Similar Sources on Bloody Sunday Riots

detailed autopsy of
mye practice paper #1
sec 3 social studies 2015
question (d)5

WARNING
Do not rush through the slides.
Understand how one step leads to the other.
You may not have the same answers as me. It is
possible. If you’re not sure, just check with me!

before you begin…
these are my colour codes and symbols
+ -
involvement is beneﬁcial involvement is NOT beneﬁcial

Study Sources D and E.
How similar are these two sources? Explain your answer.Qns(d)

How similar are these two sources? Explain your answer.Qns(d) = difference + similar

-+
= similar +difference
Ssource
D
source
E

-+
comparing thesame thing
= match(tip: similar colourcodes should havesimilarities)
Ssource
D
source
E

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
pickout
“many rioters…”

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
pickout
Some of those people
had been rioting.
pickout

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
pickout
had been rioting.
pickout

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.
Let’s use
similar words
to make the
match clearer

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.
Let’s use
similar words
to make the
match clearer
There were rioters on
Bloody Sunday
Bloody Sunday

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Bloody Sunday

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
There were rioters on Bloody Sunday
criteria
clearer now!!
Bloody Sunday

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Bloody Sunday

Let’s put it together as
one of the paragraphs

How similar are these two sources? Explain your answer.Qns(d) = similar +difference
Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
“many rioters…” Some of those people
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Both sources are similar in showing
Bloody Sunday

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
State the criteria for
comparison to make it clear
what you’re comparing.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
there were rioters on Bloody Sunday.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
Show what first source
said to support your
claim about how
they are similar

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
claim about how
they are similar
“many rioters”.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states “many rioters”.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
explain how that evidence
is related to the criteria
to make the comparison
clearer. Use exact words
as criteria.
“many rioters”.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
as criteria.
“many rioters”. This means that there were rioters on Bloody Sunday.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Both sources are similar in showing there were rioters on Bloody Sunday.
Source D states “many rioters”. This means that there were rioters on Bloody Sunday.

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Source D states
Similarly,
don’t forget
conjunctions
to indicate
that this is
a comparison

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Source D states
Similarly, Source E states that

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
had been rioting.
Source D states
Similarly, Source E states that
Show what 2nd source
claim about how
they are different

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
Similarly, Source E states that “some of these people had been rioting.”

Ssource
D
source
E
Bloody Sunday
Source D states
This means that
as criteria.

Ssource
D
source
E
Source D states
This means that This means that there were rioters on Bloody Sunday.

Source D states

Source D states
Let’s check
if both sources
and criteria matches.
we’ll connect words
that are exactly the
same as the criteria

Source D states
Triangle can be drawn
= criteria matches both sources!

-+
using our symbols, At one
look, we know both have
different views about
whether British army is
beneficial.Ssource
D
source
E

-+
using our symbols, At one
look, we know both have
different views about
whether British army is
beneficial.Ssource
D
source
E
British Army was NOT
beneficial to NI.
Whether British Army was beneficial to NI
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
beneficial to NI.
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
pickout
beneficial to NI.
“soldiers were fired on first
and were merely doing
their duty…had to resort to
using arms in the name of
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
pickout
“no evidence to suggest
that there was a need to
use lethal force…sent
additional heavily armed
soldiers to rid the rioters”
pickout
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

-+
Ssource
D
source
E
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

Dsource
D
source
EBritish Army was NOT
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
Both sources are different on
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
whether British Army was beneficial to NI

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
claim about how
they are similar

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
self-defence”
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
claim about how
they are similar
“soldiers were fired on first and were merely doing their duty…had to resort to
using arms in the name of self-defence”

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states “soldiers were fired on first and were merely doing their duty…had to resort to

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
as criteria.

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
British Army was
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
as criteria.
using arms in the name of self-defence” This means that British Army was beneficial to NI.

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Both sources are different on whether British Army was beneficial to NI
Source D states “soldiers were fired on first and were merely doing their duty…had to resort to

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
However,,
don’t forget
conjunctions
to indicate
that this is
a comparison

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
However,, Source E states that there is

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
Show what 2nd source
claim about how
they are different
“no evidence to suggest that there was a need to
use lethal force…sent additional heavily armed soldiers to rid the rioters”

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Source D states

Dsource
D
source
beneficial to NI.
Source D states
This means that
as criteria.

Dsource
D
source
E
Source D states
This means that the British Army was NOT beneficial to NI.

Source D states

Source D states
Let’s check
if both sources
and criteria matches.
we’ll connect words
that are exactly the
same as the criteria

Source D states
Triangle can be drawn
= criteria matches both sources!

so our answer so far…
similar in content / views
Difference in content / views
Source D states
Source D states

-+
source
D
source
E

-+
source
D
source
E
tone towards British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
{whole sourceshows whichaspect ofbritish army?

