audience. The survey was sent to both people from the U.S. and
people who live in Bulgaria. Taco Bell doesn’t have any stores in Bulgaria, but young people are
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Order process
Special offers/Promotions
Customization
Optimization for mobile
Registration/Sign-in
Store locator
Visuals
Nutrition information
Ingredients & Recipes
Engagement & Interaction
Heuristic Assessment
Detailed overview
Chipotle Panera Taco Bell
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 33
generally familiar with the brand thanks to Internet and social media. Sending the survey to this
specific group of people enabled me to get results that were to a great extent unbiased. The
attitudes of Bulgarian respondents resulted exclusively from looking at the website rather than
from personal experiences with the brand and prejudice.
The first couple questions aimed at capturing the general impression that the website produces.
For the vast majority of respondents this was the first visit to the website - 96%, which enabled
me to get a glimpse of visitors’ authentic first impression and reaction to the website.
Over half of them responded that they are “very interested” in further exploring the website.
An almost equal number of people described the website as “very engaging” and “moderately
engaging” and 13% thought it is extremely engaging.
The next couple questions focused on a specific section of the website - ‘The Feed’. People seem
to think that the content of this section is entertaining (59% agree and 29 % strongly agree) and
relevant (59% agree and 29% strongly agree). Further, respondents found that the Taco Bell
brand is not aggressively promoted (42% agree and 33% strongly agree). However, there was not
a distinctive majority of people who were interested in reading future posts.
The following questions focused on the attitudes towards purchase and the responses revealed
that the website is doing a great job in influencing people’s buying decisions. The majority of
people said they were either very likely or extremely likely to order food from Taco Bell based
on a website visit. Also, almost the same number of people indicated a preference toward using
the customization options. Further, around 70% of people chose to order online/via mobile app
versus at the store.
The Nutrition section also ranked high with survey respondents: almost 90% thought nutrition
information for all items is easy to find; 80% said it is well organized and about 84% thought the
nutrition calculator is easy to use.
The last question asked visitors to rank some of the attributes of the website in an attempt to get
more details on what makes it engaging and visually appealing if so.
In terms of visuals, design and overall appearance, the website scored high: around 90% of
visitors thought the website is doing either a good or a very good job.
Same goes for the content of the website (quality and richness of information) with over 80%
answering “good” or “very good”.
The full collection of survey responses can be found in Appendix 3.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 34
ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
ANALYSIS OF RESULTS
As it was brought up before, the heuristic assessment tool was designed to evaluate several KPIs
as they relate to the three communication objectives.
Fig. 3 Taco Bell heuristic assessment detailed overview
1. Promote online sales & increase revenue:
 Design and convenience of the order process
 Ease of customization process
 Optimization of the order process for mobile devices
As shown in Fig. 3, Taco Bell’s website received a perfect score on all the items related to online
sales and revenue. The website has a clean and modern design with only a few major functions
where online ordering is the primary one. It seems like every aspect of this website is designed
with the users’ convenience in mind. This certainly reflects Taco Bell’s belief that “ease is the
new loyalty” (Jennigs, 2015).
Special offers and promotions are prominently displayed on the homepage and upon login.
The customization process blends and works as an extension of the order process. The
customization functionality is intuitive and very interactive utilizing nice visuals to represent
each item that can be added or is part of the original recipe.
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Order process
Special offers/Promotions
Customization
Optimization for mobile
Registration/Sign-in
Store locator
Visuals
Nutrition information
Ingredients & Recipes
Engagement & Interaction
Taco Bell
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 35
The website and specifically the order process are optimized for mobile devices and work
seamlessly.
Further, registration and signing-in are straightforward with only a couple of fields to be
completed. Alternatively, the user has the option to login with a Facebook account, which takes
under 30 seconds if the profile is already connected to that specific mobile device.
When users order online, they pick up their food at their nearest store. This is why the store
locator is an important component in supporting online sales.
The store locator has a central position in the main navigation. It shows the nearest stores based
on a zip code entered by the user. An even quicker way is to let the website access the user’s
current location and show the closest store based on that data.
Additionally, the store locator shows a detailed map, store hours and phone number of all stores
in the user’s area.
2. Engage users and increase loyalty
 Strength of brand identity
 Engagement methods
As part of the second communication objective (user engagement), I chose to evaluate the use of
visuals as a way to support the brand identity of the company. In this regard, Taco Bell got a
perfect score as well.
As it was discussed earlier, the brand employs high-quality visuals that resonate with its target
audience (visuals utilize the so called ‘food selfie’ look). In addition, the colors of the website
reflect the color scheme of the brand – white, black and purple. The website also uses a number
of oversized visuals, which matches the best practices in the industry.
Related to this communication objective is also the only area where Taco Bell did not receive a
perfect score - the availability of engagement methods. While the website lists four different
social media channels, the ways to interact with a company representative are rather limited and
indirect. Users can only submit comments through an online form and select how the brand
responds (email/phone). On the contrary, Panera Bread provides two options for direct customer
support – chat and phone call.
3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation
 Nutrition information
In relation to the last communication objective, Taco Bell does a good job by having a well
organized and detailed nutrition information section. Visitors can use the nutrition calculator to
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 36
estimate the nutrition value of their entire purchase. Alternatively, there is a tab providing full
nutrition information for each separate menu item. The website also offers a nice way for people
with allergies or special diet to find suitable food options. By providing this information and
making it easy to use, Taco Bell enables people to make conscious decisions about their meals.
This approach certainly plays a role in changing the perception of the brand and challenges
obsolete fast food concepts such as not disclosing the list of artificial ingredients on the pretext
that they are a part of the “secret recipe”.
Further, the conducted survey aimed to evaluate the general impressions generated by Taco
Bell’s website, as well as a specific set of attitudes as they relate to the three communication
objectives:
1. Promote online sales & increase revenue:
• Perceived value of ordering online/via mobile
• Degree of motivation to purchase
• Degree of motivation to use customization options
The questions related to the first communication objective aimed to determine if the website
prompts visitors to make a purchase; whether they would prefer online ordering vs. at a store and
how likely they are to use the customization options. The responses to this set of questions
confirmed that the website successfully influences visitors’ desire to purchase Taco Bell products
and strengthens the preference for using customization options and online ordering.
Fig. 4 Survey results as they relate to communication objective # 1
2. Engage users and increase loyalty
• Degree of motivation to follow the brand on social media
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Likeliness of purchase Preference for using
customization
Preference for online
ordering
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 37
• Perception of website as entertaining and engaging
• Degree of motivation to interact with the company
• Perception of ‘The Feed’ posts
The survey indicated inferior performance in relation to the second communication objective.
When asked to evaluate how engaging the website is, only half of the people said it is either very
or extremely engaging and only about 60% said they are interested in further exploring the
content.
Further, an underwhelming number of people showed strong interest in following the brand on
social media (24%).
The next set of questions was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of ‘The Feed’ in terms of
engaging visitors. Despite the fact that the vast majority of respondents thought the content was
entertaining and relevant (87.5%), less than half wanted to see future posts.
3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation
• Perception of nutrition information presentation
Lastly, in connection to the third communication objective, respondents were asked to evaluate
the nutritional information section. Similar to the heuristic assessment, this section ranked high
with survey participants. Over 80% of them said it is well organized and easy to find and use.
RECOMMENDATIONS
As a whole, Taco Bell’s website meets the three communication objectives and their respective
KPIs. However, based on the results of the heuristic assessment and the survey, I have identified
several areas that can benefit from some improvement.
My first recommendation addresses one of the issues that came up during the heuristic
assessment - the lack of ways to get an immediate assistance or feedback from the company. I
would suggest adding a customer service phone number in addition to the online form for
comments and complaints. A quick google search showed that such number already exists, but
cannot be found on Taco Bell’s website. Another valuable addition would be a live chat
functionality which has become an industry standard when it comes to customer service.
If neither of the above suggestions is implemented, one way to improve the current form would
be to add a disclaimer about how long it usually takes the company to respond to customers.
Based on the survey results, I would also recommend that Taco Bell focus more effort on clearly
defining the potential benefits of following the brand on social media. Their current call to action
is “stay connected” which to me as a customer does not sound compelling enough. I believe they
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 38
would be able to attract more users and increase participation by giving a more persuasive reason
for people to engage on social media (promotional codes, sweepstakes, exclusive content, etc.).
After studying Taco Bell’s Facebook page, I noticed that engagement is in fact an issue. The
brand has over 10 million followers, yet less than 1% of them like, comment or share posts. I
also noticed that the posts lack variety in terms of format – most of them utilize a picture with a
caption. As quoted earlier, the company’s CEO emphasizes the importance of participation over
likes and clicks (Niccol & Brandt, 2014), but it seems like Taco Bell struggles to really engage
users. Considering the importance of social media as a part of Taco Bell’s marketing strategy, I
believe dedicated effort should go into generating and maintaining high engagement.
My last recommendation focuses on online ordering. Taco Bell aims to revolutionize the fast
food industry by being one of the first companies to introduce and popularize mobile and online
ordering. Online ordering certainly makes the customer experience fun and more efficient and is
also beneficial for the company as its customization component boosts user spending by 30%
(Jennigs, 2015). I believe, however, that the current version of the website does not make it
immediately clear that online ordering is fundamentally different from ordering at the store. If
Taco Bell wants to drive more people to order online, it has to communicate loud and clear the
advantages of online ordering versus ordering at the store such as skipping the line and being
able to fully customize your meal.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 39
DASHBOARD VISUALS
DASHBOARD VISUAL #1
Rationale
As noted earlier, Taco Bell is interested in driving more people to the website and have them use
the customization options when they make a purchase.
For visual #1 I used three KPIs. Two of them are attitudinal (perception of customization as a
valuable tool and degree of motivation to buy online) and one is behavioral (online sales as
percentage of total sales). As a benchmark I used Panera Bread whose website has identical
functionality.
My choice of KPIs is based on the assumption that if a visitor clearly sees the customization
function as an advantage of online ordering, he will be more inclined to use the website to make
a purchase, which will ultimately boost online sales.
Considering the fact that visitors should go to the store to pick up their food regardless of how
they chose to order, their perception of the customization functionality is an extremely important
factor influencing their buying decision. If they do not see a clear advantage of online ordering,
they will most likely stick with their old habits and order at the store instead.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 40
DASHBOARD VISUAL # 2
Rationale
For the most part Taco Bell’s website is designed to mimic the mobile app (to introduce visitors
to the concept of online ordering and customization and motivate them to make a purchase).
There are only four items in the main navigation and two of them are oriented toward online
sales – ‘Food’ and ‘Locations’. ‘The Feed’ is the only main section of the website that serves
communication objective #2: Engage users & increase loyalty.
For the second dashboard visual, I focused on this specific section of Taco Bell’s website to help
me analyze website engagement. I am using two attitudinal KPIs (perception of content as
relevant and perception of content as entertaining) and one behavioral KPI (‘The Feed’ bounce
rate). The benchmark is the company’s goal for bounce rate value.
Considering the nature of the Taco Bell brand and the age of its target group (18-35 years old),
the content needs to be casual, fun and easy to read. To represent this condition, I am using
‘perception of content as entertaining’ as my first KPI.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 41
In addition, young people usually care about pop culture and current events, so in order to appeal
to visitors, content needs to be relevant. This is why I chose ‘perception of content as relevant’ as
my second KPI.
Further, bounce rate can be interpreted in two ways: 1) percentage of visitors who only see one
page of the website or 2) percentage of visitors who stay on the website for a small amount of
time (Kaushik, 2007, para.8). For the purpose of this analysis, I am using the latter definition. I
would presume that lower bounce rate would mean that visitors are spending time reading
articles or watching videos depending on the piece of content, i.e., they are engaged with the
section.
The main assumption behind Dashboard visual #2: if the content is entertaining and relevant,
visitors will be more likely to stay and read it, thus contributing to overall website engagement.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 42
REFERENCES
Alexa.com. (2015). Site overview: tacobell.com. Retrieved from www.alexa.com
Barnes Reports. (October, 2015). 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food
Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513).[Industry report]. Retrieved from Business
Source Complete
Bounce Rate Demystified. (n.d.). Retrieved from Blogs: Kissmetrics:
https://blog.kissmetrics.com/bounce-rate/
Cao, J. (2015, August 19). Why long scrolling sites have become awesome. Retrieved
from TNW News: http://thenextweb.com/dd/2015/08/19/why-long-scrolling-sites-
have-become-awesome/
Company Overview of Taco Bell Corp. (n.d.). In Bloomberg Business. Retrieved from:
http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapid=4287
79
Deswal, S. (n.d.). VWO. Retrieved from VWO.com: https://vwo.com/blog/larger-product-
images-increase-conversion-rate/
Digiday/Chute. (2015). The State of Industry - Visual Marketing: Scale to Win. Retrieved
from http://digiday.com/chute-soti-download/
Ecommerce best practices 2015: 5 must-know tips to increase your online sales. (2015,
January 10). In wemakewebsites.com. Retrieved from:
http://wemakewebsites.com/blog/ecommerce-best-practices-2015-5-must-know-tips-to-
increase-your-online-sales
Epstein, E. (2014, May 29). Why Taco Bell Went Loco for Snapchat. Retrieved from
Mashable.com: http://mashable.com/2014/05/29/taco-bell-marketing-
strategy/#APT4Ic6CgiqF
Giammona, C. (2015, May 26). Taco Bell Cutting Artificial Flavors to Prove ‘Less Is
Mas’. Retrieved from Bloomberg Business:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-05-26/taco-bell-cutting-artificial-
ingredients-to-prove-less-is-mas-
Jennigs, L. (2015, October 12). Taco Bell debuts new website. Nation's Restaurant
News, pp. 19-20.
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 43
How Loading Time Affects Your Bottom Line. (n.d.). Retrieved from KISSmetrics Blog:
https://blog.kissmetrics.com/loading-time/
Kaushik, A. (August 6, 2007). Standard Metrics Revisited: #3 Bounce Rate. [Web log
comment]. Retrieved from http://www.kaushik.net/avinash/standard-metrics-revisited-3-
bounce-rate/
Lutz, A. (2014, March 28). Taco Bell Made 2 Changes That Transformed The Brand.
Retrieved from Business Insider: http://www.businessinsider.com/taco-bell-
marketing-strategy-2014-3
Macdonald, M. (n.d.). 5 Ecommerce Design Mistakes that Could Be Killing Your Sales.
Retrieved from Shopify.com: https://www.shopify.com/blog/9811290-5-
ecommerce-design-mistakes-that-could-be-killing-your-sales
MarketLine. (January 2012). Fast Food in the United States. [Industry Profile]. Retrived
from MarketLine Advantage Database
Morrison, M. (2014, July 28). In breakfast wars, Taco Bell's boldmarketing pays off with
big sales. Advertising Age, pp. 6-6.
Niccol, B. & Brandt, C. (2014). Taco Bell Goes Loco for Snapchatting Millennials.
(Mashable, Interviewer) [Video file] Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsDdUIQhRSM
Omazic, T. (2014, March ). What Women Want. Retrieved from QSR :
https://www.qsrmagazine.com/consumer-trends/what-women-want
Paine, K. (2011). Measure What Matters . Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. .
Poppick, S. (2015, June 3). Taco Bell in U.S. Will Serve Alcohol for the First Time.
Retrieved from Time.com: http://time.com/money/3908252/taco-bell-alcohol-
beer-wine-chicago/
Prater, D. (2015, October 9). Taco Bell’s New Vegan-Friendly Menu Features Millions of
Meat-Free Options. Retrieved from PETA: http://www.peta.org/living/food/taco-
bell-vegetarian-menu/
Taco Bell. (n.d.-a) In Entrepreneur.com. Retrieved from:
http://www.entrepreneur.com/franchises/tacobell/282858-0.html
Taco Bell. (n.d.-b) In Yum.com. Retrieved from: http://www.yum.com/brands/tb.asp
The QSR 50. (2015, August). Retrieved from:
https://www.qsrmagazine.com/reports/qsr50-2015-top-50-chart
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 44
The Ultimate Ecommerce Guide for Stores in the Food Industry. (2014, February 20).
In Volusion.com. Retrieved from: http://www.volusion.com/ecommerce-
blog/articles/the-ultimate-ecommerce-guide-for-stores-in-the-food-industry/
Vaughan, P. (2014, October 30). The Ultimate Cheat Sheet for Creating Social Media
Buttons. Retrieved from: http://blog.hubspot.com/blog/tabid/6307/bid/29544/The-
Ultimate-Cheat-Sheet-for-Creating-Social-Media-Buttons.aspx
Wong, V. (2013, May 29). How Fast-Food Eaters Split Along Ethnic Lines. Retrieved
from: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2013-05-29/how-fast-food-eaters-
split-along-ethnic-lines
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 45
APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Heuristic assessment
Item Taco Bell Chipotle Panera Bread
The order process is
clear and intuitive
5 3.5
(Upon ordering the
system requires a
name for the order
and the typing field is
not always
responsive.)
5
The website
provides visitors
with special
offers/promotional
prices
5 4
(buried at the
bottom, very small
font, offers available
after joining mobile
list)
5
The customization
function is easy to
use and allows a full
modification of the
order.
5 5 5
The order process is
fully optimized for
mobile devices.
5 3
(mobile-friendly, but
not specifically
optimized; some
buttons are not
responsive)
5
Registration/signing-
in is straightforward
and effortless
5 4
(a lot of information
needed which makes
registration slower)
4
(a lot of information
needed which makes
registration slower)
The ‘locations’
feature works well
and includes a map,
store hours and
contact information.
5 4
(doesn’t have a map,
links out to Google
maps)
5
The website has
strong, high-quality
visuals that support
the brand identity.
5 5 5
The website
provides detailed
5 4 5
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 46
nutrition
information.
(Allergen info table is
very confusing)
The website
provides
information about
ingredients and
recipes.
5 5 5
Visitors have a
variety of options to
interact and engage
with the company.
4 4 5
Total: 49 41.5 49
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 47
Appendix 2: Survey questions
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 48
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 49
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 50
Appendix 3: Survey Results
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 51
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 52
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 53
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 54
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 55
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 56
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 57
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 58
Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 59

