SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 36
Download to read offline
fs viewpoint                                   www.pwc.com/fsi



           02              08          15                           28
May 2012
           Understanding   Potential   Implications for             What companies
           the crisis      scenarios   US corporations              are doing now




           Breaking Up is Hard to Do:
           The Eurozone Crisis—Possible
           Implications and Contingency
           Planning for US Companies
Understanding the crisis
Eurozone crisis                                                        The current eurozone debt crisis, while building       Reform momentum is growing as political
                                                                       up over time, was triggered in April 2010 when         leaders face up to this moment after more
                                                                       Eurostat, the Europe Union (EU) statistical            than two years of procrastination and wishful
                                                                       authority, revealed that Greece’s 2009 budget          thinking. Arguably, some of the largest
                                                                       deficit was €32.3 billion, or 13.6% of its gross       financing hurdles in the most at-risk countries
                                                                       domestic product (GDP). In 2009, Greece had            have been overcome, with yields on both short-
                                                                       estimated its deficit for 2009 would come in at        and long-term debt significantly lower than at
                                                                       3.7% of GDP. The EU’s limit is 3%.¹                    the end of 2011, and consumer and industrial
                                                                                                                              confidence beginning to improve. Nevertheless,
                                                                       Global markets have since responded to the
                                                                                                                              significant operational risks remain for US
                                                                       magnitude of sovereign debt in other eurozone
                                                                                                                              firms operating in the eurozone. Contingency
                                                                       countries as investors question the ability of
                                                                                                                              planning can help mitigate the risk, and the
                                                                       these countries to repay their debts.²
                                                                                                                              strategies adopted by US firms will depend on
                                                                       Greece, Portugal, and Ireland have requested           likely market conditions. In this publication,
                                                                       financial assistance from the European Central         PwC will outline four possible scenarios for
                                                                       Bank (ECB), the European Commission (EC),              the eurozone’s future that can help guide US
                                                                       and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to           corporate decision-making.
                                                                       finance debt repayment. There has also been
                                                                       a stream of European summits to resolve the
                                                                       crisis.                                                 Consumer and industrial confidence
                                                                                                                              Consumer and Industrial Confidence
                                                                       Growing market pressure and significant
                                                                                                                                 20
                                                                       tranches of sovereign debt due for refinancing            10
                                                                       hint at a possible resolution to the current               0
                                                                       phase of the crisis. However, there is no silver         -10
                                                                       bullet—any solution will necessarily play out            -20
                                                                       over time, step by step, via fiscal austerity to pay     -30
                                                                       down debt. In addition, deep structural reforms          -40
                                                                       will be necessary to restore competitiveness and         -50
                                                                       boost long-term growth.




                                                                                                                                      2000 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                   2001 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                2002 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                             2003 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                          2004 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                       2005 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2006 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2007 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2008 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              2009 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2010 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2011 - Jan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2012 - Jan
1     harles Forelle, “EU Sees Wider Greek Deficit, Roiling Markets;
    C
    Bonds Fall as Investors View Bailout and Default as Givens,” The
    Wall Street Journal, April 23, 2010.
2   The eurozone consists of the following 17 European Union member
    countries who have adopted the euro (European Monetary Union):
    the 11 original members—Austria, Belgium, Finland, France,                                                                    Industrial confidence                                                                          Consumer confidence
    Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal,                                                               indicator, SA % balance                                                                        indicator, SA % balance
    Spain—and Greece (from January 2001), Slovenia (from January                                                              Source: Haver Analytics
    2007), Cyprus and Malta (from January 2008), Slovakia (from
    January 2009) and Estonia (from January 2011).




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Understanding the crisis                            3
Eurozone crisis                                                           In March 2012, The Economist reported,                                                           Many forecasters question whether Greece’s
                                                                          “Cheered by the signs of recovery, and relieved                                                  partial default on its debt and additional
                                                                          that disaster has been avoided (particularly                                                     funding from the ECB and the IMF of €130
                                                                          in Europe, which towards the end of last year                                                    billion is a long-term fix or simply a way to
                                                                          seemed on the brink of a calamity of Lehman-                                                     delay the inevitable. Even with this package,
                                                                          like magnitude), financial markets have been                                                     Greece’s debt is still expected to be 120% of
                                                                          climbing steadily higher.”¹                                                                      GDP in 2020 under what some consider to be
                                                                                                                                                                           optimistic economic and budget assumptions.³
                                                                          While financial markets have recently started
                                                                          to move higher, GDP data reflected a different                                                   As soon as the ink was dry on the Greek bailout
                                                                          story—confirming that the region shrank                                                          agreement, market attention turned to debt
                                                                          by 0.3% in the last quarter of 2011 while                                                        issues in Italy, Spain, and Portugal, thereby
                                                                          household spending, exports, and imports all                                                     signaling a potential continuation of the crisis
                                                                          fell.² Some fear that the eurozone may slide                                                     and once again highlighting the historical
                                                                          into deeper recession.                                                                           origins of the current dilemma.

                                                                           Percent change in real GDP since 2000                                                         Share of EurozoneGDP
                                                                                                                                                                          Share of eurozone GDP
                                                                          Percent Change in Real GDP Since 2000
                                                                           150                                                                                           Greece, Ireland,
                                                                                                                                                                         and Portugal:
                                                                           140                                                                                           6.1% of eurozone GDP

                                                                           130
                                                                                                                                                                         Spain and Italy:
                                                                                                                                                                         28.5% of eurozone GDP
                                                                           120

                                                                           110
                                                                                                                                                                         Rest of eurozone:
                                                                           100                                                                                           65.4%
                                                                                 2000
                                                                                        2001
                                                                                               2002
                                                                                                      2003
                                                                                                             2004
                                                                                                                    2005
                                                                                                                           2006
                                                                                                                                  2007
                                                                                                                                         2008
                                                                                                                                                2009
                                                                                                                                                       2010
                                                                                                                                                               2011

                                                                             Greece                                   Spain                                   Portugal

                                                                             Germany                                 Ireland                                  Italy         Source: Haver Analytics, IMF, and WEO Databases.

                                                                          Source: Haver Analytics and PwC analysis
1     Can it be… the recovery?” The Economist, 17 March, 2012.
    “
2     Eurozone crisis live: FTSE 100 posts biggest fall of 2012 - as it
    “
    happened,” Guardian Unlimited, March 6, 2012.
    http://www.guardian.co.uk
3     Greece: Request for Extended Arrangement Under the Extended
    “
    Fund Facility,” IMF Country Report No. 12/57, March 2012.




4    FS Viewpoint
The roots of the crisis go                                                 Diverging competitiveness                          This imbalance stemmed from the eurozone’s
                                                                                                                              unique governance structure (part
back to the inception of the                                               Divergences in the competitive positions
                                                                                                                              intergovernmental, part supranational)
                                                                           and current-account balances of eurozone
euro in 1999 and two                                                       countries have been building up over the           and macroeconomic policy framework
                                                                                                                              (single monetary policy and devolved
underlying problems that                                                   past decade. Countries such as Germany
                                                                                                                              fiscal authorities). Additionally, there
                                                                           and the Netherlands gained in price/
have gone unchecked:                                                       cost competitiveness while others such as          was no mechanism for regulating wider
                                                                           Greece, Ireland, Portugal, and Spain lost          macroeconomic imbalances.
                                                                           competitiveness.¹


                                                                           Current account balance (US$ billion)                   Manufacturing unit labor cost index
                                                                           Current account balance (US$ billion)                 Manufacturing unit labor cost index
                                                                             400                                                              180


                                                                             300                                                              160




                                                                                                                              Q1 2000 = 100
                                                                             200                                                              140

                                                                             100
                                                                                                                                              120

                                                                               0
                                                                                                                                              100

                                                                             -100
                                                                                                                                               80




                                                                                                                                                    2000
                                                                                                                                                           2001
                                                                                                                                                                  2002
                                                                                                                                                                         2003
                                                                                                                                                                                2004
                                                                                                                                                                                       2005
                                                                                                                                                                                              2006
                                                                                                                                                                                                     2007
                                                                                                                                                                                                            2008
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2009
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2010
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2011
                                                                             -200

                                                                                                                                               Greece                             Spain                            Portugal
                                                                             -300
                                                                                                                                               Germany                            France                           Italy
                                                                             -400                                                              Netherland
                                                                                    1999
                                                                                    2000
                                                                                    2001
                                                                                    2002
                                                                                    2003
                                                                                    2004
                                                                                    2005
                                                                                    2006
                                                                                    2007
                                                                                    2008
                                                                                    2009
                                                                                    2010
                                                                                    2011
                                                                                                                                      Source: OECD


                                                                               Germany           Netherland        Portugal

                                                                               Greece            Spain             France

                                                                               Italy

                                                                            Source: IMF
1     European Economy News,” April 2010, European Commission
    “
    Economic and Financial Affairs. Available from http://ec.europa.eu/.
    Accessed April 10, 2012.




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Understanding the crisis            5
The roots of the crisis go   Over-reliance on debt                                     The European banking sector is an important
                                                                                       channel of transmission of the crisis because
back to the inception of     The divergence trend has been supported
                                                                                       banks have large holdings of eurozone
                             by a complementary flow of credit from the
the euro in 1999 and two     surplus countries to the deficit countries. This          sovereign debt on their books. The ECB is
                                                                                       leading the effort to ease this pressure with the
underlying problems that     has caused a build up in public and private
                                                                                       introduction of its credit facility for the banking
have gone unchecked:         debt, delayed a correction in competitiveness,
                             and allowed the structural problems of the                sector, the long-term refinancing operations
                             eurozone to be largely hidden. Many countries             (LTROs).
                             are now struggling to repay this debt.



