Stop Drowning in Data:

The Metrics That Matter                   




      By: Vickie Gibbs, GM Albright Digital
                                          





                                          
                            March 20, 2013
                                          




                                               1
Take Aways …
1.    What’s Important:
      The Right Part of the Story

2.    Measurement:
      How to Identify and Measure The Right Metrics

3.    Experimentation:
      How and Why It Drives Success




                                                  2
TV Still Biggest Category with Online
Close Behind … Print Falling Fast




                                    3
Spending in Line with Time Spent
Except for Print and Mobile




                                   4
Smartphone Sales Outpacing PCs




                                  5
Mobile is Still Early… But Growing!




                                   6
Smartphones Assisting in 

Purchase Decisions 




                             7
Americans Now Spend More Time
on Social Networks Than Portals




                                   8
Google, Not Social, Driving
Online Commerce




                              9
Online Dealer Reviews Very
Influential…




                             10
… Even More So Than Referrals
and Location




                                11
The Right Part of the Story…
  }    Where are users and what is driving sales?
        ◦  TV, Online 
        ◦  NOT Print

  }    Where are users and what is driving sales online?
        ◦  Google (driver)
        ◦  Online Reviews, Social, Portals (influencers)

  }    What role does mobile play?
        ◦  Influencing sales
        ◦  Increasingly important tool for users during the purchase
           process and information post-sale




                                                                       12
You Can’t Manage What You
      Can’t Measure




                            13
Various Advertising Works
Together to Achieve Sales
    General	
            Build	
             Make	
  Dealership	
  
    Branding	
     Considera0on	
  Set	
        Decision	
  
Classify your Marketing Programs

               AutoTrader/	
  	
                   Your	
  Website	
  
               Cars.com	
  /	
  
   SEO	
       Edmunds	
           TV	
                         Adv	
  on	
  sites	
  
                                                                like	
  Cars.com	
  
                                      Local	
  
  Branding                            Online	
        SEM	
    Direct
             Twi,er	
  
                                    Radio	
                 Response
       Online	
  Review	
  
                                                    Craig’s	
  List/	
  	
  
                Facebook	
                          eBay	
  
Different Metrics…
Branding
                      Direct Response
}    Goal: Share of voice
    }    Goal: Direct sales
}    Measure: You vs Your     }    Measure: Program ->
      Competition
                   Action -> Sales
}    Long term impact
        }    Short term impact
}    Influencer of decision
   }    Purchase driver
}    Focus on people in       }    Focus on people in your
      your target                    target demographic in
      demographic
                   purchase process
Metrics by Marketing Program
Program
              Metrics
TV/ Radio
            •  Share of voice
                      •  Opportunity to deliver your message/ point of
                         differentiation to your target market
                      •  How much ad time do you have compared to your
                         competition?
                      •  Amount of showroom traffic driven by promotion
                         incentives or programs in ad
Auto Portals (e.g.,   •  Compare your presence to that of your competition
Autotrader,           •  What is your location in search results compared to
Cars.com, Edmunds)
      your competition?
                      •  Examine the amount of traffic to your dealer page and
                         VDPs (compared to competition if possible)
Social (Facebook,     •    Share of voice compared to competition
Twitter)
             •    # of followers/ # of fans 
                      •    Engagement of users: reach, comments, shares
                      •    Great opportunity to get your message of
                                                                           17
                           differentiation across to users
Metrics by Marketing Program
Program
   Metrics
SEO
       •  Content drives ranking for organic search results
           •  Long term impact when make changes for SEO 
           •  First select the terms you want to rank highly on – this
              should be done in context with your competition and
              your points of differentiation as well as what is most
              important to your users (choose terms that have high
              search traffic)
           •  Work with firm to create content and design site to
              support good SEO for those target terms
           •  Baseline + measure rank of those terms every 60-90
              days
SEM
       •    ROI
           •    CTR -> Leads -> Sales
           •    Examine by site (search engine)
           •    Examine by keyword
           •    Target your brand, but also other strategic keywords
           •    Understand which sites and keywords are driving
                                                                   18
                leads, not just traffic
Metrics by Marketing Program
Program
                  Metrics
Online Reviews            •    # of Reviews
(Google+ Local, Yelp,     •    Score/ Rank
Cars.com, Edmunds,        •    Recency of reviews
etc.)
                    •    Focus on those that are most important to your
                               consumers (examine traffic to the sites)
Your Website
             •  ROI
                          •  Traffic -> Leads -> Sales
                          •  Users at your site should convert at a higher rate – do
                             everything to capture leads at your site
3rd Party Lead            •  ROI
Providers 
               •  Leads -> Sales
                          •  Look at conversion by provider and cost to determine
                             most effective channels
                          •  Work with vendors to improve if possible
Listing Services (e.g.,   •  ROI
eBay, Craigs List)
       •  # of Listings -> Leads -> Sales
                          •  Improve listing to increase # of Leads
             19
Try New Things … 
   Optimize or
                  Experiment
   Discontinue