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysis
Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysisMaruti suzuki-balansheet-analysis
Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysisharishganigar
 
Taco Bell
Taco BellTaco Bell
Taco Bell
msq2004
 
Investment Analysis Final Project
Investment Analysis  Final ProjectInvestment Analysis  Final Project
Investment Analysis Final Project
nroopraj24
 
investment analysis and portfolio management
investment analysis and portfolio management investment analysis and portfolio management
investment analysis and portfolio management
AIMIT, St Aloysius College, Mangalore
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysis
Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysisMaruti suzuki-balansheet-analysis
Maruti suzuki-balansheet-analysis
 
Taco Bell
Taco BellTaco Bell
Taco Bell
 
Taco bell - MIS case
Taco bell - MIS caseTaco bell - MIS case
Taco bell - MIS case
 
Investment Analysis Final Project
Investment Analysis  Final ProjectInvestment Analysis  Final Project
Investment Analysis Final Project
 
Investment analysis
Investment analysisInvestment analysis
Investment analysis
 
investment analysis and portfolio management
investment analysis and portfolio management investment analysis and portfolio management
investment analysis and portfolio management
 

Similar to Taco bell cdp_bozhura_angelova (final)

Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.comPopularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
수정 윤
 
SEO Website Analysis
SEO Website AnalysisSEO Website Analysis
SEO Website Analysis
Jonathan Baker
 
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPER
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPERJ.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPER
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPERKing Gil Reyes
 
Technology Survey and Design
Technology Survey and DesignTechnology Survey and Design
Technology Survey and DesignMilind Gokhale
 
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy StepsYouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
Page 1 Solutions
 
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube ChannelHow to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
Brad Sage
 
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube ChannelHow to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
Brad Sage
 
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your ContentChapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
TAG Marketing
 
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
echolocs
 
WebSite Audit_Nature's path
WebSite Audit_Nature's pathWebSite Audit_Nature's path
WebSite Audit_Nature's pathAnya Ustinova
 
Analysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
Analysis of Website Popularity and TrafficAnalysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
Analysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
Abbie Cook
 
