Recognizing the Impact
   Civically Engaged
Older Adults Make on our
      Communities
               Detroit Griot Collaborative:
             Rachel Hewitt, Hannan Foundation
            Donald Vest, Arts League of Michigan

  Pointers Sustained and Villages Neighbor to Neighbor:
           Sharon Maier, Services for Older Citizens
Natalie Zappella, Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan
Agenda   •   Introductions
         •   What is civic engagement?
         •   Two civic engagement programs
             •   Detroit Griot Collaborative,
                 “Volunteering in Detroit” Process
             •   Community Foundation for
                 Southeast Michigan, Pointers
                 Sustained & VillagesN2N Process
         •   Listening PARTY! & Reflection
         •   Evaluation
Civic Engagement
Defined            • “Dear Detroit”
                   • What is Civic Engagement?
                   • What older adult civic
                     engagement projects do you
                     work with?
                   • What do you want to get out
                     of this workshop?
People aged 65 and over make up 12 percent of the
                                   population in Southeast Michigan.

                            • Detroit Griot Collaborative
Volunteering in                 o   Arts League of Michigan
Detroit:                        o
                                o
                                    Charles H. Wright African American Museum
                                    Detroit Renaissance Lyons Club
            Partners            o   Fred Hart Williams Geneological Society
                                o   Luella Hannan Memorial Foundation
                                o   Walter Reuther Library
                                o   WDET




   By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast
                                                               Michigan
• Identify and record 50 older Detroiters who
Volunteering in        have made service to community an integral
                       part of their lives.
Detroit Objectives   • Examine and discuss meaning behind historic
                       and ongoing commitment volunteers make to
                       civic institutions in Detroit.
                     • Define and validate roles older adults play in
                       the community through project activities,
                       thereby decreasing the perception of personal
                       development declining in later years.
                     • Disseminate stories to broader community
                       through multiple media types.
                     • Preserve collection in Walter Reuther
                       Archives.
• Development of Detroit Griot
Process     Partners
          • Defining “Service to Community”
          • Creating Questions
          • Recruitment
            o   Interviewers
            o   Interviewees
          • Recording
          • Coding and Editing
          • Dissemination
            o   Gift
            o   Listening Parties
            o   WDET
            o   Exhibit Panels
          • Evaluation
Service to community is a widely
Service Defined     inclusive definition of volunteering
                    and includes:
                     o   Informal and formal volunteering
                     o   Neighborhood, block group and
                         community service work
                     o   Labor unions
                     o   Church committees
                     o   Work with traditional civic
                         organizations
                     o   Activism
                     o   Caregiving within and outside of the
                         family
                     o   Other similar efforts
                     o   Note: volunteering and “service to
                         community” are used interchangeably.
People aged 65 and over make up 12 percent of the
                                population in Southeast Michigan.


Volunteering              Pre and Post Surveys
                             o 7 Questions regarding feelings
in Detroit:                     on volunteerism
                             o Surveys tabulated for subset:
       Results                 “Speaking our Stories”

                          Positive Change Regarding Roles
                             o   I am satisfied with my level of community
                                  involvement over my lifetime.
                                     Pre: SA and A = 22%
                                     Post: SA and A = 100%
                             o   I am satisfied with the success
                                 I have achieved as a volunteer.
                                     Pre: A = 67%; D = 33%
                                     Post: SA = 35%: A = 65%
                             o   I “made a difference” as a volunteer.
                                     Pre: SA = 56%; A = 33%
                                     Post: SA = 100%



By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast
                                                            Michigan
• Why use the narrative reflection
Volunteering in        format?
Detroit Objectives   • Quality of Life
                     • Role Definition
                     • Programming
                     • Management
                     • Public Attitudes
                     • Other?
Pointers
Sustained
Partners




With support from
CEP Goal                  Increase opportunities for
                          the growing number of people over
                          60 who seek to devote
                          time and energy to community
                          improvement and social change.