    Evaluate
      Measure
Improving Google+ Score
}    Problem: No rank on Google+ Local, no customer testimonials for
      website or Facebook

}    Solution:
      ◦  Implemented review management solution to provide
         notifications of new reviews, tracking of scores on 3rd party
         sites, a tool to encourage customers to review, and training

}    Results: 
      ◦  In 3 months, obtained over 45 internal reviews for website and
         Facebook
      ◦  In 3 months, obtained 28 reviews across both dealership on
         Google+ Local, and a rank of 28 out of 30 and 30 out of 30
Choose Best Website Incentive
Lead Capture Solution
}    Problem: Pop-up coupon vs behaviorally targeted slider

}    Solution:
      ◦  Turned off pop-up coupon
      ◦  Implemented website slider to present targeted calls-to-
         actions to customers based on browsing behavior

}    Results: 
      ◦  Website slider produced twice as many sales as the pop-up
         coupon
      ◦  Continued to optimize slider by testing colors & calls to action
Improving Conversion on
Website
}    Problem: Capture more leads from the website

}    Solution:
      ◦  Implemented website slider to present targeted calls-to-
         actions to customers based on browsing behavior
      ◦  Tested different calls to action and colors – analyzed results
         to determine which ones to implement on a permanent basis

}    Results: 
      ◦  Increase in website leads due to slider = 34%
      ◦  Increase in website sales due to slider = +20%
Conclusions
}    Pay attention to the right part of the story

}    Measure the right metrics for each program, and
      optimize over time

}    Determine strategic areas of focus and experiment
      with new programs and tactics