Localbanya Clone Script
Localbanya Clone ScriptLocalbanya Clone Script
Localbanya Clone Script
wowtech
 
Web basics 101
Web basics 101Web basics 101
Web basics 101tlcjohnson
 
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of Competitor
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of CompetitorPart I_Domain Analysis Report of Competitor
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of CompetitorDezirae N. Brown
 
Ion content marketing_ideabook
Ion content marketing_ideabookIon content marketing_ideabook
Ion content marketing_ideabook
Daniel Howard
 
Tbadv492actual good version
Tbadv492actual good versionTbadv492actual good version
Tbadv492actual good versionZach Chmill
 
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
Jeanie Guthrie Hornung
 
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl ResultsMerkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
Avocados From Mexico
 

Similar to Taco bell cdp_bozhura_angelova (final) (20)

Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.comPopularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
Popularity & traffic for muckbootcompany.com
 
SEO Website Analysis
SEO Website AnalysisSEO Website Analysis
SEO Website Analysis
 
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPER
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPERJ.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPER
J.CO DONUTS & COFFEE FINAL PAPER
 
Technology Survey and Design
Technology Survey and DesignTechnology Survey and Design
Technology Survey and Design
 
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy StepsYouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
YouTube 101: How to Master Video Marketing in 10 Easy Steps
 
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube ChannelHow to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
 
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube ChannelHow to Set Up a YouTube Channel
How to Set Up a YouTube Channel
 
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your ContentChapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
Chapter 2: Set Up & Procedures for Your Content
 
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
Can You Generate Free Traffic Using These Stumbledupon Tips?
 
WebSite Audit_Nature's path
WebSite Audit_Nature's pathWebSite Audit_Nature's path
WebSite Audit_Nature's path
 
Analysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
Analysis of Website Popularity and TrafficAnalysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
Analysis of Website Popularity and Traffic
 
Shoptopp
ShoptoppShoptopp
Shoptopp
 
Localbanya Clone Script
Localbanya Clone ScriptLocalbanya Clone Script
Localbanya Clone Script
 
EKB business Dec 16
EKB business Dec 16EKB business Dec 16
EKB business Dec 16
 
Web basics 101
Web basics 101Web basics 101
Web basics 101
 
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of Competitor
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of CompetitorPart I_Domain Analysis Report of Competitor
Part I_Domain Analysis Report of Competitor
 
Ion content marketing_ideabook
Ion content marketing_ideabookIon content marketing_ideabook
Ion content marketing_ideabook
 
Tbadv492actual good version
Tbadv492actual good versionTbadv492actual good version
Tbadv492actual good version
 
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
11 Killer Lead Generation Tips For Professional Services Firms
 
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl ResultsMerkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
Merkle 2016 Digital Bowl Results
 

Recently uploaded

Marketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
Marketing Management Notes Philip KotlerMarketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
Marketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
LaveenaShanker
 
My Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
My Personal Brand Exploration by MarianoMy Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
My Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
marianooscos
 
5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co
5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co
Winning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis Yu
Winning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis YuWinning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis Yu
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CROAI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
VWO
 
Digital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on How
Digital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on HowDigital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on How
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel BussiusYour Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter WeltmanGenerative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdfOffissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
offisadizayn
 
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docxDMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
TravisMalana
 
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
Search Engine Marketing - Competitor and Keyword research
Search Engine Marketing  - Competitor and Keyword researchSearch Engine Marketing  - Competitor and Keyword research
Search Engine Marketing - Competitor and Keyword research
ETMARK ACADEMY
 
SEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
SEO as the Backbone of Digital MarketingSEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
SEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
Felipe Bazon
 
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny LeibrandtThe New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
Pascal Fintoni
 
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
levuag
 
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel LeminTurn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
DigiMarCon - Digital Marketing, Media and Advertising Conferences & Exhibitions
 
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine OptimizationA Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
Brand Highlighters
 
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital CommerceThe What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
PushON Ltd
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Marketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
Marketing Management Notes Philip KotlerMarketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
Marketing Management Notes Philip Kotler
 
My Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
My Personal Brand Exploration by MarianoMy Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
My Personal Brand Exploration by Mariano
 
5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co
5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co
5 Big Bets for 2024 - Jamie A. Lee, Stripes Co
 
Winning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis Yu
Winning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis YuWinning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis Yu
Winning local SEO in the Age of AI - Dennis Yu
 
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CROAI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
AI-Powered Personalization: Principles, Use Cases, and Its Impact on CRO
 
Digital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on How
Digital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on HowDigital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on How
Digital Marketing Trends - Experts Insights on How
 
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel BussiusYour Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing - Daniel Bussius
 
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter WeltmanGenerative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
Generative AI - Unleash Creative Opportunity - Peter Weltman
 
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
Your Path to Profits - The Game-Changing Power of a Marketing OS for Your Bus...
 
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdfOffissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
Offissa Dizayn - Otel, Kafe, Restoran Kataloqu_240603_011042.pdf
 
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docxDMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
DMF Portfolio Piece Smart Goals - Artist Management.docx
 
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
10 Videos Any Business Can Make Right Now! - Shelly Nathan
 
Search Engine Marketing - Competitor and Keyword research
Search Engine Marketing  - Competitor and Keyword researchSearch Engine Marketing  - Competitor and Keyword research
Search Engine Marketing - Competitor and Keyword research
 
SEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
SEO as the Backbone of Digital MarketingSEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
SEO as the Backbone of Digital Marketing
 
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny LeibrandtThe New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
The New Era Of SEO - How AI Has Changed SEO Forever - Danny Leibrandt
 
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
The Old Oak - Press Kit - Cannes Film Festival 2023
 
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
20221005110010_633d63baa84f6_learn___week_3_ch._5.pdf
 
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel LeminTurn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
Turn Digital Reputation Threats into Offense Tactics - Daniel Lemin
 
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine OptimizationA Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
A Guide to UK Top Search Engine Optimization
 
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital CommerceThe What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
The What, Why & How of 3D and AR in Digital Commerce
 

Taco bell cdp_bozhura_angelova (final)