                             Pubic debt and and deficit estimates (% of GDP)(%
                             Public debt deficit estimates for 2011 for 2011      of GDP)

                                   High debt                                               180
                                                            Greece                                                            High debt




                                                                                                      Gov’t debt (% of GDP)
                                   High deficit                                                                               Moderate deficit
                                                                                           160

                                                                                           140
                                                                                   Italy
                                                                                           120
                                             Ireland                 Portugal

                                                                                  Belgium100
                                                                      France
                                                       UK
                                                                                            80
                                                                     Spain
                                                                                            60
                                    -12                -9                    -6                  -3                                0             3
                                     Government deficit (% of GDP)                          40

                                                                                            20

                                  Moderate debt                                            0                                    Low debt
                                  High deficit                           Axes represent Maastricht limits                       Low deficit
                               Source: IMF




6   FS Viewpoint
The resolution to the crisis                                    Imperfect union
will be impeded by the fact                                     The 17 members of the European Monetary Union remain sovereign
                                                                nations. The following timeline outlines potential trigger events during
that the eurozone is not a                                      2012 that may impact the timing and ultimate resolution of the crisis.
political union.
                     March             Apr                May               June…              Aug               Sept             Oct              Nov                 Dec
Refinancing          €14.4 bn                             €8 bn             €9.5 bn            €7.7 bn                                             IMF review of
                     Greek bond                           Greek bond        Portuguese         Greek bond                                          Greek economy
                     redemption/                          redemption        bond               redemption                                          (Nov)
                     disbursement                         (May)             redemption (Jun)   (Aug)
                     (Mar)
                     €14.6 bn IMF                         IMF review of                        Review of Greek
                     disbursement to                      Greek economy                        economy by the
                     Portugal (Mar)                       (May)                                IMF (Aug)
                     €5.5 bn
                     Ireland bond
                     redemption
                     (Mar)


Political meetings   EU Council        G20 Finance                          EU Council                           G20 Finance                                           EU Council
                     meeting           minister and                         meeting                              minister and                                          meeting
                     (1-2/Mar)         central banks’                       (28-29/Jun)                          central banks’                                        (13-14/Dec)
                                       meeting (20/Apr)                                                          meeting
                                                                                                                 (13-14/Sep)

                                                                                                                                    EU Council
                                                                             G20 Summit
                                                                                                                                      meeting
                                                                             (18-19/Jun)
                                                                                                                                    (18-19/Oct)


                                                                                                                                    IMF/World
                                                                                                                                   Bank Annual
                                                                                                                                   meeting (Oct)
Elections                              First round                                                                                                  US presidential
                                       of French                                                                                                   elections (6/Nov)
                                       presidential
                                       elections
                                       (22/Apr)
                                       Greek elections    Greek elections
                                       (6/May)            (6/May)
                                                                                                                                                                       Greek events


                                                                                                                                                             Understanding the crisis   7
Potential scenarios
Potential scenarios for the                                        Each scenario varies in its likelihood and                         Projected Eurozone GDP growth under
                                                                                                                                     Projected eurozone GDP growth under four scenarios.
                                                                                                                                      four scenarios
                                                                   impact.
eurozone in 2012.                                                                                                                      4%
                                                                   The eurozone that emerges from the crisis                           3%

There are a number of ways in which the                            is likely to be very different to the one we                        2%
                                                                                                                                       1%
eurozone crisis could play out depending on the                    know today, with 2012 being dominated by                             0

mix of policy responses over the next year or                      uncertainty and high volatility.                                   -1%
                                                                                                                                      -2%
                                                                                                                                      -3%
two. Presented below are four possible, though                     There is a wide range of potential outcomes.                       -4%
not necessarily exhaustive, scenarios that                                                                                            -5%
                                                                                                                                      -6%
represent a range of potential resolutions to the




                                                                                                                                             2005

                                                                                                                                                    2006

                                                                                                                                                           2007

                                                                                                                                                                  2008

                                                                                                                                                                         2009

                                                                                                                                                                                2010

                                                                                                                                                                                       2011

                                                                                                                                                                                              2012

                                                                                                                                                                                                     2013
crisis in 2012:
Scenario 1:                                                                                                                                  Scenario 1                  Scenario 2

Successive phases of monetary and fiscal                                                                                                     Scenario 3                  Scenario 4

action hold the eurozone together at the cost of                                                                                        Source: PwC analysis.

inflation.
Scenario 2:
Voluntary defaults for highly-indebted
sovereigns.
Scenario 3:
Greece exits the eurozone and a firewall is built                  Scenario description                                               Projected GDP growth (percent)2
around other economies.
                                                                                                                                      2012                                             2013
Scenario 4:                                                        Scenario 1: Successive phase of monetary and fiscal action hold    0.1                                              0.7
                                                                   the eurozone together at the cost of inflation.
A new currency union is formed by the stronger
economies.¹                                                        Scenario 2: Voluntary defaults for highly-indebted sovereigns.     -3.0                                             -1.5
                                                                   Scenario 3: Greece exits the eurozone and a firewall is built      -1.0                                             0.5
                                                                   around other economies.
                                                                   Scenario 4: A new currency union is formed by the                  -1.5                                             0.6
                                                                   stronger economies.

1     What next for the eurozone - Possible scenarios for 2012.”
    “
    Available from: www.pwc.co.uk. Updated scenarios published
    March 2012.
2   Ibid.




                                                                                                                                                                                          Potential scenarios   9
Scenario 1                           Policy action                                                          •	 Crisis is initially contained by ECB bank financing and agreement on
                                                                                                               Greek debt haircut.
Successive phases of                                                                                        •	 Greece fails to meet the conditions of the deal, triggering another round of ECB
monetary and fiscal action                                                                                     financing coupled with fiscal transfers to peripheral economies in exchange for
                                                                                                               austerity measures.
hold the eurozone together                                                                                  •	 A looser monetary policy is adopted at the end of 2012 to help restore the
at the cost of inflation.                                                                                      competitiveness of the peripheral economies.
                                     Short-term outcomes                                                    •	 No or low growth will put downward pressure on inflation, signalling a looser
                                                                                                               monetary policy in 2013.
                                                                                                            •	 “Internal appreciation” of Germany in relation to the periphery helps alleviate
                                                                                                               recessionary pressure in peripheral economies by improving their trade balances.
                                                                                                            •	 Improved credit conditions and confidence could support GDP growth of 2% in
                                                                                                               2014, as the survival of the euro looks increasingly certain.
                                     Medium-term outcomes                                                   •	 Higher inflation should ease debt restructuring, and improve competitiveness of
                                                                                                               peripheral European economies.
                                                                                                            •	 ECB raises interest rates to bring down inflation in the medium-term and
                                                                                                               restore credibility.
                                                                                                            •	 Most eurozone countries will be running primary surpluses for many years, putting a
                                                                                                               drag on growth.

                              Higher inflation in the core Eurozone
                              countries could restore the relative
                              competitiveness in the core eurozone countries could restore
                               Higher inflation of the periphery.                                                                       The policy response restores confidence and prevents
                                      the relative competitiveness of the periphery.                                                    a prolonged recession.

                                                               140
                             Consumer Price Index




                                                                                                                                         Eurozone         2012     2013     2014      2015     2016
                                                               130                                    Forecast
                                                                                                                                         GDP growth        0.1      0.7       2       1.5         1.5
                                                    2004=100




                                                               120                                                                       Inflation         1.5      3.0      3.5       3          2

                                                               110

                                                               100
                                                                     2004


                                                                             2006


                                                                                    2008


                                                                                           2010


                                                                                                    2012


                                                                                                            2014


                                                                                                                   2016




                                                                     Spain                        Germany
                                                               Source: Eurostat and PwC Analysis




10   FS Viewpoint
Scenario 2                    Policy action                                                   •	 Following the Greek precedent, other highly-indebted economies seek to restructure
                                                                                                 their debts.
Voluntary defaults for                                                                        •	 We assume a 50% default on Portuguese and Irish sovereign debt and a 25%
highly-indebted sovereigns.                                                                      default on Italian debt.
                                                                                              •	 In parallel, we assume leaders agree to measures aimed at insulating the rest of the
                                                                                                 eurozone from a collapse in confidence.
                              Short-term outcomes                                             •	 We estimate that the restructuring will cause a private sector wealth loss of up to
                                                                                                 €800bn, including €100bn to banks.
                                                                                              •	 Bank losses would be partially recapitalized by governments, the European Financial
                                                                                                 Stability Facility (EFSF), and the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), but lending
                                                                                                 would also need to be reduced.
                                                                                              •	 We expect that this would precipitate a contractionary debt spiral dragging the
                                                                                                 eurozone into a deep and protracted recession.
                              Medium-term outcomes                                            •	 We expect that restructuring governments will be locked out of credit markets
                                                                                                 and require long-term support from the rest of the eurozone and other
                                                                                                 bilateral institutions.
                                                                                              •	 Over time, these countries would have to reestablish credibility with investors.




                              Bank losses could total over €100 billion,
                              whichlosses could total over €100 billion, which could
                              Bank could precipitate a contractionary                                                      ...such a credit contraction could lead to a
                              debt spiral... contractionary debt spiral...
                              precipitate a                                                                                deep recession

                              € 35,000
                              € 30,000                                                                                      Eurozone          2012     2013     2014     2015       2016
                              € 25,000                                                                                      GDP growth         -3      -1.5     -0.5       1           2
                              € 20,000
                                                                                                                            Inflation           1        0        0        1           2
                              € 15,000
                              € 10,000
                               € 5,000
                                    0
                                         Italy

                                                 Greece*

                                                           France

                                                                    Germany

                                                                              Portugal

                                                                                         UK

                                                                                              Ireland

                                                                                                        Spain




                               Source: EBA. *Data as at 30 Dec, 2010




                                                                                                                                                                  Potential scenarios      11
Scenario 3                  Policy action                                   •	 Greece exits the eurozone by imposing temporary capital controls and
                                                                               redenominating all new and existing contracts in new drachma.
Greece exits the eurozone                                                   •	 The eurozone commits to saving the euro and uses the ECB and EFSF to build a
and a firewall is built                                                        firewall around other vulnerable economies.

around other economies.     Greece outcomes                                 •	 We expect that the new drachma could depreciate by as much as 50%, constituting
                                                                               an implicit default on debt.
                                                                            •	 Inflation would soar, potentially averaging 10% in 2012.
                                                                            •	 The Greek economy would enter a severe recession as credit conditions and
                                                                               confidence deteriorate and further fiscal austerity is mandated in return for
                                                                               IMF funding.
                                                                            •	 In the medium term, the economy could recover—driven by exports spurred by a
                                                                               weaker currency and improved competitiveness.
                            Rest of eurozone outcomes                       •	 We expect this would cause an 18-month recession in the eurozone as investors’
                                                                               losses and shaken confidence lead to capital flight and deteriorating credit
                                                                               conditions.
                                                                            •	 But the Greek exit also would provide an impetus for other vulnerable countries
                                                                               to bring forward fiscal and structural reforms to “avoid the Greek fate,” improving
                                                                               longer-term growth prospects.




                            Historical devaluations have led to tosharp contraction in
                            Historical devaluations have led a a sharp                                  The region would suffer an immediate but short-lived
                            GDP lasting one to two years. to 2 years
                            contraction in GDP lasting 1                                                recession and growth would resume after 18 months.