© copyright Alex Harris
Community
Foundation Goal      Utilize community assets, including
                    the talents of older adults, to create
                     affordable, desirable places for all
                       persons to age and live healthy,
                      empowered and productive lives
                  where whatever one has to contribute
                              makes a difference.
People aged 65 and over make up 12 percent of the
                                   population in Southeast Michigan.


Detroit
Neighborhood Fund




   By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast
                                                               Michigan
DNF Community Partners
•   Identify 10-14 community residents to participate in
Objectives                    a planning committee for 4-6 months
                          •   Co-develop Community-Based Participatory
                              Research process
                          •   Co-learn about innovative community-based
                              approaches to aging in place
                          •   Provide technical assistance and support to 2
                              planning teams through an empowerment
                              framework
                          •   Assess the feasibility and provide recommendations
                              for a home and community based support system
                              sensitive to the community
                          •   Host a community forum and develop short report
© copyright Alex Harris
Community-Based Participatory
     Research (CBPR) Defined
Alters researcher-community relationships
• Collaborative & Equitable Partnership
• Reciprocal Appreciation
• Builds community capacity
• Bridges knowledge and practice gap
• Action and social change = fundamental


CBPR is NOT:
• Basic research
• Community-placed research
• Sporadic or symbolic community
  inclusion
Beverly Burns


Pointers
            Susan Chapman
            Bridget Christian
            Betsy Creedon



Sustained
            Sharon DeHaven
            David Dieter, Christ Church Grosse Pointe
            Sharon Maier, Services for Older Citizens
            Anita Salustro




            Kathy Beltaire, West Village
            Diane Van Buren, Indian Village
            Sheu-Jane Gallagher, Gold Coast
            Sharon Garret, West Village
            Tamika Hamilton, Church of the Messiah
            Jerry Springs, Adult Well-Being Services
            Shanetta Stanley, Greater Christ Baptist Church
            Rev. Barry Randolph, Church of the Messiah
            Veronica Randolph, Church of the Messiah
            Kenyetta Walker, Community At Large
            Sheree Walton, Islandview, Mustard Tree Coop
CBSS Process, Phase 1
                                     CBSS Roundtable




                    9 Focus Groups
                   and Nominations




Initial Planning
 & Exploration
CBSS Process, Phase 2
                                              Research, Analysis
                                               and Co-learning




                           Develop Survey
                         and Conduct Survey
                              Outreach



Create Joint Ownership
  Design Research &
   Planning Process
CBSS Process, Phase 2 (cont.)




Visioning, Planning                                 Develop Report
                            Hold Community Forums
  and Additional Outreach
CBSS Process, Phase 2 (cont.)




                    Collective Reflection, Evaluation
                    And Defining of History
Implications                 •   Quality of Life

   of Narrative Reflection   •   Surfaces:
                                  • Role and Personal Meaning
                                  • Social importance
                                  • Impact on the community
                                  • Skills and capacities used or gained
                             •   Power accrues to those who are able to:
                                  • Create knowledge
                                  • Access systems of knowledge that name the problem,
                                  • Organize people and resources around the problem,
                                  • Mobilize solutions.
                             •   Public attitudes
                                  • About older volunteers
                                  • Value of program, volunteers

                             •   Programming and Management
                                  • Evaluation
Listening PARTY! & Reflection
“I thought, well, I can make a
   phone call while I’m
   having my coffee about
   the potholes in the street.”
   - Patricia Carter


                                  “The neighborhood we came
                                    from we thought was
                                    different, but maybe it was
                                    not.”
                                     - Suesetta McCree
CBSS Process, Phase 2 (cont.)