  • 1. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 2015 Taco Bell Website Assessment COMMUNICATION DASHBOARD PROJECT Northeastern University CMN 6910: Organizational Communication Assessment Bozhura Angelova December 19, 2015
  • 2. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Communication vehicle and company information ....................................................... 2 Marketing and Communications Objectives ............................................................... 10 Marketing strategy & organizational environment ...................................................... 11 Benchmarks ............................................................................................................... 21 Best practices............................................................................................................. 27 KPIs............................................................................................................................ 29 Measurement Tools and Key Findings....................................................................... 30 Analysis and Recommendations ................................................................................ 34 Dashboard visuals...................................................................................................... 39 References................................................................................................................. 42 Appendices ................................................................................................................ 45
  • 3. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 2 COMMUNICATION VEHICLE AND COMPANY INFORMATION ABOUT THE ORGANIZATION After leaving the Marines at 23, Glen Bell opened a hot dog stand in his home town - San Bernardino, California. He was not interested however in selling the typical fast food staples like burgers and hot dogs, so he began selling tacos for 19 cents from a side window of his hot dog stand. The tacos were very well received, so he started opening Taco Tia stands where tacos were the main menu item. (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-a, para. 1) In 1962, Bell sold the Taco Tia brand to his partners and opened the first Taco Bell in Downey, California. Franchising began two years later. (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-a, para. 1) Since its founding, Taco Bell has become the second most profitable brand in the U.S. and one of the leading Mexican-style fast food chains in the country (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-b, para.1 ). The Yum!Brands subsidiary offers made to order and customizable tacos, burritos, quesadillas, gorditas, nachos, chalupas, beverages, desserts and sides, and other specialty items (“Company Overview”, n.d., para. 1). The restaurant serves more than 36 million customers at its nearly 6,000 American locations. Taco Bell primarily operates in the U.S. market, but Yum!Brands is planning to make the company its third global brand (along with KFC and Pizza Hut). Outside of the U.S., there are currently around 300 Taco Bell restaurants in 20 countries. In 2014, Taco Bell ranked #4 on the 50 QSR (Quick Service Restaurants) list and in 2013 it was named Ad Age “Marketer of the Year” for reaching over $1 billion in sales of Doritos® Locos Tacos (“Taco Bell”, n.d.-b, para. 3). COMMUNICATION VEHICLE In 2015, Taco Bell introduced its redesigned website which expands “the availability of order and pay ahead capabilities and customization options which were previously available only via the brand’s mobile app” (Jennigs, 2015). In addition to using the traditional www.tacobell.com, users can now reach the website by simply typing ‘ta.co.’ in their browser address bar, which according to company officials makes the website fun and easier to access (Jennigs, 2015). Taco Bell’s VP for digital innovation and on demand, Tressie Lieberman, says the brand’s new URL is supposed to remind of an emoji in its simplicity. The brand aims to create simple and pain-free experience as they believe that “ease is the new loyalty” (Jennigs, 2015). Taco Bell’s new website gives the full brand experience – users can find nearby Taco Bell locations, place and customize an order, check its nutritional value and even buy Taco Bell gear. The website also provides opportunities to engage with the brand through their “The Feed” tab and social media buttons which are located at the bottom of almost every page.
  • 4. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 3 HOMEPAGE STRUCTURE 1. Top section – This section of the website allows visitors to search Taco Bell’s menu, login or create a user profile and review their order by clicking the shopping cart button. 2. Side navigation – This is the main website navigation where users can browse the menu, order food, find Taco Bell locations and learn about the company and its initiatives. - The ‘Food’ menu item opens up a sub navigation allowing users to look up different food categories.
  • 5. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 4 - ‘Locations’ opens a map that lets visitors find their nearest Taco Bell by typing a zip code or using their current location. - ‘The Feed’ provides curated content and blog posts that appear to be an entertaining and casual way to “start a conversation” with the audience. - ‘More’ opens up a submenu that allows users to access Taco Bell’s fan store website (http://www.livemasstore.com/storefrontB2CWEB/), Taco Bell’s career website (http://jobs.tacobell.com/), nutrition information (letter from the company and their registered dietician, nutrition calculator, full nutrition info, allergen info, ingredient statements & FAQs), company information and initiatives (history, news, careers, franchise). From the ‘More’ tab users can also register and use gift cards and contact the company with comments and suggestions.
  • 6. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 5 3, 4 & 5 Main body 3. Taco Bell’s website is designed mostly as a one-page, infinite scrolling website – currently the most functional design for mobile and small screen browsing (Cao, 2015). The home page provides a quick glimpse of some highlighted sections of the website. There is very little text and a lot of visuals. Taco Bell’s homepage currently includes a large picture (promoted food item) with a button for quick ordering. Clicking the button opens up a page that allows the visitor to fully customize the product and also read through a short entertaining intro formatted as a blog post. As we scroll down the main body of the homepage we see an oversized animated image (GIF) and the title of a blog post, which also links to the full text of the post (this specific post is also part of ‘The Feed’). 4. This section of the homepage provides a quick overview of the newest products and offers available to registered visitors plus a quick link to the entire menu.
  • 7. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 6 5. ‘The Feed’ – This part of the home page offers a preview of all the short posts published by Taco Bell under ‘The Feed’ tab. There is one highlighted post that has a prominent position at the top. The name of the section is a clever word play combining ‘feed’ as the act of giving food and feed as the ‘news feed’ on social networking sites.
  • 8. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 7 6. Social media follow buttons with a call for action – Stay connected - As Vaughan (2014) says, these buttons are great for businesses to promote their presence on various social networking sites and gain new fans/followers. 7. Bottom navigation pane – This navigation panel leads to the same pages that are available through the ‘More’ button in the main side navigation. Providing access to the same page from several different places instead of just one specific place makes it easier and quicker to find the desired information. 8. Additional sub navigation – this pane includes more specialized information such as details about Taco Bell’s ads, legal notices, privacy policy and terms of use. Since this information is most likely not something that the general population would read, this pane is appropriately located at the very bottom of the home page. SHOPPING EXPERIENCE The users can order on Taco Bell’s website several different ways. They can search for a specific food item by typing its name in the search bar at the top. Simply clicking in the search field opens a list of shortcuts to the most popular categories on the menu: tacos, burritos, breakfast, combos, etc. The second way to order is via the main website navigation. Clicking on ‘Food’ leads the user to the menu, while the button expands to show a list of the different food categories for easy access. Alternatelively the user can browse through all of them by simply scrolling down.
  • 9. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 8 There is also more than one way to customize a product and order. Users can click on the ‘customize’ button under each item to modify the product or buy it as it is by clicking the shopping cart. Alternatively, users can click on the picture of the desired item and they are taken to a separate page where they can fully customize the product by adding ‘tasty upgrades’ or changing what is
  • 10. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 9 included by default. Once they have finalized the item, they can add it to the order by clicking the bright pink button. The order can be reviewed in the shopping cart at the top right. The next steps include putting a desired payment method and selecting a pick-up location. As a whole, ordering is very straightforward and easy thanks to the intuitive design and responsiveness of the website. ENGAGING THE VISITOR The modern design, responsiveness and freshness of Taco Bell’s website fully resonates with their target audience of young people – mostly teenagers and millennials. The first thing that we see as we visit Taco Bell’s website is that it is extremely visual. According to a Digiday study, 95% of marketers find visual content to be much more effective than text and almost 10% of them believe it is 10 times more effective (The State of Industry - Visual Marketing: Scale to Win, 2015). When we browse through the food menu, we notice something interesting: all food items pictures are formatted as if someone took a picture of their meal and shared it on social media – something very typical for millennials. At the same time, the pictures are high-quality and professionally taken so that the food looks as tempting as possible.
  • 11. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 10 In the few text sections, the language is carefully chosen to sound casual and fun, yet intelligent. When visitors click on some of the food items on the menu, they are taken to a page focused on that specific item which allows customization, but also includes a short description of the product. The description sounds more like a story rather than an advertising message. The text does not focus as much on the product and its ingredients, but mostly on the emotions and thoughts that the product can evoke in the audience. Description of Boss Nachos Source: www.tacobell.com “The Feed” tab provides curated content and blog posts and most of them are focused on pop culture and trending topics and involve Taco Bell in a subtle and unobtrusive way. For example, one of the newest posts focusses on the recent introduction of the Taco emoji and the post features a lot of social media messages posted by real people which makes it sound like a story, casual article or a blog post. In addition, a prominent section of the ‘Company’ page is named ‘Taco Bell gives back’ and it is focused on the company’s charitable work. MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS OBJECTIVES 1. Promote online sales & increase revenue One of Taco Bell’s key objectives is to increase online sales and overall revenue. Their website is generally focused on providing a quick and painless way to order, customize your meal and avoid waiting in line. According to Jennings (2015), nearly 5 million people visit Taco Bell’s website each month. The new and improved online platform aims to mimic the elevated experience of Taco Bell’s mobile app. Taco Bell was the first company to introduce a mobile app with order and pay-ahead features in 2014 which to date was downloaded by 3.7 million people. The feedback from customers has
  • 12. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 11 been overwhelmingly positive: they love skipping the line and the customization options increased average spending by 30% (Jennigs, 2015). 2. Engage users and increase loyalty Despite the decrease in customer spending and signs of saturation, investment in the fast food industry remains high with new stores opening across the sector. The convenience of fast food makes it more important to the customer than a simple source of food, but what really drives customer loyalty is the investment in brand building (MarketLine Industry Profile: Fast Food in the United States, January 2012). When it comes to rising above the competition relationship to customers plays an incredibly important role. According to Paine (2011) companies who have good relationships with their clients are more likely to be forgiven when they make a mistake. Also, companies who listen and tend to their customers’ needs are the one to prosper and rise above the competition. (p.5) 3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation With today’s increasing focus on healthy lifestyle and wellbeing, fast food chains are struggling to find a way to capitalize on this trend. The endless customization options including fresh and vegetarian choices available through their website and mobile app is enabling Taco Bell to attract this new health-conscious crowd and change the perception of the brand. MARKETING STRATEGY & ORGANIZATIONAL ENVIRONMENT MARKETPLACE The fast food market in the U.S. accounts for 32.5% of the global fast food market value and has been steadily growing since 2009. The market volume is expected to reach 52.4 billion transactions by the end of 2016 (multiple purchases made during the same visit are counted as one transaction) with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of nearly 3% for the 2011-2016 period (MarketLine, 2012, p.10-12). In 2016, the fast food market value is expected to reach $93,600.3 million - an increase of almost 14% since 2011 (MarketLine, 2012). In 2011, the restaurant-QSR segment was one of the most profitable with total revenues of nearly $70 billion, which accounts for almost 80% of the market’s overall value (MarketLine, 2012). The tables below illustrate the development in terms of industry ratios, number of establishments and industry sales for the period 2013-2017.