                                  GDP index (100 = year of devaluation)                                                         2012      2013   2014   2015     2016
                            120
                            115
                                                                                                       GDP         Greece        -5       -1.5    0      2.6         2.8
                            110
                                                                                                       growth
                            105
                                                                                                                   Rest of       -1       0.5     1      1.6         1.8
                            100
                                                                                                                   eurozone
                             95
                             90                                                                        Inflation   Greece        10        8      8       6          6
                             85
                             80                                                                                    Rest of       1.5      1.8     2       2          2
                                     0               1          2             3                                    eurozone
                                  Sweden (1992)          Thailand (1997)
                                  Indonesia (1997)       Argentina (2001)
                                  Korea (1997)

                             Source: IMF, PwC analysis




12   FS Viewpoint
Scenario 4                Policy action                                                                        •	 A Franco-German acknowledgement that the existing eurozone is unsustainable
                                                                                                                  paves the way for a new, smaller, and more tightly regulated currency bloc.
A new currency union is                                                                                        •	 The new bloc includes: Germany, France, the Netherlands, Finland, and some of the
formed by the stronger                                                                                            stronger new member states.

economies.                                                                                                     •	 More stringent rules are set out for members on fiscal union and structural positions.
                          “New euro”                                                                           •	 New bloc benefits from an inflow of capital in the first year.
                          bloc outcomes
                                                                                                               •	 However, transition costs and a loss of competitiveness as a result of the stronger
                                                                                                                  currency would drag on growth in 2012.
                                                                                                               •	 The new euro exchange rate could be permanently higher by up to 15% compared
                                                                                                                  to the exchange rate for major trading partners.
                          Periphery outcomes                                                                   •	 Economies that break away from the euro face challenges of depreciating exchange
                                                                                                                  rates, soaring inflation, and falling output.
                                                                                                               •	 Future success will depend on their ability to rebuild credible fiscal and monetary
                                                                                                                  institutions.




                          Countries with weak economic fundamentals are most at
                          Countries with weak economic fundamentals                                                                         The new eurozone will experience a boost in domestic
                          risk if the euro were to break up.
                          are most at risk if the euro were to break up                                                                     demand while the periphery contracts in 2012.
                          Indicative scorecard of economic and fiscal
                          fundamentals (selected eurozone countries)


                                                   Greece                                                                                                           2012     2013   2014     2015    2016
                           Stronger fundamentals




                                                   Portugal
                                                   Ireland                                                                               GDP         New euro        0.3      2.5    2.5       2          2
                                                   Italy                                                                                 growth
                                                   Spain                                                                                             Periphery        -5      -2      0        2          3
                                                   Belgium
                                                   France                                                                                Inflation   New euro         -1       0      0        2          2
                                                   Germany
                                                   Netherlands                                                                                       Periphery       10        8      7        5          3
                                                   Finland
                                                                 government debt
                                                                 Gross general
                                                                                   (% of GDP)
                                                                                   Budget deficit
                                                                                                    yields
                                                                                                    10-year
                                                                                                              GDP growth
                                                                                                              Expected
                                                                                                                           outlook
                                                                                                                           Ratings




                                                                                                                                                                                    Potential scenarios       13
Exit of a country from the   A country leaving the eurozone may need to do     •	 Decide how to deal with existing outstanding
                             the following:                                       euro-denominated debt, which would
eurozone will have broad                                                          probably entail a major government and
                             •	 Announce and immediately impose capital
and far-reaching impacts.       controls.
                                                                                  private-sector debt restructuring (i.e.,
                                                                                  default).
                             •	 Impose immediate trade controls to limit
                                                                               •	 Recapitalize the insolvent banks to make up
                                capital outflows.
                                                                                  for losses from defaults.
                             •	 Impose immediate border controls to prevent
                                                                               •	 Determine what to do with the non-bank
                                a flight of cash.
                                                                                  financial sector and the stock and bond
                             •	 Implement a bank holiday to prevent a “run        markets.
                                on the bank.”
                                                                               •	 Determine how to handle commercial
                             •	 Announce a new exchange rate (presumably          contracts that are written and denominated
                                not floating at the beginning, given capital      in euros and now may be in the new
                                and exchange controls) so that trade could        currency.
                                continue.
                             •	 Convert all euro-denominated notes and coin
                                to a new currency.




14   FS Viewpoint
Implications for US corporations
How does all this impact   Eurozone restructuring has the potential to        Thus, companies should be more fully prepared
                           create significant change and disruption to        for a range of unpredictable outcomes. One way
US corporations?           the operations of many firms. These changes        to accomplish this is to focus on the potential
                           would potentially materialize when the broader     consequences of the four scenarios outlined to
                           economic and market environment create             determine what actions would be required at
                           conditions in which many companies cannot          an organizational level based on likely market
                           afford the direct and indirect costs to their      conditions, such as a credit crunch or currency
                           businesses of carrying out such changes.           devaluation.
                           Many of the specific actions required at the       Based on this analysis, companies can
                           organization level following a complete or         proactively develop contingency plans to
                           partial eurozone restructuring will be intrusive   address the potential consequences of various
                           to the processes, systems, and operations of       potential eurozone scenarios and begin to take
                           an organization and will have to be executed       steps to help minimize the risks today.
                           quickly and with minimal lead time for impact
                           assessment and action planning.




16   FS Viewpoint
Potential actions required   We expect the euro crisis to have a broad and
                             profound impact on US-based multinational
                             companies in the following areas, among others:



                               1    Business model and structure

                               2    Revenue

                               3    Treasury

                               4    Legal

                               5    Procurement and supply contracts

                               6    IT

                               7    Finance

                               8    HR/people

                               9    Tax

                              10    Crisis/incident management




                                                                               Implications for US corporations   17
1 	 Business model
1.                   Problem statement                  In setting long-term business strategy—what products to make, what markets to
                                                        target, where to source and manufacture, how to organize the company, where to raise
    and structure                                       and deploy capital—companies have typically planned based on the assumption of
                                                        a stable eurozone and regulatory environment with stable, moderate growth and the
                                                        free flow of goods, capital and people. The current crisis has called many of these
                                                        assumptions into question. As a result, many companies, particularly those with heavy
                                                        business activities in Europe or significant European stakeholders, will need to question
                                                        many of the fundamental assumptions that have formed the basis of their strategies,
                                                        business models, and organizational structures.
                     Critical questions                 •	 How might the various potential outcomes for the euro impact overall
                                                           corporate strategy?
                                                        •	 Where do we want to invest capital going forward? Which countries (inside and
                                                           outside the eurozone) will present attractive investment opportunities going forward?
                                                        •	 How will the crisis impact ability to effectively borrow and invest in the eurozone?
                                                        •	 Could the break-up of the eurozone result in increased regulatory costs and
                                                           additional friction in the flow of goods and services within the region?
                                                        •	 Will the declining attractiveness of European markets increase the level of
                                                           competition in other developed and developing markets?
                                                        •	 How should companies best alter their European footprint under various potential
                                                           outcomes?
                     Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Significant declines in economic growth reduces the attractiveness of
                     for corporations                      European markets.
                                                        •	 Reduced growth and higher costs result in impairment of prior investments.
                                                        •	 Constrained capital markets result in further challenges to fund European growth
                                                           and investment.
                                                        •	 Reduced growth and constrained credit weaken the supplier base and create
                                                           significant operational risks.




18   FS Viewpoint
2. 	 Revenue
2              Problem statement                  Corporate revenue and profit margins are based on uninterrupted global demand and
                                                  supply as well as free flows of capital, labor, and goods throughout the eurozone.
                                                  Should these be disrupted by the crisis (e.g., through a collapse in sales, FX
                                                  movements, or capital controls), the impact on revenues will be significant and could
                                                  undermine the viability of businesses.
                                                  Some countries may impose some form of currency controls in order to limit the
                                                  shocks to their economies. Countries with strong currencies but small economies (e.g.,
                                                  Swiss franc) will also try to suppress the value of their currencies through the use of
                                                  market mechanisms.
               Critical questions                 •	 Under what scenario and in what circumstances is revenue most at risk? How long
                                                     can businesses survive with below-average sales in the eurozone?
                                                  •	 Under what scenarios do eurozone countries become unattractive to sell to
                                                     or produce in?
                                                  •	 Can potential exposures be hedged? Have non-traditional/natural hedging strategies
                                                     been considered?
                                                  •	 Have alternative growth strategies been identified and reviewed?
                                                  •	 Can the business still afford to serve clients in euros in the short—and
                                                     medium—term? Do margins need recalculating and pricing pegged to a more
                                                     “stable” currency?
               Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 A collapse in sales could occur as a result of severe recession or unfavorable price
               for corporations                      and foreign exchange movements.
                                                  •	 Liquidity shortages as a result of sales collapse and regulatory measures could limit
                                                     cross-border transfers.
                                                  •	 Revenue streams could be significantly impacted through sharp foreign exchange
                                                     movements.




                                                                                                        Implications for US corporations    19
3.	Treasury
 3                  Problem statement                  Treasury must be prepared for the significant and difficult changes that would
                                                       occur under each scenario. A credit squeeze is likely to result. Possible capital and
                                                       foreign exchange controls may need to be invoked at short notice and eurozone
                                                       hedging strategies may need to be disaggregated by country, with aspects no longer
                                                       effective as new currencies are created. Additionally, treasury should understand
                                                       which scenarios will cause covenants to be triggered and cash to be trapped, and
                                                       set parameters for exchange rate appetites if volatility increases and new currencies
                                                       are created.
                    Critical questions                 •	 Is there an appropriate forum for discussing working capital and cash forecasting?
                                                          Have counterparty risk policies and credit scoring processes been reviewed? Is the
                                                          business appropriately hedged?
                                                       •	 How is credit risk currently monitored? Should changes be made to better predict
                                                          and/or react to declining credit?
                                                       •	 How legally enforceable are netting arrangements to reduce exposure?
                                                       •	 What cash can be moved to neutralize euro exposures, surplus repatriated?
                                                          Facilities redenominated?
                                                       •	 Will weaker eurozone banks be able to provide local funding?
                                                       •	 What will become of local deposits, if banks are no longer functioning?
                                                       •	 How might a company redirect/collect customer payments outside high
                                                          risk countries?
                                                       •	 Will cash pooling structures continue to be viable and efficient?
                                                       •	 How might increasing currency volatility impact FX hedging programs?
                    Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Diversity of funding arrangements, credit risk, trapped cash risk, off balance sheet
                    for corporations                      contingencies triggered
                                                       •	 Forecasted internal cash reserves, intercompany balances
                                                       •	 Debt arrangements upon currency restriction events, covenant implications
                                                       •	 Cross-border cash management structures and credit facility interaction
                                                       •	 Working capital strain as customers take longer to pay, suppliers weaken without
                                                          prompt payment, and foreign exchange rates change or become increasingly volatile
                                                       •	 Enforceability of euro derivatives/country of bank counterparty
                                                       •	 Volatility arising from ineffective hedging strategies or hedge accounting