                Pointers Sustained &
                Villages Neighbor to Neighbor

                        Collective Reflection, Evaluation
                                 And Defining of History
Contact Information

Rachel Hewitt, LLMSW                Sharon Maier, C.F.R.E
Community Social Worker             (Certified Fund Raising Executive)
Luella Hannan Memorial Foundation   Executive Director
4750 Woodward Avenue                Services for Older Citizens
Detroit, MI 48201                   17150 Waterloo, Grosse Pointe, MI
313.833.1300, x24                   (313) 882-9600
rhewitt@hannan.org                  soc_director@yahoo.com


Donald Vest, BA                     Natalie Zappella, MSW, MUP
Detroit Griot Collaborative         Program Associate, Community
                                    Investment
Chairman Emeritus, Arts League of
                                    Community Foundation for Southeast
Michigan
                                    Michigan
7700 2nd Avenue                     333 W. Fort St., Suite 2010
Detroit, MI 50613                   Detroit, MI 48226
donaldvest@sbcglobal.net            313.961.6675
                                    nzappella@cfsem.org

Recognizing The Impact Hannan And Cfsem Ncoa Asa Conference 2010

  • 1.
    Recognizing the Impact Civically Engaged Older Adults Make on our Communities Detroit Griot Collaborative: Rachel Hewitt, Hannan Foundation Donald Vest, Arts League of Michigan Pointers Sustained and Villages Neighbor to Neighbor: Sharon Maier, Services for Older Citizens Natalie Zappella, Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan
  • 2.
    Agenda • Introductions • What is civic engagement? • Two civic engagement programs • Detroit Griot Collaborative, “Volunteering in Detroit” Process • Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan, Pointers Sustained & VillagesN2N Process • Listening PARTY! & Reflection • Evaluation
  • 3.
    Civic Engagement Defined • “Dear Detroit” • What is Civic Engagement? • What older adult civic engagement projects do you work with? • What do you want to get out of this workshop?
  • 4.
    People aged 65and over make up 12 percent of the population in Southeast Michigan. • Detroit Griot Collaborative Volunteering in o Arts League of Michigan Detroit: o o Charles H. Wright African American Museum Detroit Renaissance Lyons Club Partners o Fred Hart Williams Geneological Society o Luella Hannan Memorial Foundation o Walter Reuther Library o WDET By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan
  • 5.
    • Identify andrecord 50 older Detroiters who Volunteering in have made service to community an integral part of their lives. Detroit Objectives • Examine and discuss meaning behind historic and ongoing commitment volunteers make to civic institutions in Detroit. • Define and validate roles older adults play in the community through project activities, thereby decreasing the perception of personal development declining in later years. • Disseminate stories to broader community through multiple media types. • Preserve collection in Walter Reuther Archives.
  • 6.
    • Development ofDetroit Griot Process Partners • Defining “Service to Community” • Creating Questions • Recruitment o Interviewers o Interviewees • Recording • Coding and Editing • Dissemination o Gift o Listening Parties o WDET o Exhibit Panels • Evaluation
  • 7.
    Service to communityis a widely Service Defined inclusive definition of volunteering and includes: o Informal and formal volunteering o Neighborhood, block group and community service work o Labor unions o Church committees o Work with traditional civic organizations o Activism o Caregiving within and outside of the family o Other similar efforts o Note: volunteering and “service to community” are used interchangeably.
  • 8.
    People aged 65and over make up 12 percent of the population in Southeast Michigan. Volunteering Pre and Post Surveys o 7 Questions regarding feelings in Detroit: on volunteerism o Surveys tabulated for subset: Results “Speaking our Stories” Positive Change Regarding Roles o I am satisfied with my level of community involvement over my lifetime.  Pre: SA and A = 22%  Post: SA and A = 100% o I am satisfied with the success I have achieved as a volunteer.  Pre: A = 67%; D = 33%  Post: SA = 35%: A = 65% o I “made a difference” as a volunteer.  Pre: SA = 56%; A = 33%  Post: SA = 100% By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan
  • 9.