  • 13. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 12 Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513) Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513) Source: 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513) COMPETITION The fast food market is highly competitive with a rather low concentration, apart from the burger segment which is ruled by Burger King and McDonalds (MarketLine, 2012). There are moderately low barriers to entry, as the U.S. fast food market does not require large capital outlay and major companies can reduce the cost of expanding by utilizing the franchise model (MarketLine, 2012). New entrants could expect retaliation by existing players (such as the launch of a price war), especially in more concentrated segments (MarketLine, 2012).
  • 14. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 13 In any case, the considerable brand strength of the major chains should not be underestimated and it may diminish much of the effect of low switching costs (MarketLine, 2012). “Price competition is prevalent amongst industry players, especially between value meals. In particular, the value meals within the $1-$2 range are a reaction to shifting consumer trends and a larger focus on competition amongst industry players. This form of price dumping has become particularly prevalent as a result of a fragile wider economic environment. “(MarketLine, 2012, p.16) As a whole, brand power forms the greatest competition in the fast food market, with McDonalds spending hundreds of millions of dollars on global advertising for example (MarketLine, 2012). MARKETING STRATEGY Yum!Brands, Taco Bell’s parent company, is one of the major players in the fast food industry and Taco Bell is its most profitable brand in the U.S. Taco Bell’s current marketing strategy is focused on changing the perception of food and promoting the concept of food as experience (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 01:13-01:20). The company’s strong marketing team which is known for some of the best lines in the business (‘run for the border’; ‘yo quiero Taco Bell’ and ‘think outside the bun’) does not hold on to the past. Instead, they pay attention to customers’ evolving taste and preferences and respond accordingly. (Niccol & Brandt, 2014) As a result Taco Bell is quickly turning into a social media sensation despite its rather unfavorable reputation from the recent past. (Lutz, 2014). For instance, Taco Bell still uses television as part of their marketing mix, but they also realize that today’s millennial consumers need to be engaged and talked to, so the brand utilized new channels such as Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Vine, etc. (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 01:44- 02:15). As a consequence, Taco Bell has 10 million followers on Facebook, 1 million followers on Twitter and they are the number one food brand on Instagram. Further, with their newly established Snapchat presence, they helped define how brands are supposed to be using this channel (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 02:54-03:04). However, engagement rather than mere numbers is what matters to Taco Bell’s executives: ‘It’s not just about likes or clicks… What I really like to see is do people co-create off this? Do they repeat the story?” (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 03:20-03:32) One of the biggest advantages of social media for marketers according to Taco Bell’s senior management is that it enables companies to get real-time, unfiltered reactions from customers as opposed to the past when the only indicators were the sales numbers or consumer research studies (Niccol & Brandt, 2014, 04:02-04:15). Along with the changes in its marketing strategy and approach, Taco Bell implemented changes in other major aspects of the business (Lutz, 2014). First, the brand revamped its menu – in 2012, they introduced Doritos Locos Tacos, which turned out to be a major success (1 billion units sold in the first year). The company also revealed a healthier ‘fresco’ menu as a response to the shift to healthier lifestyle (Lutz, 2014).
  • 15. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 14 In 2014, Taco Bell went on to reinvent breakfast. Not only did the company launch unusual items such as the waffle taco, the biscuit taco and the A.M. crunch wrap (bacon, cheese, eggs and hash brown all in one place), they went after McDonalds with a hard-hitting marketing campaign. The ad featured real people named Ronald McDonald trying the new morning items and announcing their newly found love for Taco Bell’s breakfast (Morrison, 2014). This proved to be a successful step as Yum!Brands second quarter earnings showed that breakfast was responsible for 7% of Taco Bell’s sales in the quarter and was expected to add between $70,000 and $120,000 in annual sales per restaurant (Morrison, 2014). Moreover, the company improved the quality of its ingredients. According to Brandt, Taco Bell now uses higher quality beef and rice and prepares a real pico de gallo, which had a big impact on the bottom line – the brand’s sales rose by 5% in 2013 (Lutz, 2014). To a great extent, Taco Bell’s success is connected to adequately responding to trends. For example, in response to millennials’ love for snacking Taco Bell started ‘Happier Hour’, which offers deals on Loaded Grillers and drinks, as well as ‘FourthMeal’, a sampling of Taco Bell menu items (Epstein, 2014). Earlier in 2015, Taco Bell announced their plan to start serving alcohol in selected locations as part of their rebranding efforts. The first U.S. based Taco Bell restaurant to serve beer, wine and cocktails is in Chicago and will be similar to their existing upscale locations in the U.K., Seoul and Tokyo (Poppick, 2015). Unlike other fast food companies, Taco Bell successfully tends to the needs of the vegan/vegetarian community as well. The brand offers a 13-item vegetarian menu “that has been certified meat-free by the American Vegetarian Association (AVA)” (Prater, 2015, para. 2). Taco Bell has 35 certified vegetarian ingredients on its menu and 26 of them are vegan. In a statement, Brian Niccol, Taco Bell’s CEO, announced the brand’s plans to start paying more attention to vegetarian items and to demonstrate the brand’s commitment to “deliver food that fits the customers’ evolving lifestyles” (Prater, 2015, para. 3). In an interview from 2015, Brian Niccol also said that Taco Bell is working to eliminate artificial colors, high-fructose corn syrup and trans fats from 95% of its menu (Giammona, 2015). AUDIENCE PROFILE: Source: Alexa.com
  • 16. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 15 According to data from Alexa.com (2015), visitors seem engaged with Taco Bell’s website. The bounce rate is comparatively low and the time spent on the website is well above the average (Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). From this data, we can assume that the website is easy to use and navigate and visitors seem to be finding what they are looking for. Source: Alexa.com Alexa.com (2015) indicates that female visitors are almost twice as much as male vistors and men are generally underrepresented on Taco Bell’s website. According to QSR Magazine (2014) women are one of the most powerful economic forces in the world. They represent 51% of the U.S. population, possess as much as $7 trillion in purchasing power and are responsible for 85% of consumer spending. The article further maintans that the rise of healthy eating and the increase in women’s purchasing power are interconnected. Women typically care about fresh, quality ingredients as well as customization options (Omazic, 2014). These findings seem to reflect Taco Bell’s new concept, which may be an explanation of the growing number of female visitors on their website. The most represented age groups are 18-24 and 25-34 which shows that Taco Bells millenial- focused marketing is paying off. However, we notice that all age groups are well represented and are almost reaching the internet average point.
  • 17. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 16 Visitors with children are underrepresented, which makes sense as most of Taco Bell’s customers are teenagers, students or young professionals. Source: Alexa.com The educational profile of visitors is equally distributed between those with some college education and those holding a college degree. This data also corresponds with Taco Bell’s target group. Source: Alexa.com
  • 18. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 17 Source: Alexa.com In terms of visitors’ income, we see that all income levels are well represented. The most active group of visitors are the ones making between $30K-$60K a year. Similar to all fast food restaurants, Taco Bell offers food items starting at $1 targeted at people with lower income. At the same time, visitors who use the customization options may end up paying $6-$7 per item. This array of prices may be a possible explanation of the wide range of income levels represented. As far as ethnicity goes, we can see a very strong preference from African Americans and Caucasians toward Taco Bell – about twice the internet average. Taco Bell offers an Americanized Mexican food. This may explain the lack of more Hispanics as they might prefer more authentic Mexican cuisine. While we still see some Hispanic visitors on Taco Bell’s website, Asian, African and Middle Eastern nationals are extremely underrepresented. According to Wong (2013), ethnicity is the strongest predictor of taste when it comes to fast food. To a certain extent, the ethnic variation can result from the geographic concentration of fast food chains in a specific area. Based on that, we can assume that many Taco Bell restaurants might be located in areas where most of the population is African American or Caucasian. In addition, the article reveals that another reason could lie in marketing targeted specifically to reach certain ethnicity groups (Wong, 2013). Taco Bell’s marketing is mostly age-focused, so this might explain the lack of diversity in terms of ethnicity. AUDIENCE PROFILE COMPARISON Pain (2011) advises to benchmark against two or three competitors: “a stretch goal, a peer company, and an underdog (…).” (p.37) For the sake of this analysis, McDonalds could play the role of a stretch goal and Chipotle could be seen as the underdog.
  • 19. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 18 In 2014, McDonalds had nearly three times more locations than Taco Bell (≈15,000) and almost five times more sales (nearly $35 billion) (The QSR 50, 2015). On the other hand, Chipotlle Mexican Grill is considerably smaller with only 1,755 locations and $4 billion in sales compared to Taco Bell’s nearly 6,000 restaurants and $8 billion in sales (The QSR 50, 2015). Source: Alexa.com
  • 20. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 19 Source: Alexa.com The first difference we can see is in the educational level of visitors: most of McDonalds’ visitors have some or no college education, other educational levels (graduate school and college) are underrepresented. In terms of age, McDonalds has a wider range of overrepresented visitors where 45-54, 55-64 and 65+ are the most active groups (above the internet average), as opposed to Taco Bell’s audience that is mosly between 18 and 35 years old. In terms of income the metrics look rather identical, however McDonalds’ most active group is $60K-$100K which correlates with the average age of McDonalds website visitors. McDonalds’ visitors with children and without children are equally distribited whereas in Taco Bell’s case people without children prevail. Ethnicity data is also very similar, with African Americans and Caucasians being the most frequest visitors.
  • 21. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 20 Source: Alexa.com When we compare Taco Bell and Chipotle, the first difference is in the gender section. Chipotle is visited by an overwhelming number of females – possible reason is the perception of the brand as all natural and higher quality than Taco Bell. The age section looks similar with the exception that Chipotle also attracts a large amount of people between 35-44 years of age. Chipotle has an almost equal distribution of people with and without children with a slight majority of people with no children. In terms of education level, Chipotle attracts a vast number of people with college degree which corresponds with the average age of visitors. Again, most likely connected to age, the income level of Chipotle visitors is higher: people with income between $60K and $100K+ are overrepresented. On a side note, Chipotle doesn’t have any dollar options and most items are over $6.
  • 22. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 21 As far as ethnicity goes, there is one significant difference – Hispanics are overrepresented at Chipotle’s website. A possible explanation might be the quality of the food and its authenticity. Aside from Caucasians and African Americans, other ethnicity groups are extremely underrepresented similarly to McDonalds and Taco Bell. BENCHMARKS INTERNAL BENCHMARKS “A key point to remember about any evaluation program is that measurement is a comparative tool; to decide if you are successful you compare your results to something else.” (Paine, 2011, p.37) According to Paine (2011), comparing a company to its past performance is one of the most effective benchmarks. She advises against simply choosing a random date in the past and recommends to select a benchmark that is related to a significant event. (p.37) To measure Taco Bell’s performance, I think it is important to analyze several key indicators before and after two significant events for the company – the website redesign in 2015 and the lauch of its mobile app in 2014. Thus, it will be interesting to compare financial results in 2013 vs. 2015. Some of the indicators we can evaluate are: Sales & Revenue:  Total sales in 2013/Total sales in 2015  Sales made through the mobile app to date  Sales made through the website to date  Most popular products in 2013/Most popular products in 2015  Average value of customers’ orders 2013 vs. 2015  Cost of customer aquisition in 2013 vs. 2015 Engagement & Awareness  How many followers on social media in 2013/How many followers in 2015  How visitors find us on social media  Most popular content on website/Facebook/Instagram/Twitter/etc. – assess all different channels  How far into the website visitors are going in 2015 vs. 2013  How many user profiles created on website/mobile app  Average time spent on website in 2013/Average time spent on website in 2015  Daily page views (average) in 2013/Daily page views (average) in 2015  Unique website visitors per day in 2013 (average)/ Unique website visitors per day in 2015 (average)  How many returning visitors 2015 vs. 2013  How many website items shared on social media 2013 vs. 2015