20   FS Viewpoint
4. 	 Legal
4            Problem statement                  For many organizations, legal contracts are based on existing EU law and the
                                                premise of a stable single currency, governed by the ECB. Should any of the four
                                                scenarios occur, sales, supply, and employment contracts (among others) are likely to
                                                require review and some revision. In extreme circumstances, contracts may become
                                                unenforceable. The consequences will vary dependent on applicable governing law
                                                and jurisdiction. Payment obligations will be dependent on applicable exchange rates.
                                                This in turn could cause defaults to occur. The potential for associated disputes could
                                                also increase.
             Critical questions                 •	 Is the potential impact on key contracts fully understood?
                                                •	 In the event of changes to either the currency of payment or the reference/regulatory
                                                   bodies, are the associated contractual obligations and flow down provisions clear?
                                                •	 Are the definitions within existing contracts still valid?
                                                •	 Have the potential commercial risks been considered, as well as how these risks can
                                                   be avoided or mitigated?
                                                •	 Has the financial impact of employment contracts and packages been evaluated?
                                                •	 Is there a plan in place to identify and solve legal exposures?
             Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 All key commercial contracts including supply contracts, sales contracts, joint-
             for corporations                      venture agreements, distribution agreements, and IP licensing arrangements
                                                •	 Payment arrangements and systems and support service agreements
                                                •	 Transfer pricing
                                                •	 Impact on cross default provision arising from contractual default
                                                •	 Currency hedging and treasury management
                                                •	 Referencing in all contracts (for example, euro-dependent provisions, reference to
                                                   bodies such as ECB or eurozone, Material Adverse Change)
                                                •	 Employee terms and conditions (such as salary, bonus, and other remuneration)




                                                                                                         Implications for US corporations   21
5. 	 Procurement and
 5                      Problem statement                  Many global organizations, especially large consumer products companies, rely on
                                                           sourcing raw materials, products and services needed for their operations from the
     supply contracts                                      eurozone countries. They also supply clients across Europe from different EU and non-
                                                           EU hubs. With the four scenarios in mind, the changes could result in the creation of
                                                           European low-cost countries. For US Companies, these changes could imply:
                                                           •	 Strategic sourcing decisions may need to be revisited with changes to price or
                                                              availability conditions.
                                                           •	 Supply models may need changes in pricing, logistics, invoicing, and transportion.
                                                           •	 Alternate vendors may be needed or activities may need to be brought in-house if
                                                              the vendors are unable to survive the outcome of the crisis.
                        Critical questions                 •	 Will there be low-cost country opportunities created as a result of
                                                              eurozone restructuring?
                                                           •	 Are there supply-chain risks as a result of rising material costs for suppliers no
                                                              longer in the eurozone?
                                                           •	 Can the impacts of those moves be reliably modelled (e.g., on cost or profit margin)?
                                                           •	 Can the impact of supply-side changes on key clients’ supply chains be anticipated?
                                                           •	 Are there alternative sources of supply for critical products and services? Are rapid
                                                              moves to an alternative supplier feasible?
                                                           •	 Are multiple critical suppliers in the same situation (i.e., could an organization
                                                              experience multiple vendor failures)?
                                                           •	 How might a company redirect/collect customer payments outside
                                                              high-risk countries?
                        Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 The cost of producing and operating could change dramatically as a result of sharp
                        for corporations                      economic and foreign exchange movements.
                                                           •	 Potential cost reduction opportunities may arise.
                                                           •	 Supply continuity for critical raw materials and products may need to be monitored.
                                                           •	 Supply chain reviews should be considered for the most price-sensitive products
                                                              and services, resulting in potential service model changes.
                                                           •	 Different cost and margin scenarios may need to be evaluated, and alternative
                                                              suppliers may be needed if the impact is material.
                                                           •	 Make/buy decisions may need to be revisited across a range of products, and new
                                                              efficiencies should be realized.




22   FS Viewpoint
6. 	 IT
6         Problem statement                  Regardless of size, complexity, or industry, companies are becoming increasingly
                                             reliant on IT/IS systems—both within their own companies as well as with customers,
                                             suppliers, and vendors—to conduct business operations. This reliance will create
                                             challenges for organizations to:
                                             •	 Understand the impact that the different scenarios will have on the IT environment
                                                and the various interfaces between systems (both external and internal)
                                             •	 Ensure that internal systems can remain flexible and adaptable enough to meet the
                                                demands of new and changing regulations and market environments
                                             •	 Ensure that external vendors of hardware, software, and services have developed
                                                plans to deal with each potential scenario and are able to maintain continuity of
                                                operations
                                             •	 Implement potentially significant master and transaction data changes
                                             In addition to these challenges, organizations should gauge their readiness to exploit
                                             the opportunities presented (such as integration, renegotiation of support deals,
                                             and relocation).
          Critical questions                 •	 Which systems and business areas are most exposed to the changes set out in
                                                the scenarios?
                                             •	 Do company systems have the ability to be modified to handle new currencies?
                                             •	 Can company systems handle the redenomination of historical transactions?
                                             •	 Have systems and vendors critical for survival of the organization been identified?
                                             •	 Do external vendors have plans in place to ensure continuity of IT and
                                                communications infrastructure and services?
                                             •	 Are transactions and reporting set up to accommodate a high-inflation environment?
          Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Work required to amend existing applications and data
          for corporations
                                             •	 Lack of control over IT systems due to contractual or physical limitations in the
                                                ability to reconfigure
                                             •	 Inability of systems to cope with extreme changes in inflation and valuations,
                                                including the ability to forecast and restate past performance
                                             •	 Inability of outsourced service providers to maintain continuity of their systems and
                                                to provide agreed-upon services
                                             •	 Potential increase in capacity from institutions switching businesses to non-
                                                impacted countries
                                             •	 Collapse of IT service providers, or inability to honor contractual obligations around
                                                IT service provision




                                                                                                    Implications for US corporations     23
7. 	 Finance
 7                  Problem statement                  The Finance function is heavily exposed to eurozone challenges in terms of:
                                                       •	 Accountability for planning, budgeting, and forecasting in very uncertain times by
                                                          building scenarios and securing board agreement with them.
                                                       •	 Managing increased costs (both of finance and the whole organization) and
                                                          interpreting their impacts to the organization.
                                                       •	 Keeping statutory reporting in line without major increases of effort.
                                                       •	 Dealing with increased reporting requirements and new types of what-if analyses
                                                          and complex simulations.
                    Critical questions                 •	 Is your Finance operating model still relevant?
                                                       •	 Is the sourcing strategy still optimal, does the restructuring provide opportunities to
                                                          revisit shared-service locations and outsourcing contracts?
                                                       •	 Would outsourcing transactional activity mitigate risk in volatile markets during
                                                          eurozone restructuring?
                                                       •	 How quickly could the organization exit outsourced or shared environments within
                                                          unstable economies?
                                                       •	 Can statutory and management reporting be produced with current resources and
                                                          without compromising quality?
                                                       •	 Is the function set up to deal with inflation, currencies leaving the eurozone, and the
                                                          introduction of a significant number of new currencies?
                                                       •	 Can costs arising from the changes described in the four scenarios be
                                                          modeled reliably?
                                                       •	 Is finance ready to take on a much bigger role in communicating these changes to
                                                          the rest of your organization?
                                                       •	 Do you understand the potential financial reporting impacts of each scenario,
                                                          including matters like revenue recognition, asset impairment, and hedge accounting?
                    Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Service agreements with outsourced providers
                    for corporations
                                                       •	 Continued availability of qualified staff
                                                       •	 Continued robustness and adequacy of the control environment
                                                       •	 Shared-service center (SSC) location, setup, and internal pricing
                                                       •	 Enterprise resource planning (ERP) and reporting systems
                                                       •	 Current data models
                                                       •	 Accounting policy matters and financial reporting impacts




24   FS Viewpoint
8. 	 HR/people
8                Problem statement                  For businesses operating in Europe, the HR function is key to supporting the business
                                                    strategy while adapting to the impact of economic and legislative change on staff
                                                    operations. With differences in specific HR needs among countries likely to increase,
                                                    HR functions should be equipped to deal with increasing complexity while managing
                                                    limited resources. Resources will be stretched to balance both short-and long-term
                                                    measures in dealing with rapid change while facing sustained pressure to cut costs.
                 Critical questions                 •	 With sustained pressure on cost reduction, how will HR operating models and
                                                       structures cope with differing demands across territories?
                                                    •	 How will talent be retained in less stable countries while dealing with sustained
                                                       financial pressure and rapid change?
                                                    •	 Will businesses need restructuring in response to changes in the eurozone? How will
                                                       the impact of this be addressed with respect to human resource operations?
                                                    •	 Have you defined your duty of care and responsibility to your employees in the event
                                                       of collective actions in which they are impacted?
                                                    •	 Is your team clear on how you will communicate to employees in the event of
                                                       collective actions which keep them from work?
                                                    •	 Do business continuity plans consider the potential for civil unrest or even military
                                                       conflict?
                 Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Managing a mobile and global workforce could become increasingly complex, with
                 for corporations                      less standardization across Europe in terms of tax and employment law. Businesses
                                                       should be equipped to deal with the increased risks associated with these changes,
                                                       including areas such as rewards and pensions.
                                                    •	 Those operating in less stable European countries may find themselves struggling to
                                                       retain talent as employees seek more secure environments.
                                                    •	 Some companies will need to respond to changes in the eurozone by restructuring
                                                       their businesses and contracting for high-risk operations. The implications for HR
                                                       and people activity should be dealt with appropriately, for example when redeploying
                                                       or making headcount reductions.