-+
source
D
source
E
Mostly POSITIVE aspect
of British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
pick out
an eg. of
+ve aspect

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
Eg: had to resort to using
arms in the name of self-
defence
Biased towards  
British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
{
w
ho
le
so
urce
sho
w
s
w
hich
aspect
o
f
BRITISH
ARMY?
defence
Biased towards  
British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
BOTH POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE aspect of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
pick outan eg. of+ve aspect pick out
an eg. of
-ve aspect

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Eg: Did not want to
use force…
Objective towards
British Army.
Eg: sent additional heavily-armed soldiers to
rid…many were peaceful marchers

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Eg: Did not want to
use force…
Objective towards
British Army.
Tone is
different

-+
source
D
source
E
of British Army
defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Eg: Did not want to
use force…
Objective towards
British Army.
D

source
D
source
E
Biased towards British Army
of British Army
Eg: had to resort to using arms in
the name of self-defence
Biased towards  
British Army
Eg: Did not want to use force…
Objective towards
British Army.
D
Eg: sent additional heavily-armed soldiers to rid…
many were peaceful marchers

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Both sources are different in

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Both sources are different in its tone towards the British Army

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Source D is

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Biased towards  
British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Source D is
Tone of source B

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Source D is biased towards the British Army.

source
D
source
E
of British Army
Objective towards
British Army.
Source D is biased towards the British Army. This is because it shows
Justify your claim:
why is the source biased
against healthcare in SG?

source
D
source
E
Objective towards
British Army.
mostly the positive aspect of the British Army.

source
D
source
E
Objective towards
British Army.
mostly the positive aspect of the British Army. For example, the source states that
Provide an example of what
you mean by positive aspect

source
D
source
E
Objective towards
British Army.
the British Army “had to resort to using arms in the name of self-defence”.

source
D
source
E
Objective towards
British Army.
However,
don’t forget
conjunctions
to indicate
that this is
a comparison
Source E is

source
D
source
E
Objective towards
British Army.
However, Source E is
Tone of source C

source
D
source
E
However, Source E is biased for objective towards the British Army.

source
D
source
E
However, Source E is biased for objective towards the British Army. This is because it shows
Justify your claim:
why is the source biased for
healthcare in SG?

source
D
source
E
both the positive and negative aspects of the British Army.

source
D
source
E
both the positive and negative aspects of the British Army. For example,
the source states that “did not want to use force” to show the positive aspect
Provide an example of what
you mean by positive aspect

source
D
source
E

source
D
source
E
and “sent additional heavily-armed soldiers to rid…many were peaceful marcher” to show the
negative aspect.
Provide an
example of
what you mean
by negative
aspect

source
D
source
E
negative aspect.

Source D is

negative aspect.

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone
Source D is

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone
negative aspect.

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
{Using Star
Approach

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
In Source D, the paratrooper is trying to convince
the British that the British Army was not at fault for
Bloody Sunday. This is because the source states
“his soldiers were fired on first and were merely
doing their duty.many rioters threw stone…
intention to use violence against us and we had to
resort to using arms in the name of self-defence”.
This means that the British Army fired only
because they were attacked and had to defend
themselves. This source was published in an
interview on BBC in 2010, in response to the report
by the government on Bloody Sunday. Therefore,
the paratrooper is trying to garner the support of
the British to blame the rioters for Bloody Sunday
instead of the British Army.

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
{
Using Star
Approach

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
In Source E, Lord Saville is trying to convince the
British that the British Army was at fault for Bloody
Sunday. This is because the source states that
Bloody Sunday occurred because “Lieutenant
Colonel Wilford did not comply with General Ford’s
order to tackle rioters by sending only one group of
troops” and affected many who were “peaceful
marchers”. This means that there was no reason
why the British Army should have fired at the
Catholics. This was from Lord Saville, who headed
the Inquiry Committee in charge of investigations of
events during Bloody Sunday in 2010, many years
after Bloody Sunday. Therefore, Lord Saville was
trying to garner the support of the British to blame
the British Army for their mistakes during Bloody
Sunday.

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
purpose is
different

-+
source
D
source
E
Purpose
D
Sunday.

source
D
source
E
Purpose
D
Sunday.

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
Both sources are different in its purpose.

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
Purpose of Source D
+ its justification
(basically, the whole star
approach paragraph!)

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
In Source D, the paratrooper is trying to convince the British that the British Army was not at
fault for Bloody Sunday. This is because the source states “his soldiers were fired on first and
were merely doing their duty.many rioters threw stone…intention to use violence against us and
we had to resort to using arms in the name of self-defence”. This means that the British Army
fired only because they were attacked and had to defend themselves. This source was
published in an interview on BBC in 2010, in response to the report by the government on
Bloody Sunday. Therefore, the paratrooper is trying to garner the support of the British to blame
the rioters for Bloody Sunday instead of the British Army.

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
However,
don’t forget
conjunctions
to indicate
that this is
a comparison

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
However,

source
D
source
E
Purpose
Sunday.
However,
Purpose of Source E
+ its justification
(basically, the whole star
approach paragraph!)

source
D
source
E
Purpose
However,
In Source E, Lord Saville is trying to convince the British that the British Army was at fault for
Bloody Sunday. This is because the source states that Bloody Sunday occurred because
“Lieutenant Colonel Wilford did not comply with General Ford’s order to tackle rioters by
sending only one group of troops” and affected many who were “peaceful marchers”. This
means that there was no reason why the British Army should have fired at the Catholics. This
was from Lord Saville, who headed the Inquiry Committee in charge of investigations of events
during Bloody Sunday in 2010, many years after Bloody Sunday. Therefore, Lord Saville was
trying to garner the support of the British to blame the British Army for their mistakes during
Bloody Sunday.

so our answer so far… (i)
Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone
Source D is

Source D states
Source D states
Difference in tone

Similar Sources on Bloody Sunday Riots

Similar Sources on Bloody Sunday Riots

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (8)

More from Yanjie Luo

More from Yanjie Luo (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Similar Sources on Bloody Sunday Riots