  • 23. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 22 EXTERNAL BENCHMARKS For external benchmarking, I will once again use McDonalds and Chipotle. Taco Bell, Chipotle and McDonalds experience very different traffic levels with McDonalds getting the highest numbers and Taco Bell being the least visited website (in the past 6 months). I chose to look at data from the past 6 months because I wanted it to be relevant to Taco Bell’s new website, which was introduced in September 2015. It is interesting to note that Chipotle’s traffic is closer to that of McDonalds (especially from June to August) even though it is the smallest company of the three.
  • 24. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 23 Source: Alexa.com From this data, it looks like Taco Bell’s visitors are the most engaged – the site has the smallest bounce rate and the largest number of daily page views per visitor. In terms of daily time on site, Chipotle and Taco Bell differ by only 3 seconds. Chipotle and Taco Bell have lower than the average bounce rate and more than the average daily time on site (Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). What is concerning in Taco Bell’s case however is that the bounce rate percentage grew by 19%. On the other hand, Chipotle has less than the average daily page views, which is about 4.6 (Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). While Taco Bell’s and Chipotle’s metrics are very similar, McDonalds seems to be doing a poor job in terms of engagement. The website bounce rate is very high. If we view this kind of website as closest to a retail website, the bounce rate should be between 20%-40% (Bounce Rate Demystified, n.d.). McDonalds should definitely be worried that half of the website visitors leave almost immediately after they open the site. Looking at the bounce rate combined with the traffic data shown above, we can assume that McDonalds gets lot of its website traffic from ads and landing pages.
  • 25. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 24 FUNCTIONALITY COMPARISON Website functions McDonalds Taco Bell Chipotle Clear navigation tabs    Full detailed menu    Nutrition information    Ingredients information    High-quality product images    Food customization options    Order & pay ahead capabilities    Use gift cards    Shop gear    Nearest location map    FAQ section    Search function    Join mailing list    Personal account    Contact us    Shopping cart    Social media buttons    Company information    Calls to action    News    Mobile version Navigation: food, I’m loving it(special offers), careers, locations; join mailing list; connect on social media – website looks completely different on mobile Navigation menu (minimized): food, locations, the feed, more (same as desktop website, the layout is optimized for mobile); mobile app download link; social media buttons; sign up/login; shopping cart The navigation menu is minimized, includes the following tabs: order now, menu, nutrition, company news and information, etc. (same tabs as desktop version included); search bar, locations, email list, social media – looks very similar to desktop website
  • 26. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 25 The three websites have very similar functionality and options. In my opinion, Taco Bell’s and Chipotle’s websites look slightly more modern and clean compared to McDonalds’ website. The location of the main navigation is intuitive on all three sites – McDonalds and Taco Bell have a left navigation and Chipotle has chosen to position the main navigation at the top. All three websites have oversized image on their homepages, which is a good decision according to the best practices research I conducted. The color scheme of all three websites reinforces the brand identity of each company. All three websites clearly communicate to the user the type of services that are provided. All three brands have a detailed and very visual menu, nutrition information and list of ingredients for all products. There were some differences as well: What I found strange on McDonalds website was the location of their search tab, which is kind of buried in the navigation: In contrast to McDonalds and Chipotle, it is harder to locate the FAQ section on Taco Bell’s website. The afore mentioned two sites have placed their FAQ section either as a separate button in the main navigation or under ‘Talk to us’. In order to find Taco Bell’s FAQs on the other hand, users have to scroll all the way down to the footer of the website (which is a fairly long process considering that this is a site with an infinite scrolling feature).
  • 27. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 26 Both Chipotle and Taco Bell offer online ordering. However, Chipotle’s process in not as simple as Taco Bell’s. To order online, Chipotle’s customers have to go to another website by clicking ‘Order now’.
  • 28. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 27 On Taco Bell’s website, customers can order directly from the menu or by clicking on one the promo pictures. The customization process also looks slightly different. Taco Bell’s customization is more visually appealing with pictures of all ingredients whereas Chipotle has only text. Both Chipotle and Taco Bell require a user profile to order, but Taco Bell has the option to sign up with Facebook which makes registration easier and faster. Also, Chipotle’s ‘shopping cart’ doesn’t have a very intuitive position and it isn’t visible at all times during ordering. After one item is added to the order, the shopping cart expands and takes half of the screen. In order to add another item, the user should minimize it which then makes it hard to see. It minimizes to the bottom of the page, instead of to the side for example where there is a lot of empty space. BEST PRACTICES With its new website functionality and newly established focus on online sales, Taco Bell has already entered the e-commerce space. Therefore, I believe it would be interesting to explore the best practices in this field and see how the brand’s website measures up to ecommerce standards. 1. Design According to Volusion (2014), the look of the website is the first important thing that gets customers excited, especially for food-related ecommerce sites.
  • 29. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 28 Marketers are advised to use large, professionally taken photos of their products. Stock photography is not recommended, as differentiation and uniqueness is key in this business (Volusion, 2014). Images should have a central position on the homepage to catch the eye of the customer and attract interest. According to a case study conducted by Visual Website Optimizer (n.d.) the increase in picture size may increase sales by 9.46% (Deswal, n.d) However, the visual aspect of the website doesn’t end with great pictures. Typography is another detail that should not be underestimated – it can “set the tone of the website (playful, sophisticated, casual) in a subtle, but powerful way”. (Volusion, 2014) Visual hierrarchy is another vital component of superior websites. According to Fitt’s law, human eyes are drawn to larger objects. Therefore, important elements (containing links) should be made large, as it also makes them more clickable (Macdonald, n.d.). One of the most popular design trends of 2014 is the so called ‘flat design’ characterized by clean and simple forms and appearance. This approach can work great with food stores as it suggests a “clean, pure environment” and this is exactly the kind of place, from which people would be inclined to buy food (Volusion, 2014). Another critical component is the shopping cart. Visitors should always be able to see how many items they have in their cart and check out quickly and effortlessly. 2. Content In terms of content, marketers are advised to focus on a “targeted niche” (Volusion, 2014). Keywords like ‘food’ are too broad, thus they are less likely to deliver any benefits for the business. On the other hand, optimizing for specific terms such as “gluten-free”, “fair trade”, “southern cooking” will enable people interested in these topics to find you and learn about your products and organization. Providing original and interesting descriptions of products can further differentiate some brands from the competition. Approaches include telling a story about the product, using bullet points, answering FAQs, etc. (We Make Websites, 2015). Having a blog or “knowledge center” for your products is also a good idea. This way, brands can share recipes, highlight new products, share customers’ reviews and other content that will attract the attention of visitors (Volusion, 2014). 3. Miscellaneous  Short and descriptive URLs work better with SEO and are easy to share  Descriptive page titles  Site speed is critical – research by KISSmetrics (n.d.) shows that slower loading times directly affect sales – 40% of people abandon a website that takes more than 3 seconds to load; 1 second delay in page response results in 7% less conversions and for a website that makes $100,000 a day it may lead to $2.5 Million in lost sales annually  Be imaginative  Use “you” more than “we”  Include strong calls to action (We Make Websites, 2015)
  • 30. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 29 KPIS According to Paine (2011), after we have determined our objectives, target audience and benchmarks, we are ready to “establish the specific criteria of success, or the key performance indicators (…).” (p. 37) In order to find which KPIs would be the most appropriate for Taco Bell’s main marketing and communication objectives, I carefully analyzed the website functionality and tried to determine how it relates to the objectives that I identified previously. Looking closely at each website function enabled me to see its distinctive purpose and the potential attitudes and behaviors that it may evoke. The KPIs listed in the matrix below are divided into three distinctive categories: output, attitudinal and behavioral KPIs and each set of KPIs is linked to a specific marketing objective. The next step in my process was to determine the most appropriate measurement tools to help measure each of these specific indicators. Marketing objective Output KPIs Attitudinal KPIs Behavioral KPIs Promote online sales & increase revenue  Design and convenience of the order process (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Special offers availability (amount, variety, frequency of posting – heuristic assessment)  Variety of products (number of products and product categories – heuristic assessment)  Ease of customization process (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Optimization of the order process for mobile devices (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Relative ease of registration/signing in (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Design and reliability of the location feature (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Accuracy of the ‘use current location’ feature ((heuristic assessment)  Perceived value of ordering online/via mobile  Perceived ease of online ordering (survey, focus group)  Degree of motivation to purchase (survey, focus group)  Level of interest in special offers (survey, focus group)  Degree of motivation to use customization options  Perceived value of customization process (survey, focus group)  Perception of calls to action as persuasive (survey, focus group)  Number of visitors who use special offers (website metrics)  % of visitors who order food (website metrics)  Average value of website purchase (website metrics)  % of visitors who use customization features (website metrics)  % of repeat purchase (website metrics)  % of abandoned shopping carts (website metrics)  Number of profiles created (website metrics)  % of total sales generated online (website and company metrics) Engage users and increase loyalty  Strength of brand identity (visuals & messages) (heuristic assessment)  Variety of engagement methods (heuristic assessment)  Originality of ‘The Feed’ content (heuristic assessment)  Understanding of Taco Bell’s brand (survey, focus group)  Level of interest in Taco Bell (survey, focus group)  Degree of motivation to follow the brand on social media (survey, focus group)  Number of returning visitors (website metrics)  Number of clicks on social media links (website metrics)  Number of new social media followers coming from the website (social media analytics)