                                                                                                           Implications for US corporations    25
9. 	 Tax
 9                  Problem statement                  Companies should understand the immediate tax consequences arising from various
                                                       scenarios regarding the future of the eurozone. It will be important for companies to
                                                       weigh the tax efficiencies of their proposed mitigation strategies.
                    Critical questions                 •	 Do the changes give rise to a new contract from an accounting perspective? This
                                                          may result in the recognition of profit or losses for accounting purposes that could
                                                          also be taxable or relievable.
                                                       •	 Do the changes give rise to a new contract from a legal and tax perspective?
                                                          Modification of an existing contract could potentially represent the termination of the
                                                          original contract and the creation of a new contract. This could crystallize a taxing
                                                          event (i.e., the changes could trigger a disposal for capital gains purposes).
                                                       •	 Where the contracts are between related parties, then an additional question is
                                                          whether an arm’s length fee should be paid to the counterparty as compensation for
                                                          the change in terms. The tax treatment of this fee would need to be considered from
                                                          both parties’ perspectives, and whether this payment would be taxable on one side
                                                          and deductible on the other.
                                                       •	 Will any losses be tax-deductible and can they be utilized or will they become
                                                          “trapped?” How does this change the tax profile of the group?
                                                       •	 What happens if any foreign exchange gains should arise (e.g., due to a smaller,
                                                          stronger euro)?
                                                       •	 What will be the impact on business if it cannot defer foreign exchange gains or
                                                          losses under the tax matching rules, where the hedge becomes ineffective from a tax
                                                          perspective?
                                                       •	 Has taxation been factored into contingency plans such that they are as tax efficient
                                                          as possible?
                    Key areas of exposure and impact   •	 Different scenarios may create losses; it is important to understand whether these
                    for corporations                      are foreign-exchange losses or impairment losses and the deductibility of these for
                                                          tax purposes.
                                                       •	 Redenomination of foreign assets and liabilities may result in hedges becoming
                                                          ineffective from a tax perspective.
                                                       •	 If the changes cause new contracts, especially loans, to be brought into existence,
                                                          this may impact existing agreements with the taxing authorities (e.g., withholding
                                                          tax clearances may be affected). It may also affect other taxes (e.g., VAT if there is a
                                                          change in value of the contract).




26   FS Viewpoint
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation
Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation

More Related Content

What's hot

Data Mining Article on Page 6
Data Mining Article on Page 6Data Mining Article on Page 6
Data Mining Article on Page 6Amjad Zaim
 
G E P2010 Full Report
G E P2010  Full  ReportG E P2010  Full  Report
G E P2010 Full Reportgigiii
 
Summit view sept_2010
Summit view sept_2010Summit view sept_2010
Summit view sept_2010njmsn
 
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Ppt
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.PptKeys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Ppt
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Pptmlewisblossman
 
What do recessions look like?
What do recessions look like?What do recessions look like?
What do recessions look like?mattbentley34
 
Jll Hotel Survey Dec 8 08
Jll Hotel  Survey Dec 8 08Jll Hotel  Survey Dec 8 08
Jll Hotel Survey Dec 8 08Marcusroberts
 
Report of mangerail
Report of mangerailReport of mangerail
Report of mangerailsaad ali
 
2010 Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget
2010  	Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget2010  	Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget
2010 Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budgeteconsultbw
 
Weo2009 April
Weo2009   AprilWeo2009   April
Weo2009 AprilPeter Ho
 
Export and import
Export and importExport and import
Export and importguest340c4c
 
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011yuxx88
 

What's hot (18)

Data Mining Article on Page 6
Data Mining Article on Page 6Data Mining Article on Page 6
Data Mining Article on Page 6
 
H 5 (Imf)
H 5 (Imf)H 5 (Imf)
H 5 (Imf)
 
G E P2010 Full Report
G E P2010  Full  ReportG E P2010  Full  Report
G E P2010 Full Report
 
Summit view sept_2010
Summit view sept_2010Summit view sept_2010
Summit view sept_2010
 
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Ppt
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.PptKeys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Ppt
Keys To Success In Restructuring Hr.Ppt
 
Joseluis samaniego
Joseluis samaniegoJoseluis samaniego
Joseluis samaniego
 
What do recessions look like?
What do recessions look like?What do recessions look like?
What do recessions look like?
 
Jll Hotel Survey Dec 8 08
Jll Hotel  Survey Dec 8 08Jll Hotel  Survey Dec 8 08
Jll Hotel Survey Dec 8 08
 
Report of mangerail
Report of mangerailReport of mangerail
Report of mangerail
 
World Economic Situation and Prospects Monthly Briefing No. 38
World Economic Situation and Prospects Monthly Briefing No. 38World Economic Situation and Prospects Monthly Briefing No. 38
World Economic Situation and Prospects Monthly Briefing No. 38
 
09 4 Qtr Office Review
09 4 Qtr Office Review09 4 Qtr Office Review
09 4 Qtr Office Review
 
2010 Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget
2010  	Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget2010  	Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget
2010 Q1: Feature on the 2010 Monetary Policy Statement and Budget
 
Beatriz Armendariz
Beatriz ArmendarizBeatriz Armendariz
Beatriz Armendariz
 
Weo2009 April
Weo2009   AprilWeo2009   April
Weo2009 April
 
Export and import
Export and importExport and import
Export and import
 
Europe@Risk Report 2008
 Europe@Risk Report 2008 Europe@Risk Report 2008
Europe@Risk Report 2008
 
2011 june-17
2011 june-172011 june-17
2011 june-17
 
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011
Overnight Market Wrap 10.4.2011
 

Similar to Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation

Banking in 2050 by PwC
Banking in 2050 by PwCBanking in 2050 by PwC
Banking in 2050 by PwCiRexy 何
 
K bank fx & rates strategies an update of eurozone
K bank fx & rates strategies   an update of eurozoneK bank fx & rates strategies   an update of eurozone
K bank fx & rates strategies an update of eurozoneKBank Fx Dealing Room
 
From supervision to resolution next steps on the road to european banking un...
From supervision to resolution  next steps on the road to european banking un...From supervision to resolution  next steps on the road to european banking un...
From supervision to resolution next steps on the road to european banking un...ManfredNolte
 
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decade
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decadeVgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decade
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decadeFahd Rachidy
 
Global Crisis Monitor June July 2009
Global Crisis Monitor   June July 2009Global Crisis Monitor   June July 2009
Global Crisis Monitor June July 2009Alvin Chua
 
sovereign-debt-crisis
sovereign-debt-crisissovereign-debt-crisis
sovereign-debt-crisisjaiahn
 
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013Stephan Kuester
 
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011Swedbank
 
Greece restructuring analysis
Greece restructuring analysisGreece restructuring analysis
Greece restructuring analysisjzaccaria
 
Euro Crisis: What Next?
Euro Crisis: What Next?Euro Crisis: What Next?
Euro Crisis: What Next?Cognizant
 
D&B’s Global Economic Outlook
D&B’s Global Economic OutlookD&B’s Global Economic Outlook
D&B’s Global Economic OutlookDun & Bradstreet
 
Goran Pitić, intervju
Goran Pitić, intervjuGoran Pitić, intervju
Goran Pitić, intervjuFEFA Faculty
 
FMI, Gravando las Finanzas
FMI, Gravando las FinanzasFMI, Gravando las Finanzas
FMI, Gravando las FinanzasManfredNolte
 
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?Boston Consulting Group
 
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forward
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forwardCyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forward
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forwardStavros A. Zenios
 
June 2010 summitview
June 2010 summitviewJune 2010 summitview
June 2010 summitviewnjmsn
 
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton
 

Similar to Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation (20)

Banking in 2050 by PwC
Banking in 2050 by PwCBanking in 2050 by PwC
Banking in 2050 by PwC
 
K bank fx & rates strategies an update of eurozone
K bank fx & rates strategies   an update of eurozoneK bank fx & rates strategies   an update of eurozone
K bank fx & rates strategies an update of eurozone
 
From supervision to resolution next steps on the road to european banking un...
From supervision to resolution  next steps on the road to european banking un...From supervision to resolution  next steps on the road to european banking un...
From supervision to resolution next steps on the road to european banking un...
 
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decade
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decadeVgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decade
Vgis macro the pigs and the emu lost decade
 
Global Crisis Monitor June July 2009
Global Crisis Monitor   June July 2009Global Crisis Monitor   June July 2009
Global Crisis Monitor June July 2009
 
Financing Globalisation
Financing GlobalisationFinancing Globalisation
Financing Globalisation
 
Advice for the wise december 2011
Advice for the wise   december 2011Advice for the wise   december 2011
Advice for the wise december 2011
 
sovereign-debt-crisis
sovereign-debt-crisissovereign-debt-crisis
sovereign-debt-crisis
 
Mibytes November 2011
Mibytes November 2011Mibytes November 2011
Mibytes November 2011
 
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013
EY Eurozone forecast spring 2013
 
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011The Global Economy No. 8 -  November 30, 2011
The Global Economy No. 8 - November 30, 2011
 
Greece restructuring analysis
Greece restructuring analysisGreece restructuring analysis
Greece restructuring analysis
 
Euro Crisis: What Next?
Euro Crisis: What Next?Euro Crisis: What Next?
Euro Crisis: What Next?
 
D&B’s Global Economic Outlook
D&B’s Global Economic OutlookD&B’s Global Economic Outlook
D&B’s Global Economic Outlook
 
Goran Pitić, intervju
Goran Pitić, intervjuGoran Pitić, intervju
Goran Pitić, intervju
 
FMI, Gravando las Finanzas
FMI, Gravando las FinanzasFMI, Gravando las Finanzas
FMI, Gravando las Finanzas
 
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?
How Should Financial Institutions Navigate the COVID-19 Crisis?
 
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forward
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forwardCyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forward
Cyprus Debt. The perfect crisis and a way forward
 
June 2010 summitview
June 2010 summitviewJune 2010 summitview
June 2010 summitview
 
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
Grant Thornton UK - Restructuring Outlook for 2012
 

More from Harry G. Broadman

Competition Between MNCs from the North and the South
Competition Between MNCs from the North and the SouthCompetition Between MNCs from the North and the South
Competition Between MNCs from the North and the SouthHarry G. Broadman
 
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and Possibilities
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and PossibilitiesChina: Pearls, Pitfalls and Possibilities
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and PossibilitiesHarry G. Broadman
 
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in Africa
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in AfricaThe Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in Africa
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in AfricaHarry G. Broadman
 
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic Engagement
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic EngagementNorth Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic Engagement
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic EngagementHarry G. Broadman
 

More from Harry G. Broadman (7)

Broadman bio 2 3-2017 540pm
Broadman bio 2 3-2017  540pmBroadman bio 2 3-2017  540pm
Broadman bio 2 3-2017 540pm
 
GEEM Website D1_CONTINU
GEEM Website D1_CONTINUGEEM Website D1_CONTINU
GEEM Website D1_CONTINU
 
Competition Between MNCs from the North and the South
Competition Between MNCs from the North and the SouthCompetition Between MNCs from the North and the South
Competition Between MNCs from the North and the South
 
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and Possibilities
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and PossibilitiesChina: Pearls, Pitfalls and Possibilities
China: Pearls, Pitfalls and Possibilities
 
On Investing In Africa
On Investing In AfricaOn Investing In Africa
On Investing In Africa
 
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in Africa
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in AfricaThe Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in Africa
The Backstory of Chinese & Indian Investment in Africa
 
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic Engagement
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic EngagementNorth Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic Engagement
North Korea Inside Out: The Case for Economic Engagement
 