    • Why usethe narrative reflection Volunteering in format? Detroit Objectives • Quality of Life • Role Definition • Programming • Management • Public Attitudes • Other?
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 13.
    CEP Goal Increase opportunities for the growing number of people over 60 who seek to devote time and energy to community improvement and social change. © copyright Alex Harris
  • 14.
    Community Foundation Goal Utilize community assets, including the talents of older adults, to create affordable, desirable places for all persons to age and live healthy, empowered and productive lives where whatever one has to contribute makes a difference.
  • 15.
    People aged 65and over make up 12 percent of the population in Southeast Michigan. Detroit Neighborhood Fund By 2035 this will be 1 in 4 people Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Identify 10-14 community residents to participate in Objectives a planning committee for 4-6 months • Co-develop Community-Based Participatory Research process • Co-learn about innovative community-based approaches to aging in place • Provide technical assistance and support to 2 planning teams through an empowerment framework • Assess the feasibility and provide recommendations for a home and community based support system sensitive to the community • Host a community forum and develop short report © copyright Alex Harris
  • 18.
    Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR) Defined Alters researcher-community relationships • Collaborative & Equitable Partnership • Reciprocal Appreciation • Builds community capacity • Bridges knowledge and practice gap • Action and social change = fundamental CBPR is NOT: • Basic research • Community-placed research • Sporadic or symbolic community inclusion
  • 19.
    Beverly Burns Pointers Susan Chapman Bridget Christian Betsy Creedon Sustained Sharon DeHaven David Dieter, Christ Church Grosse Pointe Sharon Maier, Services for Older Citizens Anita Salustro Kathy Beltaire, West Village Diane Van Buren, Indian Village Sheu-Jane Gallagher, Gold Coast Sharon Garret, West Village Tamika Hamilton, Church of the Messiah Jerry Springs, Adult Well-Being Services Shanetta Stanley, Greater Christ Baptist Church Rev. Barry Randolph, Church of the Messiah Veronica Randolph, Church of the Messiah Kenyetta Walker, Community At Large Sheree Walton, Islandview, Mustard Tree Coop
  • 20.
    CBSS Process, Phase1 CBSS Roundtable 9 Focus Groups and Nominations Initial Planning & Exploration
  • 21.
    CBSS Process, Phase2 Research, Analysis and Co-learning Develop Survey and Conduct Survey Outreach Create Joint Ownership Design Research & Planning Process
  • 22.
    CBSS Process, Phase2 (cont.) Visioning, Planning Develop Report Hold Community Forums and Additional Outreach
  • 23.
    CBSS Process, Phase2 (cont.) Collective Reflection, Evaluation And Defining of History
  • 24.
    Implications • Quality of Life of Narrative Reflection • Surfaces: • Role and Personal Meaning • Social importance • Impact on the community • Skills and capacities used or gained • Power accrues to those who are able to: • Create knowledge • Access systems of knowledge that name the problem, • Organize people and resources around the problem, • Mobilize solutions. • Public attitudes • About older volunteers • Value of program, volunteers • Programming and Management • Evaluation
  • 25.
    Listening PARTY! &Reflection “I thought, well, I can make a phone call while I’m having my coffee about the potholes in the street.” - Patricia Carter “The neighborhood we came from we thought was different, but maybe it was not.” - Suesetta McCree
  • 26.
    CBSS Process, Phase2 (cont.) Pointers Sustained & Villages Neighbor to Neighbor Collective Reflection, Evaluation And Defining of History
  • 27.
    Contact Information Rachel Hewitt,LLMSW Sharon Maier, C.F.R.E Community Social Worker (Certified Fund Raising Executive) Luella Hannan Memorial Foundation Executive Director 4750 Woodward Avenue Services for Older Citizens Detroit, MI 48201 17150 Waterloo, Grosse Pointe, MI 313.833.1300, x24 (313) 882-9600 rhewitt@hannan.org soc_director@yahoo.com Donald Vest, BA Natalie Zappella, MSW, MUP Detroit Griot Collaborative Program Associate, Community Investment Chairman Emeritus, Arts League of Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan Michigan 7700 2nd Avenue 333 W. Fort St., Suite 2010 Detroit, MI 50613 Detroit, MI 48226 donaldvest@sbcglobal.net 313.961.6675 nzappella@cfsem.org