  • 31. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 30  Timeliness of content published in ‘The Feed’ (heuristic assessment)  Content mix in ‘The Feed’ (heuristic assessment)  Consistency of posts in ‘The Feed’ (heuristic assessment)  Sharing options for ‘The Feed’ content  Hashtags that enable users to join the conversation on social media  Perception of website as entertaining and engaging (survey, focus group)  Degree of motivation to interact with the company (survey, focus group)  Degree of motivation to visit ‘The Feed’ (survey, focus group)  Perception of ‘The Feed’ posts  Level of motivation to read through ‘The Feed’ (survey, focus group)  % of followers actively engaging with the brand (social media analytics, website metrics)  Number of people using hashtags introduced in ‘The Feed’  % of visitors going to “The Feed” tab (website metrics)  Average time spend on site (website metrics)  Average time spend reading “The Feed” posts (website metrics)  Number of likes and shares of ‘The Feed’ content (website/social media metrics)  ‘The Feed’ bounce rate (website metrics) Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation  Truthful depiction of products (heuristic assessment)  Option to remove/replace fattening ingredients (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Richness of nutrition information (heuristic assessment)  Depth of nutrition content (heuristic assessment)  Ease of use of the nutrition calculator (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Opportunity to get nutrition data for customized items (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Opportunity to filter menu based on allergies/diet (heuristic assessment, usability testing)  Detailed information about ingredients and recipes (heuristic assessment) (Based on a website visit):  Level of trust in the brand (survey, focus group)  Perception of products as unique and innovative (survey, focus group)  Perception of food as fresh and healthy (survey, focus group)  Perception of ingredients as high quality (survey, focus group)  Level of interest in new products (survey, focus group)  Degree of interest in nutrition information  Perception of nutrition information presentation  Sales numbers of vegetarian products (company metrics)  % of people purchasing new innovative products (such as the breakfast items) (website metrics)  Number of people talking about new products on social media (social media analytics)  Number of people sharing pictures of their Taco Bell meal with a positive comment (social media analytics)  % of people checking the nutrition information (website metrics)  % of people using the nutrition calculator (website metrics)  Average time spend on nutrition information pages MEASUREMENT TOOLS AND KEY FINDINGS HEURISTIC ASSESSMENT I have designed a heuristic assessment tool to evaluate the effectiveness of Taco Bell’s website based on a set of output KPIs which were identified earlier. The major items to be assessed are the order and customization capabilities and their supporting functions – store locator, sign- in/registration, etc.
  • 32. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 31 Taco Bell’s website is being evaluated along with two competitor websites – Chipotle and Panera Bread. My intention was to continue analyzing the same two competitors from the benchmarking analysis - Chipotle and McDonalds. However, since McDonalds’ website does not have the order and pay ahead capabilities, I decided to use Panera Bread instead. The assessment tool has 10 items and each of them is ranked using a score from 1-5 where 1 is poor and 5 is excellent. The highest possible total score is 50 points. Fig. 1 below shows the total score for each website. Taco Bell and Panera got an almost perfect score of 49 points as both websites demonstrated impeccable functionality and responsiveness. In contrast, Chipotle’s website had a fair number of flaws and unresponsive fields. Fig. 1 – Total score Further, Fig. 2 gives a detailed overview of the individual scores for each of the ten items. While Taco Bell and Panera Bread had excellent scores for almost all 10 items, Chipotle had less than a perfect score for more than half of them. The main problem for Chipotle comes from unresponsive buttons and fields that create a frustrating customer experience. Chipotle’s website is mobile friendly, i.e. users are able to open and browse the website without significant difficulties. However, the website is not optimized for mobile devices. As a result, visitors need to constantly zoom in and out in order to be able to use the website functionality, which once again leads to an unsatisfactory website experience. The existence of Chipotle mobile app for online ordering probably made website ordering on mobile less of a priority for the company. By way of contrast, Taco Bell and Panera have perfectly optimized websites despite the fact that they have mobile apps with the same functionality. 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 Taco Bell Panera Chipotle Heuristic Assessment Total Score
  • 33. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 32 Fig. 2 Detailed overview The full heuristic assessment tool can be found in Appendix 1 at the end of this document. SURVEY The second measurement tool that I employed as part of this communication dashboard project is an online survey. The purpose of this measurement tool was to evaluate the attitudes and emotional responses of visitors to Taco Bell’s website. The aforementioned survey was designed to measure numerous attitudinal KPIs which were previously identified and listed in the KPIs section of this document. My goal with this survey was to not only get a general idea of visitors’ attitudes toward the website, but to also explore their point of view on two specific website sections on which I focused in my KPI matrix – ‘The Feed’ and the nutrition information section. The survey comprises 10 questions and eight of them utilize a 5-point positive/negative Likert scale. All questions use a verbal scale to avoid any ambiguity. Further, one question was a yes/no question and one was a multiple choice question. The full survey can be found in Appendix 2. The majority of people who received the survey are between 17-35 years old which corresponds very well with Taco Bell’s target audience. The survey was sent to both people from the U.S. and people who live in Bulgaria. Taco Bell doesn’t have any stores in Bulgaria, but young people are 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Order process Special offers/Promotions Customization Optimization for mobile Registration/Sign-in Store locator Visuals Nutrition information Ingredients & Recipes Engagement & Interaction Heuristic Assessment Detailed overview Chipotle Panera Taco Bell
  • 34. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 33 generally familiar with the brand thanks to Internet and social media. Sending the survey to this specific group of people enabled me to get results that were to a great extent unbiased. The attitudes of Bulgarian respondents resulted exclusively from looking at the website rather than from personal experiences with the brand and prejudice. The first couple questions aimed at capturing the general impression that the website produces. For the vast majority of respondents this was the first visit to the website - 96%, which enabled me to get a glimpse of visitors’ authentic first impression and reaction to the website. Over half of them responded that they are “very interested” in further exploring the website. An almost equal number of people described the website as “very engaging” and “moderately engaging” and 13% thought it is extremely engaging. The next couple questions focused on a specific section of the website - ‘The Feed’. People seem to think that the content of this section is entertaining (59% agree and 29 % strongly agree) and relevant (59% agree and 29% strongly agree). Further, respondents found that the Taco Bell brand is not aggressively promoted (42% agree and 33% strongly agree). However, there was not a distinctive majority of people who were interested in reading future posts. The following questions focused on the attitudes towards purchase and the responses revealed that the website is doing a great job in influencing people’s buying decisions. The majority of people said they were either very likely or extremely likely to order food from Taco Bell based on a website visit. Also, almost the same number of people indicated a preference toward using the customization options. Further, around 70% of people chose to order online/via mobile app versus at the store. The Nutrition section also ranked high with survey respondents: almost 90% thought nutrition information for all items is easy to find; 80% said it is well organized and about 84% thought the nutrition calculator is easy to use. The last question asked visitors to rank some of the attributes of the website in an attempt to get more details on what makes it engaging and visually appealing if so. In terms of visuals, design and overall appearance, the website scored high: around 90% of visitors thought the website is doing either a good or a very good job. Same goes for the content of the website (quality and richness of information) with over 80% answering “good” or “very good”. The full collection of survey responses can be found in Appendix 3.
  • 35. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 34 ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ANALYSIS OF RESULTS As it was brought up before, the heuristic assessment tool was designed to evaluate several KPIs as they relate to the three communication objectives. Fig. 3 Taco Bell heuristic assessment detailed overview 1. Promote online sales & increase revenue:  Design and convenience of the order process  Ease of customization process  Optimization of the order process for mobile devices As shown in Fig. 3, Taco Bell’s website received a perfect score on all the items related to online sales and revenue. The website has a clean and modern design with only a few major functions where online ordering is the primary one. It seems like every aspect of this website is designed with the users’ convenience in mind. This certainly reflects Taco Bell’s belief that “ease is the new loyalty” (Jennigs, 2015). Special offers and promotions are prominently displayed on the homepage and upon login. The customization process blends and works as an extension of the order process. The customization functionality is intuitive and very interactive utilizing nice visuals to represent each item that can be added or is part of the original recipe. 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Order process Special offers/Promotions Customization Optimization for mobile Registration/Sign-in Store locator Visuals Nutrition information Ingredients & Recipes Engagement & Interaction Taco Bell
  • 36. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 35 The website and specifically the order process are optimized for mobile devices and work seamlessly. Further, registration and signing-in are straightforward with only a couple of fields to be completed. Alternatively, the user has the option to login with a Facebook account, which takes under 30 seconds if the profile is already connected to that specific mobile device. When users order online, they pick up their food at their nearest store. This is why the store locator is an important component in supporting online sales. The store locator has a central position in the main navigation. It shows the nearest stores based on a zip code entered by the user. An even quicker way is to let the website access the user’s current location and show the closest store based on that data. Additionally, the store locator shows a detailed map, store hours and phone number of all stores in the user’s area. 2. Engage users and increase loyalty  Strength of brand identity  Engagement methods As part of the second communication objective (user engagement), I chose to evaluate the use of visuals as a way to support the brand identity of the company. In this regard, Taco Bell got a perfect score as well. As it was discussed earlier, the brand employs high-quality visuals that resonate with its target audience (visuals utilize the so called ‘food selfie’ look). In addition, the colors of the website reflect the color scheme of the brand – white, black and purple. The website also uses a number of oversized visuals, which matches the best practices in the industry. Related to this communication objective is also the only area where Taco Bell did not receive a perfect score - the availability of engagement methods. While the website lists four different social media channels, the ways to interact with a company representative are rather limited and indirect. Users can only submit comments through an online form and select how the brand responds (email/phone). On the contrary, Panera Bread provides two options for direct customer support – chat and phone call. 3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation  Nutrition information In relation to the last communication objective, Taco Bell does a good job by having a well organized and detailed nutrition information section. Visitors can use the nutrition calculator to
  • 37. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 36 estimate the nutrition value of their entire purchase. Alternatively, there is a tab providing full nutrition information for each separate menu item. The website also offers a nice way for people with allergies or special diet to find suitable food options. By providing this information and making it easy to use, Taco Bell enables people to make conscious decisions about their meals. This approach certainly plays a role in changing the perception of the brand and challenges obsolete fast food concepts such as not disclosing the list of artificial ingredients on the pretext that they are a part of the “secret recipe”. Further, the conducted survey aimed to evaluate the general impressions generated by Taco Bell’s website, as well as a specific set of attitudes as they relate to the three communication objectives: 1. Promote online sales & increase revenue: • Perceived value of ordering online/via mobile • Degree of motivation to purchase • Degree of motivation to use customization options The questions related to the first communication objective aimed to determine if the website prompts visitors to make a purchase; whether they would prefer online ordering vs. at a store and how likely they are to use the customization options. The responses to this set of questions confirmed that the website successfully influences visitors’ desire to purchase Taco Bell products and strengthens the preference for using customization options and online ordering. Fig. 4 Survey results as they relate to communication objective # 1 2. Engage users and increase loyalty • Degree of motivation to follow the brand on social media 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Likeliness of purchase Preference for using customization Preference for online ordering