}    Vickie Gibbs, vgibbs@albrightdigital.com,
      @AlbrightDigital, @VGCBC

Stop drowning in data 032013

  • 1.
    Stop Drowning inData:
 The Metrics That Matter 
 By: Vickie Gibbs, GM Albright Digital 
 March 20, 2013 1
  • 2.
    Take Aways … 1.  What’s Important: The Right Part of the Story 2.  Measurement: How to Identify and Measure The Right Metrics 3.  Experimentation: How and Why It Drives Success 2
  • 3.
    TV Still BiggestCategory with Online Close Behind … Print Falling Fast 3
  • 4.
    Spending in Linewith Time Spent Except for Print and Mobile 4
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Mobile is StillEarly… But Growing! 6
  • 7.
    Smartphones Assisting in
 Purchase Decisions 7
  • 8.
    Americans Now SpendMore Time on Social Networks Than Portals 8
  • 9.
    Google, Not Social,Driving Online Commerce 9
  • 10.
    Online Dealer ReviewsVery Influential… 10
  • 11.
    … Even MoreSo Than Referrals and Location 11
  • 12.
    The Right Partof the Story… }  Where are users and what is driving sales? ◦  TV, Online ◦  NOT Print }  Where are users and what is driving sales online? ◦  Google (driver) ◦  Online Reviews, Social, Portals (influencers) }  What role does mobile play? ◦  Influencing sales ◦  Increasingly important tool for users during the purchase process and information post-sale 12
  • 13.
    You Can’t ManageWhat You Can’t Measure 13
  • 14.
    Various Advertising Works Togetherto Achieve Sales General   Build   Make  Dealership   Branding   Considera0on  Set   Decision  
  • 15.
    Classify your MarketingPrograms AutoTrader/     Your  Website   Cars.com  /   SEO   Edmunds   TV   Adv  on  sites   like  Cars.com   Local   Branding Online   SEM   Direct Twi,er   Radio   Response Online  Review   Craig’s  List/     Facebook   eBay  
  • 16.
    Different Metrics… Branding Direct Response }  Goal: Share of voice }  Goal: Direct sales }  Measure: You vs Your }  Measure: Program -> Competition Action -> Sales }  Long term impact }  Short term impact }  Influencer of decision }  Purchase driver }  Focus on people in }  Focus on people in your your target target demographic in demographic purchase process
  • 17.
    Metrics by MarketingProgram Program Metrics TV/ Radio •  Share of voice •  Opportunity to deliver your message/ point of differentiation to your target market •  How much ad time do you have compared to your competition? •  Amount of showroom traffic driven by promotion incentives or programs in ad Auto Portals (e.g., •  Compare your presence to that of your competition Autotrader, •  What is your location in search results compared to Cars.com, Edmunds) your competition? •  Examine the amount of traffic to your dealer page and VDPs (compared to competition if possible) Social (Facebook, •  Share of voice compared to competition Twitter) •  # of followers/ # of fans •  Engagement of users: reach, comments, shares •  Great opportunity to get your message of 17 differentiation across to users
  • 18.
    Metrics by MarketingProgram Program Metrics SEO •  Content drives ranking for organic search results •  Long term impact when make changes for SEO •  First select the terms you want to rank highly on – this should be done in context with your competition and your points of differentiation as well as what is most important to your users (choose terms that have high search traffic) •  Work with firm to create content and design site to support good SEO for those target terms •  Baseline + measure rank of those terms every 60-90 days SEM •  ROI •  CTR -> Leads -> Sales •  Examine by site (search engine) •  Examine by keyword •  Target your brand, but also other strategic keywords •  Understand which sites and keywords are driving 18 leads, not just traffic
  • 19.
    Metrics by MarketingProgram Program Metrics Online Reviews •  # of Reviews (Google+ Local, Yelp, •  Score/ Rank Cars.com, Edmunds, •  Recency of reviews etc.) •  Focus on those that are most important to your consumers (examine traffic to the sites) Your Website •  ROI •  Traffic -> Leads -> Sales •  Users at your site should convert at a higher rate – do everything to capture leads at your site 3rd Party Lead •  ROI Providers •  Leads -> Sales •  Look at conversion by provider and cost to determine most effective channels •  Work with vendors to improve if possible Listing Services (e.g., •  ROI eBay, Craigs List) •  # of Listings -> Leads -> Sales •  Improve listing to increase # of Leads 19
  • 20.
    Try New Things… Optimize or Experiment Discontinue Evaluate Measure
  • 21.
    Improving Google+ Score }  Problem: No rank on Google+ Local, no customer testimonials for website or Facebook }  Solution: ◦  Implemented review management solution to provide notifications of new reviews, tracking of scores on 3rd party sites, a tool to encourage customers to review, and training }  Results: ◦  In 3 months, obtained over 45 internal reviews for website and Facebook ◦  In 3 months, obtained 28 reviews across both dealership on Google+ Local, and a rank of 28 out of 30 and 30 out of 30
  • 22.
    Choose Best WebsiteIncentive Lead Capture Solution }  Problem: Pop-up coupon vs behaviorally targeted slider }  Solution: ◦  Turned off pop-up coupon ◦  Implemented website slider to present targeted calls-to- actions to customers based on browsing behavior }  Results: ◦  Website slider produced twice as many sales as the pop-up coupon ◦  Continued to optimize slider by testing colors & calls to action
  • 23.
    Improving Conversion on Website }  Problem: Capture more leads from the website }  Solution: ◦  Implemented website slider to present targeted calls-to- actions to customers based on browsing behavior ◦  Tested different calls to action and colors – analyzed results to determine which ones to implement on a permanent basis }  Results: ◦  Increase in website leads due to slider = 34% ◦  Increase in website sales due to slider = +20%
  • 24.
    Conclusions }  Pay attention to the right part of the story }  Measure the right metrics for each program, and optimize over time }  Determine strategic areas of focus and experiment with new programs and tactics }  Vickie Gibbs, vgibbs@albrightdigital.com, @AlbrightDigital, @VGCBC