Eurozone Crisis: Strategies for Risk Mitigation

  • 1. fs viewpoint www.pwc.com/fsi 02 08 15 28 May 2012 Understanding Potential Implications for What companies the crisis scenarios US corporations are doing now Breaking Up is Hard to Do: The Eurozone Crisis—Possible Implications and Contingency Planning for US Companies
  • 3. Eurozone crisis The current eurozone debt crisis, while building Reform momentum is growing as political up over time, was triggered in April 2010 when leaders face up to this moment after more Eurostat, the Europe Union (EU) statistical than two years of procrastination and wishful authority, revealed that Greece’s 2009 budget thinking. Arguably, some of the largest deficit was €32.3 billion, or 13.6% of its gross financing hurdles in the most at-risk countries domestic product (GDP). In 2009, Greece had have been overcome, with yields on both short- estimated its deficit for 2009 would come in at and long-term debt significantly lower than at 3.7% of GDP. The EU’s limit is 3%.¹ the end of 2011, and consumer and industrial confidence beginning to improve. Nevertheless, Global markets have since responded to the significant operational risks remain for US magnitude of sovereign debt in other eurozone firms operating in the eurozone. Contingency countries as investors question the ability of planning can help mitigate the risk, and the these countries to repay their debts.² strategies adopted by US firms will depend on Greece, Portugal, and Ireland have requested likely market conditions. In this publication, financial assistance from the European Central PwC will outline four possible scenarios for Bank (ECB), the European Commission (EC), the eurozone’s future that can help guide US and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to corporate decision-making. finance debt repayment. There has also been a stream of European summits to resolve the crisis. Consumer and industrial confidence Consumer and Industrial Confidence Growing market pressure and significant 20 tranches of sovereign debt due for refinancing 10 hint at a possible resolution to the current 0 phase of the crisis. However, there is no silver -10 bullet—any solution will necessarily play out -20 over time, step by step, via fiscal austerity to pay -30 down debt. In addition, deep structural reforms -40 will be necessary to restore competitiveness and -50 boost long-term growth. 2000 - Jan 2001 - Jan 2002 - Jan 2003 - Jan 2004 - Jan 2005 - Jan 2006 - Jan 2007 - Jan 2008 - Jan 2009 - Jan 2010 - Jan 2011 - Jan 2012 - Jan 1   harles Forelle, “EU Sees Wider Greek Deficit, Roiling Markets; C Bonds Fall as Investors View Bailout and Default as Givens,” The Wall Street Journal, April 23, 2010. 2 The eurozone consists of the following 17 European Union member countries who have adopted the euro (European Monetary Union): the 11 original members—Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Industrial confidence Consumer confidence Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, indicator, SA % balance indicator, SA % balance Spain—and Greece (from January 2001), Slovenia (from January Source: Haver Analytics 2007), Cyprus and Malta (from January 2008), Slovakia (from January 2009) and Estonia (from January 2011). Understanding the crisis 3
  • 4. Eurozone crisis In March 2012, The Economist reported, Many forecasters question whether Greece’s “Cheered by the signs of recovery, and relieved partial default on its debt and additional that disaster has been avoided (particularly funding from the ECB and the IMF of €130 in Europe, which towards the end of last year billion is a long-term fix or simply a way to seemed on the brink of a calamity of Lehman- delay the inevitable. Even with this package, like magnitude), financial markets have been Greece’s debt is still expected to be 120% of climbing steadily higher.”¹ GDP in 2020 under what some consider to be optimistic economic and budget assumptions.³ While financial markets have recently started to move higher, GDP data reflected a different As soon as the ink was dry on the Greek bailout story—confirming that the region shrank agreement, market attention turned to debt by 0.3% in the last quarter of 2011 while issues in Italy, Spain, and Portugal, thereby household spending, exports, and imports all signaling a potential continuation of the crisis fell.² Some fear that the eurozone may slide and once again highlighting the historical into deeper recession. origins of the current dilemma. Percent change in real GDP since 2000 Share of EurozoneGDP Share of eurozone GDP Percent Change in Real GDP Since 2000 150 Greece, Ireland, and Portugal: 140 6.1% of eurozone GDP 130 Spain and Italy: 28.5% of eurozone GDP 120 110 Rest of eurozone: 100 65.4% 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Greece Spain Portugal Germany Ireland Italy Source: Haver Analytics, IMF, and WEO Databases. Source: Haver Analytics and PwC analysis 1   Can it be… the recovery?” The Economist, 17 March, 2012. “ 2   Eurozone crisis live: FTSE 100 posts biggest fall of 2012 - as it “ happened,” Guardian Unlimited, March 6, 2012. http://www.guardian.co.uk 3   Greece: Request for Extended Arrangement Under the Extended “ Fund Facility,” IMF Country Report No. 12/57, March 2012. 4 FS Viewpoint
  • 5. The roots of the crisis go Diverging competitiveness This imbalance stemmed from the eurozone’s unique governance structure (part back to the inception of the Divergences in the competitive positions intergovernmental, part supranational) and current-account balances of eurozone euro in 1999 and two countries have been building up over the and macroeconomic policy framework (single monetary policy and devolved underlying problems that past decade. Countries such as Germany fiscal authorities). Additionally, there and the Netherlands gained in price/ have gone unchecked: cost competitiveness while others such as was no mechanism for regulating wider Greece, Ireland, Portugal, and Spain lost macroeconomic imbalances. competitiveness.¹ Current account balance (US$ billion) Manufacturing unit labor cost index Current account balance (US$ billion) Manufacturing unit labor cost index 400 180 300 160 Q1 2000 = 100 200 140 100 120 0 100 -100 80 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 -200 Greece Spain Portugal -300 Germany France Italy -400 Netherland 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Source: OECD Germany Netherland Portugal Greece Spain France Italy Source: IMF 1   European Economy News,” April 2010, European Commission “ Economic and Financial Affairs. Available from http://ec.europa.eu/. Accessed April 10, 2012. Understanding the crisis 5
  • 6. The roots of the crisis go Over-reliance on debt The European banking sector is an important channel of transmission of the crisis because back to the inception of The divergence trend has been supported banks have large holdings of eurozone by a complementary flow of credit from the the euro in 1999 and two surplus countries to the deficit countries. This sovereign debt on their books. The ECB is leading the effort to ease this pressure with the underlying problems that has caused a build up in public and private introduction of its credit facility for the banking have gone unchecked: debt, delayed a correction in competitiveness, and allowed the structural problems of the sector, the long-term refinancing operations eurozone to be largely hidden. Many countries (LTROs). are now struggling to repay this debt. Pubic debt and and deficit estimates (% of GDP)(% Public debt deficit estimates for 2011 for 2011 of GDP) High debt 180 Greece High debt Gov’t debt (% of GDP) High deficit Moderate deficit 160 140 Italy 120 Ireland Portugal Belgium100 France UK 80 Spain 60 -12 -9 -6 -3 0 3 Government deficit (% of GDP) 40 20 Moderate debt 0 Low debt High deficit Axes represent Maastricht limits Low deficit Source: IMF 6 FS Viewpoint
  • 7. The resolution to the crisis Imperfect union will be impeded by the fact The 17 members of the European Monetary Union remain sovereign nations. The following timeline outlines potential trigger events during that the eurozone is not a 2012 that may impact the timing and ultimate resolution of the crisis. political union. March Apr May June… Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Refinancing €14.4 bn €8 bn €9.5 bn €7.7 bn IMF review of Greek bond Greek bond Portuguese Greek bond Greek economy redemption/ redemption bond redemption (Nov) disbursement (May) redemption (Jun) (Aug) (Mar) €14.6 bn IMF IMF review of Review of Greek disbursement to Greek economy economy by the Portugal (Mar) (May) IMF (Aug) €5.5 bn Ireland bond redemption (Mar) Political meetings EU Council G20 Finance EU Council G20 Finance EU Council meeting minister and meeting minister and meeting (1-2/Mar) central banks’ (28-29/Jun) central banks’ (13-14/Dec) meeting (20/Apr) meeting (13-14/Sep) EU Council G20 Summit meeting (18-19/Jun) (18-19/Oct) IMF/World Bank Annual meeting (Oct) Elections First round US presidential of French elections (6/Nov) presidential elections (22/Apr) Greek elections Greek elections (6/May) (6/May) Greek events Understanding the crisis 7
  • 9. Potential scenarios for the Each scenario varies in its likelihood and Projected Eurozone GDP growth under Projected eurozone GDP growth under four scenarios. four scenarios impact. eurozone in 2012. 4% The eurozone that emerges from the crisis 3% There are a number of ways in which the is likely to be very different to the one we 2% 1% eurozone crisis could play out depending on the know today, with 2012 being dominated by 0 mix of policy responses over the next year or uncertainty and high volatility. -1% -2% -3% two. Presented below are four possible, though There is a wide range of potential outcomes. -4% not necessarily exhaustive, scenarios that -5% -6% represent a range of potential resolutions to the 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 crisis in 2012: Scenario 1: Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Successive phases of monetary and fiscal Scenario 3 Scenario 4 action hold the eurozone together at the cost of Source: PwC analysis. inflation. Scenario 2: Voluntary defaults for highly-indebted sovereigns. Scenario 3: Greece exits the eurozone and a firewall is built Scenario description Projected GDP growth (percent)2 around other economies. 2012 2013 Scenario 4: Scenario 1: Successive phase of monetary and fiscal action hold 0.1 0.7 the eurozone together at the cost of inflation. A new currency union is formed by the stronger economies.¹ Scenario 2: Voluntary defaults for highly-indebted sovereigns. -3.0 -1.5 Scenario 3: Greece exits the eurozone and a firewall is built -1.0 0.5 around other economies. Scenario 4: A new currency union is formed by the -1.5 0.6 stronger economies. 1   What next for the eurozone - Possible scenarios for 2012.” “ Available from: www.pwc.co.uk. Updated scenarios published March 2012. 2 Ibid. Potential scenarios 9
  • 10. Scenario 1 Policy action • Crisis is initially contained by ECB bank financing and agreement on Greek debt haircut. Successive phases of • Greece fails to meet the conditions of the deal, triggering another round of ECB monetary and fiscal action financing coupled with fiscal transfers to peripheral economies in exchange for austerity measures. hold the eurozone together • A looser monetary policy is adopted at the end of 2012 to help restore the at the cost of inflation. competitiveness of the peripheral economies. Short-term outcomes • No or low growth will put downward pressure on inflation, signalling a looser monetary policy in 2013. • “Internal appreciation” of Germany in relation to the periphery helps alleviate recessionary pressure in peripheral economies by improving their trade balances. • Improved credit conditions and confidence could support GDP growth of 2% in 2014, as the survival of the euro looks increasingly certain. Medium-term outcomes • Higher inflation should ease debt restructuring, and improve competitiveness of peripheral European economies. • ECB raises interest rates to bring down inflation in the medium-term and restore credibility. • Most eurozone countries will be running primary surpluses for many years, putting a drag on growth. Higher inflation in the core Eurozone countries could restore the relative competitiveness in the core eurozone countries could restore Higher inflation of the periphery. The policy response restores confidence and prevents the relative competitiveness of the periphery. a prolonged recession. 140 Consumer Price Index Eurozone 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 130 Forecast GDP growth 0.1 0.7 2 1.5 1.5 2004=100 120 Inflation 1.5 3.0 3.5 3 2 110 100 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 Spain Germany Source: Eurostat and PwC Analysis 10 FS Viewpoint