  • 38. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 37 • Perception of website as entertaining and engaging • Degree of motivation to interact with the company • Perception of ‘The Feed’ posts The survey indicated inferior performance in relation to the second communication objective. When asked to evaluate how engaging the website is, only half of the people said it is either very or extremely engaging and only about 60% said they are interested in further exploring the content. Further, an underwhelming number of people showed strong interest in following the brand on social media (24%). The next set of questions was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of ‘The Feed’ in terms of engaging visitors. Despite the fact that the vast majority of respondents thought the content was entertaining and relevant (87.5%), less than half wanted to see future posts. 3. Change perception of Taco Bell’s food & create food innovation • Perception of nutrition information presentation Lastly, in connection to the third communication objective, respondents were asked to evaluate the nutritional information section. Similar to the heuristic assessment, this section ranked high with survey participants. Over 80% of them said it is well organized and easy to find and use. RECOMMENDATIONS As a whole, Taco Bell’s website meets the three communication objectives and their respective KPIs. However, based on the results of the heuristic assessment and the survey, I have identified several areas that can benefit from some improvement. My first recommendation addresses one of the issues that came up during the heuristic assessment - the lack of ways to get an immediate assistance or feedback from the company. I would suggest adding a customer service phone number in addition to the online form for comments and complaints. A quick google search showed that such number already exists, but cannot be found on Taco Bell’s website. Another valuable addition would be a live chat functionality which has become an industry standard when it comes to customer service. If neither of the above suggestions is implemented, one way to improve the current form would be to add a disclaimer about how long it usually takes the company to respond to customers. Based on the survey results, I would also recommend that Taco Bell focus more effort on clearly defining the potential benefits of following the brand on social media. Their current call to action is “stay connected” which to me as a customer does not sound compelling enough. I believe they
  • 39. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 38 would be able to attract more users and increase participation by giving a more persuasive reason for people to engage on social media (promotional codes, sweepstakes, exclusive content, etc.). After studying Taco Bell’s Facebook page, I noticed that engagement is in fact an issue. The brand has over 10 million followers, yet less than 1% of them like, comment or share posts. I also noticed that the posts lack variety in terms of format – most of them utilize a picture with a caption. As quoted earlier, the company’s CEO emphasizes the importance of participation over likes and clicks (Niccol & Brandt, 2014), but it seems like Taco Bell struggles to really engage users. Considering the importance of social media as a part of Taco Bell’s marketing strategy, I believe dedicated effort should go into generating and maintaining high engagement. My last recommendation focuses on online ordering. Taco Bell aims to revolutionize the fast food industry by being one of the first companies to introduce and popularize mobile and online ordering. Online ordering certainly makes the customer experience fun and more efficient and is also beneficial for the company as its customization component boosts user spending by 30% (Jennigs, 2015). I believe, however, that the current version of the website does not make it immediately clear that online ordering is fundamentally different from ordering at the store. If Taco Bell wants to drive more people to order online, it has to communicate loud and clear the advantages of online ordering versus ordering at the store such as skipping the line and being able to fully customize your meal.
  • 40. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 39 DASHBOARD VISUALS DASHBOARD VISUAL #1 Rationale As noted earlier, Taco Bell is interested in driving more people to the website and have them use the customization options when they make a purchase. For visual #1 I used three KPIs. Two of them are attitudinal (perception of customization as a valuable tool and degree of motivation to buy online) and one is behavioral (online sales as percentage of total sales). As a benchmark I used Panera Bread whose website has identical functionality. My choice of KPIs is based on the assumption that if a visitor clearly sees the customization function as an advantage of online ordering, he will be more inclined to use the website to make a purchase, which will ultimately boost online sales. Considering the fact that visitors should go to the store to pick up their food regardless of how they chose to order, their perception of the customization functionality is an extremely important factor influencing their buying decision. If they do not see a clear advantage of online ordering, they will most likely stick with their old habits and order at the store instead.
  • 41. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 40 DASHBOARD VISUAL # 2 Rationale For the most part Taco Bell’s website is designed to mimic the mobile app (to introduce visitors to the concept of online ordering and customization and motivate them to make a purchase). There are only four items in the main navigation and two of them are oriented toward online sales – ‘Food’ and ‘Locations’. ‘The Feed’ is the only main section of the website that serves communication objective #2: Engage users & increase loyalty. For the second dashboard visual, I focused on this specific section of Taco Bell’s website to help me analyze website engagement. I am using two attitudinal KPIs (perception of content as relevant and perception of content as entertaining) and one behavioral KPI (‘The Feed’ bounce rate). The benchmark is the company’s goal for bounce rate value. Considering the nature of the Taco Bell brand and the age of its target group (18-35 years old), the content needs to be casual, fun and easy to read. To represent this condition, I am using ‘perception of content as entertaining’ as my first KPI.
  • 42. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 41 In addition, young people usually care about pop culture and current events, so in order to appeal to visitors, content needs to be relevant. This is why I chose ‘perception of content as relevant’ as my second KPI. Further, bounce rate can be interpreted in two ways: 1) percentage of visitors who only see one page of the website or 2) percentage of visitors who stay on the website for a small amount of time (Kaushik, 2007, para.8). For the purpose of this analysis, I am using the latter definition. I would presume that lower bounce rate would mean that visitors are spending time reading articles or watching videos depending on the piece of content, i.e., they are engaged with the section. The main assumption behind Dashboard visual #2: if the content is entertaining and relevant, visitors will be more likely to stay and read it, thus contributing to overall website engagement.
  • 43. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 42 REFERENCES Alexa.com. (2015). Site overview: tacobell.com. Retrieved from www.alexa.com Barnes Reports. (October, 2015). 2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Fast Food Restaurant Industry (NAICS 722513).[Industry report]. Retrieved from Business Source Complete Bounce Rate Demystified. (n.d.). Retrieved from Blogs: Kissmetrics: https://blog.kissmetrics.com/bounce-rate/ Cao, J. (2015, August 19). Why long scrolling sites have become awesome. Retrieved from TNW News: http://thenextweb.com/dd/2015/08/19/why-long-scrolling-sites- have-become-awesome/ Company Overview of Taco Bell Corp. (n.d.). In Bloomberg Business. Retrieved from: http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapid=4287 79 Deswal, S. (n.d.). VWO. Retrieved from VWO.com: https://vwo.com/blog/larger-product- images-increase-conversion-rate/ Digiday/Chute. (2015). The State of Industry - Visual Marketing: Scale to Win. Retrieved from http://digiday.com/chute-soti-download/ Ecommerce best practices 2015: 5 must-know tips to increase your online sales. (2015, January 10). In wemakewebsites.com. Retrieved from: http://wemakewebsites.com/blog/ecommerce-best-practices-2015-5-must-know-tips-to- increase-your-online-sales Epstein, E. (2014, May 29). Why Taco Bell Went Loco for Snapchat. Retrieved from Mashable.com: http://mashable.com/2014/05/29/taco-bell-marketing- strategy/#APT4Ic6CgiqF Giammona, C. (2015, May 26). Taco Bell Cutting Artificial Flavors to Prove ‘Less Is Mas’. Retrieved from Bloomberg Business: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-05-26/taco-bell-cutting-artificial- ingredients-to-prove-less-is-mas- Jennigs, L. (2015, October 12). Taco Bell debuts new website. Nation's Restaurant News, pp. 19-20.
  • 44. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 43 How Loading Time Affects Your Bottom Line. (n.d.). Retrieved from KISSmetrics Blog: https://blog.kissmetrics.com/loading-time/ Kaushik, A. (August 6, 2007). Standard Metrics Revisited: #3 Bounce Rate. [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://www.kaushik.net/avinash/standard-metrics-revisited-3- bounce-rate/ Lutz, A. (2014, March 28). Taco Bell Made 2 Changes That Transformed The Brand. Retrieved from Business Insider: http://www.businessinsider.com/taco-bell- marketing-strategy-2014-3 Macdonald, M. (n.d.). 5 Ecommerce Design Mistakes that Could Be Killing Your Sales. Retrieved from Shopify.com: https://www.shopify.com/blog/9811290-5- ecommerce-design-mistakes-that-could-be-killing-your-sales MarketLine. (January 2012). Fast Food in the United States. [Industry Profile]. Retrived from MarketLine Advantage Database Morrison, M. (2014, July 28). In breakfast wars, Taco Bell's boldmarketing pays off with big sales. Advertising Age, pp. 6-6. Niccol, B. & Brandt, C. (2014). Taco Bell Goes Loco for Snapchatting Millennials. (Mashable, Interviewer) [Video file] Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsDdUIQhRSM Omazic, T. (2014, March ). What Women Want. Retrieved from QSR : https://www.qsrmagazine.com/consumer-trends/what-women-want Paine, K. (2011). Measure What Matters . Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. . Poppick, S. (2015, June 3). Taco Bell in U.S. Will Serve Alcohol for the First Time. Retrieved from Time.com: http://time.com/money/3908252/taco-bell-alcohol- beer-wine-chicago/ Prater, D. (2015, October 9). Taco Bell’s New Vegan-Friendly Menu Features Millions of Meat-Free Options. Retrieved from PETA: http://www.peta.org/living/food/taco- bell-vegetarian-menu/ Taco Bell. (n.d.-a) In Entrepreneur.com. Retrieved from: http://www.entrepreneur.com/franchises/tacobell/282858-0.html Taco Bell. (n.d.-b) In Yum.com. Retrieved from: http://www.yum.com/brands/tb.asp The QSR 50. (2015, August). Retrieved from: https://www.qsrmagazine.com/reports/qsr50-2015-top-50-chart
  • 45. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 44 The Ultimate Ecommerce Guide for Stores in the Food Industry. (2014, February 20). In Volusion.com. Retrieved from: http://www.volusion.com/ecommerce- blog/articles/the-ultimate-ecommerce-guide-for-stores-in-the-food-industry/ Vaughan, P. (2014, October 30). The Ultimate Cheat Sheet for Creating Social Media Buttons. Retrieved from: http://blog.hubspot.com/blog/tabid/6307/bid/29544/The- Ultimate-Cheat-Sheet-for-Creating-Social-Media-Buttons.aspx Wong, V. (2013, May 29). How Fast-Food Eaters Split Along Ethnic Lines. Retrieved from: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2013-05-29/how-fast-food-eaters- split-along-ethnic-lines
  • 46. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 45 APPENDICES Appendix 1: Heuristic assessment Item Taco Bell Chipotle Panera Bread The order process is clear and intuitive 5 3.5 (Upon ordering the system requires a name for the order and the typing field is not always responsive.) 5 The website provides visitors with special offers/promotional prices 5 4 (buried at the bottom, very small font, offers available after joining mobile list) 5 The customization function is easy to use and allows a full modification of the order. 5 5 5 The order process is fully optimized for mobile devices. 5 3 (mobile-friendly, but not specifically optimized; some buttons are not responsive) 5 Registration/signing- in is straightforward and effortless 5 4 (a lot of information needed which makes registration slower) 4 (a lot of information needed which makes registration slower) The ‘locations’ feature works well and includes a map, store hours and contact information. 5 4 (doesn’t have a map, links out to Google maps) 5 The website has strong, high-quality visuals that support the brand identity. 5 5 5 The website provides detailed 5 4 5
  • 47. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 46 nutrition information. (Allergen info table is very confusing) The website provides information about ingredients and recipes. 5 5 5 Visitors have a variety of options to interact and engage with the company. 4 4 5 Total: 49 41.5 49
  • 48. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 47 Appendix 2: Survey questions
  • 49. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 48
  • 50. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 49
  • 51. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 50 Appendix 3: Survey Results
  • 52. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 51
  • 53. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 52
  • 54. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 53
  • 55. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 54
  • 56. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 55
  • 57. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 56
  • 58. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 57
  • 59. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 58
  • 60. Running head: TACO BELL WEBSITE ASSESSMENT 59