  • 11. Scenario 2 Policy action • Following the Greek precedent, other highly-indebted economies seek to restructure their debts. Voluntary defaults for • We assume a 50% default on Portuguese and Irish sovereign debt and a 25% highly-indebted sovereigns. default on Italian debt. • In parallel, we assume leaders agree to measures aimed at insulating the rest of the eurozone from a collapse in confidence. Short-term outcomes • We estimate that the restructuring will cause a private sector wealth loss of up to €800bn, including €100bn to banks. • Bank losses would be partially recapitalized by governments, the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF), and the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), but lending would also need to be reduced. • We expect that this would precipitate a contractionary debt spiral dragging the eurozone into a deep and protracted recession. Medium-term outcomes • We expect that restructuring governments will be locked out of credit markets and require long-term support from the rest of the eurozone and other bilateral institutions. • Over time, these countries would have to reestablish credibility with investors. Bank losses could total over €100 billion, whichlosses could total over €100 billion, which could Bank could precipitate a contractionary ...such a credit contraction could lead to a debt spiral... contractionary debt spiral... precipitate a deep recession € 35,000 € 30,000 Eurozone 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 € 25,000 GDP growth -3 -1.5 -0.5 1 2 € 20,000 Inflation 1 0 0 1 2 € 15,000 € 10,000 € 5,000 0 Italy Greece* France Germany Portugal UK Ireland Spain Source: EBA. *Data as at 30 Dec, 2010 Potential scenarios 11
  • 12. Scenario 3 Policy action • Greece exits the eurozone by imposing temporary capital controls and redenominating all new and existing contracts in new drachma. Greece exits the eurozone • The eurozone commits to saving the euro and uses the ECB and EFSF to build a and a firewall is built firewall around other vulnerable economies. around other economies. Greece outcomes • We expect that the new drachma could depreciate by as much as 50%, constituting an implicit default on debt. • Inflation would soar, potentially averaging 10% in 2012. • The Greek economy would enter a severe recession as credit conditions and confidence deteriorate and further fiscal austerity is mandated in return for IMF funding. • In the medium term, the economy could recover—driven by exports spurred by a weaker currency and improved competitiveness. Rest of eurozone outcomes • We expect this would cause an 18-month recession in the eurozone as investors’ losses and shaken confidence lead to capital flight and deteriorating credit conditions. • But the Greek exit also would provide an impetus for other vulnerable countries to bring forward fiscal and structural reforms to “avoid the Greek fate,” improving longer-term growth prospects. Historical devaluations have led to tosharp contraction in Historical devaluations have led a a sharp The region would suffer an immediate but short-lived GDP lasting one to two years. to 2 years contraction in GDP lasting 1 recession and growth would resume after 18 months. GDP index (100 = year of devaluation) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 120 115 GDP Greece -5 -1.5 0 2.6 2.8 110 growth 105 Rest of -1 0.5 1 1.6 1.8 100 eurozone 95 90 Inflation Greece 10 8 8 6 6 85 80 Rest of 1.5 1.8 2 2 2 0 1 2 3 eurozone Sweden (1992) Thailand (1997) Indonesia (1997) Argentina (2001) Korea (1997) Source: IMF, PwC analysis 12 FS Viewpoint
  • 13. Scenario 4 Policy action • A Franco-German acknowledgement that the existing eurozone is unsustainable paves the way for a new, smaller, and more tightly regulated currency bloc. A new currency union is • The new bloc includes: Germany, France, the Netherlands, Finland, and some of the formed by the stronger stronger new member states. economies. • More stringent rules are set out for members on fiscal union and structural positions. “New euro” • New bloc benefits from an inflow of capital in the first year. bloc outcomes • However, transition costs and a loss of competitiveness as a result of the stronger currency would drag on growth in 2012. • The new euro exchange rate could be permanently higher by up to 15% compared to the exchange rate for major trading partners. Periphery outcomes • Economies that break away from the euro face challenges of depreciating exchange rates, soaring inflation, and falling output. • Future success will depend on their ability to rebuild credible fiscal and monetary institutions. Countries with weak economic fundamentals are most at Countries with weak economic fundamentals The new eurozone will experience a boost in domestic risk if the euro were to break up. are most at risk if the euro were to break up demand while the periphery contracts in 2012. Indicative scorecard of economic and fiscal fundamentals (selected eurozone countries) Greece 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Stronger fundamentals Portugal Ireland GDP New euro 0.3 2.5 2.5 2 2 Italy growth Spain Periphery -5 -2 0 2 3 Belgium France Inflation New euro -1 0 0 2 2 Germany Netherlands Periphery 10 8 7 5 3 Finland government debt Gross general (% of GDP) Budget deficit yields 10-year GDP growth Expected outlook Ratings Potential scenarios 13
  • 14. Exit of a country from the A country leaving the eurozone may need to do • Decide how to deal with existing outstanding the following: euro-denominated debt, which would eurozone will have broad probably entail a major government and • Announce and immediately impose capital and far-reaching impacts. controls. private-sector debt restructuring (i.e., default). • Impose immediate trade controls to limit • Recapitalize the insolvent banks to make up capital outflows. for losses from defaults. • Impose immediate border controls to prevent • Determine what to do with the non-bank a flight of cash. financial sector and the stock and bond • Implement a bank holiday to prevent a “run markets. on the bank.” • Determine how to handle commercial • Announce a new exchange rate (presumably contracts that are written and denominated not floating at the beginning, given capital in euros and now may be in the new and exchange controls) so that trade could currency. continue. • Convert all euro-denominated notes and coin to a new currency. 14 FS Viewpoint
  • 15. Implications for US corporations
  • 16. How does all this impact Eurozone restructuring has the potential to Thus, companies should be more fully prepared create significant change and disruption to for a range of unpredictable outcomes. One way US corporations? the operations of many firms. These changes to accomplish this is to focus on the potential would potentially materialize when the broader consequences of the four scenarios outlined to economic and market environment create determine what actions would be required at conditions in which many companies cannot an organizational level based on likely market afford the direct and indirect costs to their conditions, such as a credit crunch or currency businesses of carrying out such changes. devaluation. Many of the specific actions required at the Based on this analysis, companies can organization level following a complete or proactively develop contingency plans to partial eurozone restructuring will be intrusive address the potential consequences of various to the processes, systems, and operations of potential eurozone scenarios and begin to take an organization and will have to be executed steps to help minimize the risks today. quickly and with minimal lead time for impact assessment and action planning. 16 FS Viewpoint
  • 17. Potential actions required We expect the euro crisis to have a broad and profound impact on US-based multinational companies in the following areas, among others: 1 Business model and structure 2 Revenue 3 Treasury 4 Legal 5 Procurement and supply contracts 6 IT 7 Finance 8 HR/people 9 Tax 10 Crisis/incident management Implications for US corporations 17
  • 18. 1 Business model 1. Problem statement In setting long-term business strategy—what products to make, what markets to target, where to source and manufacture, how to organize the company, where to raise and structure and deploy capital—companies have typically planned based on the assumption of a stable eurozone and regulatory environment with stable, moderate growth and the free flow of goods, capital and people. The current crisis has called many of these assumptions into question. As a result, many companies, particularly those with heavy business activities in Europe or significant European stakeholders, will need to question many of the fundamental assumptions that have formed the basis of their strategies, business models, and organizational structures. Critical questions • How might the various potential outcomes for the euro impact overall corporate strategy? • Where do we want to invest capital going forward? Which countries (inside and outside the eurozone) will present attractive investment opportunities going forward? • How will the crisis impact ability to effectively borrow and invest in the eurozone? • Could the break-up of the eurozone result in increased regulatory costs and additional friction in the flow of goods and services within the region? • Will the declining attractiveness of European markets increase the level of competition in other developed and developing markets? • How should companies best alter their European footprint under various potential outcomes? Key areas of exposure and impact • Significant declines in economic growth reduces the attractiveness of for corporations European markets. • Reduced growth and higher costs result in impairment of prior investments. • Constrained capital markets result in further challenges to fund European growth and investment. • Reduced growth and constrained credit weaken the supplier base and create significant operational risks. 18 FS Viewpoint
  • 19. 2. Revenue 2 Problem statement Corporate revenue and profit margins are based on uninterrupted global demand and supply as well as free flows of capital, labor, and goods throughout the eurozone. Should these be disrupted by the crisis (e.g., through a collapse in sales, FX movements, or capital controls), the impact on revenues will be significant and could undermine the viability of businesses. Some countries may impose some form of currency controls in order to limit the shocks to their economies. Countries with strong currencies but small economies (e.g., Swiss franc) will also try to suppress the value of their currencies through the use of market mechanisms. Critical questions • Under what scenario and in what circumstances is revenue most at risk? How long can businesses survive with below-average sales in the eurozone? • Under what scenarios do eurozone countries become unattractive to sell to or produce in? • Can potential exposures be hedged? Have non-traditional/natural hedging strategies been considered? • Have alternative growth strategies been identified and reviewed? • Can the business still afford to serve clients in euros in the short—and medium—term? Do margins need recalculating and pricing pegged to a more “stable” currency? Key areas of exposure and impact • A collapse in sales could occur as a result of severe recession or unfavorable price for corporations and foreign exchange movements. • Liquidity shortages as a result of sales collapse and regulatory measures could limit cross-border transfers. • Revenue streams could be significantly impacted through sharp foreign exchange movements. Implications for US corporations 19
  • 20. 3. Treasury 3 Problem statement Treasury must be prepared for the significant and difficult changes that would occur under each scenario. A credit squeeze is likely to result. Possible capital and foreign exchange controls may need to be invoked at short notice and eurozone hedging strategies may need to be disaggregated by country, with aspects no longer effective as new currencies are created. Additionally, treasury should understand which scenarios will cause covenants to be triggered and cash to be trapped, and set parameters for exchange rate appetites if volatility increases and new currencies are created. Critical questions • Is there an appropriate forum for discussing working capital and cash forecasting? Have counterparty risk policies and credit scoring processes been reviewed? Is the business appropriately hedged? • How is credit risk currently monitored? Should changes be made to better predict and/or react to declining credit? • How legally enforceable are netting arrangements to reduce exposure? • What cash can be moved to neutralize euro exposures, surplus repatriated? Facilities redenominated? • Will weaker eurozone banks be able to provide local funding? • What will become of local deposits, if banks are no longer functioning? • How might a company redirect/collect customer payments outside high risk countries? • Will cash pooling structures continue to be viable and efficient? • How might increasing currency volatility impact FX hedging programs? Key areas of exposure and impact • Diversity of funding arrangements, credit risk, trapped cash risk, off balance sheet for corporations contingencies triggered • Forecasted internal cash reserves, intercompany balances • Debt arrangements upon currency restriction events, covenant implications • Cross-border cash management structures and credit facility interaction • Working capital strain as customers take longer to pay, suppliers weaken without prompt payment, and foreign exchange rates change or become increasingly volatile • Enforceability of euro derivatives/country of bank counterparty • Volatility arising from ineffective hedging strategies or hedge accounting 20 FS Viewpoint
  • 21. 4. Legal 4 Problem statement For many organizations, legal contracts are based on existing EU law and the premise of a stable single currency, governed by the ECB. Should any of the four scenarios occur, sales, supply, and employment contracts (among others) are likely to require review and some revision. In extreme circumstances, contracts may become unenforceable. The consequences will vary dependent on applicable governing law and jurisdiction. Payment obligations will be dependent on applicable exchange rates. This in turn could cause defaults to occur. The potential for associated disputes could also increase. Critical questions • Is the potential impact on key contracts fully understood? • In the event of changes to either the currency of payment or the reference/regulatory bodies, are the associated contractual obligations and flow down provisions clear? • Are the definitions within existing contracts still valid? • Have the potential commercial risks been considered, as well as how these risks can be avoided or mitigated? • Has the financial impact of employment contracts and packages been evaluated? • Is there a plan in place to identify and solve legal exposures? Key areas of exposure and impact • All key commercial contracts including supply contracts, sales contracts, joint- for corporations venture agreements, distribution agreements, and IP licensing arrangements • Payment arrangements and systems and support service agreements • Transfer pricing • Impact on cross default provision arising from contractual default • Currency hedging and treasury management • Referencing in all contracts (for example, euro-dependent provisions, reference to bodies such as ECB or eurozone, Material Adverse Change) • Employee terms and conditions (such as salary, bonus, and other remuneration) Implications for US corporations 21
  • 22. 5. Procurement and 5 Problem statement Many global organizations, especially large consumer products companies, rely on sourcing raw materials, products and services needed for their operations from the supply contracts eurozone countries. They also supply clients across Europe from different EU and non- EU hubs. With the four scenarios in mind, the changes could result in the creation of European low-cost countries. For US Companies, these changes could imply: • Strategic sourcing decisions may need to be revisited with changes to price or availability conditions. • Supply models may need changes in pricing, logistics, invoicing, and transportion. • Alternate vendors may be needed or activities may need to be brought in-house if the vendors are unable to survive the outcome of the crisis. Critical questions • Will there be low-cost country opportunities created as a result of eurozone restructuring? • Are there supply-chain risks as a result of rising material costs for suppliers no longer in the eurozone? • Can the impacts of those moves be reliably modelled (e.g., on cost or profit margin)? • Can the impact of supply-side changes on key clients’ supply chains be anticipated? • Are there alternative sources of supply for critical products and services? Are rapid moves to an alternative supplier feasible? • Are multiple critical suppliers in the same situation (i.e., could an organization experience multiple vendor failures)? • How might a company redirect/collect customer payments outside high-risk countries? Key areas of exposure and impact • The cost of producing and operating could change dramatically as a result of sharp for corporations economic and foreign exchange movements. • Potential cost reduction opportunities may arise. • Supply continuity for critical raw materials and products may need to be monitored. • Supply chain reviews should be considered for the most price-sensitive products and services, resulting in potential service model changes. • Different cost and margin scenarios may need to be evaluated, and alternative suppliers may be needed if the impact is material. • Make/buy decisions may need to be revisited across a range of products, and new efficiencies should be realized. 22 FS Viewpoint
  • 23. 6. IT 6 Problem statement Regardless of size, complexity, or industry, companies are becoming increasingly reliant on IT/IS systems—both within their own companies as well as with customers, suppliers, and vendors—to conduct business operations. This reliance will create challenges for organizations to: • Understand the impact that the different scenarios will have on the IT environment and the various interfaces between systems (both external and internal) • Ensure that internal systems can remain flexible and adaptable enough to meet the demands of new and changing regulations and market environments • Ensure that external vendors of hardware, software, and services have developed plans to deal with each potential scenario and are able to maintain continuity of operations • Implement potentially significant master and transaction data changes In addition to these challenges, organizations should gauge their readiness to exploit the opportunities presented (such as integration, renegotiation of support deals, and relocation). Critical questions • Which systems and business areas are most exposed to the changes set out in the scenarios? • Do company systems have the ability to be modified to handle new currencies? • Can company systems handle the redenomination of historical transactions? • Have systems and vendors critical for survival of the organization been identified? • Do external vendors have plans in place to ensure continuity of IT and communications infrastructure and services? • Are transactions and reporting set up to accommodate a high-inflation environment? Key areas of exposure and impact • Work required to amend existing applications and data for corporations • Lack of control over IT systems due to contractual or physical limitations in the ability to reconfigure • Inability of systems to cope with extreme changes in inflation and valuations, including the ability to forecast and restate past performance • Inability of outsourced service providers to maintain continuity of their systems and to provide agreed-upon services • Potential increase in capacity from institutions switching businesses to non- impacted countries • Collapse of IT service providers, or inability to honor contractual obligations around IT service provision Implications for US corporations 23
  • 24. 7. Finance 7 Problem statement The Finance function is heavily exposed to eurozone challenges in terms of: • Accountability for planning, budgeting, and forecasting in very uncertain times by building scenarios and securing board agreement with them. • Managing increased costs (both of finance and the whole organization) and interpreting their impacts to the organization. • Keeping statutory reporting in line without major increases of effort. • Dealing with increased reporting requirements and new types of what-if analyses and complex simulations. Critical questions • Is your Finance operating model still relevant? • Is the sourcing strategy still optimal, does the restructuring provide opportunities to revisit shared-service locations and outsourcing contracts? • Would outsourcing transactional activity mitigate risk in volatile markets during eurozone restructuring? • How quickly could the organization exit outsourced or shared environments within unstable economies? • Can statutory and management reporting be produced with current resources and without compromising quality? • Is the function set up to deal with inflation, currencies leaving the eurozone, and the introduction of a significant number of new currencies? • Can costs arising from the changes described in the four scenarios be modeled reliably? • Is finance ready to take on a much bigger role in communicating these changes to the rest of your organization? • Do you understand the potential financial reporting impacts of each scenario, including matters like revenue recognition, asset impairment, and hedge accounting? Key areas of exposure and impact • Service agreements with outsourced providers for corporations • Continued availability of qualified staff • Continued robustness and adequacy of the control environment • Shared-service center (SSC) location, setup, and internal pricing • Enterprise resource planning (ERP) and reporting systems • Current data models • Accounting policy matters and financial reporting impacts 24 FS Viewpoint
  • 25. 8. HR/people 8 Problem statement For businesses operating in Europe, the HR function is key to supporting the business strategy while adapting to the impact of economic and legislative change on staff operations. With differences in specific HR needs among countries likely to increase, HR functions should be equipped to deal with increasing complexity while managing limited resources. Resources will be stretched to balance both short-and long-term measures in dealing with rapid change while facing sustained pressure to cut costs. Critical questions • With sustained pressure on cost reduction, how will HR operating models and structures cope with differing demands across territories? • How will talent be retained in less stable countries while dealing with sustained financial pressure and rapid change? • Will businesses need restructuring in response to changes in the eurozone? How will the impact of this be addressed with respect to human resource operations? • Have you defined your duty of care and responsibility to your employees in the event of collective actions in which they are impacted? • Is your team clear on how you will communicate to employees in the event of collective actions which keep them from work? • Do business continuity plans consider the potential for civil unrest or even military conflict? Key areas of exposure and impact • Managing a mobile and global workforce could become increasingly complex, with for corporations less standardization across Europe in terms of tax and employment law. Businesses should be equipped to deal with the increased risks associated with these changes, including areas such as rewards and pensions. • Those operating in less stable European countries may find themselves struggling to retain talent as employees seek more secure environments. • Some companies will need to respond to changes in the eurozone by restructuring their businesses and contracting for high-risk operations. The implications for HR and people activity should be dealt with appropriately, for example when redeploying or making headcount reductions. Implications for US corporations 25
  • 26. 9. Tax 9 Problem statement Companies should understand the immediate tax consequences arising from various scenarios regarding the future of the eurozone. It will be important for companies to weigh the tax efficiencies of their proposed mitigation strategies. Critical questions • Do the changes give rise to a new contract from an accounting perspective? This may result in the recognition of profit or losses for accounting purposes that could also be taxable or relievable. • Do the changes give rise to a new contract from a legal and tax perspective? Modification of an existing contract could potentially represent the termination of the original contract and the creation of a new contract. This could crystallize a taxing event (i.e., the changes could trigger a disposal for capital gains purposes). • Where the contracts are between related parties, then an additional question is whether an arm’s length fee should be paid to the counterparty as compensation for the change in terms. The tax treatment of this fee would need to be considered from both parties’ perspectives, and whether this payment would be taxable on one side and deductible on the other. • Will any losses be tax-deductible and can they be utilized or will they become “trapped?” How does this change the tax profile of the group? • What happens if any foreign exchange gains should arise (e.g., due to a smaller, stronger euro)? • What will be the impact on business if it cannot defer foreign exchange gains or losses under the tax matching rules, where the hedge becomes ineffective from a tax perspective? • Has taxation been factored into contingency plans such that they are as tax efficient as possible? Key areas of exposure and impact • Different scenarios may create losses; it is important to understand whether these for corporations are foreign-exchange losses or impairment losses and the deductibility of these for tax purposes. • Redenomination of foreign assets and liabilities may result in hedges becoming ineffective from a tax perspective. • If the changes cause new contracts, especially loans, to be brought into existence, this may impact existing agreements with the taxing authorities (e.g., withholding tax clearances may be affected). It may also affect other taxes (e.g., VAT if there is a change in value of the contract). 26 FS Viewpoint